Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:54140
CH-WP-12606-2026.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 12606 OF 2026
Popatrao Baburao Jadhav
Age : 64 yars, Occu : Agriculture,
R/o: Khokar, Taluka Shrirampur,
District, Ahilyanagar
….Petitioner
VERSUS
1.
The Secretary,
Maharashtra State Cooperative Election
Authority, Pune, Maharashtra State.
2.
The Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative
Societies, Nashik Region, Nashik.
3.
The District Co-operative Election Officer
District Deputy Registrar, Co-operative
Societies, Ahilyanagar.
4.
The Assistant Registrar, Co-operative Societies,
Shrirampur, Tq: Shrirampur,
District: Ahilyanagar.
5.
Khokar Vividh Karyakari Seva Sahakari Society
Limited, Khokar, Taluka: Shrirampur,
District: Ahilyanagar. Through its Secretary.
6.
Sonali Gyaneshwar Kale,
Age ___years, Occu:
R/o: Khokar, Taluka: Shrirampur,
District: Ahilyanagar.
7.
The Ahmednagar District Central Co-operative
Bank Limited, Ahilyanagar, Through its
Managing Director/Chief Executive Officer
….Respondents
...
Adv.A.B. Kale for the Petitioner.
Adv.V.H. Dighe for Respondent Nos.1 and 3.
Adv.V.B. Jagtap for Respondent No.5.
Adv.S.S. Gangakhedkar for Respondent No.6
Ms.Vaishali Chaudhari, AGO for Respondent Nos.2 and 4.
...
CORAM
: MANJUSHA DESHPANDE, J.
RESERVED ON
: 30.10.2026
PRONOUNCED ON : 03.11.2026
Sunny Thote
CH-WP-12606-2026.odt
JUDGMENT :
1.
The Petitioner in this Writ Petition raises challenge to the
order dated 10.09.2026 passed by the District Co-operative Election
Officer and Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Nashik in
exercise of its powers under Rule 11 of the Maharashtra Co-operative
Societies (Election to Committee) Rules, 2014 (hereinafter referred as
‘Election Rules, 2014’).
2.
The learned Advocate, Mr.Kale, appearing for the Petitioner
submitted that the Petitioner, who is an agriculturist by profession and
member of Respondent No.5/Society, is also a Director of the said society.
He submits that the State Co-operative Election Authority published the
election programme for the election of Board of Directors of Respondent
No.7/Ahmednagar District Central Co-operative Bank Limited for the
period 2026-2031. A programme for finalisation of voters’ list was issued
by Respondent No.2 on 15.06.2026. Respondent No.5/Society convened
a meeting on 09.07.2026 without giving any intimation to the Petitioner,
who is one of the Directors, and passed a resolution nominating
Respondent No.6, one ‘Sonali Gyaneshwar Kale’, as its representative to
the election of Respondent No.7/Bank. The resolution passed in the said
meeting is illegal, arbitrary and void ab initio. He submitted that since
the Petitioner was in dispute with the society, he had no access to the
day-to-day functioning of Respondent No.5/Society. He filed a complaint
Sunny Thote
to
Respondent
No.4/Assistant
CH-WP-12606-2026.odt
Registrar
Co-operative
Societies,
Shrirampur, complaining that he was not being served with notices of the
society’s monthly meetings and was not apprised of the agenda of such
meetings. On 27.04.2026, the Assistant Registrar directed Respondent
No.5/Society to take appropriate action in the matter and submit a
report. In spite of the directions, Respondent No.5 continued to exclude
the Petitioner from the society’s affairs. He submits that Respondent
No.7/Bank published a provisional voters’ list for the election of its Board
of Directors. In the said list, the name of Respondent No.6/Sonali
Gyaneshwar Kale was included as the representative of Respondent
No.5/Society, which, according to the Petitioner, is illegal and arbitrary,
and also contrary to circular dated 16.06.2026 and provisions of the
Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960. The Petitioner, therefore,
being aggrieved by the inclusion of name of Respondent No.6, has filed
objection application under Rule 11 of the Maharashtra Co-operative
Societies (Election to Committee) Rules, 2014. He submits that specific
grounds have been made out by him in his objection. He has raised
objection on the ground that the meeting dated 09.07.2026 and the
resolution nominating Respondent No.6 are illegal, and since without
giving notice to the Petitioner, the resolution was passed. The objection to
the nomination of Respondent No.6 was also raised on the ground that
she is not a validly nominated representative and her name is liable to be
excluded from the voters’ list.
Sunny Thote
3.
CH-WP-12606-2026.odt
Mr.Kale further submits that the nomination of Respondent
No.6 as representative of Respondent No.5 suffers from disqualification
on the ground that she is a ‘defaulter’ of Respondent No.5/Society. He
submits that on 10.07.2026, a list of beneficiaries under the loan waiver
scheme was published. In the said list, name of Respondent No.6 appears
at Serial No.101466121680, showing her to be a defaulter of Respondent
No.5/Society with an outstanding loan amount of Rs.1,80,302/- as on
31.03.2026 in Loan Account No.001110309002773. Thus, in view of the
fact that Respondent No.6 is a ‘defaulter’ of Respondent No.5/Society, she
is not eligible to be nominated as representative of the society. He further
submits that this information was not available to him, therefore, he
could not raise specific challenge on this ground before Respondent No.2
prior to passing of the impugned order. The aforementioned information
about the default incurred by Respondent No.5 came to his knowledge
only when the name of Respondent No.6 appeared in the list of persons
whose loan has been waived by the Government. He would submit that
Respondent No.5/Society itself is a ‘defaulter’ of Respondent No.7/Bank.
On that count also, Respondent No.5/Society cannot vote in the elections
of Respondent No.7/Bank. He, therefore, submitted that the order passed
by Respondent No.2/District Co-operative Election Officer, which does
not take into consideration the objection raised by the Petitioner which
are supported by the documents placed on record, is an arbitrary order
Sunny Thote
CH-WP-12606-2026.odt
which does not record any reasons, as such deserves to be quashed and
set aside.
4.
Per
contra,
the
learned
Advocate,
Mr.Gangakhedkar
appearing for the contesting Respondent No.6 submitted that the
submissions of the Petitioner are under misconception of fact as well as
under the law. He submitted that the act of declaring a voter as a
‘defaulter’ requires detailed adjudication on account of eligibility of the
voter to act as a voter in the representative capacity. This aspect about
determination of eligibility to act as a voter cannot be gone into in
absence of appropriate evidence and without giving an adequate
opportunity of being heard to both the sides. This view has been recently
taken by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in its order dated 16.10.2026. Thus,
whether or not Respondent No.6 can be branded as a ‘defaulter’ which
disentitles her to cast vote in the election of Federal Society would
require to be proved by leading evidence. He further submits that before
Respondent No.3, in the objection raised by the Petitioner, no evidence
was produced in support of the claim that Respondent No.6 is a
‘defaulter’. Therefore, in absence of any specific and direct material to
that effect, merely on the basis of allegations against the Petitioner,
Respondent No.3 cannot pass any order on the issue of disqualification.
He further submitted that the resolution and proposal based upon the
resolution cannot be questioned by way of an objection, as is done by the
Sunny Thote
CH-WP-12606-2026.odt
Petitioner. The only remedy available against such resolution lies
elsewhere and not in the form of the action adopted by the Petitioner. He
submits that the name of Respondent No.6 is approved by the majority of
the Managing Committee members. Thus, the objection raised by the
Petitioner for the first time in the present Writ Petition while raising
challenge to the order passed by Respondent No.3 cannot be entertained.
5.
The learned Advocate, Mr.Dighe for Respondent Nos.1 to 3
submitted that, the Petitioner has raised several disputed questions of
facts, which cannot be gone into by Respondent No.3 as well as by this
Court. The Petitioner is having alternate statutory remedy as provided
under Section 91 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960
read with the provisions of Rule 78 of the Maharashtra Co-operative
Societies (Election to Committee) Rules, 2014 by filing dispute after the
election is over. He further submitted that the election programme of
Respondent No.7 is already declared and as per the said programme, the
polling is about to take place on 02.11.2026. He further submitted that as
per the resolution passed by Respondent No.5/Society, the name of
Respondent No.6 is included in the voters’ list, which is already finalised
on 15.09.2026. He further submitted that in view of Section 73 C A(1)(f)
(ii) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, Respondent
No.6 is not a defaulter of Respondent No.5/Society, therefore, her
delegation by Respondent No.5 is legal and proper. Accordingly, the
Sunny Thote
CH-WP-12606-2026.odt
objection of the Petitioner has been decided by a reasoned order on
10.09.2026, which does not deserve any interference.
6.
After hearing the respective Advocates and going through the
documents placed on record, the Petitioner appears to have a twofold
grievance. One is regarding his personal capacity, where he has suffered a
disqualification from the post of Director of Respondent No.5/Society
under Section 73-A of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, and
the other is against the nomination of Respondent No.6 to be a
representative of Respondent No.5/Society.
7.
On perusal of the objection filed by the Petitioner before
Respondent No.3, it appears that there is no date mentioned on the
objection Application No.18 of 2026 annexed to the Writ Petition. The
Applicant has raised objection on the ground that Respondent No.6 has
availed loan of an amount of Rs.1,80,302/-, which has not been repaid,
thus she is a defaulter as she had not cleared the dues. He has alleged
that the aforementioned information has been suppressed by the society
as well as the Secretary of the society. Since the resolution is passed by
the society and name of Respondent No.6 is forwarded by suppressing the
fact of her default in repayment of loan, the name of Respondent No.6 is
required to be deleted from the voters’ list. Even though he has filed the
objection, he has not supported the objection by any documents.
Sunny Thote
CH-WP-12606-2026.odt
Respondent No.6 has filed her say to the objection raised by the
Petitioner. In her say, she has stated that Respondent No.5/Society is in
default in making repayment of the loan to Respondent No.7/Bank,
therefore, as per the provisions of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies
Act, it was necessary to send a name of a member who is not a defaulter,
hence her name has been forwarded to be included in the voters’ list.
8.
Upon going through the impugned order, after recording the
submissions of the respective parties, Respondent No.3 has taken into
consideration the report of the Assistant Registrar, Co-operative Societies,
Shrirampur. In the said report, it is stated by the Assistant Registrar,
Shrirampur that Respondent No.5/Society is defaulter of Respondent
No.7/Bank. In the Managing Committee of Respondent No.5/Society, in
the meeting held on 09.07.2026, by way of Resolution No.2, the name of
Respondent No.6, who is member of the society, has been proposed.
Respondent No.6 is not a Director or member of the Managing
Committee and there is no document provided by the Petitioner in
support of his contention that Respondent No.6 is a ‘defaulter’. Therefore,
Respondent No.6 is qualified to be a valid voter on behalf of Respondent
No.5/Society, particularly in view of Section 73 CA(1)(f)(ii). Based on the
report of the Assistant Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Shrirampur, and
after considering the objection raised by the Petitioner, which was not
supported by any document to demonstrate that Respondent No.6 is a
Sunny Thote
CH-WP-12606-2026.odt
defaulter, Respondent No.3 has passed an order holding that the
nomination of Respondent No.6 is in accordance with Section 73 CA(1)
(f)(ii) and she does not incur any disqualification.
9.
The Petitioner himself has conceded to the position that the
objection has been filed, without any document showing that Respondent
No.6 is in default of Respondent No.5/Society. These documents have
been produced for the first time before this Court. Respondent No.3 did
not have an opportunity to appreciate the documents that have been
placed on record for the first time before this Court. The report of the
Assistant Registrar as well as the affidavit filed by Respondent No.3
support the case of Respondent No.6, stating that there is no proof for
declaring Respondent No.6 as a defaulter. The document that has been
produced for the first time before this Court has to be proved by leading
evidence, which cannot be done in the present proceedings. Even
otherwise, the date for polling in the elections of Respondent No.7/Bank
is scheduled on 02.11.2026. The voters’ list was already finalised on
15.09.2026. Thus, at this belated stage, it would not be appropriate to
interfere with the voters’ list, thereby depriving Respondent No.5/Society
of its right of casting vote in the election of Respondent No.7/Bank. Even
otherwise, the documents that have been placed on record raise disputed
questions of facts. Though the Petitioner on the basis of this document is
claiming that Respondent No.6 is a defaulter, the learned Advocate for
Sunny Thote
CH-WP-12606-2026.odt
Respondent No.7/Bank disputes the same and submits that Respondent
No.6 is not a defaulter at all.
10.
Since Respondent No. 6 is nominated to cast her vote in the
representative capacity, she would be governed by Section 73 CA(1)(f)(ii)
of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act. Only in two circumstances
as stated in sub-clause (ii), a person can incur a disqualification: first, if a
person is a defaulter of the society whom he represents, or is an officebearer of the defaulting society. In the present case, Respondent No.6 is
not an office-bearer of the society. Though it is claimed that she is a
defaulter of the Primary Agricultural Credit Cooperative Society, it has
not been proved by producing any evidence before Respondent No.3. It is
for the first time in the present Writ Petition a document is produced,
which is disputed by the Respondent.
11.
Thus, in this view of the matter, considering the disputed
question of facts raised by the Petitioner, the objection raised cannot be
taken into consideration and the order passed by Respondent No.3
cannot be interfered with. Thus, in view of the disputed questions of fact
raised in the present Writ Petition, the Writ Petition is not capable of
being entertained. Respondent No.3 has rightly passed an order based on
the documents and the report submitted by the Assistant Registrar,
Cooperative Societies, Shrirampur. In view of the same, no interference is
Sunny Thote
CH-WP-12606-2026.odt
called for and the Writ Petition is dismissed being devoid of merits.
However, it is made clear that if at all the Petitioner proposes to agitate
the issue of Respondent No.6 being a defaulter by raising a dispute, he is
at liberty to do so.
[ MANJUSHA DESHPANDE, J. ]
Sunny Thote
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review