Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
TUESDAY, THE 8TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 18TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 504 OF 2012
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT&DECREE DATED 13.12.2011 IN AS NO.45 OF 2008 OF
ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT, MAVELIKKARA ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT&DECREE
DATED 05.12.2007 IN OS NO.428 OF 2004 OF MUNSIFF COURT, MAVELIKKARA
APPELLANT/APPELLANT/PLAINTIFF:
R. SASIKUMAR
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS, S.O. RAMAKRISHNAN, JEEVAN NIVAS,
VETTIYAR MURI, VETTIYAR VILLAGE-FROM KALLIMEL MURI, VETTIYAR
VILLAGE, MAVELIKKARA TALUK.
BY ADVS.
SRI.K.JAJU BABU
SMT.DHANYA CHANDRAN
SMT.M.U.VIJAYALAKSHMI
RESPONDENT/APPELLANT/DEFENDANT:
K. SAVITHRI
AGED 68 YEARS, W/O. LATE RAGHAVAN, KRIPASADANAM, VETTIYAR
MURI, VETTIYAR VILLAGE, MAVELIKKARA TALUK, PIN-690101.
BY ADV SRI.K.SASIKUMAR
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 08.04.2025,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
JUDGMENT
1. The appellant is the plaintiff in the suit. The suit was for
declaration,
recovery
of
possession
and
consequential
injunction with respect to the plaint schedule property. The plaint
schedule property is 4.30 Ares and the residential building
therein originally belonged to one Raghavan.
2. Plaintiff is the brother's son of the said Raghavan. Defendant is
the legally wedded wife of the said Raghavan. Raghavan and
the defendant do not have any children. Raghavan died on
06.11.2004. The plaintiff claimed title over the plaint schedule
property on the strength of Ext.A1 registered Will dated
04.12.2000 allegedly executed by Raghavan bequeathing the
plaint schedule property in favour of the plaintiff.
3. Plaint allegations are that, as per the recitals in Ext.A1 Will, the
defendant has got every right to reside along with the plaintiff in
the plaint schedule property, the plaintiff has to maintain her as
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
his mother; if the defendant intends to leave the residence with
the plaintiff, the plaintiff has to pay Rs.50,000/- to the defendant;
and an amount of Rs.20,000/- is to be given to one Sujatha who
is the daughter of the brother of the defendant within three years
from the date of death of Raghavan. When the defendant got
knowledge about the Will after the death of Raghavan, the
defendant tried to obstruct the plaintiff from enjoying the plaint
schedule property and building therein and tried to make
arrangements for the disposal of the property. The plaintiff is
ready and willing to maintain the defendant as intended by
Raghavan in Ext.A1 Will. Hence, the plaintiff prayed for a
declaration of title and possession over the plaint schedule
property, a permanent prohibitory injunction restraining the
defendant from creating any encumbrance over the plaint
schedule property and from alienating the property, and to
recover possession of the plaint schedule property.
4. The defendant opposed the suit prayers by filing Written
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
Statement contending, inter alia, that on the death of Raghavan
the plaint schedule property devolved upon the defendant as the
sole legal heir. The defendant renovated the residential building
therein with the money obtained under Indira Awas Yojana
Scheme and with the money obtained from her siblings. The
building was constructed with the consent of Raghavan.
Raghavan was not having any right in the building. Raghavan
was sick and was not having sound mental capacity to execute
the Will. Raghavan has not executed any Will. The signatures
in Ext.A1 is not that of Raghavan. Raghavan was unable to
understand the contents of the Will. For the last 15 years, the
plaintiff was in enemical terms with Raghavan. The Will is not
attested by two attesting witnesses. Even if it is found that
Raghavan has executed the Will, it is an invalid document as
there are no sufficient attestors for the same.
5. On the side of the plaintiff, the plaintiff was examined as PW1,
the Doctor who treated Raghavan was examined as PW2, the
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
Secretary of the Panchayat was examined as PW3, and the
Scribe of Ext.A1 was examined as PW4. Exts.A1 to A5 were
marked from the side of the plaintiff. On the side of the
defendants, the Block Development officer was examined as
DW1 and the defendant was examined as DW2. Exts.B1 to B3
were marked.
6. The Trial Court found that Raghavan executed Ext.A1 Will with
sufficient mental capacity, that Ext.A1 Will is attested by two
attesting witnesses, including PW4 Scribe, and that PW4 Scribe
signed Ext.A1 in the capacity as witness also. The suit was
decreed declaring the title of the plaintiff over the plaint schedule
property and the building therein as per Ext.A1, granting
permanent prohibitory injunction restraining the defendant from
creating any encumbrance and from alienating the plaint
schedule property and allowing the recovery of possession of
the plaint schedule property on the strength of A1 Will permitting
the plaintiff to discharge his duties as per Ext.A1 Will.
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
7. The defendant filed Appeal before the First Appellate Court, and
the First Appellate court allowed the Appeal setting aside the
judgment and decree of the Trial court and dismissing the suit.
The First Appellate Court found that Ext.A1 Will is neither
properly executed nor properly attested; that developments
after the year 2000 would go to show the doubtful
circumstances encompassed in the will; that the plaintiff could
not remove the suspicious circumstances surrounding the
execution of Ext.A1 Will; that the evidence of PW4 is not
sufficient either to prove the signature or to prove Ext.A1 Will
beyond the shadow of suspicious circumstances and that PW4
is not an attesting witness to Ext.A1 Will.
8. This Court admitted the Regular Second Appeal on the following
substantial questions of law.
i. Viewed in the context of Sec.63 of the Indian Succession Act and
Sec.68 of the Evidence Act, whether the first appellate court is justified
in its finding that Ext.A1, Will is neither properly executed or properly
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
attested, when all the mandatory requisites have been sufficiently met
by the plaintiff to seek his right, title and right of possession over the
plaint schedule property?
ii. Whether the first appellate court ought to have found that the
appellant/plaintiff, as propounder of the Will, had discharged his onus
of establishing that Ext.A1, Will was free from suspicious
circumstances when he had proved the legally mandated elements
such as signature of the testator, his sound state of mind and the
presence of two attesting witnesses at the time of execution of the Will?
iii. Whether the first appellate court is right in relying on the
subsequent events after the execution of the Will for deciding its
validity?
9. I heard the learned Senior counsel for the appellant Sri.K.Jaju
Babu instructed by Adv.Sri.Sachin Ramesh and the learned
Counsel for the respondent Sri.K Sasikumar.
10. The learned Senior Counsel for the appellant contended that the
First Appellate Court ought not to have interfered with the well
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
considered judgment of the Trial Court. The First Appellate Court
misconstrued and misunderstood the evidence of PW4 who is
one of the attesting witnesses of Ext.A1. PW4 though was a
Scribe of Ext.A1 Will specifically stated that he had signed the
Will as a witness also. There is no legal bar for standing the
scribe as attesting witness. The plaintiff has removed all the
suspicious circumstances surrounding Ext.A1 Will and hence the
First Appellate Court ought to have dismissed the Appeal
confirming the judgment and decree of the Trial Court. The
learned Senior Counsel cited the decision of this Court in Ajay
P.Asher v. Kirit P.Asher and another [2011(3) KHC 288] to
substantiate the point that total exclusion of an heir apparent from
the estate of the testator is not ground to doubt the genuineness
of the Will and that the testator may act foolishly even heartlessly
and in such case Court shall not interfere with exercise of his
volition if he acts in full comprehension of what he is doing.
Senior Counsel cited the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
in Gopal Krishan v. Daulat Ram [2025 KHC 6009] to
substantiate the point that there is no statutory requirement under
Section 63(c) of the Indian Succession Act that the attestor
should sign the Will as per the direction of the Will. Learned
Senior Counsel concluded by submitting that the Appeal is liable
to be allowed answering the substantial questions of law in favour
of the appellant.
11.
On the other hand, the learned Counsel for the respondent
contended that the Trial Court approached the matter in a
casual manner. The pleadings and evidence were not
appreciated in the right perspective. The First Appellate Court
considered the matter extensively with reference to authoritative
pronouncements and arrived at the right conclusion. PW4 who
is shown as Scribe of Ext.A1 specifically admitted that he did
not sign the Will in the capacity as witness. There is no evidence
that the alleged attesting witnesses attested as per the direction
of the testator. Section 63(c) of the Indian Succession Act
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
mandates that the attesting witnesses shall sign as per the
direction of the testator. Learned Counsel cited the decision of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Chinu Rani Ghosh v Subhash
Ghosh [2025 KHC online 7044] to substantiate the point that
the object and purpose by which a Will is attested by a witness
is quite distinct from the object and purpose by which a scribe
would attest a Will; that an attesting witness would attest a Will
on the request made by the testator for the purpose of due
execution of the Will and in accordance with S.63 of the
Succession Act and that the object and purpose with which a
scribe or for that matter, a draftsman of the will would attest the
Will is not the same. Learned Counsel concluded by submitting
that the Appeal is liable to be dismissed as the formulated
substantial questions of law do not arise in the matter.
12.
I have considered the rival contentions.
13.
In Chinu Rani Ghosh(supra) cited by the counsel for the
respondent the question whether the attesting witnesses are to
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
be signed as per the direction of the testator was not specifically
before the Honorable Supreme Court and it was not considered
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. But in Gopal Krishan (supra)
cited by the Senior Counsel for the appellant, the Hon’ble
Supreme court specifically considered the said question and
held that the part of the Section 63(c) employs the term direction
would come into play only when attestor to the Will would have
to see some other person signing the Will. Hence the contention
of counsel for the respondent that Section 63(c) of the Indian
Succession Act mandates that the attesting witnesses shall sign
as per the direction of the testator is unsustainable.
14.
The First Appellate Court has referred various judicial
pronouncements and arrived at the conclusion that scribe can
become an attesting witness if his evidence is to the effect that
he signed the document as an attesting witness also. Of course,
there could not be any quarrel on the said proposition of law.
What is relevant is whether the Scribe was having animus
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
attestandi while signing the document and whether the said fact
is proved in his evidence.
15.
The onus of proving the Will is always on the propounder
who needs to prove testamentary capacity of the testator,
signature of the testator and attestation by two witnesses in the
absence of suspicious circumstances. When there are
suspicious circumstances, in addition to the above proof, the
propounder has to explain and remove the suspicion to the
satisfaction of the Court.
16.
PW4 is cited as the second attesting witness in Ext.A1. The
evidence of PW4 is not precise and definite regarding
attestation. At one point, he deposed that he signed as witness.
But when he was specifically asked whether he signed as
witness, he answered in the negative. Later, he said he signed
in triple capacities. When the stand of PW4 was not definite and
was wavering, it could be said that he was an attesting witness
to the document. First of all, PW4 should himself be sure as to
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
his capacity, then only he will be in position to convince his
capacity to others.
17.
The first Witness in Ext.A1 - Chellamma Meenakshi is also
a scribe in the office of PW4. Though it is sufficient to examine
one of the two attesting witnesses to prove the execution of the
document under Section 68 of the Evidence Act, such witness
has to give the evidence of attestation of the other witness also.
If the examined witness is unable to give evidence of attestation
of the other witness, the other witness has to be examined to
his attestation to the document. This Court in Mannarakkal
Madhavi (died) v. Nankanadath Pulparambil Devidasan
(died) [2024 KHC 781] has reiterated the above proposition of
law by holding that that if one attesting witnesses can prove the
execution of Will in terms of S.63(c), namely, attestation by two
attesting witnesses in the manner contemplated therein,
examination of the other witness can be dispensed with; that
Section 63(c) nowhere says both attesting witnesses must be
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
present at the same time or that they must sign simultaneously
or that they must also speak the attestation by other witness;
that when one attesting witness is unable to speak of the
attestation by the other witness the propounder can examine the
other attesting witness to satisfy the mandatory requirement
under the said section. When PW4 was examined he could not
give any definite answer with respect to the attestation of the
other witness also. When PW4 was asked whether the other
witness had signed as Scribe, initially he answered in the
affirmative and later in negative. The evidence of PW4 is
doubtful whether Chellamma Meenakshi had animus attestandi
at the time of signing the document. In such case, the
propounder ought to have examined Chellamma Meenakshi to
prove her attestation to the document. In the absence of the
evidence of Chellamma Meenakshi, it could not be held that the
execution of Ext.A1 Will is proved. The conclusion is that the
evidence of PW4 is not sufficient to prove his attestation and the
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
attestation of Chellamma Meenakshi to Ext.A1. The First
Appellate Court is perfectly justified in holding that the evidence
of PW4 is not sufficient to prove the execution of Ext.A1.
18.
The First Appellate Court found that there is suspicion
surrounding the execution of Ext.A1 Will since the testator has
bequeathed the property in favour of his nephew/plaintiff
avoiding his poor widow leaving her at the mercy of the plaintiff.
Admittedly, the plaint schedule property is the only property
which belonged to the testator. It is the residential property in
which the testator along with the defendant had been living.
After the death of the testator, the defendant has been
continuing her residence there. The original house in the
property was renovated after obtaining assistance under IAY
Scheme. It is in evidence that the application for the financial
assistance was made by the testator and the same was
received by the defendant and she renovated the residential
building. The defendant has a case that financial assistance
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
from her siblings were also used for renovating the building.
The plaintiff does not have a case that there was any kind of
difference of opinion or quarrel between the testator and the
defendant. The defendant was not having any job or income.
The defendant was fully depending on the testator for livelihood.
The testator had not made any provision for the maintenance of
the defendant. Plaintiff could not show any special reason for
the testator for bequeathing his only property in which the
testator and the defendant had been residing, to the plaintiff. In
Ajay P.Asher (supra) this Court held that total exclusion of a
heir apparent from the estate of the testator is not ground to
doubt the genuineness of the Will. But in that case also it is
found that the excluded son was having bitter litigation with the
testator. Every case has got its own unique facts and
circumstances. Total exclusion of an heir apparent from the
estate of the testator by itself is not ground to doubt the
genuineness of the Will. But in the facts and circumstances of
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
the present case, it is a suspicious circumstance which should
have been explained by the plaintiff.
The learned Senior
Counsel for the appellant contended that the testator wanted to
see that the property does not go in the hands of the defendant
after her death and hence Ext.A1 Will is executed in favour of
the plaintiff who is the brother’s son of the testator. In such case
also, there is no evidence as to why the plaintiff was chosen by
the testator from among his relatives. As rightly pointed out by
the counsel for the respondent that as per Section 15 of the
Hindu Succession Act, the property will go to the heirs of her
husband, since the defendant is not having any children. Hence
such an explanation from the plaintiff is also not acceptable. It
is hard to believe that the testator would leave his poor aged
widow having no job or income at the mercy of his nephew
bequeathing the entire property to him. The First Appellate
Court is right in holding that the plaintiff failed to remove the
suspicion surrounding the execution of Ext.A1 Will.
RSA No.504 of 2012
2025:KER:29770
19.
The testator died on 06.11.2004. The plaintiff filed the suit
against the defendant on 01.12.2004 within one month from the
death of testator. Even as per the disputed Will, the defendant
is having right of residence. But the plaintiff even sought for
recovery of possession of the property from the defendant and
the same was readily granted by the Trial Court while decreeing
the suit in favour of the plaintiff. The First Appellate Court is fully
justified in interfering with the judgment and decree passed by
the Trial Court.
20.
The substantial questions of law Nos.i & iii are answered
in the affirmative and substantial questions of law No.ii is
answered in the negative, all against the appellant.
21.
The Regular Second Appeal is dismissed with costs.
Sd/-
M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
JUDGE
Jma/shg
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review