Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED: 2nd NOVEMBER, 2019
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DIVISION BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WA No.02 of 2015
:
Appellant
Rajendra Prasad
versus
Respondents
:
Sikkim University and Others
Appeal under Rule 148 of the Sikkim High
Court (Practice and Procedure) Rules, 2011
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Appellant in person.
Mr. R. K. Dev Choudhury, Advocate for Respondents No.1
and 2.
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Advocate for Respondent No.3.
Ms. Pollin Rai,
Respondent No.4.
Assistant
Government
Advocate
for
None for Respondents No.5, 6 and 7.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
Dissatisfied with the finding of the learned Single
Judge in WP(C) No. 12 of 2012, by which the Writ Petition was
dismissed, the Appellant assails the Judgment dated 17.04.2015.
2.
In the Writ Petition, the prayers of the Petitioner (the
Appellant herein) were for quashing of the entire recruitment
process
under
the
two
Appointment
Notices,
one
dated
29.04.2010 (Annexure P-1) and the second dated 28.04.2011
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
(Annexure R/2-17), on the basis of which the Respondent No.2
issued appointments to vacant posts in its teaching faculty. That,
the private Respondents No.5, 6 and 7 in the Writ Petition being
appointees to the posts of Assistant Professors, be allowed to
remain in service on temporary basis until fresh recruitment
process is concluded in terms of the rules and regulations. He
also sought the quashing of the Termination Order dated
16.03.2012,
by
which
his
services
were
terminated
and
reinstatement into service with continuity and back wages. The
learned Single Judge having discussed the points raised by the
Appellant in the Writ Petition, concluded as follows in the
impugned Judgment;
“7. The substantive prayers in the Writ
Petition are for quashing (i) the selection process
and, (ii) the order of termination of the Petitioner.
In so far as the first prayer is concerned, it has
already been held that there was no illegality
committed by the Respondents No.1 and 2 in the
recruitment process as alleged by the Petitioner
and also that the Petitioner having acquiesced in
the position, had waived his right to question the
selection process. As regards the second prayer
also, it has been held that the order of termination
of the Petitioner was issued in due compliance of
the procedure laid down in the relevant Statutes
and Act of the Sikkim University and was not
arbitrary. It would also be significant to note that
the Petitioner was a contractual employee the term
of which expired on 31-03-2012. Therefore, the
prayer for reinstatement of the Petitioner in service
with back wages could not have been allowed.
Although the termination was effective from 16-032012, the salary for the remaining period also had
been paid to him and was issued with an
experience certificate sought for by him by orders
of this Court details of which shall be stated
hereafter.
8. The Writ Petition thus fails on account of
both its merit and its maintainability.
9. In the result, the Writ Petition is
dismissed.
10. However, before parting, it is observed
that quite apparent from the records, the Petitioner
was terminated from his service on 16-03-2012
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
when his contractual tenure was to end 15 (fifteen)
days later, i.e., on 31-03-2012. The Petitioner was
paid for the entire period till 31-03-2012 by order
of this Court dated 25-02-2013 in CM Appl No.18 of
2013 and experience certificate was also issued
pursuant to subsequent order dated 16-07-2013 in
CM Appl No.31 of 2013. In view of this and in view
of the fact that the Petitioner is a young person
with aspirations for future employment, in the
interest of justice, the Respondent University shall
consider converting the order of termination of his
contractual
service
dated
16-03-2012
as
termination simplicitor by deleting the last words
“on grounds of misconduct”.”
3.
delved
The facts in the Writ Petition are necessarily to be
into
for
clarity
in
the
matter.
Vide
Order
dated
23.09.2008 the Appellant was appointed on contract w.e.f.
01.10.2008 as an Assistant Professor, in the Respondent No.2
University in the “Department of Peace and Conflict Studies and
Management,” for a period of six months on consolidated salary,
which post he joined accordingly.
On completion of the
contractual period, on submission of fresh application, he was
reappointed in the same post, the last letter of appointment on
contract having been issued to him on 02.01.2012 employing
him up to 31.03.2012.
4.
In the meanwhile, on 29.04.2010, the Respondent
No.2 issued advertisements in various local, national newspapers
and the website of the University, advertising vacancies in
regular teaching positions. The Appellant applied for the post of
Assistant Professor in the “Department of Peace and Conflict
Studies and Management” and was required to and appeared for
the interview on 15.02.2012 at New Delhi. When the results
were
declared
he
emerged
unsuccessful.
Aggrieved,
the
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
Appellant submitted a written representation on 27.02.2012
before the Second Executive Council of the Respondent No.2,
complaining of gross violation of the Sikkim University Act, 2006
(for short “Act of 2006”) and Statutes of the Act of 2006
(hereinafter, “Statutes”) and serious lapses on the part of the
University in the recruitment process. However, pursuant to the
submission of the representation, the Appellant and three others
were issued Show Cause Notice by the Respondent No.2. By the
second meeting of the Second Executive Council held on
16.03.2012,
the
services
of
the
Appellant
and
another
contractual faculty member were dispensed with allegedly on
grounds
of
misconduct,
sans
opportunity
to
defend
the
accusation, thereby allegedly violating Clause 26 of the Statutes.
The Appellant averred that the results of the interview were
neither published in the newspapers nor affixed in the Notice
Board or the website of the Respondent No.2 but letters offering
appointment were issued to the private Respondents, while he
learnt of his failure only on enquiry from the University. That,
although the regular posts were sanctioned by the University
Grants Commission (for short “UGC Regulations”) during the
year 2008-2009, the advertisements thereto were published only
on 29.04.2010, while the interview came to be conducted later
between 10.01.2012 and 17.02.2012 in the absence of both the
Executive and the Academic Council. Besides, the University
failed to adhere to the provisions of Clause 18(1) and (2) of the
Statutes which prescribes details of members who are to
constitute the Selection Committee. Instead the members of the
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
Selection Committee were selected by the Respondent No.1,
usurping powers endorsed to the Executive and the Academic
Council to facilitate selection of his own candidates to the vacant
posts. This was done despite the Memorandum No.F.3-9/97Desk(U), dated 11.06.2001, of the Government of India which
explicitly prohibits Vice Chancellors from exercising emergency
powers. That, the first Executive Council demitted Office on
03.04.2011 and the first Academic Council on 24.08.2011.
Thereafter the first meeting of the Second Executive Council was
held on 22.02.2012 but interviews were conducted in the
intervening period as mentioned supra during the absence of
both
Councils.
In
the
said
meeting
of
22.02.2012
recommendations of the Selection Committee were endorsed
and appointment letters issued to the private Respondents
however, the Executive Council meeting lacked the minimum
requisite quorum of seven members as only six members were
present as evident from a response to an RTI query. The
interview was held at Delhi away from the Gangtok Head Office.
The Respondent No.2 also conducted a test for Computer Skills
with no notice of such test either in the advertisement or call
letter. That, the roster reservation policy was not implemented
in
both
the
impugned
advertisements,
neither
was
any
representative of the SC, ST or OBC communities included in the
Selection Committee against the mandate of Section 5.1.1 [a(6)]
of the UGC Regulations, dated 30.06.2010. A copy of the
Certificate issued by the concerned Authority declaring the
Appellant to be from the Other Backward Class was also
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
annexed. Assailing the entire selection process as surreptitious,
arbitrary, mala fide and in violation of the provisions of the
Statutes, the Appellant sought the reliefs in the Writ Petition as
extracted supra.
5.
The Respondents No.1 and 2, while
inter alia
admitting in their response that the impugned interview took
place on 15.02.2012, stated that the Appellant participated in
the interview without protest along with other applicants and is
now estopped from challenging the selection process.
The
results of the interview were sealed in an envelope on
15.02.2012
itself,
by
the
Selection
Committee
and
on
22.02.2012, at the first meeting of the Second Executive Council
held at Gangtok, Sikkim, the results were opened and declared.
Consequently, the Respondents No.5, 6 and 7 being successful,
came to be appointed as Assistant Professors in the Department
of Peace and Conflict Studies and Management. Admittedly, the
aggrieved Appellant having failed, along with his colleagues
submitted
a
representation
dated
27.02.2012
before
the
members of the Second Executive Council, but instead of
awaiting the decision, the Appellant on 28.02.2012 went to the
Press making false allegations and insinuations against the
authorities of the University. Consequent thereto on 06.03.2012,
the Respondent No.2 with the approval of the Respondent No.1,
sought an explanation from the Appellant for his act of breach of
privilege. Instead of showing cause, the Appellant questioned the
competence of the Respondent No.2 to issue the said letter.
That, on 16.03.2012, the Associate Professor, Department of
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
Peace and Conflict Studies and Management, reported to the
Respondent No.2 that the Appellant was abstaining from routine
activities of the Department and had not taken classes. In the
second meeting of the Second Executive Council held at New
Delhi, on 16.03.2012, following discussions the services of the
Appellant and another faculty member were terminated from the
same afternoon on grounds of misconduct. The Respondents
No.1 and 2 also denied the allegation of procedural lapses in the
recruitment process or flouting of Clause 18(1) and 2 of the
Statutes in the constitution of the Selection Committee. That,
Block Roster Reservation Policy was followed and there was no
mala fide exercise of emergency powers by the Vice Chancellor
who acted on the directions and authorisation of the First
Executive Council and the First Academic Council in their
meeting held on 03.04.2011 and 20.08.2011 respectively, to
nominate the required number of members to the Selection
Committee. Denying that the Respondent University fell under
the provisions of Section 5.1.1 of the UGC Regulations, dated
30.06.2010, it was asserted that they are governed by the
provisions of Clause 18(2) of the Statutes. That, no procedure is
prescribed for the University to declare results of the interview in
accordance with the suggestions of the Appellant and the
practice is to telephonically inform the successful candidates,
followed by issuance of appointment letters to them. That, the
principles of natural justice and Clause 26 of the Statutes were
not flouted as the services of the Appellant being contractual was
regulated by the terms of the contract, which, at Clause 10
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
specifies that his services may be terminated without notice if he
was found guilty of violation of one or more of the terms set out
in the letter. Besides, the Selection Committee constituted of
many eminent experts and public figures. Explaining as to why
the recruitments were made during the period pointed out, it
was submitted that the UGC had sanctioned teaching posts
against its “XI Plan allocation” and the recruitments were to be
concluded during the said Plan period. However, the interviews
could not be conducted during the existence of the First
Executive Council and First Academic Council due to the absence
of visitor's nominee and also the time entailed for carrying out
the
essential
shortlisting
and
other
procedures,
including
finalising of the dates of interview, duly considering the
availability
of
the
visitor's
nominee
and
other
Selection
Committee members. That, the Second Executive Council in its
first meeting held on 22.02.2012 fulfilled the requisite six
members in terms of Clause 11(3) of the Statutes contrary to
the Appellant’s allegation, as two-third of the existing members
of the Executive Council comprise the quorum. The interviews
were conducted at Delhi as per the suggestions of the visitor's
nominee and other Selection Committee members who came
from different parts of the country, for which the candidates
were paid TA/DA and the date of interview was intimated to the
Appellant two months prior to the interview i.e. on 20.12.2011.
That, the Computer Skills Test was conducted by the University
to assess the knowledge of computers of the applicants as a
mandatory qualification before participants appear for the
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
interview. The recruitment process was carried out in absolute
adherence to the Act of 2006 and the Statutes and hence the
Writ Petition be dismissed.
6.
The Respondent No.3 in the Writ Petition was
proceeded ex parte vide Order dated 16.10.2012 therein.
Similarly, Respondents No.5 and 6 were proceeded ex parte vide
Order dated 29.06.2012 and Respondent No.7 was proceeded ex
parte vide Order dated 03.09.2012. Respondent No.4 had no
Counter-Affidavit to file.
7.
In Rejoinder, the Appellant mostly reiterated the
averments made in the Writ Petition.
8.
In Appeal the Appellant assailed the Judgment in the
Writ Petition and reiterated the points raised in the Writ Petition.
The Respondents No.1 and 2 while supporting the impugned
Judgment, reiterated the grounds put forth by them in their
respective averments.
9.
We have heard the rival contentions of the Appellant
and the learned Counsel for the Respondents No.1 and 2 at
length and have carefully considered all documents on record
and perused the impugned Judgment. The citations made at the
Bar have also been carefully considered.
10.
In the impugned Judgment, the learned Single Judge
first took up the question of violation of the Reservation Policy
by the Respondent University and after verbose discussions
concluded that reservation to various posts appear to have been
complied as prescribed by the UGC and hence there is no
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
violation of the Government of India Office Memorandum
No.36012/2/96-Estt.(Res), dated 02.07.1997, issued by the
Ministry
of
Personnel,
Public
Grievances
and
Pensions
(Department of Personnel and Training).
11.
Assailing the said finding, the Appellant relying on
the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dr. Suresh Chandra
Verma and Others vs. The Chancellor, Nagpur University and Others 1
and R. K. Sabharwal and Others vs. State of Punjab and Others2
postulated that the scheme for reservations was to be applied
post wise, i.e. subject wise and not block reservations as done
by the Respondents No.1 and 2.
It was contended that the
learned Single Judge also ignored the fact that no records of the
Selection Committee were furnished, no roster was produced
and no attempt was made to disclose as to which candidate was
appointed against which roster point and why no OBC candidate
was appointed. The only fact disclosed to the High Court was the
ultimate result of the chosen candidates.
Thus, the learned
Single Judge was in error in holding that the reservations had
been applied as prescribed by the UGC when infact the Office
Memorandum of 1997 supra was clearly flouted.
That, in the
concerned Department, from three vacancies two were assigned
to the general category while one went to the Scheduled Tribe
sans reasons, which adversely affected the results.
12.
The
Respondents
No.1
and
resisting
the
contentions of the Appellant held that block roster reservation
(1990) 4 SCC 55
(1995) 2 SCC 745
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
had been adopted in the advertised posts and therefore due
adherence given to the reservation policy.
Moreover, at the
relevant time the Appellant had failed to vent his grievance on
this count and instead chose to appear for the interview thereby
waiving his rights, apart from which he is estopped from raising
such contentions belatedly.
In this context, the learned Single
Judge while arriving at his finding gave prolix reasons which, in
our considered view, was not necessary for the following
reasons; it is evident that the advertisement to the vacant posts
was issued on 29.04.2010 wherein the details of the roster were
reflected. It is clear that the interview was held between
10.01.2012 and 17.02.2012. Thus, the Appellant had more than
adequate time to object to the non-adherence of reservation of
roster points if any, if he was so aggrieved and was of the
opinion that the directions as laid down in Dr. Suresh Chandra
Verma
(supra) and R. K. Sabharwal (supra) were not being
complied
with.
The
bogey
of
non-compliance
of
roster
reservation policy has been raised by the Appellant only after he
emerged unsuccessful in the interview, having failed to do so in
the time between the issuance of the advertisement and the
interview which he willingly participated in. This ground therefore
merits no consideration clearly being an afterthought.
13.
The next point taken up for consideration in the
assailed Judgment was the allegation of violation of Clause 18(1)
and (2) of the Statutes and thereby constitution of the Selection
Committee.
The learned Single Judge held that the first
Executive Council and the first Academic Council vide their
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
meetings held on 03.04.2011 and 20.08.2011 respectively,
authorised
the
Vice
Chancellor
to
nominate
the
required
members of the Selection Committee to initiate the interview
process.
That, the Vice Chancellor had been authorised to
exercise his emergency powers to select the required number of
experts from the panel of names recommended by the House
and constitute the Selection Committee and proceed with the
recruitment action.
Thus, emergency powers were resorted to
by the Respondent No.1 on the authorisation and the resolution
of the first Academic Council but not suo moto. The act of the
Respondent No.1 was in conformity with Clause 42 of the
Statutes.
14.
Disagreeing with the finding the Appellant urged that
the learned Single Judge also held that the Vice Chancellor had
acted under Section 12(3) of the Act of 2006 which relates to
emergency powers, when no requirement infact existed for
invoking such powers as the Respondent No.1 could have during
the existence of the first Academic Council, between 2008 to
2011 sought for the panel of names, which he failed to do, thus
raising doubts of mala fides. That, no reserved category nominee
existed in the Selection Committee and though the point was
argued, the learned Single Judge did not deal with this issue at
all. That, choosing expert members for the Selection Committee
in several Departments cannot be dealt with by one person as
done by the Respondent No.1 as it requires expertise, this has
led to several discrepancies as apparent from the copy of the
Minutes
of
the
meeting
of
the
Executive
Council
dated
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
22.02.2012, one example being that in the Department of
International Relations/Politics the Respondent No.1 chose a
Professor of Geography as the expert while in the Department
of Peace and Conflict Studies and Management, two members
did
not
have
the
requisite
specialization
as
also
in
the
Department of Ethno Botany and Social Medicine Studies,
Department of Psychology Studies and Department of Journalism
and Mass Communications. That, the authorization of the First
Executive Council vide its meeting dated 03.04.2011 is not legal
neither is the selection and the exercise of emergency power by
the Respondent No.1 illegal. That, it is now well settled by the
ratio in University of Delhi vs. Raj Singh and Others3, that, the UGC
Regulations apply to all Universities in the country which
includes the Respondent University and hence the parameters
prescribed therein ought to have been given compliance by the
Respondents No.1 and 2. Per contra, the arguments advanced
by Respondents No.1 and 2 was that the Respondent No.1 had
acted as per directions of the Councils as observed in the
impugned Judgment. That, no mala fides emanated in the act of
the Respondent No.1 or Respondent No.2.
15.
Evidently, the First Executive Council demitted Office
on 03.04.2011 and the Academic Council on 24.08.2011. It is
not the case of the Appellant that he was unaware of the
provisions of the Act of 2006 or the Statutes as he himself has
pointed out to the non-adherence of Clause 18(1) and (2) of the
Statutes and Section 5.1.1 of the UGC Regulations of 2010. At
1994 Supp (3) SCC 516
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
the same time it is noticed that the Appellant has failed to clear
the air on which of the two provisions supra he relies on
considering that the composition of the Selection Committee
under the different provisions are not identical as Clause 18(1)
and (2) of the Statutes makes no provision for representative of
any specific community.
It is also not his case that he was
debarred by any authority from raising any objection on any
count at any time. Assuming that the constitution of the
Selection Committee was incorrect or that the Vice Chancellor
had invoked his emergency powers under Clause 12(3) of the
Act of 2006 contrary to the norms laid down, it is apposite to
notice that the Appellant failed to take steps when he had the
time to do so. As can be culled out from the submissions and
records before us the interview was conducted on 15.02.2012,
the Second Executive Council in its meeting on 22.02.2012
opened the results. Although the Appellant claims that he learnt
of his failure on enquiry from the Respondent No.2, he has not
ventured to disclose the date of such knowledge. We however
find that on 27.02.2012 he filed the representation before the
Second Executive Council. He could well have raised the issue of
the constitution of Selection Committee during the interim
period, when the First Executive Council and Academic Council
demitted Office in the year 2011 on the various dates detailed
above and the date of interviews held between 10.01.2012 to
17.02.2012, he chose not to do so.
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
16.
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
On this count, we may beneficially refer to the ratio
in Dr. G. Sarana vs. University of Lucknow and Others4 where the
Petitioner consequent to his appearance for an interview for the
post of Professor having been unsuccessful contended that the
experts were biased. The Hon’ble Supreme Court would observe
as follows;
“15. We do not, however, consider it
necessary in the present case to go into the
question of the reasonableness of bias or real
likelihood of bias as despite the fact that the
appellant knew all the relevant facts, he did not
before appearing for the interview or at the time of
the interview raise even his little finger against the
constitution of the Selection Committee. He seems
to have voluntarily appeared before the committee
and taken a chance of having a favourable
recommendation from it. Having done so, it is not
now open to him to turn round and question the
constitution of the committee. ...................…”
This observation is indeed apt for the purposes of the matter at
hand as well. Similarly, in Madan Lal and Others vs. State of J & K
and Others5 the Petitioners assailed the viva voce test and the
method that was conducted after emerging unsuccessful in the
same. The Hon’ble Supreme Court held as follows;
“9. ..........… Thus the petitioners took a
chance to get themselves selected at the said oral
interview. Only because they did not find
themselves to have emerged successful as a result
of their combined performance both at written test
and oral interview, they have filed this petition. It
is now well settled that if a candidate takes a
calculated chance and appears at the interview,
then, only because the result of the interview is
not palatable to him, he cannot turn round and
subsequently contend that the process of
interview was unfair or the Selection Committee
was not properly constituted. ...........…”
[emphasis supplied]
(1976) 3 SCC 585
(1995) 3 SCC 486
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
In this context, useful reference can also be made to the ratio in
Manish Kumar Shahi vs. State of Bihar and Others6
wherein the
Hon’ble Supreme Court pronounced as under;
“16. ........… Surely, if the petitioner's name
had appeared in the merit list, he would not have
even dreamed of challenging the selection. The
petitioner invoked jurisdiction of the High Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India only
after he found that his name does not figure in the
merit list prepared by the Commission. This
conduct of the petitioner clearly disentitles him
from questioning the selection and the High Court
did not commit any error by refusing to entertain
the writ petition.”
[emphasis supplied]
Further, in Ramesh Chandra Shah and Others vs. Anil Joshi and
Others7 after the Petitioners took part in the process of selection
and were unsuccessful in the interview, they challenged the
method of recruitment. The Hon’ble Supreme Court was of the
considered view as follows;
“24. In view of the propositions laid down
in the abovenoted judgments, it must be held that
by having taken part in the process of selection
with full knowledge that the recruitment was being
made under the General Rules, the respondents
had
waived
their
right
to
question
the
advertisement or the methodology adopted by the
Board for making selection and the learned Single
Judge and the Division Bench of the High Court
committed grave error by entertaining the
grievance made by the respondents.”
17.
Considering the facts as related by the Appellant and
on examination of all relevant documents, it needs no reiteration
that the Appellant slept over his rights, deigned it fit not to take
steps although aware of the alleged illegalities and rose to
defend his rights rather belatedly on his failure in the interview.
Indeed, it is a case of sour grapes for the Appellant. In our
(2010) 12 SCC 576
(2013) 11 SCC 309
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
considered opinion there was no requirement for the learned
Single Judge to have dwelt on the provisions of the Statutes and
justified the actions of the Respondent No.1 or the First
Academic and First Executive Council as it is evident that the
Appellant neglected to act when required. In other words, he
chose not to strike when the iron was hot and by filing the Writ
Petition, sought to take remedial measures for his non-action
which without a doubt is frowned upon by law.
18.
The next point that was considered was whether the
action of the Respondent No.1 was in conflict with the
Government of India Office Memorandum No.F.3-9/97-Desk(U),
dated 11.06.2001 which contained guidelines for invocation of
emergency powers of the Vice Chancellor.
The learned Single
Judge held that an extraordinary situation obtained in the
Respondent University, which fell within the exception carved out
in the Memorandum supra, hence there was no violation thereof.
Repelling the finding, it was vehemently canvassed by the
Appellant
that
the
Selection
Committee
in
terms
of
the
provisions of the Statutes ought to have comprised of the
persons enumerated therein. Contrary thereto, the Respondent
No.1 constituted the Selection Committee by usurping powers
endorsed to the Executive Council and the Academic Council in
violation of the Office Memorandum supra of the Government of
India, thus flouting the mandate of the provisions of the Act of
2006. The Memorandum explicitly prohibits the Vice Chancellor
of the Central Universities from executing emergency powers for
routine appointments. That, infact there was no emergency as a
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
Vice Chancellor could have well asked for the panel of names
from the first Academic Council during the years 2008 to 2011
which he clearly avoided.
In our considered opinion and as
already pointed out supra, the Appellant had adequate time to
address this issue prior to the interview.
He has not denied
knowledge of the exercise of such powers.
It was incumbent
upon him to take steps immediately which he failed to do. He
cannot now be heard to cry foul on his failure in the interview.
Besides, this question has already been dealt with supra and
needs no further discussions.
19.
The learned Single Judge next dealt with the
allegation that there was undue delay in holding the interview
and observed that this allegation does not appear to be justified
in view of the explanation given by the University. The learned
Single Judge also considered the point raised by the Appellant
that the results were declared neither by publication in the
newspaper nor was it put up on the website or Notice Board of
the Respondent University and concluded that this does not by
itself indicate any massive malpractice in the recruitment
process. These findings not having been assailed in Appeal and
hence do not require to be addressed.
20.
On the issue of additional tests being held in
Computer Skills it was concluded that no prejudice at all appears
to have been caused and found the objection to be of no
consequence.
In Appeal, the Appellant assailing this finding
contended that the insertion of the Computer Skills Test without
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
notice is contrary to the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Rakhi Ray and Others vs. High Court of Delhi and Others8,
wherein it was held that once the selection process starts, it is
not permissible to change the criteria in the midst of the
selection process. That, based on the performance in the said
test the mind of the members of the Selection Committee could
have been prejudiced. To the contrary, it was contended by the
Respondents No.1 and 2 that the Computer Skill Test is a
mandatory qualification before participants appear for the
interview.
21.
It may well be recalled that it is established law that
the body conducting the examination cannot change the course
midway, or for that matter as the proverb credited to Abraham
Lincoln goes “Don’t change horses in midstream”, nevertheless
the Appellant instead of protesting the Computer Skills Test at
the relevant time on grounds as raised in the Writ Petition, chose
to undergo the test and protested only on his failure on the
overall tests conducted, although admittedly he passed the
Computer tests.
In view of the observations of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the decisions cited hereinabove, the Appellant
cannot turn around to challenge the examinations once he has
participated therein and emerged unsuccessful, therefore this
objection is of no consequence and falls flat. The finding of the
learned Single Judge that the objection was of no consequence is
not being differed with.
(2010) 2 SCC 637
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
The Appellant’s challenge to his termination was next
22.
taken up for consideration and the learned Single Judge held
that it was to be determined whether or not the procedure by
which the services of the Appellant was terminated satisfies the
requirement of the provisions of the Act of 2006. Clause 26 of
the Statutes and the Sub-Clauses thereunder were discussed
and it was concluded that the requirements therein were fulfilled
as Show Cause Notice was issued to him.
That, the Appellant
instead of taking the opportunity to defend himself chose to
adopt a confrontationist attitude by replying to the Show Cause
questioning the authority of the Respondent No.2. The Appellant
in Appeal advanced the argument that contrary to the finding of
the learned Single Judge infact it was not established before the
Executive Council meeting held on 16.03.2012 as to who had
issued
the
responding
Press
Release.
The
to
lapses
pointed
the
Respondent
out
in
No.2
without
the
Appellant’s
representation dated 27.02.2012, terminated him.
That, the
learned Single Judge had observed that the Appellant was
involved in acts of misconduct and therefore no illegality
obtained
in
his
order
of
termination,
departmental enquiry was conducted.
when
infact,
no
That, the Appellant and
others similarly situated, preferred a complaint before the Sikkim
State Human Rights Commission with regard to dismissal on
grounds of misconduct and vide its Order dated 27.09.2012 the
Commission made a recommendation in favour of the Appellant
and others. That, Clause 26(4) of the Statutes provides that no
member of the academic staff or other employee shall be
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
removed under Sub-Clause (2) or Sub-Clause (3) of Clause 26
unless he has been given a reasonable opportunity of showing
cause against the action proposed to be taken in regard to him.
That, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has laid down in a catena of
decisions that if an employee either permanent or temporary
was
terminated
on
grounds
of
misconduct
and
if
such
termination was found illegal then reinstatement with back
wages is a normal remedy to meet the ends of justice. These
arguments were fortified with the ratio in Parshotam Lal Dhingra
vs. Union of India9, Deepali Gundu Surwase vs. Kranti Junior
Adhyapak Mahavidyalaya (D. ED.) and Others 10 and Roop Singh Negi
vs. Punjab National Bank and Others11. The Respondents No.1 and
2 contradicted this argument by reiterating the submissions put
forth in their averments and submitting in sum and substance
that no errors emanated in his dismissal, the Appellant being a
contractual employee and not covered by Clause 26 of the
Statutes. In our considered opinion the application of the Clause
supra is a moot question, the Appellant being a contractual
employee and thereby bound by the terms of the contract.
However, a Show Cause Notice had indeed been issued to the
Appellant informing him that two newspapers from Gangtok
being “Sikkim Now” and “Samay Dainik” published the Press
Release given by him on 28.02.2012, making false allegations
and insinuations against the Respondent University and its
authorities. The notice explained that the act was a serious
(1958) 1 SCR 828
(2013) 10 SCC 324
(2009) 2 SCC 570
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
violation of both the basic norms of the University and the Code
of Conduct by the Appellant. He was required to show cause as
to why action should not be initiated against him for the breach
of privilege. He was also required to respond within forty eight
hours of the issue of Notice failing which the Respondent
University would be free to take any action against him. Instead
of responding to the allegations held out against him in the Show
Cause Notice and thereby putting up an adequate defence for his
actions, he proceeded to question the competence of the
Respondent No.2 to issue the Notice thereby waiving his right to
take further steps in this context, leading to the grounds of
waiver and estoppel as raised by the Respondents No.1 and 2.
23.
The
learned
Single
Judge
also
addressed
the
consequence of the non-impleadment of the Respondents No.1
and 2 against whom allegations of mala fides were made and
concluded that the Writ Petition suffers from the vice of nonjoinder of necessary parties including non-joinder of those
persons who had been successful in the recruitment process. On
this count, the Appellant relied on the ratio of Dr. Suresh Chandra
Verma
(supra) at Paragraph 16 wherein it was stated that
“When,
therefore,
services
of
the
appellants
are
to
be
terminated in view of the change in the position of law and not
on the account of demerits and misdemeanor of individual
candidates, it is not necessary to hear the individual before their
services are terminated. The rule of audi alterem partem does
not apply in such cases and therefore there is not breach of the
principle of natural justice.” How the aforestated observation is
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
of any assistance to the Appellant is unfathomable. However, on
consideration of the reasoning in the impugned Judgment and
the averments and submissions before us, it appears that the
Respondents No.5, 6 and 7 were the parties that the Appellant
had a grievance against in view of their selection to the coveted
posts in the Department of Peace and Conflict Studies and
Management which was the Department that the Appellant had
also applied to. It is only their appointments which would be
affected in the event that reliefs were found justifiable to the
Appellant. Therefore, it is evident that an error stares us in the
face in the assailed Judgment on this count and we are in
disagreement with the conclusion of the learned Single Judge on
this aspect.
24.
The learned Single Judge further delved into the
want of quorum of the Executive Council held on 22.02.2012 and
concluded that on this count the Appellant appears to be clearly
misconceived. That, only six members were required to fulfil the
quorum in the Executive Council Meeting and not seven as can
be deduced from Clause 11(3) of the Act of 2006, which provides
that twelve members out of total of twenty or two-third of the
existing members of the Executive Council shall form a quorum.
It was argued by the Appellant that the quorum ought to have
comprised of seven members and there is no provision which
requires further ratification to include the nominated members of
the UGC as members of the Executive Council. The Respondents
No.1 and 2 would support the finding of the learned Single
Judge. On this aspect, Clause 11 of the Statutes provides that
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
seven members of the Executive Council shall form a quorum for
a meeting of the Executive Council. However, neither Clause 11
or any other Clause of the Statutes lays down the repercussions
or consequences of non-fulfilment of quorum.
This can be
juxtaposed with Clause 18 of the Statutes which deals with
composition of a Selection Committee and provides specifically
that unless the provisions as detailed in Clause 18(3)(a) and (b)
are complied with the proceedings of the Selection Committee
shall not be valid.
Thus, in the absence of any specific
consequence of non-formation of the quorum, added to the
contention being raised only on the failure of the Appellant, no
merit arises in the objection of the Appellant which is accordingly
discarded.
25.
It is also evident from the assailed Judgment that
although the Appellant was terminated from his services on
16.03.2012
when
his
contractual
tenure
was
to
end
on
31.03.2012, the Appellant was paid for the entire period till
31.03.2012 vide Orders of the Court dated 25.02.2013 in CM
Appl. No.18 of 2013 in WP(C) No.44 of 2012.
An Experience
Certificate was also issued to the Appellant pursuant to an Order
dated 16.07.2013 in CM Appl. No.31 of 2013 in WP(C) No.44 of
2012. Both the said Applications were of the year 2013. The
Respondent No.2 was also to consider converting the order of
termination dated 16.03.2012 as “termination simplicitor” by
deleting the last words “on grounds of misconduct.”
WA No. 02 of 2015
Rajendra Prasad
26.
vs.
Sikkim University and Others
It thereby concludes that the Appellant after being
unsuccessful in the interview sought to challenge it on the
grounds discussed above. It is pertinent to notice here that it is
not the Appellant’s case that he was a better candidate than the
Respondents No.5, 6 and 7 and that therefore his non-selection
was unfair and mala fide.
His contention pivots around the
formation of the Selection Committee the quorum of the
Executive Council and the points already discussed hereinabove.
It is submitted by the Appellant that he is now appointed
elsewhere indicating that no prejudice was caused to him in
terms of his future appointment.
27.
For the reasons enumerated hereinabove, the Writ
Appeal being devoid of merit deserves to be and is accordingly
dismissed.
28.
No order as to costs.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
02-11-2019
02-11-2019
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ml
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review