Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT APPEAL No.1213 of 2026
(CNR.No: HBHC010758122026)
DATE: 13.11.2026
Reserved on:
04.11.2026
Pronounced on :
13.11.2026
Uploaded on
13.11.2026
:
Between:
…Appellant
Talasani Sravan Reddy
AND
The Union of India, Ministry of Roads,
Rep. by its Regional Officer, Transport and Highways,
Regional Office, R & B Building Complex, Erra Manzil,
Hyderabad and others
…Respondents
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble Sri Justice Suddala Chalapathi
Rao)
Heard Sri Vedula Venkata Ramana, learned Senior Counsel
representing M/s. Bharadwaj Associates, for appellant, Ms.
T.Suhasini, learned counsel for respondent No.1, Mr.P.Harinath
Gupta,
learned counsel
for respondent
Nos.2 and
and
Mr.E.Ramesh Chandra Goud, learned Government Pleader for
Land Acquisition appearing for respondent No.4.
2.
The present intra Court appeal is filed by the Writ
Petitioner
assailing
the
order
passed
by
this
Court
in
W.P.No.11752 of 2023, dated 26.10.2026, whereby the learned
Single Judge, after considering the rival submissions and the
material available on record, dismissed the writ petition holding
that the award dated 20.09.2023 and the notification issued
under Section 3D of the National Highways Act, 1956,
concluded the land acquisition proceedings and that the
appellant/writ petitioner is at liberty to pursue his remedy in
accordance with law.
3.
For better appreciation of the matter, the relief sought in
the underlying Writ Petition is extracted hereunder:“…to issue a Writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate
writ declaring that the action of the 4th respondent
contained in file No.E/268/2022 (Endorsement) dated
Nil/10/2022 in not deciding the objections of the petitioner
dated 17.10.2022 and only redirecting to the petitioner to
other officers for the information, particularly in not deciding
the objections that the Kalvakurthy byepass road as per the
final DPR Map commences from channel 76/400 and not
CH 76/100 and hence acquisition of the land of the
petitioner admeasuring one acre in Sy.No.509 of Kotra
village, Mandal, is totally unnecessary and unwanted and
hence the final notification issued under section 3D of the
Act by including the land of the petitioner in Sy.No.509 of
Kotrasivar village for the purpose of laying of Kalvakurthy
byepass road on NH No.167K is arbitrary, illegal and
unjustified and set aside the final notification issued under
section 3D of the act to the extent it includes the land of the
petitioner in Sy.No.509 of Kotra Village, Veldanda Mandal,
Nagarkurnool district is arbitrary and illegal and
consequently direct the Respondents to delete the
acquisition of the land of the petitioner in Sy.No.509,
Kotrasivar Village, Veldanda Mandal, Nagarkurnool District,
for the purpose of Kalvakurthy byepass road formation on
NH No.167K and direct the respondents not to interfere with
the possession and enjoyment of the Petitioner and his
family members over the land admeasuring one acre in
Sy.No.509, Kotrasivar Village, Veldanda Mandal, Nagar
kurnool District and grant such other order or orders that
are deemed fit and proper in the circumstances of the case
and in the interests of justice…”
4.
The brief facts of the case are that the appellant's name
was recorded as owner and pattadar along with his family
members in respect of converted agricultural land admeasuring
Ac.1-00 guntas in Survey No.509 of Kotrasivar Village, Veldanda
Mandal, Nagarkurnool District (hereinafter referred to as the
"subject
land").
Earlier,
the
appellant's
father
filed
W.P.No.27864 of 2022 before this Court questioning the action
of the respondents therein in attempting to take possession of
the subject land of the petitioner and his family members
situated in Sy.No.509/EE-E/2 of Kotrasivar, Veldanda Mandal,
Nagarkurnool District. This Court, by order dated 14.07.2022,
disposed of the writ petition directing the respondents not to
dispossess the petitioner therein without following due process
of law and granting liberty to the respondents to initiate
acquisition proceedings strictly in accordance with law.
5.
The
petitioner
further
contended
that
the
Revenue
Divisional Officer, respondent No.4 in the underlying Writ
Petition issued notice dated 07.10.2022, referring to the Gazette
Notification issued under Section 3A of the Act, dated
10.07.2022, informing the petitioner about the hearing of
objections scheduled on 17.10.2022. The petitioner attended
the hearing on the said date and submitted his objections,
contending that as per the final map, the Kalwakurthy Bypass
starts from CH 76/400, whereas, as per the plan, it commences
from CH 76/100. The contention of the petitioner is that if the
Bypass Road starts from CH 76/400, his land would not be
required for the Kalwakurthy Bypass on NH No.167K and,
requested respondent No.4 to furnish the relevant plans
explaining as to how the Bypass Road was being commenced
from CH 76/100, when the final map disclosed that it starts
from CH 76/400. However, respondent No.4, who was obligated
to pass orders in terms of Section 3C(3) of the Act, on the
objections raised by the petitioner and communicate the same
to him, had instead issued the impugned endorsement in File
No.E/268/2022, dated Nil/10/2022, and did not deal with any
of the objections. While the petitioner was awaiting a speaking
order, respondent No.4 proceeded to issue a notification under
Section 3D of the Act, which was published in Namasthe
Telangana Newspaper on 13.04.2023, which is contended illegal
and hence the Writ Petition.
6.
When the Writ Petition was initially taken up for
admission, an interim order dated 26.04.2023 was passed by
the learned
Single
Judge, observing
that the
impugned
endorsement was bereft of reasons and did not answer the
objections raised by the petitioner, and granted interim
direction as prayed for. Subsequently, the said order was
vacated vide order dated 09.04.2026.
7.
Thereafter, the petitioner carried the matter in W.A.No.474
of 2026. A Division Bench of this Court, by order dated
24.04.2026,
disposed
of
the
Writ
Appeal
granting
an
opportunity to the appellant to file an application seeking
modification or recall of the interim order and further directed
the parties to maintain status quo till 29.04.2026. Pursuant to
the directions of the Division Bench, the petitioner filed I.A.No.1
of 2026 seeking to recall/set aside the order dated 09.04.2026
passed in I.A.No.1 of 2024 in W.P.No.11752 of 2023 (underlying
Writ Petition) and the same was heard by the learned Single
Judge of this Court.
8.
In the underlying Writ Petition, respondent No.4, being the
official respondent, filed a counter affidavit contending that the
Government of India had sanctioned the subject road work vide
Gazette S.O.4022(E), dated 06.11.2021, and as per the
approved alignment, the newly proposed NH No.167K of
Kalvakurthy-Karivena road connects various villages, including
Kotra, Kalwakurthy, Kurmidda, Tharnikal, Suddakal, Medipur,
Tadoor, Desitkyal, Peddamudunur, Peddakothapally, Kalwakol,
Waridyal, Chotabela, Nagarkurnool, Kollapur and Rampur in
the State of Telangana, and extends up to Mandugula
Sivapuram Karivena, terminating at its junction with NH-40
near Nandyal.
9.
Respondent No.4 further contended that the Detailed
Project
Report
(for
short,
“DPR”)
was
approved
and
communicated for widening the road to two lanes with paved
shoulders from KM 0/000 to KM 79/300 of KalwakurthyKollapur Section of NH No.167K in the State of Telangana under
Annual Plan 2021-22 on EPC mode, for an amount of Rs.886.69
Crores and for a length of 79.30 Kms, vide proceedings bearing
Lr.No.RW/HYD/NH167K/Kalwakurthy/I/4012140/2022, dated
31.03.2022, which includes Vehicle Under Pass (VUP), side
drains, footpaths, central median and central lighting, within
the R&B Right of Way of 100 feet (i.e., 50 feet on both sides)
from Kalwakurthy to Kollapur on NH No.167K.
10.
It is further contended that since out of the total length of
79.300 Kms, land acquisition is required for a length of 26.467
Kms, to an extent of 146.87 hectares, beyond the existing Right
of Way of the National Highway, for curve improvements,
realignment, bypasses and toll plaza, the Executive Engineer,
National
Highways,
Kalwakurthy,
vide
letter
No.EE
(R&B/NH/KKTY (NH-167K) 3A/2022, dated 29.03.2023, sent
the requisition proposal for acquisition of the subject land. The
Government of India published the Gazette Notification under
Section 3A of the Act, dated 10.03.2022, authorising the
Revenue
Divisional
Officer,
Kalwakurthy
Division,
i.e.,
respondent No.4 herein, as the Competent Authority for Land
Acquisition (CALA) in the stretch from Km.0+0 to Km.20+450 of
Kalwakurthy-Kollapur Section of NH No.167K. Accordingly,
a
preliminary notification under Section 3A of the Act was issued
vide Gazette of India dated 01.09.2022 for acquisition of land to
an extent of 47.9627 hectares. The said notification was
published in Namasthe Telangana and the Hindu newspapers
on 21.09.2022. It is further submitted that, out of about 615
land losers covered by the notification, the petitioner alone filed
objections
on
23.09.2022.
In
pursuance
thereof,
the
CALA/Revenue Divisional Officer, Kalwakurthy (Respondent
No.4) issued notice to the petitioner for personal hearing on
17.10.2022, on which date the petitioner also raised certain
further objections, after the stipulated period of 21 days.
Thereafter,
respondent
communicated
the
No.4
same
clarified
through
the
objections
endorsements
and
dated
21.10.2022 and 05.12.2022.
11.
It is further submitted that the Section 3A notification
contains the details of the survey numbers, extent and nature of
the land, and as per the approved Section 3D Gazette
Notification of India dated 09.03.2023, the petitioner's land to
an extent of 2529.2 square metres was notified as nonagricultural land. It is also contended that the information
regarding the alignment/survey of the Kalwakurthy Bypass of
NH No.167K was furnished to the petitioner through the RTI
reply
vide
Lr.No.DEE/NH/KKY/RTI/21/2022,
dated
12.08.2022, and that the finalisation of the alignment was
based on technical feasibility.
12.
It is further submitted that the DPR consultant had
furnished three options of alignment and the Ministry of Road
Transport and Highways, Government of India, approved the
third alignment option, which provides for the Bypass Road to
start diverting gradually from CH 76/100 and completely
separate from the existing Hyderabad-Srisailam Road of NH
No.765 at CH 76/400n. The same was communicated to the
petitioner through the RTI reply dated 12.08.2022, along with
the approved alignment, and accordingly, the objections raised
by the petitioner were considered and orders were passed on
20.10.2022 and 05.12.2022, elaborately dealing with the
objections raised by the petitioner. It is stated that when the
said orders were sought to be served on the petitioner, he did
not accept the same. Therefore, the endorsements were served
through an alternative mode on 12.12.2022, after conducting a
panchanama.
13.
Respondent No.2 also filed a counter contending that, in
terms of Section 3D(2) of the Act, once a declaration under subsection (1) is published, the land shall vest absolutely in the
Central Government, free from all encumbrances, and in terms
of Section 3D(4) of the Act, a declaration made by the Central
Government under sub-section (1) shall not be called in
question in any Court or by any authority.
14.
It is further contended by the respondents that, the Bypass
Road work is in progress and despite 95% completion of the
work and expending huge amounts, the road is not being put to
use by the public at large due to non-availability of the 200
metres stretch. Therefore, the respondents prayed for dismissal
of the Writ Petition.
15.
The learned Single Judge of this Court, after considering
the submissions made by the learned Senior Counsel Sri Vedula
Venkata Ramana, appearing for the writ petitioner, and the
learned Government Pleader appearing for the respondents,
elaborately considered the manner, observing that the objections
raised by the petitioner were received and duly addressed by
respondent No.4 vide endorsement in File No.E/268/2022,
dated Nil.10.2022. The subsequent objections raised by the
petitioner
were
also
considered
vide
endorsement
dated
Nil.10.2022 and another endorsement dated 05.12.2022, apart
from the initial endorsement dated 21.10.2022. Thus, the
objections raised by the petitioner were specifically considered
and answered by respondent No.4.
16.
Thereafter, the learned Single Judge, by placing reliance
on the judgment of the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in
National Highways Authority of India v. G.Narsing Rao &
others1 and extracting the relevant portions thereof, held that
the award dated 20.09.2023 and the notification issued under
Section 3D of the Act had concluded the land acquisition
proceedings and the objections raised by the petitioner had
been duly considered and rejected, as such the petitioner had
not made out any ground warranting interference by this Court.
Accordingly, leaving it open to the petitioner to pursue the
2022 (3) ALT 707 (DB)
remedies available to him under law, the learned Single Judge
dismissed the Writ Petition. Aggrieved by the same, the present
intra-Court Appeal has been filed.
17.
Sri Vedula Venkata Ramana, learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the Writ Appellant/Writ Petitioner, would contend
that, as per the final map, the alignment of the Bypass Road
starts from CH 76/400, whereas, as per the plan, the road
commences from CH 76/100, and if the Bypass Road were to
start from CH 76/400, the petitioner's land would not be
affected at all. However, by adopting a different alignment, the
respondents have proceeded with the road from CH 76/100,
contrary to the final map, despite the specific objections raised
by the petitioner.
18.
Learned Senior Counsel would also emphasize that, once
the final alignment was shown in the acquisition proceedings as
commencing from CH 76/400, the respondents could not
deviate from the said alignment and proceed with the road from
CH 76/100, thereby affecting the rights of the petitioner. It is
therefore contended that the objections raised by the petitioner
were not properly considered and had mechanically rejected the
same, without assigning proper reasons.
19.
It is further contended that, even though the final
notification under Section 3D of the Act has been issued, as the
respondents have deviated from the original final alignment ,this
Court has jurisdiction to examine the matter under judicial
review
and
set aside
the
award
and
the
consequential
proceedings. Learned Senior Counsel would further submit that
the learned Single Judge has not examined the issue in its
proper perspective and that the reasoning and findings recorded
by the learned Single Judge are liable to be set aside.
20. Per contra, learned Government Pleader appearing for the
respondent-State would contend that the learned Single Judge
has specifically considered and answered all the contentions
raised by the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Writ
Appellant/Writ Petitioner. It is submitted that the objections
raised by the petitioner were duly considered and answered
through the endorsements dated Nil/10/2022, 21.10.2022 and
05.12.2022. Therefore, it is contended that, once the objections
have been considered and rejected by the competent authority,
the petitioner cannot raise the same contentions again.
21.
Learned Government Pleader would further contend that,
once a notification under Section 3D of the National Highways
Act, 1956, is issued, the land specified in the schedule to the
said notification vests absolutely in the Central Government,
free from all encumbrances.
22.
Learned Government Pleader would also place reliance on
the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Union of India
Vs Kushala Shetty and others2, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme
Court has held that Courts are not at all equipped to decide
upon the viability and feasibility of the particular project and
whether the particular alignment would subserve the larger
public interest. In such matters, the scope of judicial review is
very limited. The Court can nullify the acquisition of land, in the
2011 SCC OnLine SC 370
rarest of rare cases, if a particular project, is found to be ex facie
contrary to the mandate of law or tainted due to mala fides.
23.
Learned Government Pleader, drawing clue from the
aforesaid judgment, would submit that in the present case, the
alignment was determined by the experts and that the petitioner
has not attributed any mala fides to the respondents. The only
grievance raised by the petitioner is with regard to the alleged
change in the alignment from CH 76/400 to CH 76/100. It is
contended that the objections raised by the petitioner in this
regard were considered and rejected by the competent authority.
Therefore, in view of the notification already issued under
Section 3D of the Act and the law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Kushala Shetty (supra), no interference by
this Court is warranted in a well considered and well reasoned
order passed by the learner Single Judge.
24.
Having heard
Sri
Vedula
Venkata
Ramana,
learned
Senior Counsel for appellant, Ms.T.Suhasini, Mr.P.Harinath
Gupta, and Mr.E.Ramesh Chandra Goud, learned counsel
appearing for respective respondents and having given earnest
consideration to the submissions advanced by the respective
counsel, perused the record.
25.
The grievance of the appellant is twofold; firstly, the
objections reused by the petitioner were not duly considered and
secondly, the respondent proceeded with the alignment contrary
to the final map.
26.
As regards the first issue, it is evident that the objections
raised by the petitioner were duly considered and rejected by
respondent No.4, who is the competent authority, through the
endorsement in File No.E/268/2022, dated 21.10.2022, and the
subsequent endorsement dated Nil/10/2022. It is also evident
that certain further objections were raised by the petitioner,
which were also considered by the competent authority.
Therefore, the contention that the objections raised by the
petitioner were not considered cannot be accepted.
27.
Insofar as the second limb of the grievance of the writ
petitioner is concerned, though as per the final map, the
alignment of the road was shown as commencing from CH
76/400, the respondents have proceeded with the alignment
commencing
from
CH
76/100,
and
had
the
alignment
commenced from CH 76/400, his land would not have been
affected, and that the objections raised by him in this regard
were not properly considered by respondent No.4. It is pertinent
to note that respondent No.4, in the counter affidavit, has
specifically
explained
that
three
alignment
options
were
prepared and placed before the Ministry of Road Transport and
Highways, Government of India, and the Ministry approved the
third alignment option, under which the road commences from
CH 76/100, the alignment commencing from CH 76/100 was
proceeded with, and accordingly, the objections raised by the
petitioner were considered and rejected by the competent
authority. Thereafter, the notification under Section 3D(1) of the
National Highways Act, 1956, was issued, and by virtue of the
said notification, the land specified therein vested absolutely in
the
Central
Government,
free
from
all
encumbrances.
Subsequently, the award dated 20.09.2023 was also passed.
28.
Taking note of the above circumstances, the learned Single
Judge dismissed the Writ Petition, leaving it open to the
petitioner to avail the remedies available to him in accordance
with law.
29.
In that view of the matter, when the objections raised by
the petitioner were specifically considered and addressed by the
Competent Authority and the notification under Section 3D(1) of
the Act was issued, the principles laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Kushala Shetty (mentioned supra), assume
relevance. The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in paragraph 28 of the
said judgment, held as follows:
“28. Here, it will be apposite to mention that NHAI is a
professionally managed statutory body having expertise in
the field of development and maintenance of national
highways.
The
projects
involving
construction
of
new
highways and widening and development of the existing
highways,
which
are
vital
for
the
development
of
infrastructure in the country, are entrusted to experts in the
field of highways. It comprises of persons having vast
knowledge and expertise in the field of highway development
and maintenance. NHAI prepares and implements projects
relating
to
development
and
maintenance
of
national
highways after thorough study by experts in different fields.
Detailed project reports are prepared keeping in view the
relative factors including intensity of heavy vehicular traffic
and larger public interest. The courts are not at all equipped
to decide upon the viability and feasibility of the particular
project and whether the particular alignment would subserve
the larger public interest. In such matters, the scope of
judicial review is very limited. The court can nullify the
acquisition of land and, in the rarest of rare cases, the
particular project, if it is found to be ex facie contrary to the
mandate of law or tainted due to mala fides. In the case in
hand, neither has any violation of mandate of the 1956 Act
been established nor has the charge of malice in fact been
proved. Therefore, the order under challenge cannot be
sustained.”
30.
Thus, in view of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court that Courts are not equipped to decide the viability and
feasibility of a particular project or to examine whether a
particular alignment would serve the larger public interest, and
that the scope of judicial review in such matters is limited, and
interference is warranted only in exceptional cases where
violation of the mandate of law or mala fides is established, we
do not find any illegality, infirmity or error in the order passed
by the learned Single Judge warranting interference by this
Court. The Writ Appellant/Writ Petitioner has failed to make out
any grounds for interference with the well-considered order
passed by the learned Single Judge, and the appeal is devoid of
merits and liable to be dismissed.
31.
Accordingly, the Writ Appeal is dismissed. There shall be
no order as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall
stand closed.
_________________________________
P.SAM KOSHY, ACJ
_________________________________
SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO, J
Date: 13.11.2026
NIT
THE HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT APPEAL No.1213 of 2026
13.11.2026
NIT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review