Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
BEFORE:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE HIRANMAY BHATTACHARYYA
WPA 28873 OF 2025
Pranab Maity & Ors.
VS.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the Petitioners
: Mr. Ashim Kumar Routh
Mr. Subhayan Barik
Ms. Manishka Dhar
….. advocates
For the State
: Mr. Chandi Charan De, AGP
Ms. Saswati Chatterjee
For the respondent nos. 10 & 11
: Ms. Aparajita Mitra
Reserved on
: 04.02.2026
Judgment on
: 21.04.2026
…. advocates
….. advocate
Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, J.:1. Petitioner has challenged the notice dated November 17, 2025 issued by the
Sub-Divisional Officer, Kakdwip, District 24 Parganas (S) being the 7th
respondent directing the parties to attend the hearing under Section 10(3) of
the West Bengal Highways Act, 1964.
2. The Assistant Engineer, Kakdwip Highway Sub-division, being the 6th
respondent issued a notice dated 12.03.2024 under Section 10(1) of the
West Bengal Highways Act, 1964 (for short “the 1964 Act”) directing the
petitioner to remove the encroachment upon Gangasagar to Kachubaria
main Road in LR Dag No. 1778, within Mouza Harinbari, JL No. 031, under
Police Station Sagar, in the District of 24 Parganas (South). Thereafter, the
6th respondent issued a letter under Section 10(2) of the 1964 Act to the 7 th
respondent. Pursuant to the letter issued under 10(2) of the 1964 Act, the
7th respondent issued a notice dated July 25, 2024 fixing a date of hearing
under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act.
3. Petitioner
challenged
the
aforesaid
notices
dated
12.03.2024
and
25.07.2024 by filing a writ petition being WPA 20204 of 2024. During the
pendency of the said writ petition, an order dated 06.08.2024 was passed by
the 7th respondent under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act directing the 6th
respondent to recover possession and to remove the encroachment from the
PWD Road. Being aggrieved by the order dated 06.08.2024 passed by the 7th
respondent, petitioner preferred an appeal under Section 10(4) of the 1964
Act being appeal no. 10 of 2024-25. The appeal no. 10 of 2024-25 was,
however, disposed of by the District Magistrate 24 Parganas (S) being the 2nd
respondent by an order dated 22.04.2025 by affirming the order dated
06.08.2024 passed by the 7th respondent with a direction upon the 6th
respondent to remove the encroachment.
4. Thereafter, WPA No. 20204 of 2024 was dismissed by an order dated
05.05.2025 upon holding that there is no cogent reason to interfere with the
notices dated 12.03.2024 and 25.07.2024. By the said order the petitioner
and the private respondents therein were directed to appear before the 7 th
respondent on May 15, 2025 and also on subsequent dates and time as
would be fixed by the respondent no. 7 for participating in the proceeding
under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act. By the said order it was clarified that
till the passing of the final order under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act by the
7th respondent, there shall be an order of status quo upon the plot in
question.
5. Challenging the order dated 22.04.2025 passed by the 2nd respondent under
Section 10(4) of the 1964 Act, petitioner filed a writ petition being WPA
18229 of 2025. A co-ordinate bench, by an order dated 28.08.2025, allowed
the writ petition by setting aside the order dated 22.04.2025. Thereafter, a
notice dated 17.11.2025 was issued by the 7th respondent requesting the
petitioner and the private respondents to attend the hearing under Section
10(3) of the 1964 Act on 16.12.2025.
6. Challenging the said notice dated 17.11.2025 issued by the 7th respondent,
petitioner has approached this Court.
7. Mr. Routh, learned advocate appearing for the petitioner submitted that the
land in question from which alleged encroachment has been directed to be
removed is a Raiyati land of the petitioners. He, thus, contended that a
proceeding under Section 10 of the 1964 Act could not have been invoked
for removal of structures standing on a raiyati land. Mr. Routh further
contended that pursuant to an order dated 05.05.2025, date(s) of hearing in
connection with the proceeding under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act was
/were fixed and the petitioner duly attended the said hearing. He contended
that the hearing in connection with the proceeding under Section 10(3) of
the 1964 Act had been concluded and thus there was no scope for issuance
of further notices under Section 10(2) of the 1964 Act and a hearing notice
under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act dated 17.11. 2025.
8. Mr. Dey learned Additional Government Pleader seriously disputed the
submission of Mr. Routh. He contended that pursuant to the order passed
by a co-ordinate bench, date of hearing in connection with the proceeding
under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act was fixed. He contended that in order to
afford an opportunity of hearing to the respective parties, the notice dated
17.11.2025 was issued by the 7th respondent.
9. The learned advocate appearing for the private respondent submitted that
since the petitioner made construction by encroaching upon the PWD Road,
a proceeding under Section 10 of the West Bengal Highways Act, 1964 was
initiated and pursuant to an order dated 05.05.2025 passed by a coordinate bench in WPA 20204 of 2024, the hearing notice dated 17.11.2025
was issued by the 7th respondent.
10. Heard the learned advocates for the parties and perused the materials
placed.
11. A notice under Section 10(1) of the 1964 dated 12.03.2024 was issued
requesting the noticees to remove the encroachment on Public Works
(Roads) acquired land of Kachubaria-Gangasagar Road in a portion of CS
Plot no. 1778, Mouza Harinbari, JL 031 under Police Station Sagar in the
District of 24 Parganas (South) and to restore the highways to its original
condition within the time limit indicated in the said notice. Since the
encroachment was not removed in compliance with the direction contained
in the 10(1) notice, the 6th respondent made an application to the 7th
respondent for removal of the encroachment and delivery of possession of
the land encroached upon to the highway authority. Upon receipt of such
application from 6th respondent, the 7th respondent issued a notice dated
July 25, 2024 fixing a date of hearing under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act on
06.08.2024 requesting the petitioner and the private respondents to appear
at the said hearing.
12. Challenging the aforesaid notices dated 12.03.2024 and 25.07.2024,
petitioner filed a writ petition being WPA 20204 of 2024. During the
pendency of the said writ petition the 7th respondent passed an order dated
06.08.2024 in exercise of powers vested upon such respondent under
Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act authorising the 6th respondent to recover
possession and to remove the encroachment from the land in question.
13. When WPA No. 20204 of 2024 came up for hearing on 12.09.2024 a
submission was made before the co-ordinate bench by the learned advocate
for the petitioner that though the petitioners approached the District
Magistrate to file an appeal against the order dated 06.08.2024 the said
appeal has not been received by the District Magistrate. On the basis of
such submission the co-ordinate bench passed an order of stay of operation
of the order dated August 6, 2024 for a limited period. The said interim
order was extended from time to time till April 30, 2025.
14. In the meantime, petitioner preferred an appeal under Section 10(4) of the
1964 Act before the District Magistrate 24 Parganas (South) which was
registered as Appeal no. 10 of 2024-25. The said appeal was disposed of by
an order dated 22.04.2025 thereby affirming the order dated 06.08.2024
passed by the 7th respondent with a direction upon the 6th respondent to
remove the encroachment.
15. WPA No. 20204 of 2024 came up for hearing on 05.05.2025 before a coordinate bench. The co-ordinate bench after noting that the subject matter
of the writ petition are the notices dated 12.03.2024 and 25.07.2024 issued
by the respondent no. 6 and 7 respectively dismissed the writ petition by an
order dated 05.05.2025 upon observing that in the absence of any material
to come to a finding that the aforesaid two notices are either illegal and /or
illogical and also in view of the fact that the writ petitioners have miserably
failed to prove at least prima facie that the plot of land in question is a
raiyati land, the Court found no cogent reason to interfere with the
aforementioned two notices dated 12.03.2024 and 25.07.2024. The coordinate bench, however, directed the petitioner and the private respondents
to appear before the 7th respondent positively on May 15, 2025 and also on
subsequent dates and time as would be fixed by the 7th respondent for
participating in the proceeding under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act. The coordinate bench, however, made it clear that till the passing of the final order
under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act by the 7th respondent there shall be an
order of status quo upon the plot in question.
16. The petitioner alleged that the order dated 22.04.2025 passed by the District
Magistrate under Section 10(4) of the 1964 Act was communicated to the
petitioner by a letter dated 15.07.2025. The petitioner thereafter challenged
the order dated 22.04.2025 passed by the 2nd respondent by filing a writ
petition being WPA 18229 of 2025 which stood allowed by an order dated
28.08.2025 passed by a co-ordinate bench. While passing the order dated
28.08.2025 the co-ordinate bench recorded the submissions of the
respective parties that the hearing in connection with the proceeding under
Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act before the 7th respondent authority had been
concluded but no order has been passed. The co-ordinate bench, by the
order dated 28.08.2025, was pleased to set aside the order dated
22.04.2025 and all consequent actions taken by the authorities including
the 6th respondent pursuant to the order dated 22.04.2025 were also set
aside.
17. Record reveals that the co-ordinate bench while disposing of WPA 20204 of
2024 permitted the writ petitioner and the private respondents to participate
in the proceeding under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act before the 7th
respondent on a specified date i.e., on 15th May 2025. It is not in dispute
that pursuant to the order dated 05.05.2025 several dates for hearing were
fixed and the parties have uniformly submitted before the co-ordinate bench
in course of hearing of the writ petition being WPA 18229 of 2025 on
28.08.2025 that the hearing in connection with the provisions of Section
10(3) of the 1964 Act has already been concluded but no order has been
passed.
18. More than 6 months have elapsed since the date of hearing before the 7th
respondent in connection with the proceeding under Section 10(3) of the
1964 Act but no decision appears to have been taken by the 7th respondent.
19. After going through the notice dated 17.11.2025 issued by the 7th
respondent it appears to this Court that a date for hearing under Section
10(3) of the 1964 Act was fixed. It is not in dispute that while the 7th
respondent was in seisin over the proceeding under Section 10(3) of the
1964 Act, a writ petition being WPA 18229 of 2025 was filed by the
petitioners and till the disposal of the said writ petition, the final order of the
hearing conducted by the 7th respondent had not been communicated to the
parties.
20. It is also not the case of the parties that the final order was communicated
by the 7th respondent as on the date when the hearing of the instant writ
petition was concluded.
21. Since more than six months have elapsed from the date of conclusion of
hearing in the proceeding under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act and the order
under Section 10(3) is yet to be communicated to the parties, this Court is of
the considered view, that the parties have to be afforded an opportunity of
hearing afresh by the 7th respondent in the proceeding under Section 10(3)
of the 1964 Act.
22. By the notice dated 17.11.2025, the 7th respondent only fixed a date for
hearing under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act on 16.12.2025. The 7th
respondent cannot be faulted for giving a further opportunity of hearing to
the respective parties in view of the peculiar facts of this case that after the
conclusion of hearing under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act by the 7th
respondent, the order passed earlier under Section 10(4) of the 1964 Act
was set aside in a writ petition at the instance of the petitioner.
23. In view of the subsequent events that took place after the conclusion of
hearing in the proceeding under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act, this Court is
of the considered view that the 7th respondent was justified in fixing a
further date of hearing on 16.12.2025.
24. The notice dated 17.11.2025 has to be construed to be a notice of hearing
under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act and the same does not suffer from any
infirmity warranting interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India.
25. Since the instant writ petition was filed prior to the date fixed for hearing as
indicated in the notice dated 17.11.2025, and also that sufficient time has
passed since the last date of hearing before the 7th respondent in the
proceeding under Section 10(3) of the 1964 Act, the parties are directed to
appear before the 7th respondent on May 18, 2026 at or about 12 noon along
with the server copy of this order. The 7th respondent is directed to fix a date
of hearing, which shall be duly intimated to the parties, and pass a reasoned
order after affording an opportunity of hearing to the petitioner, the private
respondents or their authorised representatives and communicate the
reasoned order to the parties as expeditiously as possible but positively on
or before June 12, 2026.
26. In the event any party/parties fail to appear on the date fixed for hearing, 7th
respondent shall proceed in accordance with law and complete the entire
exercise as indicated hereinbefore within the specified time limit.
27. The writ petition stands disposed of with the aforesaid observations and
directions.
28. There shall be, however, no order as to costs.
29. Urgent photostat certified copies, if applied for, be supplied to the parties
upon compliance of all formalities.
(HIRANMAY BHATTACHARYYA, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review