Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No: MA No. 134/2014
Reserved on: 15.09.2026
Pronounced on: 07.10.2026
Uploaded on: 07.10.2026
Raj Sharma (Bharti)
…Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
Ms. Zoya Bhardwaj, Advocate
Through:
Vs.
Collector
another
land
Acquisition
and
…. Respondent(s)
Through:
Mr. Ravinder Gupta, AAG
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Instant appeal was filed by two appellants namely Kailash
Nath Sharma and Raj Sharma (Bharti) under Section 52 of
the
J&K
Land
Acquisition
Act,
Svt.,
thereby
challenging a judgment dated 02.12.2013 passed by
learned Additional District Judge, Jammu, whereby a
reference
made
by
respondent
No.
1-Collector
Land
Acquisition PWD, Jammu under Section 18 of the J&K
Land Acquisition Act, Svt., 1990 on file No. 6/LA of 1996
has been dismissed.
2.
The facts as emanating from the record are that the two
appellants are brother and sister of one Kumari Shanta
Bharti who in turn owned and possessed in her own name
MA No. 134/2014
and right 13 kanals’ parcel of land under Khasra No. 63,
situated at Village Sitni ( Sitlee), Jammu.
3.
In the year 1973, said land was acquired by the
respondents for the purpose of construction of By-Pass
Road to Tawi Bridge in terms of an award No. LA-1878-80
dated 19.12.1973. It is pertinent to mention here that the
acquisition
award
No.
LA-1878-80
dated
19.12.1973
pertained to 196 kanals 14 marlas of land falling in Village
Sitni (Sitlee) and it included said 13 kanals of land in
khasra No. 63 owned by Kumari Shanta Bharti- the
predecessor-in-interest of two appellants.
4.
It seems that Kumari Shanta Bharti- the predecessor-ininterest of two appellants, opted not to receive cash
compensation in respect of her 13 kanals acquired land,
and exercised an option for an alternative equivalent land.
5.
After much delay on 05.10.1994, the respondent No. 1Collector Land Acquisition PWD Jammu passed an award
bearing No. LA/201-02, thereby providing alternate and
equivalent value land, comprising two chunks of land in
Village Sitni, i.e., eight (8) kanals three (3) marlas in Khasra
No. 62 min and seventeen (17) marlas in Khasra No. 96
and third chunk of land, i.e., four (4) kanals in Khasra No.
344 min.
6.
It appears that possession of two chunks of land in khasra
numbers 62 & 96 situated in Village Sitni came to be
MA No. 134/2014
delivered to the Kumari Shanta Bharti- the predecessor-ininterest of two appellants, but she complained that
possession of 4 kanals of land comprised in Khasra No. 344
at Village Khanpur was never delivered to her because said
chunk of land was found to be in claim and possession of
the Army.
7.
Kumari Shanta Bharti-the predecessor-in-interest of the
two appellants also felt aggrieved that there was an
inordinate delay of almost 20 years to pass the award of
alternate land and that gave rise to claim of damages for
deprivation of her property for twenty years on account of
escalation of prices relating to development of her land.
8.
This prompted Kumari Shanta Bharti- the predecessor-ininterest of two appellants to make an application under
Section 18 of the J&K Land Acquisition Act, Svt. 1990
before respondent No.1-Collector Land Acquisition PWD
Jammu thereby seeking reference of the dispute.
9.
In her said application for reference, Kumari Shanta
Bharti- the predecessor-in-interest of the two appellants,
besides stating that possession of 4 kanals of land situated
in Village Khanpur had not been handed over to her, also
contended that the delay in passing the award with regard
to the alternative land had given rise to a claim for
compensation in her favour on account of escalation in the
costs of construction that had taken place between the
MA No. 134/2014
years 1973-when her land was taken over, and 1994-when
the award was passed.
10. The respondent No.1-Collector Land Acquisition, PWD
Jammu made a reference of the disputes to the Principal
District Judge, Jammu, and the reference came to be
assigned to the learned Additional District Judge, Jammu.
11. The respondent No.1-Collector Land Acquisition PWD
Jammu filed its reply to the application for reference in
which it was pleaded that passing of the award involved
going through several formalities and that the case had to
pass through several channels, as such, there was no
intentional delay in passing the award. It was also pleaded
by
respondent
No.1-Collector
Land
Acquisition
PWD
Jammu that possession of the entire land provided to
Kumari Shanta Bharti- the predecessor-in-interest of the
two appellants in terms of the award has been handed over
to her.
12. Vide an order dated 18.11.1996, learned Additional District
Judge, Jammu framed the following issues:1.
“Whether the award was passed by respondent
collector after inordinate and abnormal delay, if so
what is its effect on the reference and award? OPP
2.
In case issue no.1 is proved in affirmative, whether
the applicant is entitled to compensation for wrongful
deprivation of her property and loss occasioned
thereby, if so what is the quantum thereof? OPP
3.
Whether because of land given in exchange to the
petitioner at different places, the petitioner has been
put to inconvenience, lesser use with lesser value of
MA No. 134/2014
property, if so whether the petitioner is entitled to
compensation on that score and what is the quantum
of compensation? OPP
13.
4.
Whether the land in question belongs to Brindaban
housing society, if so what is its effect on award? OPR
5.
At last to what relief the petitioner is entitled.
It seems that Kumari Shanta Bharti- the predecessor-ininterest of the two appellants filed an application before the
learned Reference Court, praying for framing of an
additional issue with regard to the question as to whether
complete possession of the land given in exchange to her
i.e., Kumari Shanta Bharti- the predecessor-in-interest of
the two appellants in terms of the award, had been handed
over to her. The application was allowed by the learned
Reference
Court
when
on
15.01.1998,
the
following
additional issue came to be framed with onus placed upon
the respondents in the reference:“3-A Whether the respondent has delivered to the
petitioner complete possession of entire land agreed to
be delivered to the petitioner in exchange of the land
acquired in terms of the award?...O.P.R”
14. In order to prove her case, Kumari Shanta Bharti- the
predecessor-in-interest
witness
box,
and
of
her
two
appellants
statement
was
entered
the
recorded
on
12.11.1999. No other witness was examined by the
appellant. It is pertinent to mention here that Kumari
Shanta Bharti- the predecessor-in-interest of the two
appellants had made an application before the Reference
MA No. 134/2014
Court for summoning respondent No.1-Collector Land
Acquisition PWD Jammu as a witness, along with the
record showing whether physical possession of 4 kanals of
land falling under Khasra No. 344, situated in Village
Khanpur, had been delivered to her. The record further
shows that respondent No.1-Collector Land Acquisition
PWD Jammu did appear before the Court as a witness.
However, on 29.11.2001, his examination-in-chief, as also
part of his cross-examination, was recorded by the
Reference Court. Since the court time was over, as such,
his further cross-examination was deferred. Thereafter,
several opportunities were granted to the respondents for
appearance of respondent No.1-Collector Land Acquisition
PWD Jammu for recording his further statement in cross
examination, but it seems that for one reason or the other,
the respondent No.1-Collector Land Acquisition PWD
Jammu did not appear before the Court for recording his
further
statement.
Ultimately,
vide
an
order
dated
29.08.2007 of the learned Reference Court, the evidence of
the respondents was closed and the case was set down for
final arguments.
15. During pendency of reference proceedings, Kumari Shanta
Bharti expired on 13.06.2010.
MA No. 134/2014
16. By virtue of an order dated 29.10.2012, the learned
Reference
Court
brought
on
record
her
two
legal
heirs/representatives.
17. The learned reference Court vide its impugned judgment
dated 02.12.2013, has proceeded to dismiss the reference
on the ground that Kumari Shanta Bharti, the petitioner
failed to produce any evidence to show that due to the
abnormal delay in passing the award of land in exchange,
she had suffered any loss or that because the land given in
exchange was situated at different places, she had been put
to any inconvenience so as to be compensated with
monetary damages.
18. Two legal representatives namely Kailash Nath Sharma
(brother) and Raj Sharma Bharti (sister) of Kumari Shanta
Bharti
filed
the
present
appeal
for
challenging
the
impugned judgment on the grounds that the learned
Reference Court has failed to appreciate the factual
position that the chunk of 4 kanals of land in khasra
number 344 in Village Khanpur was never handed over to
their predecessor-in-interest. It has been contended that
the issue in this regard has not at all been discussed or
decided by the learned Reference Court. It has been further
contended that the Reference Court has misapplied its
mind to the facts of the case and refrained from dealing
with the issue with regard to handing over possession of 4
MA No. 134/2014
kanals of land situated at Khanpur, which part of the land
was already and is in possession of the Army and was
never handed over to the predecessor-in-interest of the
appellants.
19. During the pendency of this appeal, appellant No. 1 Kailash
Nath Sharma expired leaving the appeal to be pursued by
the surviving appellant No. 2 Raj Sharma (Bharti).
20. I have heard learned counsel for the parties. I have also
gone through the record of the Reference Court, the
grounds of appeal, and the impugned judgment.
21. So far as the finding of the learned Reference Court that the
appellant has not led any evidence regarding the alleged
loss suffered due to delay in passing of the award is
concerned, the same appears to be well-founded. This
Court is not convinced much less persuaded by the
submission of the learned Counsel for the appellant that
delay of almost twenty years in passing the award of
exchange of land in favour of Kumari Shanta Bharti per-se
was actionable to render the State liable to pay damages to
her. There is no evidence led by the predecessor-in-interest
of the appellants on this aspect of the matter.
22. When this court examines the record of the case, it comes
to fore that the only evidence led by Kumari Shanta Bharti
is her own statement examining herself as a witness.
Though Kumari Shanta Bharti has stated that she had
MA No. 134/2014
suffered loss to the tune of Rs. 15 lakhs on account of the
delayed passing of the award and that she is also entitled
to compensation of Rs. 2 lakhs on account of having been
given land at three different places, yet she has not
produced any evidence to support and corroborate her
aforesaid statement. No evidence has been produced before
the Reference Court to establish the costs of construction
that was prevailing in the year 1973 when the land of
Kumari Shanta Bharti was acquired and the cost of
construction at the time when the land at two places was
actually allotted to her in terms of the award passed in the
year 1994. Kumari Shanta Bharti failed to depose and
explain as to in what manner she had suffered loss by
allotment of land at two different places. In the absence of
any evidence to this aspect and in this regard, it is not
open to this Court to evaluate the plea of purported loss
suffered by Kumari Shanta Bharti.
23. Apart from the above, in the present case Kumari Shanta
Bharti was given land in exchange and she was not
awarded any cash compensation, so her contention that
she had suffered loss on account of delay in passing of the
award could not have been accepted by the Reference Court
even if there would have been any such evidence led by
Kumari Shanta Bharti. It would have been a question of
law as to whether it was permissible in terms of scope and
MA No. 134/2014
purpose of section 18 of the J&K Land Acquisition Act, Svt.
1996 to ask for reference of said nature for adjudication.
24. Otherwise also, this Court is not inclined to accept the
submission of the learned counsel of the appellant that
delay in awarding alternate land in lieu of acquired land
had raised development costs for her. This Court declines
to accept the said plea because if the land acquired from
her (Kumari Shanta Bharti) was subject to escalation in
price, the land given to her in exchange was also subject to
equivalent escalation in its market price, therefore, it
cannot be stated that Kumari Shanta Bharti had suffered
any monetary loss by delayed award. Therefore, the finding
of the learned Reference Court in this regard cannot be
interfered with. In fact, learned counsel for the appellant
has not laid much stress on this contention during the
course of hearing.
25. Now, the main point at issue which is required to be
determined is as to whether 4 kanals of land in Khasra
No.344 situated at Khanpur, awarded in favour of Kumari
Shanta Bharti predecessor-in-interest of the appellant, had
actually been handed over to her so as to constitute the full
satisfaction of award in exchange so as to discharge
respondent
No.
as
an
indenting
authority
and
respondent No. 1- Collector Land Acquisition PWD, Jammu
as an acquisition authority for their statutory obligation to
MA No. 134/2014
compensate the expropriated owner Kumari Shanta Bharti
under the scheme of the J&K Land Acquisition
Act, Svt
1990 .
26.
It is on the aforesaid precise point of law that two
appellants have filed the present appeal to assail the
judgment of Reference Court. In fact, in the application
made under Section 18 of the J&K Land Acquisition Act,
Svt, 1990 this issue was emphasized by Kumari Shanta
Bharti- predecessor-in-interest of the appellant before
respondent No. 2- Collector Land Acquisition PWD Jammu.
Not only this, it is at the instance Kumari Shanta Bhartithe predecessor-in-interest of the appellant that the learned
Reference Court was implored to frame an additional issue
on this aspect of the matter, which came to be framed on
15.01.1998.
27. To support the contention that the chunk of 4 kanals of
land falling under Khasra No. 344, situated at Khanpur,
was never handed over to her, Kumari Shanta Bharti had
not only expressly pleaded so in the application for
reference but she has also made a specific assertion in her
statement recorded before the Reference Court that this 4
kanals of land in KhasraNo.344 situated in Village
Khanpur was never handed over to her. Kumari Shanta
Bharti has stated that though the Patwari had shown this
patch of land to her but when the Patwari went to the spot
MA No. 134/2014
to conduct demarcation, the Army Authorities claimed that
the said land belonged to them as they had acquired the
said land. Kumari Shanta Bharti has further stated that
she made a complaint in this regard before the Deputy
Commissioner Jammu as also before the concerned
Minister, but no heed was paid to her complaint. Kumari
Shanta Bharti has gone on to state that if the State
authorities would have allotted alternate land to her in lieu
of this patch of 4 kanals of land then her grievance would
have been redressed to her satisfaction notwithstanding the
delay in passing of award and bifurcation of alternate land
in three different parcels instead of one.
28. When cross-examined on this aspect of the matter, Kumari
Shanta Bharti admitted that the land in Khasra Nos. 96 (17
marlas), 62 (8.1kanal) and 344 (4 kanal) was allotted in her
favour, but she explained that possession of 4 kanals of
land in Khasra No. 344, situated at Khanpur, was never
handed over to her, whereas possession of the rest of the
land in other two khasra numbers was handed over to her.
29. The respondent No. 2-Collector Land Acquisition PWD
Jammu, in his examination-in-chief, stated that possession
of 4 kanals of land falling under Khasra No. 344, situated
at Village Khanpur, was also handed over alongwith
possession of land in two other khasra numbers. However,
the cross-examination of the respondent No. 2-Collector
MA No. 134/2014
Land Acquisition PWD Jammu remained inconclusive, and
he never appeared before the Court for recording his
further cross-examination. The respondent No. 2-Collector
Land Acquisition PWD Jammu also did not produce the
record relating to the handing over of physical possession
of 4 kanals of land situated at Village Khanpur, which was
specifically summoned by Kumari Shanta Bharti- the
predecessor-in-interest of the appellant by way of her
application dated 18.04.2000.
30. In the face of the aforesaid nature of evidence, the assertion
of Kumari Shanta Bharti, predecessor-in-interest of the
appellant, that she was never handed over possession of 4
kanals of land situated at Khanpur has remained unrebutted and the same stands established. The statement
of the respondent No. 2-Collector Land Acquisition PWD
Jammu in his incomplete testimony that this patch of land
was also handed over to Kumari Shanta Bharti cannot be
relied upon because he had chosen not to appear in
witness box so as to complete his cross-examination,
therefore, the same does not and cannot qualify as
“evidence” in the eyes of law.
31. Apart from the above, the respondent No. 2-Collector Land
Acquisition PWD Jammu was in possession of the relevant
record, and once Kumari Shanta Bharti had taken a
definite stand that she was not handed over possession of 4
MA No. 134/2014
kanals of land situated at Village Khanpur in Khasra No.
344, the respondent No. 2-Collector Land Acquisition PWD
Jammu was legally obliged to produce the relevant revenue
record in this regard to rebut the assertion of the
predecessor-in-interest
of
the
appellant.
A
party
in
possession of the record, if it fails to produce the same
despite the adverse party seeking its production, an
inference has to be drawn that if such record had been
produced, it would have been un-favourable to the party in
possession of the same failing to produce so.
32. Thus an adverse inference has to be drawn against the
respondent No. 2-Collector Land Acquisition PWD Jammu
for withholding the record relating to handing over
possession of 4 kanals parcel of land in khasra number
344 Khanpur otherwise awarded under the award. Thus,
from the material on record and the evidence produced
before the learned Reference Court, it can safely be stated
and held that 4 kanals of land comprised in Khasra No.
344, situated at Village Khanpur, was never handed over to
the predecessor-in-interest of the appellant.
33. As already stated, from the statement of Kumari Shanta
Bharti- the predecessor-in-interest of the appellant, which
remained un-rebutted, it is established that possession of 4
kanals of land situated at Village Khanpur was never
handed over to Kumari Shanta Bharti- the predecessor-inMA No. 134/2014
interest of the appellant. In fact, this aspect of the matter is
further strengthened by a communication/ letter dated
02.07.2005 addressed by the Director, Land Management,
Jammu
Development
Authority,
to
the
Deputy
Commissioner, Jammu, a copy whereof is available on the
record of the Reference Court and the same has also been
annexed by the appellant along with the memo of appeal.
As per the said communication/letter, a patch of land
measuring 3 kanals and 9 marlas, bearing Khasra No. 164
of Village Khanpur (Nagrota), was identified for allotment in
favour of Kumari Shanta Bharti-the predecessor-in-interest
of the appellant in place of 4 kanals of land possession
whereof
was
communication,
never
delivered
to
her.
Vide
said
the Jammu Development Authority had
expressed its no objection to the Govt. for allotment of the
said piece of land in favour of Kumari Shanta Bharti-the
predecessor-in-interest of the appellant.
34. Learned Reference court, while passing the impugned
judgment, has not adverted to the aforesaid aspect of the
matter at all. In fact, the learned Reference court has
neither
dealt
with
the
additional
issue
framed
on
15.01.1998 in its impugned judgment nor considered the
evidence led on this issue, thereby landing itself into a
grave error.
MA No. 134/2014
35. All these facts go on to show that though vide award dated
05.10.1994, land measuring 13 kanals, comprising 8
kanals 3 marlas under Khasra No. 62 and 17 marlas under
Khasra No. 96, situated at Village Sitni, and 4 kanals
under Khasra No. 344, situated at Village Khanpur, had
been allotted in favour of Kumari Shanta Bharti-the
predecessor-in-interest of the appellant in lieu of equivalent
land situated at Village Sitni which had been acquired for
construction
of
the
road
in
terms
of
award
dated
19.12.1973, yet the whole of the land given in exchange to
her had not been handed over to Kumari Shanta Bharti,
inasmuch as the land measuring 4 kanals under Khasra
No. 344 at Village Khanpur had never been handed over to
her.
36. It was incumbent upon respondent No. 2-Collector Land
Acquisition PWD Jammu and the authorities of the State to
ensure that the whole of the land allotted in exchange to
Kumari Shanta Bharti was duly handed over to her only
then it could be stated that the award dated 05.10.1994
stands
satisfied.
Respondent
No.
2-Collector
Land
Acquisition PWD Jammu was duty-bound to ensure that
the land measuring 4 kanals under Khasra No. 344,
situated at Village Khanpur, was handed over to Kumari
Shanta Bharti- the predecessor-in-interest of the appellant
and, if it was not possible to do so on account of its
MA No. 134/2014
occupation by any third party, respondent No. 2-Collector
Land Acquisition PWD Jammu was duty bound to ensure
that alternate land of equivalent value is provided to
Kumari Shanta Bharti-expropriated owner. It is the duty of
respondent No. 2-Collector Land Acquisition PWD Jammu
under the J&K Land Acquisition Act, Svt. 1990 to ensure
that the award is satisfied and that the landowner is given
compensation in terms of the award.
37. It would be pertinent to mention here that at the time of the
acquisition proceedings from 1973 to 1994 and even till
2019 right to property in the erstwhile State of Jammu &
Kashmir was a fundamental right under Article 19 (1)(f) of
the Constitution of India as was applicable to the erstwhile
State of Jammu & Kashmir. Kumari Shanta Bharti, who is
an aggrieved expropriated owner of property was not
adequately compensated by handing over to her possession
of entire allotted land. Thus, her fundamental right to
property stood violated. Even now, the right to property
continues
to
be
a
constitutional
right
post
J&K
Reorganization Act, 2019. Therefore, the respondents, viz.
the intending department and the Collector are legally
bound to compensate to the successors-in-interest of
Kumari Shanta Bharti by providing to them the land
equivalent in value to the patch of land that was earmarked
for her in terms of the award.
MA No. 134/2014
38. In view of the foregoing discussion, the appeal is allowed to
this effect, and the impugned judgment dated 02.12.2013
passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Jammu, is
set aside. The respondents are directed to identify 4 kanals
of State/JDA land of similar value in place of 4 kanals of
land of khasra number 344 Village Khanpur, and make its
allotment in favour of the appellant Raj Sharma ( Bharti)
and legal heirs, if any, of deceased appellant No. 1 Kailash
Nath Sharma. The respondents shall further ensure that
possession of the same is duly handed over to the
appellant. The entire exercise shall be completed by the
respondents within a period of three months from the date
of receipt of a copy of this order.
39. Disposed of as above.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
Jammu
07.10.2026
Madan Verma-Secy.
Whether order is speaking?
Whether order is reportable?
KARAM CHAND
2026.10.07 13:34
I attest to theMA
accuracy
No.and
134/2014
integrity of this document
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review