Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
WP (C) No. 2477/2023
CM No. 5859/2023
Reserved On: 9th of September, 2026.
Pronounced On: 25th of September, 2026.
Uploaded On: 25th of September, 2026.
Whether the operative part or
full Judgment is pronounced:
Full.
Rafiq Ahmad Chowhan, (42 Years)
S/O Noor-ud-Din Chowhan
R/O Bulinar Hafrada, Tarthpora,
District Kupwara.
… Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr Sheikh Manzoor, Advocate with
Mr Shabir Ahmad Shah, Advocate.
V/S
1. Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir,
Through Commissioner/ Secretary to Government,
Home Department, Civil Secretariat,
Srinagar/ Jammu.
2. Director General of Police,
Jammu & Kashmir, Srinagar/ Jammu.
3. Inspector General of Police, J&K,
Zonal Police Headquarters (ZPHQ),
Srinagar.
4. Deputy Inspector General of Police,
NKR, Baramulla.
5. Senior Superintendent of Police,
Kupwara.
… Respondents
Through: Mr T. A. Lone, Dy. AG vice
Mr Mohsin-ul-Showkat Qadri, Sr. AAG.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE.
(JUDGMENT)
01.
The Petitioner, through the medium of the instant Writ Petition
filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, seeks a direction upon
WP (C) No. 2477/2023
CM No. 5859/2023
the Respondents, more particularly Respondent No.5-Senior Superintendent
of Police, Kupwara, to issue formal engagement Order in his favour as SPO
on the strength of Order dated 21st of August, 2015 issued by Respondent
No.2 and, accordingly, allow him to perform his duties as SPO.
02.
The Petitioner claims that his brother, namely, Ab. Majeed
Chowhan, who was working as SPO and posted in Special Operations
Group (SOG) Villigam, got killed by unknown gunmen in April, 2007; that
in the said incident, the house of the Petitioner was also burnt and the
Petitioner, along with his family members, had a narrow escape to their life;
that as a measure of rehabilitation, the Respondents processed the case of
the Petitioner for his engagement as SPO in place of his deceased brother
and, accordingly, in terms of Order dated 21st of August, 2015, the
Respondent No.2-Director General of Police, J&K granted approval for
engagement of the Petitioner, along with another candidate to be engaged as
SPOs in the Police Organization.
03.
It is further stated by the Petitioner that the Respondent No.5,
thereafter, got the particulars, character and antecedents of the Petitioner
verified from different agencies, however, failed to issue the formal
engagement Order in favour of the Petitioner; that the Petitioner filed
various representations/ applications before the Respondents from time to
time seeking formal engagement order in his favour based on the Order
issued by the Respondent No.2, however, his case remained pending in the
office of Respondent No.5, on one pretext or the other. On the basis of this
factual backdrop, it has been finally prayed that the Petition of the
Petitioner be accepted and the Respondents, more particularly Respondent
No.5 be directed to issue formal engagement Order in his favour as SPO on
the strength of Order dated 21st of August, 2015 issued by Respondent No.2
and, accordingly, allow him to perform his duties as SPO.
04.
Upon notice having been issued, the Respondents have filed
their Reply/ Objections, inter alia, stating therein that the approval for
WP (C) No. 2477/2023
CM No. 5859/2023
engagement of the Petitioner as SPO was issued by PHQ, J&K vide Order
dated 21st of August, 2015, on which date, the age of the Petitioner was 26
years and 08 months, however, the Petitioner did not bother to appear in the
office of Respondent No.5 for his joining within the stipulated period of
time, but physically approached the office of Respondent No.5 on 23 rd of
December, 2019 for his joining, i.e., after a gap of more than four years
from the issuance of aforesaid approval Order; that the report sought from
SSP, Handwara revealed that the brother of the Petitioner, who was
working as SPO, was killed by unknown terrorists in the year 2007 during
an encounter at Bulinard forests and after sacrifice of his life for the
integrity of the nation, the family members of the said deceased have
received ex-gratia relief of ₹2.00 lacs, besides the widow of the deceased,
namely, Saleema Begum, was also engaged as an SPO, who is presently
performing her duties at Police Station Viligam under belt No. 279/SPO.
05.
The Respondents, in their Reply/ Objections, have further
pleaded that that the approval of the Petitioner for his engagement as an
SPO was accorded by PHQ, J&K on operational grounds and not under
rehabilitation scheme in place of his brother, as claimed by the Petitioner in
his Petition; that the Petitioner was supposed to join immediately without
any delay, however, on 23rd of December, 2019, that is after a gap of four
years and four months from the date of issuance of aforesaid approval
Order, the Petitioner approached/ applied for his joining, in the office of
Respondent No.5, when his age had reached as 31 years and 13 days,
thereby having crossed the required upper age limit of 28 years; that the
educational qualification of the Petitioner is 8th pass, whileas, the required
qualification for engagement of SPO is 10th pass or above, as such, the
Petitioner is otherwise not eligible for engagement as SPO.
06.
Heard learned Counsel for both the sides, perused the
pleadings available on record and considered the matter. I have also gone
through the record, as produced by the Respondents through their Counsel.
WP (C) No. 2477/2023
CM No. 5859/2023
07.
Although, the Petitioner has claimed that he was engaged as an
SPO since his brother, namely, Ab. Majeed Chowhan, who was working as
an SPO, had got killed in April, 2007 and that he, along with his family, had
a narrow escape when their house was burnt. He, therefore, claims to have
been engaged as an SPO vide Order dated 21st of August, 2015, when
approval was granted for his engagement along with another candidate by
Respondent No.2-Director General of Police, J&K. The Respondents,
however, submit that the approval for engagement of the Petitioner as an
SPO was granted by PHQ, J&K on operational grounds and not under the
rehabilitation Scheme in place of his brother, as claimed by him in his
Petition, however, the Petitioner instead of joining immediately without any
delay, approached the Respondents on 23rd of December, 2019, i.e., after a
gap of four years and four months from the date of issuance of aforesaid
approval Order. The Respondents have, thus, claimed that the Petitioner
approached for joining as an SPO in the office of Respondent No.5-Senior
Superintendent of Police, Kupwara, when his age had reached as 31 years
and 13 days, thereby having crossed the required upper age limit of 28
years, besides, the educational qualification of the Petitioner was only 8th
pass, whileas, the required qualification for engagement as an SPO is 10th
pass and above and, as such, the Petitioner was otherwise not eligible for
engagement as an SPO.
08.
The case set up by the Petitioner is that, after the accord of
approval by the PHQ, J&K, for his engagement as an SPO, he was not
issued any formal Order to report to submit his joining or report for duties
and that he had been approaching the Respondents to submit his joining
report which was not received by them, inasmuch as, the Respondent No.5
had not passed any formal order in this behalf.
09.
Since, the approval for engagement of the Petitioner as an SPO
had been granted on 21st of August, 2015, as such, the crucial date for
reckoning of his age and educational qualification was that date and not
WP (C) No. 2477/2023
CM No. 5859/2023
when he had approached the Respondent No.5 for submission of his joining
report.
10.
On perusal of the approval order for engagement of the
Petitioner as an SPO, as issued by the PHQ, J&K on 21st of August, 2015, it
is apparent that the said Order clearly provides that the Senior
Superintendent of Police, Kupwara/ Respondent No.5 herein will issue
formal engagement order in respect of the Petitioner herein against
available vacancy of SPO, subject to clearance of verification. Therefore,
with the tone and tenor of the aforesaid Order of approval, it cannot be
construed that either age or educational qualification were left to be decided
by Respondent No.5-Senior Superintendent of Police, SSP Kupwara. Even
if these requirements were to be fulfilled at the time of joining report to be
submitted by the Petitioner, the same have to be construed in reference to
the year 2015, that is when approval had been accorded for his engagement
and not later in point of time.
11.
The Respondents, particularly Respondent No.5, in absence of
issuance of any engagement order pursuant to PHQ Order to engage the
Petitioner as SPO, cannot take the plea at this stage that the Petitioner was
over-age and was not having the requisite qualification, when he himself
failed to act upon the orders of the PHQ issued way back in the year 2015.
12.
Viewed thus, the present Writ Petition is allowed with a
direction to the Respondent No.5 to consider the appointment of the
Petitioner as an SPO, having regard to his age and qualification in the
month of August, 2015, that is, when approval for engagement of the
Petitioner as an SPO was accorded by PHQ, J&K, and pass appropriate
orders in the matter as per Rules. The Respondent No.5, as expected, is
directed to pass the consideration order within a period of six weeks from
the date of receipt of certified copy of this Judgment.
13.
Record, as produced, be returned to the Respondents through
their Counsel, against proper receipt.
WP (C) No. 2477/2023
CM No. 5859/2023
14.
Writ Petition is, thus, disposed of on the above terms, along
with the connected CM.
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
September 25th, 2026
“TAHIR”
i.
Tahir Manzoor Bhat
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
Whether the Judgment is approved for reporting?
Yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review