Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
TUESDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 29TH MAGHA, 1946
CRP NO. 580 OF 2018
AGAINST THE COMMON ORDER DATED 16.12.2017 IN OP(ELE)
NO.11 OF 2012 AND OTHER CASES OF THE ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
COURT, NORTH PARAVUR
REVISION PETITIONER/PETITIONER:
VARGHESE,
AGED 63 YEARS,
S/O.ULHANNAN, KIZHKKUMPARAMBIL HOUSE,
PULLUVAZHI KARA,RAYAMANGALAM VILLAGE.
BY ADV.
SRI.P.C.HARIDAS
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
POWER GRID CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.,
CONSTRUCTION AREA OFFICE,MAVELIPURAM
COLONY,KAKKANAD, COCHIN - 682 030.
SPECIAL TAHSILDAR (LA),
POWER GRID CORPORATION INDIA LTD.,
CHEVARAMBALAM, KOZHIKODE - 17.
BY ADV.
SRI.MILLU DANDA PANI SC,
SMT.G SHEEBA GP
THIS CIVIL REVISION PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 18.02.2025, ALONG WITH CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE
SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
TUESDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 29TH MAGHA, 1946
CRP NO. 137 OF 2020
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 05.03.2019 IN OP(ELE) NO.126
OF 2015 OF THE ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT, NORTH PARAVUR
REVISION PETITIONER/1ST RESPONDENT IN OP(ELE) 126/2015:
POWER GRID CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.,
400 KV SUB STATION, PALLIKKARA,
KIZHAKKAMBALAM VILLAGE, KUMARAPURAM P.O.,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK-683 565,
REPRESENTED BY GENERAL MANAGER.
BY ADV
SRI.PRAVEEN K. JOY
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS 1 TO 6 & 2ND RESPONDENT IN OP(ELE)
126/2015:
HAWAMMA,AGED 67 YEARS,
W/O.KOCHUMUHAMMAD, PIRAMBILLYKUDY,
VENGOLA KARA, ARAKKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK-683 554.
SUDHEER,AGED 50 YEARS,
S/O.KOCHUMUHAMMAD, PIRAMBILLYKUDY,
VENGOLA KARA, ARAKKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK-683 554.
JASMI,AGED 44 YEARS,
D/O.KOCHUMUHAMMAD, PIRAMBILLYKUDY,
VENGOLA KARA, ARAKKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK-683 554.
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
SHUKOOR,AGED 43 YEARS,
S/O.KOCHUMUHAMMAD, PIRAMBILLYKUDY,
VENGOLA KARA, ARAKKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK-683 554.
FATHIMA, AGED 42 YEARS,
D/O.KOCHUMUHAMMAD, PIRAMBILLYKUDY,
VENGOLA KARA, ARAKKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK-683 554.
KADHEEJA,AGED 39 YEARS,
D/O.KOCHUMUHAMMAD, PIRAMBILLYKUDY,
VENGOLA KARA, ARAKKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK-683 554.
SPECIAL TAHSILDAR(LA),
POWER GRID CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.,
CHEVARAMBALAM, KOZHIKODE-673 017.
BY ADVS.
SRI.P.C. HARIDAS PULICKAL CHANDRASEKHARA PILLAI
SRI.SURESH V.S.(K/000350/1992)
SMT.G.SHEEBA, GP
THIS
CIVIL
REVISION
PETITION
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
ADMISSION ON 18.02.2025, ALONG WITH CONNECTED CASES, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
TUESDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 29TH MAGHA, 1946
CRP NO. 533 OF 2018
AGAINST THE COMMON ORDER DATED 16.12.2017 IN OP(ELE)
NO.12 OF 2012 AND OTHER CASES OF THE ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
COURT, NORTH PARAVUR
REVISION PETITIONER/PETITIONER:
RAJALAKSHMI, AGED 54 YEARS,
W/O. ASHOKAN, KAPPILLIL HOUSE,
PULLUVAZHI KARA, RAYAMANGALAM VILLAGE.
BY ADV
SRI.P.C.HARIDAS
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
POWER GRID CORPORATION INDIA LTD.,
CONSTRUCTION AREA OFFICE,
MAVELIPURAM COLONY, KAKKANAD,
COCHIN - 682 030.
SPECIAL TAHSILDAR (LA)
POWER GRID CORPORATION INDIA LTD.,
CHEVARAMBALAM, KOZHIKKODE – 17.
BY ADVS.
SMT.G SHEEBA,GP
SRI.MILLU DANDAPANI,SC
THIS CIVIL REVISION PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 18.02.2025, ALONG CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE SAME
DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
TUESDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 29TH MAGHA, 1946
CRP NO. 139 OF 2020
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 11.03.2019 IN OP(ELE) NO.70
OF 2014 OF THE ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT, NORTH PARAVUR
REVISION PETITIONER/1ST RESPONDENT IN OP(ELECTRICTY)
70/2014:
POWER GRID CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.,
CONSTRUCTION AREA OFFICE,
MAVELIPURAM COLONY,
KAKKANAD, KOCHI-682030,
REPRESENTED BY GEENRAL MANAGER
BY ADV
SRI.PRAVEEN K. JOY
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS/2ND RESPONDENT IN OP(ELECTRICITY)
70/2014:
AISHA UMMA,AGED 76 YEARS,
W/O.MAITHEEN, PIRAMBILLYKUDY HOUSE,
VENGOLA KARA, ARACKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK-683554
SPECIAL TAHSILDAR(LA),
POWER GRID CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.,
CHEVARAMBALAM, KOZHIKODE-673017
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
BY ADVS.
SRI.P.C.HARIDAS PULICKAL CHANDRASEKHARA PILLAI
SRI.SURESH V.S.(K/000350/1992)
SMT.G.SHEEBA, GP
THIS CIVIL REVISION PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 18.02.2025, ALONG WITH CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE
SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
TUESDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 29TH MAGHA, 1946
CRP NO. 426 OF 2019
AGAINST THE COMMON ORDER DATED 11.03.2019 IN OP(ELE)
NO.70 OF 2014 AND OTHER CASES OF THE ADDITIONAL DISTRICT II, NORTH PARAVUR
REVISION PETITIONER/PETITIONER:
AISHA UMMA,
AGED 70 YEARS,
W/O. MAITHEEN,
PIRAMBILLYKUDY HOUSE,
VENGOLA KARA, ARACKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK.
BY ADV
SRI.P.C.HARIDAS
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
POWER GRID CORPORATION INDIA LTD.,
CONSTRUCTION AREA OFFICE,
MAVELIPURAM COLONY, KAKKANAD,
COCHIN-682 030.
SPECIAL TAHSILDAR (LA),
POWER GRID CORPORATION INDIA LTD.,
CHEVARAMBALAM, KOZHIKKODE-17.
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
BY ADVS.
SRI.MILLU DANDAPANI
SMT.G.SHEEBA, GP
THIS CIVIL REVISION PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 18.02.2025, ALONG WITH CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE
SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
TUESDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 29TH MAGHA, 1946
CRP NO. 474 OF 2019
AGAINST THE COMMON ORDER DATED 05.03.2019 IN OP(ELE)
NO.126 OF 2015 OF THE ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT, NORTH
PARAVUR
REVISION PETITIONERS/PETITIONERS:
HAWAMMA,
AGED 66 YEARS,
W/O. KOCHUMUHAMMED, PIRAMBILLYKUDY,
VENGOLA KARA, ARACKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK.
SUDHEER,
AGED 48 YEARS,
S/O. KOCHUMUHAMMED, PIRAMBILLYKUDY,
VENGOLA KARA, ARACKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK.
JASMI,
AGED 42 YEARS,
D/O. KOCHUMUHAMMED, PIRAMBILLYKUDY,
VENGOLA KARA, ARACKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK.
SHUKOOR,
AGED 41 YEARS,
S/O. KOCHUMUHAMMED, PIRAMBILLYKUDY,
VENGOLA KARA, ARACKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK.
FATHIMA,
AGED 40 YEARS,
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
D/O. KOCHUMUHAMMED, PIRAMBILLYKUDY,
VENGOLA KARA, ARACKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK.
KADEEJA,
AGED 37 YEARS,
D/O. KOCHUMUHAMMED, PIRAMBILLYKUDY,
VENGOLA KARA, ARACKAPPADY VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK.
BY ADV
SRI.P.C.HARIDAS
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
POWER GRID CORPORATION INDIA LTD.,
NO.400 KV SUB STATION, PALLIKKARA,
KIZHAKKAMBALAM VILLAGE, KUMARAPURAM P.O.,
KUNNATHUNADU TALUK, PIN - 683 356.
SPECIAL TAHSILDAR (LA),
POWER GRID CORPORATION INDIA LTD.,
CHEVARAMBALAM, KOZHIKKODE - 673 017.
BY ADVS.
SRI.MILLU DANDA PANI,SC
SMT.G.SHEEBA, GP
THIS CIVIL REVISION PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 18.02.2025, ALONG WITH CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE
SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
TUESDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 29TH MAGHA, 1946
CRP NO. 664 OF 2019
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 16.12.2017 IN OP(ELE) NO.12
OF 2012 OF THE ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT, NORTH PARAVUR
PETITIONER/1ST RESPONDENT:
THE POWER GRID CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.,
CONSTRUCTION AREA OFFICE,
MAVELIPURAM COLONY,
KAKKANAD,
COCHIN - 682030.
BY ADV
SRI.ROJO J.THURUTHIPARA
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONER AND RESPONDENT - 2:
RAJALAKSHMI,
AGED 56 YEARS,
W/O. ASHOKAN, KAPPILLIL HOUSE,
PULLUVAZHI KARA,
RAYAMANGALAM VILLAGE,
KUNNATHUNAD TALUK,
PIN - 683545.
SPECIAL THASILDHAR (LA),
POWER GRID CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.,
CHEVARAMBALAM,
KOZHIKODE - 673017.
BY ADVS.
SRI.P.C.HARIDAS
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
SHRI.SURESH V.S.
SMT.G.SHEEBA, GP
THIS
CIVIL
REVISION
PETITION
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
ADMISSION ON 18.02.2025, ALONG WITH CONNECTED CASES, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
TUESDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 29TH MAGHA, 1946
CRP NO. 44 OF 2020
AGAINST THE COMMON ORDER DATED 16.12.2017 IN OP(ELE)
NO.11 OF 2012 OF THE ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT, NORTH
PARAVUR
PETITIONER/RESPONDENT:
M/S POWER GRID CORPORATION OF INDIA LIMITED,
CONSTRUCTION AREA OFFICE, KAKKANADU,
KOCHI-682030.
BY ADVS.
SMT.V.A.HARITHA
SRI.S.SREEKUMAR (SR.)(S-571)
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONER/2ND RESPONDENT:
V. VARGHESE,
S/O. ULAHANNAN, AGED 65,
KIZHAKKUMPARAMBIL HOUSE, PULLUVAZHI KARA,
RAYAMANGALAM VILLAGE,
REPRESENTED BY HIS POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER,
PAUL K. JOHN, AGED 53, S/O. ULAHANNAN,
KIZHAKKUMPARAMBIL HOUSE, PULLUVAZHI KARA,
RAYAMANGALAM VILLAGE, PIN-683541.
SPECIAL TAHSILDAR (L.A.),
POWER GRID CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.,
CHEVARAMBALAM, KOZHIKODE- 673017.
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
BY ADVS.
SRI.P.C.HARIDAS
SRI.SURESH V.S.
SMT.G.SHEEBA, GP
THIS CIVIL REVISION PETITION HAVING BEEN
FINALLY HEARD ON 18.02.2025, ALONG WITH CONNECTED
CASES, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
K.BABU, J.
-------------------------------------------
CRP Nos. 580, 533 of 2018,
426, 664, 474 of 2019
& 139, 44, 137 of 2020
--------------------------------------------Dated this the 18th day of Februrary, 2025
ORDER
Common questions arise for consideration in all these
Civil Revision Petitions. The Power Grid Corporation of India
Limited drew 400 KV double circuit lines through the
properties of the claimants. The respective claimants filed
petitions under Sections 10 and 16 of the Telegraph Act
read with Section 151 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and
Section 42 of the Electricity Supply Act, 1948 before the
Additional District Court, North Paravur, claiming enhanced
compensation under various heads. The Trial Court allowed
those applications. The claimants approached this Court
contending that the compensation awarded is meagre,
whereas the Power Grid Corporation challenged the awards
contending that the amount awarded is exorbitant.
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
CRP Nos. 426 of 2019 and 139 of 2020
2.
The Power Grid Corporation of India Limited had
drawn a 400 KV electric line through the property of the
claimant comprised in Sy.No.337/6 of Arackappady Village.
The property was a wet land, cultivated with various crops
including
plantains.
The
Corporation
quantified
the
compensation as Rs.25,263/-. The Trial Court granted a sum
of Rs.12,17,237/- as compensation with interest at the rate
of 6% from 04.07.2011 till the date of realisation.
CRP No.474 of 2019 and 137 of 2020
3.
The case of the claimants is that their property is
used for the purpose of drawing 400 KV Cochin-Trichur
electric line. The claimants received only an amount of
Rs.7,12,170/- towards compensation for various trees cut
and removed from their property. The Trial Court granted a
sum of Rs.86,15,600/- as compensation with interest at the
rate of 8% from the date of cutting of trees till the date of
realisation.
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
CRP No.580 of 2018 and 44 of 2020
4.
The case of the claimant is that he is the owner
in possession of 26.15 Ares of property comprised in
Re.Sy.Nos.203/2, 203/17, 203/4 of Rayamangalam Village.
The land is very fertile, cultivated with yielding and nonyielding trees. For the purpose of drawing 400 KV KochiTrichur electric line through his property, trees were cut and
removed by the Power Grid Corporation of India Limited. The
Trial
Court
granted
a
sum
of
Rs.85,13,500/-
as
compensation with interest at the rate of 8% from the date
of cutting of trees till the date of realisation.
CRP No.533 of 2018 and 664 of 2019
5.
The case of the claimant is that she is the owner
in possession of 34.8 Ares of property comprised in
Re.Sy.Nos. 205/2, 205/3 and 205/4 of Rayamangalam
Village. The land is very fertile, cultivated with yielding and
non-yielding trees. For the purpose of drawing 400 KV KochiTrichur electric line through her property, trees were cut
and removed by the Power Grid Corporation of India
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
Limited. The Trial Court granted a sum of Rs.11,59,100/- as
compensation with interest at the rate of 8% from the date
of cutting of trees till the date of realisation.
6.
I
have heard the learned counsel for
the
claimants, the learned Standing Counsel appearing for the
Power Grid Corporation of India Limited and the learned
Government Pleader appearing for the Special Tahasildar.
7.
The common grounds raised by the claimants are
the following:(a)The compensation for diminution in land value
granted is too low, in view of the fact that the
value of the entire properties is affected by way
of drawing the line.
(b)
The land value determined by the District
Court is too low.
(c)
The properties of the claimants are situated
in prominent places in the locality with road
access.
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
(d) The situs of the land was not considered while
awarding compensation.
8.
The Power Grid Corporation of India Limited
raised the following contentions:The land value fixed by the Trial Court for awarding
compensation towards diminution in the land value is much
higher than the fair value fixed by the Government. The
claimants did not place any credible materials to establish
the land value, and therefore, the Trial Court should have
relied on the fair value fixed by the Government. The report
of the Commissioner is not a valuable piece of evidence to
enter into a conclusion regarding the land value. The
Commissioner assessed the value of the properties long
time after the lines were drawn. The claimants were
sufficiently compensated even prior to the institution of the
claim petitions. For fixation of the compensation towards
cutting and removal of the trees, the Trial Court ignored the
detailed
valuation statement prepared by the Competent
Authority at the time of cutting, but relied on the
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
assessment made by the Commissioner which is not at all
relevant. The Corporation has not acquired the properties. It
has only drawn electric lines over the properties, by which
the value of the properties is not substantially diminished.
9.
In KSEB v. Livisha [(2007) 6 SCC 792], the
Supreme Court held that the proper multiplier to be used for
fixation of compensation on the value of trees is 8. While
dealing with the question of diminution in the land value in
KSEB v. Livisha, the Supreme Court held thus:“10. The situs of the land, the distance between the high
voltage electricity line laid thereover, the extent of the
line thereon as also the fact as to whether the high
voltage line passes over a small track of land or through
the middle of the land and other similar relevant factors
in our opinion would be determinative. The value of the
land would also be a relevant factor. The owner of the
land furthermore, in a given situation may lose his
substantive right to use the property for the purpose for
which the same was meant to be used.”
10.
Now, I shall consider the impugned awards on
the touchstone of the principles discussed above.
CRP Nos.426 of 2019 and 139 of 2020
11.
The affected area by way of drawing the line is
estimated as 10.9 Ares. The Commissioner appointed by the
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
Trial Court prepared Ext.C1 report which has become part of
evidence as per Order XXVI Rule 10 of the CPC. It has come
out in evidence that the property abuts a Panchayat road.
The claimant relied on Ext. A1 title deed dated 29.11.2007.
Relying on Ext.C1 report and Ext.A1 title deed, the Trial
Court fixed the market value as Rs.90,000/- per cent. When
converted into cents the affected area is admittedly 26.9
cents.
The
Trial
Court
assessed
the
value
towards
diminution in the land value as Rs.24,21,000/-. The Court
held that the claimant is entitled to half of the total value,
which comes to Rs.12,10,500/-. The compensation for 8
plantains cut and removed was fixed by applying the
following formula:
8 X 500 X 8 = 32,000/Therefore, the claimant was entitled to a total compensation
of
Rs.12,42,500/-.
The
Corporation
had
already
paid
Rs.25,263/- at the time of drawing the line. Therefore, the
Court fixed the compensation as Rs.12,17,237/- with 6%
interest from 04.07.2011
till the date of realisation.
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
Considering
the
assessment
of
compensation
on
the
touchstone of the principles discussed above, this Court is of
the view that the order impugned in CRP Nos.426/2019 and
139/2020 is liable to be confirmed. The Civil Revision
Petitions filed by the claimant and the Corporation lack
merits and stand dismissed. The order dated 11.03.2019 in
O.P.(Ele) No.70/2014 stands confirmed.
CRP No.474 of 2019 and 137 of 2020
12.
The Commissioner reported that 17 coconut
trees were cut and removed. The total coconuts obtained in
an year from 1 coconut tree was assessed as 197 (after
deducting droppings and expenditure). The market price of
one coconut, as published in the newspaper was, Rs.8.
Based on Livisha’s case, 8 is taken as the multiplier. The
Court applied the following formula to assess the value of
coconut trees:197 X 17 X 8 X Rs.8 = Rs.2,14,336/13.
The Commissioner reported that 100 rubber
trees were cut and removed. The quantity of latex collected
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
from a rubber tree was fixed at 13Kg per year. The price of
rubber at the relevant time was Rs.200/- per Kg. The Court
applied
the
following
formula
for
assessing
the
compensation towards cutting and removal of the rubber
trees:
100 X 13 Kg X Rs.200 X 8 = Rs.20,80,000/- [25% of the income deducted towards
expenditure and fixed the compensation at
Rs.15,60,000/-].
14.
100 nutmeg trees were also cut and removed
from the property. The Court fixed the total number of
nutmegs obtained in one year from a tree as 3,000. The
Court calculated the rate of premature fall at 25% and 25%
towards expenditure. Therefore, the number of nutmegs
was assessed as 1,688. The dried nutmegs obtained was
assessed as 12Kg. The Trial Court assessed that from 1
nutmeg 2 gms of Jathipathri is obtained. The Commissioner
reported that the price of Jathi was Rs.200/- and Jathipathri
was
Rs.800/-.
The
value
of
Jathi
was
assessed
at
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
Rs.19,20,000/- (100 X 12 X 200 X 8). The value of Jathipathri
was assessed at Rs.21,12,000/- (100 X 3.3 X 800 X 8).
Therefore, the total amount towards loss of nutmeg trees
was assessed at Rs.40,32,000/15.
The Commissioner reported that 18 arecanut
trees were cut and removed from the property. The price of
dried arecanut is Rs.110/-. Based on the assessment that
8 Kgs of arecanuts are obtained per year from 1 arecanut
tree, the value of arecanut was assessed at Rs.1,26,720/(110 X 18 X 8 X 8). The claimants were found to be entitled
to Rs.59,33,056/- as value of improvements. The affected
area of land due to the drawing of electric line was fixed as
26.30 Ares (64.99 cents). The land value was fixed at
Rs.1,00,000/- per cent. So the value of the land affected was
assessed at Rs.64,99,000/- (64.99 X 1,00,000/-). Out of this,
50% was deducted towards diminution of land value, and
hence, the value of land injuriously affected was assessed at
Rs.32,49,500/-. An extent of 1.47 Ares of land was used for
the erection of tower. The land value at the place where the
tower was erected was fixed at Rs.40,000/- per cent. So, the
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
value was fixed at Rs.1,45,200/- (3.63 cents X 40,000).
Therefore, the total compensation entitled to the claimants
was assessed in the following manner:Value of trees cut and removed =
Rs.59,33,056/-
Value of land
= Rs.33,94,700/-
Total
= Rs.93,27,756/-
16.
The Corporation had already paid Rs.7,12,170/-
towards compensation. The balance compensation to which
the claimants were entitled was assessed at Rs. 86,15,586/which is rounded to Rs.86,15,600/- with 8% interest from
the date of cutting of trees till the date of realisation. The
compensation fixed by the District Court is fair and
reasonable. The compensation is in tune with the guidelines
issued by the Supreme Court in
Livisha’s case. I find no
reason to interfere with the impugned order. Therefore, the
impugned order in CRP Nos.474/2019 and 137/2020 is liable
to be confirmed. Civil Revision Petitions filed by the claimant
and the Corporation lack merits and stand dismissed. The
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
order dated 05.03.2019 in O.P.(Ele) No.126/2015 stands
confirmed.
CRP No.580 of 2018 and 44 of 2020
17.
The Commissioner reported that 32 coconut
trees were cut and removed. The Trial Court followed the
assessment of value made in O.P.(C)No.10/2012 and the
value of the coconuts was fixed at Rs.4,03,456/- (197 X 32 X
8 X Rs.8). In Ext.C1 report, the Commissioner stated that 40
numbers of pepper plants were cut and removed. Yield of 1
pepper plant was fixed as 3 Kgs per year, out of which 25%
was deducted towards expenses. Net yield of 1 pepper plant
therefore, was fixed at 2.250 Kgs. The value of 1 Kg of
pepper was Rs.250/- at the relevant time. The Court fixed
the compensation as Rs.1,80,000/- (2.25 X Rs.250 X 8 X 40
Nos.).
18.
The Commissioner reported that 44 nutmeg
trees were cut and removed. The Trial Court followed the
assessment of value applied in
O.P.(C) No.10/2012
and
other cases. The Trial Court assessed the value of Jathi at
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
Rs.8,44,800/- (44 X 12 X 200 X 8) and the value of
Jathipathri at Rs.9,29,280/- (44 X 3.3 X 800 X 8). Thereby,
the total income obtained from the nutmeg trees is
assessed at Rs.17,74,080/-.
19.
40 arecanut trees were cut and removed. The
valuation arrived towards cutting and removal of 40
arecanut trees is as follows:110 X 8Kg X 8 X 40 = Rs.2,81,600/20.
3 jack fruit trees were also cut and removed. The
Trial Court fixed Rs.20,000/- for the various trees cut and
removed. For various other trees including 88 anjili trees, 4
mango trees, 88 timber trees, mahagony trees etc. the Trial
Court fixed a compensation of Rs.80,000/-. The claimant
was found to be entitled to a total compensation of
Rs.27,39,136/- towards the value of trees cut and removed.
21.
Relying on Ext.B4 fair value notification and
Ext.C1(a) report, wherein it is mentioned that the land has
road frontage on two sides, the Trial Court fixed the value of
land at Rs.2,00,000/- per cent. The Trial Court found that the
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
area of the land injuriously affected is 26.15 Ares (64.59
cents). The value of total affected area is fixed as 64.59 X
Rs.2,00,000/- which is equal to Rs.1,29,18,000/-. The District
Court assessed 50% as deduction towards diminution of
land value due to the drawing of electric line. Hence, the
value of the land injuriously affected was assessed at
Rs.64,59,000/-. The total compensation entitled to the
claimant was assessed as follows:Value of trees cut and removed = Rs.27,39,136/Value of land injuriously affected = Rs.64,59,000/-
Total compensation
22.
= Rs.91,98,136/-
The claimant had already received Rs.6,84,726/-
towards compensation. The balance compensation entitled
to the claimant is found to be Rs.85,13,410/- which is
rounded to Rs.85,13,500/- with 8% interest from the date of
cutting
of
trees
till
the
date
of
realisation.
The
compensation fixed by the District Court is fair and
reasonable. The compensation is in tune with the guidelines
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
issued by the Supreme Court in
Livisha’s case. I find no
reason to interfere with the impugned order.
CRP Nos.580 of 2018 and 44 of 2020 lack merits and
stand dismissed. The order dated 16.12.2017 in O.P.(Ele)
No.11/2012 stands confirmed.
CRP No.533 of 2018 and 664 of 2019
23.
6 coconut trees were cut and removed. The Trial
Court followed the method of calculation adopted in O.P.(C)
No.10 of 2012. So, the compensation towards cutting of
coconut trees was assessed at Rs.75,648/- (197 X 6 X 8 X
Rs. 8)
24.
Three Pepper plants were cut and removed. The
compensation was assessed at Rs.13,500/- (2.25 X 250 X 8
X 3 Nos). For various other trees, the Trial Court fixed the
compensation at Rs.20,000/-. So, the total compensation
entitled to the claimant towards cutting and removal of the
trees was assessed by the Court at Rs.1,09,148/-.
25.
The Court assessed the area injuriously affected
by way of drawing electric line as 29.90 Ares (73.85 cents).
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
Relying on Ext.B16 fair value notification and Ext.C1(e) plan,
the Court fixed the value of the property at the relevant
time at Rs.60,000/- per cent. The value of the land
injuriously affected was assessed at Rs.44,31,000/- (73.85 X
60,000) out of which 75% was deducted towards diminution
of land value, and hence, the value of the land injuriously
affected was assessed at Rs.11,07,750/-. The claimant was
awarded a sum of Rs.1,09,148/- towards the value of trees
cut and removed. The total compensation entitled to the
claimant was assessed as follows:Value of trees cut and removed = Rs. 1,09,148/Value of land injuriously affected = Rs.11,07,750/_________________
Total compensation
26.
= Rs.12,16,898/-
The claimant had already received Rs.57,801/-
towards compensation. The balance compensation entitled
to the claimant is found to be Rs.11,59,100/- with 8%
interest from the date of cutting of trees till the date of
realisation. The compensation fixed by the District Court is
fair and reasonable. The compensation is in tune with the
2025:KER:28971
CRP NO.580 OF 2018 & CONN. CASES
guidelines issued by the Supreme Court in Livisha’s case. I
find no reason to interfere with the impugned order.
CRP Nos.533 of 2018 and 664 of 2019
filed by the
claimant and the Corporation lack merits and stand
dismissed.
The
order
dated
16.12.2017
in
O.P.(Ele)
No.12/2012 stands confirmed.
Sd/K.BABU
JUDGE
VPK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review