Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/22
GAHC010196422022
2026:GAU-AS:13663
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.A./276/2022
PALLAB SAIKIA @ PAMPU SAIKIA
S/O HAREN SAIKIA, R/O LOTAIMARI, P.S.- RUPAHIHAT, DIST.- NAGAON,
ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM
REP. BY P.P., ASSAM.
Advocate for the appellant
: Mr. J. Borah, Adv.
Advocate for the respondent : Ms. B. Bhuyan, Addl. P.P.
assisted by Ms. R. Saloi, Adv.
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MICHAEL ZOTHANKHUMA
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANJAN MONI KALITA
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 09.09.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 16.09.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the : No.
operative part of the judgment ?
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
Page No.# 2/22
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
(M. Zothankhuma, J)
1.
Heard Mr. J. Borah, learned counsel for the appellant. Also heard Ms. B.
Bhuyan, learned Sr. Counsel and Addl. P.P, Assam, assisted by Ms. R. Saloi,
learned counsel for the State.
2.
This is an appeal against the impugned Judgment dated 27/05/2022
passed by the learned Addl. Sessions Judge, FTC, Nagaon in Case No. Sessions
(T-1) 26/2012, by which the appellant has been convicted under Sections
302/326/341 IPC.
3.
The appellant vide sentence order dated 31/05/2022, has thereafter
been sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life, with a fine of Rs.20,000/-, in
default, simple imprisonment for 4 months under Section 302 IPC. The appellant
has also been sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for 1 year and to pay
a fine of Rs.5,000/-, in default, simple imprisonment for 1 month under Section
326 IPC. He has also been sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for 7
days under Section 341 IPC. All the sentences are to run concurrently.
4.
Section 302 IPC provides for punishment for murder, while Section 326
IPC provides for punishment for voluntarily causing grievous hurt by dangerous
weapons or means. Section 341 IPC provides for punishment for wrongful
restraint.
5.
The facts of the case, in brief, is that the Prosecution Witness No.-1,
Page No.# 3/22
(PW-1), who was the VDP Secretary of Lataimari Village, informed the
Rupahihat Police Station through phone on 09/10/2009 at around 9:15 p.m, that
an unknown person had accosted a male and female teacher on Na-ali Road
and assaulted them with a sharp weapon, causing injuries to both of them. He
thus requested that the police should come to the place of occurrence.
Accordingly, on the basis of the information received through phone on
09/10/2009 at around 9.15 p.m., GD Entry No.204 was made. The information
received in the police station was thereafter conveyed to the SP/Addl. SP(HQ),
Nagaon over phone. The O/C of the police station, along with other police
personnel, thereafter left for the place of occurrence.
6.
On 10/10/2009, PW-4 submitted an FIR to the O/C of the Rupahihat
Police Station, stating that on 09/10/2009 at around 8:00 to 8:30 pm, when her
husband was returning from Samaguri where he had gone for some work with
his colleague (PW-8), some miscreants had stabbed her husband Sri Dibyahas
Saikia with a sharp weapon near Na-ali Pathar Borpul, which led to his death.
The miscreants had also assaulted PW-8 on both of her hands with a sharp
weapon. However, PW-8 took advantage of the darkness and had escaped. As
the news spread throughout the village, PW-4 rushed to the place of occurrence
and saw her husband’s body. She later came to know that the killer was a fellow
villager, namely Sri Pallab Saikia (Pampu), who had surrendered at the police
station with the weapon in the early morning of 10/10/2009 and had confessed
that he had killed the deceased. The police thereafter registered Rupahihat P.S.
Case No.322/2009 under Sections 341/326/302 IPC. PW-18 was entrusted with
investigation of the case after GD Entry No.204 dated 09/10/2009 had been
made. After completing his investigation, PW-18 submitted the charge-sheet
Page No.# 4/22
against the appellant, on finding a prima facie case established under Sections
302/326/341 IPC.
7.
The learned Trial Court thereafter framed charges against the appellant
under Sections 302, 326 and 341 IPC, to which the appellant pleaded not guilty
and claimed to be tried. The learned Trial Court thereafter examined 18
Prosecution Witnesses and the appellant as Defence Witness No.1 (DW-1). One
Inspector Nipu Kalita was also examined as Court Witness No.1 (CW-1). After
examination of the appellant under Section 313 Cr.P.C, wherein the appellant
denied that he had committed the crime or that he had surrendered before the
police, the learned Trial Court came to a finding that the Prosecution had been
able to prove the guilt of the appellant under Sections 302, 326 and 341 IPC.
Accordingly, he was convicted under Sections 302/326/341 IPC and sentenced
accordingly.
8.
The learned counsel for the appellant submits that the only eyewitness
to the alleged crime is PW-8, who is an injured witness. He submits that the
evidence of PWs-5, 9, 14 & 16 is based upon the information allegedly given to
them by PW-8, the appellant and PW-4. However, the same has been denied by
PW-18 (I.O.), whose testimony is to the effect that PWs-5, 9, 14 & 16 did not
say those incriminating statements to him. He submits that PW-5 had stated in
her testimony that PW-8 had asked her to give water and had stated that the
appellant had caused injury to her hands. However, in the cross-examination of
PW-18 (IO), PW-18 stated that PW-5 did not tell him that PW-8 asked PW-5 to
give her water and/or that the appellant had assaulted and injured her hands
with a dagger.
Page No.# 5/22
9.
The counsel for the appellant also submits that PW-9 in her testimony
had stated that PW-8 (injured eye-witness) had told her that the appellant had
cut her hands with a dao. However, PW-18 had stated in his cross-examination
that PW-9 did not tell him that PW-8 had told PW-9 that the appellant had
assaulted and cut PW-8
10.
The appellant’s counsel also submits that PW-14, in her evidence, had
stated that the appellant had told her that he had cut the deceased and PW-8.
However, PW-18 in his cross-examination stated that PW-14 did not tell him that
the appellant had told PW-14, that the appellant had cut a woman and a man.
11.
The counsel for the appellant submits that PW-16 in her evidence, had
stated that her mother (PW-4) had told her that the appellant had murdered the
deceased and PW-8 had been injured. PW-18, however, in his cross-examination
had stated that PW-16 did not tell him (PW-18) that PW-4 had told PW-16 that
her father was murdered and PW-8 was injured.
12.
The learned counsel for the appellant submits that the above omissions
made by the above four witnesses, i.e, PWs-5, 9, 14 & 16 in their statements
made to the police under Section 161 Cr.P.C, has however found place in their
testimonies. As such, when there are contradictions/discrepancies between the
statements made under Section 161 Cr.P.C, vis-à-vis their testimonies, that part
of the contradictions/discrepancies cannot be admissible as evidence. The
omissions, being major contradictions, indirectly disprove the testimony of PW-8
that she had seen the assault made by the appellant on the deceased with a
sharp weapon. He submits that in terms of Section 6 of the Evidence Act, the
Page No.# 6/22
facts connected with the fact in issue which form part of the same transaction,
are relevant. As such, when it has been proved that some parts of the
testimonies of PWs-5, 9, 14 & 16 had not seen light of day, prior to their
testimony in Court, as has been proved by PW-18 in his cross-examination, the
said extracted statements could not be used as evidence against the appellant.
As the testimonies of PWs-5, 9, 14 & 16 were doubtful and lacked credibility, the
testimony of PW-8 was also doubtful.
13.
The learned counsel for the appellant further submits that though the
case of the Prosecution is that the appellant had surrendered with a weapon in
the Police Station with blood soaked clothes, the clothes and the weapon of the
appellant were never sent for forensic examination, though the weapon had
been seized by the police. He further submits that PW-8 (injured eye-witness)
had in the meantime married the appellant. He also submits that there is no
motive established by the prosecution, for the appellant to have killed the
deceased or injured PW-8.
14.
The learned counsel for the appellant further submits that as PW-8
cannot be said to be a credible witness and as the second FIR submitted on
10/10/2009 had been used as an FIR, instead of the earlier GD Entry No.204
dated 09/10/2009, the trial of the appellant had been vitiated and accordingly,
the appellant should be acquitted of the charges framed against him.
15.
In support of his contention that the FIR dated 10.10.2009 could not be
the basis for beginning the investigation in view of G.D Entry No. 204 dated
09.10.2009, the learned counsel has relied upon the judgment of the Supreme
Page No.# 7/22
Court in the case of Yanob Sheikh Alias Gagu vs. State of West Bengal ,
reported in (2013) 6 SCC 428. With regard to his submission that some
omissions or additions made by a Prosecution witness may have a vital bearing
upon the truth of the story given by the Prosecution, he relies upon the
judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Tahsildar Singh and another
vs. State of UP, reported in AIR 1959 SC 1012.
16.
The learned Additional Public Prosecutor, on the other hand, submits
that PW-5, PW-9, PW-14 and PW-16 cannot be said to be contemporaneous
witnesses of PW-8, who is an injured eyewitness. The learned Additional Public
Prosecutor submits that PW-8 being a witness to the occurrence of the crime
and as she had been injured in the incident, it is unlikely that PW-8 would have
spared the actual assailant who had injured her. Further, the evidence of an
injured witness has greater evidentiary value than a normal witness and unless
compelling reasons exist, the evidence of PW-8 cannot be discarded lightly. The
learned Additional Public Prosecutor submits that unless there is some defect in
the investigation which vitiates the entire Prosecution case, no prejudice can be
said to have been caused to the appellant, only because the FIR dated
10.10.2009 had been submitted after the GD Entry No.204 had been made on
the basis of a telephonic information. In support of her submission, the learned
Additional Public Prosecutor has relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court
in the case of Ashok Kumar Singh Chandel vs. State of Uttar Pradesh ,
reported in (2022) 20 SCC 114. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor
submits that in view of there being an injured eyewitness whose testimony had
not been shaken during cross-examination, there was no infirmity in the
conviction of the appellant by the learned Trial Court.
Page No.# 8/22
17.
We have heard the learned counsels for the parties.
18.
As can be seen from the evidence adduced by the Prosecution
witnesses, PW-8 is the injured eyewitness who was returning home with the
deceased from Samaguri in a small vehicle. PW-8 states in her deposition that
before reaching her home, the appellant who she identified in the dock, stopped
their car. When the deceased was about to get out from the driver’s seat, the
appellant hit the head of the deceased with a dao. On being hit on the head,
the victim fell down. The appellant then rained blows with a dao on both the
hands of PW-8, due to which she sustained wounds in both hands. PW-8 then
stated that she somehow went about 2 furlongs and entered her house. While
entering her house, she fell down. Later, her family members took her to
Nagaon Civil Hospital for treatment. From there, she was sent to Guwahati
Medical College & Hospital (GMCH) and subsequently treated by a private doctor
in Tezpur. PW-8 further stated that she underwent treatment for one and a half
years and that her hand had still not completely healed.
19.
In her cross-examination, PW-8 denied the suggestion that she had
made a false accusation against the appellant stopping their vehicle and raining
blows on the deceased and PW-8. She also denied the suggestion that she did
not sustain any injuries or did not undergo treatment anywhere.
20.
The evidence of PW-1, who is the person who gave the information to
the Police on 09.10.2009, is to the effect that he was a Village Defence Party
(VDP) Secretary and that he had called the Police Station. He had gone to the
place of occurrence and saw the deceased lying face down. The Police came
Page No.# 9/22
and thereafter took the dead body. PW-1 stated that he heard that the
deceased was robbed by dacoits and that PW-8 had told him that after being
robbed, the victim had been tied up. In his cross-examination, PW-1 stated that
PW-9, who was the mother of PW-8 had stated that the deceased had been
hacked by the dacoits and that her daughter had also been hacked.
21.
PW-2, who is the cousin brother of the deceased, in his evidence stated
that he was informed by his brother Utpal that somebody had attacked the
deceased. He also stated that he had heard that dacoits had attacked the
deceased.
22.
The evidence of PW-3, is to the effect that he knew the appellant and
PW-4 who submitted the FIR on 10.10.2009 and the deceased. He heard that
an incident of dacoity had taken place in the house of PW-8. He stated in his
cross examination that on enquiry being made, PW-8 had stated that dacoits
had cut her.
23.
The evidence of PW-4, who is the wife of the deceased, is to the effect
that while waiting for her husband to come home at around 8 p.m on
09.10.2009, she heard a sound and saw the elder brother of the deceased
riding a bicycle and calling for a boy named Tutu, who lived in front of the
house, shouting that a very serious incident had taken place. On asking Tutu, as
to what had happened, Tutu told her that somebody had hacked PW-8 and that
her husband had been tied up at Na-ali. PW-4 then informed her mother-in-law
and went to the place of occurrence. She then went to the house of PW-8,
where she saw PW-8 lying unconscious. In the place of occurrence, she saw her
Page No.# 10/22
husband lying in a pool of blood.
In her cross-examination, PW-4 states that she had heard from villagers
that the appellant had killed her husband and accordingly she lodged an FIR
against him.
24.
The evidence of PW-5 is to the effect that she knew PW-4 and the
appellant. On the day of occurrence at about 8.30 p.m, PW-8 returned alone to
her house with injuries on both of her hands. On PW-8 entering the house, PW8 fell down and sought for a glass of water. After having water, PW-8 stated that
the appellant had cut her hands. Due to a hue and cry, people gathered.
Thereafter, a vehicle was called which took her to the Nagaon Hospital for
treatment. Thereafter, she was referred to the GMCH.
25.
The evidence of PW-6, is to the effect that he knew PW-4 and the
appellant. PW-6 stated that PW-8 is his sister and on the date of occurrence at
about 8:30 p.m, he heard his sister (PW-8) shouting. Hearing PW-8, he came
out and found his sister had sustained serious injury on both of her hands. PW8 then told PW-6 that the appellant had caused the injuries to her hands.
Thereafter, PW-8 was taken to civil hospital for treatment. PW-6 then stated that
he did not know how the deceased had died, due to which PW-8 was declared
hostile.
26.
The cross-examination of PW-6 by the Prosecution and by the defence is
as follows:
“XXX (Cross-examination by the Prosecution)
Page No.# 11/22
It is not a fact that Bandhabi came to the house and told me that
accused Pampu caused death of Biprahash Saikia and also assaulted her
causing hand injuries with intent to kill her. It is not a fact that I have
hidden the real story and made false deposition to save the accused.
XXX (Cross- examination by the defence)
Finding Bandahbi returned to the house with injury I came out from the
house to call some nearby people. At the relevant point of time she was
semi unconscious. I could not say who were gathered Bandhabi Saikia
went I went out to call upon the villagers. I have heard from the
attendence that accused Pampu@ Pallav Hazarika caused injuryto
Biprohash Saikia. I have not make visit to the place of occurrence where
the dead body of deceased was recovered. I have made statement to the
I/o that I have seen the injury on the person of Bandhabi Salkia and
thereafter Bandhabi was shifted to civil hospital Nagaon. Except the above
I did not make any statement before the I/O. It is not a fact that accused
did not cause cut injury to Bandhabi Saikia.”
27.
The evidence of PW-7, who is the Doctor who examined PW-8 on
09.10.2010, is to the effect that the nature of injury on PW-8 was as follows:“Nature of Injury:
1. one incised deep cut injury size 6"X4"X1" on right arm exigency to
elbow Invariant vertebrae membranes.
2. Incised deep cut injury size 5"X5"X1" left arm exigency to elbow.
Whether Simple or Grievous: grievous injury.
By what kind of weapon inflicted: Sharp cutting heavy weapons.
Remarks: the patient was referred to GMCH.”
28.
The evidence of PW-9, who is the mother of PW-8, is to the effect that
she saw her daughter come running to her house at around 8 p.m and saw
Page No.# 12/22
injury on both of her hands and there was blood on her whole body. PW-8 cried
‘morilu’ and her elder daughter PW-5 gave water to PW-8. PW-9 stated that PW8 told her that the appellant had cut her hands with a dao. Further, when they
had stopped their car, the appellant had struck the throat of the deceased with
a dao. Thereafter, an ambulance was called and PW-8 was sent to Nagaon Civil
Hospital and she was referred to Guwahati Medical College. PW-9 stated that
she did not know the number of days PW-8 took for treatment. She also stated
that PW-8 was not cured even now and that her fingers were deformed and PW8 somehow managed to take food with one hand.
29.
The evidence of PW-10, is to the effect that he had heard that the
appellant had assaulted and injured the deceased. He also stated that he came
to learn that when the deceased was returning from Samaguri along with PW-8,
the appellant had assaulted and injured both of them.
30.
The evidence of PW-11 is hearsay evidence.
31.
The evidence of PW-12 is also hearsay evidence., inasmuch as, he has
stated that he had heard from the village people that the appellant had caused
the death of the deceased.
32.
The evidence of PW-13, is to the effect that on the day of occurrence,
he along with the driver of the 108 vehicle found the injured girl with her hands
cut and blood flowing. Thereafter they gave her first aid and admitted the victim
to B.P Civil Hospital.
Page No.# 13/22
33.
The evidence of PW-14, is to the effect that he was a Constable in the
Nagaon Police Station and was on duty at Rupahi Police Station at around 12
a.m from 4 p.m. He saw the appellant, who told him that he had cut the
deceased and PW-8. One mit dao, one kopi dao and one torchlight was
thereafter kept on the ground by the appellant. PW-14 accordingly informed the
ASI and the In-Charge of the Police Station.
34.
The evidence of PW-15, who is the Doctor, who performed Post-Mortem
Examination on the deceased on 09.10.2009, is to the effect that there was a
deep laceration and injury on the left side of the neck involving all the vessels.
The trachea was also injured. There was lacerated injury of chest and of the
right ear. There was also lacerated injury of upper muscle region up to vertical.
The nature of the multiple injuries on the body was mandible. All the injuries
were anti-mortem in nature. In his opinion, the cause of death was due to
shock and haemorrhage, as a result of the multiple injuries sustained by the
deceased.
35.
The evidence of PW-16, who is the daughter of PW-4 and the deceased,
is to the effect that she knew the appellant. She stated that her mother told her
that the appellant had stopped the car of her father and when her father had
come out from the car, the appellant had struck him with a dao, due to which he
fell down. The appellant then assaulted PW-8 on her hands due to which she
fled from her house.
36.
The evidence of PW-17, who is a retired Sub-Inspector of Police, is to
the effect that on 10.10.2009, while he was on duty at Rupaihat Police Station
Page No.# 14/22
and was in his quarter, PW-14 informed him that a person in an injured state
having a dagger, a dao and a torchlight came to the Police Station. He then
went to the Police Station and saw the appellant sitting on a bench in the
veranda, with cut injuries by a sharp weapon on the throat of the appellant.
Thereafter, a dagger, a dao and a torchlight was seized from the appellant which
was exhibited in Court. In his cross-examination, PW-17 stated that he saw
blood on the dagger.
37.
The evidence of PW-18 is to the effect that on 09.10.2009, while he was
at Rupahihat Police Station as an Attached Officer, PW-1 had informed him over
phone that a male teacher and a lady teacher had been restrained on the road
and assaulted grievously with a sharp weapon. After GD Entry No.204 dated
09.10.2009 was made, he was entrusted to investigate the matter. After
investigating the matter, he submitted a charge- sheet against the appellant.
38.
PW-18 stated in his cross-examination that PW-8 had been sent to the
hospital by the local people and though he had gone to the house of PW-8, he
could not examine her, as he did not find her.
39.
The evidence of the appellant as DW-1, is to the effect that he had not
murdered the deceased or caused any injury to PW-8. DW-1 stated that his
brother had seen the deceased with cut injuries and had died. His brother was
arrested by the Police on suspicion. As DW-1 was ill, he had not come out from
the house. When he came to know of the arrest of his brother, he along with his
father went to the Rupahihat Police Station on the next day at about 6 to 6.30
am. As the policeman on duty saw cut injury on his neck which had been
Page No.# 15/22
bandaged, the police had detained him, though he had told the police that he
had received the cut injury accidentally while repairing a bamboo fence the
previous afternoon. The Police then arrested him. DW-1 also stated that he had
married PW-8 on 11.07.2017, i.e. 6 months after PW-8 had testified in Court
against him.
40.
In his cross-examination, DW-1 stated that PW-8 was a good-looking
woman and that he was seriously in love with her in 2009 when the incident
took place. He also stated that ordinarily, a person in love would not like if the
girl he loved moved around with another man. However, DW-1 stated that he
was busy and had no time for such things. DW-1 also testified that he was not
happy when PW-8 went for official work outside the school with the deceased
and he had questioned PW-8 about the same.
41.
The evidence of Court Witness (CW) No.1, is to the effect that he was
the O.C of the Rupaihat Police Station and the custodian of the General Diary of
the Police Station. As per Volume X, which is the General Diary of the Police
Station, it was recorded in the context of GD Entry No. 204 dated 09.10.2009.
That at about 4.30 a.m of 10.20.2009, the appellant had surrendered at the
Police Station with the weapon of assault, one knife and one kopi dao. It was
also noted in the General Diary that the appellant was soaked in blood and his
neck was injured. It was also recorded that the appellant had surrendered.
42.
In his cross-examination, CW-1 stated that, as per GD Entry No.212
dated 09.10.2009, in the context of GD Entry No. 204, one Paltu Saikia, son of
Haren Saikia had been picked up and brought to the Police Station. However,
Page No.# 16/22
the subsequent GD entry did not disclose as to what happened to Paltu Saikia.
CW-1 denied the suggestion that the appellant had not surrendered at the
Police Station or that he had not come to the Police Station with a kopi dao and
a knife. He also stated that it was not recorded as to whether the clothes of the
appellant were seized or not. It was also not mentioned whether any forensic
test was conducted.
43.
The examination of the appellant under Section 313 Cr.P.C shows that he
has denied killing the deceased or injuring PW-8. He also denied surrendering
before the Police. He also stated that the injury on his neck was caused by the
sharp edge of a bamboo, while working in his house.
44.
The evidence of PW-8, who is an injured eye-witness to the incident,
shows that her evidence has not been shaken or controverted in any manner at
the time of cross-examination. Though the appellant had taken a stand that the
prosecution has not been able to establish any motive for the appellant to have
killed the deceased or injured PW-8, who he alleges to have subsequently
married, motive is not significant in a case where there is an eye-witness to the
crime.
45.
In the case of Nandu Singh vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (now
Chhattisgarh), reported in (2022) 19 SCC 301, the Supreme Court has held
that while absence of motive is not singlehandedly fatal to a prosecution's case,
a complete absence of motive changes the overall evaluation and definitely
weighs in favour of the accused, when the entire case is based entirely on
circumstantial evidence. The present case is not based on circumstantial
Page No.# 17/22
evidence, but on the basis of an injured eye-witness. As held in various
decisions of the Supreme Court, the testimony of an injured eye-witness carries
high evidentiary value and cannot be discarded lightly.
46.
In the present case, the testimony of PW-8 has not been controverted or
shaken and as such, can be the basis for conviction of the appellant.
47.
In the case of State of U.P. vs. Naresh, reported in (2011) 4 SCC
324, the Supreme Court has observed that the evidence of an injured witness
must be given due weightage. His presence in the place of occurrence at the
time of the incident cannot be doubted. It also held that the evidence of an
injured witness should be relied upon, as he would not like his actual assailant
to go unpunished, merely to implicate a third person falsely for the commission
of the offence, unless there are grounds for rejection of his evidence on the
basis of major contradictions and discrepancies.
48.
In the present case, there is no doubt of the fact that PW-8 was at the
scene of occurrence and at the time of the incident, as both her hands were
injured, due to which, to this day has not completely healed. This is clear from
the evidence of PW-9, who is the mother of PW-8, who testified that the fingers
of PW-8 were deformed and PW-8 somehow manages to take food with one
hand.
49.
With regard to the attempt by the appellant’s counsel to discredit PW
Nos. 5, 9, 14 and 16, by alleging that parts of their testimonies before the
learned Trial Court had not been told by them to the Investigating Officer (PW-
Page No.# 18/22
18), we find that the said stand taken by the appellant is wrong, inasmuch as,
the statements made by PW Nos. 5, 9, 14 and 16 under Section 161 Cr.PC
contains the statements, which the appellant’s counsel has enumerated in the
earlier paragraphs, alleging that they had not been stated to PW-18. The
evidence of PW-5, PW-9, PW-14 and PW-16 is not contradicted when compared
to their statements made under Section 161 Cr.P.C. As such, we find that the
credibility of PW Nos. 5, 9, 14 and 16 as witnesses is not hit by Section 162
Cr.PC and/or Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act.
50.
Going back to the issue of whether there was any motive for the
appellant to have attacked the deceased and PW-8, we find that the evidence of
the appellant as DW-1, shows that he was in love with PW-8. The evidence of
DW-1 also shows that he was not happy with PW-8 going with the deceased for
official work outside the school. The evidence of DW-1 also shows that he had
questioned PW-8 about the same. The above evidence of DW-1 gives rise to an
inference that the appellant was jealous of the deceased and also to the fact
that he was unhappy with PW-8, which could be a reason for the appellant
attacking the deceased and PW-8. In any event, motive loses its significance in
a case where there is direct ocular evidence. It assumes great significance only
in a case based entirely on circumstantial evidence.
51.
In the present case, though there are some minor discrepancies in the
evidence of the prosecution witnesses, there is nothing to discredit the evidence
of PW-8, who is an injured eye-witness.
52.
In the case of Ashok Kumar Singh Chandel (supra) , the Supreme
Page No.# 19/22
Court has held that sufficiency or insufficiency of motive does not have a direct
bearing on the actual evidence against the accused, particularly when the
prosecution relies on direct evidence of an injured eye-witness. Further, minor
discrepancies cannot be said to cause prejudice to the appellant, unless the
discrepancy goes to the root of the matter.
53.
With regard to the issue of GD Entry No.204 dated 19/10/2009, having
been registered on the basis of a phone call made to the police, prior to the FIR
dated 10/10/2009, having been submitted by the informant, we find that even
though the GD Entry No. 204 could have been considered to be the FIR and the
subsequent written FIR dated 10/10/2009 considered to be a statement made
under Section 161 Cr.PC, the telephonic call was a mere telephonic information,
inviting the police to the place of occurrence. A first information report normally
should give the basic essentials in relation to the commission of a cognizable
offence, upon which the Investigating Officer can immediately start the
investigation in accordance with the provisions of Section 154/165 Cr.PC. It is
not possible to accept the contention that the FIR subsequently registered was
a 2nd FIR with regard to the same occurrence, with similar details and was hit
by Section 162 Cr.PC.
54.
In the present case, though the telephonic call made on 09/10/2009, led
to GD Entry No.204, the same does not mean that the GD Entry 204 is to be
treated as the first FIR. The first telephonic information gave no details, except
the fact that two teachers were assaulted with a sharp weapon and the police
should go to the place of occurrence. The telephonic information given by the
V.D.P Secretary resulted in the body being taken by the Police at night and a
Page No.# 20/22
inquest and Post-Mortem examination being done. The sketch-map of the place
of occurrence was also made. Nothing else was done on the basis of the
telephonic information. When the information received by the police without any
details, as regards the name of the culprits or the nature of injuries, the same
need not be treated as an FIR. As such, it cannot be said to be hit by Section
162 Cr.PC.
55.
In the case In the case of Superintendent of Police, CBI and
others, versus Tapan Kumar Singh, reported in (2003) 6 SCC 175, the
Supreme Court held that a GD entry may be treated as an FIR in an appropriate
case, where it discloses the commission of a cognizable offence. It also stated
that an FIR is not an encyclopedia, which must disclose all facts and details
relating to the offence reported. The above clearly goes to show that it is not
mandatory that all telephonic calls need to be treated as an FIR and when the
police case has been registered on the basis of the written FIR, it does not
cause any prejudice to the appellant. As such, it cannot be said that the trial has
been vitiated only because the telephonic call has not been treated as an FIR.
56.
In the case of Yanob Sheikh @ Gagu (supra), the Supreme Court has
held that a second FIR about the same occurrence between the same persons
and with similarity of scope of investigation, cannot be registered and by
applying the test of similarity, it may then be hit by the proviso to Section 161
Cr.P.C. In the present case, the contents of the FIR and the telephonic
conversation are not similar. Further, all the investigation, besides the inquest,
Post-Mortem examination and making of sketch map, had been done on the
basis of the written FIR dated 10/10/2009, which resulted in the registration of
Page No.# 21/22
Rupahihat P.S. Case No.322/2009. As such, we do not find any infirmity in the
Police not treating the telephonic information to be the first FIR.
57.
Further, we do not find any prejudice has been caused to the appellant,
just because the telephonic information given to the police on 09/10/2009 had
been registered to GD Entry No.204, while the written FIR had been submitted
on 10/10/2009. There is nothing to show as to how there has been infringement
of Section 162 Cr.PC and as to what prejudice has been caused to the appellant
by the same. As such, we do not find any grounds to interfere with the
impugned judgment, only because of GD Entry No.204 was not considered to be
the FIR. We also find that though the weapons seized from the appellant, who
had surrendered before the Police Station, had not been sent for forensic
examination, there is nothing to doubt the fact that the appellant had killed the
deceased and injured PW-8. The minor discrepancy between the testimonies of
the witnesses, whose evidences were hearsay evidence, does not in any manner
vitiate the trial.
58.
With regard to the submission made by the appellant’s counsel that
some omissions and additions made by the Prosecution Witness Nos. 5, 9, 14
and 16 affected the credibility of the injured eyewitness PW-8, by relying upon
the decision of the Supreme Court in Tahsildar Singh (supra), we find that
the appellant has not been able to make out a case of there being any
omissions or additions made by the Prosecution witnesses and as such, the
decision of the Supreme Court in Tahsildar Singh (supra), with regard to be
above, is not attracted to the facts of the case.
Page No.# 22/22
59.
In view of the reasons stated above, we do not find any ground to
interfere with the impugned Judgment dated 27/05/2022 or the sentence order
dated 31/05/2022, passed by the learned Addl. Sessions Judge, FTC, Nagaon in
Case No. Sessions (T-1) 26/2012.
60.
The appeal is accordingly dismissed.
61.
Send back the TCR.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
signed
Kuntal Digitally
by Kuntal Datta
Date: 2026.09.16
Datta 10:52:35 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review