The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. In the present case, the suit was filed on 26.03.2021 and by applying the guidelines in case of Curewin Pharmaceuticals (supra), admittedly, there was no pre-institution mediation and settlement as required under Section 12-A of the Act of 2015. However, the suit filed by the plaintiffs/respondent could not have been rejected by filing application under Order 7 Rule 11 as Section 12-A of the Act of 2015 has been made mandatory by the Apex Court in case of Patil Automation (supra) w.e.f. 20.08.2022. Therefore, this Court is of the view that the suit cannot be rejected for non-compliance of Section 12-A as the same was filed on 26.03.2021 that is prior to 20.08.2022.
18. In view of the aforesaid, we do not find any error in the impugned order passed by the trial Court and hence, this petition being bereft of merit and substance, is hereby dismissed. No order as to cost.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA
ON THE 4th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. PETITION No. 3837 of 2022
BETWEEN:1.
PUSHPSHREE HOSPITALS AND
RESEARCH
CENTRE THROUGH PROPRIETOR DR. GIRISH
TA O R I 12-13, PRAKASH NAGAR, NAVLAKHA
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
DR. GIRISH TAORI S/O SHRI M.M. TAORI, AGED
ABOUT 57 YEARS, OCCUPATION: PROPRIETOR
PUSHPSHREE HOSPITALS AND
RESEARCH
CENTRE 12-13, PRAKASH NAGAR, DISTIRCT
INDORE. (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(SHRI KARPE PRAKHAR MOHAN, COUNSEL FOR PETITIONERS).
AND
1.
KOTHARI
CHEMIST
(PROPRIETORSHIP
CONCERN)
THROUGH
PROPRIETOR
JAGDISHCHANDRA
S/O
LATE
SHRI
MANAKCHAND KOTHARI, AGED 78 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 14 PRAKASH NAGAR
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
JAGDISHCHANDRA
S/O
LATE
SHRI
MANAKCHAND
KOTHARI
OCCUPATION:
PROPRIETOR KOTHARI CHEMIST 14, PRAKASH
NAGAR, DISTRICT INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI YOGESH KUMAR MITTAL, COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENTS).
This petition coming on for admission this day, Justice Sushrut Arvind
Dharmadhikari passed the following:
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:30:30
ORDER
This Miscellaneous Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India assails the order dated 01.07.2022 (Annexure-P/4) passed in Comms20/2022 whereby the application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, filed by the petitioners/defendants has been rejected.
2.
Briefly stated facts of the case are that the respondents are plaintiffs
before the trial Court who have filed a suit for recovery under Order 7 Rule 1 of
the CPC read with Section 16 of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 (hereinafter
referred to as the Act of 2015). On the basis of the transactions and averments,
plaintiffs have sought recovery of the amount.
After issuance of notice,
petitioners/defendants filed an application under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC
contending that Section 2 of the Commercial Courts Act defines "Commercial
Disputes" and looking to the aforesaid definition, the alleged transaction is not
covered under any of the clauses mentioned in Section 2 of the Act and
therefore, the provisions of the Act are not applicable and the plaint is liable to
be rejected. Another ground that was raised in the application was the noncompliance of Section 12-A of the Act as the suit was filed without exhausting
the remedy of pre-institution mediation, hence the same is not maintainable.
3.
Learned trial Court, while passing the impugned order held that as
per Section 2 (1)(c-xviii) which provides for 'Agreement for sale of goods or
provisions of services', there is a commercial dispute between the parties. It
was further held that the compliance of provisions of Section 12-A of the Act
of 2015 is not mandatory, and accordingly the application under Order 7 Rule
11 filed by the petitioners/defendants was rejected. Hence, this petition.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioners contended that the trial Court has
failed to consider that the alleged transactions cannot be said to be falling within
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:30:30
the purview of the commercial dispute as defined under Section 2 of the Act of
2015. If a recovery suit is treated to be and tried in Commercial Court, then the
purpose of enactment of the Act of 2015 will be frustrated. Further, the trial
Court has erred in holding that compliance of Section 12-A of the Act are not
mandatory. The provisions of Section 12-A is clear and unambiguous, which
shows that a suit which does not contemplate any urgent interim relief under this
Act cannot be instituted unless the plaintiff exhausts the remedy of preinstitution mediation. Hence, the impugned order passed by the trial Court is
illegal and contrary to law and deserves to be set aside. In support of his
contention, learned counsel for the petitioners placed reliance on the judgment
passed by the Apex Court in case of Patil Automation Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. vs.
Rakheja Engineers Pvt. Ltd., (2022) 10 SCC 1.
5.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents opposed the prayer
and submitted that the dispute between the parties is a commercial dispute
under Section 2(1)(c-xviii) of the Act of 2015 since there was implied contract
between the parties for supply of goods. Learned counsel for the respondents
placing reliance on the judgment of the Apex Court in case of Patil
Automation (Supra) further contended that the mandatory effect of Section
12-A is prospective in nature and shall be effective from 20.08.2022. No
retrospective effect is provided to the said mandate and hence it is not
applicable on the suits which were instituted prior to 20.08.2022 without due
compliance of Section 12-A. It is further contended that the impugned order is
based on legal ground as it was decided on 01.07.2022 based upon the
prevailing law laid down in catena of judgments wherein it was held that the suits
shall not be dismissed for non-compliance of Section 12-A as the procedural
law prescribes procedure to facilitate the justice. He further submitted that the
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:30:30
petitioners/defendants have a remedy of filing a revision petition under Section
115 of the CPC against the order impugned. Hence, this petition under Article
227 of the Constitution of India is not maintainable.
6. Heard learned counsel for the parties. Perused the impugned order.
7.
In this case, the three pertinent questions that needs to be answered
are as follows:
(i) Whether this miscellaneous petition under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India is maintainable in the light of the fact that the
petitioners had an alternate remedy to file civil revision under Section 115
of the CPC?
(ii) Whether the present suit falls under the term 'Commercial Dispute' as
per Section 2(1)(c-xviii) of the Act of 2015?
(iii)
Whether the compliance of Section 12-A of the Act of 2015 is
mandatory before instituting the Commercial Suit?
8. Firstly, as far as the maintainability of this petition under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India is concerned, it is settled law that whenever the trial
Court rejects an application filed under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC, the only
remedy is of filing a civil revision under Section 115 of the CPC. But in the
present case, the petitioners bypassing the said remedy has raised their
grievance by filing this petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
Though, there are catena of cases wherein it has been held that the High Courts
shall refrain from exercising supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 when an
alternative efficacious remedy exists, but recently, the Apex Court in case of
Raj Shri Agrawal @ Ram Shri Agrawal & Anr. vs. Sudheer Mohan &
Ors. in Civil Appeal No. 7266/2022 has held that when a civil revision lies
before the High Court, in such case, the High Court ought to have converted
the writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India into revision
petition under Section 115 CPC and ought to have considered the same in
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:30:30
accordance with law and on its own merits, rather than permitting the writ
petitioner to file a fresh revision application under Section 115 of the CPC.
Therefore, in view of the aforesaid, this Court, considering the important
question of law to be answered, is of the opinion that the supervisory
jurisdiction needs to be exercised for the sake of justice. In the present case,
the first question being answered positively, therefore, this Court is taking up
question number two and three accordingly.
9. The second controversy involved, which has been vehemently argued
by the learned counsel for the petitioners is that in the present case, it is only a
simple case of recovery of money, therefore, the Commercial Court ought to
have allowed the application filed under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC as it does
not have jurisdiction but this Court concurs with the view taken by the trial
Court because at the very outset, in the plaint, it is being pleaded that the
plaintiffs/respondent is a chemist and the defendants/petitioner is a hospital and
amidst the plaintiff and defendant, various business transactions have taken
place. As per Section 6 of the Act of 2015, it is very clear that the Commercial
Courts shall have jurisdiction to try all suits and applications relating to a
commercial dispute of a Specified Value arising out of the entire territory of the
State over which it has been vested territorial jurisdiction. In the present case,
the plaintiff and defendant, being two business entities, have business
transactions as pleaded under the plaint.
10.
The Apex Court, in case of Saleem Bhai vs. State of
Maharashtra, (2003) 1 SCC 557 has held that while deciding the application
under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC, the trial Courts have to consider the
averments made in the plaint only.
judgment reads as under :
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:30:30
The relevant portion of the aforesaid
''A perusal of Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C. makes it clear that the relevant
facts which need to be looked into for deciding an application thereunder
are the averments in the plaint. The trial court can exercise the power
under Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C. at any stage of the suit-before registering
the plaint or after issuing summons to the defendant at any time before
the conclusion of the trial. For the purposes of deciding an application
under clauses (a) and (d) of Rule 11 of Order VII C.P.C. the averments in
the plaint are germane; the pleas taken by the defendant in the written
statement would be wholly irrelevant at that stage, therefore, a direction
to file the written statement without deciding the application under Order
VII Rule 11 C.P.C. cannot but be procedural irregularity touching the
exercise of jurisdiction by the trial court. The order, therefore, suffers
from non-exercising of the jurisdiction vested in the court as well as
procedural irregularity. The High Court, however, did not advert to these
aspects. We are, therefore, of the view that for the afore-mentioned
reasons, the common order under challenge is liable to be set aside and
we, accordingly, do so. We remit the cases to the trial court for deciding
the application under Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C. on the basis of the
averments in the plaint, after affording an opportunity of being heard to
the parties in accordance with law.''
11. Considering the same, the trial Court has rightly held that both, the
plaintiff and the defendant being business entities, the dispute between them
falls under the category of the commercial dispute as mentioned under Section
2(1)(c-xviii) of the Act of 2015. As per Section 2(1)(c-xviii), any dispute with
respect to the agreement for sale of goods or provision of service is considered
as commercial goods and falls under the definition of Commercial Disputes.
Therefore, there is no error or controversy with respect to the findings given by
the trial Court with respect to the suit falling under the definition of 'Commercial
Dispute'.
12. The third issue that has been raised by the petitioner in the present
case is regarding non-compliance of Section 12-A of the Act before the
institution of suit. Section 12A of the Act of 2015 is reproduced as under :
''12A. Pre-Institution Mediation and Settlement. - (1) A suit, which does not
contemplate any urgent interim relief under this Act, shall not be instituted
unless the plaintiff exhausts the remedy of pre-institution mediation in
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:30:30
accordance with such manner and procedure as may be prescribed by rules
made by the Central Government.''
13.
This issue, has been dealt with in detail by the Apex Court in case
o f Patil Automation (supra). The relevant paragraph of the aforementioned
judgment is reproduced hereunder :
''113. Having regard to all these circumstances, we would dispose of the
matters in the following manner;
113.1 We declare that Section 12-A of the Act is mandatory and hold that
any suit instituted violating the mandate of Section 12-A must be visited
with rejection of the plaint under Order 7 Rule 11. This power can be
exercised even suo motu by the Court as explained earlier in the
judgment. We, however, make this declaration effective from 20.08.2022
so that stakeholders concerned become sufficiently informed.
113.2 Still further, we however direct that in case plaints have been
already rejected and no steps have been taken within the period of
limitation, the matter rejection of the plaint has been acted upon by filing
a fresh suit, the declaration of prospective effect will not avail the
plaintiff.
113.3 Finally, if the plaint is filed violating Section 12-A after the
jurisdictional High Court has declared Section 12-A mandatory also, the
plaintiff will not be entitled to the relief.'
14.
The judgment in case of Patil Automation (supra) was
pronounced on 17.08.2022 wherein the Apex Court has issued certain
directions by which the controversy has been settled.
Before answering
question No. (iii), it would be appropriate to mention the chronology of events
of the present case :
(i) The civil suit was filed by the plaintiffs/respondents on 26.03.2021.
(ii) In the civil suit, application under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC was filed by
the defendants/respondents on 21.12.2021.
(iii) Reply to the application under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC was filed on
15.03.2022.
(iv) The order impugned rejecting the application under Order 7 Rule 11
was passed by the trial Court on 01.07.2022.
15.
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:30:30
It is pertinent to mention here that the Coordinate Bench of this
Court, while deciding similar issue regarding Section 12-A of Act of 2015 in
case of Curewin Pharmaceuticals Pvt. Ltd. vs. Curewin Hylico Pharma
Pvt. Ltd., in M.A.No. 1269/2021 dated 01.07.2021 has held as under :
''11). The provision is clear and unambiguous, which shows that a suit
which does not contemplate any urgent interim relief under this Act
cannot be instituted unless the plaintiff exhausts the remedy of preinstitution mediation.''
16.
This Court by way of judgment in case of Curewin
Pharmaceuticals (supra) has held that pre-institution mediation under Section
12-A is mandatory before filing of a commercial suit. However, the Apex Court
in case of Patil Automation (supra) has held that declaration by which
Section 12-A has been made mandatory before filing any commercial suit shall
be brought into effect from 20.08.2022.
17. In the present case, the suit was filed on 26.03.2021 and by applying
the guidelines in case of Curewin Pharmaceuticals (supra), admittedly, there
was no pre-institution mediation and settlement as required under Section 12-A
of the Act of 2015. However, the suit filed by the plaintiffs/respondent could
not have been rejected by filing application under Order 7 Rule 11 as Section
12-A of the Act of 2015 has been made mandatory by the Apex Court in case
of Patil Automation (supra) w.e.f. 20.08.2022. Therefore, this Court is of the
view that the suit cannot be rejected for non-compliance of Section 12-A as the
same was filed on 26.03.2021 that is prior to 20.08.2022.
18.
In view of the aforesaid, we do not find any error in the impugned
order passed by the trial Court and hence, this petition being bereft of merit and
substance, is hereby dismissed.
No order as to cost.
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:30:30
(S. A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
vidya
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:30:30
(DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review