Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH
DATED THIS THE 31ST DAY OF JANUARY 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.100353 OF 2019 (PAR/POS-)
BETWEEN:
PREMALATHA W/O. KETHAN CHADDA,
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. B-93, NEELKANT VILLAGE,
NEAR RAJAN MATHRE OFFICE, NERIVALI ROAD,
DOMBIVILI (E), KALYAN, MAHARASHTRA.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. ARAVIND D. KULKARNI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
VIJAYALAKSHMI
M KANKUPPI
1.
GIRIJA W/O. MAHANTAPPA JANGERI @ PYATI,
AS PER ORDER DATED 18.08.2022, THE LRS OF
DECEASED R1 (R2 TO R6) ARE ON RECORD,
AMENDED AS PER MEMO FILED FOR TREATING R2 TO R6
AS LRS OF DECEASED R1
2.
JAGADISH S/O. MAHANTAPPA JANGERI @PYATI,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS, OCC. BUSINESS,
R/O PANCHAXARI NAGAR, GADAG-582101.
3.
MANJUNATH S/O. MAHANTAPPA JANGERI @ PYATI,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS, OCC. BUSINESS,
R/O PANCHAXARI NAGAR, GADAG-582101.
4.
LAXMI W/O. JAGADISH JANGERI @ PYATI,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
VIJAYALAKSHMI M
KANKUPPI
Date: 2026.02.18
10:57:35 +0530
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
R/O PANCHAXARI NAGAR, GADAG-582101.
5.
VIKAS S/O. JAGADISH JANGERI @ PYATI,
AGED ABOUT 16 YEARS,
OCC. STUDENT, GADAG
MINOR/GUARDIAN BY GUARDIAN MOTHER
LAXMI W/O. JAGADISH JANGERI @ PYATI,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. PANCHAXARI NAGAR, GADAG-582101.
6.
PUTTARAJ S/O. MANJUNATH JANGERI @ PYATI,
AGED ABOUT 11 YEARS,
OCC. STUDENT,
MINOR/GUARDIAN BY GUARDIAN MOTHER,
CHETANA W/O MANJUNATH JANGERI @ PYATI,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. PANCHAXARI NAGAR, GADAG-582101.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. SABEEL AHAMED, ADVOCATE FOR R2 TO R6;
R2 TO R6 ARE LRS OF R1)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC, PRAYING TO
ALLOW THIS APPEAL AND BY SETTING ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND
DECREE IN O.S.NO.24/2018 PASSED BY ADDL. SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE,
GADAG ON 20TH APRIL 2019 THEREBY DISMISSING THE SUIT OF
PLAINTIFF IN SO FAR AS SUIT SCHEDULED 2, 3, 8 TO 11 PROPERTIES
ARE CONCERNED AND CONSEQUENTLY DECREE THE SUIT OF THE
PLAINTIFF BY HOLDING THAT APPELLANT HEREIN ALSO ENTITLED
FOR 1/4TH SHARE IN THE SAID PROPERTIES AND ETC.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.)
This is the appeal filed by appellant/plaintiff under Section
96 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, praying for setting aside the
judgment
and
decree
dated
20.04.2019
passed
in
O.S.No.24/2018 on the file of Additional Senior Civil Judge,
Gadag, in respect of dismissing the suit over suit schedule item
Nos.2, 3, 8 to 11 of properties.
2.
Parties would be referred with their ranks, as they
were before trial Court for sake of convenience and clarity.
3.
Plaintiff is the daughter of defendant No.1 and one
Mahantappa Jangeri. Mahantappa had two sons and a daughter
i.e. defendant Nos.2 & 3, plaintiff; defendant No.1 is wife of
deceased Mahantappa Jangeri. Defendant No.4 is the wife of
defendant No.2, defendant No.5 is the son of defendant No.2 and
defendant No.6 is the son of defendant No.3. Plaintiff has filed
the suit praying for partition and separate possession of her 1/4th
share in all suit schedule properties by metes and bounds.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
4.
The contention of plaintiff is that all suit schedule
properties are the ancestral and joint family properties of plaintiff
and
defendants.
Plaintiff
being
daughter
of
deceased-
Mahantappa Jangeri who died on 27.07.2017 is a coparcener as
per Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act of 2005 (in short, the
Act, 2005) and thus, she is entitled for share in all the suit
schedule properties by metes and bounds.
5.
Defendant No.2 filed his written statement which is
being adopted by defendant Nos.1, 3 to 6, wherein they have
admitted
the
relationship
between
parties.
However,
the
contention of defendants is that, at the time of marriage of
plaintiff, in view of her share, she has taken 10 tolas gold, 10
tolas silver and two lakhs cash for settling her family life. Hence,
she is not entitled for any share in suit schedule properties. They
have taken contention that some of the suit schedule properties
were self-acquired properties and are purchased in the name of
defendant
No.1.
Thus,
those
properties
are
her
absolute
properties. Furthermore, there is already partition between
defendant No.1 and her husband. Defendant No.1 has executed
registered gift deeds dated 03.06.2015 and 23.02.2015 and they
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
are legal documents and thus, conveyed some of the properties
in favour of defendant Nos.4 to 6. Hence, plaintiff is not entitled
for any relief prayed in the plaint and prayed for dismissal of suit
with costs.
6.
Based on above pleadings, the following issues were
framed before the trial Court:
ISSUES
“1. Whether the plaintiffs prove that, she and
defendants are the members of Hindu Joint
Family and suit properties are their joint
family properties and available for partition?
2.
Whether the defendants prove that, the suit
schedule properties purchased in the name of
Mahantappa are the self acquired properties
of deceased Mahantappa contended in para
No.4 of their written statement?
3.
Whether the defendants proves that, the
properties mentioned in para No.5 of their
written statement are the self acquired
properties of defendant No.1?
4. Whether defendants further prove that, there
was already a partition held in the joint
family as contended in para No.6 of their
written statement?
5. Whether the defendants further prove that, the
defendant No.1 being the absolute owner
executed as of the property registered gift
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
deed dated 21.06.2017 as contended in para
No.6 of their written statement?
7.
6.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief
as claimed in plaint?
7.
What Order or decree?”
On behalf of plaintiff, plaintiff was examined as PW1,
got marked Exs.P1 to P47 and closed her side before trial Court.
On behalf of defendants, one of the defendants is examined as
DW1 and examined a witness as DW2, got marked Exs.D1 to D8
and closed their side.
8.
After hearing arguments of both sides, the learned
trial judge has decreed the suit in respect of item Nos.1, 4 to 7
and 12 of suit schedule properties and dismissed the suit in
respect of item Nos.2, 3, 8 to 11 of suit schedule properties.
9.
Aggrieved by dismissal of suit in respect of item
Nos.2, 3, 8 to 11, the present appeal is preferred by the plaintiff.
10.
During
pendency
of
this
appeal,
defendants/respondent Nos.2 to 6 have filed I.A.No.1/2025
under Order XLI Rule 27 of CPC with five documents.
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
11.
In the affidavit annexed to I.A.No.1/2025, one of the
respondents has stated that inadvertently, they could not
produce some documents. The certificate of registration issued
by
Small
Scale
Industries
Department
and
certificate
of
appreciations were kept in official files and were not available at
the time of tendering their evidence. The sale deed dated
12.07.2016, gift deeds dated 03.06.2015 and 20.06.2017 were
not traced and collected due to oversight and unavoidable
circumstances. Thus, in spite of exercise of due diligence, they
could not produce those documents. Now, they intend to produce
those documents to substantiate their contention. Hence, prayed
for allowing respondent Nos.1 to 6 to produce the additional
documents and to permit them to adduce additional evidence in
support of their case.
12.
Learned
counsel
for
appellant/plaintiff
has
filed
objections to I.A.No.1/2025, wherein, he contended that ample
opportunity
was
there
for
defendants
to
produce
these
documents because these documents were alleged to be the
earlier documents and available at the time of filing their written
statement and leading their evidence. In this appeal, the
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
respondents appeared in the year 2021. But only on 18.09.2025
i.e., about 4 years after filing of the appeal and service of notice
of appeal, respondents have filed the application without any
admissible
reason
and
hence,
prayed
for
dismissal
of
I.A.No.1/2025 with costs. In this regard, he relied on some
citations. He further contended that there was no pleading in
respect of some of these documents and hence, they cannot be
taken on record.
13.
Heard arguments of both sides on main appeal and
also on I.A.No.1/2025.
14.
Learned counsel for appellant Sri Aravind D. Kulkarni
would submit that item No.2 of suit schedule properties was
purchased
by
original
propositus
who
died
intestate
and
admittedly, it was purchased out of joint family nucleus. Item
No.3 of suit schedule properties was standing in the name of
original propositus and thus, it was also purchased by him. Item
Nos.8 to 11 are purchased in the name of defendant No.1 by
original propositus during his lifetime from 1991 onwards and
defendant No.1 had no independent source of income to
purchase those properties. Even, DW1 in his cross-examination
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
admitted that these properties were purchased by their father in
the name of his wife-defendant No.1. Original propositus could
not have executed gift deed in respect of item Nos.2 and 9 of
suit schedule properties because they were ancestral properties
and he being one of the coparceners, cannot execute gift deed in
respect of those properties without the consent of other
coparceners. Hence, it is void ab initio and said document was
produced only along with I.A.No.1/2025, without any admissible
reason and thus, cannot be looked into.
15.
Learned counsel for appellant would further submit
that admittedly, plaintiff married a person of other community
and thus, her parents were angry with her and they have not
attended her marriage and Ex.D8, the marriage invitation card
was concocted and learned trial judge has clearly held that it is a
concocted document and that finding is not questioned by
defendants. Under these circumstances, definitely no gold, silver
or cash was given to plaintiff by defendants or her father at the
time of her marriage. Hence, plaintiff is entitled for equal share
in all the suit schedule properties by metes and bounds.
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
16.
During pendency of this appeal, respondent No.1
died intestate. Plaintiff and defendant Nos.2 and 3, i.e., appellant
and respondent Nos.2 and 3 are her legal representatives and
they are already on record. Hence, her share is to be equally
divided amongst appellant and other defendant Nos.2 and 3.
Hence,
prayed
for
allowing
the
appeal
and
to
dismiss
I.A.No.1/2025.
17.
Learned counsel Sri Sabeel Ahamed for respondent
Nos.2 to 6 would submit that item No.2 of suit schedule
properties was purchased by original propositus in the year
1977, by his hard earning and thus, it was his self-acquired
property. Thus, he was having every right to execute registered
gift deed in favour of his wife in respect of said property and also
in respect of item No.9, which was also purchased in the year
1991.
18.
Learned
counsel
for
respondents
would
further
submit that plaintiff has not prayed for cancellation of registered
documents and also not even made a prayer that those
registered documents are not binding on her share. Hence, she
cannot pray for cancellation of those documents and further,
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
plaintiff has not established the existence of joint family nucleus
to purchase these properties either in the name of original
propositus or in the name of defendant No.1. Defendants have
fairly conceded for decree in respect of ancestral properties and
thus, they have not challenged the judgment and decree in
respect of granting share to plaintiff in respect of item Nos.1, 4
to 7 and 12 of suit schedule properties. Furthermore, he has
produced some documents along with this appeal, i.e., the
certificate issued by Directorate of Small Scale Industries in the
name of defendant No.1, to prove that defendant No.1 was
having independent source of income. He has also produced the
registered gift deed executed by original propositus in favour of
defendant No.1 on 03.06.2015 and thus, plaintiff cannot claim
any share in respect of item Nos.2 & 9 of suit schedule
properties. As far as item Nos.10 & 11 of suit schedule properties
are concerned, they are standing in the name of defendant No.1
and they are the absolute properties of defendant No.1.
Furthermore, defendant No.1 has executed registered gift deed
in favour of defendant Nos.4 to 6 in respect of item Nos.2 and 9
and thus, considering these aspects, the learned trial judge has
dismissed the suit. These documents produced along with
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
I.A.No.1/2025, were not in custody of defendant Nos.2 and 3 at
the time of filing their written statement or at the time of
tendering their evidence and they could not trace them and now,
they have traced those documents and they are proper and
necessary documents and relevant documents to establish the
contention of defendant Nos.2 to 6. Hence, prayed for allowing
I.A.No.1/2025.
19.
Having heard the arguments of both sides, verifying
the appeal records along with the trial Court records, the points
that arise for consideration are:
i.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for
share in item Nos.2, 3, 8 to 11 of suit
schedule properties?
ii.
Whether the learned trial judge erred
in not considering the claim of plaintiff
in
proper
manner
and
thus,
the
judgment and decree of trial Court on
those items is erroneous?
iii.
Whether interference of this Court on
the above said judgment and decree in
respect of item Nos.2, 3, 8 to 11 is
required?
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
iv.
Whether respondents be permitted to
adduce additional evidence?
20.
Findings on those points are in AFFIRMATIVE for the
following reasons:
21.
The admitted facts of the case are that defendant
Nos.2 & 3 are sons and plaintiff is the daughter of deceasedMahantappa Jangeri and defendant No.1- Girija. It is an admitted
fact that plaintiff married the person of another community on
19.11.2009.
22.
The contention of plaintiff is that item Nos.2, 3 & 8 to
11 are also the ancestral and joint family properties of plaintiff
and defendants and thus, she is entitled for share in those
properties.
23.
It is a fact that item No. 2 of suit schedule property is
purchased in the name of original propositus under registered
sale deed dated 21.02.1977. Ex.P.2-the record of rights of this
property stands in the name of original propositus. However,
Ex.P.2 reveals that its Pahani and mutation are not yet executed.
The plaintiff has not produced even a single document to show
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
that this property was purchased in the year-1977 by original
propositus and it is still in their family. Ex.P.2 will not establish
the said position. But defendants have produced Ex.D.6-Mutation
No.14894 to show that the original propositus has mortgaged
this property in favour of Society. There is no dispute that this
property belonged to the family, because defendants contended
that original propositus has executed registered gift deed in
favour of defendant No.1 in respect of this property during 2015
and now along with I.A.No.1/2025, they have produced the
Xerox copy of said gift deed. Now if revenue entries are not
standing in the name of the executants; then the revenue
authorities cannot register the document. Hence, considering
Ex.D.5 and admission of both sides, it could be said that, this
property was standing in the name of original propositus.
24.
As far as, item No.3 is concerned, plaintiff has
produced the property extract of 1994-95 to show that, it was
standing in the name of original propositus. This property is not
sold or alienated by family members as per the contention of
both sides. Hence, it was standing in the name of original
propositus.
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
25.
Item No.8 is re-survey No.444/A at plot No.5. Ex.P.7
is the R.T.C. extract of this property. It shows that, it was
standing in the name of defendant No.1. Ex.P.8 also establishes
that Item No.9 was standing in the name of defendant No.1. No
documents are produced in respect of Item No.10 of the
property. As far as Item No.11 is concerned, Ex.P.9 is produced.
This is the original registered sale deed dated 29.06.1977 in the
name
of defendant No.1. Now
along with I.A.No.1/2025,
defendants have produced the certified copy of sale deed dated
12.07.2016 and original gift deed dated 20.06.2017 executed by
defendant No.1 in favour of wife of defendant No.3. None of the
revenue records of said property is produced by either side. As
discussed earlier, these documents are recent documents and
the revenue authorities could not have allowed the party to
execute either sale deed or gift deed, if it is not standing in their
respective names.
26.
original
It is the specific contention of plaintiff/appellant that
propositus
was
not
having
any
right
to
execute
registered gift deed in favour of defendant No.1 in respect of
Item No.2 of suit schedule properties, because it was purchased
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
from the ancestral and joint family income. In this regard, the
cross-examination of DW.1 reveals that, DW.1 categorically
admitted that his father was having 3 acres 5 guntas and it is the
ancestral property of his father. When plaintiff established that,
there was some ancestral property, which was giving yield, it is
the duty of the person who is disputing its nature that, it was
purchased from hard earned money of original propositus and it
was his self-acquired property.
Furthermore, even in the Gift
deed, there is no recital that this is the self-acquired property of
deceased Mahantappa Jangeri. In this regard, no material is
produced by defendants. It is only deposed by DW.1 that his
father was doing Coolie work and purchased said property.
However, that cannot be accepted without any admissible
evidence. DW.2 also not deposed anything on these points.
27.
In the cross-examination, DW.1 admitted that his
father has purchased some of the properties in the name of his
mother (defendant No.1). However he has deposed that his
mother was doing tailoring and earning income. But he does not
know what her income was at that time. There shall be some
specific pleading regarding these facts. In this regard in the
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
written statement, it is only stated that some of the properties
were the self-acquired properties of their father and some of the
properties were purchased by defendant No.1 and they are her
absolute properties. However some material has to be placed
that, from which source the original propositus has purchased
those properties to which, defendants alleged that they are the
self-acquired properties of original perpetrators. In the absence
of such material, it cannot be said that Item No.2 of suit
schedule properties was the absolute property of deceased
original propositus-Mahantappa Jangeri.
28.
Generally, if any property stands in the name of a
female, then it would be her absolute property. However, in the
instant case, DW.1 himself in the cross-examination categorically
admitted that, his father has purchased some of the properties,
in the name of his mother. Furthermore admittedly, Item No.9 of
suit schedule properties was standing in the name of defendant
No.1. Under those circumstances, there was no need or necessity
for the original propositus to execute registered gift deed in
respect of said property in to the name of defendant No.1. This
execution of alleged registered gift deed by original propositus in
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
favour of defendant No.1 itself shows that, said property was not
her absolute property.
29.
There was partition between defendant No.1 and her
husband as per Ex.P.10. Under this document, this Item No.9
was partitioned between defendant No.1 and her husband and
registered partition deed was executed on 25.06.2011. When
there are daughter and sons to original propositus and defendant
No.1, there cannot be any partition between original propositus
and defendant No.1 alone without impleading them. Hence,
apparently this Ex.P10 has no value in the eye of law. But that
can also substantiate the contention of plaintiff that this property
was purchased in the name of defendant No.1 by her husband.
As far as, other items of suit schedule properties i.e., Item
Nos.10 and 11 are concerned, Ex.P.9 is the registered sale deed
in respect of Item No.11. Even though, this property is
purchased in the name of defendant No.1 alone, it is also to be
considered as joint family property. Furthermore as it is
defendant No.1 died intestate and plaintiff being her daughter,
will get share even in Item No.11 of suit schedule property.
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
30.
On careful perusal of the above documents, it is clear
that, only to exclude the plaintiff to get share in these properties,
it appears that original propositus has executed registered gift
deed in respect of Item Nos.2 and 9 in favour of defendant No.1
who in turn has executed registered gift deed in respect of those
properties in favour of defendant Nos.4 to 6 who are her
daughter-in-law and grandchildren.
31.
Learned
counsel
for
respondents
has
produced
several documents along with I.A.No.1/2025. Even though,
proper reasons are not assigned for non-production of those
documents before Trial Court, they are relevant documents to
decide this case and hence, under Order XLI Rule 27(b) CPC, if
the Court comes to the conclusion that, those documents are
required to be examined to enable it to pronounce judgment,
then the Court may permit the party to adduce additional
evidence.
32.
In the instant case, as discussed above, in respect of
some of the suit schedule properties i.e., Item Nos.9 and 10 of
suit schedule properties, no admissible revenue documents are
produced. However, the respondents have produced additional
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
documents in respect of those properties i.e. registered gift
deeds and registered sale deed. Those documents would enable
the Court to say that they are the properties belonging to the
family of plaintiff and defendants and hence, to come to said
conclusion,
those
documents
are
relevant
and
important
documents. Furthermore, there is no dispute amongst plaintiff
and defendants about existence of these properties in the joint
family. Under these circumstances, respondents have to be
permitted to adduce additional evidence by producing additional
documents.
33.
As far as certificate issued by Small Scale Industries
Unit and some appreciation letters produced along with I.A.No.1/
2025, there is no specific pleading about these documents in the
written statement and they are Xerox documents. Hence, they
are inadmissible in law.
34.
As discussed above, there is sufficient joint family
nucleus in the family and out of that, some of the properties
were purchased in the name of original propositus and some in
the name of defendant No.1. When sufficient nucleus is
established, the burden shifts upon the person who alleges that,
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
they are self-acquired properties of the original propositus and
defendant No.1. Even though, defendant No.1 was alive during
pendency of the suit, she has not made any efforts to enter the
witness box and to depose that what was her income and
savings to purchase Item Nos.8 to 11 of suit schedule properties
in her name. In the absence of these things, it is to be held that,
those properties were also the joint family properties.
35.
With this background, it is to be analysed whether
original propositus was having any right to execute registered
gift deed in favour of defendant No.1 in respect of joint family
properties. In this regard, learned counsel for appellant would
rely upon the judgment of Co-Ordinate Bench of this Court in the
case of Rudrawwa vs. Balawwa1 wherein it is held as follows:
“This
takes
us
to
the
question
whether
Shivalingappa could have validly gifted his undivided
interest in the copercenary property, under Ex.54.
Acording to Mitakshara Law as applied in all States, no
coparcener can dispose of his undivided interest in
coparcenary property by gift. This we think is well
settled, nor was that proposition controverted before
us.
(1967) MLJ (Part I) 71
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
Mr. Savanur relied on the decision of the Full
Bench of this Court in Sundara Adava v. Girija (1), to
which both of us were parties, in support of his
contention. Therein we were considering the question
whether a divided Hindu governed by Aliyasanthana
Law could bequeath his interest in view of S.7 and 30 of
the 'Act'. We came to the conclusion that he could not
do so. While examining the provisions of the 'Act',
dealing with S.6 this Court observed that the interest of
the deceased coparcener is quantified and provision is
made for its intestate succession under S.6 and that
interest is made capable of testamentary disposition by
S.30 (1). The quantification referred to therein, as
mentioned earlier, is for the purpose of S.6 and the
quantified share can be bequeathed by testamentary
disposition in view of S.30 of the 'Act'. This Court did
not lay down in that case that because of S.6 of the
'Act' it became permissible for a Hindu to gift away his
undivided interest in the coparcenary property. If that
decision is read as a whole, instead of helping Mr.
Savanur's contention, it goes against it.
Mr. Savanur's another argument was that if a sale
of his undivided interest by a Hindu coparcenary is
permissible in law, there is neither reason nor logic for
not permitting him to bequeath the same by gift. All
that we need say is that law is not logic. In the matter
of sales, we are governed by the Hindu Law texts as
interpreted by Courts. In this case, we are considering
whether there has been any change in the law relating
to gifts because of the provisions of the 'Act'.”
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
36.
judgment
Learned counsel for appellant also relies upon the
of
single
Bench
of
this
Court
in
the
case
of
M.Narayanaswamy (deceased) by his legal representatives vs.
M.Narayanappa and others2. At paragraph No.9, relied the
statement of law in Mayne’s Hindu Law, sixteenth edition.,
paragraph No. 406, which reads as under:
“It is now equally well settled in all the states that
a gift or devise by a coparcener in a Mithakshara family
of his undivided interest is wholly invalid… A coparcener
cannot make a gift of his undivided interest in the family
property, movable, either to a stranger or to a relative
except for purposes warranted by special texts.”
37.
The Co-ordinate Bench has relied upon Mayne’s
Hindu Law, sixteenth edition, wherein it is clearly held that the
gift of undivided interest is void without the consent of other
coparcener.
38.
It is not in dispute that Mahantappa Jangeri was the
propositus and was Karta of the joint family. The Karta of joint
family is having right to gift some of the properties under pious
obligation. A Hindu may dispose of by gift, his separate or self-
RFA No.1906/2005 dated 09.12.2020
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
acquired property. However, a coparcener under Mitakshara law
has no power to gift his share. In the instant case, the gift by
husband to the wife which is not covered under Mitakshara law,
only under Dayabhaga law, the coparcener can gift his property.
However, parties are governed by Mitakshara law is not in
dispute. But he can gift a small portion of joint family property
being father and Karta to his daughter. However, that is not the
situation
in
present
case.
Hence,
even
if
the
additional
documents produced by respondents are considered, the gift by
original propositus to defendant No.1 is not in accordance with
law and void. Hence, she would not get any absolute right over
the Item Nos.2 & 9 of suit schedule properties to execute gift
deed in favour of defendant Nos.4 to 6. Hence, the gift deed
executed by defendant No.1 in favour of defendant Nos.4 to 6
also held to be void. Under those circumstances, definitely
plaintiff is entitled for her share even in Item Nos.2, 3 & 8 to 11
of suit schedule properties. However, the learned Trial Judge has
not observed these points of law meticulously and come to the
wrong conclusion that, the original propositus has a right to
execute gift deed and has not considered the fact that DW.1 has
given categorical admission about the purchase of properties in
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1346-DB
RFA No. 100353 of 2019
HC-KAR
the name of defendant No.1. Hence, to that extent, the
judgment and decree of Trial Court is erroneous and it requires,
interference. Accordingly, the points under consideration are
answered as above and we proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
i)
The appeal filed by appellant under Section 96
of C.P.C. is allowed.
ii)
I.A.No.1/2025
filed
by
respondents
under
Order XLI Rule 27 R/w Section 151 of C.P.C. is
allowed.
iii) The plaintiff is entitled for 1/3rd share in Item
Nos.2, 3 and 8 to 11 of the suit schedule
properties by metes and bounds.
iv) Draw preliminary decree accordingly.
SD/(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
JUDGE
SD/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
RKM-para 1 to 23
SSP-para 24- end
CT:PA
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 15
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review