Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
(1)
912-wp-11431-2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO.11431 OF 2019
1. Rajendra Hanmantrao Helchal
2. Shreya Ravindra Helchal
3. Shweta Shivdatt Helchal
...PETITIONERS
VERSUS
1. The State of Maharashtra
Through its Secretary,
tribal Department, Mantralaya
Mumbai-32.
2. The Scheduled Tribe Certificate
Scrutiny Committee, Aurangabad,
Through its Deputy Director. (R).
3. The Executive Engineer,
Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution
Company Ltd. Vidyut Bhavan, Near Bustand,
Hingoli, Tq. & Dist. Hingoli.
...RESPONDENTS
Mr. Pratap V. Jadhavar, Advocate for Petitioners.
Mr. P. S. Patil, AGP for Respondent Nos. 1 and 2-State.
Mr. A. R. Salve, Advocate for Respondent No.3.
CORAM
: KISHORE C. SANT &
JITENDRA JAIN, JJ.
RESERVED ON
: 28th AUGUST 2026.
PRONOUNCED ON
: 27th OCTOBER 2026.
ORDER :- [PER:- KISHORE C. SANT, J.]
(2)
1]
912-wp-11431-2019
Heard Mr. Jadhavar, learned Counsel for the Petitioners, Mr.
Patil, learned AGP for Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 and Mr. Salve, learned
Counsel for the Respondent No.3. At the joint request of the parties, the
petition is taken up for final disposal at the stage of admission.
2]
By way of this Writ Petition, the Petitioners have challenged
a Judgment and Order dated 16/08/2019 passed by Respondent
No.2/the Scheduled Tribe Certificate Scrutiny Committee, Aurangabad
(hereinafter referred to as “Committee”), thereby invalidating a tribe
claim of the petitioners as belonging to “Mannervarlu” a Scheduled
Tribe.
3]
All the petitioners are related to each other. The petitioner
No.1 is real uncle of Petitioner Nos. 2 and 3. Petitioner Nos. 2 and 3
happen to be the cousin sisters. The father of petitioner No.2 and 3 are
real brothers of petitioner No.1.
4]
A challenge is raised to a common judgment and order
wherein the Committee has refused to grant validity certificate in favour
of these petitioners. The petitioner Nos.2 and 3 happen to be a students.
Their proposals are forwarded by their respective colleges. The
(3)
912-wp-11431-2019
petitioner No.1 is in service with Respondent No.3 and his claim was
forwarded by Respondent No.3.
5]
The petitioners claim to be belonging to the Scheduled Tribe
(Mannervarlu). The petitioner No.1 has secured service as belonging to
Scheduled Tribe, whereas petitioner No.2 and 3 are desirous of
prosecuting their professional careers and seek admission to professional
courses as belonging to Scheduled Tribe (Mannervarlu).
6]
The petitioners, in support of their claim, submitted 44
documents. So far as school record is concerned, there are six
documents provided from the school records. The Scrutiny Committee
after considering all the documents held that the petitioners failed to
prove their tribe status.
7]
vehemently
Mr. Jadhavar, the learned Counsel for the petitioners,
argued
the
petition.
He
submitted
that
the
Respondent/Committee has utterly failed to consider legitimate claims
of the petitioners. The Committee did not apply its mind properly to the
record. Though there are validity certificates granted to near relatives of
the petitioners, those are not considered. The petitioners produced
(4)
documents
even
prior
to
independence
912-wp-11431-2019
of
one
Narayanswami
Hanmantrao Helchal, the great-grand-father of petitioner Nos.2 and 3
and grand-father of petitioner No.1, still that is not considered. The
revenue record in the name of forefathers is not considered. So far as
record of Ravindra Helchal, father of petitioner No.2 is concerned, it
shows that he belongs to Mannervarlu. However, still that was not
considered. Even the record of the petitioners is not considered, wherein
their caste is recorded as Mannervarlu. He submits that the Vigilance
Cell report has not disputed the relationship of the petitioners with the
validity holders. The contra entries are wrongly relied upon by the
Committee. He thus prays for allowing the writ petition.
8]
In support of his submissions, learned Counsel for the
petitioners relied upon the following judgments:(i)
(ii)
9]
Rajesh Jagdishrao Gode Vs. State of Maharashtra and
Ors.1;
Maharashtra Adiwasi Thakur Jamat Swarakshan Samiti
Vs. State of Maharashtra and Ors.2.
Mr. Patil, learned AGP, on the other hand, vehemently
opposed the petition. He submitted that the learned Members of the
Committee have considered all the material produced on record. It is
1 2006 (4) All MR 131
2 (2023) 16 SCC 415
(5)
912-wp-11431-2019
only on going through the record, the affinity test and the report of the
Vigilance Cell. The Committee recorded that the petitioners have not
proved their tribe status. He submits that there are contra entries in the
name of Ravindra, father of petitioner No.2, is shown to be “Phulmali” in
the school record, where he had taken an admission on 01/07/1978. So
far as revenue record is concerned, it is rightly recorded that no such
original record is found for verification. The service book where the tribe
of father of petitioner No.1 is shown as Mannervarlu is issued in 2003,
and therefore, it cannot be said to be a a document that can be relied
upon. The sale-deed which is sought to be relied upon is in Urdu
language. However, the original sale-deed is not on record and there are
no corresponding entries found in the record. The sale deed purported
to be of 1946 is not mentioned in any other record. He prays for
rejection of the petition.
10]
This Court has heard the parties. This Court has gone
through the petition papers and also perused the files of the petitioners
and the order passed by the Committee. This Court has verified the
material documents which were produced by the petitioners and
respondent before this Court.
(6)
11]
912-wp-11431-2019
The question before this Court is as to whether the
petitioners have proved their tribe status before the Committee by giving
cogent and reliable evidence. Secondly, as to whether the committee has
rightly refused to grant validity to the petitioners.
12]
The Committee in its judgment considered 44 documents.
Document Nos. 1 to 10 are in respect of petitioners and their relatives
are discarded, for the reason that those are of recent origin. All other
entries are after the date of notification. There is a document i.e. bond
executed by Narayanswami, where the caste is shown to be
Mannervarlu. The said Narayanswami happens to be grandfather of
Petitioner No.1 and great-grand-father of Petitioner Nos. 2 and 3.
13]
So far as Hanmantrao Helchal is concerned, the service book
is of 2003 and, therefore, it is not considered. So far as school record of
Ravindra is concerned, it is considered that in the entry of Ravindra from
Zilla Parishad Bahuvidh Prashala Hingoli, where he took admission on
01/07/1978, his caste is shown as Hindu Phulmali. The entry in the
name of Pratibha, real sister of Rajendra and paternal aunt of petitioner
Nos. 2 and 3, is shown only as Hindu in the school record of Manik
Smarak Aarya Vidyalaya, Hingoli. The entry in the name of Vijayendra
(7)
912-wp-11431-2019
Helchal is shown to be only as Munnarwar in the school record of Manik
Smarak Aarya Vidyalaya, Hingoli, however, the said entry is of 1977.
Another entry of a cousin uncle namely, Nitin Helchal is shown as
Munnurwar from the school record of Manik Smarak Aarya Vidyalaya,
Hingoli; however, the said entry is of 05/06/1987. It is thus recorded
that the entries of father, uncle etc., from the year 1978 and 1987 are
shown to be Phulmali or Munnurwar. The Committee, therefore,
considered the affinity test. It is observed that even in affinity test, the
petitioners failed to show affinity with their tribe. Considering this basic
record, even the Committee found that the petitioners have failed to
prove their tribe status.
14]
While coming to this conclusion, the Committee considered
the marriage invitation card of the relatives, blood relatives of the
petitioners and found that it is not as per tribal culture. So far as bond is
concerned, as stated earlier, it is considered that there is no entry found
corresponding with the said document in any Government department.
About the entry also, the Committee has rightly considered this aspect as
well. The Committee considered the judgments in the cases of (i) Raju
Ramsing Vasave vs. Mahesh Deorao Bhivapurkar & Ors. 3 (ii) Narayan D.
3 (2008) 9 SCC 54
(8)
912-wp-11431-2019
Jambhule Vs. Scheduled Tribe Scrutiny Committee and Ors .4 (iii) Jyoti
Sheshrao Mupade Vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors. 5 (iv) Devendra
Gurunath Khadgikar Vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors.6 and
Rajeshwar Baburao Bone Vs. State of Maharashtra7.
15]
The respondent/Committee further considered that the
original place of residence of the family was shown to be Tirupatinagar,
Hingoli, Tal. & Dist. Hingoli. In the said village, no persons from
Mannervarlu
community
are
found.
The
respondent/Committee
considered the language of the petitioners as well and found that it does
not match with the language of Mannervarlu community.
16]
Coming to the record, this Court has considered the original
record from the file of the petitioners and considered the genealogy. No
relation with the paternal aunt namely Pratibha is seen for the relation
who is shown to be Hindu in the school record. Even the father Ravindra
is shown as Phulmali in the school record. There is no dispute about the
same. There is also no explanation as to why while admitting Ravindra
and Pratibha to the school, their caste is shown as Phulmali and Hindu.
PIL/11/2016 (Nagpur) dated 15/04/2016
WP/1954/2009 (Aurangabad) dated 22/08/2012
WP/3739/2009 (Bombay) dated 12/02/2012
AIR 2015 SC 3024
(9)
17]
912-wp-11431-2019
This Court has seen the certified copy of the school leaving
certificate of Ravindra, which shows the caste as Hindu Phulmali. Even
in the general register of the school, the caste of Ravindra is shown to be
Phulmali. The certified copy of school leaving certificate of petitioner
No.1 is also seen, which is certified by the Manik Smarak Aarya
Vidyalaya (Primary School), Hingoli. In caste column, his caste is shown
only as Hindu. The school leaving certificate issued by Headmaster of
the Manik Smarak Aarya Vidyalaya (Secondary School) Hingoli, also
records the caste of Rajendra Helchal only as Hindu. Though a copy of
tribe certificate issued by Akhil Maharashtra Mannervarlu Organization
is seen in the record; however, it is rightly considered by the Committee
that the said organization is not an authority to issue such certificate.
The said certificate issued by such organization is of consequence. Only
it is seen that by taking advantage of the similarity between the caste of
petitioners as Munnurwar/Mannerwar, they claim themselves to
belonging to a Scheduled Tribe Mannervarlu.
18]
This Court has also seen the file of one Shivanand
Rameshchandra Kodgirkar, who happens to be cousin of the petitioner
No.1. In his file, it is stated that though his surname was Helchal after
( 10 )
912-wp-11431-2019
shifting from their original place to other place, he adopted his surname
as Kodgirkar. There is validity granted in favour of Shivanand Kodgirkar
as belonging to Mannervarlu. Petitioners tried to take benefit of the said
validity. It is further seen that though Shivanand Kodgirkar is granted
validity on its own merit, in the present case, in view of specific contra
entries about the father, paternal aunt of the petitioners, the validity
granted in favour of Shivanand Kodgirkar cannot be used to grant
validity in favour of the petitioners.
19]
So far as judgment in the case of Rajesh Gode (supra) is
concerned, the Hon’ble Apex Court had considered that the Committee
can rely even upon an unregistered document. In that case, in the birth
register, the caste of the petitioner’s brother and father was shown as
Hindu Mahadeo Koli, which was supported by two old documents, one
was private agreement and second was Government grant in the name
of ancestor of the petitioner as belonging to Koli Mahadeo. Grand-father
and father as shown as Mahadeo Koli and in that view, the documents
were relied though the documents were not registered. In that case,
though the document was unregistered, corresponding record was
available showing document was genuine. In the present case, there is
( 11 )
912-wp-11431-2019
no corresponding record found of the alleged bond of the year 1948. A
second major factor is that the record of the father of the petitioner No.2
itself is shows his caste as Phulmali in the school record. Same is the
case with paternal aunt namely, Pratibha who is shown as Hindu.
In the case of Maharashtra Adiwasi Thakur Jamat (supra),
20]
the Hon’ble Apex Court has observed in paragraph No. 40 as under:
“40.
Thus, to conclude, we hold that:
40.1 Only when the Scrutiny Committee after holding an enquiry is
not satisfied with the material produced by the applicant, the case can
be referred to Vigilance Cell. While referring the case to Vigilance Cell,
the Scrutiny Committee must record brief reasons for coming to the
conclusion that it is not satisfied with the material produced by the
applicant. Only after a case is referred to the Vigilance Cell for making
enquiry, an occasion for the conduct of affinity test will arise.
40.2 For the reasons which we have recorded, affinity test cannot be
conclusive either way. When an affinity test is conducted by the
Vigilance Cell, the result of the test along with all other material on
record having probative value will have to be taken into consideration
by the Scrutiny Committee for deciding the caste validity claim; and
40.3 In short, affinity test is not a litmus test to decide a caste claim
and is not an essential part in the process of the determination of
correctness of a caste or tribe claim in every case.”
21]
It is for the Committee to decide whether vigilance cell
enquiry is necessary or not. In the present case, clearly a case is made
out that there was no sufficient material available in favour of
petitioners. A vigilance cell report was called.
( 12 )
22]
912-wp-11431-2019
Considering mainly that there are contra entries in respect of
near relatives of the petitioners, which are not explained and disputed,
this Court does not seen any fault with the reasoning of the committee
and Committee has rightly delivered the judgment. The judgment relied
upon by the petitioners also has no application to the facts of this case.
In the case of Rajesh Gode (supra) it was only on the fact of that case
that unregistered documents were considered. It cannot be said to be a
general rule. In the present case, further, the judgment is not applicable
for want of more than one reason. In the present case, there are no
corresponding entries found and produced by the petitioners.
23]
Considering all above, this Court does not find any merit in
the writ petition. The writ petition stands dismissed.
[JITENDRA JAIN, J.]
D.A.ETHAPE
[KISHORE C. SANT, J.]
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review