Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:48481
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
917 WRIT PETITION NO. 13406 OF 2025
Prafulla s/o. Prakash Rathod
Age : 66 yrs, Occu. : Business,
R/o. Mandavi, Tal. Kinwat,
Dist. Nanded.
...
PETITIONER
(Org. Respondent No.1)
VERSUS
1.
Allabaksh Abdul Razzak
Age : 85 yrs, Occu. : Business,
R/o. Kinwat, Tal. Kinwat,
Dist. Nanded.
2.
Ramlu Shankarrao Nilawar (since deceased)
Age : 84 yrs, Occu. : Business,
R/o. Kinwat, Tal. Kinwat,
Dist. Nanded.
3.
Shankarrao Madhavrao Chadawar
Age : 75 yrs, Occu. : Business,
R/o. Kinwat, Tal. Kinwat,
Dist. Nanded.
4.
Thakur Narayan Jadhav
Age : 70 yrs, Occu. : Agri,
R/o. Sarakhani, Tal. Kinwat,
Dist. Nanded.
5.
Jaswantsingh Gyansingh Sokhi
Age : 70 yrs, Occu. : Business,
R/o. Kinwat, Tal. Kinwat,
Dist. Nanded.
6.
Digambar Bapurao Patil
Age : 80 yrs, Occu. : Agri,
R/o. Malakjam, Tal. Kinwat,
Dist. Nanded.
7.
Yadavrao Mukundrao Nemmaniwar (since deceased)
R/o. Yelampura, Tal : Kinwat,
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
Dist Nanded.
8.
IsaKhan Sardarkhan
Age : 75 yrs, Occu. : Business,
R/o. Kinwat, Tal. Kinwat,
Dist. Nanded.
9.
Dinkar Bapurao Chadawar
Age : 70 yrs, Occu. : Business,
R/o. Kinwat, Tal. Kinwat,
Dist. Nanded.
10.
Narayanrao Rajaram Sidam
Age : 70 yrs, Occu. : Agri,
R/o. Gokunda, Tal. Kinwat,
Dist. Nanded.
11.
Gangareddy s/o. Bhumanna Bainamwar
Age : 70 yrs, Occu. : Agri,
R/o. Bellori, Tal. Kinwat,
Dist. Nanded.
12.
Ramrao s/o Ganpatrao Jadhav
Age : 70 yrs, Occu. : Agri,
R/o. Kamthala, Tal. Kinwat,
Dist. Nanded.
13.
Sakhaulla Khan s/o. Amanulla Khan
Age : 66 yrs, Occu. : Business,
R/o. Kinwat, Tal. Kinwat,
Dist. Nanded.
14.
The State of Maharashtra
Through the Principal Secretary (Law & Judiciary Dept.)
Mantralaya, Mumbai.
15.
The Deputy Charity Commissioner,
Nanded Region, Nanded.
...
RESPONDENTS
_______________________________________
Mr. Rajendra S. Deshmukh, Senior Counsel i/b. Mr. Amol R. Joshi for the
Petitioner
Mr. P. R. Katneshwarkar, Senior Counsel i/b. Mr. S.N. Janakwade for
Respondent No. 1.
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
Mr. Ramchandra S. Patil, for Respondent Nos. 3 to 6, 8 to 10.
Mr. Arvind S. Deshmukh for Respondent Nos. 11 to 13.
Mr. V. M. Kagne, learned AGP for Respondent Nos. 14 & 15.
_______________________________________
CORAM : NITIN B. SURYAWANSHI &
ABASAHEB D. SHINDE, JJ.
RESERVED ON :
PRONOUNCED ON :
04/08/2026
07/10/2026
JUDGMENT (PER : ABASAHEB D. SHINDE, J) :
1.
Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith with the consent of the
parties, the Writ Petition is heard finally at the stage of admission.
2.
By this Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the Petitioner is taking exception to the order dated 20 th October 2025,
passed by the Respondent No. 15 – Deputy Charity Commissioner at Nanded
under Section 41-A of the Maharashtra Public Trust Act, 1950 (for the sake
of brevity hereinafter called the ‘Trust Act’) in Inquiry Application No. 848 of
2025.
FACTUAL MATRIX :3.
It is the case of the Petitioner that the “Kinwat Shikshan Santha,
Kinwat, Dist. Nanded” is an Educational Trust (hereinafter called as the ‘said
Trust’) registered under the Trust Act. It is governed by the provisions of the
Trust Act and the Scheme of the said Trust. The term of elected Board of
Trustees is of five years.
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
4.
The last elections of Board of Trustees were held in January 2016, in
which the Petitioner was elected as a Chairman of the said Trust and to that
effect the Change Report bearing Inquiry No. 287 of 2016 under Section 22
of the Trust Act, was filed before Respondent No. 15. By order dated 15 th
March 2019 Respondent No. 15 allowed the said Change Report. The entry
of Board of Trustees including the name of the Petitioner was taken in
Schedule-I of the said Trust. As the tenure of erstwhile Board of Trustees
came to an end, fresh elections were held in December 2022, for the period
2022 to 2027. The Petitioner, Respondent No. 1 and Respondent Nos. 11 to
13 got elected. Respondent Nos. 3 to 10 claims to have been elected in the
said election. The petitioner filed Change Report bearing Inquiry No. 1212 of
2022 whereas, Respondents No. 4 filed Change Report bearing Inquiry No.
1213 of 2022 before Respondent No. 15.
5.
It is further case of the Petitioner that, while both the Change Reports
were pending before Respondent No. 15, Respondent No. 2 (now deceased)
filed an application under Section 41-A of the Trust Act, contending that, the
said Trust runs Baliram Patil College at Kinwat District Nanded (hereinafter
called as “the said College”). Due to pendency of both the Change Reports,
the appointments of teaching and non-teaching staff of the said College
could not be made. The salaries of the in-service employees have also not
been paid. The entire day to day activities of the said college have come to a
standstill as a result of which the students of the said College are being
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
made to suffer. It was thus prayed that, by rejecting both the Change Reports
directions be issued to hold fresh elections of the said Trust.
6.
The Petitioner as well as other contesting Respondents opposed the
said application on the ground of its maintainability. It was contended that,
since both the Change Reports were pending adjudication, there was no
cause of action for filing such an application. It appears from the record that
Respondent No. 2 (original Applicant) expired during the pendency of the
said Application, as a result of which Respondent No. 1 was transposed as
the Applicant in the said proceedings.
7.
The Petitioner further contends that, Respondent No. 15 on 20 th
October 2025 pronounced the judgment in the Change Reports thereby
rejecting both of them. Though the Petitioner prayed for certified copy of the
judgment, the same was not provided to him, on the contrary, Respondent
No. 15 by impugned order allowed the application filed by the Respondent
No. 1 under Section 41-A of the Trust Act on the same day, thereby directing
to hold fresh elections of the said Trust and submit the Change Report to that
effect. The Petitioner therefore has approached this Court challenging the
impugned order.
SUBMISSIONS :8.
Mr. Deshmukh, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Petitioner
while assailing the impugned order strenuously submits that, the application
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
under Section 41-A of the Trust Act itself was not maintainable, as there was
no occasion for filing the said application in the midst of hearing of the
pending Change Reports. He submits that, Respondent No. 15 has exceeded
his jurisdiction by allowing the said application merely because the Change
Reports filed by both the rival groups have been rejected. He further submits
that, whosoever is aggrieved by the rejection of its Change Report can resort
to remedy of filing Appeal under Section 70 of the Trust Act. He would
submit that, before passing the impugned order, Respondent No. 15 has not
given sufficient opportunity of hearing to the Petitioner as well as the other
contesting respondents. The impugned order is thus violative of the principle
of natural justice. He therefore urged that, impugned order deserves to be
quashed and set aside. In support of his submissions he has relied on the
following Judgments :I.
Vanmala Manoharrao Kamdi & Ors. Vs. Deputy Charity
Commissioner, Nagpur & Ors. 2012(3) Mh.L.J.594,
II.
Shri. Damodar Jairam Sao Vs. Deputy Charity Commissioner,
Nagpur Region & Ors. (decided on 19th September 2011 in Writ
Petition No. 4847 of 2010).
III. Hazarat Maulana Mufti Mujeeb Ashraf Sahab and Ors. Vs.
Allamah Haji Sayyed Hussaini Miyan Sahab and Ors. (2020(4) MhLJ
757),
IV.
Shri. Shyam Vasant Kale and Anr. Vs. The learned Assistant
Charity Commissioner-II, Nagpur and Ors. (decided on 10th June 2026
in Writ Petition 4116 of 2026)
V.
Ramesh Tulshiram Bhutekar and Anr. Vs. The Asiatic Society of
Mumbai & Ors. (decided on 06th November 2025 in Writ Petition No.
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
15028 of 2025),
VI. Dinkar Shankarrao Patil & Ors. Vs. Dr. Sheshrao Shankarrao Patil
& Ors. (2008(3) Mh.L.J. 833),
VII. Raghunath s/o. Motiram Patil Vs. The State of Maharashtra &
Ors. (2008 (2) Mh.L.J. 78).
9.
Per contra, Mr. Katneshwarkar, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
Respondent No. 1 would submit that, the said Application was filed taking
into consideration the interest of the students as well as the employees of the
said college and the difficulties being faced while managing the day to day
affairs of the said Trust. The said application satisfies the test laid down
under Section 41-A of the Trust Act. He further submits that, Respondent
No. 15 has rightly passed the impugned order. He would submit that, since
election process pursuant to the impugned order is set in motion by issuing
notice for holding the elections, this Court would be slow in interfering with
the election process. To substantiate his submissions he placed reliance on
the following judgments :
I.
Shivram Apparao Suryawanshi and Ors. Vs. Assistant Charity
Commissioner-1, Latur & Ors. (Decided on 11th April 2023 in Writ
Petition No. 2122 of 2023),
II.
Balwantrao Jaywantrao Wagh & Ors. Vs. The Hon’ble Deputy
Charity Commissioner, Jalgaon & Ors. (Decided on 19th March 2024 in
Writ Petition No. 2704 of 2024),
III. Dattatraya Mahadeo Hiware & Ors. Vs. Arjun Sambhaji Shinde &
Ors. (2007(1) Mh.L.J. 48),
IV.
Sandip Ram Meghe and Ors. Vs. Pundalikrao Balaji Gohad &
Ors. (2013(4) Mh.L.J. 703),
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
V.
Mahavir Jain Vidyalaya & Ors.
Commissioner & Ors. (2001(5) AllMR 731),
VI.
Vs.
Assistant
Charity
Shaji K. Joseph Vs. V. Vishwanath & Ors. (2016(4) SCC 429).
CONSIDERATION :10.
We have heard the learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner, learned
Senior Counsel appearing for Respondent No. 1, learned Counsel for
Respondent Nos. 3 to 10, learned Counsel appearing for Respondent Nos. 11
to 13, learned AGP for Respondent Nos. 14 and 15, at length, perused the
record and the judgments relied upon by the respective counsel.
11.
Before adverting to the rival submissions advanced by both the sides it
would be apt to consider the provisions of Section 41-A of the Trust Act
which reads thus :
41-A. Power of Commissioner to issue directions
(for proper administration of the trust) : ––
(1) Subject to the provisions of this Act, the Charity
Commissioner may from time to time issue directions to
any trustee of a public trust or any person connected
therewith, to ensure that the trust is properly administered,
and the income thereof is properly accounted for or duly
appropriated and applied to the objects and for the
purposes of the trust; and the Charity Commissioner may
also give directions to the trustees or such person that if he
finds that any property of the trust is in danger of being
wasted, damaged, alienated or wrongfully sold, removed
or disposed of.
(Provided that, if any application is made by the trustee of
any trust for seeking directions under sub-section (1), the
Charity Commissioner shall decide such application within
three months from the date of its receipt and if it is not
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
practicable so to do, the Charity Commissioner shall record
the reasons for the same.)
(2) It shall be the duty of every trustee or of such person to
comply with the directions issued under sub-section (1).
12.
A bare perusal of Section 41-A of the Trust Act makes it abundantly
clear that, the Charity Commissioner is entrusted with powers to issue
directions from time to time to any trustee or a person connected therewith
to ensure that the trust is properly administered and any income thereof is
properly accounted for or duly appropriated and applied to the objects and
for the purposes of the trust. The Charity Commissioner is also empowered
to issue directions if he finds that any property of the trust is in danger of
being wasted, damaged, alienated or wrongfully sold, removed or disposed
of. It is equally true that, the above provision also empowers the Charity
Commissioner to issue directions to hold the elections if such a contingency
arises.
13.
The question, therefore, falls for consideration in this Writ Petition is
whether a situation has arisen warranting the issuance of directions for
holding fresh elections of the said Trust.
14.
Indisputably, as per the provisions of Section 56F of the Trust Act and
the scheme of the said Trust, term of the elected Board of Trustees of the said
Trust is of five years. The last elections of the said Trust were held in 2016.
After the expiry of term of the Board of Trustees, the elections were held in
December 2022 for the period of 2022-2027. Pursuant to the said election,
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
the petitioner, Respondent Nos.1 and 11 to 13, filed a Change Report bearing
Enquiry No.1212/2022, whereas Respondent Nos.3 to 11, filed a Change
Report bearing Enquiry No.1213/2022 before Respondent No.15. While both
these Change Reports were pending, on 09th July 2025, Respondent No.2
(deceased) appears to have filed an application under Section 41A of the
Trust Act, seeking directions to hold fresh elections. Respondent No.15 by the
impugned order allowed the said application on the premise that, by virtue
of the rejection of both the Change Reports, the executive body entered in
Schedule-I has become de-facto trustees, therefore,they cannot take policy
decisions. So as to ensure proper administration of the said Trust, it would be
necessary to issue directions for holding fresh elections.
15.
It is trite law that, the powers under Section 41A of the Trust Act
cannot be resorted to in a routine manner. Before entertaining such an
application and passing order thereon, the Assistant Charity Commissioner
will have to arrive at a subjective satisfaction, whether the circumstances
enumerated under Section 41A of the Trust Act are made out by the
Applicant/s.
Meaning
thereby,
such
powers
cannot
be
exercised
mechanically.
16.
In the instant case, as can be seen from the record that, even before
the Change Reports of the rival groups could be heard and decided, the
application under Section 41A of the Trust Act was filed. Respondent No.15
allowed the said application, thereby directing to hold fresh elections, owing
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
to rejection of the Change Reports filed by the rival groups. Respondent
No.15 presumed that, the order of rejection of the Change Reports filed by
the rival groups has attained finality. However, it is pertinent to note that,
any order passed by the Assistant Charity Commissioner either accepting or
rejecting the Change Report is always amenable to Appeal under Section 70
of the Trust Act.
17.
It is settled position of law that, the right of appeal is not merely a
matter of procedure, but a substantive right. In light of this, the petitioner
has every right to challenge the order of rejection of his Change Report in
view of the fact that the term of Board of Trustees, including the petitioner is
upto December 2027. We are therefore of the considered view that, if the
impugned order is allowed to be sustained, it would amount to taking away
the Petitioner’s statutory right of appeal under Section 70 of the Trust Act.
18.
In almost similar set of facts, learned Single Judge of this Court in the
case of Raghunath S/o. Motiram Patil (supra) held thus :
“8.
Turning to the facts of the case on hand, it
appears that Change Report No. 13 of 2005, filed by one
group, was rejected by the learned Assistant Charity
Commissioner on 3rd May, 2007. The learned Assistant
Charity Commissioner presumed that the said order is
final, there is no trustee in the office and, therefore,
administrator needs to be appointed. Appeal against
order passed under Section 22 is provided under Section
70 of the said Act. Right of appeal is a valuable right. It is
apropos to refer to a Constitution Bench judgment of the
Apex Court in the matter of Garikapati Veeraya v.
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
Subbiah Choudhary and Ors. Reported in AIR 1957 SC
540. The Apex Court observed:
(23) From the decisions cited above the following
principles clearly emerge:
(i) That the legal pursuit of a remedy, suit,
appeal and second appeal are really but steps
in a series of proceedings all connected by an
intrinsic unity and are to be regarded as one
legal proceeding.
(ii) The right of appeal is not a mere matter of
procedure but is a substantive right.
(iii)
The institution of the suit carries
with it the implication that all rights of appeal
then in force are preserved to the parties
thereto till the rest of the career of the suit.
(iv)
The right of appeal is a vested right
and such a right to enter the superior Court
accrues to the litigant and exists as on and
from the date the lis commences and although
it may be actually exercised when the adverse
judgment is pronounced such right is to be
governed by the law prevailing at the date of
the institution of the suit or proceeding and
not by the law that prevails at the date of its
decision or at the date of the filing of the
appeal.
(V) This vested right of appeal can be taken
away only by a subsequent enactment, if it so
provides expressly or by necessary intendment
and not otherwise.”
19.
We respectfully agree with the above view. Applying the aforesaid
observations of this court to the case in hand, we find that, the impugned
order passed by Respondent No. 15 cannot sustain.
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
20.
The issue whether an application under Section 41-A of the Trust Act
seeking directions to hold election, can be entertained and allowed by the
Assistant Charity Commissioner either while Change Report is pending
adjudication or after its rejection has been underscored by the Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court in the case of Dinkar Shankarrao Patil (supra), wherein
this court held thus:
“12)
Now, turning to the case on hand, there is no dispute
that two change reports are filed and pending before the learned
Assistant Charity Commissioner on behalf of the petitioners as
well as respondents 1 and 2. Both of them are claiming that
general body meeting of the trust in question had taken place,
on a particular date and few persons have been elected either as
a member of the managing committee and/or office bearers of
the trust in question. In relation to this aspect, both learned
Counsel have produced on record ample material, consisting of
affidavits and copies of the correspondence, either to the
University or from the University. Both applications,
undisputedly, are pending before the learned Assistant Charity
Commissioner. The question of fact, regarding election of the
trust in question and election of the members as well as office
bearers of the trust, at present, is pending before the learned
Assistant Charity Commissioner. We, therefore, refrain ourselves
from referring this material in extenso and record any finding.
The orders, which are likely to be passed by learned Assistant
Charity Commissioner are subject to further proceedings under
Sections 70 and 72 of the said Act.
13.
The orders purportedly passed by the learned Assistant
Charity Commissioner under Section 41-A of the Act in routine
have been challenged by filing writ petitions time and again
before this Court. It is an usual phenomenon that two or more
groups are claiming management of the registered public trust.
The change reports, according to them, under Section 22 of the
said Act have been filed before the learned Assistant Charity
Commissioner. Before disposal of change reports under Section
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
22, learned Assistant Charity Commissioner gets the application
purportedly under Section 41-A from one of the groups or
sometimes from both the groups and instead of disposing and
deciding the application under Section 22 of the said Act,
learned Assistant Charity Commissioner entertains an
application purportedly under Section 41-A of the Act and
orders are being passed.
14.
According to the provision under Section 22 of the said
Act, change occurred has to be reported to the learned Assistant
Charity Commissioner. The decision of the learned Assistant
Charity Commissioner is not final in the matter and such orders
are taken up in further proceedings either under Sections 70 or
72 of the said Act and ultimately under Article/s 226/227 of the
Constitution of India before this Court. It is, in this backdrop, the
learned Assistant Charity Commissioner or the learned Charity
Commissioner exercising powers under Section 41-A of the Act
has to be careful while entertaining such an application. He
should record a finding whether the application is entertainable
under Section 41-A of the Act. It is in this circumstance, the
learned Assistant Charity Commissioner should pass orders on
such applications. The learned Assistant Charity Commissioner
concerned shall decide and dispose of the change reports
expeditiously, if necessary, by hearing the matters on day to day
basis. Such final disposal of the change reports may help in
proper administration of the trust in question, as well as the
trustees concerned.
15.
As observed by us in the foregoing paragraphs, such
directions under Section 41-A of the Act can be given to trustees.
Unless such status being a trustee is available with the learned
Assistant Charity Commissioner, he shall not entertain an
application under Section 41-A of the Act and issue directions.
All endeavor should be made for final disposal of the change
reports or the applications filed under Section 22 of the said Act.
16.
Process of recruitment of some teaching and nonteaching staff as approved by the University in relation to Senior
College is in vogue. Such process is initiated in view of an
advertisement published on 10.11.2007. Such recruitment
process shall be proceeded in accordance with provisions of
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
Maharashtra Universities Act, 1994. We are told that the
Selection Committees are provided under Sections 78 and 79 of
the said Act of 1994. In case member / representative of the
trust is required to be a member of the Selection Committee, one
member, out of eight remaining, who are not recited as elected
members of board of trustees in either of the change reports and
who is having highest educational qualification shall represent
the trust on the selection committee. If such two members are
equally qualified, one who has acquired highest qualification in
earlier point of time shall be deemed senior and be the member
of the Selection Committee on behalf of the trust.
17.
We have gone through the application filed by
respondent Nos. 1 and 2 purportedly under Section 41-A of the
said Act in the case on hand. we are of the firm opinion that this
application ought not to have been entertained by the learned
Assistant Charity Commissioner under Section 41-A of the said
Act. The order impugned in this writ petition, therefore, needs
to be quashed and set aside, with further direction that the
Assistant Charity Commissioner, Osmanabad shall decide
Change Reports 717 and 722 of 2007 on/or before 18.04.2008.
The petitioners as well as respondents 1 and 2 shall remain
present before the Assistant Charity Commissioner on
25.02.2008 at 11.30 a.m. ”
21.
In the light of the aforesaid ratio it is clear that, Respondent No. 15
has exceeded his jurisdiction in passing the impugned order under Section
41-A of the Trust Act.
22.
So far as judgments relied upon by the learned Senior Counsel for the
Petitioner in the case of Vanmala Manoharrao Kamdi (supra), Shri. Damodar
Jairam Sao (supra), Hazarat Maulana Mufti Mujeeb Ashraf Sahab (supra),
Shri. Shyam Vasant Kale (supra), Ramesh Tulshiram Bhutekar (supra) and
Shri. Damodar Jairam Sao (supra) are concerned, those are on the point as
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
to whether the order passed under Section 41-A of the Trust Act is a quasi
judicial or an administrative order. There is no dispute about the legal
proposition that same is administrative in nature. We thus find that, these
judgments have no bearing on the facts of the present case.
23.
Now coming to the judgments relied upon by the learned Senior
Counsel appearing for Respondent No. 1. In the case of Shivram Apparao
Suryawanshi (supra), the challenge was to the order passed by the Assistant
Charity
Commissioner
thereby
rejecting
withdrawal pursis
filed
in
application under Section 41-A of the Trust Act. The learned Single Judge of
this Court dismissed the Writ Petition, holding that the said withdrawal
pursis was filed by the petitioner in collusion with Respondents therein.
24.
Similarly, in the case of Balwantrao Jayawantrao Wagh (supra),
Dattatraya Mahadeo Hiware (supra) and Sandip Ram Meghe (supra), the
directions issued by Assistant Charity Commissioner for holding elections
were upheld by this court since, the term of the Board of Trustees therein
had come to an end. In the instant case, as observed herein-above, the term
of elected Board of Trustees is going to expire in December 2027. We are,
therefore, of the opinion that none of these judgments are applicable to the
case in hand.
25.
So far as the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Shaji
K. Joseph (supra) and judgment of this Court in the case of Mahavir Jain
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
Vidyalaya (supra) are concerned, those are on the aspect as to whether this
Court can interfere with the election process after its commencement. In the
case in hand, the fresh elections are being held pursuant to the impugned
order. Since the impugned order does not sustain in the eyes of law, in view
of what we have observed hereinabove, the consequential declaration of the
election programme is hardly of any consequence. With due respect, even
these judgments have no application.
“CONCLUSION” :
26.
In view of the aforesaid discussion and in the light of the judgment of
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Dinkar Shankarrao Patil
(supra) and the judgment of the learned Single Judge of this Court in the
case of Raghunath Motiram Patil (supra), we are of the considered view that
the impugned order passed by Respondent No. 15 is unsustainable and the
same deserves to be quashed and set aside.
27.
In the result, we pass the following order :
:: ORDER ::
A)
The present Writ Petition is allowed.
B)
The impugned order dated 20th October 2025, passed by
the Ld. Deputy Charity Commissioner, Nanded under
Section 41-A of the Maharashtra Public Trust Act, 1950,
in Inquiry Application No. 848/2025 is hereby quashed
and set aside.
C)
The Appellate Authority before whom the appeal filed by
the Petitioner challenging the rejection of Change Report
is stated to have been pending, is directed to decide and
(AWB) Writ Petition No.13406.2025.doc
dispose of the same as expeditiously as possible and in
any case, within a period of three months from the date
of receipt of copy of this order by giving opportunity of
hearing to all the contesting parties
D)
Rule is thus made absolute in the above terms with no
order as to costs.
( ABASAHEB D. SHINDE, J. )
( NITN B. SURYAWANSHI, J. )
Ajay Jadhavpatil
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review