The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. 12.2023 All the writ petitions involve similar grievances by individual petitioners in relation to the recruitment exercise conducted under advertisement dated 12.02.2021 by the Joint Recruitment Board Tripura (JRBT, for short) under Directorate of Employment Services and Manpower Planning, Government of Tripura for filling up the posts of Lower Division Clerk; Junior Operator (Pump); Junior Multitasking Operator (Uncommon); Agriculture Assistant (except TAFS Grade III); Agriculture Assistant (TAFS Grade III) totaling 2410 posts at Annexure-2. All these writ petitioners have participated in the recruitment exercise. There individual cases are being separate recorded hereinafter. Petitioner Pritam Barman in WP(C) No.728 of 2023 belongs to SC category and participated in the recruitment exercise for the post of Junior Operator (Pump) as first preference; Junior Multi-tasking Operator (Uncommon) as second preference; Agriculture Assistant (except TAFS Grade III) as third preference; and Agriculture Assistant (TAFS Grade III) as fourth preference. According to the petitioner, as per the merit list published by the JRBT on 13.09.2023, the last successful candidate in SC category to the post of Junior Operator (Pump) got 90 marks whose name is at Sl. No.1953. As per the information obtained under RTI vide Annexure-7, petitioner has got 103 marks in the same category. The petitioner, …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No.728 of 2023
WP(C) No.729 of 2023
WP(C) No.730 of 2023
WP(C) No.731 of 2023
WP(C) No.732 of 2023
IN WP(C) No.728 of 2023
Sri Pritam Barman
......... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
State of Tripura and others
...... Respondent(s)
IN WP(C) No.729 of 2023
Sri Subrata Dey
......... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
State of Tripura and others
...... Respondent(s)
IN WP(C) No.730 of 2023
Sri Debasish Saha
......... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
State of Tripura and others
...... Respondent(s)
IN WP(C) No.731 of 2023
Sri Suman Debnath
......... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
State of Tripura and others
...... Respondent(s)
IN WP(C) No.732 of 2023
Sri Bapan Saha
......... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
State of Tripura and others
...... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Dipankar Sharma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
_O_R_D_E_R_
14.12.2023
All the writ petitions involve similar grievances by individual
petitioners in relation to the recruitment exercise conducted under
advertisement dated 12.02.2021 by the Joint Recruitment Board Tripura (JRBT,
for short) under Directorate of Employment Services and Manpower Planning,
Government of Tripura for filling up the posts of Lower Division Clerk; Junior
Operator (Pump); Junior Multitasking Operator (Uncommon); Agriculture
Assistant (except TAFS Grade III); Agriculture Assistant (TAFS Grade III)
totaling 2410 posts at Annexure-2. All these writ petitioners have participated
in the recruitment exercise. There individual cases are being separate recorded
hereinafter.
Petitioner Pritam Barman in WP(C) No.728 of 2023 belongs to SC
category and participated in the recruitment exercise for the post of Junior
Operator (Pump)
as
first
preference;
Junior Multi-tasking
Operator
(Uncommon) as second preference; Agriculture Assistant (except TAFS Grade
III) as third preference; and Agriculture Assistant (TAFS Grade III) as fourth
preference. According to the petitioner, as per the merit list published by the
JRBT on 13.09.2023, the last successful candidate in SC category to the post of
Junior Operator (Pump) got 90 marks whose name is at Sl. No.1953. As per the
information obtained under RTI vide Annexure-7, petitioner has got 103 marks
in the same category. The petitioner, therefore, served a legal notice vide
annexure-8 upon the concerned respondents before approaching this Court in
relation to his grievances. Petitioner has prayed for revision of the merit list and
inclusion of his name for the said post.
Petitioner Subrata Dey in WP(C) No.729 of 2023 belongs to UR
category and participated in the recruitment exercise under the aforesaid
advertisement for appointment to the post of Junior Operator (Pump) as first
preference; Junior Multi-tasking Operator (Uncommon) as second preference;
Agriculture Assistant (except TAFS Grade III) as third preference; and
Agriculture Assistant (TAFS Grade III) as fourth preference. According to the
petitioner, as per the merit list published by the JRBT dated 13.09.2023, the last
successful candidate in UR category to the post of Junior Multi-tasking
Operator (uncommon) got 86 marks whose name is at Sl. No.1965. As per the
information obtained under RTI vide Annuexure-7, the petitioner has got 102
marks in the same category. The petitioner, therefore, served a legal notice
upon the concerned respondents vide Annexure-9 and thereafter has
approached this Court with the same prayer.
Petitioner Debasish Saha in WP(C) No.730 of 2023 belongs to UR
category and participated in the recruitment exercise for the post of Junior
Operator (Pump)
as
first
preference;
Junior Multi-tasking
Operator
(Uncommon) as second preference; Lower Division Clerk as third preference;
Agriculture Assistant (except TAFS Grade III) as fourth preference; and
Agriculture Assistant (TAFS Grade III) as fifth preference. According to the
petitioner, as per the merit list published by the JRBT dated 13.09.2023, the last
successful candidate in UR category to the post of Junior Operator (Pump) got
88 marks whose name is at Sl. No.1963. As per the information obtained under
RTI vide Annexure-7, petitioner has got 107 marks in the same category. The
petitioner, therefore, served a legal notice upon the concerned respondents vide
Annexure-8 and thereafter has approached this Court with the same prayer.
Petitioner Suman Debnath in WP(C) No.731 of 2023 belongs to
UR category and participated in the recruitment exercise for the post of Lower
Division Clerk as first preference; Agriculture Assistant (except TAFS Grade
III) as second preference; Agriculture Assistant(TAFS Grade III) as third
preference; Junior Operator (Pump) as fourth preference and Junior
Multitasking Operator(Uncommon) as fifth preference. According to the
petitioner, the merit list published by the JRBT dated 13.09.2023, the last
successful candidates in UR category to the post of LDC got 69 marks whose
name is at Sl. No.1978. As per the information obtained under RTI, vide
Annexure-7, petitioner has got 108 marks in the same category. The petitioner,
therefore, served a legal notice upon the concerned respondents vide Annexure8 and thereafter has approached this Court with the same prayer.
Petitioner Bapan Saha in WP(C) No.732 of 2023 belongs to UR
category and participated in the recruitment exercise for the post of Junior
Operator (Pump) as first preference; Junior Multitasking Operator (Uncommon)
as second preference; Agriculture Assistant(TAFS Grade III) as third
preference. According to the petitioner, as per the merit list published by the
JRBT dated 13.09.2023, the last successful candidate in UR category for the
post of Junior Operator (Pump) got 88 marks whose name is at Sl. No.1963. As
per the information obtained under RTI vide Annexure-7, the petitioner has got
97 marks in the same category. The petitioner, therefore, served a legal notice
upon the respondents vide Annexure-8 and thereafter has approached this Court
with the same prayer.
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel for the petitioner
assisted by Mr. D. Saha, learned counsel submits that the preparation of merit
list appears to be flawed as in individual cases as per information obtained
under RTI, these petitioners have found that they have got more marks than the
last successful candidate in that category for the respective posts for which they
have given the first preference. As such, they have approached this Court since
their grievances were not being redressed at the level of the respondent-Board
and the competent authority.
Learned Additional Government Advocate Mr. Dipankar Sharma
submits that inconsistent pleadings have been made by some of the writ
petitioners about their claims for being considered for appointment to a
particular post as the order of preference of the petitioners vary whereas the
reference of the last successful candidate for a particular post does not appear to
tally with the pleadings. In such circumstances, since the matter has been taken
up for the first time to today, he is not in a position to controvert the averments
made by the individual writ petitioners. The applications and the marks scored
by individual petitioners and those who have been declared successful in the
merit list are in the custody of the JRBT which is the recruiting body. In case,
the Court deems it proper the petitioners may be remitted to the JRBT for
redressal of their grievances though as of now from their pleadings no choate
cause of action seems to arise. In case upon scrutiny of the claims of individual
petitioner the JRBT finds that there is any substance in the case of individual
petitioners, they may consider inclusion of their names in the merit list and
make appropriate recommendation to the appointing authority thereafter.
However, this Court may not observe anything on the merits of the case of the
petitioners either way at this stage.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
petitioners and the State. Individual petitioners in substance have set up their
case that certain candidates having lower marks in their category with the same
preference have been recommended whereas the petitioners have been left out.
These contentions are subject to scrutiny by the recruitment board. At this stage
this Court does not deem it necessary and proper to make any comments on the
rival cases of the parties. It has been pointed out by learned counsel for the
State that in some of the writ petitions the petitioners have made inconsistent
pleadings in the sense that whereas concerned petitioners have applied for a
particular post in first preference, the reference point of the last selected
candidate as per them is of a candidate who has been recommended for some
other posts. As such, at this instance, instead of commenting on the individual
cases of the petitioners and taking into consideration that against 2410 total
vacancies recommendations have been made in respect of only 1980 posts as
per the merit list published by the recruitment board, the JRBT should examine
the case of the individual petitioners upon scrutiny of their applications and the
relevant records to arrive at a considered decision whether the petitioners have
been arbitrarily left out from the merit list whereas candidates having lower
marks than them have been included in their category for the post for which the
petitioners had given their first preference. It is also informed by the learned
counsel for the petitioner that recommended candidates have been offered
appointment. In such a situation, the petitioners are granted liberty to approach
the Chairman, JRBT, respondent No.4 in respect of their grievances by filing a
representation enclosing the copy of the writ petitions also within a period of
1(one) week. Respondent No.4 would consider the representation of the
petitioner, in accordance with law, within a period of 4(four) weeks thereafter.
Upon such consideration if it is found that the grievance of the petitioner is
genuine and legitimate, it would be open for the JRBT to revise the merit list by
including the name of one or the other petitioner whose case has been found to
be genuine and to recommend to the competent authority for appointment to the
respective post to which they are eligible and found successful. The decision be
also communicated to the individual petitioners as per the address indicated in
their representation/writ petition thereafter. If the individual petitioner is
adversely affected by such decision he is at liberty to raise his grievances again
in an appropriate proceeding.
Writ petitions are disposed of accordingly. Pending application(s),
if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
DIPESH DEB
DIPESH DEB
Date: 2023.12.18
14:55:16 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review