Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.687 of 2024
Purabi Roy (Saha)
W/O: Late Nepal Kanti Roy,
R/O: Vill: Pabiachara, Kailashahar, North Tripura.
------ Petitioners
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by its Secretary, Department of Finance,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
2. The Secretary,
Department of Urban Development Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin- 799010.
3. Kumarghat Municipal Council,
To be represented by the Chief Executive Officer, Kumarghat
Municipal Council, Kumarghat, Unokoti, Tripura.
------ Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. A. Debbarma, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G. A.
Date of hearing
and delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
20.01.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
:
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order(Oral)
By means of filing this writ petition, the petitioner has
prayed for the following reliefs:
i) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why
a
writ
in
the
nature
of
Mandamus
and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like nature
shall not be issued whereby directing the Respondents to
make the full and final payment of Gratuity with interest
@ 9% per annum to the Petitioner w.e.f. the date on
which gratuity became payable till date of payment after
adjusting lump sum amount of Rs 8,47,900/- already
paid.
ii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders
and/or direction/directions of like nature shall not be
issued whereby directing the Respondents to pay the
Petitioner interest @ 9% per annum on Rs 1,80,827/-,
w.e.f., 01.02.2019 to 23.10.2019.
iii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders
and/or direction/directions of like nature shall not be
issed whereby directing the Respondents to pay interest
@ 9% per annum to the Petitioner Rs.1,24,592/- w.e.f.
01.02.2019 to 08.01.2020.
iv) Make the rules absolute.
v) Call for records.
vi) Pass any further order/orders as this Hon’ble High
Court considers fit and proper.
AND
For this act of kindness, your humble Petitioners as in
duty bound shall ever pray.
2.
Heard Learned Counsel Ms. A. Debbarma representing the
petitioner and also heard Learned Addl. G.A., Mr. M. Debbarma
appearing on behalf of the State-respondents.
3.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Counsel for the
petitioner first of all drawn the attention of this Court that the
husband of the petitioner namely Nepal Kanti Roy was an employee
under Kumarghat Municipal Council and discharged his functions as
Town Supervisor and on attaining the age of superannuation, he
retired from service on 31.12.2018 from the same post (Annexure2).
4.
The Chief Executive Officer, Kumarghat Municipal Council in
this regard issued one release order from which it appears that he
was released from that office on 31.12.2018 (Annexure-3).
5.
After that, the Deputy Chief Executive Officer, Kumarghat
Municipal Council under Unokoti District issued Pension Payment
Order of said Nepal Kanti Roy on 22.09.2020 (Annexure-4).
6.
In the mean time, the Director, Directorate of Urban
Development approached the Chief Executive Officer, Kumarghat
Municipal Council by a communication dated 09.09.2019 requesting
him to make payment of Rs.1,80,827/- towards payment of gratuity
out of total amount of Rs.7,23,308/- to said Nepal Kanti Roy, Retired
Town Supervisor (Annexure-5) and accordingly, the Chief Executive
Officer, Kumarghat Municipal Council issued two sanction memos on
30.01.2019 and 23.10.2019 by which an amount of Rs.5,42,481/being the provisional gratuity and further amount of Rs.1,80,827/being the balance 25% of gratuity amount were sanctioned in favour
of Nepal Kanti Roy (Annexure-6 and 7). Further, according to
Learned Counsel, said Nepal Kanti Roy expired on 06.12.2023 and
the Deputy Chief Executive Officer issued one death certificate on
13.12.2023 in this regard (Annexure-8).
7.
Thereafter, the SDM, Kumarghat, Unakoti issued survival
certificate
on
03.02.2024
(Annexure-9)
showing
the
present
petitioner Smt. Purabi Roy Saha, his wife, Mr. Nabarun Roy, his son
and Mrs. Anamika Roy, his daughter as his legal heirs.
8.
Thereafter, the petitioner issued legal notice through her
concerned Learned Advocate on 17.05.2024 (Annexure-10) to the
respondents for releasing the remaining amount of Gratuity with 9%
interest for deferred payment of Gratuity. But as there was some
typographical error in the legal notice so the petitioner further served
legal notice upon the respondents by another communication dated
02.09.2024 (Annexure-11) and accordingly, the Joint Director, Urban
Development Department made reply to the said legal notice on
09.09.2024
(Annexure-12)
and
the
Deputy
CEO,
Kumarghat
Municipal Council also made reply to the legal notice on 21.06.2024
(Annexure-13). But as the issue of the present petitioner was not
addressed by the respondents properly so the present petitioner has
filed this writ petition seeking the reliefs as mentioned above.
9.
Learned Counsel at the time of hearing further drawn the
attention of this Court that in para No.10 of the writ petition, it was
stated by the petitioner that vide Notification dated 06.10.2018, the
basic pay of Nepal Kanti Roy(since dead) was enhanced to
Rs.55,600/- from Rs.47,430/- as per the TSCS(Revised Pay) (First
Amendment) Rules, 2018 and, as such, considering the length of
qualifying service of the husband of the petitioner, said Nepal Kanti
Roy was entitled to Rs.9,62,307/- as gratuity but according to
Learned Counsel, the respondents have wrongly calculated the
amount and in the counter affidavit in para No.5, according to them,
a sum of Rs.8,47,900/- was shown which was not proper as per the
relevant provisions of the payment of Gratuity Act. So, Learned
Counsel finally urged for allowing relief to the petitioner.
10.
On the other hand, Learned Addl. G.A. appearing on behalf
of the respondents opposed the submission made by Learned
Counsel for the petitioner and submitted that in para No.5 of the
counter
affidavit,
the
respondents
have
mentioned
the
total
entitlement of the deceased husband of the petitioner and the Staterespondents by this time has already released Rs.8,47,900/- and, as
such, the petitioner is not entitled to any further amount.
For the sake of convenience, the relevant portion of para
No.5 of the counter affidavit is mentioned herein below:
“Thereafter, TSCS (Revised Pay) (First Amendments)
Rules-2018 has come into force and after adoption by the
Administrative Authority as being autonomous body, on
revised calculation of gratuity increased to Rs.8,47,900/and accordingly, balance revised amount of Rs. (8,47,900
–
7,23,308/-)
=1,24,592/-
has
been
released
subsequently. So, 75% and 25% of gratuity amount has
been sanctioned and released within the prescribed period
and the last revised gratuity has been sanctioned after
adoption of the TSCS (Revised Pay) (First Amendments)
Rules-2018 and therefore, no delay has been occurred on
the part of the respondent state.”
11.
I have heard detailed argument of both the sides and also
gone through the relevant papers submitted by the parties in this
writ petition. At the time of hearing, Learned Addl. G.A. also drawn
the attention of this Court the communication dated 21.06.2024
written by Deputy Chief Executive Officer, Kumarghat Municipal
Council to Miss A. Debbarma, the Learned Counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioner and submitted that the respondents have
already paid the said sum of Rs.8,47,900/- and after releasing of the
said amount, no further amount is due to said deceased husband of
the petitioner and, as such, the present petition is not maintainable.
12.
Now, after hearing both the sides, it appears that the
gratuity amount as aforesaid has not been paid to the husband of
the petitioner in terms of the relevant provisions of the payment of
the gratuity Act, 1972.
Section 7(3) of the payment of gratuity Act provides that:
7. Determination of the amount of gratuity.(3) The employer shall arrange to pay the
amount of gratuity within thirty days from the
date it becomes payable to the person to whom
the gratuity is payable.
From the above provision, it is clear that the employer shall
arrange to pay the amount of gratuity within one month from the
date of superannuation on retirement of said Nepal Kanti Roy. Here
in this case, said Nepal Kanti Roy proceeded on retirement on
31.12.2018 which is also duly been admitted by the Staterespondents and there is no dispute on that.
13.
Now, sub-section(2) of Section 4 along with explanation of
the payment of gratuity Act provides as under:
4. Payment of gratuity.(2) For every completed year of service or part
thereof in excess of six months, the employer shall
pay gratuity to an employee at the rate of fifteen
days’ wages based on the rate of wages last drawn
by the employee concerned:
Provided that in the case of a piece-rated employee,
daily wages shall be computed on the average of
the total wages received by him for a period of
three
months
immediately
preceding
the
termination of his employment, and, for this
purpose, the wages paid for any overtime work
shall not be taken into account:
Provided further that in the case of an employee
who is employed in a seasonal establishment and
who is not so employed throughout the year, the
employer shall pay the gratuity at the rate of seven
days’ wages for each season.
Explanation.- In the case of a monthly rated
employee, the fifteen days’ wages shall be
calculated by dividing the monthly rate of wages
last drawn by him by twenty-six and multiplying the
quotient by fifteen.
From the aforesaid provision, it is clear that how the amount
is to be calculated.
14.
Here in this case, the present petitioner in para No.11 of the
writ petition calculated the amount of gratuity as follows:
Calculation of Gratuity (55,600) x 15 x 30 years
=Rs 9,62,307/-
On the other hand, the State-respondents in para No.5 of
the counter affidavit has shown the amount of calculation of service
gratuity of said Nepal Kanti Roy as follows:
Based on TSCS (Revised Pay) (First Amendments) Rules2018, the Basic Pay of Nepal Kanti Roy, the husband of
the petitioner is Rs.55,600/- and as per calculation the
Service gratuity is Rs.8,47,900/- and the calculation
would be like as:
55600 x 61
=8,47,900/-
But it is not clear as to how the said amount was calculated
by the respondent-authority.
15.
From the communication dated 21.06.2024 as already
stated,
it
appears
that
vide
memo
No.F.1(8)/CEO/KGT/MC/P-
III/PEN/2018-19/3556-60; Dt.30/01/2019, the respondent-authority
released an amount of Rs.5,42,481/- which was within the specified
time period as mentioned in sub-section 3 of Section 7 of payment of
gratuity Act. Thereafter, the respondent-authority further released
an amount of Rs.1,80,827/- vide memo No.F.1(8)/CEO/KGT/MC/PIII/PEN/2019-20/1856-60; Dt.23/10/2019 i.e. after elapsing of
almost 09(nine) months from the specified time period and after
that, the respondents further released an amount of Rs.1,24,592/vide
Memo
No.F.1(8)/CEO/KGT/MC/P-III/PEN/2019-20/177-80;
Dt.08/01/2020 i.e. almost after 1(one) year from the date of
retirement of said Nepal Kanti Roy. The respondent-authority in the
counter affidavit took the plea that after the amendment of TSCS
(Revised Pay) (First Amendment) rules of 2018 came into force and
after adoption by the Administrative authority being an autonomous
body, the revised calculation of gratuity increased to Rs.8,47,900/from Rs.7,23,308/-. But the respondent-authority in their counter
affidavit could not give any specific account how they have calculated
the amount of Rs.8,47,900/- where they themselves admitted in
their notification dated 06.10.2018 that the basic pay of Nepal Kanti
Roy was enhanced to Rs.55,600/- from Rs.47,430/- as per TSCS
(Revised Pay) (First Amendment) Rules of 2018 and infact, said
Nepal Kanti Roy went on superannuation on retirement after the
introduction of TSCS (Revised Pay) (First Amendment) Rules, 2018.
In course of hearing, Learned Addl. G.A. submitted that if there is
any error in the calculation then the respondent-authority shall pay
the balance amount to the petitioner.
16.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner in course of hearing also
relied upon Annexure-14 i.e. another notification dated 08.04.1997
of the Government of Tripura, Finance Department wherein in para
No.4(a) & 4(b), the following clauses are mentioned:
4. The prescribe rate of interest will be
a. beyond 3 month after the gratuity becomes due and
up to one year 7 % per annum.
b. beyond one year, 10% per annum
The interest would be payable till the end of moth
prescribe the month in which the payment of DCR
gratuity is actually due.
In this case, the first amount of Rs.5,42,481/- was released
on 30.01.2019, i.e., within the stipulated period prescribed under the
Act but the second amount, i.e., Rs.1,80,827/-, was released on
23.10.2019, i.e., after a considerable period following his retirement
on 31.12.2018. As such, in my considered view, the petitioner is
entitled to get interest at the rate of 7% per annum on the said
amount. Subsequently, the third amount, i.e. Rs.1,24,592/-, was
released on 08.01.2020 i.e., more than a year later. Therefore, the
petitioner is further entitled to get 10% interest per annum on the
said amount.
17.
From the counter affidavit and also after hearing the
submission made by Learned Addl. G.A. appearing on behalf of the
State-respondents, it appears that the calculation as shown by the
State-respondents in their counter affidavit was not proper and not
in accordance with the specific provision of the Act. As such, the
petitioner is entitled to get the balance amount as per calculation
made in para No.11 of the writ petition filed by the present petitioner
which may come to Rs.1,14,407/- excluding interest.
18.
In the result, the writ petition filed by the petitioner is
allowed. The petitioner is entitled to interest at the rate of 7% per
annum with effect from 01.02.2019 to 23.10.2019 on Rs.1,80,827/and the petitioner is further entitled to interest at the rate of 10%
per annum on amount of Rs.1,24,592/- with effect from 01.02.2019
to 08.01.2020 and in addition to that, the petitioner is also entitled
to the balance amount of Rs.1,14,407/- as per calculation with
applicable interest as made in para No.11 of the writ petition after
deducting the amount of Rs.8,47,900/- already been paid by the
respondent-authority in favour of the petitioner. The respondentauthority shall pay the said amount with interest as mentioned above
within a period of 4(four) months from the date of passing of this
Judgment/order.
With these observations, this writ petition stands disposed
of.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.01.24 18:20:22
-08'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review