Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 18th NOVEMBER, 2016
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------S.B. : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RFA No.03 of 2015
Appellant
:
Pradeep Golyan,
S/o Late Om Prakash Golyan,
R/o Jorethang,
P.O. & P.S. Jorethang,
South Sikkim.
versus
Respondent
:
Durga Prasad Mukhia,
S/o Late P. B. Mukhia,
R/o Jorethang,
P.O. & P.S. Jorethang,
South Sikkim.
Appeal under Order XLI, Rules 1 and 2
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. A. Moulik, Senior Advocate with Mrs. Kesang Diki Bhutia and Mr.
Ranjit Prasad, Advocates for the Appellant.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tamanna Chhetri and Ms.
Malati Sharma, Advocates for the Respondent.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CO No.05 of 2015
Appellant
:
Durga Prasad Mukhia,
S/o Late P. B. Mukhia,
R/o Jorethang,
P.O. & P.S. Jorethang,
South Sikkim.
versus
Respondent
:
Pradeep Golyan,
S/o Late Om Prakash Golyan,
R/o Jorethang,
P.O. & P.S. Jorethang,
South Sikkim.
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
Cross Objection under Order XLI Rule 22(1)
and (2) read with Section 151 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tamanna Chhetri and Ms.
Malati Sharma, Advocates for the Appellant.
Mr. A. Moulik, Senior Advocate with Mrs. Kesang Diki Bhutia and
Mr. Ranjit Prasad, Advocates for the Respondent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Appeal has been preferred by the Appellant/
Defendant assailing the Judgment and Decree, both dated 30-062015, in Eviction Suit No.01 of 2013, of the Learned District
Judge, South Sikkim, at Namchi, decreeing the suit in favour of
the Respondent/Plaintiff. A Cross Objection was also filed by the
Respondent/Plaintiff assailing the finding of the Learned Trial
Court in Issue no.3.
2.
The Regular First Appeal and the Cross Objection are
taken up together as they arise out of the same impugned
Judgment.
3.
The Plaintiff before the Learned Trial Court and the
Respondent herein, (hereinafter referred to as the “Plaintiff”) had
sought for eviction of the suit premises by the Defendant,
Appellant herein, (hereinafter referred to as the “Defendant”), and
for recovery of arrears of rent.
The facts before the Learned Trial
Court as averred by the Plaintiff was that in a family partition, he
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
had received three rooms including the suit property as his share
on the ground floor of a building, situated in Jorethang, South
Sikkim, of which two rooms collectively measuring 30' x 15' are
the suit premises, in the occupation of the Defendant. The third
room measuring 9' x 15' is in the occupation of another tenant
Anil Kumar Gupta, at a monthly rent of Rs.2,000/- (Rupees two
thousand) only. In addition to the said three rooms, he received
three other rooms on the first floor of the same building which is
utilised as his residence.
Another room in the terrace of the
building also fell in his share and is being used as a kitchen. The
suit property was initially rented out to the father of the
Defendant in the year 1993, at a monthly rent of Rs.1,100/(Rupees one thousand and one hundred) only.
On his death in
the year 2000, the tenancy was continued by the Defendant, at a
monthly rent of Rs.1,800/- (Rupees one thousand and eight
hundred) only. Apart from the said property, the Plaintiff has no
other house or buildings anywhere.
In May, 2011, the Plaintiff
sought to enhance the rent, which was declined by the Defendant,
instead without the Plaintiff’s consent, he unilaterally started
sending monthly rent amounting to Rs.2,500/- (Rupees two
thousand and five hundred) only, through Money Orders, from the
same month.
That, the Defendant used to make advance
payments for rent which were duly adjusted on a monthly basis
by the Plaintiff, a balance of Rs.35,182/- (Rupees thirty five
thousand one hundred and eighty two) only, remains in the
advance credit of the Defendant. Thus calculated, balance arrears
of Rs.13,418/- (Rupees thirteen thousand four hundred and
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
eighteen) only, from the month of May, 2011 up to July, 2013,
are due from him.
That, the rents received from the tenanted
premises of the Defendant and Anil Kumar Gupta are the only
source of income of the Plaintiff, who lost his eyesight due to
health complications in the year 2003 and was dependent on his
wife for his daily needs.
Subsequently, his wife developed an
ailment in her leg, thereby requiring their eldest daughter Ms.
Sabnam Mukhia to resign in April, 2013, from her private job,
where she had been employed from 2000, to assist her parents.
Being thus unemployed, she requires to start a business in
Jorethang to generate income and to take care of her parents for
which Trade Licence for readymade garments has already been
obtained by her.
In the circumstances, the premises in
occupation of the Defendant being bona fide required, a request
was made to him to vacate and hand over possession of the suit
property.
On his refusal, the suit was filed, inter alia, with the
prayers that the Defendant be evicted from the suit premises on
the ground of bona fide requirement of the Plaintiff, for the use of
his daughter and a direction to the Defendant to make good the
arrears of rent, with interest till the premises are vacated.
4.
The Defendant, in his Written Statement repudiated
the grounds put forth by the Plaintiff and contended that, the suit
was filed merely to harass him on his refusal to enhance the rent,
which the Plaintiff habitually increases. As the Plaintiff refused to
accept the monthly rent, he had no option but to forward it
through Money Orders which were declined by the Plaintiff.
He
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
denies having defaulted in payment of rent and asserts that the
suit premises is being utilised as a godown by him, being
unsuitable for running a shop.
That, there is no bona fide
requirement and the Trade Licence had been obtained illegally, as
the younger daughter of the Plaintiff, was working as a Under
Secretary in the UD&HD, Government of Sikkim, hence the suit be
dismissed.
5.
The Learned Trial Court after perusing the pleadings
and hearing the Learned Counsel for the parties, framed the
following issues;
6.
(i)
Whether the suit is maintainable?
(ii)
Whether the suit properties/demised properties
are required by the Plaintiff and/or his family
members for their bona fide requirement?
(iii)
Whether the Defendant has defaulted in payment
of the concerned rent for the suit premises w.e.f.
May, 2011?
(iv)
Whether the suit has been filed only to evict the
Defendant without any basis?
(v)
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the reliefs
prayed for by him?
The Plaintiff and Defendant examined themselves and
three other witnesses each.
7.
The Learned Trial Court while deciding Issue no.2,
first, was of the view that the suit premises was required bona
fide by the Plaintiff/his daughter. Issue no.3 was decided against
the Plaintiff as the Court found no default in payment of rent by
the Defendant. Issues no. 1, 4 and 5 were taken up together and
decided in favour of the Plaintiff, and the suit decreed accordingly.
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Durga Prasad Mukhia
Durga Prasad Mukhia
Pradeep Golyan
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
8.
Before this Court, the arguments raised by Learned
and
vs.
Counsel for the Appellant-Defendant are that, the bona fide
requirement of the Plaintiff-Respondent has not been proved as
no grounds have been indicated to show that the requirement is
genuine. That, a distinction has to be made between ‘desire’ and
‘requirement’ and in the instant case, there being no proof of
bona fide requirement, it is merely the desire of the Plaintiff. The
Defendant had been asked to vacate only because he had not
agreed to enhancement of rent, which was abruptly foisted on
him with difficult terms and conditions. Had he consented, then
the question of eviction would not have arisen. That, it is indeed
surprising that the Plaintiff’s elder daughter had given up her job
in 2013 when the father allegedly became visually impaired in
2003 itself and in such a situation the parents ought to have
moved to her place of work. That, the other tenant Anil Kumar
Gupta has not been evicted as he was agreeable to the enhanced
rent.
9.
Learned Senior Counsel for the Defendant while
referring to the rent control enactments in this State submitted
that, the Gangtok Rent Control and Eviction Act I of 1956 (in short
“Notification of 1956”), prescribes that eviction may be effected
when the tenanted premises are required for the “landlord or his
dependents”,
whereas the Government of Sikkim, Health and
Works Department, Notification No.6326—600-H&W—B, dated
14-04-1949, (in short “Notification of 1949”), which is applicable
in the instant case, only speaks of the “personal occupation” of the
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
landlord.
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
That, as the premises admittedly are required for the
Plaintiff’s daughter, hence the question of personal occupation of
the
landlord
does
not
arise
and
consequently,
requirement of the Plaintiff is not established.
bona
fide
To fortify his
submissions, reliance was placed on Rahabhar Productions Pvt. Ltd.
vs. Rajendra K. Tandon1, Gangtok Auto Works Pvt. Ltd. and Others vs.
Tobgyal Wangchuk Tenzing Namgyal and Others2, Pratap Rai Tanwani
and Another vs. Uttam Chand and Another3 and Ram Dass vs. Ishwar
Chander and Others4.
10.
The Plaintiff-Respondent filed a Cross Objection to the
Appeal raising the claim that although the Learned Trial Court had
found no default in payment of rent, however, if one were to
consider the evidence on record, it is explicit that the Defendant
was paying a monthly rent of Rs.1,800/- (Rupees one thousand
and eight hundred) only, which the Plaintiff had sought to
increase and the Defendant was not agreeable to. The Defendant
unilaterally started sending a sum of Rs.2,500/- (Rupees two
thousand and five hundred) only, by Post which was not accepted
by the Plaintiff, being devoid of agreement, therefore, rent has
not been received by the Plaintiff from the month of May, 2011,
resulting in arrears, but the finding of the Learned Trial Court is to
the contrary. Learned Senior Counsel Shri A. Moulik for the
Defendant countered that although the rent was sent by Post it
was forwarded to the correct address of the Defendant and it was
by choice that the Defendant did not accept the rent. Relying on
1.
2.
3.
4.
(1998) 4 SCC 49
AIR 1985 Sikkim 23
(2004) 8 SCC 490
(1998) 3 SCC 131
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
Har Charan Singh vs. Shiv Rani and Others5 it was contended that
Section 27 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, deals with the topic
“Meaning of service by post” and where a document is sent by
post in the correct address, it is assumed that the service has
been effected meaning thereby that the rents sent by post were in
the knowledge of the Defendant.
Reliance was also placed on
State of M.P. vs. Hiralal and Others6 wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court
while deliberating on the Supreme Court Rules, 1966, Pt.II,
Or.XV, R.11 held that where the addressee Respondents manage
to send the notices returned with postal remarks “not available in
the house”, “house locked” and “shop closed”, the notices were
deemed to have been served.
11.
During the course of the submissions, however,
Learned Senior Counsel Shri N. Rai for the Plaintiff conceded that
there was no default in payment of rent, but undoubtedly arrears
accrued on account of non-acceptance of rent by him forwarded
by Post. That, however, the Learned Trial Court in its impugned
Judgment had failed to direct payment of the amount due from
the Defendant.
12.
With regard to bona fide requirement of the Plaintiff, it
was contended by Learned Senior Counsel Shri N. Rai that the
daughter perforce had to resign due to the ill health of her
parents and had to obtain a Trade Licence for the purpose of
running the business of readymade garments, which would enable
her to earn an
5. AIR 1981 SC 1284
6. (1996) 7 SCC 523
income. The
documentary
evidence
clearly
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
establishes that the Plaintiff is 100% disabled visually, while the
Plaintiff’s wife also has leg ailments and had suffered a brain
stroke. There is no denying that she is seriously ill and unable to
care for the Plaintiff as she was incapacitated, thus, requiring the
intervention of their elder daughter who had to resign from her
private service.
That, the premises can be run as a shop and
merely because the Defendant was using it as a godown, it is
incorrect to say that its suitability is limited to the said purpose.
In fact, there are other shops being run in the same lane. That,
Anil Kumar Gupta has not been ousted as income is generated for
the family from his tenancy and the cross-examination of the
Appellant himself would indicate the requirement of the daughter
for starting a business. That, a second house of the Plaintiff has
already been sold to one Om Prakash Gupta, who for his part has
deposed as P.W.4 and stated that he has purchased the second
house.
To fortify his submissions, he has placed reliance on
Shamshad Ahmad and Others vs. Tilak Raj Bajaj (Deceased) through
Lrs. And Others7, Sait Nagjee Purushotham & Co. Ltd. vs. Vimalabai
Prabhulal and Others8.
That, the daughter had to take over as
admittedly the Plaintiff’s son died and in such circumstances, the
comparative hardship of the landlord and the tenant are to be
weighed. On this count, reliance was placed on Badrinarayan
Chunilal Bhutada vs. Govindram Ramgopal Mundada9.
It is further
submitted that the Appellant himself has a five storied house,
located near the Police Station in Jorethang and, therefore, the
7. (2008) 9 SCC 1
8. (2005) 8 SCC 252
9. (2003) 2 SCC 320
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
question of his lacking accommodation does not arise.
It was
also contended that the tenant cannot dictate terms to the
landlord, on which reliance has been placed on Dwarkaprasad vs.
Niranjan and Another10.
13.
I have heard the rival submissions of Learned Senior
Counsel at length and given my anxious consideration.
I have
also carefully perused the evidence and documents on record as
well as the impugned Judgment.
14.
As the Plaintiff has conceded that there was no default
in payment of rent, the only question that falls for consideration
of this Court is whether the Defendant ought to be evicted from
the suit premises
the
Plaintiff
or
on account of the bona fide requirement of
whether the suit has been filed without any
basis?
15.
So far as rent control and eviction is concerned,
Sikkim is governed by Notification of 1956 and Notification of
1949, in terms of the provision of Article 371F(k) of the
Constitution of India, which commences with a non obstante
clause and reads as follows;
of
“371F. Special provisions with respect to the State
Sikkim.—Notwithstanding
anything
in
this
Constitution,—
.......................................................
(k) all laws in force immediately before the
appointed day in the territories comprised
in the State of Sikkim or any part thereof
shall continue to be in force therein until
amended or repealed by a competent
Legislature or other competent authority;”
10. (2003) 4 SCC 549
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
That, having been said, the disputed premises fall outside
Gangtok and, therefore, Notification of 1956 is not relevant for
the present purposes. I will, therefore, confine my discussions to
the Notification of 1949, which is pertinent for the purposes of the
matter at hand. For convenience, the provisions thereof are being
reproduced hereinbelow;
”GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
Health and Works Department.
Notification No.6326—600-H&W—B.
Under powers conferred in para 2 of Notification
No.1366--G, dated the 28th July 1947, the following
Rules have been framed to regulate letting and subletting of premises controlling rents thereof and
unreasonable eviction of tenants as the scarcity of
housing accommodation still exists in Sikkim.
I
The landlords can charge rent for premises
either for residential or business purposes on the basis of
the rents prevailing in locality in the year 1939, plus an
increase upto 50 per cent so long as the scarcity of
housing accommodation lasts.
2. The landlords cannot eject the tenants so long
as the scarcity of housing accommodation lasts, but when
the whole or part of the premises are required for their
personal occupation or for thorough overhauling the
premises or on failure by the tenants to pay rent for four
months the landlords may be permitted to evict the
tenant on due application to the Chief Court.
3. Any tenant may apply to this Department for
fixing his rent.
On receipt of such application the
Department will enquire about the rent prevailing in the
locality in 1939 , and fix rent as per Rule (I) above.
4. Any person acting in contravention of this
Notification will be liable to prosecution under para 4 of
notification No.1366-066-G, dated the 28th July, 1947.
5. The tenant means those person in actual
occupation. Landlords means owners of the
premises.
These rules will come into force with immediate
effect.
By order of his Highness the Maharaja of Sikkim.
R.B. Singh,
Gangtok,
The I4th, April, 1949.
Secretary,
Health and Works Department,
Government of Sikkim.”
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
The object of the Act is to ensure that there is no
unreasonable eviction of tenants as scarcity of housing exists in
Sikkim. Thus, the grounds available to a landlord for evicting his
tenant are;
(i)
when the whole or part of the premises are required for
their personal occupation
(ii)
or for thorough overhauling of the premises
(iii)
or on failure by the tenants to pay rent for four months.
16.
In the instant matter, we are not concerned with
either the overhauling of the premises or the default in monthly
rent. It is confined to bona fide requirement of the landlord , the
concomitant question arising thereof is; whether the requirement
of the landlord brings within its ambit the requirement of his
immediate family, i.e., wife and children?
17.
In Dwarkaprasad10 (supra), the Hon’ble Apex Court
while dealing with the question as to whether the premises in suit
were reasonably and bona fide required by the landlord for
occupation by himself held that “Really the question would be to
interpret the word “himself”, that is, what meaning is to be given to the word
“himself”?
Is it to be confined to the plaintiff alone or can it include the
requirement of family members of the plaintiff, that is, his son, brothers and
sisters etc.?”
On this question, reliance was placed on Institute of
Radio Technology vs. Pandurang Baburao11 wherein it was held that
“the relevant words used in the Bombay Rent Restriction Act, 1939 were: “own
occupation”. It was argued on behalf of the tenant that this meant that the
premises must be required by the landlord for his occupation. Repelling the
11. AIR 1946 Bom 212
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
argument it was observed that the words “his own occupation” mean
occupation of himself and all persons who are dependent on him. The landlord
had appeared as a witness in this case and had stated that his family consisted
of his son, his widowed sister, her two daughters, two daughters of his
daughter and his cousin. The Court was satisfied that those persons were the
plaintiff's dependants and therefore, were entitled to live along with him.
……………. Therefore the word ‘himself’ occurring in the Act which is subjectmatter of the present case has to be read as himself and members of his
family.”
Reference was also made to the decision in Balabhadra
Beharilal vs. Premchand Lalchand12 wherein a Division Bench of the
High Court was considering the need of the widowed daughter
and her children as members of the family of the landlord. It was
observed that;
“3. The main point canvassed before us was that
the need of the widowed daughter and her children must
be deemed to be the need of the landlord. In our opinion,
the contention of the petitioner is correct and must be
upheld. No doubt, after marriage the daughter passes out
of the father’s family and goes into that of the husband.
But the fact of marriage does not sever the blood
relationship which exists between a father and his
daughter. The existence of this relationship does give rise
to certain moral obligations. Where, in pursuance of such
moral obligations, a father affords support to his daughter
and her children, their needs become his needs.”
It was, inter alia, concluded by the Hon’ble Apex Court that
bona fide requirement of the landlord is not confined to him alone
but includes the requirement of his family members.
18.
On the same lines, in Kailash Chand and Another vs.
Dharam Dass13 where Section 14(3) of the Himachal Pradesh Urban
Rent Control Act, 1987, was in question, it was held by the
Hon’ble Apex court that—
“24. The expression “his own occupation” as
occurring in sub-clause (i) of clause (a) of Section (3) is
not to be assigned a narrow meaning. It has to be read
12. AIR 1953 Nag 144
13. (2005) 5 SCC 375
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
liberally and given a practical meaning. “His own
occupation” does not mean occupation by the landlord
alone and as an individual. The expressions “for his own
use” and “for occupation by himself” as occurring in two
other Rent Control Acts, have come up for the
consideration of this Court in Joginder Pal v. Naval Kishore
Behal [(2002) 5 SCC 397] and Dwarkaprasad v. Nirnajan
[(2003) 4 SCC 549]. It was held that the requirement of
members of family of the landlord or of the one who is
dependent on the landlord, is the landlord’s own
requirement. Regard will be had to the social or socioreligious milieu and practices prevalent in a particular
section of society or a particular region to which the
landlord belongs, while interpreting such expressions. The
requirement of the family members for residence is
certainly the requirement by the landlord for “his own
occupation”.”
19.
Thus, the above Judgments clearly postulate what
that the words “personal occupation” or “his own occupation” or
“landlord’s
occupation”
mean.
On
the
touchstone
of
the
ratiocination supra the object and spirit of the Notification of 1949
cannot be said to be any different from that of the above
decisions. Thus, it is clear that the term “personal occupation” in
the Notification of 1949, extends to occupation and requirement
of not only the landlord, but brings without its ambit the
immediate and extended joint family of the landlord or where the
existence of a relationship gives rise to certain moral obligations,
such as, extending shelter to a married daughter.
20.
Now, coming to bona fide requirement by the Plaintiff.
The evidence on record indicates firstly that both the Plaintiff and
his wife are suffering from physical ailments as substantiated by
medical reports.
Their only son has evidently passed away and
the younger daughter is married.
It is only the elder daughter
who was employed in a Hotel in Gangtok from the year 2000, who
is left to tend to her parents. Although it was argued by Learned
Senior Counsel for the Defendant that the parents ought to have
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
moved to her place of work, on this aspect, it may be stated that
apart from there being no such legal compulsion, the physical and
medical
condition
of
the
parents
have
to
be
taken
into
consideration. Exhibit 1A, which is a Certificate for Persons with
Disabilities, issued by the Senior Consultant (Ophthalmology),
STNM Hospital, Government of Sikkim, Gangtok, dated 12-042012, certifies that the visual disability of the Plaintiff is 100%.
The argument that the daughter had resigned from work only in
2013 whereas the visual disability of the Plaintiff had commenced
from 2003 itself, is answered by this document, inasmuch as the
daughter was left with no option but to come and take care of her
parents after her father was 100% visually impaired. At the same
time, Exhibit 2, a Medical Report pertaining to the Plaintiff’s wife
dated 13-12-2012, indicates that she is suffering from early
degenerative changes in her knee joint, apparently till her own
disability she was taking care of the Plaintiff and hence the
belatedly resignation of their daughter from her job.
Exhibit 3,
which is of February, 2014, further indicates that the Plaintiff’s
wife
was
also
hospitalised
for
hypertension
and
acute
haemorrhage in a portion of the brain. The only source of income
is from the tenanted premises in dispute and that of Anil Kumar
Gupta, but the daughter seeks to establish a business in the
premises occupied by the Defendant by running a business in
readymade garments, for which she has obtained a Trade Licence
as well. As the younger daughter is married, there is no question
of relying on her income, therefore, there is no question of mere
‘desire’ but is clearly a genuine ‘requirement’ of the Plaintiff.
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Durga Prasad Mukhia
Durga Prasad Mukhia
Pradeep Golyan
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
21.
In Sait Nagjee Purushotham8 (supra) the Hon’ble Apex
and
vs.
Court has held that, it is always the prerogative of the landlord
that if he requires the premises in question for his bona fide use,
for expansion of business, the tenants cannot be heard to say that
the landlords are already have their business at other places. The
tenant cannot dictate terms to the landlord and advise him as to
what he should or should not do. It is always the privilege of the
landlord to choose the nature and place of business.
22.
We may also usefully refer to Bega Begum vs. Abdul
Ahad Khan14 which is pari materia to the fact in controversy.
The
Court was dealing with the Jammu and Kashmir Rent Act and,
inter alia, held that; “The owner of the property cannot be denied eviction
and compelled to live poorly merely to enable the tenants to carry on their
flourishing business activity at the cost of the landlord. The fact that there is no
other means for the landlord to augment his income except by getting the
tenancy premises vacated compared against the conduct of the tenant who
having obtained the premises for a fixed number of years has overstayed and
enjoyed the premises for a long period of time are relevant factors not to
deprive the landlord from the possession over the tenancy premises and
recording a finding of no equity in favour of the tenants continuing in
possession any further.”
The relevant factors, of course, which need
to be considered, are the comparative inconvenience, loss, trouble
and prejudice.
23.
While discussing scarcity of accommodation, it would
be apposite to state that the Defendant admittedly owns a five
storied building in Jorethang itself. Therefore, the question of him
14. (1979) 1 SCC 273
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
Durga Prasad Mukhia
and
Durga Prasad Mukhia
vs.
Pradeep Golyan
being reduced to vagrancy on account of lack of accommodation
has to be answered in the negative.
Obviously the comparative
hardship is tilted in favour of
landlord.
the
In this context,
support may be drawn from the decision in Sidhharth Viyas and
Another
vs. Ravi Nath Misra and Others15 wherein it was held as
follows;
“10. The object of rent law is to balance the
competing claims of the landlord on the one hand to
recover possession of building let out to the tenant and of
the tenant to be protected against arbitrary increase of
rent or arbitrary eviction, when there is acute shortage of
accommodation. Though, it is for the legislature to resolve
such competing claims in terms of statutory provisions,
while interpreting the provisions the object of the Act has
to be kept in view by the Court. Unless otherwise
provided, a tenant who has already acquired alternative
accommodation is not intended to be protected by the
Rent Act.”
24.
From
the
observations
hereinabove
and
the
discussions, I find no reason to interfere with the decision of the
Learned Trial Court save to the effect that the arrears of rent from
May, 2011, to be calculated till the Defendant vacates the suit
property, shall be made over to the Plaintiff. Interest on the
arrears prayed for, however, is not granted in view of the facts
and circumstances of the case as discussed herein above.
The
impugned Judgment of the Learned Trial Court stands modified
accordingly.
25.
In the result, the Appeal is dismissed.
The Cross
Objection is allowed in part.
26.
The Defendant shall vacate the suit premises on or
before 31-12-2016 and hand over vacant possession to the
Plaintiff.
15. (2015) 2 SCC 701
RFA No.03 of 2015 and C.O. No.05 of 2015
Durga Prasad Mukhia
Durga Prasad Mukhia
Pradeep Golyan
Pradeep Golyan
vs.
27.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Trial
and
vs.
Court for information.
28.
In the circumstances, no order as to costs.
29.
Records of the Learned Trial Court be remitted
forthwith.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
18-11-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review