Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
26.02.2026
Ct. no.14
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Sl. Nos.1-4
ss
CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
WPA 23024 of 2024
Munna Kundu
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
with
WPA 23917 of 2024
Rekharani Mahato
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
with
WPA 23967 of 2024
Alaka Mahato
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
with
WPA 28510 of 2024
Purba Dan
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Rudranil De
Mr. Soumo Charan
Mr. Subir Sanyal, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Ratul Biswas
Mr. Kaushik Chowdhury
… for the petitioners
… for the WBBPE
Mr. Sayan Datta
… for the State (in WPA 23024 of 2024)
Mr. Arindam Chattopadhyay
Ms. Lipika Chatterjee
… for the State (in WPA 23917 of 2024)
Mr. Tapas Kumar Dey
Mr. Malay Krishna De
…for the State (in WPA 23967 of 2024)
Ms. Sukanya Datta
… for the State (in WPA 28510 of 2024)
Mr. B.P. Vaisya
Mr. Gourav Das
Ms. Tapati Sarkar
...for the DPSC, South 24-Parganas in
WPA 23917/24.WPA28510 of 2024
Mr. B.P. Vaisya
Mr. Nilay Baran Mandal
… for the DPSC, Purulia in WPA 23024 of 2024,
WPA 23967 of 2024 and 28510 of 2024
1.
,
These matters are appearing in the list under the
heading „For Orders‟.
2.
Since the subject matter of the aforementioned writ
petitions are similar in nature, these writ petitions
were heard analogously.
3.
For better appreciation the necessary facts are
enumerated as follows.
(i) The petitioner, Munna Kundu, in WPA 23024 of
2024, previously filed a writ petition being WPA
25110 of 2023 seeking for inter-district transfer on
the ground of distance. The aforesaid writ petition
was disposed of on 28th February 2024 as follows.
“In the above circumstances, West Bengal Board of Primary
Education after receiving an appropriate report from the
District Primary School Council, South 24 Parganas and
District Primary School Council, Bankura and subject to
availability shall consider the petitioner‟s application in
accordance with law and dispose of the same within a
period of two months from date mandatorily and positively.”
Pursuant to such order, Secretary, West Bengal
Board of Primary Education rejected the prayer of
the petitioner on 21st August 2024 with the following
observation.
“ 5.….. As per Rule 4 Clause (b) of the West Bengal Board of
Primary Education (Transfer of Teachers including Head
Teacher) Rules, 2002 as amended vide Notification No.
1072-SE/EE/10M-45/2021 dated 13/09/2021 wherein it
states that „on an application from a teacher, transfer
approved teacher within its jurisdiction from one primary
school to another primary school on the condition that such
approved teacher, in case of mutual transfer, is confirmed
and in case of single transfer, is confirmed and has
completed minimum five years of continuous service‟. Thus,
it is seen that in case of single transfer the confirmation of
service is mandatory and the teacher has to be completed
minimum five years of service. At the time of hearing, the
petitioner could not submit the confirmation letter of her
service and she has not completed 5 years of service, which
was pointed out and discussed with the petitioner at the
time of hearing.
6. Having considered the facts as above, the prayer of the
petitioner for single transfer is not considered as the
petitioner did not fulfil the eligibility criteria as stipulated in
Rule 4(b) of the West Bengal Primary Education (Transfer of
Teachers and Head Teacher) Rules, 2002. Consequently, no
relief can be granted to the petitioner.
(ii) The petitioner, Rekharani Mahato, in WPA 23917
of 2024, previously filed a writ petition being WPA
25980 of 2023 seeking for inter-district transfer on
the ground of distance. The aforesaid writ petition
was dismissed on 28th February 2024. Challenging
the said order the aforementioned petitioner filed an
appeal being MAT 607 of 2024.
(iii) The petitioner, Alka Mahato, in WPA 23967 of
2024, previously filed a writ petition being WPA
25979 of 2023 seeking for inter-district transfer on
the ground of distance. The aforesaid writ petition
was dismissed on 28th February 2024. Challenging
the said order the aforementioned petitioner filed an
appeal being MAT 608 of 2024.
(iv) Both the appeals being MAT 607 of 2024 and
MAT 608 of 2024 were disposed of on 13th May 2024
with similar direction as follows.
“In view of such submission, the appeal and its connected
application are disposed of granting liberty to the appellant
to submit a fresh representation annexing all the documents
in support of contention to the Secretary, West Bengal Board
of Primary Education within a period of two weeks. If such
representation is made within the time, as specified, the
Secretary shall consider the same in accordance with law
and communicate the decision to the appellant within a
period of four weeks from date of receipt of the
representation.”
Pursuant thereto, both the appellants submitted
their respective representations before the authority
concerned. The representation of Rekharani Mahato
was disposed of by the Secretary, West Bengal Board
of Primary Education on 2nd September 2024 as
follows.
“ In Rule 4 Clause (b) of the West Bengal Board of Primary
Education (Transfer of Teachers including Head Teacher)
Rules, 2002 as amended vide Notification No. 1072SE/EE/10M-45/2021 dated 13/09/2021 it is clearly stated
that- „on an application from a teacher, transfer approved
teacher within its jurisdiction from one primary school to
another primary school on the condition that such approved
teacher, in case of mutual transfer, is confirmed and in case
of single transfer, is confirmed and has completed minimum
five years of continuous service‟.
In the instant matter the petitioner/appellant has joined as a
primary teacher on 23.7.2021 i.e her period of service in the
present school is less than five years.
Hence using all information, records, the relevant rules,
government orders and in terms of the extant norms, the
prayer of the petitioner/appellant for transfer from South 24
Parganas to Purulia cannot be accepted as per Rule 4(b) of
the West Bengal Board of Primary Education (Transfer of
Teachers including Head Teacher) Rules, 2002 and its
amendment vide Notification No. 1072-SE/EE/10M-45/2021
dated 13/09/2021. So, no relief can be granted to the
petitioner/appellant.”
Similarly, the representation of Alka Mahato was
disposed of 2nd September 2024 as follows.
“ In Rule 4 Clause (b) of the West Bengal Board of Primary
Education (Transfer of Teachers including Head Teacher)
Rules, 2002 as amended vide Notification No. 1072SE/EE/10M-45/2021 dated 13/09/2021 it is clearly stated
that- „on an application from a teacher, transfer approved
teacher within its jurisdiction from one primary school to
another primary school on the condition that such approved
teacher, in case of mutual transfer, is confirmed and in case
of single transfer, is confirmed and has completed minimum
five years of continuous service‟.
In the instant matter the petitioner/appellant has joined as a
primary teacher on 20.7.2021 i.e her period of service in the
present school is less than five years.
Hence using all information, records, the relevant rules,
government orders and in terms of the extant norms, the
prayer of the petitioner/appellant for transfer from South 24
Parganas to Purulia cannot be accepted as per Rule 4(b) of
the West Bengal Board of Primary Education (Transfer of
Teachers including Head Teacher) Rules, 2002 and its
amendment vide Notification No. 1072-SE/EE/10M-45/2021
dated 13/09/2021. So, no relief can be granted to the
petitioner/appellant.”
(v) The petitioner, Purba Dan, in WPA 28510 of
2024, previously filed a writ petition being WPA 9769
of 2023 seeking for inter-district transfer on the
ground of distance. The aforesaid writ petition was
dismissed on 21st May 2024. Challenging the said
order the aforementioned petitioner filed an appeal
being MAT 1245 of 2024. The appeal court set aside
the aforesaid order and directed as follows.
“The Secretary of the Board is directed to consider the said
application in the light of the said notification dated
November 2, 1991 as amended from time to time and
conscious decision shall be taken within four weeks from the
date of communication of this order.”
Pursuant thereto, the Secretary of the Board passed
order on 5th November 2024, observing that as there
was no specific principles and procedure for transfer
of teacher or non-teaching staff in a primary school
between two primary councils, so the Board in the
year 1991 had to set the said principles and
procedure for the purpose of clause (k) of sub-section
(1) of section 19 of the West Bengal Primary
Education Act, 1973 to transfer a teacher or nonteaching staff from a primary school within the
jurisdiction of one Primary School Council to primary
school within the jurisdiction of another Primary
School Council. In the said notification, there is no
specific saying about the age and length of service of
the teacher at the time of application for his/her
transfer. Later the School Education Department,
Government of West Bengal framed the West Bengal
Primary Education (Transfer of Teachers including
Head Teacher) Rules, 2002 as amended which is in
vogue and is introduced in supersession of all
previous rules or notifications. Further the ground of
suffering of the father and loss of pregnancy
(miscarriage) is not covered under 5(3) (a) of Rules of
2002. Though the ground of long distance between
the working place of the petitioner and spouse may
be covered under Rule 5(3A)(a) but the Pupil Teacher
Ratio (PTR) in the applicant’s school is adverse. On
such score, the prayer of the petitioner for transfer
was rejected.
4.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid orders passed by
the Secretary of the Board, rejecting the prayer of the
petitioners for transfer, the present writ petitions
have been filed challenging such action on the part
of the said respondent authority.
5.
Mr. Rudranil De, learned advocate appearing for the
petitioners submit that the West Bengal Primary
Education (Transfer of Teachers including Head
Teacher) Rules 2002 (hereinafter referred to as the
„Rules of 2002‟) has been promulgated in exercise of
power conferred under clause (k) of sub-section (2) of
section 106 of the West Bengal Primary Education
Act, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as „Act of 1973‟)
containing exhaustive provision relating to transfer
of teachers including Head Teacher. It is pertinent to
note that the aforesaid rule has its applicability only
in respect of transfer of the primary school teacher
from one primary school to another within the
territorial jurisdiction of the respective Primary
School Council and does not expand its horizon in
case of transfer of primary school teachers from one
territorial jurisdiction of the council to another
council. Rule 1(2) of Rules of 2002 clearly provides
that the rules shall apply to teachers including Head
Teacher for the purpose of transfer from one primary
school to another within the jurisdiction of a council,
therefore under no stretch of imagination the Rules
of 2002 would apply in case of inter-district transfer.
In order to decide the transfer application in respect
of inter-district transfer of primary school teachers
the principles and procedures for transfer of a
teacher or non-teaching staff in a primary school
between two primary school councils introduced vide
Notification dated 2nd November 1991 is to be
followed by the Board and not the Rules of 2002. As
per the notification dated 2nd November 1991 there is
no such embargo that the concerned teacher has to
complete continuous five years of service prior to
making application for transfer. In MAT 1245 of
2024, preferred by the petitioner Purba Dan, the
Hon’ble Division Bench directed the Secretary of the
Board to consider the said application of the
petitioner/appellant
in
the
light
of
the
said
Notification dated 2nd November, 1991 as amended
from time to time and take a conscious decision.
However,
the
authority
concerned
in
utter
contravention of the direction of the Hon’ble Division
Bench did not apply the procedures as laid down in
Notification dated 2nd November 1991 and applied
the provisions of Rules of 2002, which is palpably
illegal and cannot be sustained in law. He also
indicates that the Board has applied the procedures
of the Notification dated 2nd November, 1991 in case
of one Monika Meheta pursuant to order passed in
appeal being MAT 1189 of 2024.
In light of his aforesaid submissions, he prays that
the impugned orders passed by the Secretary of the
Board is liable to be set aside.
6.
Mr. Subir Sanyal, learned Senior Advocate appearing
for the West Bengal Board of Primary Education, on
the contrary, submits that in the year 1991 the
Board for the first time introduced the principles and
procedures for transfer of primary school teacher
from one Primary School Council to another vide
Notification dated 2nd November, 1991 for the
purpose of section 19(1) (k) of the Act of 1973.
Subsequent thereto, in exercise of the rule making
powers conferred under section 106(1) of the Act of
1973 the State in order to carry forward the purpose
of the Act, introduced the Rules of 2002, in
supersession of previous rules and notifications,
which precisely deals with transfer of teacher of a
primary school. The State government has the
legislative power and competence to frame rules for
the purpose of section 19(1) (k) i.e. inter-council
transfer and also for transfer of teachers within the
jurisdiction of the council i.e. intra-council transfer.
Section 19 (1) of the Act of 1973 empowers the Board
to transfer a teacher or non-teaching staff from a
primary school within the jurisdiction of a Primary
School Council to a primary school within the
jurisdiction of another Primary School Council.
Although Rule 1(2) of Rules of 2002 provides that the
rules shall apply to teachers including Head Teacher
for the purpose of transfer from one primary school
to another within the jurisdiction of the council, yet,
Rule
thereof,
prior
to
amendment,
clearly
stipulated that in case of inter-council transfer, the
council shall follow the principles and procedures of
the Board in accordance with provisions conferred by
clause (k) of section 19 (1) of the Act of 1973. With
the amendment of Rule 8 it is specifically provided
that while considering inter-council transfer in
accordance with the provisions of section 19(1)(k) of
the Act of 1973, the Board shall mutatis mutandis
follow the provisions of these Rule. Therefore, Rules
of 2002 covers both intra-council transfer as well as
inter-council transfer as has been framed by the
State
in
exercise
of
its
statutory
powers.
Consequently, it cannot be said that Rules of 2002
only applies in case of intra-council transfer and has
no manner of application in respect of inter-council
transfer in view of the language used in Rule 1(2).
From the very beginning Rule 8 was introduced to
deal with inter-council transfer, which has been
amended from time to time in order to carry out the
purpose of the Act. It is settled proposition of law
that the statute has to be read as a whole. Thus,
when the transfer Rules of 2002 contain specific
provision for inter-council transfer, the said rule
cannot be said to be applicable only for intra-council
transfer. Moreover, the rules have to be read in its
entirety. The title of the statute is no doubt an
important part of an enactment and can be referred
for determining the general scope of legislation,
however, the nature of any such enactment is always
to be determined not on the basis of the label given
to it but on the basis of its substance. To buttress
his contention, he relies on the following decision of
Hon’ble Supreme Court (i) Manohar Lal versus
State of Punjab reported in AIR 1961 SC 418; (ii)
Amarendra Kumar Mohapatra and Others versus
State of Orissa and Others reported in (2014) 4
SCC 583. In this context, he also refers to the book
on Interpretation of Statutes by G.P Singh, 7th
Edition.
Furthermore, he indicates that although in the
appeal being MAT 1245 of 2024 filed by one of the
petitioners namely Purba Dan a direction was passed
by the Hon’ble Division Bench to consider the
application
of
the
petitioner
in
terms
of
the
Notification dated 2nd November 1991, however, in a
similar
situation
the
Hon’ble
Division
Bench
dismissed the appeal being MAT 114 of 2025 (Saroj
Kanti Bag versus State of West Bengal & Others) after
considering the amended provisions of Rule 8 of
Rules of 2002, which was not placed before the
appellate court for its consideration in the appeal
filed by Purba Dan.
In light of the above, he submits that the impugned
orders passed by the Secretary of the Board does not
call for interference.
7.
In reply to the aforesaid contention raised on behalf
of the Board, Mr. De, learned advocate for the
petitioner relying on the decision of Hon’ble Supreme
Court passed in Poppatlal Shah versus The State
of Madras, Union of India and Others reported in
AIR 1953 SC 274 submits that the statutes shall
have to be considered in its entirety and picking up
one word from one particular provision and thereby
analysing it in a manner contrary to the statement of
objects and reasons is neither permissible nor
warranted.
8.
Upon
hearing
the
learned
advocates
for
the
respective parties, following issues have fallen for
consideration.
Firstly, whether the Rules of 2002 as amended would
apply or the Notification No. 230/91-92 dated 2nd
November, 1991 in respect of transfer of primary
school teachers from one District Primary School
Council to another?
Secondly, whether the Secretary of the Board is
justified in passing the orders rejecting the prayer of
the petitioners for inter-district transfer as per
existing Rules of 2002?
9.
Both these issues being interrelated are taken up
together for the sake of brevity and convenience of
discussion.
10. At the outset, there cannot be any quarrel that the
statute shall have to be read and considered in its
entirety. Though short title and application of a
statue is no doubt important part of an enactment
which can be referred for determining the general
scope of the legislation, however, the true nature of
an enactment has to be determined on the basis of
substance and the title cannot obviously control the
express operative provisions of the Act. It is settled
principles of law that the statute has to be read as a
whole and picking of one word from one particular
provision and thereby analysing it in a manner
contrary to the statement of objects and reasons is
neither permissible nor warranted as has been
rightly indicated by the learned advocate for the
petitioners. Such position of law culls out from the
decisions and references made by either of the
parties in the course of hearing. In such backdrop,
let me assess as to whether Rule 1(2) of the Rules of
2002 make the rules applicable only in case of intracouncil transfer. Rule 1(2) of the Rules of 2002
provides that these rules shall apply to teachers
including Head Teacher for the purpose of transfer
from one primary school to another within the
jurisdiction of a council. Be that as it may, Rule 8,
prior to amendment, provided that in case of intercouncil
transfer
principles
and
the
council
procedures
of
shall
follow
the
the
Board
in
accordance with the provisions conferred by clause
(k) of sub-section (1) of section 19 of the Act. Thus, it
is found that from the very inception of the rules, the
provisions for inter-council transfer were introduced
in the rules.
11. Subsequent thereto, the Rules of 2002 was amended
on 13th September 2021.The Rule 8 after amendment
read as follows.
“8. Inter Council Transfer- While considering inter-council
transfer in accordance with the provisions of clause (k) of
section 19 (1) of the Act, the Board shall mutatis mutandis
follow the provision of these rules particularly sub-rule (3) of
rule 5 of these rules;
Provided that the Board may or basis of application or
otherwise transfer any female teacher who is victim of crime
with the concurrence of the State government in the school
education department. It shall maintain due confidentiality
in regard to the identity of such victim”
It manifests from the aforesaid amended provision,
that the Rules of 2002 are to be applied by the Board
mutatis mutandis in case of inter-council transfer. It
is a principle enshrined therein which is required to
be followed by the authorities before deciding the
application for transfer filed by the primary school
teacher. Section 19 (1) (k) of the Act of 1973
empowers the Board to transfer a teacher or non-
teaching staff from a primary school within the
jurisdiction of a Primary School Council to a primary
school within the jurisdiction of another Primary
School Council. Thus, upon conjoint reading of
section 19(1)(k) of the Act of 1973 as well as the
express provisions of Rule 8 as amended, it leaves no
manner of doubt that the Rules of 2002 squarely
apply in case of inter-council transfer authorizing the
Board to act in accordance with the said Rules for
effecting transfer of primary school teachers.
12. It has been strenuously argued on behalf of the
petitioners that in case of inter-council transfer, the
Notification dated 2nd November 1991 is to be
followed. The principles and procedures for transfer
of primary school teacher from one Primary School
Council to another vide Notification dated 2nd
November, 1991 was introduced in order to carry
forward the purpose of section 19(1) (k) of the Act of
1973. Subsequent thereto, in exercise of the rule
making powers conferred under section 106(1) of the
Act of 1973 the State in order to carry forward the
purpose of the Act, introduced the Rules of 2002 vide
Notification No. 809-SE (Pry) dated 15th July 2002,
in supersession of previous rules and notifications,
which precisely deals with transfer of teacher of a
primary school. Therefore, with the coming into effect
of the Rules of 2002, the earlier notification and/or
principles and procedures relating to inter-council
transfer
stands
superseded.
Consequently,
the
applicability of said Notification dated 2nd November
1991 for inter-council transfer lost its force after
promulgation of Rules of 2002 dealing with transfer
of teacher and Head Teacher in case of both intracouncil as well as inter-council transfers.
13. In the appeal filed by petitioner namely Purba Dan
the Hon’ble Division Bench directed the Secretary of
the
Board
to
consider
the
application
of
the
petitioner/appellant in light of the Notification dated
2nd November 1991. Be that as it may, it is found
that the amended provisions of Rule 8 of Rules of
2002 were not placed before the Hon’ble Division
Bench in the appeal preferred by Purba Dan (MAT
1245 of 2024). It is relevant to note that the Hon’ble
Division Bench in a subsequent appeal while dealing
with similar question in Saroj Kanti Bag (supra) in
MAT 114 of 2025 dismissed the appeal upon
considering the amended provisions of Rule 8 of the
Rules of 2002.
14. The precise challenge to the impugned orders of the
Secretary of the Board is that he applied Rules of
2002 while deciding the application of transfer of
petitioners
instead
of
Notification
dated
2nd
November 1991, where there is no embargo of
completing five years of continuous service. In the
foregoing paragraph it has already been held that
Rules of 2002 applies in case of inter-district
transfers. Admittedly, none of the petitioners had
completed five years of continuous service at the
time when the prayers were sought to be considered
by the authority on the ground of distance. The
amended provisions of Rule 4(b) of Rules of 2002
provides that the council on an application from a
teacher,
transfer
approved
teacher
within
its
jurisdiction from one primary school to another
primary school on the condition that such approved
teacher, in case of mutual transfer, is confirmed and
in case of single transfer, is confirmed and has
completed minimum five years of continuous service.
As per Rule 8 while considering inter-council transfer
in accordance with the provisions of clause (k) of
section 19 (1) of the Act, the Board shall mutatis
mutandis follow the provision of the Rules of 2002.
Thus, the Board is under statutory obligation to
consider the provisions of Rule 4(b). In terms of the
aforesaid Rule 4(b), it goes without saying that there
is clear embargo to consider and entertain a prayer
for transfer of primary School teacher prior to
completion of minimum five years of continuous
service. A Statutory authority is bound to act in
accordance with existing rules and cannot transgress
the limited sphere. Such being the position as the
impugned orders of the Secretary of the Board is
passed following the existing Rules of 2002 as
amended, the same cannot be said to be contrary to
law requiring intervention of the court.
15. It has been vociferously argued on behalf of the
petitioner, relying on a reasoned order dated 5th
February 2025 passed by the Secretary of the Board
in case of Monika Meheta, pursuant to order of the
Hon’ble Division Bench passed in MAT 1189 of 2024,
wherein the prayer of the petitioner for transfer was
allowed following the Notification dated 2nd November
1991, that similar benefit be extended to the
petitioners. However, in view of the discussions made
herein above in the foregoing paragraphs, such order
of the Secretary of the Board cannot be a precedent
to extend benefit to the petitioners on the ground of
parity dehors the existing rules.
16. In light of the above discussion, the impugned orders
passed by the Secretary, West Bengal Board of
Primary Education rejecting the prayer of the
petitioners for grant of inter-district transfer does not
call for any interference and as such the writ
petitions for short of merit.
17. Accordingly, the writ petitions being WPA 23024 of
2024, WPA 23917 of 2024, WPA 23967 of 2024
and WPA 28510 of 2024 stand dismissed.
18. All connected applications, if any, stand disposed of.
19. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
20. There shall be no order as to costs.
21. Urgent photostat certified copy of the order, if
applied for, be given to the parties on compliance of
all necessary legal formalities.
(Bivas Pattanayak, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review