Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
AS. NO: 416 OF 2025
Appeal filed under Section 96 R/w Order XLI Rule 1 & 2 o'f C.P C., aggrieved
by the order dated 14th July.2025 made in IA No 772 of 2022 in O S.No 1064 of
2022 on the file of the lll Addl. District Judge, Rangareddy at L.B.Nagar, Hyderabad.
Between:
Purvam Satyanarayana, S/o Late Pentaiah, Aged about 73 Years, OccRetired Employee And agriculture, R/o H.No 17-2-553, Kurmanguda,
Saidabad Hyderabad Telangana - 500 059
APPELLANT/RespondenUPlai ntiff
AND
1. Nandyala Rama Krishna Reddy, S/o. late Yella Reddy, aged about 63 years,
Occ- Real Estate Business, R/o. H.No.6-7-524, Ravindranagar colony,
Nalgonda Town and District- 508001.
2. lVlekala Ram Reddy, S/o. iate Lachi Reddy, aged about 64 years, Occ-
Business, R/o. H.No.2-155, Hanma Sai Nagar, Uppal, Ranga Reddy District,
Hyderabad-500039
3. Pannala Ram Reddy, Sio, late Bal Reddy, aged about 66 years, Occ- agril.,
R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga
Reddy District- 501 5 'l 0
4. Pannala Dhanpal Reddy, S/o. Ram Reddy, aged about 46 years, Occ- agril.,
R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga
Reddy District 50.1 510.
5. Pannala Sathi Reddy, Sio. late Bal Reddy, aged about 65 years, Occ- agril.,
R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga
Reddy Districr 501510.
6. Pannala Madhusudhan Reddy, S/o. Sathi Reddy, aged about 41 years. Occ-
agril., R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamlal village, Abdullapurmet lvlandal,
Ranga Reddy District- 50.'1510.
.
7. Pannala Surender Reddy, S/o. Sathi Reddy, aged about 34 years, Occ- agril.,
R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet lvlandal, Ranga
Reddy District- 501 510.
' .,,
,/
/
8. Pannala Narasirnha Reddy, S/o late Bal Reddy, aged about 64 years, Occ-
agril.. R/o. Ragarrnaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet ftilandal,
Ranga Reddy Districl 50 1 51 0
9. Pannala lvlalla Reddy, S/o. Narsimha Reddy, aged about 33 years, Occ7
aqril.. R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal,
Ranga Reddy District- 501510.
10. Pannala Srikanth Reddy. S/o Narsimha Reddy, aged about 32 years, Occagril.. R/o. Ragarrnaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal vrllage. Abdullapurmet lvlandal,
Ranoa Reddy District- 501 51 0
11. Pannala Venkat Reddy, S/o. Late Linga Reddy. aged about 84 years, Occ-
agril., R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamlal village, Abdullapurmet lr4andal,
Ranga Reddy Districl 501510.
l2.Pannala Gunna Reddy. S/o. Venkat Reddy, aged about 54 years, Occ- agril.,
R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet lt/andal, Ranga
Reddy District- 501510
13. Pannala Padma, Wo. late Linga Reddy, aged about 54 years, Occhousewife, R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet
ltilandal, Ranga Reddy District- 501510.
14. Pannala Narsimha Reddy, S/o. Late Pochi Reddy. aged about 64 years, Occagrii., Rio. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village. Abdullapurmet ftilandal,
Ranga Reddy District- 501 5.1 0
15. Pannala Balakrishna Reddy, S/o. Narsimha Reddy, aged about 35 years,
Occ- agril., R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamlal village, Abdullapurmet
Mandal, Ranga Reddy District- 501510.
16. Pannala Yadi Reddy, S/o. late Pochi Reddy, aged about 60 years, Occ- agril.,
R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yam.jal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga
Reddy District- 501 510.
lT.Painala Bheem Reddy, S/o. late Pochi Reddy, aged about 46 years, Occagril., R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal,
Ranga Reddy Distrrct- 501 51 0
lS.Alimineti Malla Reddy, S/o. late Veera Reddy, aged about 64 years, Occagril., R/o. Brahmanapally village, Abdullapurmet lrlandal, Ranga Reddy
District. 501510.
19. S. Tulasi Das, S/o. late Thavitiah, aged about 70 years, Occ- Advocate, R/o.
36/2RT, Block-6, LIGH, MCH colony, Old Malakpet, Hyderabad - 500036.
20. K. Srinivas Rao, S/o. Raghava Rao, aged aboulT2 years, R/o. Thurka Yamjal
village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga Reddy District - 501 510.
2'1 . K. Tirumal Rao, S/o. Raghava Rao, aged about 70 years, R/o. Thurka Yamjal
village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga Reddy District - 501510.
22.K. Ramachandra Rao, S/o. Raghava Rao, aged about 68 years, R/o. Thurka
Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga Reddy District - 50 j 51 0.
23. K ,Gopai.Rao, S/o. Raghava Rao aged about 64 years, R/o. Thurka yamjal
village, Abdullapurmet lr/andal, Ranga Reddy Distlict 501510.
24 Purvam Brahmanand, S/o. late Yadaiah, aged about 50 years, Occ- Business,
Rio. H.No.17-2-556, Saidabad, Hyderabad-500059.
25. Purvam Suri, S/o. late Yadaiah, aged about 45 years, Occ- Business, R/o.
H No 17'2-555, Saidabad, Hyderabad-500059
26. Purvam Vijay, S/o. late Yadaiah, aged about 42 years, Occ- Business, R/o.
H.No.17 2-556, Saidabad, Hyderabad-500059.
27. The Tahasildar -Cum- Joint Sub- Registrar, Abdullapurmet Tahasil, Ranga
Reddy District, At- Abdullapurmet Village and lvlandal, Ranga Reddy District.
Pin Code 501505
28. The District Collector, Ranga Reddy District. At. Lakidikapool, Hyderabad -
500 004
(Respondents 2lo 28 are not necessary parties)
RESPONDENTS
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the orders passed in in lA No 772 of 2022 in OS No '1 064 of 2022 on
the file of lhe lll Additional District Judge, Rangareddy at L.B. Nagar pending
disposal of the present Appeal
Counsel for the Appellant : SRl. R SUSHANTH REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 : SRI P VENKAT REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 to 28 :
NOT NECESSARY PARTIES
The Court delivered the following: JUDGMENT
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
AS.NO.416 ()F 2025
DATE:.2O.OL.2026
Between:
Purvam Satyaneirayana
S/o. Late Pentaiah
Appeliant
And
Na:'rdyala Rama Krishna Reddy,
S/o. latc Yella Reddy end 27 others.
...llespondents
Mr. R. Sushanth Rcdrll,, ie.lrned counsel appe:uing for the appellant.
Mr. P. VenkaL Reddy, learned counsel appearing lor the .espondent No. t
JUDGMENT: (Per Hon'ble Justice Moushumi Bhattacharya)
1.
The appellant/plaintiff has filed the Appeal Suit against an order
c)ated 14.O7.2O25 passed by the learned III Additional District Judge,
Ranga Reddy District, L.B. Nagar, in 1.A.No.772 of 2022 in O.S,No. 1064
of 2022, hled by the respondent No. l/defendant No. 1 in the plaintiffs
Su it.
2.
The plaintiff filed the Suit in O.S.No.1064 of 2022 for declaration of
os,nership. perpetual injunction and mandatory injunction and lor a
declaration that the registered General Power of Attorney bearing
document No.45/2O06 dated 01.O6.2O06, registered Sale Deed bearing
document No.4938/2008 dated 25. 11.2008 and registered Sale Deed
bearing document No.2528312015 dated 09.12.2015 are sham, null and
void and not binding on the plair-rtiff, along with rectilication of revenue
records and rectilication of boundaries.
3.
The respondent No.l/defendant No. 1 filcd t.A.No.772 of 2022 in
O.S.No. 1O64 of 2022 for rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11(a)
and 11(d) of The Code of Civil Procedure, i9O8 ('CPC) on the grounds
that the plaint did not disclose a cause of action and was barred by the
law of limitation.
4.
By the impugned order dated 14.07.2025, the Tria-l Court allowed
I.A.No.772 of 2022 i.e., the application for rejection of the plaint filed in
the plaintiffs Suit.
5.
The plaintiff is the appellant before this Court. The respondent
No. 1/defendant No.
6.
I is the sole contesting respondent before this Court.
By the impugned order, the Trial Court accepted the contention of
the respondent No.l/defendant No. 1 that the earlier Suit filed by the
respondent No. 1 in 2O16 (O.S.No.23l of 20761 gave a cause of action to
t
lhe plaintiff to h1e a Suit for declaration while the other reliefs sought for
in O.S.No. 1064 of 2022 were barred by limitation.
.
Learned counsel appearing for the atppellant/ plaintiff submits that
paragraph 27 ol tine plaint clearly states that the cause of action for filing
the Suit arose in May, 2022, when the defendant No. I trespassed into
the Suit schedule property and illegally erected temporary concrete
plates in the south-w-est corner therein. Counsel further submits that the
rcspondent No.3, along lr'ith other respondents, sold the Suit schedule
land to the brothcr of the appeliant through a registered Sale Deed dated
08.07.1980. Subsequently, the brother of the appellant executed a
registered Gilt Deed dated 24.07.1987, transferring the Suit schedule
land in favour of the appellant.
8.
The Revenue Authorities, after conducting a de nouo enquiry,
issued an ORC (Occupancy Rights Certiiicate) in favour of the
appellant/ plaintiff on 08.04.1996 and mutated his name as pattedar.
Accordingly, the plaintiffs name was recorded as the pattedar and
possessor in the revenue records from 1995- 1996 onwards.
9.
Counsel submits that the respondent No.3 alienated the land
bearing Sy.No.272 admeasuring Ac.O1.0O gts., in Thurka Yamjal Village,
by executing a General Porver of Attorney dated O1.06.2006 followed by a
registered SaIe Deed dated 25.1 1.2008 in favour of the respondent No.2.
It is also submitted that the respondent No.2 filed a Suit O.S.No.603 of
2015, which was later dismissed as not pressed on 02.O3.2016 after the
respondent No.2 having admitted that the appellant is the owner and
possessor of the Suit schedule land as reflected in paragraph 8 of
1.A.No.510 of 2015 filed therein. While the said Suit was pending, the
respondent No.2 sold the land in favour of the respondent No. I through
registered Sale Deed dated 09.12.2015.
10. Counsel further submits that the re spondent No. 1 is seeking to
take advantage of the order granting temporary injunction passed by the
High Court ol 02.O6.2O2L in CMA No.421 of 2O2O allowing I.A.No.503 of
2O19 in O.S.No.231 of 2016, while suppressing material facts in respect
of (he Suit scheduie property. Counsel urges that the Trial Court in the
impugned order dated 1,4.07 .2025 failed to appreciate the scope of
enquiry under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC and took into account the
contentions of the respondent No. 1 in the written statement instead of
limiting its consideration only to the averments in the plaint and lhe
documents filed therewith.
11. Learned counsel appearing for the respondent No. 1 (the petitioner
in I.A.No.772 of 2022 in O.S.No. 1064 of 2022 hled under Order VII Rule
11 of the CPC) submits that the averments in the plaint in O.S.No.1064
\\
of 2022 establish the knowledge of the appellant/plaintiff about the
existence of several registered documents sought to be cancelled in the
said Suit. in 2016 itself when the respondent No.1 had Iiled O.S.No.231
oi 2O ltr
12. Counsel relies on the paragraph Nos. 10, 15 and 16 in the plaint to
show that the plaintiff had knowledge of the pendency of the earlier Suit
trled Lry thc respondent No. I (O.S.No.23l of 201.6) seeking declaration ol
tile u,hile referring to the documents sought to be cancelled in that Suit.
Counsel rclie s on section 3 ol The Transfer of Property Act, 1882, on the
point of 'constructive notice'of the said documents and Article 58 of the
schedulc to 'fhc Lrmitation Act, 1963, to emphasize that the Suit is
barred by limitation on account of passage of three years from the date of
knowledge of existence of the documents.
13. Thc question which arises before us is whether the Trial Court was
correct in allowing the respondent/defendant No.1's Interlocutory
Applicatron for rejection of plaint on the ground that the plaint rvas iiable
to be relected under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC as the claim therein
rvas barrcd by the law of limitation ald the plaintiff did not have a cause
of action to lrle the Suit (O.S.No. 1064 of 20221.
14. It is elementary that for considering a question with respect to the
rejection ol a plarnt, the Court is only required to consider the averments
made in the plaint. Hence, the statements made in the plaint are
nccessary to decide as to whether the plaintiff had a cause ol aclion to
file the Suit and whether the plaint was barred by the law of limitation.
Order VII Rule I I of the CPC provides that a .plaint shall be rejectcd in
the six cases set out under the said Rule including rvhere the plaint does
not disclose a cause of action [Sub-rule (a)] and wherc the Suit appears
from the statement in the plaint to bc barred by any law [Sub-rule (d)1.
These were also the grounds taken by the respondent No. 1 to seek
rejection of the plaint filed by the appellant in O.S.No.1064 ol 2022.
15. The prayer in the plaint seeks reliefs, inter aLia, for Declaration that
the plaintiff is the absolute owner, pattedar and possessor ol the Suit
Schedule Lands and for Rectihcation of the Registered Sale Deed dated
08.07.1980 and the Registered Gift Settlement Deed dated 24.O7 .1987
.
The plaintift has also sought for Declaration that the Registered Gencral
Power of Attorney dated O1.06.2006 and the Registered Sa-le Deeds daled
25. 1 1.2008 and O9.12.2O 15 are null and uoid and not binding on the
plaintiff. The prayer in the plaint is relevant sincc Article 58 of the
Schedule to The Limitation Act, 1963, stipulates a limitation period of
thrce years from the time when the right to sue first accrues for
obtaining ary other Declaration. The limitation period of thrce years
I
from accrual of the plaintiffs right to sue would precipitate a cioser look
at the specihc stalements made in the plaint itself.
16. Paragraph 10 of the plaint states that the defendant No. 1 lited in
the earlier Suit in 2016 (O.S.No.231 of 2016) in respect of the land in
Sy.No.272 admeasuring Ac.01.00 gts., for Declaration and Perpetual
lnjunction. Pral,er (a) of the plaint reflects that the plaintiff sought
Declaration of Title in the present Suit of 2022 io respect of land in the
same survev number i.e., Sy.No.272 of Thurka Yamjal Village,
Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga Reddy District. From the averments
made in paragraph iO, it is clear that the plaintiff was very much aware
of the Suit hled by the respondent No. 1 in 2016 since the plaintiff was
the defendant therein.
.
Parergraphs I 5 and i 6 of the plaint reiterate the fact of the
defendant No.l's Suit including an IA having been filed therein for
interim injunction against the plaintiff. The averments made in the
plaint in respect ol the Suit filed by the defendant No. 1 in 2016 in
respect of the land situated in the same survey number makes it evident
that the plaintiff had knowledge of the dispute since 2016 itself which in
turn required the pLaintiff to obtain a Declaration in respect of the Suit
Schedule Lald, il the plaintiff was so advised, within three years of such
knowledge. This meals that the plaintiff should have filed the Suit for
i
B
Declaration within three years of 2OL6 i.e., within 2019 as stipulated
under Article 58 of the Schedule to The Limitation Act, 1963. The
plaintiff however filed the Suit in 2022.
18. Article 59 of the Schedule to The Limitation Act, 1963, rvould also
be relevant in the present facts since Article 59 pertaining to a Suit for
the cancellation or setting aside of an Instrument or Decree or for the
rescission of a Contract, stipulates a limitation period of threc years from
the date of knowledge of the facts which would entitle thc plaintiff to
have the Instrument or Decree cancelled or set aside or have the contract
rescinded.
19. As stated above, at least two of the reliefs prayed for in the plaint
in O.S.No. 1O64 ol 2022 seek rectification of registered Sale Deed dated
08.07.1980 and a registered Gift Settlement Deed dated 24.07.1987.
Hence, the plaintiff was under an additional obligation under Article 59
of the Schedule to The Limitation Act, 1963 to seek cancellation of the
registered instruments/Sale Deeds within three years lrom the date of
knowledge of the plaintiff which would be three years from 2O16 (i.e.,
when the plaintiff was made a party defendant to the Suit f-rled by the
respondent No.1 i.e., O.S.No.231 of 2016l. Thus, we are constrained to
hold that the plaint filed in the Suit was liable to be rejected under Order
Vll Rule 1 I (d) of the CPC as being barred by the law of Limitation.
20. The Court also finds substance in the contention of learned
counsel appcaring for the respondent No. 1 that the plaintiff was deemed
to have 'constructive notice' of the registered documents as envisaged
under section 3 of thc Trarsfer of Property Act, 1882 ('1882 Act'), as all
the documcnts of which rectihcation was sought for, are public
documents. The fact that the plaintiff failed to file a Suit for Declaration
within the limitation period as provided for under Article 58 of the
Schedule to The l-imitation Act, 1963 also raises a doubt on the
plaintiffs cause o[ action lor filing the Suit in 2022.
21. Paragraph 35 of the plaint avers that the cause of action for filing
the Suit arose in the first s,eek of May, 2022, when the defendant No.l
illegaliy and unlawfully trespassed and made temporary concrete plates
on the plaintiff's property arrd again on 05.06.2022, when the defendant
No.l tried to trespass and questioned the right and title of the plaintiff
over the Suit Schedule Land and threatened to dispossess the plaintiff
from the Suit Schedule Lard.
22. Paragraph 37 avers that the Suit is filed well within time, since the
defendant No.1 and his men trespassed into the plaintiff's property and
illegaJly erected temporary concrete plates in the hrst week of May,2022.
Paragraphs 35 and 37 however are inconsistent with the averments in
paragraph 10 of the plaint $,here the plaintiff categorically states that
the
defendant No. i filed a Suit in 2016 against the plaintiff for the relief of
Declaration and Perpetual Injunction in respect of land in Sv.No.272.
Paragraph 1O further goes on to state that the defendant No.1 flled the
Suit in 2016 on the basis of having purchaSed the land from thc
defendant No.2 under a registered Sale Deed dated 09.12.2015. In this
context, it is to be noted that prayer (J) of the plaint seeks a Declaration
that the Sale Deed dated 09.12.2015 is nuli artd uoid and not binding on
the plaintifL Hence, it is evident from the averments made in paragraphs
35 and 37 that they are made only to save the limitation period and
introduce a cause of action which is non-eistent and contrary to the
admitted facts in the plaint.
23. The cause of action is further diluted, if not demolished, by the
averments made in paragraph l5 of the plaint where it is stated that the
IA No.503 of 2Ol9 filed by the defendant No.1 in O.S.No.231 of 2O16 was
dismissed by the Trial Court on ll.O2.2O2O. Thereafter, the defendant
No. 1 preferred CMA No.42l of 2020 before the High Court and the CMA
was allowed on 02.06 .2021 . The plaintiff challenged the said order
before the Supreme Court by way of SLP (C) No.11286 of 2O2l which was
dismissed on 16. 12.2021. The aforesaid statements would further
establish that the plaintiff could not succeed up to the Supreme Court
and the order of the High Court allowing the CMA filed by the defendant
No.l on 02.06.2021 was confirmed and remained so till the filing of the
plaintifl"s Suit in 2022. The above paragraphs lead to the inescapable
conclusion that the plaint in O-S.No. 1064 of 2022 failed to establish a
cause of actiorl. The Court is inlormed that the plaintiff is continuing to
contest thc Suit filed by thc defendant No. 1 i.e., O.S.No.231 of 2O16
before the Trial Court.
24. The cases cited on behalf of the appellant/ plaintiff are required to
be placed in context. In Salim D. AgboatutaLa u. Shamalji Oddhauji
Thakkar), the Supreme Coilrt came to a specific finding that the answer
to the issue whether notices were served on the plaintiff/limitation could
only be ascertained at trial. ln P-V.Gttru Raj Reddg u. P.Neeradha Reddg2
reiterated that rejection of a plaint on the ground of limitation must be
carefully adjudicated on the basis of the pleadings in the plaint.
25. The Supreme Court in Central Bank of India u. PrabLn Jain3 held
that there cannot be partial rejection of a plaint under Order VII Rule 11
of the Code, and even if one relief survives, the plaint cannot be rejected
under the said provision. This case is not applicable to the facts of the
present case since the Trial Court rightly found that the plaint failed to
disclose a &use of action and was also barred bv Law. Jageshwarai Deut
\
'1zozr1 rz scc roo
lzors) s scc::r
'(zozs) a scc:a
u. Shatrughnn Rama noted the difference between non-disclosure of a
cause of action and a defective cause of action and held that while the
formcr falls w.ithin rhe scope of Order VII Rule 11 of the Code, the latter
should be decided during trial of the Suit.
26.
On the other hand, Khatri Hotels (P) Ltd. u. Union of Indias clearll
laid dou,n that the Court must ascertain as to when the right to sue {irst
accrue to the appellants before the Supreme Court and also noted clear
drafting of the plaint to convey an impression that the right to sue
accrued to the appellants much later when they learnt about thc wrong
recording of entries in Khasra Revenue records. Whereas, the cause ol
action actually accrued much earlier in 1990.
27. Shi MukundBhauan Tntst u. Shrimant Chhatrapati Udagan Raje
Pratapsinh Majaraj Bhonsle', involved, inter aLia, ascertaining the
limitation period for setting aside the sale deed and the Supreme Court
relied on Article 59 of the Limitation Act which provides for limitation of
three years arrd accordingly held that the plaintiff was barred from
seeking cancellation of the registered sale deed.
il
i
olzoou
ts scc sz
'1zorr1 s scc rze
62024
SCC Online SC 3844
I
28. The Supreme Court in Uma Deui u. Anand KumarT noted the failure
of the plaintiff to address the crucial question of when they became
au'are of the registered sale deeds and specificd the exact date of such
knorvledgc. The Supreme Court accordingly held that the plaintiff was
hence prima focie ltarred by law and the plaintiffs cannot reignite their
rights after sleeping for a considerable period of time. Thus, the
decisions relied upon by the respclndent/ defendant reiterate that the
plaintiff is under a statutory obligation to plead the exact date of
knowledge of the registered instruments of which cancellation is sought.
29. In the presenl: case, the plaint failed to disclose any cause of action
altogether in view ol the respondent having succeeded up to the Supreme
Court and the plaintifl having hled the Suit in 2022 in respect of the land
having .the same su rvey number. Hence, the cases cited on behalf of the
appellant do not come to his rescue.
30. As stated above, the plaintiff sought for rectification of the Sale
Deed dating back to 08.07.1980 and failed to provide any explanation as
t
to rvhy Articles 58 and 59 of 'l'hc Limitation Act, 1963 will not apply to
\
the present case in terms of seeking declaration and rectification as
would be indicatecl in tl-re prayers in the plaint.
/
lzozs) s scc rss
I
I
1,4
31. Thus, we do not find any error in the impugned order by which the
application of the respondent No.1 was allowed and the plaint in
O.S.No. 1064 of 2022 was rejccted. Although a few of the other reasons
given by the Trial Court including the right Lrf the plaintiff to seek
permanent injunction is not relevant to the issue, we hnd the ultimate
conclusion arrived at by the Trial Court to be correct. We agree with the
primary finding that rectification of registered instruments of 1980,
1987, 2OO8 and 20 L5 cannot be sought for in a Suit hled in 2022. We
thus find that the Trial Court correclly decided the IA for rejection of
plaint as the plaintilf did not have a cause of action to file the suiL in
2022 and the Suit was barred by iimitation. We hence l-rnd no merit in
the Appeal Suit.
32. A.S.No.416 of 2025, along with all connected applications, 1S
accordingly dismissed- Therc shall be no ordcr as to costs.
SD/- P. CH. NAGABHUSHAMBA
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
i/TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The lll Additional District &. Sessrons Judge, Ranga Reddy, at L.B. Nagar,
Hyderabad. (With records if any)
2. One CC to SRt. R SUSHANTH REDDy Advocate [OpUC]
3. One CC to SRl. P VENKAT REDDY Advocate tOpUCl
4. Two CD Copies
PSL
\0"
I
HIGH COURT
DATED:2010112026
1 HEbIA
,JK
o
o
,k
).,,
JUDGMENT
AS.No.416 of 2025
DISMISSING THE APPEAL
@
\ \ Dh
[ INN
?$?t
x
*
.4.
I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY. THE TWENTIETH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
AS. NO: 416OF 2025
Between:
Purvam Satyanarayana, S/o Late Pentaiah, Aged about 73 Years, OccRetired Employee And agriculture, R/o H.No 17-2-553, Kurmanguda,
Saidabad Hyderabad Telangana - 500 059
APPELLANT/RespondenUPlaintiff
AND
1, Nandyala Rama Krishna Reddy, S/o. late Yella Reddy, aged about 63 years,
Occ- Real Estate Business, R/o. H.No.6-7-524, Ravindranagar colony,
Nalgonda Town and District- 50800'1.
2, Mekala Ram Reddy, S/o. Iate Lachi Reddy, aged about 64 years, OccBusiness, R/o. H.No.2-'155, Hanma Sai Nagar, Uppal, Ranga Reddy District,
Hyderabad-500039
3. Pannala Ram Reddy, S/o. late Bal Reddy, aged about 66 years, Occ- agril.,
R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga
Reddy District- 501 51 0.
4. Pannala Dhanpal Reddy, S/o. Ram Reddy, aged about 46 years, Occ- agril.,
R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga
Reddy District- 501 510.
5. Pannala Sathi Reddy, S/o. late Bal Reddy, aged about 65 years, Occ- agril.,
R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga
Reddy District- 501 5'l 0.
6. Pannala Madhusudhan Reddy, S/o. Sathi Reddy, aged about 41 years, Occagril., R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal,
Ranga Reddy District- 501510.
7. Pannala Surender Reddy, S/o. Sathi Reddy, aged about 34 years, Occ- agril.,
R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga
Reddy District- 501510
8. Pannala Narasimha Reddy, S/o. late Bal Reddy, aged about 64 years, Occ-
agril., R/o. Ragannaguda H/o Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal,
Ranga Reddy District- 50 '1 51 0
9. Pannala tvlalla Reddy, S/o. Narsimha Reddy, aged about 33 years, Occ-
agril., R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal,
Ranga Reddy District- 501 510.
10. Pannala Srikanth Reddy, S/o. Narsimha Reddy, aged about 32 years, Occ-
agril., R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamlal village, Abdullapurmet [Vlandal,
Ranga Reddy District- 5015'10.
11. Pannala Venkat Reddy. S/o. Late Linga Reddy, aged about 84 years, Occ-
agril., R/o Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet lvlandal,
Ranga Reddy District- 5015'l0.
12.Pannala Gunna Reddy, S/o. Venkat Reddy, aged about 54 years Occ- agril.,
R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet lVlandal, Ranga
Reddy District- 50'1 51 0.
13. Pannala Padma, Wo. late Linga Reddy, aged about 54 years, Occ-
housewife, Rio. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet
Mandal, Ranga Reddy Districl 501510.
14. Pannala Narsimha Reddy, S/o. Late Pochi Reddy, aged about 64 years, Occ-
agrii., R:/o Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet I/andal,
Ranga Reddy District- 501510.
15. Pannala Balakrishna Reddy, S/o. Narsimha Reddy, aged about 35 years,
Occ- agril., R/o Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamlal village, Abdullapurmet
Ivlandal, Ranga Reddy District 50'1510.
16 Pannala Yadi Reddy, S/o. late Pochi Reddy, aged about 60 years, Occ- agril.,
R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet lvlandal, Ranga
Reddy District- 501 510.
17. Pannala Bheem Reddy, S/o. late Pochi Reddy, aged about 46 years, Occ-
agril., R/o. Ragannaguda H/o. Thurka Yam.jal village, Abdullapurmet [vlandal,
Ranga Reddy District- 501510.
18.A|'imineti Malla Reddy, S/o. late Veera Reddy, aged about 64 years, Occagril., R/o. Brahmanapally village, Abdullapurnret Mandal, Ranga Reddy
District- 501510
19. S. Tulasi Das, S/o. late Thavitiah, aged about 70 years, Occ- Advocate, R/o.
36/2RT, Block-6, LIGH, MCFIcolony, Old Malakpet, Hyderabad - 500036
20.K. Srinivas Rao, S/o. Raghava Rao, aged aboul T2 years. R/o. Thurka Yamjal
village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga Reddy District - 501510.
2'1 . K. Tirumal Rao, S/o. Raghava Rao, aged about 70 years, R/o. Thurka Yamjal
village, Abdullapurmel li/andal, Ranga Reddy District, 501510.
22. K. Ramachandra Rao, S/o. Raghava Rao, aged about 68 years, R/o. Thurka
Yamjal village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga Reddy Diskict - 501510,
23.K. Gopal Rao, S/o. Raghava Rao, aged about 64 years, R/o. Thurka Yamjal
village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga Reddy District - 5015'10.
24.Purvam Brahmanand, S/o. late Yadaiah, aged about 50 years, Occ- Business,
R/o. H No.17-2-556, Saidabad, Hyderabad-500059.
25. Purvam Suri, S/o. late Yadaiah, aged about 45 years, Occ_ Business, R/o.
H.No.'17-2-556, Saidabad, Hyderabad-S00059
.
I
/
26. Purvam Vijay, S/o. late Yadaiah, aged about 42 years, Occ- Business, R/o.
H.No.17-2-556, Saidabad, Hyderabad-500059.
27. The Tahasildar -Cum- Joint Sub Registrar, Abdullapurmet Tahasil, Ranga
Reddy District, At- Abdullapurmet Village and lt/landal, Ranga Reddy District
Pin Code - 501505.
28. The District Collector, Ranga Reddy District. At. Lakidikapool, Hyderabad 500 004
(Respondents 2 to 28 are not necessary parties)
RESPONDENTS
Appeal filed under Section 96 R/w Order XLI Rule 1 & 2 of C.P.C., aggrieved
by the order dated 14th July, 2025 made in I A.No 772 of 2022 in O.S.No 1064 of
2022 on the file of the lll Addl District Judge, Rangareddy at L.B.Nagar, Hyderabad
ORDER: This appeal coming on tbr hcaring ancl upon perusing the grounds ofappeal,
the Judgrnent and Decree ofthe Lower ('ourt and thc material papers in the Petition and upon
hearing the argument of Sri R, Sushanth Rcddy. r\dvocate firr thc appcllant and of Sri P.
Venkat Reddy, Advocate for the Respontlcnt.
'l hat this Cour-t doth Ordel and l)cclcs as Iirllorvs:
l. That this appeal is be and hcrebl' drsruisscd
2. That there shalI be no ordcr as to costs.
SD/. P. CH. NAGABHUSHAMBA
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
,TRUE COPY/i
G
SECTION OFFICER
.lir
l. 'lhe lll Additional District & Scssions Judge. Rangarcddy District. L.B. Nagar,
I lyderabad.
2. Two CD Copics.
HIGH COURT
DATED:2010112026
DECREE
AS.No.416 ot 2025
DISMISSIN(; -f I{E APPIiAL
o
I
&s l,
lu
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review