The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. In the light of the discussions made earlier, the contentions made by the learned counsel for the appellants are liable to be rejected. Finding no substantial question of law arising for consideration, the second appeal stands dismissed by affirming the judgement and decree dated 30.08.2017 in AS.No.62 of 2009 passed by the I Additional Subordinate Judge, Villupuram reversing the Page8 of 10 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis SA No. 234 of 2026 judgement and decree dated 28.01.2009 in OS.No.92 of 2006 passed by the Principal District Munsif, Tirukovilur. Consequently, the connected miscellaneous petition is closed. No costs. 23-03-2026 Index: Yes/No Speaking/Non-speaking order nr To
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SA No. 234 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 23-03-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE S. SOUNTHAR
SA No. 234 of 2026 and
CMP.No.7478 of 2026
1. Rajammal
2. Saradhambal
3. Rani
4. Samy Pillai
Krishnan (Died)
5. Vijiammal,
6. Murugan
7. Shakila
Devendran (Died)
8. D.Suguna
9. Jothi
10.Abinaya
11.D. Arunkumar
(cause title accepted vide C/o
dated 08.06.2023 made in
CMP.No.11597/2023 in
SA.Sr.No.99065 of 2017)
( Appellants 8 to 11 are impleaded as
LR’s of deceased Devendran)
..Appellant(s)
Vs
Indirani Ammal (Died)
1. Nagalakshmi Ammal
2. Mallika
3. Kumar (died)
4. Ravi
5. Uma
6. Arul Jothi
7. Jayanthi
(R3 died, R6 & R7 are brought on record
as LR’s of deceased R3 vide c/o
dated 19.12.2025 made in CMP.No.4791/2024
in SA.Sr.No.99065/2017)
..Respondent(s)
__________
Page1 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 234 of 2026
Prayer :Second appeal is filed under Section 100 of Code of Civil Procedure
code, praying to reverse the Judgement and Decree dated 30.08.2017 passed in
AS.No.62 of 2009 by the learned First Additional Subordinate Judge,
Villupuram reversing the Judgement and Decree dated 28.01.2009 passed by the
learned Principal District Munsif,Tirukovilur in OS No.92 of 2006.
For Appellant(s):
M/s.T.K.Saravanan
JUDGMENT
The unsuccessful defendants are the appellants. The respondents/
plaintiffs filed a suit seeking partition of their 1/4th share each. The suit was
dismissed by the trial court. The appeal filed by the respondents/plaintiffs was
allowed. Aggrieved by the same. The appellants/defendants have come before
this court by way of second appeal.
2. According to the respondents/plaintiffs, the suit property along with
the property on the western side was originally belonged to one Thasthakeer
Sahib. He sold the said property in favour of Kulliammal and Ammamuthu
Ammal under registered sale deed dated 10.04.1912. There was a partition
between Kulliammal and Ammamuthu Ammal and the suit property was
allotted to the share of Kulliammal. The said Kulliammal died leaving behind
her only son Ponnakonar. The said Ponnakonar died leaving behind three sons
and two daughters namely Chinnasamy, Ammachiammal, Indirani Ammal,
Krishnan and Kannan. The above said Kannan died as a bachelor and hence, his
1/5th share devolved upon his siblings namely the above mentioned four
__________
Page2 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 234 of 2026
persons. Thus, the above mentioned four children of Ponnakonar entitled to
1/4th share each in the suit property. The daughter of Ponnakonar namely
Indirani Ammal is the 1st plaintiff. The another daughter of Ponnakonar namely
Ammachi ammal executed a Will bequeathing her 1/4th share in favour of her
granddaughter namely 2nd plaintiff. Ponnakonar's son Chinnasamy died and his
legal representatives are defendants 1 to 4. The other son of Ponnakonar has
been arrayed as 5th defendant. Thus, according to the plaintiffs, they are entitled
to 1/4th share each. The defendants 1 to 4 collectively entitled to 1/4th share
and the 5th defendant also entitled to 1/4th share. It is also stated by the plaintiffs
that the 5th defendant filed a suit for partition in OS.No.406 of 1995 against
Chinnasamy claiming ½ share in the suit property. The plaintiffs were not added
as a party in the said suit and a collusive decree was obtained as if the plaintiff
therein was entitled to ½ share. Since the plaintiffs were not party to the said
decree, the same was not binding on the plaintiffs. It was also stated that during
the pendency of the execution proceedings in the partition suit referred above,
the 2nd plaintiff’s predecessor-in-interest namely Ammachiammal filed a suit in
O.S.No.137 of 1997 seeking declaration and injunction. She also sought for
prayer that decree in OS.No.406 of 1995 should not be executed. The said suit
was dismissed. However, it was found by the court that plaintiff therein namely
Ammachiammal, 1st plaintiff, 5th defendant and Chinnasamy konar are entitled
to 1/4th share each in the suit property. The appeal filed by Ammachiammal
was also dismissed. It is further stated that the 2 nd plaintiff had constructed a
__________
Page3 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 234 of 2026
house in the suit property and she has been residing thereon. In spite of the
demand for partition, the defendants failed to respond and hence, the plaintiffs
were constrained to file a suit seeking partition of their 1/4th share each.
3. The defendants filed a written statement and resisted the suit on the
ground that the plaintiffs never enjoyed the suit property and therefore, they
were not entitled to claim partition. The Will relied on by the 2 nd plaintiff was
also denied. It was also claimed that since the plaintiffs had no right over the
suit property, they were not added as parties in OS.No.406 of 1995. The
averments in the plaint regarding findings in OS.No.137 of 1997 filed by
Ammachiammal was also denied. The further allegation that the second plaintiff
had been residing in the suit property was also denied. On these pleadings, the
defendants sought for dismissal of the suit.
4. Before the trial court, the 2nd plaintiff was examined as PW1. The
attestors to the Will relied on by her were examined as PW2 and PW3. The 2 nd
plaintiff's mother and daughter of Ammachiammal was examined as PW4. On
behalf of the plaintiffs, 38 documents were marked as Ex.A1 to Ex.A38. The 5 th
defendant was examined as DW1 and one Rajikonar was examined as DW2. On
behalf of the defendants, 14 documents were marked as Ex.B1 to Ex.B14.
5. The trial court, on appreciation of oral and documentary evidence
available on record, came to the conclusion that the prayer for partition was
barred by limitation as Ponnakonar died in the year 1956 itself. The trial court
also found that 1st plaintiff had not established her possession over the suit
__________
Page4 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 234 of 2026
property. It was also found that the Will relied on by the 2 nd plaintiff was not
proved and as a necessary consequence, dismissed the suit. Aggrieved by the
same, the plaintiffs preferred an appeal in AS.No.62 of 2009 on the file of
Additional Sub Court, Villupuram. The first appellate court, on appreciation of
evidence of attestors and PW4, upheld the validity of the Will relied on by the
second plaintiff. The first appellate court also found that there was no evidence
available on record to suggest that Ponnakonar died prior to coming into force
of the Hindu Succession Act and consequently, held that the plaintiffs were
entitled to decree as prayed for. Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree
passed by the first appellate court, the defendants have come before this court.
6. The learned counsel for the appellants vehemently contended that the
suit filed by Ammachiammal, the predecessor-in-interest of the 2 nd plaintiff, in
OS.No. 137 of 1997 seeking declaration of title and injunction was dismissed
and in such circumstances, the present suit filed by the plaintiffs is barred by
res-judicata. The learned counsel also submitted that having raised a plea that
the entire suit property was orally gifted in favour of Ammachiammal, the
present suit for partition is not maintainable. He also submitted that the
plaintiffs failed to prove joint possession of the suit property and therefore, the
present suit is barred by limitation for their failure to demand partition for more
than statutory period.
__________
Page5 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 234 of 2026
7. It is seen from the records that 2nd plaintiff’s predecessor-in- interest
namely Ammachiammal filed a suit in OS.No.137 of 1997 seeking declaration
of title and injunction. Though she claimed right over the entire suit property
under the settlement allegedly executed by her father Ponnakonar, the said suit
was dismissed as she failed to establish gift. However, a perusal of the judgment
passed in OS.No.137 of 1997, which has been marked as Exhibit A9, would
establish that while dismissing the suit, the court found that suit property was
inherited by Ponnakonar from her mother and he died intestate. Therefore, there
was a clear finding that all the children of Ponnakonar were entitled to share in
the said property. The Court also found that OS.No.406 of 1995 was fought
between the sons of Ponnakonar and the plaintiffs have not been made as parties
and therefore, the said decision would not affect the rights of the present
plaintiffs.
8. The plea of adverse possession raised by defendants 1 and 2 therein,
namely Chinnasamy Konar (predecessor-in-interest of present defendants 1 to
4) and 5th defendant herein namely Krishnan, was negatived by the trial court
with a specific finding. Ultimately, the above said suit was dismissed with
liberty to the plaintiffs to file suit for partition. In the light of the findings
rendered in OS.No.137 of 1997 and by virtue of the liberty granted by the court
in the said suit, the decision in OS.No.137 of 1997 will not bar the present suit
and the contention raised by the learned counsel for the appellants in this regard
__________
Page6 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 234 of 2026
is not acceptable to this court.
9. The learned counsel for the appellants also attempted to argue that
Ponnakonar died prior to coming into force of the Hindu Succession Act.
Therefore, his daughters were not entitled to share in the estate of deceased
Ponnakonar. It is pertinent to mention that appellants/defendants have not raised
any specific plea that Ponnakonar died prior to coming into force of the Hindu
Succession Act and hence, his daughters were not entitled to share in his estate.
In fact, the trial court found that Ponnakonar died prior to 26.07.1956. The
Hindu Succession Act came into force on 17.06.1956. However, there is no
evidence available on record to suggest that Ponnakonar died prior to coming
into force of the Hindu Succession Act. In fact, there is a finding by the court in
the earlier suit in OS.No.137 of 1997 that Ponnakonar died intestate and all of
his heirs are entitled to share. In the absence of specific plea that Ponnakonar
died prior to coming into force of the Hindu Succession Act and also any
evidence, the submission made by the learned counsel for the appellants cannot
be countenanced. Even assuming there is an evidence, the same cannot be
considered in the absence of specific plea in the written statement.
10. The first appellate court referred to the evidence of DW2 wherein he
categorically admitted that there was an ancestral house in the suit property and
the 2nd plaintiff’s predecessor-in-interest namely Ammachiammal was residing
thereon. He also admitted that as on today, there is a tiled house in the suit
__________
Page7 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 234 of 2026
property and the 2nd plaintiff Nagalakshmi has been residing thereon for the past
20 years. In such circumstances, the plea raised by the defendants as if the
plaintiffs were ousted from the suit property is not acceptable. Further, the plea
of ouster raised by the defendants in the earlier suit in OS.No. 137 of 1997 was
also negatived. In such circumstances, the submission made by the learned
counsel for the appellants based on the plea of ouster is also not appealable to
this Court.
11. The first appellate court carefully considered the evidence of attestors
to the Will relied on by the 2 nd plaintiff, who were examined as PW2 and PW3
and came to the conclusion that execution of the Will was duly proved. It also
pointed out that Ammachiammal executed a Will, Ex.A2 in favour of 2nd
plaintiff on 15.10.1989. The said Ammachiammal’s only heir namely her
daughter was examined as PW4. She clearly admitted that Ammachiammal
executed a Will in favour of 2nd plaintiff. Taking into consideration all these
facts, the first appellate court gave a factual finding that the Will relied on by
the 2nd plaintiff was duly proved and the said finding requires no interference in
the absence of any perversity.
12. In the light of the discussions made earlier, the contentions made by
the learned counsel for the appellants are liable to be rejected. Finding no
substantial question of law arising for consideration, the second appeal stands
dismissed by affirming the judgement and decree dated 30.08.2017 in AS.No.62
of 2009 passed by the I Additional Subordinate Judge, Villupuram reversing the
__________
Page8 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 234 of 2026
judgement and decree dated 28.01.2009 in OS.No.92 of 2006 passed by the
Principal
District
Munsif,
Tirukovilur.
Consequently,
the
connected
miscellaneous petition is closed. No costs.
23-03-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
nr
To
1. The I Additional Subordinate Judge, Villupuram
2. The Principal District Munsif, Tirukovilur
__________
Page9 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 234 of 2026
S.SOUNTHAR, J.
nr
SA No. 234 of 2026 and
CMP.No.7478 of 2026
23-03-2026
__________
Page10 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review