Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
signed
LHAINEI Digitally
by
LHAINEICHONG
CHONG HAOKIP
Date: 2023.01.10
HAOKIP 12:54:33 +05'30'
AT IMPHAL
W.P.(C) No. 551 of 2021
Shri Th. Changkhonlung John, aged about 64 years,
Chief/Khullakpa of Chaiba (Charungkhou) Village, P.O. & P.S.
Bishnupur, Kangvai Sub-Division, Churachandpur District,
Manipur-795126.
... Petitioner
-Versus 1. The State of Manipur represented by Additional Chief Secretary
(TA & Hills), Government of Manipur, New Secretariat, North
Block, Babupara, PO & PS Imphal West, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001.
2. The Deputy Commissioner, Churachandpur District, PO & PS
Churachandpur HQ, Manipur-795128.
3. Shri Dongkhopao Haokip, S/o Late Paokholam Haokip, R/o
New Kungpi Village, P.O & P.S. Loktak Project, Kangvai
District, Manipur.
... Respondents
W.P.(C) No. 947 of 2018
1. Shri. Ph. Khuigailung, aged about 70 years Chief/ Headman of
Kokadan Khullen Village, P.O. & P.S. Loktak, Henglep SubDivision, Churachandpur District, Manipur-975124.
2. Shri P.G. Gaithaothui, aged 60 years, Chief/Headman of
Majuron Kabui Village, P.O. & P.S. Loktak, Henglep SubDivision, Churachandpur, Manipur-795124.
... Petitioners
-Versus 1. State of Manipur represented by Secretary (TA & Hills),
Government of Manipur, New Secretariat, North Block,
Babupara, PO & PS Imphal West, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001.
2. The Deputy Commissioner, Churachandpur District, PO & PS
Churachandpur HQ, Manipur-795128.
WP(C) No. 551 of 2021 &Anr.
Page 1
3. Shri Dongkhopao Haokip aged about 66 years, S/o Late
Paokholam Haokip, R/o New Kungpi Village, P.O & P.S. Loktak
Project, Kangvai Sub-Division, Churachandpur District,
Manipur-795124.
... Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. D. Julius Riamei, Adv.
For the respondents
:
Mr. A. Vashum, GA.& Mr.
Th. Henba, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
19.10.2022
Date of Judgment & Order
:
10.01.2023
Judgment & Order
[1]
Heard Mr. D. Julius Riamei, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners, Mr. A. Vashum, learned Government Advocate appearing for
the respondents No. 1 & 2 and Mr. Th. Henba, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent No. 3.
[2]
The present writ petitions had been filed challenging the legality and
validity of the order dated 25.01.2008 issued by the Principal Secretary
(Hills), Government of Manipur recognising New Kungpi Village as a full
fledged hill house tax paying village as well as the land ownership
certificate dated 30.01.2017 issued by the Deputy Commissioner,
Churachandpur coupled with a prayer for quashing and setting aside the
impugned orders and the impugned certificate.
WP(C) No. 551 of 2021 &Anr.
Page 2
The present writ petitions are being disposed of by this
common judgment and order since the issue raised in the present writ
petitions are the same. According to the petitioners, they are the
Chief/Headman/Khullakpa of Chaiba (Charungkhou), Majuron Kabui
Village
and
Kokadan
Khullen
Village,
Kangvai
Sub-Division,
Churachandpur District, Manipur. The said villages of the petitioners are all
old villages having clear cut boundaries and recorded in the list of villages
in the Scheduled of the Manipur State Hills Peoples (Administration)
Regulation, 1947 and the villages have been paying hills house tax since
time immemorial till date. The villagers are the owners and possessing and
enjoying the lands under the said village for hundred of years.
[3]
According to the petitioner, it has been brought to their knowledge
that the Principal Secretary (Hills), Government of Manipur issued an order
dated 25.01.2008 according approval to the recognition of New Kungpi
Village as a full fledged hills house tax paying village and that the Deputy
Commissioner, Churachandpur issued a land ownership certificate dated
30.01.2017 to the effect that the respondent No. 3 is the Chief of the said
New Kungpi Village. The boundaries of the New Kungpi Village as
discribed in the said order dated 25.01.2008 and the certificate dated
30.01.2017 are as under:North – Laimaton Ching
Sought – Leimatak river
East – Moisillui (river)
Westn- Lep Chang Dung/Lui/River
WP(C) No. 551 of 2021 &Anr.
Page 3
The case of the petitioners is that the boundaries of the New
Kungpi Village as are given in the aforesaid order dated 25.01.2008 and
the land ownership certificate dated 30.01.2017 is overlapping the village
boundaries of the petitioners’ villages. It is also the case of the petitioners
that on the basis of the said order dated 25.01.2008 and land ownership
certificate dated 30.01.2017, the respondent No. 3 and his men started to
interfere with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the village lands
of the petitioners’ villages. Having been aggrieved, the petitioners filed the
present writ petitions challenging the aforesaid order dated 25.01.2008
and land ownership certificate dated 30.01.2017.
[4]
Mr. D. Julius Riamei, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners
submitted that the impugned order dated 25.01.2008 had been issued by
the Secretariat Hill Department purportedly in exercise of the powers
conferred under section 3(2) of the Manipur (Village Authorities in Hills
Areas) Act 1956, however, there is no provisions under section 3(2) of the
said Act for recognition of a new hill village. It has also been submitted by
the learned counsel ,that under the Office Memorandum dated 26.08.2008
issued by the Principal Secretary (Revenue), Government of Manipur, it
has been declared that any orders issued under section 3(2) of the
Manipur (Village Authorities in Hill Areas) Act, 1956 with regard to
recognition of hill village shall be void ab-initio. Under the said Office
Memorandum, it has also been declared that orders relating to creation
and/or recognition of villages shall be issued by the Revenue Department,
WP(C) No. 551 of 2021 &Anr.
Page 4
as provided by the Business of the Government of Manipur (Allocation)
Rules, 1999. In view of the above, the learned counsel for the petitioners
submitted that the impugned order dated 25.01.2008 is null and void abinitio since the Principal Secretary (Hills), Government of Manipur, who
issued the impugned order has no power and jurisdiction to issue the
impugned order.
It has also been submitted by the learned counsel appearing
for the petitioners that the same issue raised in the present writ petition
had already been decided by this Court by rendering a judgment and order
in the case of “Shri Z. Shimthar&Ors. Vs. State of Manipur & Ors.”
reported in 2016 SCC OnLine Mani 192. The relevant portions of the said
judgment and order are as under:“8.
The question which does arise as to whether, Principal
Secretary (TA & Hills) does have the authority to pass order in the
matter relating to amalgamation or bifurcation of the village.
“9.
In order to have answer to it I need not to go far away
than to Office Memorandum dated 26.08.2008 published in the
Extraordinary Manipur Gazette (Annexure A/15), relevant part of which
reads as follows:“..............
No. 16/2/MISC/2008-Com (Rev): As provided by the
Business of the Government of Manipur (Allocation) Rules, 1999,
issued by the Confidential and Cabinet Department vide Notification
No. 3/1/77-Com (PI) dated 10th August, 1999, all matters relating to
the creation of Districts, Sub-Divisions, Tehsils, Villages and
alteration of boundaries thereof are allocated to the Revenue
Department.
It has been brought to the notice of the
Government, however, that orders are being issued under
Section 3(2) of Manipur (Village Authorities Hill Areas) Act,
1956, regarding recognition of hill villages in Manipur, in spite of the
fact that such provisions of the Act deals only with declaration that a
village shall have an elected Village Authority. In other words, any
WP(C) No. 551 of 2021 &Anr.
Page 5
orders issued under the provisions of the Act referred to above in
regard to recognition of hill villages shall be void ab-initio.
In the above backdrop, it has been decided to issue instructions
that orders relating to creation and/or recognition of villages shall be
issued by the Revenue Department as provided by the Business of
the Government of Manipur (Allocation) Rules, 1999.”
“10.
Thus, it does appear that a clear stipulation is there that
in the matter relating to creation and/or recognition of villages,
competent authority to take decision is the Revenue Department and,
thereby, the order impugned dated 30.11.2013 (Annexure A/13) passed
by the Principal Secretary (TA & Hills), Government of Manipur who
does not have power to pass such order being illegal is hereby
quashed. Consequently, the order which was passed on 10.12.2014
(annexure A/14) by the same authority which is subject matter of
challenge in WP(C) No. 668 of 2016 is also quashed.”
[5]
The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners further submitted
that the Deputy Commissioner, Churachandpur has no authority and
jurisdiction under any statute or law to declare the respondent No. 3 as
Chief of New Kungpi Village and that as the land ownership certificate
dated 30.01.2017 issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Churachandpur
was based on the null and void ab-initio order dated 25.01.2008 issued by
the Principal Secretary (Hills), Government of Manipur, the impugned land
ownership certificate dated 30.01.2017 is also liable to be quashed and set
aside as being null and void ab-initio.
[6]
The stand taken by the Official respondents in the affidavit-in-
opposition filed on behalf of the respondent No. 1 is that the Deputy
Commissioner, Churachandpur forwarded a proposal dated 04.12.2008 for
recognition of a new village and that on receiving the said proposal, the
Government allowed the recognition of New Kungpi Village as a full
WP(C) No. 551 of 2021 &Anr.
Page 6
fledged hill house tax paying village in exercise of the powers conferred
under section 3(2) of the Manipur (Village Authorities In Hill Areas) Act,
1956. It has also been stated in the said affidavit-in-opposition that the
Deputy Commissioner, Churachandpur issued the impugned land
ownership certificate on the basis of the report submitted by the SDO,
Kangvai vide letter dated 02.12.2016.
[7]
Mr. Th. Henba, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No. 3
submitted that the petitioners have no locus-standi to challenge the
impugned orders as they are not aggrieved persons. It has been
contended that the petitioners are only raising boundary dispute about the
villages and as the land of the villages are not surveyed area, such dispute
can be decided only by Civil Court and not in a writ proceedings. It has
also been submitted by the learned counsel that there is also gross
unexplained delay and lapses on the part of the petitioner in filing the
present writ petitions. In view of the above, it has been submitted by the
learned counsel that the present writ petitions are not maintainable and
liable to be dismissed outright. In support of his contention, the learned
counsel relied on the judgment rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
case of “JasbhaiMotibhai Desai Vs. Roshan, Haji Bashir Ahmad”
reported in (1976) (1) SCC 671, wherein it has been held as under:“12. According to most English decisions, in order to
have the locus standi to invoke certiorari jurisdiction, the petitioner
should be an “aggrieved person” and, in a case of defect of
jurisdiction, such a petitioner will be entitled to a writ of certiorari
as a matter of course, but if he does not fulfil that character, and
WP(C) No. 551 of 2021 &Anr.
Page 7
is a “stranger”, the Court will, in its discretion, deny him this
extraordinary remedy, save in very special circumstances.”
“37. It will be seen that in the context of locus standi to
apply for a writ of certiorari, an applicant may ordinarily fall in any
of these categories : (i) „person aggrieved‟; (ii) „stranger‟; (iii)
busybody or meddle-some interloper. Persons in the last category
are easily distinguishable from those coming under the first two
categories. Such persons interfere in things which do not concern
them. They masquerade as crusaders for justice. They pretend to
act in the name of pro bono publico, though they have no interest
of the public osr even of their own to protect. They indulge in the
pastime of meddling with the judicial process either by force of
habit or from improper motives. Often, they are actuated by a
desire to win notoriety or cheap popularity ; while the ulterior
intent of some applicants in this category, may be no more than
spoking the wheels of administration. The High Court should do
well to reject the applications of such busybodies at the threshold.
“38. The distinction between the first and second
categories of applicants, though real, is not always welldemarcated. The first category has, as it were, two concentric
zones ; a solid central zone of certainty, and a grey outer circle of
lessening certainty in a sliding centrifugal scale, with an outermost
nebulous fringe of uncertainty. Applicants falling within the central
zone are those whose legal rights have been infringed. Such
applicants undoubtedly stand in the category or „persons
aggrieved‟. In the grey outer circle the bounds which separate the
first category from the second, intermix, interfuse and overlap
increasingly in a centrifugal direction. All persons in this outer
zone may not be „persons aggrieved”.
[8]
I have heard the rival contention of the learned counsel appearing
for the parties at length and also carefully examined the material available
on record. It is an admitted fact that the impugned order dated 25.01.2008
had been issued by the Principal Secretary (Hill), Government of Manipur,
purportedly in exercise of the powers conferred under section 3(2) of the
Manipur (Village Authorities in Hills Areas) Act, 1956 recognising New
Kungpi Village as a full fledged hill house tax paying village. Since the
impugned order have been passed under section 3(2) of the said Act, it
WP(C) No. 551 of 2021 &Anr.
Page 8
will be appropriate to examine the provisions of the said Act, which are
reproduced hereinunder:“3.
Constitution of Village Authorities :-
“(1)
For every village having twenty or more tax-paying
houses there shall be a village Authority consisting of –
(a) five members, where the number of taxpaying
houses in the village is not less than twenty but
is not more than sixty;
(b)
seven members, where the number of
taxpaying houses in the village is more than
sixty but is not more than one hundred;
(c)
ten members, where the number of tax paying
houses in the village is more than one hundred
but it‟s not more than one hundred and fifty;
twelve members, where the number of
taxpaying houses in the village is more than
one hundred and fifty.”
(d)
“2.
The Chief Commissioners may, having regard to the
general interests of the people of any village as also to the demand, if
any, from the people of that village for an elected Village authority,
declare, by notification in the Official Gazette, that the village shall have
an elected Village Authority, and there upon the members of the Village
Authority of that village shall be elected in accordance with the
provisions of this Act and the rules made thereunder.
“(3)
Where no declaration under sub-section (2) has been
made in relation to any village, the members of the Village Authority of
that village shall be nominated by the Chief Commissioner.
“(4)
Where there is a Chief or Khulakpa in a village, he shall
be the ex-officio chairman of the Village Authority of that village; and
where there is no such Chief or Khulakpa in the village, the Chairman of
the Village Authority of that village shall be elected by the members of
the Village Authority from among themselves.”
[9]
On careful examination of the above provisions of the said Act, this
Court is of the considered view that there is absolutely no provisions for
recognition of a new village, rather the provisions under section 3(2) of the
said Act only provides for declaration of constituting a village authority.
WP(C) No. 551 of 2021 &Anr.
Page 9
The said provisions did not conferred any power and jurisdiction to the
Secretariat Hill Department for recognition of a new hill village.
Accordingly, this Court finds considerable force in the submission
advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners that the
impugned order dated 25.01.2008 had been issued by the Principal
Secretary (Hills), Government of Manipur without having any authority and
jurisdiction and that the impugned order is null and void ab-initio. In this
regard, we can gainfully relied to the judgment passed by the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of “Deepak Agro Foods Vs. State of Rajasthan”
reported in (2008) 7 SCC 748 wherein, it has been held as under:“17. All irregular or erroneous or even illegal orders cannot be
held to be null and void as there is a fine distinction between the orders
which are null and void and orders which are irregular, wrong or illegal.
Where an authority making order lacks inherent jurisdiction, such order
would be without jurisdiction, null, nonest and void ab initio as defect of
jurisdiction of an authority goes to the root of the matter and strikes at
its very authority to pass any order and such a defect cannot be cured
even by consent of the parties. (See Kiran Singh V. Chaman Paswan.)
However, exercise of jurisdiction in a wrongful manner cannot result in a
nullity-it is an illegality, capable of being cured in a duly constituted legal
proceedings.”
“19. In Rafique Bibi V. Sayed Waliuddin explaining the
distinction between null and void decree and illegal decree, this Court
has said that a decree can be said to be without jurisdiction, and hence
a nullity, if the court passing the decree has usurped a jurisdiction
which it did not have; a mere wrong exercise of jurisdiction does not
result in a nullity. The lack of jurisdiction in the court passing the decree
must be patent on its face in order to enable the executing court to take
cognizance of such a nullity based on want of jurisdiction. The Court
further held that a distinction exists between a decree passed by a court
having no jurisdiction and consequently being a nullity and not
executable and a decree of the court which is merely illegal or not
passed in accordance with the procedure laid down by law. A decree
suffering from illegality or irregularity of procedure, cannot be termed in
executable.”
WP(C) No. 551 of 2021 &Anr.
Page 10
[10]
Moreover, under the Office Memorandum dated 26.08.2008 issued
by the Principal Secretary (Revenue), Government of Manipur, it has been
declared that any order issued under the provisions of section 3(2) of the
Manipur (Village Authorities in Hill Areas) Act, 1956 with regard to
recognition of hill villages in Manipur shall be void ab-initio. For ready
reference, the contents of the said office memorandum is reproduced
hereunder:“GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
SECRETARIAT: REVENUE DEPARTMENT
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Imphal, the 26th August, 2008.
Subject:- Instructions regarding creation or recognition
of villages.
No. 16/2/MISC/2008-Com(Rev): As provided by the Business of the
Government of Manipur (Allocation) Rules, 1999, issued by the
Confidential and Cabinet Department vide Notification No.3/1/77Con(PI) dated 10th August, 1999, all matters relating to the creation of
Districts, Sub-Divisions, Tehsils, Villages and alteration of boundaries
thereof are allocated to the Revenue Department.
It has been brought to the notice of the Government, however, that
orders are being issued under Section 3(2) of Manipur (Village
Authorities Hill Areas) Act, 1956, regarding recognition of hill villages in
Manipur, in spite of the fact that such provision of the Act deals only
with declaration that a village shall have an elected Village Authority. In
other words, any orders issued under the provisions of the Act referred
to above in regard to recognition of hill villages shall be void ab-initio.
In the above backdrop, it has been decided to issue instructions that
orders relating to creation and/or recognition of villages shall be issued
by the Revenue Department, as provided by the Business of the
Government of Manipur (Allocation) Rules, 1999.
P. SHARAT Chandra
Principal Secretary (Revenue),
Government of Manipur.”
WP(C) No. 551 of 2021 &Anr.
Page 11
[11]
The respondents have not been able to point out any provisions of
law enabling the Deputy Commissioner, Churachandpur for declaring the
respondent No. 3 as Chief of New Kungpi Village and as the impugned
land ownership certificate have been issued by the Deputy Commissioner,
Churachandpur basically in terms of the impugned order dated
25.01.2008, this court did not find any reason or ground for upholding the
same.
[12]
On a conjoined reading of the provisions of section 3(2) of the
Manipur (Village Authorities In Hill Areas) Act, 1956, the Office
Memorandum dated 26.08.2008 issued by the Secretariat, Revenue
Department and the judgment and order passed by this Court in the case
of Shri Z. Shimthar (Supra), this Court is of the considered view that the
impugned order dated 25.01.2008 and the impugned land ownership
dated 30.01.2017 have been issued without any jurisdiction or authority
and accordingly, the said impugned order dated 25.01.2008 and impugned
land ownership certificate dated 30.01.2017 are hereby declared as null
and void ab-initio.
[13]
As the impugned orders are found to be void ab-initio, the question
of maintainability of the present writ petitions on the ground of delay and
latches as well as locus-standi of the petitioners are not applicable for the
simple reason that a null and void ab-initio order cannot be validated on
the ground of technical defects.
WP(C) No. 551 of 2021 &Anr.
Page 12
In the result, the present writ petitions are allowed by
quashing and setting aside the impugned order dated 25.01.2008 issued
by the Principal Secretary (Hills), Government of Manipur as well as the
impugned land ownership certificate dated 30.01.2017 issued by the
Deputy Commissioner, Churachandpur. In view of the facts and
circumstances of the present cases, there will be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Lhaineichong
WP(C) No. 551 of 2021 &Anr.
Page 13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review