Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
SWP No. 1910/2015
IA No. 1/2015
Reserved on: 04.08.2026
Pronounced on:11.08.2026
Uploaded on:11.08.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
Raj Singh, age 36 years S/o Shri Shadi Lal
R/o Village Neera Tehsil & District Ramban
…..Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. M P Sharma, Advocate
1. Commissioner-Cum-Secretary to Government,
Education Department, Civil Secretariat, Srinagar.
2. Director School Education, Jammu.
3. Chief Education Officer, Ramban.
4. Zonal Education Officer, Ramban.
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Anishwar Chatterji Koul, GA
Mr. Adarsh Bhagat, GA
Coram:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE WASIM SADIQ NARGAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
PRAYER
1.
The petitioner through the medium of instant petition has sought the
following reliefs:
a) To set aside or quash Advertisement notice vide its
No:DIP/J-2070 dated 05.06. 2015 of Chief Education
Officer (District Chairman, SSA) Ramban, so far as it
pertains to a post falling in S.No:3 in aforestated
advertisement.
b) To direct or command respondents for appointment of
petitioner as RET in terms of panel prepared vide order No.
CEOR/10/28130-33 dated 04.12.2010.
c) To prohibit respondents from making selection in terms of
advertisement dated 05.06.2015.
SWP No. 1910/2015
BRIEF FACTS
2.
The brief facts leading to the filing of the present petition are that, pursuant
to Government Order No. 597-Edu of 2003 and communication issued by
the State Project Director, Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA), Srinagar, bearing
No. Edu/SPD/SSA/27829-55 dated 04.08.2010, the respondents invited
applications in the prescribed format from permanent residents of the
erstwhile State of Jammu and Kashmir for engagement as Rehbar-eTaleem (ReT) Teachers under the Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA). As per
the applicable policy, such engagements were to be made on village basis
in rural areas and on ward basis in urban areas. It is further submitted that,
in furtherance of the aforesaid Government Order and communication, the
Office of the Chief Education Officer, Ramban, issued Advertisement
Notice No. DIP/J-8055 dated 07.12.2010, inviting applications for
engagement of ReT Teachers against the posts sanctioned for newly
opened Primary Schools under the SSA Scheme. The advertisement, inter
alia, included vacancies pertaining to Education Zone Ramban, including
those for newly established Primary Schools in the respective
villages/wards falling within the said Zone.
3.
It is the specific case of the petitioner that, being fully eligible in all
respects, including age, educational qualifications, experience, and other
prescribed criteria, he submitted his application in the prescribed format,
along with all requisite documents, well within the stipulated time before
the office of the respondents for his engagement as a Rehbar-e-Taleem
SWP No. 1910/2015
(ReT) Teacher against the post notified for the newly opened Primary
School under the Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA) in Village Neera,
Education Zone Ramban. It is further submitted that, after scrutiny of the
applications, the petitioner, along with the other eligible candidates, was
called for interview. In compliance with the interview call letter, the
petitioner appeared before the Interview Committee, where his original
documents relating to educational qualifications, experience, age, and
proof of residence were duly verified by the respondents. Thereafter, in
accordance with the instructions issued by the Zonal Education Officer,
Ramban, a tentative merit panel was displayed in the concerned village for
inviting objections from 25.12.2010 to 31.12.2010. Upon examining the
said tentative panel, the petitioner found his name reflected at Serial No. 5
and was fully satisfied with his placement therein. However, the candidates
figuring at Serial Nos. 6 and 13 submitted objections against the tentative
panel in terms of Government Order No. 1639-Edu of 2003 dated
12.11.2003, Government Order No. 288-Edu of 2009 dated 08.04.2009,
and communication No. DSEJ/RET/2430 dated 21.01.2011 issued by the
Director, School Education, Jammu, primarily disputing the applicability
and implementation of Government Order No. 288-Edu of 2009 dated
08.04.2009 in the preparation of the merit panel.
4.
It is the further case of the petitioner that, upon the filing of objections by
the candidates figuring at Serial Nos. 6 and 13 against the tentative merit
panel prepared by the Zonal Education Officer, Ramban, the matter was
SWP No. 1910/2015
referred through the proper channel to the Director, School Education,
Jammu for appropriate consideration. Since no effective decision was
taken by the respondents, the petitioner was constrained to invoke the writ
jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court by filing a writ petition challenging the
action of the respondents. In the said writ petition, the candidates figuring
at Serial Nos. 1 and 2 of the final select panel were also impleaded as
private respondents. It is submitted that this Court was pleased to issue
notice to the respondents and, in the accompanying application for interim
relief, restrained the respondents from issuing appointment orders in
favour of the private respondents. Pursuant thereto, the official respondents
entered appearance and filed their objections before this Hon'ble Court.
Thereafter, upon reconsideration of the matter, the official respondents
accepted the petitioner's contention and prepared the final select panel,
wherein the candidates who had figured at Serial Nos. 6 and 13 in the
tentative merit panel were placed at Serial Nos. 1 and 2, respectively, and
were selected for engagement as Rehbar-e-Taleem (ReT) Teachers.
Consequently, the selected candidates were directed to obtain their
appointment orders and join their respective places of posting. It is further
submitted that the candidate who had figured at Serial No. 13 in the
tentative merit panel and was placed at Serial No. 2 in the final select panel
obtained his appointment order and joined his assigned school. However,
the candidate who had figured at Serial No. 6 in the tentative merit panel
and was placed at Serial No. 1 in the final select panel neither obtained the
SWP No. 1910/2015
appointment order nor joined against the post for which he had been
selected.
5.
It is the specific case of the petitioner that, upon learning that the candidate
placed at Serial No. 1 in the final select panel had neither accepted the
appointment nor joined against the post of Rehbar-e-Taleem (ReT)
Teacher in the newly opened Primary School, Mota, Village Neera,
Education Zone, Ramban, the petitioner immediately submitted a detailed
representation before the respondents setting out the true and correct
factual position. In the said representation, the petitioner specifically
pointed out that although his name figured at Serial No. 5 in the tentative
merit panel, the candidates placed at Serial Nos. 1 to 4 were not willing or
eligible to accept appointment in the newly opened Primary School, Mota,
Village Neera, Education Zone, Ramban. It was further brought to the
notice of the respondents that the candidate who had originally figured at
Serial No. 6 in the tentative merit panel and was subsequently placed at
Serial No. 1 in the final select panel had also failed to accept the
appointment and did not join the said school, as he had already been
selected and appointed as a permanent teacher elsewhere. The petitioner
further submitted that, in the aforesaid circumstances, he was the only
eligible and willing candidate available for engagement against the said
post and, therefore, was entitled to be considered for appointment as a
Rehbar-e-Taleem (ReT) Teacher in the newly opened Primary School,
Mota, Village Neera, Education Zone, Ramban. However, instead of
SWP No. 1910/2015
considering the petitioner's representation and his legitimate claim in
accordance with law, the respondents issued the impugned advertisement
seeking to fill the very same post afresh. The issuance of the impugned
advertisement is ex facie arbitrary, illegal, unconstitutional, and violative
of the petitioner's vested and accrued rights. The action of the respondents
is wholly contrary to the applicable Government Orders and the settled
principles governing the selection and engagement of Rehbar-e-Taleem
Teachers. Accordingly, the impugned advertisement, insofar as it pertains
to the post in question, is liable to be quashed.
6.
It is further submitted that the respondents were legally bound to undertake
the process of selection strictly in accordance with Government Order No.
1639-Edu of 2003 dated 12.11.2003, read with Government Order No.
288-Edu of 2009 dated 08.04.2009, and Communication/Order No.
DSEJ/RET/2430 dated 21.01.2011 issued by the Director, School
Education, Jammu. However, the respondents initially failed to adhere to
the aforesaid Government Orders while preparing the merit and select
panels, compelling the aggrieved candidates to challenge the same before
this Hon'ble Court. Consequently, the selection process was revisited and
the claims of the aggrieved candidates were duly considered in accordance
with the applicable Government Orders. It is further submitted that, during
the pendency of the aforesaid proceedings, one of the selected candidates,
namely Vipan Kumar, was appointed as a permanent teacher in another
school and, therefore, neither accepted the appointment nor joined as a
SWP No. 1910/2015
Rehbar-e-Taleem (ReT) Teacher in the newly opened Primary School,
Mota, Village Neera, Education Zone, Ramban. As a consequence, the
vacancy remained unfilled and, in accordance with the applicable policy
and the settled principles governing the selection process, the petitioner's
claim, being the next eligible and willing candidate in the merit list,
became liable to be considered for engagement against the said post.
Despite repeated representations submitted by the petitioner and
notwithstanding his legitimate claim arising out of the non-joining of the
selected candidate, the respondents failed to consider his case in
accordance with law. Instead, they issued the impugned advertisement
proposing to fill the very same post afresh, without first considering the
petitioner's accrued right to be considered for engagement. The action of
the respondents is arbitrary, illegal, unreasonable, and violative of the
aforesaid Government Orders as well as Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India. It is respectfully submitted that the representations
submitted by the petitioner have remained pending and undecided till date.
In these circumstances, the petitioner has been left with no efficacious or
alternative statutory remedy except to invoke the extraordinary writ
jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India. Hence, the present writ petition.
7.
Record further reveals that this Court vide order dated 15.10.2015 while
entertaining the instant matter, by way of ad-interim direction, has passed
the following direction:
SWP No. 1910/2015
“Meanwhile, as ad interim, subject to objections and till
next date before the Bench, engagement process pursuant to
Notification dated 05.06.2015 vis- a- vis aforementioned
post of Rehbar-e-Taleem shall stay.”
LEGAL ANALYSIS
8.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and perused the record. Also heard
Mr. Anishwar Chatterji Koul as well as Mr. Adarsh Bhagat, learned
Government Advocates.
9.
During pendency of the aforesaid writ petition, the Hon’ble Apex Court in
case titled “Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir & Ors vs Saba
Wani” has passed a judgment in which the Hon’ble Apex Court while
dealing with the petition preferred by the Union Territory of J&K & Ors.,
has been pleased to issue the following directions”:
a) The Closure Order of ReT Scheme dated 16.11.2018 for
cancellation/withdrawal shall not retrospectively impair the right of
the candidates found placed in the select panel. In view of the
discussion made hereinabove, the candidates placed in respective
select panels shall be issued engagement/appointment orders as per
their position in the select panel having regard to the available
vacancies.
b) The State shall issue the formal engagement orders to the candidates
of select panel within a period of eight weeks in terms of the direction
(a) above.
c) Candidates appointed as per directions (a) and (b) from the select
panel under the ReT Scheme are directed to acquire minimum
qualification prescribed under NCTE Regulations and Notifications,
including to qualify the TET, within 3 years and 3 attempts from date
of their engagement/appointment. In this regard, the State is directed
to organize the TET annually. After successfully acquiring the
minimum qualification and passing TET within prescribed time limit,
the services of such appointees shall be. accordingly, regularized on
completion of two years of service thereafter.
d) The direction (c) above shall be applicable to the other similarly
situated candidates who have already been appointed from the select
SWP No. 1910/2015
panels under the ReT Scheme after 23.08.2010 i.e.. the date of NCTE
notification prescribing minimum qualifications and prior to the
issuance of Closure Order, and do not possess minimum qualification
including TET as per the notification of NCTE. However, those
appointees shall acquire prescribed qualification within the time as
specified in direction (c).
e) It is obligatory upon this Court to direct that once the
candidates/appointees under the ReT Scheme have acquired the
prescribed qualifications and qualified the TET as indicated above,
the seniority of all such candidates/appointees shall be redrawn and
determined by the competent authority of the State, maintaining their
respective positions in the select panels uninfluenced by the date of
appointment, joining or regularization. The inter se seniority shall
also be determined accordingly.
f) It is further directed that if the candidates/appointees including those
already appointed and regularized who do not acquire/possess the
requisite qualifications in terms of the NCTE notifications and fail to
qualify the TET within the period prescribed hereinabove, the State is
at liberty to dispense with their services as the mandate of Article 21A of the Constitution of India cannot be left at altar even while
rendering complete justice invoking Article 142 of the Constitution of
India. It is further clarified that those candidates/appointees would
not have any claim with to seniority ог regularization as directed
respect hereinabove.
g) The directions issued hereinabove are in rem and shall apply mutatis
mutandis to the candidates already appointed pursuant to 74
advertisements that are subject matter of present proceedings, though
they are not party to the present appeals. In view thereof, this
judgment shall be widely publicized, and all the candidates/appointees
shall be duly informed of these directions so that they can take
recourse for acquiring the minimum qualification as per NCTE
Regulations and Notifications, if they have not already acquired the
same.
h) The directions contained in clauses (a) to (g) hereinabove shall apply
to all the candidates who are litigating in any Court and such cases
have been filed prior to the date of this judgment. It is further clarified
that candidates who have not already filed cases in any Court shall
neither acquire any fresh cause of action by virtue of these directions
nor be entitled to seek any further directions from any Court in that
regard.
i) At the cost of repetition, it is clarified that this judgment shall not be
construed as reviving the ReT Scheme for any purpose whatsoever,
nor shall it be interpreted so as to create or confer any right upon
candidates who were not part of a prepared select panel or who failed
to approach the Court timely. Moreover, these directions are being
issued in the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case invoking
the power under Article 142 of the Constitution of India and it shall
not be treated as precedent in any manner whatsoever.
SWP No. 1910/2015
j) In view of the observations made in para 24 above, we believe that the
State Government shall apply their mind to the facts and
circumstances of the case and the situation prevalent in the State and
to take an appropriate decision with respect to the revision of the
honorarium of such teachers as they deem fit.
10. Before adverting to the binding effect of the aforesaid Apex Court
judgment on the claim of the petitioner, it is pertinent to notice the nature
of the relief sought in the present petition. The petitioner seeks quashing of
the subsequent Advertisement Notice dated 05.06.2015 insofar as it
pertains to the post in question and a consequential direction for his
appointment on the basis of the panel prepared pursuant to the earlier
selection process. The petitioner’s claim is founded essentially upon his
placement at Serial No. 5 in the tentative merit panel and his assertion that,
upon the non-joining of the candidate subsequently placed at Serial No. 1
in the final select panel, he became entitled to be considered against the
said post. However, the record, as noticed hereinabove, shows that the
petitioner was never included in the final select panel. Thus, acceptance of
the petitioner’s prayer would necessarily require this Court to reopen the
earlier selection process, reconsider the claims of the candidates in the
light of the subsequent non-joining of a selected candidate and thereafter
create a fresh right of selection and engagement in favour of the petitioner
under the erstwhile ReT Scheme.
11. The ad-interim direction passed by this Court on 15.10.2015, whereby the
engagement process pursuant to Advertisement Notice dated 05.06.2015 in
respect of the post in question was stayed, also cannot be construed as
SWP No. 1910/2015
conferring any substantive or vested right of selection or engagement upon
the petitioner. The said interim protection was intended only to preserve
the position during the pendency of the proceedings and did not have the
effect of reviving the earlier selection process or elevating the petitioner
from his position in the tentative merit panel to the status of a selected
candidate. More importantly, after the closure of the ReT Scheme and in
view of the latest judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in “Union
Territory of Jammu and Kashmir & Ors. v. Saba Wani”, no direction
can now be issued which would have the effect of reopening the earlier
selection process or creating a fresh right of engagement in favour of a
candidate who was not part of the prepared select panel. Granting the relief
sought by the petitioner at this stage would, therefore, amount to reviving
the erstwhile ReT Scheme and would run contrary to the express directions
issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
12. Admittedly, the petitioner was not figuring in the select panel. Therefore,
in view of the directions passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in case titled
“Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir & Ors. v. Saba Wani”, referred to
hereinabove, the instant petition cannot be allowed, as any such relief
would tantamount to reviving the ReT Scheme and conferring a right upon
a candidate who was not figuring in the prepared select panel. The
directions issued by the Hon’ble Apex Court are applicable to the
candidates whose names figure in the select panel and in whose favour
engagement/appointment orders are to be issued in terms of their
SWP No. 1910/2015
respective positions in the select panel, having regard to the available
vacancies. Since the petitioner does not figure in the select panel, no relief
can be granted to him at this stage.
13. In addition, the Hon’ble Apex Court has also made it clear that the
candidates so appointed as per the directions (a) and (b) from the select
panel under the RET scheme are directed to acquire minimum qualification
prescribed under NCTE regulations and notifications including the
qualified TET within three years and three attempts from the date of their
engagements/appointments. As such, the directions (a) to (j) referred
hereinabove, shall be applicable strictly in favour of those candidates
whose names figured in the select panel and admittedly in the instant case,
the petitioner nowhere figures in the select panel, as such, no relief can be
granted to the petitioner at this stage.
CONCLUSION
14. Therefore, in the light of the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court,
the instant petition has been rendered infructuous and accordingly, same is
dismissed as the relief prayed for by the petitioner at this stage cannot be
acceded thereto as the same will tantamount to reviving the RET Scheme
which if be done will be direct conflict with the directions issued by the
Hon’ble Apex Court.
15. Thus, viewed from any angle, the writ petition, in the light of the aforesaid
development and the law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court, is
dismissed. However, dismissal of the instant writ petition shall not come in
SWP No. 1910/2015
the way of the petitioner to agitate his cause before appropriate forum, if so
advised and permissible under law.
16. Interim direction, if any, shall stand vacated.
(WASIM SADIQ NARGAL)
JUDGE
JAMMU
11.08.2026
Vijay
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes/No
Whether the judgment is reportable: Yes/No
Vijay Kumar
2026.08.11 17.52
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Jammu
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review