Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PREM NARAYAN SINGH
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1090 of 2019
BETWEEN:1.
PRAKASH S/O BALURAM BAWRI, AGED ABOUT 23
YEARS, SARVANIYA MASANI, DISTT. NEEMUCH
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
RAJESH@RAJU S/O BALURAM BAVARI, AGED
ABOUT 27 YEARS, SARVANIYA MASANI (MADHYA
PRADESH)
3.
BALURAM@BALU S/O KISHANLAL BAVARI, AGED
ABOUT 50 YEARS, SARVANIYA MASANI, DISTT.
NEEMUCH (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI SANTOSH KUMAR MEENA, ADVOCATE )
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH STATION HOUSE
OFFICER THRU. P.S. JAWAD, DISTT. NEEMUCH
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI RAJESH JOSHI, GA FOR STATE )
Reserved on: 18.01.2024
Delivered on: 19.01.2024
This appeal having been heard and reserved for judgment, coming on
for pronouncement this day, the court passed the following:
JUDGEMENT
This criminal appeal is preferred under section 374 of Cr.P.C. by the
appellant being aggrieved by the judgment dated 08.01.2019, passed by ASJ,
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/20/2024
12:40:19 PM
Jawad, District Neemuch (M.P.), in S.T. No.73/20154, whereby each appellant
has been convicted for the offence punishable under Section 365 of IPC and
sentenced to undergo 6-6 Months R.I. with fine of Rs.3000/- each with default
stipulations.
2. As per the case of prosecution, on 13.05.2015 at about 11PM in the
night, the appellants have kidnapped the complainant. Hence, the missing
person report was lodged and thereafter, during the investigation, it is found that
the appellants have kidnapped the complainant. Hence, offence was registered
against the appellants.
3 . During investigation, spot map was prepared, seizure memos were
prepared and statements of the witnesses were recorded. After completion of
investigation, charge-sheet was filed under Section , 365/34, 342, 323 and 506
of IPC.
4. The appellants abjured their guilt and they took a plea that they are
innocent.
5.After analyzing the prosecution evidence and considering the rival
submissions, the Trial Court has acquitted the appellants under Section 342,
323 and 506 of the Act and whereas convicted them only under Section 365/34
of IPC by sentencing for 6-6 months each.
.
Counsel for the appellants submits the appellants and the
complainant has already compromised the case and the application under
Section 320 of Cr.P.C was filed before the trial Court, but the same was not
considered and the appellants were convicted. It is further submitted that there
is no minimum sentence prescribed under Section 365 of IPC and prays that the
sentence of the appellants may be reduced to the period already undergone
because the appellant Prakash has suffered 10 days and Rajesh and Baluram
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/20/2024
12:40:19 PM
have suffered 7-7 days respectively out of six months and the fine amount may
be enhanced or as the Court may deem fits in the interest of justice as the
incident had taken place in the year 2015.
7 . Learned counsel for the respondent/state submits that the offence
under sections 365 of IPC is non-compoundable, therefore, the offence cannot
be compounded under section 320 of the Cr.P.C
8 . Nevertheless, the appellants have not impugned the merits of
conviction and confined their arguments as to sentencing of the appellants on
the basis of compromise application, but still this appellate Court is of the view
to examine the sanctity of conviction. On this aspect, I have gone through the
order of the trial Court. The prosecution case is not only fortified by the eyewitnesses but also well supported by documentary evidence adduced before the
trial Court. In view of the whole evidence produced by the prosecution,
conclusion of learned trial Court regarding conviction is appears to be on sound
reasoning, it does not warrant any interference. Accordingly, this finding with
regard to conviction under Section 365 of IPC, is hereby affirmed.
9 .
Now, the Court is turning to the sentencing part and effect of
compromise placed by the complainant/injured and accused person regarding
the conviction under Section 365 of IPC. In the case of Narinder Singh and
Ors Vs. State of Punjab And Anr, 2014 (6) SCC 466 relying on the various
judgments, the Apex Court permitted the compounding in a non-compoundable
case and quashed the criminal proceedings. The Hon'ble Apex Court in para
no.21 has observed as under:-
"21. However, we have some other cases decided by this
Court commenting upon the nature of offence under
Section 307 of IPC. In Dimpey Gujral case (supra), FIR
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/20/2024
12:40:19 PM
was lodged under sections 147,148,149,323,307,552 and
506 of the IPC. The matter was investigated and final
report was presented to the Court under Section 173 of the
Cr.P.C. The trial court had even framed the charges. At
that stage, settlement was arrived at between parties. The
court accepted the settlement and quashed the
proceedings, relying upon the earlier judgment of this
Court in Gian Singh vs. State of Punjab & Anr. 2012
AIR SCW 5333 wherein the court had observed that
inherent powers under section 482 of the Code are of
wide plentitude with no statutory limitation and the
guiding factors are: (1) to secure the needs of justice, or
(2) to prevent abuse of process of the court. While doing
so, commenting upon the offences stated in the FIR, the
court observed:
“Since the offences involved in this case are of a
personal nature and are not offences against the
society, we had enquired with learned counsel
appearing for the parties whether there is any
possibility of a settlement. We are happy to note that
due to efforts made by learned counsel, parties have
seen reason and have entered into a compromise.”
This Court, thus, treated such offences including one
under section 307, IPC were of a personal nature and
not offences against the society."
10.
Here, it is also poignant that this compromise has been filed at the
stage of appeal before this Court. On this point, the view of Hon'ble Apex
Court in the Unnikrishnan alias Unnikuttan versus State of Kerala
reported in AIR 2017 Supreme Court 1745 is worth referring in the context
of this case as under:"10. In series of decisions i.e. Bharath Singh vs. State of
M.P. and Ors., 1990 (Supp) SCC 62, Ramlal vs. State of J &
K, (1999) 2 SCC 213, Puttaswamy vs. State of Karnataka and
Anr, (2009) 1 SCC 71 1, this Court allowed the parties to
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/20/2024
12:40:19 PM
compound the offence even though the offence is a noncompoundable depending on the facts and circumstances of each
case. In some cases this Court while imposing the fine amount
reduced the sentence to the period already undergone."
11. What emerges from the above is that even if an offence is not
compoundable within the scope of Section 320 of Code of Criminal
Procedure the Court may, in view of the compromise arrive at
between the parties, reduce the sentence imposed while maintaining
the conviction."
11.
Even this Court in Cr.A. No.268/2016 (Kanha @ Mahesh v/s The
State of Madhya Pradesh) decided on 26.08.2017 as well as in Cr.A.
No.561/2010 (Radhakrishnan & 3 Others v/s The State of Madhya
Pradesh) decided on 18.04.2017 and in CRA No.604/2000 (Aaram singh vs.
The State of Madhya Pradesh) decided on 08.08.2019, Sohan Jangu &
others vs. State of Madhya Pradesh passed in CRA No.550/2023 on
11.07.2023, has taken a similar view.
12. On this point, this Court is also also inclined to quote the excerpt of
the judgment rendered by Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Bhagwan
Narayan Gaikwad vs. State of Maharashtra; [2021 (4) Crimes 42 (SC)
which is as under:"28. Giving punishment to the wrongdoer is the heart of the
criminal delivery system, but we do not find any legislative or
judicially laid down guidelines to assess the trial Court in meeting out
the just punishment to the accused facing trial before it after he is
held guilty of the charges. Nonetheless, if one goes through the
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/20/2024
12:40:19 PM
decisions of this Court, it would appear that this Court takes into
account a combination of different factors while exercising discretion
in sentencing, that is proportionality, deterrence, rehabilitation, etc.
29. The compromise if entered at the later stage of the incident
or
even after conviction can indeed be one of the factor in
interfering the sentence awarded to commensurate with the nature of
offence being committed to avoid bitterness in the families of the
accused and the victim and it will always be better to restore their
relation, if possible, but the compromise cannot be taken to be a
solitary basis until the other aggravating and mitigating factors also
support and are favourable to the accused for molding the sentence
which always has to be examined in the facts and circumstances of
the case on hand."
13. As the offence under Section 365 of the Indian Penal Code is not
compoundable under Section 320 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, it
is not possible to pass the order of acquittal on the basis of compromise but, it
is by now well settled that such a compromise can be taken into account for
reduction of sentence when the offence is of personal in nature and not
affecting the society at large. The appellants and the complainant are living in the
same society, they are residing happily since last so many years, they want to
live with peace, and therefore, to meet the ends of justice, the sentence of
imprisonment awarded against the appellants may be reduced for a period of
already undergone. Hence, in the interest of justice the appellants may awarded
sentence till the rising of the Court by enhancing the fine amount of Rs.6000/- in
place of Rs.3000/- payable by each of the appellants within a period of two
months from today.
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/20/2024
12:40:19 PM
14. In view of the aforesaid principles laid down by Hon'ble Apex Court
and by this Court taking into consideration that the incident had taken place in
the year 2017 and no fruitful purpose would be served in keeping the appellants
in jail even after the compromise between the parties, this Court is of the view
that while maintaining the conviction under sections 365 of IPC, the jail sentence
under this offence is reduced to the period already undergone on the basis of
compromise arrived at between the parties.
15. The appellants are directed to deposit the enhanced fine of Rs.6000/within two months from today. The bail bond of the appellants shall be
discharged after depositing enhanced fine amount. In case of default of
payment of fine amount, the appellants shall undergo actual jail sentence as
awarded by the learned trial Court.
16. The fine amount if already deposited by the appellants shall be
adjusted.
17. The judgment of learned trial Court regarding seized property stands
confirmed.
18. A copy of this order be sent to the trial Court concerned for
necessary compliance.
19.With the aforesaid, the present appeal stands disposed off.
Pending application, if any stands closed.
Certified copy, as per rules.
(PREM NARAYAN SINGH)
JUDGE
amit
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/20/2024
12:40:19 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review