Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 08.06.2019
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH :
THE HON‟BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RFA No. 13 of 2017
Appellants
:
1. Shri Rajendra Prasad Mangla,
Son of Late Narsing Das Mangla,
Proprietor Golden Tea Company,
Resident of Rangpo, East Sikkim.
2. M/s Golden Tea Company,
Proprietor Rajendra Prasad Mangla,
Lal Market Road, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondent
:
Shri Govind Agarwal,
Son of Late Chetram Agarwal,
Lal Market Road, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
Appeal under Order XLI Rules 1 and 2
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Sudesh Joshi and Mr.
Advocates for the Appellants.
Sonam
Palden
Tamang,
Dr. (Ms.) Doma T. Bhutia, Advocate for the Respondent.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J
1.
The Appellants herein were ordered to vacate the
suit premises of the Respondent on bona fide requirement of
the Respondent and default in payment of rent by the
Appellants, vide the Judgment dated 31.08.2017 in Eviction
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
Suit No. 08 of 2014 (Shri Govind Agarwal v. Shri Rajendra
Prasad Mangla and Another). Aggrieved, the Appellants herein
are assailing it in Appeal.
2.
The
Respondent‟s/Plaintiff‟s
case
before
the
learned trial Court was that the suit property described in
Schedule „A‟ to the plaint comprising of a shop measuring
9‟x14½‟, on the fourth floor of a five storeyed RCC building,
along with a gully measuring 30‟x60‟ and in the third floor of
the same building
rooms measuring a total area of 22‟x45‟
and
rented
11‟x20‟
were
Respondent/Plaintiff
out
(hereinafter
by
the
mother
of
the
“Respondent”)
to
the
Appellants/Defendants No. 1 and 2 (hereinafter “Appellants
No. 1 and 2”), vide an Agreement dated 17.05.1978. The
Appellant No. 1 is in continuous occupation of the said suit
premises since 1978 with rent fixed at Rs.625/- (Rupees six
hundred and twenty five) only, per month, excluding water
and electricity charges. The third shop on the fourth floor
which is rented to the Appellants, fell in the share of the
Respondent by a verbal partition effected by his mother, late
Saraswati Agarwal, between him and his two brothers. The
Respondent‟s wife carries on business in the adjacent shop,
which fell in the share of his youngest brother, after duly
obtaining his brother‟s permission but the income therefrom
is paltry. The Respondent‟s specific case is that his family
which includes his wife, brother-in-law and two sons who are
pursuing higher education are entirely dependent on him,
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
apart from which he suffers from several health issues, hence
the requirement for the tenanted premises in order to
augment his income. That apart, the Respondent has been
compelled to take up premises at a monthly rent of
Rs.7,500/- (Rupees seven thousand and five hundred) only,
in Gangtok. That, on the other hand, the Appellant No. 1 is
settled in Rangpo where he conducts business in his four
storeyed RCC building. That, the Respondent‟s mother who
was receiving the house rent for the Schedule „A‟ premises
passed away on 21.01.2010 but despite knowledge of this
fact, the Appellant No. 1 continued to remit the monthly rent
by Money Order in her name. That, on 19.04.2013, the
Respondent issued a Legal Notice to the Appellant No. 1
terminating the rent agreement dated 17.05.1978. The
Appellant No. 1 sent a reply through their Lawyer dated
16.05.2013, Exhibit 12, implicitly revealing that the suit
premises were in the occupation of his employees and was
not in his own use. Later in response, to the Respondent‟s
letter dated 04.01.2014, Exhibit 13, the Appellant No. 1 sent
another reply on 24.01.2014, Exhibit 14, allegedly reiterating
the requirement of the suit premises for his employees. That,
although the Appellant No. 1 sought to meet the Respondent
to settle the matter amicably, he failed to appear on the dates
fixed, hence the prayers in the plaint inter alia seeking
eviction
of
the
Appellants
requirement and default in rent.
on
grounds
of
bona
fide
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
3.
The Appellants, in their written statement, denied
and disputed the claims of the Respondent and pleaded
ignorance of the partition amongst the Respondent and his
two brothers. That, no proof of ownership of the suit premises
by the Respondent has been furnished nor disclosure made
with regard to who the rent was to be tendered to, hence the
Appellant No. 1 has continuously been tendering rent in the
name of the Respondent‟s mother by Money Order. The
question of default in rent does not arise as it is the
Respondent who has failed to accept the rents tendered by
him by Money Orders. The Appellants deny having any other
business besides the tea business located in the tenanted
premises. Admitting that the Appellant No. 1 lives in Rangpo,
he specified that it was on account of his ill health and
asserted that he periodically visits the tenanted premises to
oversee the business which he denies is in the occupation of
his employees. That, there is no bona fide requirement of the
Respondent whose income from the shop suffices for his
family, hence the suit be dismissed.
4.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the
learned trial Court framed the following issues:
“(1) Whether the Plaintiff is the absolute
owner/landlord of the suit premises?
(2) Whether the Plaintiff requires the suit
premises for his and his dependents‟
bona fide use and occupation?
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
(3) Whether the Defendant has defaulted in
payment of the monthly rents?
(4) Relief(s), if any.”
5.
On Issue No. 1, the learned trial Court concluded
that the Respondent is the owner of the tenanted premises.
On Issue No. 2, it was found that the Respondent required
the tenanted premises bona fide for occupation and for his
business.
Issue
No.
was
decided
in
favour
of
the
Respondent on account of default of payment of rent by the
Appellants from the month of January, 2010. On Issue No. 4,
it was concluded that the Appellants are to be evicted from
the scheduled premises and to hand over vacant and peaceful
possession to the Respondent and to pay arrears of rent from
January
to
August
2017.
The
suit
was
decreed
accordingly.
6.
the
The grounds urged in Appeal herein are that in
Notices
sent
to
the
Appellants
on
behalf
of
the
Respondent, he claims to be the owner of the entire five
storeyed building and not just of the suit premises, which
tantamounts to commission of fraud. That, it is a well settled
principle of law that if any Judgment or Order is obtained by
fraud it cannot be said to be a Judgment or Order in law. On
this count, reliance was placed on A.V. Papayya Sastry and
Others v. Govt. of A.P. and Others 1. The Respondent, due to his
(2007) 4 SCC 221
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
vacillating pleadings has failed to establish that he is the
owner of the suit premises and his claim of partition of
properties remained unproved even by the evidence of his
wife, PW 2 or his brother-in-law, PW 5. That, the burden of
proof on this aspect rests on the Respondent. On this count,
succour was drawn from the ratio in Corporation of City of
Bangalore
v.
Kuppuswami
Zulekha
and
Bi
and
Another3.
Others2
That,
the
and
Rangammal
provisions
of
v.
the
“Gangtok Rent Control and Eviction Act I of 1956” requires
only the owner to file an Eviction Suit but no proof of
ownership has been advanced by the Respondent. That, on
account of the refusal by the Respondent‟s mother to accept
rent in cash after 1998, the Appellants started remitting it by
Money Order which they have continued to do even after her
death due to ignorance as to the owner of the premises,
hence no arrears of rent accrues to the Respondent. That, the
evidence of the Postmen examined in the Court clearly reveal
that even during the lifetime of Saraswati Agarwal, the
Respondent would not allow them to meet her when they
went to deliver the Money Order to her. That, the Respondent
was bent on evicting the Appellants from the suit premises as
can be gauged from his attitude. It was further urged that the
Respondent has also failed to establish bona fide requirement.
Learned Counsel would also deny any attornment by the
(2008) 11 SCC 306
(2011) 12 SCC 220
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
Appellants No. 1 and 2 to the Respondent. That, in fact the
shop being run by PW 2, the Respondent‟s wife is their own
shop as established by Exhibit 5, the Trade Licence issued in
her name for business to be carried on in her own property.
No evidence has been furnished to establish that the shop fell
in the share of the Respondent‟s youngest brother Anand
Agarwal. That, during the course of evidence, an effort was
made to establish that the Respondent is the karta of his
family but this is a concept introduced only in the evidence
and is in contradiction to the pleadings of partition. Assuming
that the property is of a Hindu Undivided Family, the suit
cannot be filed by the Respondent in his personal capacity.
The Appellants No. 1 and 2 also sought to question the locus
standi of Saraswati Agarwal to partition the suit properties,
verbal or otherwise as she did not qualify as a karta of a
Hindu Undivided Family and could only act as its manager. On
this count, reliance was placed on Shreya Vidyarthi v. Ashok
Vidyarthi and Others4. That, the evidence of Manila Sherpa, PW
4 to establish that the Respondent has taken premises on
rent from her for business purposes remained unproved. PW
7, Suresh Kumar Agarwal claimed that the partition was
affected in the year 1979 but no details thereof were
furnished. Ironically, the living brothers of the Respondent
and his nephews were not brought to establish this fact. That,
PW 7 is an unreliable witness as in a bid to improve the
(2015) 16 SCC 46
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
Respondent‟s case he has added facts which have not been
averred in the Plaint. The witness, under cross-examination,
testified that Saraswati Devi Agarwal was not the landlady of
the tenanted premises during her lifetime thereby belying the
admission of the Respondent. Besides, he was unaware of the
mode of payment of rent to her. Although reliance was placed
on Exhibit 9 and Exhibit 10 allegedly sent by the Respondent
to the Appellant No. 1 requiring him to vacate the suit
premises and settle outstanding rents, but no proof of either
the letters having been sent or the Appellants being in receipt
thereof were furnished. That, although the Legal Notice,
Exhibit 10 speaks of an Agreement, dated 17.05.1978,
purportedly
executed
Respondent,
the
between
document
the
was
Appellants
not
and
exhibited
the
thereby
prompting an adverse inference under Section 114(g) of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872. That, Exhibit 12 is the document
by which the Respondent claims that the Appellants attorned
to him and allegedly requested the Respondent to execute a
formal agreement pertaining to
revised rent repeatedly but
these
unsubstantiated.
allegations
Respondent‟s
case
too
went
having
remained
That,
the
unestablished,
the
impugned Judgment requires to be set aside.
7.
Resisting the arguments of learned Counsel for
the Appellants No. 1 and 2, learned Counsel for the
Respondent in the first instance, admitted that no documents
of ownership to establish that the Respondent was indeed the
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
owner of the tenanted premises existed. That, the partition
was an oral one effected by the late mother of the
Respondent and it is now settled law that in a suit for eviction
the title of the landlord cannot be adjudicated upon. Reliance
in this context was placed on Dr. Yogesh Verma v. Shri Shiv
Kumar Agarwal and Another5
and Smt. Kaushilya Minda and
Another v. Rajesh Verma6. That, the evidence of the Appellants‟
witness, Sushmita Mangla, DW 6, the daughter of the
Respondent‟s late brother, Raj Kumar Agarwal establishes
that Bijay Agarwal, her brother, is running the corner shop
thus lending support to the fact of oral partition. That, Exhibit
12, the reply by the Appellants‟ Counsel to the Legal Notice
sent by the Respondent‟s Counsel is a clear indication of
attornment by the Appellants to the Respondent. That, Exhibit
D-1 the Trade Licence issued in the name of the Appellant No.
1 bears the signature of Sispal Chaudhary, his employee
lending credence to the fact that the Appellants are not in
possession of the tenanted premises but have sublet the
premises to Sispal Chaudhary, DW 3. This fact is buttressed
by the cross-examination of the Appellant No. 1 who has
admitted that he has not filed any document to show that he
was running the business of M/S Golden Tea Company. That
the bona fide requirement of the Respondent is established by
the evidence of the witnesses furnished by the Respondent.
AIR 2018 (NOC 278) 97
AIR 2017 Sikk 1
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
Contending that there was default in payment of rent for
seven years from January 2010 to 2017, it was postulated
that the Appellants despite attornment to the Respondent in
2013 continued to send rent in the name of the Respondent‟s
deceased mother which he could not accept. On this count
reliance was placed on Shyam Sundar Beriwala & Ors. v. M/s.
Bhajanlal
Sajjan
Kumar7.
That,
the
requirement
of
the
Respondent is bona fide and the tenant cannot dictate terms
to the landlord regarding use of his property as held in R.C.
Tamrakar and Another v. Nidi Lekha8. Hence, no error emanates
in the observations and conclusion of the learned trial Court
and consequently the Appeal be dismissed.
8.
I have considered the rival contentions of both
learned Counsel at length and given due consideration to their
submissions. I have also carefully considered the evidence
and
documents
on
record
and
perused
the
impugned
judgment as also the citations made at the Bar.
9.
The questions that fall for consideration before
this Court are as follows:
1. Whether a jural relationship exists between the
Respondent and the Appellants No. 1 and 2?
2011 SCC OnLine Cal 2880
(2001) 8 SCC 431
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
2. Whether the Appellants No. 1 and 2 were liable
to
be
evicted
on
grounds
of
bona
fide
requirement of the Respondent and for default
in payment of rent?
10.
While examining the first question hereinabove
framed, it is imperative to advert to Issue No. 1 settled for
adjudication by the learned trial Court viz. “Whether the
Plaintiff is the absolute owner/landlord of the suit premises?”
The learned trial Court, as already stated, observed that the
Respondent was the owner of the tenanted premises. It is
now no more res integra that in eviction proceedings the
question of title to the properties may be incidentally
discussed but cannot be decided finally. In this view of the
matter, it is relevant to refer to Bhogadi Kannababu and Others
v. Vuggina Pydamma and Others9, wherein the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court observed inter alia as follows;
“19. In this connection, we may also
point out that in an eviction petition filed on
the ground of sub-letting and default, the court
needs to decide whether relationship of
landlord and tenant exists and not the
question of title to the properties in question,
which may be incidentally gone into, but
cannot be decided finally in the eviction
proceeding.”
(emphasis supplied)
Later in Keshar Bai v. Chhunulal10, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
held as follows;
(2006) 5 SCC 532
(2014) 11 SCC 438
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
“14. …The High Court has accepted that
in his cross-examination the respondent has
stated that he was not accepting the appellant
as his landlady. ……… The High Court has
further held that the respondent was within the
permissible limit in asking the appellant to
produce documentary evidence about his title
as a landlord. The High Court, in our opinion,
fell into a grave error in drawing such a
conclusion. Even denial of a landlord's title in
the written statement can provide a ground
for eviction of a tenant. It is also settled
position in law that it is not necessary that the
denial of title by the landlord should be
anterior
to
the
institution
of
eviction
proceedings. .................
15. The High Court has expressed that
the respondent was justified in asking the
appellant to produce the documents. Implicit
in this observation is the High Court's view
that the respondent could have in an eviction
suit got the title of the appellant finally
adjudicated upon. There is a fallacy in this
reasoning.
In
eviction
proceedings
the
question of title to the properties in question
may be incidentally gone into, but cannot be
decided finally. …”
(emphasis supplied)
Hence, it is evident that the question of title is not required to
be settled in an Eviction Suit.
11.
The
Appellants
have
placed
reliance
on
Corporation of City of Bangalore v. Zulekha Bi and Others (supra)
to establish that the burden of proof of ownership lies on the
Respondent. This is irrelevant for the present purposes as the
instant matter pertains to a landlord-tenant dispute and not
title. Reliance was further placed on Rangammal v. Kuppuswami
and Another (supra), which is also misplaced as it is in the
context of partition of a joint family property. In these
circumstances, the argument of learned Counsel for the
Appellants that the owner and none else is to file the suit in
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
terms of the provisions of the “Gangtok Rent Control and
Eviction Act I of 1956” is untenable.
12.
Be
that
as
it
may,
to
establish
that
the
Respondent was the landlord of the Appellants, the attention
of this Court was drawn to Exhibit 10, a Legal Notice sent to
the Appellant No. 1 on 19.04.2013 by the Respondent‟s
Advocate. Exhibit 10 inter alia informs that the Respondent
runs a shop beside the rental shop given to the Appellants on
rent and due to his financial constraints he requires the
tenanted premises to overcome his financial difficulties, thus
he terminates the rent agreement dated 17.05.1978 between
him and the Appellant No. 1 and required them to vacate the
premises. In response thereof, the Appellant No. 1 sent a
reply dated 16.05.2013, Exhibit 12 which inter alia reflects as
follows;
“2. ... That your client has been regularly
refusing to accept the tendered rents for the
last several years.
..................................................................
5. That as regards your client requesting
my client to vacate the said premises, the
same does not bear an element of truth in it.
As a matter of fact, rather my client has been
requesting your client to execute a formal
agreement, with revised rent time and again,
over almost two decades, to which your client
is yet to respond. Your client has been
regularly refusing to accept the rents
personally, besides he is continuously ignoring
to executing a formal rental agreement over
two decades, as a result of which my client is
forced to tender rent by way of money orders
every month without fail since then, each time
hoping that the rent would be accepted by
your client. In fact your client is neither
revising the rent, nor accepting the same
directly from my client, or has he executed a
revised rental agreement (sic), as was agreed
Orally amongst them over decades ago. ...
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
6. That my client informs me that by
sending a notice, your client appears to create
undue pressure upon my client, to succumb to
his so called requirements, in circumstances
when your client has neither revised the rent
nor executed a fresh agreement so far, and
has been regularly refusing acceptance of
rents. In such circumstances, my client is
untouched by element of default at any point
of time. Your Notice is un-warranted, and it
appears that your Client did not tell you truth
that - the Oral agreement between my client
and your client was that – my Client would
live/stay as long as he wish to run the shop
(sic). Your Client had enhanced/revised the rate
of rent to Rs.675/- per month in May, 1978,
and your Client appear to be adamant in
enhancing rent still further. My client reserves
his right to file an application before the
appropriate authority under the Law for
fixation of rent, if your client does not do so.
7. That my client has been occupying the
rental premises, and has been regularly
tendering the rent from the time of his late
father, and the rent tendered by money orders
is being regularly refused by your client. ... The
reason for issuance of the Notice under
reference is the refusal by my client to accept
the proposal for exorbitant enhancement of
rent, as it was unjustified and illegal demand of
your client, and against the statutory
provisions of the law of the land. ...
8. ... and also your client has not
executed any revised agreement or revised
the rent despite several requests made by my
client, and my client has not defaulted at any
point of time in tendering rents to your Client.
My Client has been tendering rents regularly
to your Client by M.O.; Hence, your Notice to
quit and vacate the tenanted shop within 30
days of receipt is not valid.
9. ... It is your Client who has forced my
Client by his refusal to tender the rent every
month by Money Orders, that too at his cost,
which is under the law and the means to make
payment directly upon refusal to accept the
rent directly from the tenant. My client is not
going to vacate the shop under his occupation
and use as asked by you. Your client is at
liberty to file an eviction suit against my client
at his sole risk, ...
10. ....................................................
Kindly tell your Client not to file any suit
against my Client who is still willing to sit
across table to finalise a workable/acceptable
rental and execute an amicable agreement
thereafter, in order to harass and make un-due
pressure over him, as presently he is not well
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
since too long ago, and your client started
harassing him, ...”
(emphasis supplied)
This response was met by a counter response of the
Respondent dated 04.01.2014, Exhibit 13, reiterating that the
Respondent was in requirement of the tenanted premises for
his bona fide personal use and that of his dependents and
requested that the Appellants vacate the tenanted premises.
Another response ensued from the Appellant No. 1 being
Exhibit 14, dated 24.01.2014, reiterating therein that the rent
had not been revised by the Respondent nor a fresh
agreement executed but the rents being tendered by the
Appellant No. 1 were being refused. That, the parties could sit
together and work out an acceptable rental and execute an
amicable agreement between themselves. On this note, we
may now examine what attornment entails.
13.
In Uppalapati Veera Venkata Satyanarayanaraju and
Another v. Josyula Hanumayamma and Another 11, a four Judge
bench
of
the
Hon‟ble
Supreme
Court
has
explained
“attornment” as follows;
“14. “Attornment, in its strict sense, is an
agreement of the tenant to a grant of the
reversion made by the landlord to another, or,
as it has been defined, „the act of the tenants
putting one person in the place of another as
his landlord‟” — see para 732, Foa's General
Law of Landlord and Tenant. This means that
in the first instance attornment is made in
favour of the person who has derived his title
or supposed title from the original landlord. It
AIR 1967 SC 174
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
implies a continuity of the tenancy created by
the original landlord in favour of the tenant. It
is in these circumstances that the existing
tenant, for the rest of the period of his
tenancy, agrees to acknowledge the new
landlord as his landlord. Such an agreement of
the tenant amounts to attornment and by such
an attornment the tenant by his act substitutes
the new landlord in place of the previous one.
Such attornment is complete the moment the
tenant agrees to acknowledge the new landlord
to be his landlord. Any future payment or nonpayment of rent does not affect the
relationship created by the attornment. The
new landlord will have his remedies with
respect to the rents falling in arrears.
Again, it is stated in para 745 at p. 475:
“With regard to the title of a person from
whom the possession was not obtained, but
who has been recognised as landlord by the
tenant, such recognition may be by express
agreement, by attornment, or other formal
acknowledgment (as by paying a nominal sum
of money), by payment of rent, or of a nominal
sum as rent, or by submission to a distress.”
The attornment is here described as one mode
of recognising a person as one's landlord, just
as payment of rent is another mode for the
purpose. Expression to similar effect is to be
found in paras 746, and also 747 where it is
further noted:
“But the tenant is not allowed to impeach
the title of a person to whom he has paid rent,
or whose title he has otherwise recognised,
without showing a better title in some other
person. …”
……………………………………………………………………………
16. These observations make it clear that
simply by attornment the tenant is estopped
from questioning the derivative title of the
claimant's successor just as the acceptance of
rent will create an estoppel against the
landlord from denying the person, who paid the
rent, to be his tenant. These observations do
not indicate that any actual payment of rent
by the tenant who has attorned is necessary
to make the attornment effective. If it was
otherwise, the new landlord in whose favour
the tenant has attorned, will not be able to
take successfully any action against that
person till that person had made the first
payment of rent.
…………………………………………………………………………………”
(emphasis supplied)
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
14.
The above-stated decision was referred to by the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Apollo Zipper India Limited v. W.
Newman and Company Limited12 wherein it was also held inter
alia as follows;
“58. As mentioned above, the title of the
landlord over the tenanted premises in a suit
for eviction cannot be examined like a title suit.
Similarly, the attornment can be proved by
several circumstances including taking into
consideration the conduct of the tenant qua
landlord.”
(emphasis supplied)
The ratiocination extracted supra exposits with clarity the
position of law on attornment and its implications.
15.
A careful examination of the documents relied on
by the parties as discussed hereinabove clearly establish that
the
Appellants
had
by
their
conduct
attorned
to
the
Respondent. The Appellant No. 1 in the communications has
insisted on a settlement between him and the Respondent to
reach an amicable amount to be paid as revised rent to the
Respondent. If the Appellant No. 1 did not consider the
Respondent as his landlord then there was no reason for him
to
seek
such
a
settlement.
The
Appellants,
by
the
correspondences reflected hereinabove have accepted the
Respondent as their landlord. Although the rent was remitted
in the name of Saraswati Agarwal, the Appellant No. 1 has
insisted in his correspondence that the Respondent refused to
accept rent and thus could not hold the Appellants responsible
(2018) 6 SCC 744
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
for default, this aspect also points to a clear acceptance of the
Respondent as his landlord. Ignorance of oral partition was
asserted by the Appellant No. 1 and a feeble attempt was
made to establish acrimony amongst the Respondent and his
living brother and nephew pertaining to the suit premises,
thereby making an insidious attempt to insert a plea of nonjoinder of parties. It would be relevant to point out that in a
suit by a landlord against a tenant for arrears of rent and
eviction, it is not necessary to implead the brothers or other
relatives of the landlord and title cannot be an issue. It may
also pertinently be mentioned that it is settled law that a plea
of non-joinder cannot be raised at the appellate stage as held
in Church of Christ Charitable Trust and Educational Charitable
Society, Represented by its Chairman v. Ponniamman Educational
Trust, Represented by its Chairperson/ Managing Trustee13.
It
may be claimed that the Respondent by not accepting the
rent has denied his position as a landlord, however the Legal
Notices, Exhibit 10 and Exhibit 19 and the Counter Reply,
Exhibit 13 stand testimony to his assertion that he is the
landlord of the tenanted premises.
16.
The Appellants relied on Shreya Vidyarthi v. Ashok
Vidyarthi and Others (supra) wherein it was held that a Hindu
widow is not a coparcener in the undivided family of her
husband therefore she cannot act as a karta of that undivided
(2012) 8 SCC 706
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
family, however she can act as its manager. This is an
indubitable position of law but in the instant matter no
objections from the brother of the Respondent ensued and
the Appellant No. 1 has no locus standi to raise this question.
Consequently in view of the foregoing discussions, it can
safely be concluded that a jural relationship exists between
the Appellants and the Respondent.
17.
It is now to be examined meticulously as to
whether the Respondent herein has been able to establish his
bona fide requirement and rent in arrears amounting to four
months or more.
18.
The Gangtok Rent Control and Eviction Act I of
1956 lays down at Paragraph 4 as follows;
“4. A Landlord may not ordinarily eject
any tenant. When, however, the whole or part
of the premises are required for the bonafide
occupation of the landlord or his dependents or
for thorough overhauling (excluding additions
and alterations) or when the rent in arrears
amount to four months rent or more, the
landlord may evict the tenant on filing a suit of
ejectment in the Court of the Chief Magistrate.
The tenant so evicted shall, however, have the
first right to re-occupy the premises, after
over-hauling, on such enhanced rent as may be
fixed by the Sikkim Darbar before it is let out
to any other tenant.”
19.
The Respondent in his evidence has deposed that
his wife, brother-in-law and both his sons who are pursuing
higher education, one in USA and one in Nepal are dependent
upon him added to which he himself has health issues.
According to him, the college fees and living costs of his sons
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
are exorbitant. The evidence of the Respondent on this count
is supported by the evidence of his sons PW 3, Ashish
Agarwal and PW 6, Akash Agarwal who have both stated that
their father bears their educational and other miscellaneous
expenses. To
further
validate
this
assertion, Exhibit 6
(collectively) has been relied upon by the Respondent, which
pertains to the enrolment of PW 6 Akash Agarwal, in the
University of Toledo, USA and Lease Agreement for living
apartments and student fees of the University. Exhibit 7
(collectively) pertains to the witness PW 3, Ashish Agarwal
and his selection in the academic session of 2008, Tribhuvan
University, Institute of Medicine, Nepal and fee receipts.
Exhibt 17 was also relied upon by the Respondent to indicate
the state of his health and the condition “Generalized
myasthenis (myasthenia gravis)” from which he suffers. The
Respondent‟s wife, PW 2
supported the
fact that
the
Respondent is a patient of the said ailment and requires
medical treatment and that she along with their sons who are
studying as also her brother are dependent on her husband.
The evidence of Manila Sherpa, PW 4, however is of no
assistance to the Respondent as neither the year of having
rented out the premises to the Respondent nor any receipts
pertaining to rent have been furnished.
20.
The Appellant No. 1 admitted that he is the sole
proprietor of Golden Tea Company being run in the tenanted
premises and he is in sole occupation of the tenanted
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
premises. As per the Respondent, which is admitted by the
Appellant No. 1, he is now settled in Rangpo with his family.
The Respondent went on to state that the Appellant No. 1 is
not residing in Rangpo on account of ill health but is
conducting his business in Rangpo. The Trade Licences,
Exhibit D-5, Exhibit D-6 and Exhibit D-7 issued in the name of
one Din Dayal Mangla and Lalita Devi Mangla belongs to the
joint family of the Appellant No. 1. The evidence of DW 6,
Sushmita Mangla supports the evidence of the Respondent
that the Appellant No. 1 is living in Rangpo. She added that
Din Dayal Mangla lives in Siliguri and has two shops in
Rangpo of which his wife was the proprietor of one. She
would further testify that Sita Mangla who is the wife of the
Appellant No. 1, lives in Siliguri in the house of Usha Mangla
and
Din
Dayal
Mangla.
Her
evidence
raises
a
strong
probability that the Appellant No. 1 was indeed conducting his
business at Rangpo as Din Dayal Mangla and his wife in
whose names the business Licences were issued are living in
Siliguri, as also the wife of the Appellant No. 1. No evidence
was furnished to prove that the Appellant No. 1 frequented
Gangtok to supervise his business while PW 7, Suresh Kumar
Agarwal testified that he had never seen the Appellant No. 1
coming to Gangtok to take stock of his business here. In fact
from all accounts, it appears that the employee of the
Appellant No. 1 has been sublet the premises but since this is
not an issue herein the Pandora‟s box can remain closed. The
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
evidence on record also reveals that the Respondent has no
other business except the business of one small tea shop and
his family is entirely dependent on the income generated from
this business. His medical condition would undoubtedly entail
higher expenditure. In view of the afore discussed facts and
circumstances, I am of the considered opinion that the
Respondent requires the premises bona fide for his own use.
21.
In Sidhharth Viyas and Another v. Ravi Nath Misra
and Others14 it was propounded as follows;
“10. The object of rent law is to balance the
competing claims of the landlord on the one
hand to recover possession of building let out
to the tenant and of the tenant to be protected
against arbitrary increase of rent or arbitrary
eviction, when there is acute shortage of
accommodation. Though, it is for the
legislature to resolve such competing claims in
terms of statutory provisions, while interpreting
the provisions the object of the Act has to be
kept in view by the Court. Unless otherwise
provided, a tenant who has already acquired
alternative accommodation is not intended to
be protected by the Rent Act.”
22.
That having been said, it would now be necessary
to consider whether there was default in payment of rent. It
is an admitted fact that the Appellant No. 1 was in the know
of the passing away of the Respondent‟s mother as the
Appellant No. 1 incessantly insisted on a meeting with the
Respondent to settle the rent matter with him. This reveals
that he was aware that the Respondent No. 1 was the rightful
(2015) 2 SCC 701
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
owner of the suit premises. This is fortified by the fact that
the Respondent had a living brother and a nephew but no
such arrangements were sought to be made with them by the
Appellant No. 1. The Appellant No. 1 admittedly continued to
send Money Order in the name of Saraswati Agarwal despite
knowledge of her death when in the circumstances supra it
was imperative that the rent be despatched in the name of
the Respondent. The Respondent, in his cross-examination,
has denied that the Appellant No. 1, after the death of his
mother came and enquired from him as to whom the rent
should be tendered to and he had refused to answer. Why the
Appellant No. 1 failed to enquire from the other brother and
nephew of the Respondent when no response on this count
was
forthcoming
from
the
Respondent
is
shrouded
in
mystery. He also denied that from May 1998, his mother
refused to accept the monthly rent tendered in cash by the
Appellant No. 1 pursuant to which the Appellant No. 1 had to
send it through Money Order. DW 8, the Postman who
allegedly went to deliver the Money Order deposed that as
per the Post Office Rules, the remitter has to give the proper
address of the payee including the house number in order to
have the Money Order delivered. DW 5, another Postman
deposed that Money Order can be received only by the person
in whose name it is sent and not by any other person. DW 4,
also a Postman working in the Head Post Office, Gangtok has
stated that “... as per the Rule of the Post Office, in the case
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
of delivery of MO to the concerned payee there has to be two
witnesses along with the Postman and the same practice is
followed in case of return of the MO. …” No evidence in this
context is in the records of the case to support the Appellants‟
case neither have any records been put forth to establish the
Respondent‟s refusal to accept the rent. Accordingly it is
found that the Appellants were in default of payment of rent
from January 2010 to 2017.
23.
So far as the question of obtaining the judgment
by fraud is concerned, the Appellants relied on A.V. Papayya
Sastry and Others
(supra) wherein it was held that fraud
vitiates all judicial acts whether in rem or in personam and
that a judgment, decree or order obtained by fraud has to be
treated as non est and nullity and can be challenged in any
Court at any time. It may be remarked here that the
pleadings and the evidence are to be read in its entirety and
there cannot be cherry picking of the sentences for the
purposes of convenience. It is clear from the Schedule to the
plaint that the Respondent was referring only to the suit
property, hence this argument of the Appellants is not
tenable.
24.
In view of the discussions hereinabove, the
decision of the learned trial Court save to the extent
discussed
with
interference.
regard
to
Issue
No.
1,
warrants
no
R.F.A. No. 13 of 2017
Rajendra Prasad Mangla & Anr. vs. Govind Agarwal
25.
Appeal dismissed.
26.
Consequently the Appellants shall vacate the suit
premises within three months from today i.e. by 10.09.2019
and hand over vacant possession to the Respondent. The
Appellants shall pay the arrears in rent from January 2010 till
the time they vacate the suit premises. No interest is ordered
on the defaulted rent amount.
27.
Copy of the Judgment be sent to the learned trial
Court for information.
28.
No order as to costs.
29.
Records of the learned trial Court be remitted
forthwith.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
08.06.2019
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ml
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review