Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT At CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:The Hon’ble Justice Madhuresh Prasad
And
The Hon’ble Justice Partha Pratim Roy
F.M.A. 49 of 2026
With
CAN 1 of 2026
Purna Chandra Sarkar
Vs.
West Bengal Gramin Bank & Ors.
For the Appellant
: Mr. Indranath Mitra
For the Bangiya Gramin Vikas Bank : Ms. Sreemoyee Mitra
Heard on
: 21.08.2026
Judgment on
: 21.08.2026
Madhuresh Prasad, J.:
1.
Heard
the
learned
advocates
representing
the
writ
petitioner/appellant and the respondent Bank.
2. The writ petitioner while working as a Senior Manager (MMG GradeIII) was due to retire on 31.10.2024. Two days prior thereto on
28.10.2024 a letter was written to him whereby and whereunder he
was communicated regarding alleged lapses in respect of five loan
accounts sanctioned by him. A charge memo in respect of the same
allegation was served on him on 04.02.2025. The same led to
issuance
of
an
order
of
punishment
dated
13.03.2025.
The
punishment awarded was reduction of basic pay by 1 (one) stage
lower in the time scale of pay to which he belonged to as Officer ScaleIII, with retention of FPP, PQP, Stagnation increment, if any, on and
inclusive the date of his superannuation.
3. The learned advocate representing the writ petitioner submits that
there was no provision in the service regulation which may be invoked
for issuing a charge memo on 04.02.2025, post retirement of the writ
petitioner. He submits that the disciplinary proceeding founded on a
charge memo dated 04.02.2025, after his superannuation on
31.10.2024 was, therefore, without jurisdiction. The Hon’ble Single
Judge according to the learned advocate for the appellant has glossed
over this aspect of the matter.
4. It is submitted that the entire action founded on the charge memo is
dehors the regulation governing disciplinary action in respect of the
officers of the Bank. Under these circumstances the punishment
founded on such an action is unsustainable under the Bangiya
Gramin Vikas Bank (Officers and Employees) Service Regulations,
2010. Read with amendments from time to time (for short ‘2010
Regulation’).
5. The learned advocate for the respondent Bank has drawn attention of
the Court towards the letter dated 28.10.2024. It is submitted that
since the alleged irregularity committed by the writ petitioner was
discovered few days prior to his retirement, and since issuance of a
charge memo involves a procedure which was likely to take some
time, authorities communicated the alleged irregularities to the writ
petitioner
prior
to
his
superannuation
on
28.10.2024.
The
proceedings, therefore, were initiated by the letter dated 28.10.2024,
prior to his superannuation. The consequence of the proceeding is
also a very minor punishment involving reduction of basic pay by one
stage, lower in the time scale of pay to which he belonged. The
petitioner had an alternative remedy of appeal available under the
2010 Regulation. The Hon’ble Single Judge, therefore, rightly declined
to interfere with the departmental proceeding and punishment.
6.
We have considered the rival submissions and perused the record.
7. The 2010 Regulation prescribes the procedure for conducting
departmental proceedings against officers of the Bank. The same
contemplates issuance of a charge memo in case of a proposed
penalty. The procedure for imposition of penalties is specified in
Regulation 39 of the 2010 Regulation. The Regulation contemplates
that a minor penalty as specified therein shall not be imposed unless
the officer is given a notice in writing. The notice is required to
contain the grounds on which it is proposed to impose the penalties.
The notice must also afford a reasonable opportunity for making a
statement of defense and the statement of defense submitted is
required to be taken into consideration.
8. The 2010 Regulation further prescribes that a major penalty shall not
be imposed except by an order signed by the competent authority and
that no such order shall be passed without a charge or charges being
framed in writing and giving to the officer. The 2010 Regulation
further contemplates conduct of an enquiry giving reasonable
opportunity to defend the charge/s. Regulation 40 of the 2010
Regulation specifies the circumstances under which the procedure for
imposition of penalties in Regulation 39 can be waived/dispensed
with. Regulation 45 (3) and (4) are relied upon by the learned advocate
for bank to sustain the action taken against the writ petitioner. We,
therefore, consider it apposite to reproduce Regulation 45 of the 2010
Regulation which reads:
“45. Disciplinary proceedings after retirement. –
(1) An officer or employee who is under suspension on a charge of
misconduct and who attains the age of superannuation, shall be
deemed to be in service even after the age of superannuation for the
specific purpose of continuation and conclusion of the disciplinary
proceedings and issue of final order thereon.
(2) The officer or employee who is under suspension shall not be
eligible for any subsistence allowance for the period beyond the
date of superannuation.
(3) The officer or employee against whom disciplinary proceeding
has been initiated shall cease to be in service on the date of
superannuation but the disciplinary proceeding shall continue as if
he was in service until the proceedings are concluded and final
order is passed in respect thereof.
(4) The officer or employee against whom disciplinary proceedings
has been initiated shall not receive any pay and/or allowances after
the date of superannuation and also not be entitled for the payment
of retirement benefits till the proceeding is completed and final order
is passed thereon except his own contribution to Contributory
Provident Fund (CPF).
Explanation: For the purposes of this regulation, the normal
retirement benefits such as encashment of privilege leave and
Gratuity may be withheld till the completion of the disciplinary
proceeding and passing of final order by the Competent Authority
and the release of benefits shall be as per the final order of the
Competent Authority.”
9. A
plain
reading
of
the
regulation/s
reveals
that
the
same
contemplates issuance of a notice in writing communicating the
grounds for the proposed minor penalty. And affording a reasonable
opportunity
for
making
statement
of
defense
in
writing
and
consideration of such statement.
10.
For major penalties the Regulation contemplates a charge memo
being served. In the present case neither notice as contemplated in
the proviso to Regulation 39 (1)(b) was served on the petitioner, nor a
charge memo as contemplated in the proviso to Regulation 39 (2)(b) of
the Regulation. The learned Advocate for the bank has also not
pointed out any order to show that the petitioner was placed under
suspension prior to his retirement.
11.
A plain reading of Regulation 45 relied upon by the learned
Advocate
for
the
bank
reveals
that
the
same
contemplates
continuation and conclusion of the disciplinary proceeding only if the
officer/employee is under suspension on a charge of misconduct. The
regulation, therefore, contemplates a suspension and issuance of
charge memo prior to the date of superannuation for continuance of
the proceedings post retirement.
12.
In the present case the submission of the learned advocate for the
Bank that proceeding was initiated prior to his superannuation is
made with reference to the letter dated 28.10.2024. The letter relied
upon is neither a charge memo, nor notice for minor penalty as
contemplated in the 2010 Regulation. The date of the charge memo is
specifically mentioned as 04.02.2025, in the order of punishment
dated 13.03.2025. The charge memo, therefore, was issued about four
months after the petitioner retired. No suspension order was brought
to our notice of a date prior to the petitioner’s superannuation.
13.
Under these circumstances, keeping in background the provisions
contained in the 2010 Regulations, there was no justification for
proceeding against the petitioner, by charge memo dated 04.02.2025,
even if the consequences were minor. Once the regulation specifies
the manner in which a proceeding can be conducted against a person
likely to retire, the authorities of the Bank are bound by such
procedure and no discretion is left in the authorities to proceed
dehors the regulation.
14.
It is by now a settled law that when the Statute/Rule/Regulation
lays down a procedure for doing a particular thing, the authority
vested with power is bound by such procedure. Our conclusion in this
regard is fortified by decision of the Apex Court in the case of CIC v.
State of Manipur, reported in (2011) 15 SCC 1. The judgment reads:
“40. It is well known that when a procedure is laid down statutorily
and there is no challenge to the said statutory procedure the Court
should not, in the name of interpretation, lay down a procedure
which is contrary to the express statutory provision. It is a timehonoured principle as early as from the decision in Taylor v. Taylor
[(1875) 1 Ch D 426 (CA)] that where a statute provides for something
to be done in a particular manner it can be done in that manner
alone and all other modes of performance are necessarily forbidden.
This principle has been followed by the Judicial Committee of the
Privy Council in Nazir Ahmad v. Emperor [(1935-36) 63 IA 372 : AIR
1936 PC 253 (2)] and also by this Court in Deep Chand v. State of
Rajasthan [AIR 1961 SC 1527 : (1961) 2 Cri LJ 705] , AIR at para 9
and also in State of U.P. v. Singhara Singh [AIR 1964 SC 358 :
(1964) 1 Cri LJ 263 (2)] reported in AIR at para 8.”
15.
In view of our consideration above, the entire action founded on the
letter dated 28.10.2024 and charge memo dated 04.02.2025, was
without jurisdiction.
16.
The order of the Hon’ble Single Judge dismissing the writ petition
also took note of existence of alternative remedy of appeal available to
the writ petitioner.
17.
We would observe that the law in this regard is well settled,
exhaustion of alternative remedy before invocation of writ jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is a rule of discretion.
The jurisdiction of the Writ Court is not completely barred but
discretion is required to be exercised having regard to the facts and
circumstances of each case.
18.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Magadh Sugar
& Energy Ltd. v. State of Bihar, reported in (2022) 16 SCC 428
has stated the law as regards exercise of writ jurisdiction when there
is an alternative remedy. The Apex Court held that existence of an
alternative remedy does not by itself Bar the High Court from
exercising its jurisdiction in certain contingencies. The law was stated
by the Apex Court in paragraph 20 of the judgment in the following
terms:
"20. While a High Court would normally not exercise its writ
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution if an effective and
efficacious alternative remedy is available, the existence of an
alternative remedy does not by itself bar the High Court from
exercising its jurisdiction in certain contingencies. This principle has
been crystallised by this Court in Whirlpool Corpn. v. Registrar of
Trade Marks [Whirlpool Corpn. v. Registrar of Trade Marks, (1998) 8
SCC 1] and Harbanslal Sahnia v. Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd. [Harbanslal
Sahnia v. Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd., (2003) 2 SCC 107] Recently, in
Radha Krishan Industries v. State of H.P. [Radha Krishan Industries
v. State of H.P., (2021) 6 SCC 771] a two-Judge Bench of this Court
of which one of us was a part of (D.Y. Chandrachud, J.) has
summarised the principles governing the exercise of writ jurisdiction
by the High Court in the presence of an alternative remedy. This
Court has observed : (Radha Krishan Industries case [Radha
Krishan Industries v. State of H.P., (2021) 6 SCC 771] , SCC p. 795,
para 27)
“27. The principles of law which emerge are that:
27.1. The power under Article 226 of the Constitution to issue writs
can be exercised not only for the enforcement of fundamental rights,
but for any other purpose as well.
27.2. The High Court has the discretion not to entertain a writ
petition. One of the restrictions placed on the power of the High
Court is where an effective alternative remedy is available to the
aggrieved person.
27.3. Exceptions to the rule of alternative remedy arise where : (a)
the writ petition has been filed for the enforcement of a fundamental
right protected by Part III of the Constitution; (b) there has been a
violation of the principles of natural justice; (c) the order or
proceedings are wholly without jurisdiction; or (d) the vires of a
legislation is challenged.
27.4. An alternative remedy by itself does not divest the High Court
of its powers under Article 226 of the Constitution in an appropriate
case though ordinarily, a writ petition should not be entertained
when an efficacious alternative remedy is provided by law.
27.5. When a right is created by a statute, which itself prescribes
the remedy or procedure for enforcing the right or liability, resort
must be had to that particular statutory remedy before invoking the
discretionary remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution. This rule
of exhaustion of statutory remedies is a rule of policy, convenience
and discretion.
27.6. In cases where there are disputed questions of fact, the High
Court may decide to decline jurisdiction in a writ petition. However,
if the High Court is objectively of the view that the nature of the
controversy requires the exercise of its writ jurisdiction, such a view
would not readily be interfered with.” (emphasis supplied)”
19.
The law by now is well settled. A person is bound by the norms of
discipline and subject to being proceeded against for misconduct only
during the course of his employment. Till such time a person
continues in employment he is covered by the rules/ regulations
governing his conduct; and for taking action in cases of misconduct.
Once the petitioner retired the master servant relationship was
severed. Post retirement an employer normally, cannot proceed
against a person, unless there is a specific provision clothing the
authority with such discretion retaining jurisdiction to proceed
against an employed employee.
20.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, in the case of Chairman-cum-
Managing
Director,
Mahanadi
Coalfields
Limited
vs.
Rabindranath Choubey, reported in (2020) 18 SCC 71 stated the
law in this regard with reference to earlier decisions of the Hon’ble
Apex Court, that “… relevant rules governing the service conditions of
an employee are the determining factor as to whether or not the
domestic enquiry can be held against an employee who stood retired
after reaching the age of superannuation”.
21.
In the present case no such provision in any rule/ regulation is
brought to our notice, whereby and whereunder the respondents
could exercise such discretion/ jurisdiction to proceed against the
writ petitioner, post retirement. The charge memo dated 04.02.2025
and the entire action founded thereupon, therefore, was legally,
having no legal force or validity, and is a nullity in the eyes of law.
22.
The petitioner’s post retiral dues have been adversely affected by
such a charge memo and punishment order which was dehors the
regulation and without jurisdiction, in such facts and circumstances
of the present case, we are of the view that mere existence of an
alternative remedy by itself did not divest the writ Court of its powers
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
23.
We, therefore, set aside the order of the Hon’ble Single Judge and
allow the writ petition. The charge memo dated 04.02.2025 and the
order of punishment dated 13.03.2025 are hereby quashed.
24.
The writ petition is allowed in these terms.
25.
The petitioner would be entitled to consequential benefits as a
result of quashing of the charge memo and the punishment order.
26.
Pending application stands disposed of.
27.
Urgent certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties, expeditiously after complying with all necessary legal
formalities.
(Madhuresh Prasad, J.)
I agree.
(Partha Pratim Roy, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review