Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CJ.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan
Son of late Manik Chand Pradhan,
Kutchery Rangpo
Rangpo, East Sikkim.
… Petitioner.
versus
1.
Union fo India,
Through the Secretary,
Ministry of Road Transport and
National Highways,
1, Sansad Marg, New Delhi-110001.
2.
The General Manager (Projects),
National Highways and Infrastructure
Development Corporation Limited,
Ministry of Road Transport and Highways,
Opposite Mount Zion School Kidzee,
M.P. Golai, Tadong,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
3.
The State of Sikkim,
Through the District Collector,
East District/ duly authorized Competent
Authority of the Central Government,
Sichey, Gangtok, East Sikkim.
… Respondents.
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. T.B. Thapa, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Ranjan Chettri,
Mr. Khem Raj Sapkota and Ms. Chandrika M. Karki,
Advocates for the Petitioner.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Senior Central
Advocate for Respondents No. 1 and 2.
Government
Mr. Santosh Kr. Chettri, Asstt. Government Advocate
for Respondent No. 3.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
(05.07.2017)
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
The petitioner, stated to be the landowner of the land
bearing Khesra Plot No. 2384/3685/P ad-measuring 0.46 Hectare
land situate at IBM, Central Pendam Block, Rangpo Sub Division,
East District, Sikkim, has come up with this petition, purported to
be under Section 11 (4), 11 (5) and 11 (6) of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as ―the Act of
1996‖), seeking appointment of a Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate
and decide the issue of fair compensation in respect of the land
acquired therein.
2.
The brief facts, as projected by the petitioner, are that
the Government of India, Ministry of Road Transport and
Highways published a notification dated 13 th April 2016 under
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
sub-section (1) of Section 3A of the National Highways Act, 1956
(hereinafter referred to as ―NH Act‖), declaring its intention to
acquire the land specified in the Schedule annexed thereto for
building (widening/ two-laning, etc.) including the bypasses,
maintenance, management and operation of National Highway
No. 10 (old NH No. 31A) on the stretch of land from Km. 51.870
to Km. 53.900 in East District, in the State of Sikkim, wherein
the land-in-question was included.
Subsequent thereto, a
notification dated 09th July 2016 (Annexure P-3) under Section
3D of the NH Act, was published in the Gazette of India
Extraordinary Part II – Section 3 – Sub-section (ii) providing that
no objection was received from any person by the competent
authority and as such, land specified therein stands acquired and
vested absolutely in the Central Government, free from all
encumbrances. The compensation in respect of land-in-question
owned by the petitioner was determined under the provisions of
NH Act to the tune of Rs.10,92,04,010/- (Rupees Ten Crores
Ninety Two Lakhs Four Thousand and Ten) only. The petitioner
accepted the cheque dated 12th January 2017 for the said
amount.
Feeling dissatisfied with the determination of the
amount,
it
is
stated
that
the
petitioner
has
made
a
representation to the competent authority under the provisions of
NH
Act,
namely
to
the
third
respondent,
requesting
for
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
determination of the amount of compensation, rehabilitation and
resettlement and other benefits by an Arbitrator to be appointed
by the Central Government, as provided under Section 3G(5) of
the NH Act. Finding no response from the third respondent, the
instant petition is filed as aforestated.
3.
Mr. T.B. Thapa, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the petitioner, referring to the provisions of Section 3G(5) of the
NH Act, would contend that the provisions of the Act require
reference to appoint an Arbitrator by the Central Government, in
the event, the amount determined by the competent authority is
not acceptable to either of the parties.
It is further contended
that the provisions of the Act of 1996 is applicable to the
arbitration under sub-section (6) of Section 3G of the NH Act.
Thus, the petitioner has made a representation for appointment
of the Arbitrator under the provisions of the Act of 1996 on
17.01.2017, which remained un-responded.
Thus, this Court,
exercising its jurisdiction under Section 11 (6) of the Act of 1996,
may appoint an Arbitrator, who is non-partisan, unbiased,
possessed with high dignity, well qualified and also not being an
employee of the Central or State Government, as Sole Arbitrator
to
adjudicate the disputes involved herein, in respect
of
determination of compensation for the land-in-question acquired
by the Central Government.
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
4.
Mr. Thapa would further contend that Section 12(5)
read with Seventh Schedule and Fifth Schedule of the Act, 1996
requires that the Arbitrator, may not be interested in the dispute
and also has any other past or present relationship with the
parties, must be unbiased and of unimpeachable integrity.
Referring to the counter affidavit filed by the respondents-Central
Government, wherein the Central Government has come up with
an Order dated 08th July 2016, whereunder Secretary-cum-Relief
Commissioner,
Land
Revenue
and
Disaster
Management
Department, Government of Sikkim, has been notified as
Arbitrator for all Districts in the State of Sikkim, learned Senior
Counsel
would
further
urge
that
the
Secretary-cum-Relief
Commissioner, being an employee of the Central Government
and also working with the State Government, may not be
unbiased, independent and fearless to adjudicate the dispute
fairly and freely.
A retired Judge of the High Court or the
Supreme Court may be appointed as an Arbitrator. It is further
submitted by the learned Senior Counsel that the appointment of
an Arbitrator before issuance of notification dated 09 th July 2016,
declaring the acquisition of land as acquired and also before
determination of compensation, is null and void and the same
may not be given effect to, in the case on hand.
Mr. Thapa
would further urge that the Supreme Court in a catena of
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
decisions viz. Datar Switchgears Ltd. Vs. Tata Finance Ltd.
and another1, Ace Pipeline Contracts (P) Ltd. Vs. Bharat
Petroleum Corpn. Ltd.2, Northern Railway Administration,
Ministry of Railway, New Delhi vs. Patel Engineering
Company Ltd.3 and Voestalpine Schienen GMBH vs. Delhi
Metro Rail Corporation Ltd.4, in categorical terms, propounded
the principal of law that no appointment made after filing of an
application under Section 11 (6) of the Act of 1996 is valid
appointment under the provisions of Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996. Further, the Secretary-cum-Relief Commissioner is a
superior officer to the District Collector in the line, who has been
the competent authority under the NH Act and the determination
of compensation made by him may not be examined properly.
5.
Next, it is contended that even otherwise the order
dated 08th July 2016, appointing the Arbitrator, was never
communicated to the petitioner, even after the demand was
made for appointment of the Arbitrator on 17th January 2017.
Thus, this is an internal correspondence, but not an order as laid
down by the Supreme Court in Bachhittar Singh vs. State of
Punjab and another5 and the same is not binding on the
parties.
------------------------------1
(2000) 8 SCC 151
(2007) 5 SCC 304
(2008) 10 SCC 240
(2017) 4 SCC 665
AIR 1963 SC 395
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
6.
In response, Mr. Karma Thinlay, learned Central
Government Counsel appearing for all the respondents, would
submit that the petition deserves to be dismissed as the Central
Government had already appointed the Arbitrator i.e. Secretarycum-Relief
Commissioner,
Land
Revenue
and
Disaster
Management Department, vide order dated 08th July 2016 for all
the disputes in respect of determination of compensation for
acquisition of land in the State of Sikkim, in exercise of powers
under sub-section (5) of Section 3G of the NH Act.
And as such,
it is not necessary to appoint any Arbitrator as sought for by the
petitioner. It is further contended that the Secretary-cum-Relief
Commissioner is a competent person dealing with the land
acquisition cases and is fully expert on determining the valuation
and compensation for the land.
Learned Counsel would next
contend that the allegation is vague, unsubstantiated and general
in nature, which deserves to be rejected.
7.
A thoughtful consideration is given to the submissions
put forth by the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the parties
and the documents annexed to the petition and relevant
statutory provisions are carefully examined.
8.
Indisputably, the land-in-question was acquired by the
respondents under provision of NH Act for the purpose, as
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
aforestated, and the compensation was determined by the
competent authority to the tune of Rs.10,92,04,010/- (Rupees
Ten Crores Ninety Two Lakhs Four Thousand and Ten) only for
the land-in-question. The petitioner, feeling dissatisfied, invoking
his
right
under
Section
3G(5)
of
the
NH
Act,
made
a
representation to the prescribed competent authority i.e. the
third respondent on 17th January 2017. The said representation
remained un-responded, as according to the learned Senior
Counsel appearing for the petitioner, the representation/demand
was made to the competent authority i.e. Central Government,
for appointment of an Arbitrator, as required under Section 3G(5)
of the NH Act. Failing which, the petitioner was constrained to
file this petition, seeking a direction of this Court to appoint the
Arbitrator in exercise of powers under Section 11(6) of the Act of
1996.
9.
Before adverting to the factual matrix involved in the
case on hand, it is apposite to refer to the relevant provisions.
Sub-section (6) of Section 11 of the Act of 1996 obligates the
Supreme Court or the High Court, as the case may be, to secure
the appointment of the Arbitrator.
Sub-section (5) of Section 11
of the Act of 1996 prescribes that if the parties fail to agree on
the arbitrator within thirty days from receipt of a request by one
party from the other party to so agree, the appointment shall be
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
made, upon request of a party, by the Supreme Court or, as the
case may be, the High Court.
Sub-section (2) of Section 11
prescribes that the parties are free to agree on a procedure for
appointing the arbitrator or arbitrators. Relevant provisions read
as under: ―11. Appointment of arbitrators. — (1) A person of
any nationality may be an arbitrator, unless otherwise
agreed by the parties.
(2) Subject to sub-section (6), the parties are
free to agree on a procedure for appointing the
arbitrator or arbitrators.
(3) Failing any agreement referred to in subsection (2), in an arbitration with three arbitrators, each
party shall appoint one arbitrator, and the two appointed
arbitrators shall appoint the third arbitrator who shall act
as the presiding arbitrator.
(4) If the appointment procedure in sub-section
(3) applies and—
(a) a party fails to appoint an arbitrator
within thirty days from the receipt of a
request to do so from the other party; or
(b) the two appointed arbitrators fail to
agree on the third arbitrator within thirty
days from the date of their appointment,
the appointment shall be made, upon request of a party,
by the Supreme Court or, as the case may be, the High
Court or any person or institution designated by such
Court.
(5) Failing any agreement referred to in subsection (2), in an arbitration with a sole arbitrator, if the
parties fail to agree on the arbitrator within thirty days
from receipt of a request by one party from the other
party to so agree the appointment shall be made, upon
request of a party, by the Supreme Court or, as the case
may be, the High Court or any person or institution
designated by such Court.
(6) Where, under an appointment procedure
agreed upon by the parties,—
(a) a party fails to act as required under
that procedure; or
(b) the parties, or the two appointed
arbitrators, fail to reach an agreement
expected of them under that procedure;
or
(c) a person, including an institution, fails
to perform any function entrusted to him
or it under that procedure,
a party may request the Supreme Court or, as the case
may be, the High Court or any person or institution
designated by such Court to take the necessary
measure, unless the agreement on the appointment
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
procedure provides
appointment.‖
x x x
10.
other
x x x
means
x x x
for
x x x
securing
the
x x x
In this case, there is no mechanism provided for
appointment of the Arbitrator under the provisions of the NH Act,
except sub-section (6) of Section 3G, which contemplates
applicability of provisions of the Act of 1996 to every arbitration
under the Act and as such, it is evident that the Central
Government is competent to appoint an Arbitrator, being a party
to the dispute, on receipt of a representation/ demand made by
other party, being aggrieved by the determination of the
compensation amount. In the case on hand, as submitted by the
petitioner, the representation was made to the prescribed
competent authority under the provisions of NH Act, i.e. to the
third respondent, the District Collector, East Sikkim.
It is the
case of the petitioner that the District Collector is the requisite
authority for making demand to refer the dispute to the
arbitrator to be appointed by the Central Government under subsection (5) of Section 3G of the NH Act.
11.
It is categorically stated by the learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the respondents that for want of appropriate
request to the proper competent authority, no decision on
appointment of the Arbitrator vide order dated 08th July 2016
could be communicated to the petitioner.
It is also contended
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
that the present petition is not maintainable for want of
compliance of Section 11(5) of the Act 1996 read with Section
3G(5)
of
the
NH
Act
before
approaching
this
Court
for
appointment of an Arbitrator.
12.
On bare perusal of Section 3, which provides for
appointment of the competent authority, read with Section 3A of
the NH Act, it is manifest that the competent authority, so
appointed under the Act, shall act on behalf of the Central
Government. Section 3A of the NH Act clearly contemplates that
the intention to acquire such land be notified in the Official
Gazette, which shall be done by the competent authority. Thus,
the competent authority, so notified, is a competent person to
receive application by either party for appointment of the
Arbitrator, in the event, the amount so determined is not
acceptable, under provisions of sub-section (5) of Section 3G of
the NH Act.
13.
The contention of learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the respondents is that the competent authority, being the
authority to determine the compensation, may not be the Central
Government, is noted to be rejected.
Drawing simile from the
Right
Transparency
to
Fair
Compensation
and
in
Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, wherein
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
the Collector is competent to pass the award and determine the
market value, but under Section 64, an application is made to
the Collector by a person, who has not accepted the award. On
receipt of application, the Collector is obliged to make a
reference to the appropriate authority. Likewise, in the case on
hand, the competent authority alone is empowered to receive the
request by a party to refer the dispute to the Arbitrator, to be
appointed by the Central Government.
In such an event, the
request was properly made by the petitioner on 17 th January
2017 for appointment of the Arbitrator. Section 11 of the Act of
1996 contemplates appointment of an Arbitrator within thirty
days from the receipt of a request to do so from the other party.
In the event the appointment is not made within such time, the
parties are at liberty to take recourse to provision of Section 11
of the Act of 1996. Thus, this petition is maintainable.
14.
Indisputably, the District Collectors of all the Districts
are appointed as competent authority for their respective
Districts under Section 3A of the NH Act, as evident from the
order dated 31st December 2015.
15.
The respondents, according to Mr. Thapa, learned
Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner, has come up first
time with an order of appointment of an Arbitrator with the
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
counter affidavit filed on 23rd May 2017 herein.
Thus, the said
order is no order in the eyes of law, as the same was not
communicated to the concerned person.
Referring to the
proposition of law laid down by the Supreme Court in Bachhittar
Singh (supra), Mr. Thapa would further contend that the order
be treated as invalid. Learned Senior Counsel next submits that
since such an order became effective on communication to the
petitioner after filing of the petition, this was without authority of
law.
16.
On examination, it is found that the order dated 08th
July 2016 (Annexure A-1) was issued by the respondent
department
under
signature
Government of India.
of
Deputy
Secretary
to
the
Seemingly, the said order was neither
notified nor communicated to any concerned persons, who are
likely to be impacted by the said order.
The notification dated
09th July 2016, whereunder the land-in-question along with other
lands were declared to have been acquired and vested absolutely
in the Central Government, free from all encumbrances, also
does not indicate the appointment of the Arbitrator before
publication of the notice and as such, there was no reason for the
petitioner and other parties to be informed of the appointment of
the Arbitrator. In such view of the matter, even if the Arbitrator
is appointed, the same shall come into effect so far as the
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
petitioner is concerned from the date of filing of the counter
affidavit i.e. the date when the petitioner came to know about
the order.
17.
In Bachhittar Singh (supra), a constitution bench of
the Supreme Court, examining the nature and ambit of an order
of the State Government, held as under:
―(10) …………… Therefore to make the opinion amount
to a decision of the Government it must be
communicated to the person concerned. In this
connection we may quote the following from the
judgment of this Court in the State of Punjab v. Sodhi
Sukhdev Singh : AIR 1961 SC 493 at p. 512:
"Mr. Gopal Singh attempted to argue that before
the final order was passed the Council of
Ministers had decided to accept the respondent’s
representation and to reinstate him, and that,
according to him, the respondent seeks to prove
by calling the two original orders. We are unable
to understand this argument. Even if the Council
of Ministers had provisionally decided to reinstate
the respondent that would not prevent the
Council from reconsidering the matter and
coming to a contrary conclusion later on, until a
final decision is reached by them and is
communicated to the Rajpramukh in the form of
advice and acted upon by him by issuing an order
in that behalf to the respondent."
Thus it is of the essence that the order has to be
communicated to the person who would be affected by
that order before the State and that person can be
bound by that order. For, until the order is
communicated to the person affected by it, it would be
open to the Council of Ministers to consider the matter
over and over against and, therefore, till its
communication the order cannot be regarded as
anything more than provisional in character.‖
18.
The aforestated principle of law was referred with the
approval in MCD vs. Qimat Rai Gupta6, holding that the
communication of an order is a necessary ingredient for bringing
-----------------------------6
(2007) 7 SCC 309
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
an end result to a status or to provide a person an opportunity to
take recourse to law if he is aggrieved thereby, the order is
required to be communicated.
19.
Bharat
Subsequently, in Bipromasz Bipron Trading SA vs.
Electronics
Limited
(BEL)7,
the
Supreme
Court
recapitulated the said proposition of law as under: ―38.
…………The order made by a statutory authority or
an officer exercising the powers of that authority comes
into force so far as the authority/officer is concerned,
from the date it is made by the authority/officer
concerned.
But so far as the affected party is
concerned, the order made by the appropriate authority
would
be
the
date
on
which
it
is
communicated………………‖
20.
In Vivek Batra vs. Union of India8, the Supreme
Court has further reaffirmed the proposition of law laid down by
the Supreme Court in Sethi Auto Services Station vs. DDA :
(2009) 1 SCC 180 that notings in the file culminate into an
executable order, affecting the rights of the parties, only when it
reaches the final decision-making authority in the department,
gets his approval and the final order is communicated to the
person concerned.
21.
In view of the aforestated well-settled principles of
law, the order dated 08th July 2016 appointing the Secretarycum-Relief
Commissioner,
-------------------------------7
(2012) 6 SCC 384
(2017) 1 SCC 69
Land
Revenue
and
Disaster
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
Management Department, Government of Sikkim as Arbitrator
for all the Districts of the Sikkim cannot be held as an order of
appointment of the Arbitrator in the disputes involved herein.
Moreover,
other
mode
of
communication
for
extending
authenticity to the order or circular of the Central Government or
State Government, is publication by way of notification either in
the Gazette or in any other mode, presumably to bring into
notice of the concerned persons or else the Central Government
ought to have communicated in the notification dated 9th July
2016 of acquisition of land for the appointment of the Arbitrator
to enable the aggrieved parties to take recourse to the
appropriate forum, if necessary.
It is clearly stated by the
learned counsel appearing for the respondents that it was neither
published by way of notification nor informed through the
notification of acquisition of land dated 09th July 2017 to any
party. Thus, unhesitatingly it is held that the Arbitrator was not
appointed in the instant dispute.
22.
At this stage, it is pertinent to examine the relevant
provisions of the Act of 1996, which is made applicable to the
dispute herein.
Section 3G (5) and (6) of the NH Act read as
under: ―3G.
Determination
compensation.-
of
(1) to (4) …………………………
amount
payable
as
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
(5)
If the amount determined by the competent
authority under sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) is not
acceptable to either of the parties, the amount shal, on
an application by either of the parties, be determined by
the arbitrator to be appointed by the Central
Government.
(6)
Subject to provisions of this Act, the provisions of
the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996)
shall apply to every arbitration under this Act.‖
23.
On plain reading of the relevant provisions, which is
clear and unambiguous, it is revealed that on refusal to appoint
the Arbitrator, as contemplated under sub-section (5) of Section
3G of the NH Act, the appointment of the Arbitrator and also the
adjudication by the Arbitrator shall be in accordance with the
provision of the Act of 1996.
24.
Mr. Thapa would contend that once the petition has
been moved for appointment of the Arbitrator, the other party is
divested of the power to appoint the Arbitrator.
25.
In Datar Switchgears Ltd. (supra), the Supreme
Court observed as under: ―19.
…………………… if one party demands the opposite
party to appoint an arbitrator and the opposite party
does not make an appointment within 30 days of the
demand, the right to appointment does not get
automatically forfeited after expiry of 30 days. If the
opposite party makes an appointment even after 30
days of the demand, but before the first party has
moved the Court under Section 11, that would be
sufficient. In other words, in cases arising under Section
11(6), if the opposite party has not made an
appointment within 30 days of demand, the right to
make appointment is not forfeited but continues, but an
appointment has to be made before the former files
application under Section 11 seeking appointment of an
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
arbitrator. Only then the right of the opposite party
ceases. ……………………‖
26.
In Northern Railway Administration (supra), the
similar issue came up for consideration before the Supreme
Court, wherein it was held as under: ―12.
A bare reading of the scheme of Section
11 shows that the emphasis is on the terms of the
agreement being adhered to and/or given effect as
closely as possible. In other words, the Court may ask to
do what has not been done. The court must first ensure
that the remedies provided for are exhausted. It is true
as contended by Mr. Desai, that it is not mandatory for
the Chief Justice or any person or institution designated
by him to appoint the named arbitrator or arbitrators.
But at the same time, due regard has to be given to the
qualifications required by the agreement and other
considerations.‖
27.
In Ace Pipeline Contracts (P) Ltd. (supra), the
observations made in the Datar Switchgears Ltd. (supra) was
referred with affirmation as under: ―Therefore, mandamus can be issued by the courts in
exercise of pwers under Section 11(6) of the Act but the
demand should be in the event of failure by the
authorities to appoint arbitrators within the reasonable
time.‖
28.
In view of the aforestated well-settled proposition of
law, the Central Government has failed to appoint the Arbitrator
within the prescribed time, as required, and as such, this Court
may proceed to appoint the Arbitrator, in accordance with law.
29.
The question in respect of neutrality, impartiality and
independence of the Arbitrator, as pleaded by the learned Senior
Counsel, appearing for the petitioner, is not relevant to the issue
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
under consideration in case on hand.
The appointment of the
Arbitrator made by the Central Government before 08 th July 2016
is found as invalid.
In such view, the Court is not inclined to
examine this issue at this stage as it is premature.
It is
beneficial to refer to the observation made by the Supreme Court
in
Voestalpine Schienen GMBH (supra), in respect of the
requisites of an Arbitrator, wherein the Supreme Court has
observed as under: ―24. Section 12 has been amended with the objective to
induce neutrality of arbitrators, viz., their independence
and impartiality. The amended provision is enacted to
identify the 'circumstances' which give rise to 'justifiable
doubts' about the independence or impartiality of the
arbitrator. If any of those circumstances as mentioned
therein exists, it will give rise to justifiable apprehension
of bias. The Fifth Schedule to the Act enumerates the
grounds which may give rise to justifiable doubts of this
nature. Likewise, Seventh Schedule mentions those
circumstances which would attract the provisions of
Subsection (5) of Section 12 and nullify any prior
agreement to the contrary. In the context of this case, it
is relevant to mention that only if an arbitrator is an
employee, a consultant, an advisor or has any past or
present business relationship with a party, he is
rendered ineligible to act as an arbitrator. Likewise, that
person is treated as incompetent to perform the role of
arbitrator, who is a manager, director or part of the
management or has a single controlling influence in an
affiliate of one of the parties if the affiliate is directly
involved in the matters in dispute in the arbitration.
Likewise, persons who regularly advised the appointing
party or affiliate of the appointing party are
incapacitated. A comprehensive list is enumerated in
Schedule 5 and Schedule 7 and admittedly the persons
empaneled by the Respondent are not covered by any of
the items in the said list.‖
30.
The petitioner has given a list of Arbitrators, who are
not acceptable to the other party. In such view of the matter, it
is deemed proper to appoint Mr. Justice A.P. Subba, former
Arb. P. No. 01 of 2017
Prakash Chand Pradhan vs. Union of India & Ors.
Judge of this High Court as an Arbitrator to the disputes.
Mr.
Justice Subba is requested to enter upon the reference in issue,
after notice to the parties, at the earliest. The professional fee
and expenses is determinable with the agreement by the
Arbitrator himself.
31.
The petition is ordered, accordingly.
Chief Justice
05.07.2017
jk/
Approved for Reporting
Internet
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review