Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
(APPELLATE SIDE)
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Smita Das De
W.P.A. No. 27700 of 2025
Sri Rahul Chanda
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
With
WPA 25203 of 2025
CAN 1 of 2025
Shobha Singh
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the Petitioner (WPA
27700 of 2025)…. For the
Respondent (WPA 25203 of
2025).
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
For the State in both the
writ petitions
: Mr. Pantu Deb Roy, Ld. AGP,
: Mr. Pannalal Bandopadhyay
For the Intervener
:
:
:
:
For the Petitioner (WPA
25203 of 2025)
For the Respondent(WPA
27700 of 2025)
: Mr. N.I. Khan
Reserved on
Judgment on
: 06/01/2026
: 21/01/2026
Mr. Debabrata Saha Roy, Sr. Adv
Mr. Pingal Bhattacharyya
Mr. Subhankar Das
Mr. Neil Basu
Mr. Sankha Biswas
Ms. Oindrilla Sarkar
Mr. Avidipta Paul
Mr. Soumen Bhattacharjee
Mr. Ankan Das
Ms. Sradhya Ghosh
Mr. Raunak Seal
: Mr. Amlan Kr. Mukherjee
Smita Das De, J.:1.
Both the writ petitions are heard together and disposed of accordingly
by a common order, as the issue pertains to plying of vehicles of the
writ petitioners herein, in the route No. 71 running from Howrah to
Saltlake.
2.
For the sake of convenience and in order to effectively address the
issue involved herein, the facts relevant for adjudication are being
culled out and taken from WPA No. 27700 of 2025.
3.
The petitioner in the instant case challenges inter alia, the resolution
dated September 24, 2025 resolved under agenda no. 4, refusing to
issue the order of replacement of the old vehicle and the renewal of
the permit of the new vehicle in respect of the route no. 71 running
from Howrah to Salt Lake hereinafter referred to as the said route.
4.
Apropo the facts of the case, the petitioner is a permanent stage
carriage permit holder of the said route being PSTP No. 029/71/
NEW/2010.
5.
Initially the said permit stood in the name of one Pradeep Singh.
Subsequently, the same was transferred in the name of the petitioner
with the prior consent of the erstwhile owner and the permit was
accordingly renewed by extending the period of validity of the permit
by the respondent authorities.
6.
The petitioner took steps for replacement of the old vehicle with a new
BS-III norms complained vehicle. The petitioner purchased a new
vehicle on hire purchase by taking a loan from West Bengal Transport
Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd. (hereinafter referred to
as WBTIDCL for the sake of brevity and convenience).
7.
Thereafter, the petitioner produced the new vehicle before the
authority concerned for the renewal of the permit and replacement of
the old vehicle with the new vehicle since the validity period of the
permit was about to expire on February 21,2025.
8.
In the meantime one Shobha Singh (being the private respondent
herein) filed a Writ Petition being WPA No. 4949w of 2018 before this
court on March 26, 2018. A representation was made before the
respondent authorities for grant of permanent stage carriage permit in
respect of a vacancy created in the route No. 71 due to non-plying of
the vehicle of a Bus No. WB04E-3525 (WBTIDCL Bus).
9.
In pursuance of an order dated September 3,2018 passed by the
Coordinate Bench of this Court in WPA 4949 of 2018 directing inter
alia, the respondent No. 2 to consider the representation of the private
respondent dated March 26, 2018 for ascertaining as to whether the
writ petitioner herein has been plying the vehicle in the said route or
not.
10.
The RTA Board, Kolkata took a resolution and rejected the prayer of
the private respondent on November 15, 2018 on the ground of there
being ‘no vacancy’ in the route No. 71.
11.
A further Writ Petition was filed before this Court by the private
respondent challenging inter alia, the order of rejection passed by the
RTA Board on April 9, 2019. Upon considering the same the
Coordinate Bench of this Court further directed the respondent No. 2
to take a fresh decision on the issue as prayed for by the private
respondent. Subsequently the RTA Board again rejected the prayer of
the private respondent on the ground of “no vacancy” in the route
No. 71.
12.
A further Writ Petition was filed by the private respondent in WPA No.
17233 of 2019 assailing the Resolution of RTA Board dated May 6,
2019 wherein the Coordinate Bench was pleased to set aside the said
resolution directing inter alia, for fresh consideration in the light of
the order already passed on April 9, 2019 in WPA 4578 of 2019.
13.
Subsequently the prayer of the private respondent was further
rejected on October 10, 2023 on the self-same ground i.e. ‘no vacancy’
in route No. 71.
14.
In the meantime the private respondent initiated a Contempt
Proceeding against the respondent No. 2 for non-compliance of the
order dated March 31, 2023 passed in WPA 17233 of 2019 of this
court.
15.
In pursuance of such Contempt Proceedings the RTA Board took a
fresh resolution on November 9, 2023 by issuing an offer letter in
favour of the private respondent for the route No. 71 by cancelling the
permit of the petitioner.
16.
The resolution taken by the petitioner on October 10, 2023 by the RTA
Board was communicated accordingly to the petitioner, which became
the subject matter of challenge in WPA No. 28142 of 2023.
17.
The matter was extensively heard by the Coordinate Bench of this
Court and on September 3,2025 the judgment was delivered with an
observation which is reproduced below:
“Therefore, on the two scores that is the permit of the petitioner being cancelled
in absence of compliance of any of the Clauses as enumerated in Section 86(1)
of the 1988 Act and also in absence of the writ petitioner having been afforded
any opportunity to furnish his explanation as regards proposed cancellation of
his permit, the resolution adopted by the Board on October, 2023, appears to
be not in compliance with the statutory provisions. At the cost of reiteration,
this Court further notes that the impugned resolution has been adopted
without ascertaining whether the 24th position of the fleet strength is actually
vacant or not. The resolution dated October 10, 2023, therefore, would not be
eligible to be sustained for the reasons as stated above.
Hence, the said resolution dated October 10, 2023 by the respondent
/Regional Transport Authority Board, Kolkata Region as regards cancellation
of the permit of the writ petitioner vide resolution No 4 is set aside. ”
18.
Thereafter, the petitioner filed another Writ Petition being WPA No.
3921 of 2025 praying inter alia, for the replacement of the vehicle No.
WB04E-3525 (WBTIDCL Bus) since the petitioner was restrained to
ply on the said route after February 21, 2025. The Writ Petition was
disposed of by an Order dated February 19, 2025 directing inter alia,
the RTA Board to replace the vehicle and to allow the petitioner to ply
the vehicle till the disposal of the Writ Petition No. 28142 of 2023. On
February 27, 2025 the prayer for replacement was rejected by allowing
the petitioner to ply his vehicle till the same attains the finality.
19.
In view of the judgment and order dated September 3, 2025 passed by
the Coordinate Bench of this Court the resolution dated October 10,
2023 taken by the respondent No. 2 with regard to the cancellation of
the permit of the petitioner was quashed and set aside.
20.
In this context the petitioner submitted by relying upon a decision in
the case of Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Coal India Ltd. And
Others Versus Ananta Saha and Others reported in (2011) 5 SCC
142 which states i.e. it is a settled legal proposition that if initial
action is not in consonance with law, subsequent proceedings would
not sanctify the same. In such a fact situation, the legal maxim
sublato fundamento cadit opus is applicable, meaning thereby, in
case a foundation is removed, the superstructure falls. In the present
case vacancy, offer letter etc emanates out of an order of cancellation
of a permit which was issued in favour of the writ petitioner by a
resolution dated October 10, 2023 which has been quashed and/or
set aside, therefore the filling up of alleged vacancy by issuing an offer
letter in favour of the private respondent is misconceived and is not
legally sustainable.
21.
It is submitted that in spite of specific orders of this court the
respondent authorities refused to pass an order of replacement on the
ground of locus of the petitioner.
22.
The petitioner submits that in respect of all the orders passed by the
Coordinate Bench of this Court, orders have been obtained by the
private respondent without impleading the petitioner to the array of
the proceedings.
23.
The State respondent submits that already a resolution has been
taken by the respondent No. 2 on February 27, 2025 and May 27,
2025 to obtain a NOC from WBTIDCL being the actual owner of the
vehicle.
24.
The route in question is a notified route having a fleet strength of 40.
If the private respondent is allowed to ply the vehicle then the position
of the private respondent would have been over and above 40 and
would have attained the position of 41 st.
25.
The private respondent submits that the petitioner has already
surrendered the permit and never plied the vehicle in the route in
question. Such contention of the private respondent was refuted by
the petitioner stating inter alia, that the question of non-plying of the
vehicle in the route in question does not arise since the documents
annexed to the writ petition corroborates that the vehicle of the
petitioner has already suffered immensely and has been penalized for
violating the traffic rules prescribed under the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 for the period 2017 to 2024.
Now taking up WPA 25203 of 2025 wherein the private respondent of
WPA 27700 of 2025 is the petitioner herein challenging inter alia, the
non-issuance of a stage carriage permit of the said route being route
No. 71 in favour of the petitioner despite due compliance with all the
terms and conditions of the offer letter including the purchase of the
emission norms complained vehicle as required for.
1.
The petitioner submits that the said route is a notified route with a
fleet strength of 40, the vehicle owned by one Rahul Chanda being the
petitioner in WPA No. 27700 of 2025 being the private respondent
herein, has been plying the vehicle in excess of the fleet strength of 40
by holding the 41st position in the said route.
2.
The petitioner submits that as per the resolution No. 4 dated October
10, 2023, the RTA Board was pleased to cancel the permit being No.
029/71/NEW/2005 owned by the private respondent by offering an
Offer Letter in favour of the petitioner against the alleged position of
24 in the said route.
3.
The private respondent submits that in the light of the order passed
by the Coordinate Bench of this Court the resolution dated October
10, 2023 is not legally sustainable as the same has lost its force, and
is a nullity in the eye of law.
4.
The State respondents fairly takes a stand and submits that since an
offer letter has already been issued by the respondent authorities to
the
writ
petitioner,
the
respondent authorities
are
willing
to
accommodate the petitioner to ply his vehicle against a vacancy
available in a different route having a close proximity to the route No.
71. The petitioner refuses to accept such alternative route for plying
his vehicle. The State respondents in this context of such refusal
submits in all fairness that in near future if any vacancy is declared in
respect of the said route the petitioner shall get a preference out of
turn to apply for the said route in question.
5.
Mr. Soumen Bhattacharya, Learned counsel appearing in CAN 1 of
2025 for the addition of parties submits that in the said route there is
one vehicle plying over and above the fleet strength of 40. If the
private respondent is allowed to ply then the petitioner shall hold the
position of 42nd, which de hors the mandate of the notification.
6.
After hearing the rival contentions of the parties in respect of both the
Writ Petitions, I am of the considered view that the decision has been
taken by the respondent authorities on October 10, 2023 without
proper application of mind. The creation of vacancy against the 24 th
position in the fleet strength is no longer in dispute as the private
respondent is running the vehicle in the said route in full swing
without any interruption. In view of the judgment and Order of the
Coordinate bench of this Court, the resolution dated October 10, 2023
is a nullity in the eye of law and is not legally sustainable as it has
lost its force since the order of the cancellation of a permit of the writ
petitioner has been set aside and quashed.
7.
The respondent authority has misconstrued the letter and the spirit of
the order and/or judgment dated September 3, 2025. The decision
taken by the respondent by way of a resolution cancelling the permit
of the writ petitioner reflects thereby the arbitrariness and the
biasness of the respondent authorities frustrating the entire process of
decision making.
8.
In the light of the observation made in WPA No. 27700 of 2025 the
writ petition No. 25203 of 2025 is misconceived and cannot be
entertained and is liable to be dismissed.
9.
In view of the above discussions the following directions are
adumbrated hereunder:a)
Rahul Chanda being the writ petitioner of WPA 27700 of 2025 is
directed to make payment of all admissible dues to WBTIDCL
within a period of 2 weeks from date.
b)
The WBTIDCL is directed to issue NOC forthwith in favour of
Rahul Chanda subject to the satisfaction of payment of the
arrears which has fallen due.
c)
The copy of the NOC received from WBTIDCL shall be placed
before the RTA, Kolkata being the respondent No. 2 herein
within a week thereafter.
d)
The respondent No. 2 is directed to pass an order of
replacement of old vehicle being WB04E-3525 of Rahul Chanda
being the petitioner in terms of the order dated February 19,
2025 passed in WPA 3921 of 2025 within 2 weeks from the date
of submission of NOC obtained from WBTIDC Ltd.
e)
However, it is made clear that since the rights of Shobha Singh
the petitioner of WPA of 25203 of 2025 has been prejudiced due
to a wrong decision taken by the respondent No. 2, the
respondent No. 2 is directed to find an alternative route to allow
Shobha Singh, to ply her vehicle in a close proximity to the
route in question or else to accommodate her against any
vacancy if declared in the said route by giving a preference to
apply for the same. The said decision shall not act as
precedence to the other intending / existing operators in the
said route.
f)
The RTA Kolkata shall renew the permit of Rahul Chanda as per
the application dated February 2, 2025 accordingly.
g)
The respondent authorities shall make a field enquiry to
ascertain as to whether any vehicle is at all plying over and
above the fleet strength of 40, in that case the respondent
authorities shall forthwith take necessary steps in accordance
with law against the vehicle owner holding the 41 st position.
h)
In the event, if the respondent authorities concerned decides to
increase the fleet strength over and above 40, the respondent
authorities shall communicate such decision to Shobha Singh
for allowing her to make an application for grant of permit to ply
the vehicle in the said route.
10. In conspectus of the above, the Shobha Singh has lost her locus to
agitate the issue of filling up the vacancy against the 24th position in
the said route.
11. By setting aside and quashing the resolution dated October 10, 2023
vide Judgment/Order dated September 3, 2025, the locus of Rahul
Chanda is resurrected and his position remains restored as 24 th in the
fleet strength of 40.
12. The writ petition No. WPA 27700 of 2025 is disposed of in terms of
directions passed herein and WPA No. 25203 of 2025 is dismissed
accordingly in view of WPA 27700 of 2025. CAN 1 of 2025 for
addition of parties is allowed and disposed of. No order as to cost.
13. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order if applied for, be supplied
to the party on priority basis upon compliance upon requisite
formalities.
(Smita Das De, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review