Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANAND PATHAK
ON THE 17th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. CRIMINAL CASE No. 52949 of 2023
Between:PREM PARASHAR S/O SHRI RAMSWAROOP
PARASHAR,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS,
OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURIST R/O ARYA
NAGAR DISTRICT BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPLICANT
(BY SHRI ANAND PUROHIT -ADVOCATE)
AND
STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH,
THROUGH
POLICE
STATION
KOTWALI
DISTRICT BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SHRI RAVINDRA SINGH KUSHWAH -DY. ADVOCATE
GENERAL AND SHRI PAWAN DWIVEDI – AMICUS CURIAE)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This application coming on for admission this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
1.
The applicant has filed this third bail application u/S.439 Cr.P.C for
grant of bail. Applicant has been arrested on 15-09-2023 by Police
Station Kotwali District Bhind in connection with Crime No.173/2022
registered for offence under Sections 409, 420, 34 of IPC. His first bail
application (M.Cr.C.No.44386/2023) was dismissed as withdrawn vide
order
dated
05-10-2023
and
second
bail
application
(M.Cr.C.No.47031/2023) was dismissed as withdrawn vide order dated
18-10-2023.
2.
It is the submission of learned counsel for the applicant that he has
been falsely implicated in the case and his source of implication is
memo under Section 27 of the Evidence Act. Nothing less nothing
more. He has no role to play directly or indirectly in commission of
offence. He does not bear any tainted criminal background and also
suffered more than two months of incarceration as pre-trial detention.
3.
Learned counsel for the applicant further referred the fact that vide
order dated 21-12-2023 temporary bail was granted to the applicant
and he was released on temporary bail on his furnishing personal bond
of Rs.50,000/- with one solvent surety in the like amount to the
satisfaction of the trial Court. It is further submitted that charge-sheet
has already been filed in the matter. He seeks continuance of such
relief and prays for making temporary bail order absolute.
4.
Learned counsel for the respondent/State opposed the prayer, however
could not dispute the facts as narrated by counsel for the applicant.
5.
Heard learned counsel for the parties at length and perused the case
diary.
6.
This is a peculiar case where Branch Manager of CMS Company,
Gwalior Branch filed a complaint with the allegations that Company
operates nationally and engaged in contracts with various Banks where
it systematically collects fund from these Banks and subsequently in
secured position transports this money for loading into the ATMs
across different locations through designated agents. According to
complainant, two custodians namely, Ashish Jadon and Satendra
Chauhan were appointed to load the cash in 18 ATMs following the
route sequence 01 in Bhind. Both custodians had access to essential
material including Admin Card, Key to the ATMs and One Time
Password (OTP) for vault access.
7.
During an audit conducted from 24-01-2022 to 28-01-2022 by Auditor
Manish Yadav, it was discovered that in 15 out of 18 ATMs the loaded
cash was less than the expected amount. It was further investigated in
which it was revealed that custodians Ashish Jadon and Satendra
Chauhan deliberately under reported the cash amount loaded into the
ATMs. This coordinated efforts resulted in misappropriation of a total
sum of INR 12,198,000/-. In an attempt to rectify the situation, Ashish
Jadon returned a portion of the embezzled amount around Rs.8.5 lacs.
During the course of investigation based on disclosure statement of
prime accused Ashish Jadon, the present applicant has been arrayed in
the capacity of accused. Moreover, he has also alleged that he had
given Rs.7 lacs to the present applicant. Therefore, charge-sheet has
been filed against the present applicant.
8.
Considering the submission and the source of implication of the
applicant and the fact that charge-sheet has been filed, this Court
allowed the application of the applicant for temporary bail vide order
dated 21-12-2023. This Court now confirms the said order of
temporary bail and makes it absolute. Applicant may be released on
already furnished bail bonds and surety with the condition as
enumerated in the temporary bail order dated 21-12-2023. It is
expected that applicant shall not be the source of embarrassment and
harassment to the complainant in any manner.
Accordingly, the application preferred by the applicant under
Section 439 of Cr.P.C. is hereby allowed.
9.
Since it is a case of very wider financial/social ramification and
performed with innovative criminal bent of mind, therefore, to
understand the fall outs of such crimes, this Court earlier appointed
Shri Pawan Dwivedi, Advocate as amicus curiae to advance arguments
and to suggest some measures to curb such menace. He filed a detail
synopsis in this regard. He argued at length about the working pattern
of ATMs and predicaments of the Banks as well as common customers
to make them safe from the onslaught of Cyber/Regular Criminals.
Shri Dwivedi referred different RBI notifications which safeguard the
working of ATMs. He discussed and deliberated with different
stakeholders of Banking Industry. The Observations as contained into
his synopsis are as under:
“After taking to various persons who are working in the
field of Banking or related operations it has been
observed that:
(i) Main problem lies in the fact that there are no strict
compliance with the instructions/guidelines issued by the
RBI with respect to cash loading procedure
(ii) Most of the banks are not doing reconciliation process
with the time frame as suggested by the RBI.
(iii) Most of the CCTV camera are not working.
(iv) The process of engaging workers is not robust in the
organisations providing services of cash loading. The
data grid of employees is not being maintained in
accordance
with
the
instructions
of
the
RBL
(v) The rotation of custodian 1 and custodian 2 and
shifting them to different teams at times is not frequent.”
10.
After referring observations which are mainly in the nature of
problematic area, learned amicus curiae made certain suggestions also
which are reproduced for posterity and for better understanding of the
problems and its solutions. These suggestions can be taken into
account by the Policy Makers of Banks and other Stakeholders:
“(A) The Banks, The Service Provider and the SubContractor shall strictly adhere to the time lines and
instructions/guidelines issued by the RBI from time to
time with respect to cash replenishment in ATMs.
(B) All the vans should have a GPS installed and also the
controlling technology for immobilizing the van whenever
required. They must have active CCTV camera at all
times of their operations.
(C) All the ATMs must have active CCTV camera at all
times.
(D) The cash replenishment procedure should be watched
over by a Cyber Security Operations Centre.
(E) Custodian 1 and Custodian 2 shall be equipped with
active body camera during their ATM replenishment
procedure.
(F) Custodian shall submit both Cash Position receipts
(i.e. before and after cash replenishment) on the same day
to the concerned Bank.
(G) The Banks must do reconciliation of transactions
(replenishment) between the Banks, The Service Provider
and Sub- Contractor within 3 days from the date of
loading of cash.
(H) The Custodian 1 and Custodian 2 shall be changed
frequently as a team (i.e. making team of different persons
like sometimes A with B and sometimes A with D & so on)
also their duty shall be shifted to different zone of ATMs
from time to time.
(I) The mandate of digital One Time Combination Lock
for operating ATM for cash replenishment shall be strictly
adhered to.
(J) The indent of cash shall be made at least one day in
advance.
(K) The CCTV footage of the ATMs shall be preserved till
the reconciliation of cash replenishment is done and till
resolution of any dispute (if arises).”
Hopefully, these suggestions would serve as wake up call for all
stakeholders especially for Banking industry.
11.
Besides that, one more development is being observed by this Court
about recurring cases of ATMs cutting by Gas Cutter and thereafter
taking money from it. This daredevilry is performed by outstationed
criminals or inter-state operatives in absence of or under nonoperational condition of CCTV Cameras and absence of Guards.
Therefore, it is expected from the Banks that their ATMs would be
installed near Public Institutions or at a place from where CCTV
Cameras of some other buildings can capture the scene of crime with
clarity so that at least vehicle number and other material particulars
regarding robbers can be ascertained for nabbing them in case of such
incident. These suggestions may already exist but their constant
followup would certainly check the apprehension of crime in
substantive manner.
12.
Copy of this order be sent to the Finance Secretary, Govt. of India,
North Block, New Delhi, Governor, Reserve Bank of India,
Mumbai, Managing Director/Chief Executive Officer of C.M.S.
Info System Ltd. Company, Goregaon East, Mumbai, Managing
Director, State Bank of India, Sector -11, CBD Belapur, Navi
Mumbai, Managing Director, Punjab National Bank, Dwarka,
Delhi, Managing Director, ICICI Bank, ICICI Bank Towers,
Bandra -Kurla Complex, Mumbai and Managing Director, Axis
Bank, Axis House, Mumbai for information and contemplation over
the suggestions given. Reserve Bank of India may circulate this order
with suggestions and directions to different Banks, if advised so.
13.
Before parting, this Court intends to record deep appreciation for the
valuable assistance rendered by Shri Pawan Dwivedi, Advocate as
amicus curiae.
14.
Application stands disposed of.
(Anand Pathak)
Judge
Anil*
ANIL
KUMAR
CHAURAS
IYA
CHAURASIYA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA
PRADESH BENCH GWALIOR, ou=HIGH
COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH BENCH
GWALIOR,
2.5.4.20=8512f40a1a9eaa50b6802d068
b51dae27e84c266b09d283f0799e67cd
c7df50f, postalCode=474001,
st=Madhya Pradesh,
serialNumber=EC534CBB3B245F05011
9F06F4A296DD83C765A1E2ACC6EC7D
8BD8CBCC9C2446E, cn=ANIL KUMAR
CHAURASIYA
Date: 2024.01.25 14:36:03 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review