The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. In view of the above, it is observed that the Tribunal has rightly considered the decision of the Apex Court in Amrit Paul Singh’s case (supra), and fastened liability on the respondent No.1-owner of the Car by keeping in mind admitted policy violations regarding permit and registration, and in the absence of proof to the contrary. Therefore, the finding of the Tribunal in respect of fastening liability on the owner does not call for interference.
21. In view of the foregoing reasons, this Court proceeds to pass the following: i) The appeal is allowed-in-part; ii) The impugned judgment and award dated
30. 01.2019 passed by the II Additional Senior Civil - 11 MFA No.100628 of 2020 Judge and Additional MACT, Dharwad, in M.V.C. No.24/2016, is modified; iii) The respondent Nos.1 to 4 – claimants are entitled for 75% of the total compensation of Rs.17,82,800/- as against Rs.8,90,000/- awarded by the Tribunal along with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of filing of the petition till deposit; iv) The compensation amount along with accrued interest if any, shall be deposited by the respondent No.1 – owner of the Car, within eight weeks from the date of filing of the petition till deposit; v) Apportionment and disbursement of the compensation amount shall be as per the order of the Tribunal. vi) Amount in deposit along with accrued interest, if any shall be transmitted to the Tribunal. No order as to costs. Sd/(DR. K.MANMADHA RAO) KGK, CT:VP
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1MFA No.100628 of 2020
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 23rd DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
®
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE K.MANMADHA RAO
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.100628 OF 2020 (MV-D)
BETWEEN:
1.
RAJESAB S/O. RASULAB KOPPAD,
AGE : 45 YEARS, OCC : COOLIE.
2.
KUMARI. TASENAM BANU D/O. RAJESAB,
AGE : 18 YEARS, OCC : STUDENT.
3.
KUMAR. ARBAJA ALI S/O. RAJESAB KOPPAD,
AGE : 15 YEARS, OCC : STUDENT.
4.
KUMARI. RAHINA D/O. RAJESAB KOPPAD,
AGE : 14 YEARS, OCC : STUDENT.
ALL ARE R/O: GANJIGATTI,
TQ : KALAGHATAGI,
DIST : DHARWAD – 580 012.
APPELLANT NO.3 AND 4 ARE MINORS
REPRESENTED BY THE MINOR GUARDIAN FATHER
AS APPELLANT NO.1
…APPELLANTS
Digitally signed
by
MOHANKUMAR
B SHELAR
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
(BY SRI. G. R. TURAMARI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
RAJAKUMAR S/O. DEVAJI NAIK,
AGE : 48 YEARS,
OCC :BUSINESS & OWNER OF THE SWIFT
DEZIRE MARUTI CAR BEARING ITS TEMPORARY
REGISTRATION NO.MH-13/TR-L 17,
R/O: 230, MOUNESHWAR NAGAR,
SHINDAGRI ROAD,
TQ: AND DIST : VIJAYAPURA – 586 101.
2.
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER,
THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO.LTD.,
-2MFA No.100628 of 2020
R/O : SOMESHWAR HEIGHTS,
OPP : OLD DY.S.P.OFFICE,
P.B.ROAD,
DIST : DHARWAD – 580 010.
3.
NAGARAJ S/O. RAJENDRA DUNDI,
AGE : 26 YEARS, OCC : DRIVER,
R/O : C/O. YASHODA VIDWAN, H.NO.41,
VISHWESHWAR NAGAR, HUBBALLI,
OWNER OF THE MOTORCYCLE TEMP.
NO.KA-25/TC-01.
4.
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER,
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
R/O: AVENUE COMPLEX, 1ST FLOOR,
OPP: DHO, NEAR OLD S.P.CIRCLE,
HALLIKERI CHAWL, HALIYAL ROAD,
DHARWAD – 580 008.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. H. N. HANCHINAMANI, ADVOCATE AND
SMT. SUSHMA B. NAIK, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
SRI. G.N.RAICHUR, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
SRI. S.S. JOSHI, ADVOCATE FOR R4;
NOTICE TO R3-DISPENSED WITH)
THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF THE MOTOR
VEHICLES ACT, PRAYING TO ENHANCING THE COMPENSATION AND
FIXING THE LIABILITY TO THE RESPONDENT NO.2 INSURANCE
COMPANY BY MODIFYING THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD PASSED BY
THE COURT OF THE II ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND
ADDITIONAL
MACT,
DHARWAD
IN
M.V.C
NO.24/2016,
DATED
30.01.2019 AND ALLOW THE APPEAL, IN THE INTEREST JUSTICE AND
EQUITY.
THIS
MFA
HAVING
BEEN
HEARD
AND
RESERVED
FOR
JUDGMENT ON 09.01.2026 AND COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT
THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE K.MANMADHA RAO
-3MFA No.100628 of 2020
CAV JUDGMENT
1.
This
appeal
is
filed
by
the
claimants
seeking
modification of the judgment and award dated 30.01.2019
passed by the II Additional Senior Civil Judge and Additional
MACT,
Dharwad
No.24/2016,
(for
seeking
short,
“the
enhancement
Tribunal”),
of
in
M.V.C.
compensation
and
fastening of liability on respondent No.2 - Insurance Company.
2.
The parties are referred to as per their ranking before
the Tribunal for the sake of convenience and easy reference.
3.
The brief facts of the case are as follows:
On 24.12.2015 at about 5.00 p.m., near Naragund Mini
Vidhana Soudha on Hubballi–Solapur Road, when Smt. Ashabi
was
alighting
from
a
motorcycle
bearing
registration
No.KA25/TC-01, a Swift Dzire Car bearing Registration No.MH13/TRL-17, driven at a high speed in a rash and negligent
manner dashed against her. As a result of the impact, Ashabi
sustained grievous injuries and died on the spot. The postmortem was conducted at the Government Hospital, Naragund,
and the funeral rites were performed by the petitioners.
It is the case of the claimants that deceased Ashabi was
aged 33 years, engaged in tailoring work, earning Rs.9,000/- per
month and the claimants were entirely dependent on her income.
-4MFA No.100628 of 2020
The accident occurred solely due to the negligence of the driver
of the Car.
4.
The claim petition was filed under Section 166(1) of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, “the MV Act”), claiming
compensation of Rs.12,00,000/-.
5.
Upon issuance of notice, respondent Nos.1 to 4
appeared through their respective counsel. Respondent Nos.2
and 4 – Insurance Companies filed separate statements of
objections, whereas respondent No.1 did not choose to contest
the petition by filing objections.
6.
In order to substantiate their case, claimant No.1
examined himself as PW-1 and produced six documents, which
were marked as Exs.P1 to P6. On the other hand, the
respondents examined one witness as RW-1 and produced four
documents marked as Exs.R1 to R4.
7.
On the basis of the pleadings and evidence on record,
the Tribunal by the impugned award held that the accident
occurred due to negligence of the driver of the Car and awarded
compensation of Rs.8,90,000/- with interest @ 8% per annum,
fastening liability on respondent No.1-owner of the Car holding
that the insurer was not liable.
-5MFA No.100628 of 2020
8.
Learned counsel for the appellants contend that the
Tribunal erred in assessing the income of the deceased at
Rs.5000/- per month, which is on lower side considering the year
of accident. It is also contended that the compensation awarded
under the head of loss of dependency is inadequate and require
enhancement. Though PW-1 is not an eyewitness to the
accident, his deposition reiterates the averments made in the
claim petition regarding the cause of the accident. He further
submits that documentary evidence such as the FIR, complaint,
post-mortem report, charge sheet, MVI report, and spot mahazar
produced at Exs.P1 to P6 clearly establish the manner of the
accident.
9.
It is contended that as per the complaint, when the
deceased was travelling as a pillion rider on the motorcycle
bearing registration No.KA-25/TC-01, a Car bearing registration
No.MH-13/TRL-17, driven rashly and negligently at a high speed,
dashed against the motorcycle, causing the deceased to fall on
the road and succumb to the injuries on the spot. Therefore, it is
argued that the accident occurred solely due to the negligence of
the driver of the Car, and the appellants seek enhancement of
compensation, particularly under the head of loss of dependency.
-6MFA No.100628 of 2020
10.
Learned counsel for respondent No.2 – Insurance
Company contends that the deceased was travelling as a pillion
rider on the motorcycle bearing registration No.KA-25/TC-01,
which was ridden at a high speed and in a negligent manner by
its rider, who did not possess a valid and effective driving
licence. Due to such negligence, the deceased fell from the
motorcycle and died on the spot. He submits that a false
complaint
was
lodged
against
the
driver
of
the
Car.
It is further contended that the Car involved in the accident was
not duly registered as on the date of the accident and was not
permitted to ply on the road. The vehicle, though registered as a
passenger-carrying vehicle, did not have a valid permit on the
date of the accident. It is also contended that the temporary
registration of the motorcycle bearing registration No.KA-25/TC01 was valid only up to 20.12.2015 and the accident occurred on
24.12.2015. Hence, it is submitted that respondent No.1 violated
the provisions of the M.V.Act and the terms and conditions of the
policy, and therefore the appeal deserves to be dismissed as
against respondent No.2.
11.
In support of his contention, the learned counsel
places reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
-7MFA No.100628 of 2020
the case of Amrit Paul Singh Vs.Tata AIG General Insurance
Co.Ltd., reported in AIR 2018 SC 2662. In the present case,
there is nothing brought on record by the insured to prove that
he had a permit of the vehicle. In such a situation onus cannot
be cast on the insurer.
12.
Learned counsel for respondent No.4 contends that
the rider of the motorcycle did not possess a valid and effective
driving licence at the time of the accident. The temporary
registration of the motorcycle was valid from 21.11.2015 to
20.12.2015, whereas the accident occurred on 24.12.2015.
Thus, the motorcycle was not permanently registered on the
date of the accident, and respondent No.3 violated the terms and
conditions of the insurance policy. Therefore, respondent No.4 is
not liable to indemnify respondent No.3. It is further contended
that though the accident occurred due to the negligence of the
driver of the Car, respondent No.4 cannot be fastened with
liability. Accordingly, prays to dismiss the appeal.
13.
Heard
the
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
appellants, learned counsels appearing for respondent Nos. 2
and 4 and perused the material available on record.
-8MFA No.100628 of 2020
14.
Having carefully considered the rival submissions and
the materials on record, it is not in dispute that the accident in
question occurred on 24.12.2015 and resulted in the death of
Ashabi. The involvement of the Car bearing Registration No.MH13/TRL-17 in the accident is also not seriously disputed. The
police records, namely the FIR, complaint, spot mahazar, IMV
report, post-mortem report, and charge sheet produced at
Exs.P1 to P6 clearly establish that the accident occurred due to
the rash and negligent driving of the driver of the said Car.
15.
Further in respect of the quantum of compensation is
concerned, it is seen that the Tribunal has assessed the monthly
income of the deceased at Rs.5,000/- in the absence of
documentary proof. However, considering the fact that the
accident occurred in the year 2015 and that the deceased was
stated to be engaged in tailoring work, the notional income
adopted by the Tribunal is on the lower side. This Court deems it
appropriate to reassess the monthly income of Rs.8000/- as per
the chart prepared by the Legal Services Authority. As the
deceased was aged 33 years as per the PM report, 40% has to
be added to the income of the deceased towards future
prospects as per the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
-9MFA No.100628 of 2020
Court in the case of National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs.Pranay
Sethi and others reported in 2017 ACJ 2700. The multiplier
applicable is ‘16’. Since there were four dependants at the time
of accident, 1/4th of her income has to be deducted towards
personal expenses. Accordingly, on re-determination of the ‘loss
of dependency’, the same works out to be:
8,000 + 40% x 12 x 16 x 3/4 = Rs.16,12,800/-
16.
The Tribunal has awarded a sum of Rs.1,00,000/-
towards ‘loss of love and affection’, Rs.40,000/- towards ‘loss of
consortium’,
Rs.15,000/-
towards
‘loss
of
estate’
and
Rs.15,000/- towards ‘funeral expenses’, which is just and
reasonable.
17.
In
view
of
the
above
discussion,
the
total
compensation re-determined by this Court under various heads
are as follows:
1. Loss of Dependency
2. Loss of love and affection
:
:
Rs.
Rs.
16,12,800/1,00,000/-
3. Loss of Consortium
:
Rs.
40,000/-
3. Loss of estate
:
Rs.
15,000/-
4. Funeral expenses
:
Rs.
15,000/-
TOTAL :
Rs.
17,82,800/-
18.
The claimants are entitled for total compensation of
Rs.17,82,800/-
as
against
Rs.8,90,000/-
awarded
by
the
- 10 MFA No.100628 of 2020
Tribunal along with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from
the date of filing of the petition till deposit.
19.
As regards the liability, as per the order passed by
the Tribunal, the respondent No.1 being the owner of the vehicle
is held liable for the negligence in the ratio of 25% on the
deceased and 75% on the owner of the Car. Therefore the
claimants are entitled for 75% of the total compensation
awarded in their favour.
20.
In view of the above, it is observed that the Tribunal
has rightly considered the decision of the Apex Court in Amrit
Paul Singh’s case (supra), and fastened liability on the
respondent No.1-owner of the Car by keeping in mind admitted
policy violations regarding permit and registration, and in the
absence of proof to the contrary. Therefore, the finding of the
Tribunal in respect of fastening liability on the owner does not
call for interference.
21.
In view of the foregoing reasons, this Court proceeds
to pass the following:
ORDER
i)
The appeal is allowed-in-part;
ii)
The
impugned
judgment
and
award
dated
30.01.2019 passed by the II Additional Senior Civil
- 11 MFA No.100628 of 2020
Judge and Additional MACT, Dharwad, in M.V.C.
No.24/2016, is modified;
iii)
The respondent Nos.1 to 4 – claimants are entitled
for
75%
of
the
total
compensation
of
Rs.17,82,800/- as against Rs.8,90,000/- awarded
by the Tribunal along with interest at the rate of
6% per annum from the date of filing of the
petition till deposit;
iv)
The compensation amount along with accrued
interest
if
any,
shall
be
deposited
by
the
respondent No.1 – owner of the Car, within eight
weeks from the date of filing of the petition till
deposit;
v)
Apportionment
and
disbursement
of
the
compensation amount shall be as per the order of
the Tribunal.
vi)
Amount in deposit along with accrued interest, if
any shall be transmitted to the Tribunal.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(DR. K.MANMADHA RAO)
JUDGE
KGK, CT:VP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review