Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
MONDAY, THE 7TH
DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 17TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 05.02.2011 IN AS NO.30 OF
2010 OF SUB COURT, HOSDRUG
ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 24.11.2010 IN
OS NO.152 OF 2008 OF MUNSIFF COURT, HOSDRUG
APPELLANTS/RESPONDENT/PLAINTIFF:
PEEKKARA VEETIL KUNHIRAMAN(DIED,LHRS IMPLEADED)
S/O.P.V.AMBU, RESIDING AT BANGALAM,, PEROLE VILLAGE,
P.O.BENGALAM, HOSDURG TALUK,, KASARAGOD DISTRICT.
SUPPL.A2
C.V.THANKAMANI
AGED 58 YEARS
D/O PEEKKERA VEETTIL KUNJIRAMAN,AGED 58 YEARS,RESIDING AT
CHALUVALAPPIL HOUSE,THEKKAN BANGALAM,MADIKAI VILLAGE,HOSDURG
TALUK,KASARAGOD DISTRICT-671314.
SUPPL.A3
C.V LEELA
D/O PEEKKERA VEETTIL KUNJIRAMAN,AGED 54 YEARS,RESIDING AT
CHALUVALAPPIL HOUSE,THEKKAN BANGALAM,MADIKAI VILLAGE,HOSDURG
TALUK,KASARAGOD DISTRICT-671314.
SUPPL.A4
C.V VILASINI,
D/O PEEKKERA VEETTIL KUNJIRAMAN,AGED 52 YEARS,RESIDING AT
CHALUVALAPPIL HOUSE,THEKKAN BANGALAM,MADIKAI VILLAGE,HOSDURG
TALUK,KASARAGOD DISTRICT-671314.
SUPPL.A5
C.V DAMODHARAN,
S/O PEEKKERA VEETTIL KUNJIRAMAN,AGED 50 YEARS,RESIDING AT
CHALUVALAPPIL HOUSE,THEKKAN BANGALAM,MADIKAI VILLAGE,HOSDURG
TALUK,KASARAGOD DISTRICT-671314.
SUPPL.A6
C.V RAJENDRAN
S/O PEEKKERA VEETTIL KUNJIRAMAN,AGED 47 YEARS,RESIDING AT
CHALUVALAPPIL HOUSE,THEKKAN BANGALAM,MADIKAI VILLAGE,HOSDURG
TALUK,KASARAGOD DISTRICT-671314.
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
SUPPL.A7
C.V LATHIKA,
D/O PEEKKERA VEETTIL KUNJIRAMAN,AGED 44 YEARS,RESIDING AT
CHALUVALAPPIL HOUSE,THEKKAN BANGALAM,MADIKAI VILLAGE,HOSDURG
TALUK,KASARAGOD DISTRICT-671314.
SUPPL.A8
P.V NARAYANI,
D/O PEEKKERA VEETTIL KUNJIRAMAN,AGED 70 YEARS,RESIDING AT
PUTHIYAVEETTIL HOUSE,THEKKAN BANGALAM,MADIKAI
VILLAGE,HOSDURG TALUK,KASARAGOD DISTRICT-671314.
SUPPL.A9
C.RATHEESH,
S/O PEEKKERA VEETTIL KUNJIRAMAN,AGED 37 YEARS,RESIDING AT
PUTHIYAVEETTIL HOUSE,THEKKAN BANGALAM,MADIKAI
VILLAGE,HOSDURG TALUK,KASARAGOD DISTRICT-671314.
SUPPL.A10 P.V.RANJINI,
D/O PEEKKERA VEETTIL KUNJIRAMAN,AGED 33 YEARS,RESIDING AT
PUTHIYAVEETTIL HOUSE,THEKKAN BANGALAM,MADIKAI
VILLAGE,HOSDURG TALUK,KASARAGOD DISTRICT-671314.
(THE LEGAL HEIRS OF DECEASED SOLE APPELLANT ARE IMPLEADED AS
SUPPL. APPELLANTS 2 TO 10 AS PER ORDER DATED 20.05.2020 IN
IA 1/2020.)
BY ADV M.GOPIKRISHNAN NAMBIAR
RESPONDENT/APPELLANT/DEFENDANT:
THEKKEVEETIL NARAYANAN
S/O.MANI AMMA, RESIDING AT ANGOKALARI HOUSE,,
PUTHIRIYEDAKKAM, PEROLE VILLAGE,, P.O.PUTHIRIYADAKKAM,
HOSUDRG TALUK, KASARAGOD DISTRICT.
BY ADV SRI.SURESH KUMAR KODOTH
THIS
REGULAR
SECOND
APPEAL
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
ADMISSION
07.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
JUDGMENT
1.
The plaintiff in a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction is
the appellant. The plaint schedule property originally is shown
as 85 cents of land in R.S.No.181/2 of Perole village. After the
filing of the Ext.C1 Commission Report and Ext.C1(a) Plan, the
extent was amended as 79.388 cents of land. Both sides admit
that the Jenmom right of the plaint schedule property belonged
to Vettakkorumakan Devaswom.
2.
The plaintiff claimed that the plaintiff obtained kuzhikanam
right over the plaint schedule property 50 years back. The
defendant obtained Purchase Certificate with respect to an
extent of 2 Acre 50 cents of land including the plaint schedule
property as per order in I.A.No.10919/75. Immediately upon
knowing the issuance of the Purchase Certificate, the plaintiff
filed an Appeal before the appellate authority, and the same is
pending consideration. The plaintiff is in possession and
enjoyment of the plaint schedule property and paying
government taxes and rent to the jenmi and making
improvements. The plaint schedule property consists of
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
improvements like jack tree, Kurukuthi tree cultivated by the
plaintiff. The cause of action for filing the suit is that the
defendant trespassed into this property on 06.04.2008 and cut
the trees in the plaint schedule property and he tried to take
possession of the property.
3.
The defendant opposed the suit prayers by contending inter
alia that the plaintiff is a proxy of the defendants in
O.S.No.32/1996 filed by the plaintiff for recovery of possession.
The defendant obtained delivery of the property on 27.10.2007.
According
to
the
defendant,
the
defendant
obtained
kuzhikanam right orally from the Vettakkorumakan Devaswom,
Nileswar and had been regularly paying the purappad to the
jenmee and thereafter purchased the jenm right as per order
in O.A.No.10919/75. The plaintiff is a total stranger to the
plaint property and he has no right title or possession over the
property.
4.
On the side of the plaintiff, the plaintiff was examined as PW1
and his son was examined as PW2. Exts.A1 to A7 were marked
from the side of the plaintiff. No oral evidence was adduced
from the side of the defendants. But Exts.B1 to B15 documents
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
were marked from the side of the defendant. The Commission
Report was marked as Ext.C1 and the Rough Sketch was
marked as Ext.C1(a).
5.
The Trial Court decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiff
restraining
the
defendant
by
a
permanent
prohibitory
injunction from trespassing into the plaint schedule property
and cutting the existing trees and putting fire to the leaves and
committing waste and damages.
6.
The defendant filed Appeal before the First Appellate Court and
the same was allowed setting aside the judgment and decree of
the Trial Court and dismissing the suit.
7.
Both the Trial Court as well as the First Appellate Court found
that there is no dispute with regard to the identity of the
property.
8.
The Trial Court found that the plaintiff has got possession over
the plaint schedule property as Ext.B1 to B10 documents
produced by the defendant are not binding on the plaintiff as
he was not a party to the said proceedings. The Trial Court also
found that no oral evidence was adduced from the side of the
defendant to prove the possession over the suit property.
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
Exts.A1 to A5 proved the possession of the suit property.
9.
The First Appellate Court found that the possession of the
plaint schedule property could not be found in favour of the
plaintiff as Exts.A1 to A5 do not show that the same relates to
the plaint schedule property. The plaintiff has not explained the
difference of the extent in the plaint schedule property and the
property identified by the Advocate Commissioner. It is also
found that the plaintiff did not make necessary pleadings with
respect to the tenancy claimed by the plaintiff. No reason is
stated for not obtaining a Purchase Certificate even after the
advent of the Kerala Land Reforms Act. Even though no
attempt was made by the defendant to tender evidence in the
matter, the plaintiff did not discharge his burden to prove his
title and possession over the plaint schedule property.
10. This Court admitted the Appeal on the following substantial
question of law:
Whether the First Appellate Court was justified in
reversing the decree for injunction granted by the
trial court, without proper appreciation of the
evidence and ignoring the fact that Exts.B1 to B5 are
not proved to be in respect of plaint schedule
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
property and no oral evidence was tendered by the
respondent and appellant by his evidence and
production of Exts.Al to A5 showed that he has been
in possession of the property.
11. I
heard
the
learned
counsel
for
the
appellants,
Sri. Gopikrishnan Nambiar and the learned counsel for the
respondent, Sri.Suresh Kumar Kodoth.
12. The learned counsel for the appellants contended that Exts.A1
to A5 prove that the plaintiff has tenancy arrangement with the
jenmi. There is no dispute with regard to the jenmom right over
the plaint schedule property. It is vested with the Devaswom.
When it is proved that the plaintiff has obtained tenancy right
from the jenmi, in the absence of any contention from the
defendant that the plaintiff is never dispossessed from the
plaint schedule property, the only inference is that the plaintiff
continued with the possession over the plaint schedule
property. Even though the defendant produced Exts.B1 to B15
documents, the defendant did not mount the box to prove those
documents properly. The said documents are not binding on the
plaintiff as the plaintiff was not a party to the said proceedings.
Even though the defendant obtained Purchase Certificate, the
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
same is also not binding on the plaintiff as the said Purchase
Certificate was obtained without notice to the plaintiff. The
plaintiff
filed
Appeal
before
the
Appellate
Authority
immediately on getting knowledge of the Purchase Certificate
obtained by the defendant. Exts.A1 to A5 would show that the
plaintiff obtained tenancy right over 85 cents of land in survey
No.181/2 of Perole village. The Trial Court considered the
matter in the right perspective and granted decree in favour of
the plaintiff and the First Appellate Court illegally interfered
with the finding of the Trial Court and set aside the judgment
and decree of the Trial Court. When Exts.B1 to B15 is
eschewed, there is no evidence on the part of the defendant to
prove his title or possession over the plaint schedule property.
There is only a minor discrepancy in the boundaries of the
property identified by the Advocate Commissioner. The said
minor discrepancy is not at all relevant or material and there is
no dispute from the part of the defendant with regard to the
identity of the plaint schedule property. The only evidence
available before the court is the Exts.A1 to A5 documents which
would prove that it is the plaintiff who is having possession over
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
the plaintiff schedule property. It is true that there are some
contradictions in the evidence of the plaintiff. When the
plaintiff was examined as PW1, he was aged more than 80 years
and hence the contradictions are to be ignored reading the
evidence as a whole. The evidence of PW1 was supplemented
by the evidence of PW2 son also. The learned counsel cited the
decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Salem Municipality
v. P. Kumar & Ors. [(2019) 13 SCC 307] to substantiate the
point that there is presumption in continuity of facts once
shown to have prevailed, unless discontinuity is proved. Here,
in view of Exts.A1 to A5 documents, the continuity of the
possession of the plaint schedule property is proved and in the
absence of any discontinuity or possession, the same is to be
accepted as proving possession in favour of the plaintiff. The
learned counsel further cited the decision of the Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
in
M.V.Lakshminarayana
M.
Rao
Kallappa
[AIR
SC
Setty
v.
2299]
to
substantiate the point the plaintiff is entitled to protect his
possession as against persons who have no better title than
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
himself to the suit property. The learned counsel further cited
the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Nair Service
Society Ltd. v. Rev. Fr. K.C. Alexander [AIR 1968 SC 1165]
to substantiate the point that a person who has possession of
land has got good title against the whole world except the true
owner and that when an injunction is granted it is only against
the defendants and not against any other person. Here, the
plaintiff is seeking injunction only against the defendant and in
the absence of any evidence to show that the defendant is in
possession of the plaint schedule property, the plaintiff is
entitled to succeed in the suit.
13. On
the other hand the learned counsel for the respondent
contended that Exts.B1 to B15 documents would prove that the
plaintiff is a proxy of the defendants in O.S.No.32/1996 filed by
the defendant herein for recovery of possession of the plaint
schedule property. Admittedly, the defendant has obtained a
Purchase Certificate with respect to the property, including the
plaint schedule property. In view of Section 72(K) of the Kerala
Land Reforms Act, it is conclusive proof as to the title of the
defendant. The tenancy right claimed by the defendant is
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
extensively considered in Ext.B1 judgment and found in favour
of the defendant. It is clear from Ext.B1 judgment that the
defendant obtained tenancy from the jenmi and on the strength
of the said tenancy right, the defendants obtained a Purchase
Certificate from the Land Tribunal. Even though the plaintiff
filed Appeal before the Appellate Authority challenging the
Purchase Certificate, the same was dismissed. PW1 admitted
that Exts.B1 to B15 documents relate to the very same property
and the said documents are binding on the plaintiff. In view of
the evidence before the court, the First Appellate Court was
right in setting aside the judgment and decree of the Trial
Court dismissing the suit.
14. I have considered the rival contentions.
15. The plaint schedule property originally shown in the plaint as
85 cents of land situated in survey No.181/2 of Perole village.
Both sides admit that the plaint schedule property belonged to
Vettakkorumakan Devaswom. According to the plaintiff, the
plaintiff obtained kuzhikanam right from the jenmi. According
to the defendant, the defendant obtained kuzhikanam right
from the jenmi. In order to prove the tenancy right under the
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
jenmi, the plaintiff has produced Exts.A1 to A5 documents.
Exts.A1 to A3 are Purappad receipts of the years corresponding
to the English calender 1951, 1953 and 1954. Exts.A4 and A5
are the Land Tax Receipts. In Exts.A1 and A3, it is seen that it
is with respect to 85 cents of land in Survey No.181/2. In
Ext.A2, the details of the property are not seen. In Exts.A4 and
A5, the name of the Jenmi as the Devaswom and the name of
the plaintiff as the lessee alone are shown, and the details of
the property are not shown.
16. The contention of the learned counsel for the appellants is that
on a conjoint reading of Exts.A1 to A5, Ext.A4 and A5 could only
be relating to 85 cents of land situated in Survey No.181/2
referred to in Exts.A1 and A3 documents. But the defendants
had proved that they had obtained a Purchase Certificate from
the Land Tribunal in O.A.No.10919/1975 dated 10/07/1976. It
is issued as per Ext.A7 order of the Land Tribunal. Even though
the plaintiff challenged the said Order granting purchase
certificate, it is seen that the said appeal is dismissed. Since
the plaintiff challenged the said Order granting a Purchase
Certificate, it could be assumed that it covers the property,
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
including the plaint schedule property. Even though the
plaintiff claimed that the plaintiff continued possession of the
plaint schedule property after the date of Ext.A1 to A5
documents, no such document is produced before the Court.
Exts.A1 to A3 would show that the rent paid as per those
receipt is 15 Paras of paddy. But in the evidence of PW1, it
states that he has been paying Rs.100/- as rent to the Jenmi.
Though he claims that he has receipts of payment of the said
rent, no such receipt was produced before the Trial Court. He
has not assigned any reason for non payment of land tax after
the date of Ext.A5 Land Tax receipt. The property is a vacant
land. Hence none of the parties will be in a position to produce
any evidence to show that they are in possession of the plaint
schedule property. The court can rely only on the document
produced by the parties to find out whose case is more
probable. It is seen from Exts.B1 to B15 documents that the
plaintiff had filed an earlier suit as O.S.No.32/1996 for recovery
of possession. The delivery of the property was effected on
27/10/2007. It is admitted by the PW2 that the plaint schedule
property and the property covered by Exts.B1 to B5 are the
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
same properties. It is also clear that the plaintiff described the
plaint schedule property as 85 cents since the plaint schedule
property in O.S. No.32/1996 was also 85 cents of land. When
the property was taken delivery in pursuance of decree in O.S.
No.32/1996,
the
plaintiff
did
not
raise
any
objection.
Immediately after obtaining the delivery of the property by the
plaintiff in O.S. No.32/1996, the present suit is filed. If the
plaintiff had possession over the plaint schedule property, the
plaintiff ought to have obstructed delivery and should have
raised a claim under Order 21 Rule 97 CPC. The plaintiff is not
entitled to maintain a separate suit in view of the bar under
Order 21 Rule 101 of the Civil Procedure Code.
17. The
evidence of PW1 and PW2 are not satisfactory to find
possession in favour of the plaintiff. It is clear that the case
pleaded by the defendant is more probable to prove possession
of the plaint schedule property in favour of the defendant. The
First Appellate Court rightly found that the plaintiff did not
prove title and possession over the plaint schedule property.
18. Under the circumstances, I do not find any ground or reason to
interfere into the judgment and decree passed by the First
RSA NO. 565 OF 2011
2025:KER:30648
Appellate Court. The substantial question of law formulated in
the appeal is answered in the affirmative and in favour of the
respondent. Accordingly, this Regular Second Appeal is
dismissed.
Sd/-
M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
JUDGE
Shg/smsxx
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review