Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R.S.A.NO.367 OF 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
MONDAY, THE 15TH DAY OF JULY 2024 / 24TH ASHADHA, 1946
RSA NO. 367 OF 2024
AGAINST
THE
JUDGMENT
DATED
03.02.2024
IN
AS
NO.66
OF
OF
PRINCIPAL SUB COURT, THALASSERY
JUDGMENT DATED 30.06.2014 IN OS NO.193 OF 2011 OF MUNSIFf COURT,
KUTHUPARAMBA
APPELLANTS/APPELLANTS/PLAINTIFFS:
PONTHEN LAKSHMI, AGED 92 YEARS
D/O. APPA, NO OCCUPATION, CHORANTAVIDA, PINARAYI AMSOM
DESOM, P.O. PINARAYI, KANNUR DISTRICT., PIN - 670741
THIRUVANGADAN RAMACHANDRAN, AGED 61 YEARS
S/O. RAGHAVAN, SALESMAN, CHORANTAVIDA, PINARAYI AMSOM
DESOM, P.O. PINARAYI, KANNUR DISTRICT., PIN - 670741
THIRUVANGADAN ARUNA, AGED 55 YEARS
D/O. RAGHAVAN, NO OCCUPATION, ARCHANA, MANGATTIDOM AMSOM,
KIRACHI DESOM, P.O. VENGAD, KANNUR DISTRICT., PIN - 670612
BY ADV. SRI. R.SURENDRAN
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS:
PONTHEN RADHA,AGED 83 YEARS,
D/O. APPA, NO OCCUPATION, SREEVALSAM, MANGATTIDOM AMSOM,
KIRACHI DESOM, P.O. VENGAD, KANNUR DISTRICT., PIN - 670612
THIRUVANGADAN LEELA,AGED 62 YEARS,
D/O. RAGHAVAN, NO OCCUPATION, SREEVALSAM, MANGATTIDOM
AMSOM, KIRACHI DESOM, P.O. VENGAD, KANNUR DISTRICT.,
PIN - 670612
THIRUVANGADAN MOHANAN,AGED 56 YEARS
S/O. RAGHAVAN, AGED 56 YEARS, NO OCCUPATION, SREEVALSAM,
MANGATTIDOM AMSOM, KIRACHI DESOM, P.O. VENGAD, KANNUR
DISTRICT., PIN - 670612
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON 15.07.2024,
R.S.A.NO.367 OF 2024
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 15th day of July, 2024
1. The Plaintiffs in a suit for declaration, partition and
consequential injunction are the Appellants in this Regular
Second Appeal.
2. The parties are referred according to their status before the
trial court.
3. The 1st plaintiff is the elder sister of the 1 st defendant. The
2nd & 3rd plaintiffs and 2nd & 3rd defendants are the children
of the 1st defendant.
4. The suit was filed for declaring that the plaint schedule
property having an extent of 18 cents covered by Ext.A6
document is a co-ownership property belonging to the
plaintiffs and defendants and seeking partition of the same
by allotting 5/15 share to the plaintiff, 6/15 share to the 1 st
defendant and 1/15 share each to 2nd & 3rd plaintiffs and 2nd
& 3rd defendants.
R.S.A.NO.367 OF 2024
5. The plaintiffs filed the suit contending that the 1 st plaintiff
and the 1st defendant purchased 2/3rd right over a property
belonging to the husband of the 1 st defendant Raghavan
utilizing the money obtained by them in lieu of their share in
partition,; that on the death of Raghavan his 1/3 right
devolved upon the 1st defendant and her children; that the
said property was sold by Ext.A3 document that they
decided to purchase another property; that Krishnan,
husband of the Plaintiff No.3 had entered into Ext.A4
Agreement for sale to purchase 28 cents; that Krishnan
Purchased 10 cents and the plaintiffs and the defendants
jointly purchased the remaining 18 cents, which is the plaint
schedule property, as per Ext.A6 document utilizing the sale
proceeds of Ext.A3; that at the time of execution of Ext.A6
they learnt that it would be difficult to mortgage the
property if it was purchased in their joint name; that
accordingly the property was purchased as per Ext.A6 in the
sole name of 1st defendant; that since plaint scheduled
property
was
purchased
using
the
sale
proceedings
belonging to the plaintiffs and defendants received as per
Ext.A3 sale deed, the plaintiffs and the defendants are the
co-owners of the same according to their share in Ext.A3
R.S.A.NO.367 OF 2024
and the same is liable to be partitioned among them; that
when the aforesaid Krishnan went to the property for
collecting
coconuts, the defendants 2 and 3 objected
claiming right over a portion of the property; that thereafter,
it is learnt that Ext.A7 Settlement deed is executed by the
1st defendant in favour of the defendants 2 and 3 as if it is
her absolute property and that the plaintiffs came to know
about
Ext.A7
only
on
10.02.2011.With
the
aforesaid
averments, the plaintiffs prayed for a declaration that the
pliant schedule property is a co-ownership property of the
plaintiffs and the defendants; that Ext.A6 is actually enured
for the benefit of the co-owners and that Ext.A7 is valid to
the extent of share of the 1 st defendant and not binding on
the plaintiffs and for partition.
6. The defendants filed written statement contending inter alia
that the suit is barred by limitation; that Rs.1,25,000/received
as
sale
proceeds
of
Ext.A3
document
were
distributed among all the plaintiffs; that property was
purchased as per Ext.A6 document utilizing the funds of all
the defendants; that the property covered by Ext.A6
absolutely belonged to the 1st defendant with every right of
R.S.A.NO.367 OF 2024
alienation; and that presently the property belonged the 2 nd
and 3rd defendants as per Ext.A7.
7. The Trial Court dismissed the suit holding that the claim is
barred by limitation and also that there is nothing to prove
that the sale consideration in Ext.A6 was met jointly by the
plaintiffs along with the 1st defendant to purchase the
property.
8. The plaintiffs filed appeal before the First Appellate Court
and the same was also dismissed confirming the judgment
and decree passed by the trial court.
9. I heard the Counsel for the Appellants.
10.
The contention of the counsel for the appellants is that
the finding of the trial court as well as the appellate court
that the suit is barred by limitation is unsustainable.
According to him going by Section 58 of the Limitation Act,
he has to file the suit within three years and cause of action
for filing the suit arose only when Ext.A7 document was
executed which questioned their title. According to him no
relief with respect to Ext.A6 document was sought for and
hence the calculation of the period of limitation from the
date of execution of Ext.A6 document is erroneous.
He
contended that the finding in the impugned judgments that
R.S.A.NO.367 OF 2024
no evidence could be let into to disprove the contents of
Ext.A6 document in view of Section 92 of the Evidence Act,
1872 is unsustainable as the plaintiffs are not party to
Ext.A6 document. He also contended that the reliance
placed on Ext.B1 lawyer notice is also unsustainable since
the same was done by a mistake committed by another
counsel who was representing the 1st plaintiff.
11.
With regard to the question of limitation, I am of the view
that the reliefs claimed by the plaintiffs are essentially with
respect to Ext.A6 document. The plaintiffs seek relief to the
effect that they are the co-owners of the property covered
by Ext.A6 even if Ext.A6 stands in the sole name of the 1 st
defendant. It is clear from the impugned judgment that the
evidence of PW1 is to the effect that she came to know
about the existence of Ext.A6 on the date of execution of
Ext.A6 itself. If the plaintiffs had any objection with respect
to Ext.A6, they ought to have initiated the suit within the
limitation period and admittedly the suit was not filed within
three years from the date of execution of Ext.A6 document.
Hence the finding in the impugned judgments that the suit
is time barred is clearly sustainable.
R.S.A.NO.367 OF 2024
12.
The next contention raised by the counsel is with respect
to Section 92 of the Indian Evidence Act.
It is true that
since the plaintiffs are not parties to Ext. A6 document,
they are entitled to adduce evidence to disprove the
contents of the same.
But I am of the view that the
plaintiffs have not discharged the burden to prove that the
sale consideration of Ext. A6 property was met by them
jointly with the 1st defendant. The Trial court as well as the
First Appellate court concurrently found that inspite of
examination of PWs 2 to 5 there is no evidence to indicate
that the sale consideration of Ext.A6 property was jointly
met by the plaintiffs with the defendants. In the impugned
judgments the Courts relied on Ext.B1 lawyer Notice dated
27.01.2011 sent as per the instruction of the 1st plaintiff in
which the 1st plaintiff demanded to return the share of sale
consideration obtained as per Ext.A3. It clearly indicates
that the A6 property was purchased without utilizing the
amounts of the plaintiffs received on sale as per Ext.A3.
13.
The counsel for the appellants submitted that it is a
mistake which happened in Ext.B1 on the part of the
advocate who issued it on behalf of the 1st plaintiff without
understanding the correct facts . But the 1st plaintiff did not
R.S.A.NO.367 OF 2024
have any such case while she was examined as PW1.
It
indicates that initially the grievance of the 1st plaintiff is with
regard to the non-payment of share of sale consideration
obtained as per Ext.A3 and later she changed her stand and
made a claim over the plaint scheduled property. It appears
that plaintiffs 2 and 3 who are the children of the 1 st
defendant joined with the 1st plaintiff in the suit since as per
Ext.A7, the 1st defendant transferred the entire property
covered by Ext.A6 in favour of the defendants 2 and 3 who
are her other children.
14.
In view of the aforesaid circumstances, I do not find any
merit in the Second Appeal. The questions of law framed in
the Appeal Memorandum do not arise in the matter.
Accordingly, the Second Appeal is dismissed.
Sd/-
M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
JUDGE
MJL
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review