Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:12212
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
TUESDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 15TH MAGHA, 1946
MACA NO. 911 OF 2014
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 30.04.2013 IN OPMV NO.241 OF 2006 OF
MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL & SPECIAL COURT FOR E.C. ACT CASES,
THRISSUR
APPELLANT:
PRANEESH
AGED 26 YEARS
S/. PRASAD, RESIDING AT MADATHIPARAMBIL HOUSE, P.O.
KUNNAKULAM, THRISSUR DISTRICT.
BY ADV SRI.T.C.SURESH MENON
RESPONDENTS:
P I MOHANAN
S/O. INNAYAKKAN, RESIDING AT PAKKATH HOUSE, P.O.
CHOWANNUR, KUNNAMKULAM, THRISSUR DISTRICT, PIN-680503.
VINOD
S/O. SUNNY, RESIDING AT VALAYANAD VEEDU, KOTTAYIL ROAD,
P.O. KUNNAMKULAM, THRISSUR-680503.
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
DIVISIONAL OFFICE, PARK HOUSE, ROUND NORTH, THRISSUR680001.
BY ADVS.
SRI.MAHESH V.MENON
SRI.S.ARUN RAJ- SC
MACA NO. 911 OF 2014
2025:KER:12212
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY
HEARD ON 04.02.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
MACA NO. 911 OF 2014
2025:KER:12212
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 4th day of February, 2025
The 1st respondent in O.P.(M.V.) No.241/ 2006 on the file of the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Thrissur, is the appellant herein. (For the
purpose of convenience, the parties are hereafter referred to as per their rank
before the Tribunal)
2. The petitioner filed the above O.P. under Section 166 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, claiming compensation for the injuries sustained
in a motor vehicle accident that occurred on 13.12.2005. According to the
petitioner, on 13.12.2005 at about 4.30 a.m, while he was traveling in an
autorickshaw bearing Reg.No, KL-8/F 1873, the 2nd respondent had driven
the same in a rash and negligent manner and dashed against one tanker lorry.
As a result of the accident, the petitioner sustained serious injuries.
3. The 1st respondent is the R.C owner, the 2nd respondent is the
driver and 3rd respondent is the insurer of the autorickshaw. According to the
petitioner, the accident occurred due to the negligence of the driver of the
offending vehicle. The quantum of compensation claimed in the O.P. is
Rs.1,50,000/-.
4. The insurance company filed a written statement, admitting the
MACA NO. 911 OF 2014
2025:KER:12212
accident as well as policy, but disputing the negligence on the part of the
driver of the offending vehicle.
5. The evidence in the case consists of the documentary evidence
of Exts.A1 to A8, and Ext.B1 were marked.
6. After evaluating the evidence on record, the Tribunal found
negligence on the part of the driver of the offending vehicle, awarded a total
compensation of Rs.96,967(Rounded to 97,000/-) and directed the insurer to
pay the same.
7. Aggrieved by the quantum of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal, the 1st respondent preferred this appeal.
8. Now the point that arises for consideration is the following:
Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal is just
and reasonable?
9.
Heard Sri. T.C Suresh Menon represented by A.R Nimod, the
learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner/appellant, Sri. Mahesh V.
Menon, the learned Counsel for the 1st respondent and Sri. S Arun Raj,
learned Standing counel appearing for the 3rd respondent.
10. The Point: In this case the accident as well as valid policy of
the offending vehicle are admitted. One of the contentions raised by the
learned counsel for the petitioner is regarding the income of the petitioner as
fixed by the Tribunal. According to him, the petitioner was working as
MACA NO. 911 OF 2014
2025:KER:12212
Salesman and shoe maker, earning Rs. 4000/- per month, but the Tribunal
fixed his monthly income at Rs.3000/-. The learned counsel for the insurer
would argue that the income fixed by the tribunal is reasonable.
11. As per the dictum laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the decision in Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance
Insurance Co. Ltd. [2011 (13) SCC 236], the notional income of a coolie, in
the year 2005 will come to Rs.5000/-. Since the petitioner could not prove his
job or income as claimed in the OP, in the light of a dictum laid down in the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ramachandrappa (supra) , his
notional income is liable to be fixed as that of a coolie, at Rs.5000/-.
12. In the accident the petitioner sustained the following injuries:
“Comminuted fracture capitulum of left humerus
at elbow and framas loss, comminuted fracture
coronoid process of left ulna at elbow, displaced
intra articular fracture coronoid process of left
elbow, open reduction and internal fixation done
under general anesthesia.”
13.
As per Ext. A8, disability certificate the condition of the
patient is showing as follows:
“1. Surgical scars over the (L)elbow
2. Range of flexion of the (L)elbow is only 1000
3. Fixed flexion deformity of 20° of the (L)elbow
4. Ulnar nerve palsy(partial) of the little and ring
fingers of the (L)hand
5. Difficulty in lifting weights with the (L)hand
which makes it difficult for him to work as a
salesman
MACA NO. 911 OF 2014
2025:KER:12212
6. Pain and difficulty (L)arm and elbow on
strenuous activities
7. Radiologically, maluniting fractures of the
capitellum and coronoid process, implants
remaining in situ
The whole body permanent disability has been
calculated using Mcbride scale as follows:
% for intraarticular fracture capitellum and
coronoid process (L)elbow with fixed flexion
deformity, stiffness of the (L)elbow and partial
ulnar nerve palsy = 12%”
14. Ext.A8 disability certificate shows that the petitioner suffered
12% permanent physical disability. It was issued by the Asst. Professor of
Orthopaedics in Govt. Medical College, Thrissur. The Tribunal, however,
scaled down the percentage of disability of the petitioner to 5%, without
assigning valid and cogent reasons. The law is settled that, if the Tribunal is
not satisfied with the disability certificate produced by the petitioner, the
remedy is to refer him to a medical board or higher Authority.(See
Manikantan G. v. Janardhanan Nair and Others, 2021 (5)KHC 305).
Having not done so, the Tribunal was not justified in scaling down the
percentage of disability from what is shown in the disability certificate. I do
find any grounds to disbelieve the said disability and as such the permanent
physical disability of the petitioner is fixed as 12%.
MACA NO. 911 OF 2014
2025:KER:12212
15. On the date of accident, the petitioner was aged 18 years.
Therefore, 40% of the monthly income is to be added towards future
prospects, as held in the decision in National Insurance Co.Ltd v Pranay
Sethi [(2017) 16 SCC 680] and the multiplier to be applied is 18, as held in
Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation, (2009) 6 SCC 121. In the
above circumstances, the loss of disability will come to Rs.1,81,440/-.
16. Since the notional income of the petitioner is re-fixed at
Rs.5000/-, towards loss of earning he is entitled to get a sum of Rs. 15000/(5000x3 months)
17.
Towards the head ‘pain and sufferings’, the Tribunal has
awarded Rs.18000/-. Towards 'loss of amenities of life' Rs. 13000/- was
awarded. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
compensation awarded on those heads are on the lower side. At the same
time, towards 'extra nourishment', and damage to cloth compensation was not
awarded.
18. The petitioner sustained serious injuries in the accident and was
treated as inpatient for 5 days. Because of the injuries sustained, the
percentage of disability suffered and the length of treatment undergone by the
petitioner, I hold that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal on the heads
‘pain and sufferings’, and 'loss of amenities of life' are on the lower side and
not awarded by the tribunal and hence they are enhanced to Rs.25000/-, and
MACA NO. 911 OF 2014
2025:KER:12212
15000/- respectively. Towards 'extra nourishment' and damage to clothing.
Rs.3000/-and 1000/- respectively are allowed.
19. No change is required, in the amounts awarded on other heads,
as the compensation awarded on those heads appears to be just and
reasonable.
20. Therefore, the petitioners/ appellants are entitled to get a total
compensation of Rs.2,65,007/-, as modified and recalculated above and given
in the table below, for easy reference.
Sl.
No.
Head of Claim
Amount awarded by
Amount Awarded in
Tribunal (in Rs.)
Appeal
(in Rs.)
1 Loss of earning( total)
15000
2 Medical expenses
20567
20567
3 Bystander Expenses
4 Transportation Expenses
5 Extra nourishment
----
6 Damage to clothing
----
7 Pain and suffering
18,000
25000
Disability
32400
1,81,440
Loss of amenities
13000
15000
Total
Rs.96,967/- (Rounded Rs.2,65,007
to Rs.97,000)
Enhanced
Rs.1,68,007
21. In the result, this Appeal is allowed in part, and Respondent
No. 3 is directed to deposit a total sum of Rs.2,65,007/-/- (Rupees Two lakhs
MACA NO. 911 OF 2014
2025:KER:12212
sixty five thousand seven rupees Only), less the amount already deposited, if
any, along with interest @ 8% per annum from the date of the petition till
deposit/realisation, excluding interest for a period of 216 days, the period of
delay in filing the appeal, with proportionate costs, within a period of two
months from today.
22. On depositing the aforesaid amount, the Tribunal shall disburse
the entire amount to the petitioner, excluding court fee payable, if any,
without delay, as per rules.
Sd/C. PRATHEEP KUMAR,
JUDGE
vnk/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review