The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. that Under the non-conventional heads also this Court finds in the nature of disability suffered by late Gopinathan, a reasonable enhancement can be granted in favour of the appellants.
12. Coming to the next question regarding the entitlement for Attendant Charges, this Court cannot but notice the fact that late Gopinathan was suffering from an unstable mind due to the psychiatric disabilities consequent to the gliosis of right frontal and temporal lobes. In addition to that, in Ext.A9, the Doctor who examined the late has specifically found that he could not move about without assistance of a person. Therefore, the claimants are entitled to get Attendant Charges for one person from 17.10.2017 till 30.06.2020 i.e. from the date of accident till his death. The view taken by this Court is supported by the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kajal v. Jagdish Chand & Ors. [(2020) 4 SCC 413]. Therefore, it is held that the appellants are entitled to have the compensation calculated under the head Attendant Charges for 2025:KER:30688 person from 17.10.2017 till 30.06.2020. As an upshot of these discussions, the appellants are entitled to succeed. The appeal is thus allowed and the appellants are entitled for enhanced compensation as follows: Heads Amount awarded by the Tribunal Total compensation awarded in appeal Enhanced amount of compensation Notional income of late Gopinathan is fixed at Rs.17,325/-. Percentage of permanent disability is restored to 70%. Loss of earnings 18,000/- 1,38,600/[17325x8] 1,20,600/[138600-18000] Pain and suffering 80,000/- 1,00,000/-…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:30688
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 7TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MACA NO. 1887 OF 2021
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 23.12.2020 IN OPMV NO.1725 OF
2017 OF MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, IRINJALAKUDA
APPELLANTS/PETITIONERS:
RADHAMANI
AGED 64 YEARS
W/O. GOPINATHAN, VARIKKAT HOUSE, MANNAMPETTA,
VARAKKARA P.O., THRISSUR DISTRICT-680 302.
GIREESH
AGED 41, W/O. GOPINATHAN, VARIKKAT HOUSE,
MANNAMPETTA, VARAKKARA P.O.,
THRISSUR DISTRICT-680 302.
GEETHA
AGED 39, W/O. VINOD S. NAIR, PARVATHY VILASAM,
AIMS PONEKKARA P.O., ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, 682 041.
GINEESH
AGED 35, W/O. GOPINATHAN, VARIKKAT HOUSE,
MANNAMPETTA, VARAKKARA P.O.,
THRISSUR DISTRICT-680 302.
BY ADVS.
EBIN GOPURAN
JOSEPH GOPURAN
RESPONDENT/2ND RESPONDENT:
NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
AMBIKA ARCADE, M.G.ROAD, THRISSUR-68001
REPRESENTED BY IT'S MANAGER.
BY ADV SEBASTIAN VARGHESE
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 28.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
MACA No.1887/2021
2025:KER:30688
EASWARAN S., J
.....................................
MACA No.1887 of 2021
...................................…
Dated this the 28th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
The legal heirs of late Gopinathan are the appellants.
Late
Gopinathan approached the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal,
Irinjalakuda, in O.P.(MV)No.1725/2017, claiming compensation on
account of an accident that occurred on 17.10.2017 at about
A.M., while he was riding a motorcycle bearing Reg.No.KL-45-G7589 through Amballur – Varandarappilly public road and when he
reached Alagappanagar Union Office, a car bearing Reg.No.KL-08BA-250 came from west to east direction and hit the backside of
the motorcycle. As a result of the accident, the motorcycle lost
control and late Gopinathan fell down and sustained severe injuries.
Immediately, he was taken to Elite Mission Hospital, Koorkkanchery
and was treated there as an inpatient.
2.
Late Gopinathan contended that he was a Mechanic,
earning a monthly income of Rs.20,000/-.
In support of the
contention, Exts.A1 to A14 documents were produced. In support
MACA No.1887/2021
2025:KER:30688
of his claim that on account of the accident, late Gopinathan
suffered permanent disability up to 70%, Ext.A9 - Disability
Certificate was pressed into service. PW1 was examined to prove
the contents of Ext.A9. The Insurance Company produced Ext.B1
copy of the insurance policy and did not adduce any oral evidence.
The Tribunal, on appreciation of facts, found that the disability of
late Gopinathan can only be fixed from the date of accident
i.e.17.10.2017 till his death i.e.30.06.2020. The Tribunal thereafter
granted the following the compensation:
Sl. Head of Claim
No.
Amount
Claimed
(Rs.)
Amount
Awarded
(Rs.)
Basis vital details in
a nutshell
Loss of earnings
Nil
18,000
(Rs.9,000x2months)
Transportation expenses
20,000
10,000
Damage to clothing
5,000
2,000
Extra nourishment
3,000
2,000
Medical expenses
5,00,000
3,29,973
Ext.A14
Bystander’s expenses
25,000
8,400
(Rs.300x28days)
Pain and suffering
2,00,000
80,000
Permanent disability
5,00,000
52,920
Loss of earning power
2,00,000
Nil
Loss of amenities
3,00,000
40,000
Loss of injury
2,00,000
Nil
Anticipated medical
expenses
2,00,000
Nil
Total
Rs.21,53,000/- Rs.5,43,293/- Rs.5,43,300/is limited to
(rounded off) along
Rs.20,00,000/with interest @8%
(Rs.9,000x12x7x7%)
)
MACA No.1887/2021
2025:KER:30688
p.a. from 05-122017 till realization.
3.
Aggrieved
by
the
compensation, the legal heirs
insufficiency
in
the
of late Gopinathan,
grant
of
who are
impleaded as claimants 2 to 5, are before this Court in the present
appeal.
4.
Heard, Sri.Joseph Gopuran - learned counsel appearing
for the appellants and Sri.Sebastian Varghese – learned counsel
appearing for the Insurance Company.
5.
The learned counsel for the appellants with reference to
Ext.A9 submitted that in the light of the evidence of PW1, wherein
it is specifically stated that late Gopinathan was suffering from post
traumatic disabilities and was categorised having 70% disability
both neurological and psychiatric. The Tribunal was not justified in
reducing the percentage of disability to 7%.
Such perverse
appreciation of facts certainly requires interference by this Court.
As regards the income claimed by late Gopinathan on his avocation
as a Mechanic, the Tribunal ought not have fixed the same as
Rs.9,000/- and the same is required to be refixed in terms of the
notification issued under the provisions of the Minimum Wages Act,
1948.
MACA No.1887/2021
2025:KER:30688
6.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the
Insurance Company pointed out that late Gopinathan was not
examined by a Medical Board.
Even going by Ext.A9, the
percentage of disability is noted as 35%.
Even otherwise, under
Ext.A10, the permanent disability noted by the Doctor who
examined late Gopinathan towards long risk of post traumatic
epilepsy is only 20%, which is a whole bodily disability. Therefore,
the learned counsel for the Insurance Company justified the
findings rendered by the Tribunal, stating that the Tribunal has
rightly appreciated the facts and fixed the permanent disability at
7%.
7.
I have considered the rival submissions raised across
the Bar and is of the opinion that the appellants are entitled to
succeed on the points to follow.
8.
As regards the notional income of late Gopinathan is
concerned, this Court finds that Tribunal has erred in fixing the
same at Rs.9,000/-.
Going by the principles laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Angad Tiwari and Another v.
National Insurance Company Ltd. and Another [2024 KHC
8590], this Court finds that the claimant is entitled to have the
income fixed in terms of the minimum wage notified by the State of
MACA No.1887/2021
2025:KER:30688
Kerala. In G.O.(P)No.56/2017/Fin. dated 28.04.2017, the State of
Kerala has notified the minimum wage as Rs.17,325/-. Therefore
the Tribunal ought to have fixed the notional income of the late
Gopinathan at Rs.17,325/-.
9.
As regards the fixation of the percentage of permanent
disability, it must be noticed by this Court that the contents of
Ext.A9 has been proved by the claimants by due process of law by
examining the Doctor who issued the same.
If the Tribunal was
dissatisfied with the evidence produced before it, it ought to have
referred the victim to the medical board under Rule 387 of the
Kerala Motor Vehicles Act, 1989. Having not done so, the Tribunal
could not have reduced the percentage of disability to such a low
extent, which would shock the conscience of the Court. Therefore,
this Court has no doubt in its mind to hold that the Tribunal had
appreciated the facts in a perverse manner, which requires
interference in this proceedings.
10.
In Prakash Chand Sharma v. Rambabu Saini and
Others [2025 KHC Online 7108], the Hon'ble Supreme Court
reiterated the above principle and held that the Tribunal, while
considering the application under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1983,
cannot reduce the percentage of disability without
MACA No.1887/2021
2025:KER:30688
ordering
reassessment.
Therefore,
read
in
cumulative,
the
irresistible conclusion is that the appellants are entitled to succeed
on this point and the disability of late Gopinathan has to be fixed in
terms of Ext.A9 at 70%.
11.
that
Under the non-conventional heads also this Court finds
in the nature of disability suffered by late Gopinathan, a
reasonable
enhancement
can
be
granted
in
favour
of
the
appellants.
12.
Coming to the next question regarding the entitlement
for Attendant Charges, this Court cannot but notice the fact that
late Gopinathan was suffering from an unstable mind due to the
psychiatric disabilities consequent to the gliosis of right frontal and
temporal lobes. In addition to that, in Ext.A9, the Doctor who
examined the late has specifically found that he could not move
about without assistance of a person. Therefore, the claimants are
entitled to get Attendant Charges for one person from 17.10.2017
till 30.06.2020 i.e. from the date of accident till his death.
The
view taken by this Court is supported by the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Kajal v. Jagdish Chand & Ors. [(2020) 4 SCC
413]. Therefore, it is held that the appellants are entitled to have
the compensation calculated under the head Attendant Charges for
MACA No.1887/2021
2025:KER:30688
person from 17.10.2017 till 30.06.2020.
As an upshot of these discussions, the appellants are entitled
to succeed. The appeal is thus allowed and the appellants are
entitled for enhanced compensation as follows:
Heads
Amount awarded
by the Tribunal
Total
compensation
awarded in
appeal
Enhanced amount
of compensation
Notional income of late Gopinathan is fixed at Rs.17,325/-.
Percentage of permanent disability is restored to 70%.
Loss of earnings
18,000/-
1,38,600/[17325x8]
1,20,600/[138600-18000]
Pain and suffering
80,000/-
1,00,000/-
20,000/[100000-80000]
Loss of amenities
40,000/-
1,50,000/-
1,10,000/[150000-40000]
Permanent
Disability
52,920/-
10,18,710/[17325x12x7x70/1
00]
9,65,790/[1018710-52920]
Attendant Charges
Nil
5,54,400/5,54,400/[17325x32 months]
Total enhanced amount of compensation
Accordingly,
the
appellants/claimants
17,70,790/-
are
awarded
an
additional compensation of Rs.17,70,790/- (Rupees seventeen
lakhs seventy thousand seven hundred ninety only) over and above
the compensation awarded by the Tribunal with interest @8% per
annum from the date of petition till realization together with
proportionate costs. Since the claimants have restricted their claim
to Rs.20 lakhs before the Tribunal, the claimants are liable to pay
MACA No.1887/2021
2025:KER:30688
additional court fees on the enhanced amount. The Insurance
Company is directed to deposit the aforesaid amount within a
period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
judgment. The Tribunal shall deduct the deficit court fees from the
deposit before releasing the same. The balance amount shall be
apportioned in the ratio 70:10:10:10 among the claimants 2 to
5, as ordered by the Tribunal.
The appeal is ordered accordingly.
Sd/-
EASWARAN S.
JUDGE
ACR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review