The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
24. For the reasons as discussed above, this court is constrained to find that the FIR or other materials available in this case do not disclose a cognizable offence to have been made out against the petitioners herein. Apparently this case is the outcome of the matrimonial disharmony between the defacto complainant and the principle accused no.1 and therefore for the reasons as mentioned above this court cannot rule out existence of any malicious or malafide intention in setting the criminal justice system in motion against the petitioners herein. It is settled law that the court must ensure that criminal prosecution is not used as an instrument of harassment or for seeking private vendetta or with an ulterior motive to pressurize the petitioners.
25. Hence it is ordered that the CGR case no. 2086/2025 presently pending before learned Chief Judicial Magistrate is hereby quashed quo the petitioners namely Purba Chatterjee, Ayan Mazumder, Surajit Biswas @ Surojit Biswas and Soham Dasgupta (wrongly named as Souvik Das Gupta in the FIR). Since no affidavit is invited the allegations contained in the petition of complaint against the petitioners are deemed to have been denied by the petitioners.
26. CRR 5550 of 2025 thus stand disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE AJOY KUMAR MUKHERJEE
CRR 5550 of 2025
Purba Chatterjee & Ors.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Anr.
For the petitioners
:
Mr. Antarikhya Basu
Mr. Madhumita Basak,
Mr. Mayurakshi Saha
For the Opposite party no.2
:
Mr. Anirban Guha Thakurata
Ms. Nahid Ahmed
Mr. Biswajit Ghosh
For the State
:
Mr. Sankalpa Bhattacharjee
Heard on
:
23.06.2026
Judgment on
:
25.08.2026
Dr. Ajoy Kumar Mukherjee, J.
1.
A written complaint was lodged by opposite party no. 2 (in short OP
no.2) herein against the petitioners interalia stating that the defacto
complaint/OP no.2 got married to the accused no.1 (who is not the
petitioner herein). The petitioner no.1 herein allegedly maintained an illicit
relationship with the said husband of OP no.2 i.e. accused no.1 since
February, 2025. The petitioner no.3 and petitioner no.4 herein are the
husband and the son of the petitioner no.1, whereas the petitioner no.2 is
the person employed by the husband of the OP no.2. The OP no.2 in her
complaint specifically alleged that she was subjected to continuous mental
and physical torture by her husband for a considerable period of time. It is
further alleged that all the accused persons have been engaging in
systematic intimidation, coercion and extortion by demanding exorbitant
amount of money under threat of physical violence. On 03.07.2025 the
accused no.1 along with petitioner no.2 acting upon the instructions of the
other petitioners forcibly attempted to evict the OP no.2 from her
matrimonial home and in course of the incident, the husband /accused in
connivance with the petitioners committed theft of the belongings and
valuable items of the OP no.2 and unlawfully removed the same from her
possession. All the accused persons used to visit her residence and allegedly
conspired with an intention to intimidate and extort money. It is further
alleged that persistent physical violence has caused grievous injuries and
has endangered her physical and mental well-being.
2.
On the basis of the aforesaid complaint Rabindra Sarobar PS case no.
80 of 2025 dated 06.07.2025 under section 85/305/351(3)/3(5) of the BNS
2023 corresponding to CGR Case no. 2086 of 2025 was registered for
investigation against the accused no.1/husband of the complainant and
also against the petitioners herein.
3.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid proceeding learned counsel for the
petitioners submits that even if the allegations in the FIR are taken at their
face value and accepted in their entirety the same do not constitute offence
under section 85 of the BNS against the petitioners herein as alleged offence
can be attributed only to the victim’s husband and his relatives by blood,
marriage or adoption. The petitioner herein are neither the husband nor
relative of the husband of defacto complainant.
4.
He further submits that the allegations in the FIR are primarily
directed against the husband of the defacto complainant i.e. accused no.1.
The allegations against the present petitioners suffers from inherent
improbabilities and is evidently motivated by malafide intention to harass
the petitioners. The allegations are omnibus in nature and bereft of
particulars and fails to disclose the commission of any cognizable offence
against the present petitioners. The allegations levelled in the complaint are
nothing but an afterthought and a manufactured version, lodged only with
the intent to falsely implicate the present petitioners.
5.
It is further contended on behalf of the petitioners that the defacto
complainant had earlier lodged a complaint against her husband but in the
earlier narrative made against her husband, no reference whatsoever was
made to the present petitioners, which shows that they were sought to be
implicated only at a later stage out of malafide and vindictive intent.
Therefore the instant proceeding is nothing but an afterthought and has
been lodged with the intent to falsely implicate the present petitioners.
Petitioners further contention is that the School Attendance Register dated
03.07.2025, clearly demonstrates that the petitioner no.1 was discharging
her professional duties as an Assistant Teacher from 10:30 am. to 4:30 PM
which disproves her physical presence at the scene of her alleged
occurrence. The FIR contains sweeping, general allegations without
attributing any specific overtact or criminal role to the petitioners. Petitioner
no.2 and 4 are young students and they have no connection to the
matrimonial discord. Their inclusion is based solely on their academic
association with petitioner no.1, on the basis of a guess work. Learned
counsel for the petitioners further submits that the FIR discloses the name
of one ‘Souvik Das Gupta’ as an accused yet the petitioner no. 1 has no son
by that name and her son’s name is Soham Das Gupta. This error also
underscores the cooked up and malicious nature of the complainant based
on hearsay evidence. Therefore they have prayed for quashment of the said
proceeding quo the petitioners herein.
6.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the OP no. 2 submits that the
petitioners have come before this court for quashing of the FIR, at a
premature stage and there is no reasonable ground to quash the FIR
because if it is allowed it would take away the right of victim/OP no.2 to
avail a fair investigation and to seek justice in accordance with law. He
further submits that FIR is not an encyclopaedia and is not expected to
contain every minute details relating to the occurrence complained of.
7.
In the instant case, the OP no.2 herself is the victim who had lodged
the complaint on her own without any legal assistance and being a layman
she cannot be expected to draft the complaint with legal precision or to
narrate every factual details in the manner expected in legal pleadings.
Therefore merely because the complaint does not contain exhaustive
particulars, cannot render the FIR vague, when it otherwise discloses
commission of cognizable offences warranting investigation in accordance
with law. Therefore, the allegations made in the complaint against the
present petitioner are vague and general in nature and is wholly misplaced
and untenable in law. It is further argued on behalf of the op no.2 that the
complaint was lodged by the OP no.2 after 27 years of marriage because
throughout the subsistence of the matrimonial relationship, she had
endured continuous hardship. Her further case is that the lodging of the
complaint was not a sudden or impulsive decision but was the result of
years of suffering, tolerance and repeated attempts, on her part to sustain
matrimonial relationship. But when it reached at a stage beyond tolerance
she ultimately lodged the instant complaint.
8.
Learned counsel for the OP No.2 further argued that apart from the
allegations attracting section 85 of the BNS, the complaint also discloses
commission of offence under section 305 and 351 (3) read with section 3(5)
of the BNS and the allegations in respect of the same have been specially
made against the petitioners herein. It has been specially alleged in the
complaint that the petitioners had actively acted in concert with the
husband and had instigated as well as contributed towards the continuous
physical and mental torture suffered by OP no.2. The petitioner no.1 has
sought to rely upon school register to establish her location at the relevant
point of time. However, said documents are disputed in nature and their
veracity cannot be examined at this stage of the proceeding. In the instant
case the investigation is still at a very nascent stage. The investigating
agency is yet to collect vital electronic evidence including call details record
and tower location of the petitioners and at this stage court cannot place
reliance upon such disputed documents.
9.
Counsel for the Op no.2 further argued that husband of the OP no. 2
is presently residing at Chandernagore at the behest of petitioner no.1
herein and the said facts can only be properly ascertained upon collection of
electronic evidence and completion of investigation. Thus at this premature
stage and before collection of such vital evidences, the proceeding ought not
to be quashed specially when material evidence establishing the role and
involvement of the accused persons is yet to be brought on record. However,
learned counsel for the OP no.2 on instruction submits that while lodging
the FIR, the name of petitioner no.4 was inadvertently mentioned as ‘Souvik
Das Gupta’ instead of “Soham Das Gupta” and it occurred due to bonafide
mistake. But such inadvertent error in mentioning the name of the
petitioner no.4 cannot affect the substance of the allegations made in the
complaint or be construed as a ground to discredit the case of the OP No.2
at this stage.
10.
He further submits that the petitioners have referred about delay of 3
days in lodging of the FIR but such contention is factually incorrect and
contrary to the records itself. The incident in question had happened on
03.07.2025 and the complaint was received by police authority on the same
date but they had registered the FIR on 06.07.2025 and therefore, there was
no delay whatsoever on the part of the OP no.2 in approaching the police
authorities. He further argued that the First Information Report is not an
encyclopaedia which must disclose all facts and details relating to the
offence reported. Therefore, when the investigation by the police is in
progress, the court should not only go into the allegations made in the FIR
but police must be permitted to complete the investigation. In this context
petitioner has placed reliance upon the judgements of Mushkan Vs. Ishan
Khan reported in 2025 SCC Online 2355, Rajesh Bajaj Vs. State of NCT
of Delhi and Ors, (1990) 3 SCC 259, State of UP Vs. OP Sharma (1996)
7 SCC 750 and Skoda Auto Volkswagan India Pvt. Ltd. Vs. State of UP,
(2020) SCC Online SC 958.
11.
Therefore he submits that when the first information report clearly
discloses commission of cognizable offences, quashing of the FIR and the
entire proceeding at an embryonic stage would create impediment to the
Court of Justice and would cause grave prejudice to the OP no.2 and
therefore he has prayed for dismissal of the instant application.
Decision
12.
The petitioners herein along with the accused no.1 (i.e. husband of
defacto complainant) are booked in the instant proceeding under section
85/305/351(3)/3 (5) of the BNS 2023. It is needless to mention that one of
the essential ingredients to constitute offence under section 498A is that the
victim was subjected to “cruelty” as defined under that said section “by her
husband or the relative of the husband”. It is not in dispute that the instant
petitioners are neither the husband nor the relative of the husband.
Petitioner no.1, Purba Chatterjee is stated to be a student of Accused no.1
and currently engaged in research work. Petitioner no.2 Ayan Mazumder is a
student of accused no.1 and currently pursuing his studies. Petitioner no.3
is the husband of petitioner no.1 and petitioner no.4 is the son of petitioner
no.1 and 3, though his name has been wrongly written as ‘Souvik Dasgupta’
instead of ‘Soham Das Gupta’.
13.
At the cost of repetition the crux of the allegations in short is that the
complainant after her marriage to the principal accused no. 1 (who is not
the petitioner herein) was subjected to persistent physical violence, mental
torture, verbal abuse and public humiliation. She further alleged that her
husband had been maintaining an extra marital affair with petitioner no.1
herein since February 2025 and that the petitioners acting in conspiracy
with the husband frequently visited the complainant’s residence to
intimidate her with intent to extort money and forced her to vacate the
premises. Ultimately, on 03.07.2025 the said accused no.1 along with
petitioner no.1 and petitioner no.3 herein attempted to forcefully evict her
from her matrimonial home. Upon her refusal to vacate, it is further alleged
that the principle accused unlawfully absconded with his personal
belongings as well as articles belonging to the complainant thereby
committing theft and he also caused criminal intimidation.
14.
Now one of the essential ingredients to constitute offence under
section 85 of the BNS is that the prosecution is required to prove that the
victim was subjected to “cruelty” as defined in the said section “by her
husband or any relative of the husband”. In view of the ratio laid down in the
judgment of U. Suvetha Vs. State by Inspector of Police and Another
reported in (2009) 6 SCC 757 a girl friend or associate cannot be treated as
a relative. The petitioners are neither the husband nor the relative of the
husband either by blood, marriage or adoption. Therefore, the petitioners
are not falling within the definition of the word “relative” as defined in the
said judgement which reads as follows:-
“10. In the absence of any statutory definition, the term “relative” must be
assigned a meaning as is commonly understood. Ordinarily it would
include father, mother, husband or wife, son, daughter, brother, sister,
nephew or niece, grandson or granddaughter of an individual or the
spouse of any person. The meaning of the word “relative” would depend
upon the nature of the statute. It principally includes a person related by
blood, marriage or adoption.”
15.
Learned Counsel for the petitioners has also taken an alibi that the
school attendance record dated 03.07.2025 shows that on that date i.e. on
03.07.2025, petitioner no. 1 was discharging her professional duties as an
Assistant Teacher from 10.30 to 4.30 P.M. Even though such document,
filed along with this application cannot be said to be an unimpeachable
document but fact remains that neither petitioner no.1 nor the other
petitioners are the relative of principle accused no.1. Therefore, the
allegation do not contain the ingredient required to constitute the offence
under section 85 of the BNSS against the present petitioners
16.
Now in order to constitute the offence under section 305 of the BNS
the prosecution is required to show prima facie that the petitioners
herein/accused persons removed movable property and they removed the
property out of the possession of the complainant, without her consent with
a dishonest contention from her dwelling unit. In the present case from the
FIR it is clear that in para 5 the defacto complainant has specifically stated
that on the date of occurrence, the principal accused acting in collusion
with petitioner no.1 herein attempted to forcibly evict the complainant from
her matrimonial residence and upon complainant’s rightful refusal to
vacate, the principal accused i.e. accused no.1 (who is not the petitioner
herein) unlawfully absconded with his personal belongings as well as
articles belonging to the complainant, thereby committed theft. Therefore,
from the FIR it is abundantly clear that the complainant has attributed the
entire allegation of theft at her dwelling house only against her husband/
accused no.1 and not against any of the petitioners herein and therefore,
section 305 of the BNS has got no application in the instant proceeding, so
far as the present petitioners are concerned.
17.
Now section 351(3) of BNS, deals with the commission of offence of
criminal intimidation by threatening to cause death or grievous hurt or to
cause destruction of any property by fire or to cause an offence punishable
with death or imprisonment for life or imprisonment upto seven years or to
impute unchastity to a women. Therefore, one of the essential ingredients of
the offence under the section is that accused threatened the victim with
injury to her person reputation or property and he did so with intent to
cause alarm to the victim of offence and the accused did so to cause the
victim to perform any act which he was not legally bound to do. In the FIR it
has been only alleged in para 6 as follows:‘that the principle accused has been habitually perpetrating physical violence
upon the complainant causing grievous hurt and endangering her physical and
mental well-being’
18.
Criminal intimidation as defined in the Sanhita states that in the first
part there must be an act of threating another with injury to his person,
reputation or property or to the person or reputation of anyone in which
that person is interested and in the second part which refers the intent with
which the threatening is carried out is either to cause alarm to the person
threatened or to do any act which he is not legally bound to do or omit to do
any act which that person is legally entitled to do as the means of avoiding
the execution of threat.
19.
From the above quoted complaint, it is quite clear that the defacto
complainant has also not attributed any allegation of criminal intimidation
against the present petitioners but only against the principal accused. Since
the allegation in the FIR has been attributed against the principal accused
No.1 only, the allegation of criminal intimidation under section 351 (3) has
also got no application against the present petitioners.
20.
Now so far as the allegation under section 3(5) of BNS 2023 is
concerned two factors must be established. One is common intention and
second is participation of the accused in the commission of an offence.
Section 3(5) deals with constructive criminal liability and it provides that
where a criminal act is done by several persons in furtherance of the
common intention of all, each of such persons is liable for that act in the
same manner, as if it was done by him alone.
21.
In the instant case as I have stated above that section 85/3(5) of the
BNS has got no application against the petitioners since they are neither
husband nor the relative of the husband of the defacto complainant and so
far as allegation under section 305/3(5) and 351(3)/3(5) are concerned it
has also got no application in the present context against the present
petitioners in view of the fact that the FIR clearly discloses that entire
allegation under 305 and 351(3) have been attributed against husband of
the defacto complainant and not against the present petitioners. Since the
husband of defacto complainant/accused no.1 is not before this Court, I
have not examined the role played by the said accused no.1 in committing
the offence. Nevertheless since the allegations under section 305 and 351(3)
has been solely attributed against the husband of the defacto complainant,
it does not attract the word “in furtherance” as used in section 3(5) because
the word “furtherance” indicates some kind of aid or assistance producing
an effect i.e. advancement or promotion, but such allegation is completely
lacking in the present context against the petitioners. In the entire petition
of complaint, nowhere the role played by any of the petitioners in the alleged
crime has been mentioned separately or clearly. Therefore, even if all the
averment made in the FIR are taken to be correct, the case for prosecution
under sections 85/ 305/351 (3)/3(5) is not made out against the present
petitioners
22.
Therefore in order to make out a case against the present petitioners
the materials left for consideration of the court is only mentioning of the
names of the petitioners with non-specific, allegations as appearing from the
FIR. The allegation that the petitioners in connivance with principle accused
have tried to oust her from her matrimonial home may apparently espouse
the sentiments of people, though are not sufficient to set a criminal process
in motion against the petitioners who are mostly the students and
researchers working under the principle accused no.1 and who have the
constitutionally guaranteed right to have a free peaceful and unblemished
life, unless sufficient prima facie material is there against them, justifying
their sacrificing such freedom.
23.
In Bhajanlal’s Case, (1992) supp 1 SCC 335 the Apex Court stated
that though it may not be possible to lay down any precise or clearly
defined, sufficiently channelized an inflexible guidelines or rigid formula or
to give an exhaustive list of myriad kind of cases, where jurisdiction under
section 482 of the Code/528 of the BNSS for quashing of an FIR should be
exercised, but there are circumstances where the court may be justified in
exercising such jurisdiction, which includes where the FIR does not prima
facie constitute any offence or does not disclose a cognizable offence against
the accused justifying investigation by the police.
24.
For the reasons as discussed above, this court is constrained to find
that the FIR or other materials available in this case do not disclose a
cognizable offence to have been made out against the petitioners herein.
Apparently this case
is the outcome of the matrimonial disharmony
between the defacto complainant and the principle accused no.1 and
therefore for the reasons as mentioned above this court cannot rule out
existence of any malicious or malafide intention in setting the criminal
justice system in motion against the petitioners herein. It is settled law that
the court must ensure that criminal prosecution is not used as an
instrument of harassment or for seeking private vendetta or with an ulterior
motive to pressurize the petitioners.
25.
Hence it is ordered that the CGR case no. 2086/2025 presently
pending before learned Chief Judicial Magistrate is hereby quashed quo the
petitioners namely Purba Chatterjee, Ayan Mazumder, Surajit Biswas @
Surojit Biswas and Soham Dasgupta (wrongly named as Souvik Das
Gupta in the FIR). Since no affidavit is invited the allegations contained in
the petition of complaint against the petitioners are deemed to have been
denied by the petitioners.
26.
CRR 5550 of 2025 thus stand disposed of.
27.
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this Judgment, if applied for, be
given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(DR. AJOY KUMAR MUKHERJEE, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review