Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..1..
2025:KER:27751
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 4TH CHAITHRA, 1947
OP(C) NO. 1367 OF 2016
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED IN OS NO.44 OF 1999 OF I
ADDITIONAL MUNSIFF COURT ,NEYYATTINKARA
PETITIONER/S:
PICHI
D/O SUNDARI, SAMUDAYAPATTUVILA VEEDU,
MURIYANKARA, PARASSALA P.O.
THYAGARAJAN
S/O. APPAVU, SAMUDAYAPATTUVILA VEEDU,
MURIYANKARA, PARASSALA P.O.
BY ADVS.
SRI.M.BALAGOVINDAN
SRI.T.K.ANANDA PADMANABHAN
RESPONDENT/S:
ARULAN NADAR ANANTHAPAPPU
SAMUDAYAPATTUVILA VEEDU, MURIYANKARA DESOM,
PARASSALA PAKUTHY (DIED) 695 614.
THAMARAKSHI
D/O THAI, SAMUDAYAPATUVILA VEEDU, MURIYANKARA,
PARASSALA P.O. 695014.
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..2..
2025:KER:27751
SOJA
D/O THAMARAKSHI, SAMUDAYAPATUVILA VEEDU,
MURIYANKARA, PARASSALA P.O. 695814.
SHEEBA
D/O THAMARAKSHI, SAMUDAYAPATUVILA VEEDU,
MURIYANKARA, PARASSALA P.O. 695614.
SAJU
S/O ANANTHAPAPPU, SAMUDAYAPATTUVILA VEEDU,
MURIYANKARA DESOM, PARASSALA PAKUTHY 695614.
SHAJI
S/O ANANTHAPAPPU, SAMUDAYAPATTUVILA VEEDU,
MURIYANKARA DESOM, PARASSALA PAKUTHY-695014.
BY ADVS.
R2 TO R4 BY
ADVS: ARUN V.G. (K/795/2004)
INDULEKHA JOSEPH
NEERAJ NARAYAN
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
25.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED
THE FOLLOWING:
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..3..
2025:KER:27751
“C.R.”
K.BABU, J.
------------------------------------OP(Civil) No.1367 of 2016
--------------------------------------Dated this the 25th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
The prayers in the Original Petition are as follows:“(a)Issue appropriate direction or order directing the
Additional
Munsiff
Court-I,
Neyyattinkkara,
not
to
proceed on the basis of Exhibit-P5 till the disposal of
Exhibit-P6,
pending
before
the
Land
Tribunal
Thiruvananthapuram.
(b)Issue appropriate direction or order and quash ExhibitP5 order passed by the Additional Munsiff Court-I,
Neyyattinkkara
in
E.A.140/16
in E.P.100/10
in
O.S.
44/1999.
(c)Issue appropriate direction or order Grant such other
relief that are deemed fit and proper in the circumstances
of the case.” (sic)
2.
The petitioners are the defendants in O.S.No.44
of 1999 on the file of the Additional Munsiff’s Court-I,
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..4..
2025:KER:27751
Neyyattinkara.
It was a suit for declaration of title,
prohibitory injunction and recovery of possession.
plaintiffs lost the case in the trial Court.
The
The First
Appellate Court reversed the findings of the learned
Munsiff and decreed the suit.
In the Second Appeal, this
Court confirmed the decree passed by the First Appellate
Court.
3.
The plaintiffs filed a petition for execution of the
decree. In the Execution Court, the defendants filed an
application
under
Section
CPC
challenging
the
executability of the decree. The Execution Court rejected
the application filed by the defendants as per Ext.P5.
Petitioner No.2 filed an application before the Land
Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram, claiming the benefit of
cultivating tenants invoking Section 72B of the Kerala
Land Reforms Act, 1963 (‘KLR Act’ for short) as per
Ext.P6.
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..5..
2025:KER:27751
4.
I have heard the learned counsel for the
petitioners and the learned counsel for the respondents.
5.
The plaintiffs pleaded the following:-
The original plaintiff had acquired title over the plaint
schedule property as per partition deed No.3947/1986
dated 17.11.1986. The property came to the possession of
the predecessor-in-interest of the plaintiff based on an
ottikuzhikanam. The mortgage has not been redeemed.
He has been in possession of the property.
The
defendants have no right over the property.
They
attempted to trespass upon the plaint schedule property.
After the institution of the suit, the defendants trespassed
upon the property and constructed a small building in the
basement already constructed by the plaintiff.
6.
The defendants filed a written statement along
with a counter-claim raising the following contentions:The plaintiff has no right over the property.
defendants are in possession of the property.
The
A larger
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..6..
2025:KER:27751
extent of property, including the plaint schedule property,
belonged
to
the
predecessors
of
the
plaintiff
and
defendant No.2 by the name Mathiran, Arulan and
Yagappan.
They obtained the property as per deed Nos.
2126/1104 ME and 1600/1107 ME. This property was not
partitioned.
Defendant No.2 is the grand daughter of
Mathiran, and the plaintiff is the son of Arulan.
The
plaintiff is not in possession of the property.
He is
attempting to trespass upon the property.
Hence, the
defendants are entitled to a permanent prohibitory
injunction as prayed for in the counter-claim.
7.
The trial Court dismissed the suit and the
counter-claim. The plaintiff challenged the judgment and
decree before the First Appellate Court.
The First
Appellate Court decreed the suit, holding that the plaintiff
acquired title over the suit property.
8.
The First Appellate Court came to the following
conclusions:-
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..7..
2025:KER:27751
The plaintiff has acquired title over the property.
The mortgage in respect of the property had been
redeemed earlier.
The defendants trespassed upon the
plaint schedule property.
Based on these findings, the
First Appellate Court decreed the suit as follows:“(a)Title of the plaint schedule property is
declared in favour of the plaintiff.
(b)Defendants are directed to hand over vacant
possession of plaint A schedule property after
demolishing B Schedule structure within three
months from today. If the order is not complied,
the plaintiff is allowed to recover possession of
the property after demolishing the structure
through the process of court.
(c)Defendants are restrained by a permanent
prohibitory injunction from trespassing upon
plaint schedule property and committing any
waste after handing over possession.
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..8..
2025:KER:27751
(d)Appellant is allowed to recover the costs from
the respondents.”
9.
This Court confirmed the findings of the First
Appellate Court in a Regular Second Appeal.
10.
In the application filed under Section 47 CPC,
the petitioners/defendants essentially raised the following
contentions:(1)The legal heirs of one of the mortgagees named
Mathiran were not made parties.
(2)The mortgage in respect of the property had not been
redeemed.
(3)The decree is not executable as the trial Court lacked
inherent jurisdiction to proceed with the matter.
(4)The petitioners are the co-owners of the property.
11. The petitioners/defendants have raised all these
contentions during the trial. The challenges went up to
the
Second
disallowed.
Appeal.
All
their
contentions
were
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..9..
2025:KER:27751
12. A Court executing a decree cannot go into a
question as to the correctness or legality of the decree.
It can entertain an objection that the decree is a nullity
for want of jurisdiction. All questions as to the discharge,
satisfaction or execution of the decree can be raised in a
petition under Section 47 CPC.
enacted
for
the
beneficial
This Section has been
purpose
of
eliminating
unnecessary litigations by allowing the parties before the
Court to obtain adjudication of all questions relating to
the execution, discharge or satisfaction of the decree.
The essential conditions to apply Section 47 are
the following:(a)the question must be one arising between the
parties to the suit in which the decree is passed
or their representatives, and
(b) it must relate to the execution, discharge and
satisfaction of the decree.
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..10..
2025:KER:27751
14. The
questions
raised
by
the
petitioners/defendants do not fall under the scope of the
Section 47 CPC.
Therefore, the challenge on the
dismissal of the application under Section 47 CPC by the
Execution Court fails.
15.
The defendants have now raised a contention
that they are cultivating tenants of the property, and
hence, entitled to the benefit of Section 72B of the KLR
Act.
The defendants had filed Ext.P6 application before
the Land Tribunal.
They prayed for a direction to the
Execution Court not to proceed further in the execution
petition till the disposal of the application before the
Tribunal.
16. The
learned
petitioners/defendants
Counsel
relying
for
on
the
Penangal
Prabhakaran Nambiar v. Ahamed Koya [2020 (1) KLT
364] and Maniyan v. Ramachandran [1999 (2) KLJ 492]
contended
that
the
petitioners
are
entitled
to
an
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..11..
2025:KER:27751
adjudication of their claim for tenancy by the Land
Tribunal.
I do not find any precedential value in the
decisions relied on by the petitioners in support of their
contentions.
17. The learned counsel for the respondents relied
on a series of decisions to contend that the claim of the
defendants before the Tribunal is hit by the principle of
constructive res judicata.
18. It
is
pertinent
to
note
that
the
petitioners/defendants had not raised any contention
claiming tenancy or kudikidappu in the trial of the suit.
Their claim was based on the pleading that they are the
co-owners of the plaint schedule property.
19. The learned counsel for the respondents relied
on Victoria v. K.V. Naik and Others [1997(6) SCC 23],
Kesava Bhat v. Subraya Bhat [1979 KHC 346], Vittala
D. Prabhu and Others v. Nalini Shenoy [2012 KHC
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..12..
2025:KER:27751
443] and Devaki Amma Kamalamma v. Grace Appi
Amma [2017 (3) KHC 12] in support of his contentions.
20. In
Victoria
v.
K.V.
Naik
(Supra),
the
mortgagors filed a suit for redemption of the mortgage.
The mortgagee claimed fixity of tenure in respect of the
entire extent of the land under Sections 4-A(1)(b) and 13
of the KLR Act.
Alternatively, the mortgagee claimed to
be entitled to deemed kudikidappu right over a portion of
the land by operation of Explanation IV to Section 2(25)
of
the
KLR
Act.
The
trial
Court
negatived
the
contentions. A Final decree was passed. When the matter
came to this Court, it was held that the judgment debtors
are precluded from claiming the right of kudikidappu in
view of their prior approach to the Land Tribunal on a
claim that they are cultivating tenants entitled to an
assignment of the right, title and interests of the land
owner over the land in question and therefore, their plea
of kudikidappu is barred by res judicata.
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..13..
2025:KER:27751
21. When the matter reached the Supreme Court, it
was held that if the plea had not been raised, it operates
as constructive res judicata on the principle of “might
and ought” and if it is taken and rejected, it operates as
res judicata and the same cannot be raised in execution.
22. A Full Bench of this Court in Kesava Bhat v.
Subraya Bhat (Supra) considered whether the failure to
plead rights acquired pending the suit or proceeding
constitutes res judicata. The Full Bench held that the
principle of constructive res judicata would stand as a bar
from agitating her claim in a subsequent proceeding.
23. On a claim of tenancy under Section 106 of the
KLR Act raised in the final stage of a suit, which was
available to the party even in an earlier proceeding, a
Division Bench of this Court in Narayanan v. Kunchi
Amma Parukkutty Amma [1986 KHC 359] held thus:“13. In the instant case, we do not propose to dispose of
the revision petition on the principle that the execution
court cannot go behind the decree, for the reason that it
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..14..
2025:KER:27751
may be possible to contend that there is lack of inherent
jurisdiction on the part of the civil court to decide a
matter which is required by S.125 of the Act to be
referred to the Land Tribunal. As pointed out earlier, in
Ramadas's case (1984 KLT 371) the Division Bench of this
Court has held that the decision in such cases by a civil
court without reference to the Land Tribunal would be
without jurisdiction and therefore null and void. We would
therefore rest our decision on the broader principle that
the claim of tenancy under S.106 of the K.L.R. Act which
the petitioner sought to raise in the final stages of the suit
appears to us to be a plea which was available to him
even in the earlier proceedings and which he might and
ought to have raised in those proceedings, and therefore
the lower court did not err in not referring that question
to the Land Tribunal. [Emphasis supplied].“
24. It is also important to note that Section 108A of
the Kerala Land Reforms Act provides that Section 11 of
the
Code
of
Civil
Procedure
is
applicable
proceedings under the Land Reforms Act.
to
the
This view is
fortified by the decision of the Division Bench in Vittala
D. Prabhu and Others v. Nalini Shenoy (Supra).
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..15..
2025:KER:27751
Therefore, the proceeding initiated by the petitioners
before the Land Tribunal is barred by res judicata.
The resultant conclusion is that the petitioners are
not entitled to the reliefs prayed for.
The Original
Petition stands dismissed.
Sd/K.BABU,
JUDGE
kkj
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..16..
2025:KER:27751
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 1367/2016
PETITIONERS‘ EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1:
TRUE COPY OF THE MORTGAGE DEED OF
1107.
EXHIBIT P2:
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN OS 8/59
OF THE SECOND ADDITIONAL MUNSIFF
NEYYATTINKARA DATED 11.2.1963.
EXHIBIT P3:
TRUE COPY OF THE FINAL DECREE IN OS
1066/67 DATED 5.4.1969.
EXHIBIT P4:
TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION UNDER
SECTION 47 IN OS 44/99 DATED
12.8.2015.
EXHIBIT P5:
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN EA 390/2015
IN EP 100/2010 IN OS 44/1999 DATED
16.3.2016.
EXHIBIT P6:
TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION NO.S(S.M)
14/2016 DATED 28.5.2016.
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R2(a)
The true copy of the plaint in O.S No.
44 of 1999 on the files of the First
Additional Munsiff Court,
Neyyattinkara
Exhibit R2(b)
The true copy of the written statement
filed by the defendants in O.S No. 44
of 1999 on the files of the First
Additional Munsiff Court,
Neyyattinkara
Exhibit R2(c)
The true copy of the judgment of the
First Additional Munsiff Court,
OP(C )No.1367 of 2016
..17..
2025:KER:27751
Neyyattinkara in O.S No. 44 of 1999
dated 25.02.2003
Exhibit R2(d)
The true copy of the decree of the
First Additional Munsiff Court,
Neyyattinkara in O.S No. 44 of 1999
dated 25.02.2003
Exhibit R2(e)
The true copy of the judgment of the
Court of Sub Judge, Neyyattinkara in
A.S No. 206 of 2003 dated 08.09.2009
Exhibit R2(f)
The true copy of the judgment of the
Hon’ble High Court of Kerala in RSA
No. 557 of 2010 dated 25.05.2015
Exhibit R2(g)
The true copy of the plaint in O.S No.
294 of 2016 on the files of the
Munsiff Court, Neyyattinkara
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review