The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. Accordingly, in order to preserve the subject matter of the litigation and to ensure that neither party derives an undue advantage during the pendency of the proceedings, the present appeal is disposed of by supplementing the directions contained in the order dated 11.09.2025 passed by the learned trial Court. The respondents/defendants shall not create any third-party right, title or interest in the suit property, whether by way of sale, gift, mortgage, permanent lease, transfer, alienation or otherwise, during the pendency of the suit. They shall, however, be at liberty to use and enjoy the property and may let out the same on a yearly basis, subject to the condition that any rent, profit or income derived therefrom shall remain subject to the final outcome of the suit and the determination of the respective rights and shares of the parties.
17. It is made clear that the observations made hereinabove are confined to the adjudication of the present appeal arising out of an interlocutory order and shall not be construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the rival claims. The learned trial Court shall decide the suit independently, on the basis of the pleadings, evidence and applicable law, uninfluenced by any observation made in this order.
18. The appeal stands disposed of in the above terms. All pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of. (Sanjay Parihar) Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 18
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
MA No. 53/2025
CM No. 6029/2025
Cav No. 2156/2025
Date of pronouncement: 12.08.2026
Date of uploading: 12.08.2026
Rajesh Khajuria & Ors.
.....Appellants
Through :- Mr. Ranjeev Dubey, Advocate
v/s
Arun Khajuria & Ors.
.....Respondents
Through :- Mr. Vishal Goel, Advocate
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
JUDGEMENT (ORAL)
12.08.2026
1.
This petition is taken up for disposal at the admission
stage.
2.
Heard learned counsel for both sides and gone through
the documents placed on record.
3.
The appellants herein are the plaintiffs before the Court
of learned Principal District Judge, Udhampur. They instituted a
civil suit seeking a declaration that the plaintiffs, along with pro
forma defendant Ajay Kumar Khajuria and contesting defendant
Arun Khajuria, are owners in joint possession of land measuring 3
marlas (approximately 700 square feet), being Abadi Deh land
situated at Ward No. 3, Ramnagar Chowk, Tehsil and District
Udhampur. It is pleaded that the parties inherited the said property
MA No. 53/2025
from their predecessor-in-interest, late Isher Dass. The plaintiffs
have also sought partition of the property by metes and bounds in
accordance with their respective shares in the existing structure,
besides a decree of permanent prohibitory injunction restraining the
contesting defendant from changing the nature and character of the
building existing over the suit land.
4.
By virtue of the order impugned dated 11.09.2025, the
learned trial Court declined to grant the interim relief prayed for by
the plaintiffs/appellants, holding that they had failed to establish a
prima facie case. Upon consideration of the pleadings and material
placed before it, the trial Court observed that the defendants
appeared to be in exclusive possession of the suit property and had
already raised construction of the ground floor during the year
2024. The trial Court further noticed that no objection had been
raised by the plaintiffs at the time such construction was
undertaken and, therefore, their plea of joint possession did not,
prima facie, find support from the material on record.
5.
While declining the interim relief, the learned trial Court
nevertheless sought to safeguard the interest of the plaintiffs by
directing that the construction raised by the defendants would
remain subject to the final outcome of the suit. It was further
provided, in the alternative, that the defendants would compensate
the plaintiffs/appellants monetarily to the extent of their share,
calculated on the prevailing market value. The defendants were also
directed to furnish an undertaking before the Court to that effect.
MA No. 53/2025
Aggrieved of the said order, the appellants have preferred the
present appeal, principally contending that the suit property
originally belonged to their father, late Isher Dass, and, therefore,
devolved upon his legal heirs in accordance with law.
6.
The defendants, on the other hand, placed reliance upon
a family settlement dated 20.05.2024, stated to have been executed
between the mother of the parties, namely Shakuntla Devi, and
defendant Arun Khajuria. The appellants submit that the said
settlement is already under challenge in a separate suit and that the
Court seized of those proceedings has stayed its operation. It is,
therefore, contended that the learned trial Court, despite the
subsistence of the said interim order, failed to adequately protect
the interest of the appellants by restraining the respondents from
changing the nature and character of the suit property or from
creating any third-party interest therein on the strength of the
impugned settlement.
7.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondents has
vehemently
opposed
the
appeal
and
submitted
that
the
appellants/plaintiffs have failed to establish any prima facie case
warranting interference. It is contended that the learned trial Court
has appropriately balanced the competing equities and protected the
interests of both sides while passing the order impugned.
8.
The controversy between the parties pertains to land
measuring 3 marlas, admittedly falling within the category of Abadi
Deh. According to the appellants, the property belonged to their
MA No. 53/2025
father, late Isher Dass, and, upon his demise, devolved upon his
legal heirs in equal shares. The respondents, however, assert that
the property exclusively belonged to the mother of the parties,
Shakuntla Devi, who remained in exclusive possession thereof and
had, as far back as in the year 1971, let out a portion thereof. It is
further their case that, pursuant to the family settlement dated
20.05.2024, Shakuntla Devi parted with possession in favour of
respondent Arun Khajuria. According to the respondents, the mere
fact that the family settlement is under challenge in separate
proceedings would not, by itself, dislodge their claim of exclusive
possession over the suit property.
9.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the
appellants further submitted that an application had been moved
before the learned trial Court under Order I Rule 8 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, inter alia, asserting that Shakuntla Devi could not
have created an exclusive interest in favour of respondent Arun
Khajuria by taking recourse to the aforesaid settlement. The
contention essentially is that Shakuntla Devi herself did not possess
any exclusive right, title or interest in the suit property capable of
being transferred exclusively in favour of one of the parties.
10.
Having considered the rival submissions and regard
being had to the nature of the controversy, it is evident that the
matter involves seriously disputed questions of fact and title which
can appropriately be determined only upon the parties leading
evidence before the learned trial Court. At the interlocutory stage,
MA No. 53/2025
therefore, the endeavour of the Court ought to be to preserve the
subject matter of the suit and protect the competing interests of the
parties so that the ultimate decree, if any, is not rendered
ineffectual.
This
assumes
significance
particularly
when
the
appellants dispute the claim of exclusive possession set up by the
respondents and assert their status as co-sharers in property
allegedly inherited from their father, late Isher Dass.
11.
The pedigree table placed on record indicates that late
Isher Dass was survived by his wife, Shakuntla Devi, and four sons.
The other sons dispute the claim that Shakuntla Devi held the suit
property in her exclusive right and possession and, consequently,
also question her competence to confer exclusive rights or
possession upon respondent Arun Khajuria. The rival claims in this
regard necessarily require adjudication on the basis of evidence and
cannot appropriately be conclusively determined at the stage of
consideration of an application for interim relief.
12.
It is a settled principle governing joint property that,
ordinarily, possession of one co-sharer is treated as possession on
behalf of all the co-sharers unless ouster or exclusion is specifically
pleaded and established in accordance with law. The mere exclusive
use or occupation of a particular portion by one co-sharer would
not, by itself, necessarily extinguish the rights of the other cosharers. The suit land is admittedly described as Abadi Deh. Such
land ordinarily constitutes the inhabited village site used for
residential and allied purposes by the inhabitants of the village,
MA No. 53/2025
including land underneath residential houses and appurtenant
areas. In the present case, it is not the case of either side that late
Isher Dass was not an inhabitant of the village.
13.
Whether
the
suit
property
belonged
exclusively to
Shakuntla Devi or constituted property inherited from late Isher
Dass is, therefore, a substantial issue requiring adjudication by the
learned trial Court. Any determination on that issue would
necessarily have a direct bearing upon the nature and extent of the
rights claimed by the respective parties. At this interlocutory stage,
it would neither be appropriate nor permissible to record any
conclusive finding on the question of title.
14.
Another
significant
circumstance
which
cannot
be
overlooked is that the respondents claim rights on the basis of the
family settlement dated 20.05.2024. Admittedly, the said settlement
is already the subject matter of challenge in separate proceedings
pending before the competent Court, wherein its operation has been
stayed by an interim order. Once the operation of the document
forming the basis of the respondents' asserted rights has been
stayed, any benefit or interest claimed by them on the strength
thereof must necessarily remain subject to the final outcome of
those proceedings. Consequently, any construction raised or other
acts undertaken by the respondents on the basis of the interest
allegedly flowing from the settlement dated 20.05.2024 would
likewise remain subject to the adjudication of the rights of the
parties in the pending proceedings.
MA No. 53/2025
15.
In the aforesaid circumstances, the learned trial Court
cannot be faulted insofar as it has permitted the existing possession
of the respondents to continue while making the construction raised
by them subject to the final outcome of the suit. Such an
arrangement, at the interlocutory stage, substantially balances the
equities between the parties. However, the apprehension expressed
by the appellants that the respondents may, during the pendency of
the suit, create third-party rights or interests in the suit property
cannot altogether be brushed aside. Creation of such third-party
rights may not only complicate the pending litigation but may also
prejudice the rights of the parties and impede effective execution of
the decree that may ultimately be passed.
16.
Accordingly, in order to preserve the subject matter of the
litigation and to ensure that neither party derives an undue
advantage during the pendency of the proceedings, the present
appeal is disposed of by supplementing the directions contained in
the order dated 11.09.2025 passed by the learned trial Court. The
respondents/defendants shall not create any third-party right, title
or interest in the suit property, whether by way of sale, gift,
mortgage, permanent lease, transfer, alienation or otherwise, during
the pendency of the suit. They shall, however, be at liberty to use
and enjoy the property and may let out the same on a yearly basis,
subject to the condition that any rent, profit or income derived
therefrom shall remain subject to the final outcome of the suit and
the determination of the respective rights and shares of the parties.
MA No. 53/2025
17.
It is made clear that the observations made hereinabove
are confined to the adjudication of the present appeal arising out of
an interlocutory order and shall not be construed as an expression
of opinion on the merits of the rival claims. The learned trial Court
shall decide the suit independently, on the basis of the pleadings,
evidence and applicable law, uninfluenced by any observation made
in this order.
18.
The appeal stands disposed of in the above terms. All
pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
JAMMU
12.08.2026
Sneha
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable: No
MA No. 53/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review