Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
AS No. 62 of 2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 02-07-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE N. SATHISH KUMAR
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE M.JOTHIRAMAN
AS No. 62 of 2019
AND
CMP NO. 2902 OF 2019, CMP NO. 29640 OF 2024,
CMP NO. 29638 OF 2024
R.Padmanaban
S/o K.V Rajaram, No.36, Arcor Road,
Villapakkam Village, Arcot Taluk, Vellore Dt.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. R.Ramalingam
S/o Rajarathinamudaliar, No.227/1, Amman
Koil St., Sevur Village And Post, Arni Taluk,
Tiruvannamalai District.
2. R.SIVAKUMAR (Died)
S/o Ramalingam,
No.227/1, Amman Koil St., Sevur Village And
Post, Arni Tk, Tiruvannamalai Dt.
3. R.Kuppammal
W/o R.Ramalingam,
No.227/1, Amman Koil Street,
Sevur Village and Post,
Arani Taluk, Thiruvannamalai Dist.
4. D.Lakshmi @ Latha,
W/o Late R.Sivakumar,
Anjaneyar koil Street,
Nedukunam Village,
Vandavasi Taluk, Thiruvannamalai Dist.
..Respondent(s)
__________
Page1 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
PRAYER: Appeal Suit filed under Section 96 CPC r/w. Order 41 Rules 1 and 2
of CPC against the decree and Judgment dated 23.10.2018 in O.S.No.48/2017
passed by the Hon’ble Additional District and Sessions Judge (FTC) Court,
Arni, Tiruvannamalai Dt.
R2 Died. (R3 and R4 brought on record LRs of the deceased R2, vide Court
Order dated 22.02.2023 made in CMP No.3845 of 2023 in AS No.62 of 2019,
(SVNJ and RKMJ).
For Appellant(s):
Mr.A.Panneerchelvam
For Respondent(s):
M/s.D.R.Arunkumar
Counsel for R1 and R3
R2- Died, R4- No Appearance
Judgment
(Judgment of the Court was delivered by M.Jothiraman J.)
Unsuccessful plaintiff has preferred the present appeal suit. The Suit has
been filed for Specific Performance, delivery of possession and for the
alternative relief of refund of the advance amount. The parties are referred as
per their rankings in the Suit.
2. Brief case of the plaintiff is as follows:
2.1. The suit property belongs to the 1 st defendant. The 2nd defendant is
the son of the 1st defendant. The plaintiff and the 1st defendant entered into an
Agreement of Sale dated 24.07.2010 for a consideration of Rs.30,750/- per cent
and the total sale consideration was fixed at Rs.36,28,500/-. The total extent of
the suit property is 1.18 acres. The period of performance of the contract was
__________
Page2 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
fixed at three months, though it was mutually agreed that time is not the essence
of contract. As per the recitals contained in the agreement, the period of
contract will commence on the completion of survey by the 1st defendant and
proving the extent which is yet to be performed by the 1 st defendant. On the
date of agreement, the plaintiff has paid an advance amount of Rs.1,00,000/-.
2.2. The plaintiff is always ready and willing to perform his part of
contract and upon request, performed his part of contract by measuring the suit
property and to execute the registered sale deed, for which the 1 st defendant has
been evading. The plaintiff came to know that the 1 st defendant, in order to
frustrate the contact, executed a Settlement Deed in favour of the 2 nd defendant
with regard to suit schedule property. The plaintiff issued a notice to the
defendants on 23.02.2011, for which the 2 nd defendant alone has issued a reply
notice on 03.03.2011 containing false and untenable allegations.
defendant neither complied with the demands of the plaintiff.
The 1 st
Hence, the
plaintiff has filed the Suit for Specific Performance and Delivery of Possession
and alternatively prayed for refund of the advance amount.
3. Brief case of the defendants are as follows:
3.1. The defendants denied the Sale Agreement dated 24.07.2010. The
defendants denied that the plaintiff issued a notice to the defendants through his
counsel on 23.02.2011. Further the defendants stated that the 1 st defendant has
__________
Page3 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
so many times requested the plaintiff to perform the same before expiry of the
date of agreement, but the plaintiff did not take care for execution of the sale
agreement for want of money to pay the balance of sale consideration. The suit
property is an ancestral property of the defendants and there was a suit between
the 1st defendant with his sisters before the District Munsif Court, Arani in
O.S.No.558 of 2004.
3.2. The defendants further stated that the plaintiff is doing Real Estate
Business and his motivation is to purchase the property at lowest rate and to sell
the same at higher rate. The plaintiff has unnecessarily filed the suit against the
defendants in order to arrange the balance sale consideration during the period
of trial. The Suit is barred by limitation and the plaintiff is not entitled to the
relief sought for in the Suit.
4.
Based on the above pleadings, the Trial Court has framed the
following issues:
(i) Whether the Sale Agreement dated 24.07.2010 is valid?
(ii) Whether the Suit is barred by limitation?
(iii) Whether the Suit in O.S.No.558/2004 on the file of the District Munsif
Court, Arani is binding on the parties?
(iv) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief sought for?
(v) To what other reliefs, the plaintiff is entitled to?
__________
Page4 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
5. On behalf of the plaintiff, the plaintiff examined himself as PW1 and
one A.Arunachalam as PW2 and one P.Ravichandran as PW3. Exs.A1 to A9
were marked. On behalf of the defendant, the first defendant examined himself
as DW1 and Exs.B1 and B2 were marked.
6. On appreciation of the evidence adduced on either side, the Court
below had negated the relief of Specific Performance and granted the alternative
relief of refund of the advance amount. Aggrieved over the same, the plaintiff
has preferred the present appeal.
7. During the pendency of the appeal suit, the appellant / plaintiff has
filed an application in CMP.No.29638 of 2024 in A.S.No.62 of 2019 under
Order 1 Rule 10(2) CPC r/w. Section 151 CPC seeking to implead
Tmt.D.Amudha and Tmt.R.Anitha as proposed respondents 5 and 6 in this
appeal suit. In the affidavit filed in support of the said application, it has been
stated by the plaintiff that during the pendency of the appeal, he has filed an
application to implead the respondents 2 and 3 as party to the above appeal and
the same was allowed by this Court, vide order dated 22.02.2023. The 1 st
defendant, pendency of the appeal suit, has executed a Settlement Deed in
respect of the suit schedule property in favour of the proposed respondents, vide
Doc.No.11291 of 2023 dated 11.12.2023 on the file of the Sub Registrar, Arani,
__________
Page5 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
which clearly establish that the 1st respondent has made encumbrances over the
property in violations of the orders passed in CMP.No.2902 of 2019 in
A.S.No.62 of 2019 dated 06.02.2019. In view of the subsequent developments
that has arisen, it has become just and necessary to implead the said
Tmt.D.Amudha
and
Tmt.R.Anitha
as
proposed
respondents,
namely
respondents 4 and 5. Hence, the plaintiff has filed the said application.
8. The appellant / plaintiff has also filed an application in CMP.No.29640
of 2024 in A.S.No.62 of 2019 under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC to receive
additional documents.
In the affidavit filed by the appellant in the said
application, it has been stated that the 1 st defendant had executed settlement
deed in favour of the proposed parties, namely Tmt.D.Amudha and
Tmt.R.Anitha, which is a clear violation passed by this Court in CMP.No.2902
of 2019 in A.S.No.62 of 2019 dated 06.02.2019. The alienation of the suit
property, vide DOC.No.11210 of 2013 dated 11.12.2023 is hit by Section 52 of
the Transfer of Property Act. The above said documents are necessary to decide
the issue involved in this appeal. If the document is received as an additional
evidence, no prejudice would be caused to the other side.
9. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant would submit that the
Court below ought to have granted the relief of specific performance, as it has
accepted the case of the plaintiff. Since the Court below has given a clear
__________
Page6 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
finding that the Suit for Specific Performance is maintainable and the
documents relief on by the defendants will not support the case of the plaintiff,
however, the Court below erred in holding that the plaintiff has not verified and
confirmed the extent of property as well as the title of the property before
entering the Sale Agreement. The Court below rightly concluded that Ex.A1 –
Sale Agreement is valid and true and when such a conclusion arrived, the Court
below ought not to have rejected the relief of specific performance.
The
plaintiff is always ready and willing to perform his part of contract and also
placed the lodgement schedule before the Court below to deposit the balance
sale consideration. However, the Court below has not permitted the plaintiff to
deposit the balance sale consideration amount to the credit of the Suit.
Therefore, the plaintiff has proved the means to perform his part of contract
during the relevant point of time and therefore, negating the relief of specific
performance is legally unsustainable and prays for allowing this appeal.
10. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents/defendants
would submit that on appreciation of the entire evidence adduced on either side,
the Court below has rightly found that the equitable relief of granting specific
performance was negated and the relief of refund of the advance amount was
granted and there is no infirmity in the judgment and decree passed by the Court
below and prays for dismissal of the Suit.
__________
Page7 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
11. We have heard both sides and perused the records. In the light of the
above submissions, the following points for determination / issues arises in this
appeal suit:
(i) Whether the petition filed to receive additional document is to be
allowed ?
(ii) Whether the proposed parties are to be impleaded?
(iii) Whether the plaintiff is always ready and willing to perform his part
of contract ?
(iv) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief of specific
performance ?
12. It is the specific case of the plaintiff that the 1 st defendant executed
Ex.A1-Sale Agreement dated 24.07.2010 for a sale consideration @ Rs.30,750/per cent and total sale consideration was fixed at Rs.36,28,500/- to an extent to
1 Acre 18 cents. On the date of Sale Agreement, the plaintiff has paid an
advance of Rs.1,00,000/-. It is seen from the written statement filed on behalf
of the defendants wherein in para 4, it has been stated that the allegations in
para 2 of the plaint that the agreement dated 24.07.2010 whereunder the 1 st
defendant has agreed to measure the suit property with the help of surveyor and
for the proved extent, the plaintiff has to pay the sale consideration at the rate of
Rs.30,750/- per cent and the total sale consideration was fixed at Rs.36,28,500/are all not true and correct. It is also stated that the agreement of sale dated
__________
Page8 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
24.07.2010 is an unilateral agreement executed by the 1 st defendant in favour of
the plaintiff, is utterly false.
The defendants themselves, in the written
statement in para 6, categorically stated that the 1 st defendant so many times has
requested the plaintiff to perform the sale before the expiry of the sale
agreement, but the plaintiff did not take care for execution of the sale agreement
for want of money to pay the balance sale consideration. However, in para 10
of the written statement, it has been stated that the agreement of sale is a
fabricated document by the plaintiff and created without lawful consideration.
Inconsistent stands taken by the defendants in the written statement reveals that
the 1st defendant entered into an agreement of sale with the plaintiff under
Ex.A1 dated 24.07.2010.
13. During the pendency of this appeal, the 1 st defendant had executed
settlement deed in favour of the proposed parties mentioned in CMP.No.29638
of 2024, namely Tmt.D.Amudha and Tmt.R.Anitha. Similarly, the Settlement
Deed executed by the 1st defendant dated 11.12.2023 is vital to decide the issue
involved and the same is received an additional evidence involved in this
appeal.
During the pendency of the appeal, the appellant / plaintiff has filed
two applications to implead Tmt.D.Amudha and Tmt.R.Anitha as respondents 4
and 5. Since the 1st defendant has executed Settlement Deed dated 11.12.2023
on the file of the Sub-Registrar, Arani, it is hit by Section 52 of the Transfer of
Property Act. Since subsequent development has arisen in this case and the said
__________
Page9 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
document comes into existence during the pendency of the appeal, the said
documents to be received as Additional Evidence after impleading them as
proposed respondents.
14. It is seen from the records that along with the petition, Xerox copy of
the Settlement Deed in respect of the suit property in favour of the proposed
respondents, vide DOC.No.11291 of 2023 dated 11.12.2023 on the file of the
SRO, Arani. It is relevant to note that the reasons stated in the affidavit are not
sufficient and it does not attract the conditions enumerated under Order 41 Rule
27 CPC. The proposed parties as respondents receiving the Settlement Deed
executed by the 1st defendant during the pendency of the appeal have no
relevancy to decide the issue involved in this appeal. There is no merits in these
petitions and the same are liable to be dismissed. Therefore, Issue Nos.1 and 2
are answered accordingly.
15. PW1 has categorically deposed about the execution of Ex.A1. PWs.2
and 3 have also spoken about the execution of Ex.A1 and the advance amount
received by the 1st defendant.
Therefore, the execution of Ex.A1 – Sale
Agreement has been clearly established by the prosecution.
16. A perusal of Ex.A1 shows that the plaintiff and the 1 st defendant
entered into an Agreement of Sale Dated 24.07.2010, wherein the 1 st defendant
__________
Page10 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
has agreed to measure the suit property with the help of surveyor and for
proving the extent, the plaintiff has to pay sale consideration @ 30,750/- per
cent and the total sale consideration was fixed at Rs.36,28,500/- to a total extent
of suit property 1 Acre and 18cents. It also shows that the said Sale Agreement
is an unilateral agreement executed by the 1 st defendant in favour of the plaint.
The period of contract was fixed at 3 months. The 1 st defendant received an
advance amount of Rs.1,00,000/- on the date of the Sale Agreement.
17. DW1, in his cross examination, admitted the execution of Ex.A1 –
Sale Agreement and also received Rs.1,00,000/-as advance.
He has also
admitted the recitals in his cross examination.
18. According to the appellant / plaintiff, he is always ready and willing
to perform his part of contract and has been requesting the 1 st defendant to
perform his contract by measuring the suit property and to prove the extent and
receive the balance sale consideration. The suit Agreement of Sale is dated
24.07.2010. The plaintiff issued legal notice to the defendant through his
counsel on 23.02.2011 calling upon the defendants to execute the sale deed
under Ex.A2, whereas the 2nd defendant has received a notice and given reply
under Ex.A3 dated 03.03.2011. The Suit came to be filed on 16.08.2012 after a
lapse of two years. According to the appellant, he was ready to deposit the
balance sale consideration amount by filing the lodgement schedule before the
__________
Page11 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
Court below. However, the Court below have not permitted the appellant to
deposit the amount.
19. It is also relevant to refer to the decision in R.Sharma Naik v.
G.Srinivasiah reported in 2024 INSC 927, wherein it has been held that there is
a fine distinction between readiness and willingness to perform the contract.
Both the ingredients are necessary for the relief of specific performance. While
readiness means the capacity of the plaintiff to perform the contract which
would include his financial position, willingness relates to the conduct of the
plaintiff.
20. It has been repeatedly held by Hon’ble Supreme Court in several
judgments that the plaintiff in a suit for specific performance, should be always
ready and willing to perform his part of the contract in terms of the contract.
Section 16[c] of the Specific Relief Act bars the relief of specific performance
of a contract in favour of a person who fails to aver and prove his / her readiness
and willingness to perform his/her part of the contract. It may not be necessary
or essential to plaintiff to actually tender money to the defendant or to deposit
money in Court unless it is directed by the Court, to prove readiness and
willingness, in view of Explanation [i] to Clause [c] of Section 16 of Specific
Relief Act. Nevertheless, he must prove his readiness to perform his part of
contract [to pay balance] by acceptable evidence.
__________
Page12 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
21. In the case of Man Kaur Vs. Arthar Singh Sangha reported 2010 [6]
CTC 652: 2010 [10] SCC 512, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as follows:“40. …..A person who fails to aver and prove that he has
performed or has always been ready and willing to perform the
essential terms of the contract which are to be performed by him
(other than the terms the performance of which has been prevented
or waived by the defendant) is barred from claiming specific
performance. Therefore, even assuming that the defendant had
committed breach, if the plaintiff fails to aver in the plaint or prove
that he was always ready and willing to perform the essential terms
of contract which are required to be performed by him (other than
the terms the performance of which has been prevented or waived
by the plaintiff), there is a bar to specific performance in his
favour. Therefore, the assumption of the respondent that readiness
and willingness on the part of the plaintiff is something which need
not be proved, if the plaintiff is able to establish that the defendant
refused to execute the sale deed and thereby committed breach, is
not correct. Let us give an example. Take a case where there is a
contract for sale for a consideration of Rs. 10 lakhs and earnest
money of Rs. 1 lakh was paid and the vendor wrongly refuses to
execute the sale deed unless the purchaser is ready to pay Rs. 15
lakhs. In such a case there is a clear breach by the defendant. But
in that case, if the plaintiff did not have the balance Rs. 9 lakhs
(and the money required for stamp duty and registration) or the
capacity to arrange and pay such money, when the contract had to
be performed, the plaintiff will not be entitled to specific
performance, even if he proves breach by the defendant, as he was
not “ready and willing” to perform his obligations.”
22. From the illustration given by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, it can be
held that the proof of continuous readiness and willingness from the date of
contract, time of hearing is mandatory before a person seeks the relief of
specific performance. In Umabai Vs. Nilkanth Dhondiba Chavan reported in
__________
Page13 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
2005 [6] SCC 243, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that there must be
finding by the Court regarding the continuous readiness and willingness of
plaintiff to perform his part of the contract before granting specific
performance. The Hon'ble Supreme Court recently in U.N.Krishnamurthy
through LRs Vs. A.M.Krishnamurthyreported in 2022 [2] MWN [Civil] 799,
after referring to several binding precedents, has held as follows:''45. The Respondent Plaintiff has relied upon the notice
dated 13.02.2003 and evidences of PW2 & PW3 to prove that he
was always ready and willing to perform his part of the contract.
Even though it may be true that the Respondent Plaintiff had
deposited the balance sale consideration in court on 06.04.2010, it
cannot be ignored that such deposit was made by him seven years
after 15.3.2003, being the date by which the sale had to be
concluded. No evidence has been adduced on behalf of the
Respondent Plaintiff as to how the Respondent Plaintiff was in a
position to pay or make arrangements for payment of the balance
sale consideration within time. The Courts below also erred in not
adjudicating upon this vital issue except to make a sweeping
observation that, given that the Respondent Plaintiff was a
businessman he had sources to arrange the balance funds. Careful
study of balance sheet dated 31.03.2003 of the Respondent Plaintiff
would demonstrate that he did not have sufficient funds to discharge
his part of contract.
46. It is settled law that for relief of specific performance, the
Plaintiff has to prove that all along and till the final decision of the
suit, he was ready and willing to perform his part of the contract. It
is the bounden duty of the Plaintiff to prove his readiness and
willingness by adducing evidence. This crucial facet has to be
determined by considering all circumstances including availability
of funds and mere statement or averment in plaint of readiness and
willingness, would not suffice.''
23. In the case on hand, though time was fixed as 3 months to perform the
contract and the plaintiff has to pay the balance sale consideration within a
__________
Page14 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
period of 3 months, however, after a lapse of 7 months alone plaintiff has
chosen to issue legal notice under Ex.A2 dated 23.02.2011 and thereafter after a
lapse of two years, he has chosen to file the Suit. The plaintiff has failed to
prove that he is always ready and willing to perform the contract from the date
of the Agreement. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant vehemently
contended that the appellant has sufficient means at the relevant point of time
and he has prayed to deposit the amount before the Court below through
lodgement schedule and since the Court below has not permitted to deposit the
amount, he could not able to deposit the amount before the Court below, which
clearly shows that the plaintiff is always ready and willing to perform his part of
contract. In this regard, the plaintiff has not chosen to place any bank statement
of accounts or any other documentary prove that the plaintiff was having
financial capacity to pay the balance sale consideration of Rs.36,28,500/- within
the period of three months from the date of the sale agreement, since he has paid
only a meagre amount of Rs.1,00,000 advance.
24. Upon appreciation of the evidence adduced by either side, the Court
below has rightly come to the conclusion that the plaintiff has failed to perform
his part of contract as per the conditions stipulated in the agreement and
accordingly, negated the relief of specific performance and granted the
alternative relief of refund of the advance amount. This Court finds no infirmity
or illegality in the judgment and decree passed by the Court below and the same
is liable to be dismissed.
__________
Page15 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
25. In the light of the above reasoning, this Appeal Suit stands dismissed,
confirming the decree and Judgment dated 23.10.2018 in O.S.No.48/2017
passed by the learned Additional District and Sessions Judge (FTC) Court, Arni,
Tiruvannamalai District.
No costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous
petitions are also dismissed.
(N.S.K.,J.)
(M.J.R.,J.)
02-07-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
JVM
To
The Additional District and Sessions Court (FTC),
Arni, Tiruvannamalai District.
__________
Page16 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 62 of 2019
N.SATHISH KUMAR J.
AND
M.JOTHIRAMAN J.
JVM
AS No. 62 of 2019
AND
CMP NO. 2902 OF 2019,
CMP NO. 29640 OF 2024,
CMP NO. 29638 OF 2024
02-07-2026
__________
Page17 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review