Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED:
07.04.2026
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE C.V. KARTHIKEYAN
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE K.RAJASEKAR
A.S.No. 27 of 2019
And
A.S.No. 358 of 2014
A.S.No. 27 of 2019:
1.
Padmasini Sathi
Wife of Late Semur P.Sathi
2.
Ram P.Sathi
son of Late Semur P.Sathi
3.
Harini Sathi
Daughter of Late Semur P.Sathi
(All represented by their power of Attorney Agent
M.S.Sankameshwaran
son of Late M.C.Somasundaram,
997, T.V.S. Avenue,
Anna Nagar Western Extension
Chennai – 600 101.
... Appellants/Plaintiffs
Vs
1.
Dr.S.P.Rajan
Son of Late S.R.Perumal Gounder
2.
S.P.Srinivasan (died)
Son of Late S.R.Perumal Gounder
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
3.
S.Sivaprakasam
son of S.P.Srinivasan
4.
S.Dinesh Kumar
son of S.P.Srinivasan
5.
Gunavathi
wife of S.P.Srinivasan
6.
Shyamala Vijayanand
Wife of Late S.Vijayanand
7.
Minor Sachithan
son of Late S.Vijayanand
8.
Minor Kashvi
Daughter of S.Vijayanand
[RR 3 to 8 already on records as LRs of the deceased 2nd respondent viz.,
(S.P.Srinivasan) vide Court order dated 30.08.2022 in A.S.No. 27 of 2019
(MDJ & SMJ)
(Respondent Nos. 7 & 8 represented by their mother and guardian
Shyamala Vijayanand)
... Respondents/Defendants
PRAYER: This Appeal has been filed under Section 96 of the CPC against
the Judgment and Decree dated 31.07.2013 made in O.S.No. 59 of 2007 on
the file of II Additional District Court, Erode in so far as it went against the
appellants.
***
A.S.No. 358 of 2014:
1.
S.P.Srinivasan (died)
S/o. S.R.Perumal Gounder
2.
S.Sivaprakasam
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S/o. S.P.Srinivasan
3.
S.Dineshkumar
S/o. S.P.Srinivasan
4.
Gunavathi
W/o. S.P.Srinivasan
5.
Shyamala Vijayanand
W/o. Vijayanand
6.
Minor Sachidhan
S/o. Vijayanand
7.
Minor Kashvi
D/o. Vijayanand
Appellants 6 and 7 represented by their
mother Shyamala Vijayanand
... Defendants 2 to 8/Appellants
Vs.
1.
Padmasini Sathi
Wife of Late Semur P.Sathi
2.
Ram P.Sathi
son of Late Semur P.Sathi
3.
Harini Sathi
Daughter of Late Semur P.Sathi
4.
S.P.Rajan
... Plaintiffs/Respondents
... 1st Defendant/4th Respondent
(Respondents 1 to 3 represented by their power of Attorney Agent
M.S.Sankameshwaran
son of Late M.C.Somasundaram,
997, T.V.S. Avenue,
Anna Nagar Western Extension
Chennai – 600 101).
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
PRAYER: This Appeal has been filed under Section 96 of the CPC against
the Judgment and Decree dated 31.07.2013 made in O.S.No. 59 of 2007 on
the file of II Additional District Court, Erode whereby allowing the suit in
O.S.No. 59 of 2007 on the terms that 1/4 th of the A-schedule property and
1/3rd of B, C and D schedule properties were decreed in favour of the
respondents herein.
***
For Appellants in
A.S.No. 27 of 2019
: Mr.G.Masilamani
Senior Counsel
and Mr.V.P.Senkuttuvel
Senior Counsel
for K.R.Nishanth &
U.Bharanidharan
For RR 3 to 8 in
A.S.No. 27 of 2019
: Mr.T.P.Manoharan
Senior Advocate
for Mr.M.Guruprasad
R-1 Notice in notice
R2-Died
For Appellants in
A.S.No. 358 of 2014
: Mr.T.P.Manoharan
Senior Advocate
for Mr.M.Guruprasad
1st Appellant - Died
For RR 1 to 3 in
A.S.No. 358 of 2014
: Mr.G.Masilamani
Senior Counsel
and Mr.V.P.Senkuttuvel
Senior Counsel
for K.R.Nishanth &
U.Bharanidharan
R-4 Given up
COMMON JUDGEMENT
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
(Order of the Court was made by C.V.KARTHIKEYAN, J.)
The plaintiffs in O.S.No. 59 of 2007 on the file of the II Additional
District Court at Erode aggrieved by the Judgment and Decree dated
31.07.2013 are the appellants herein.
2. The suit in O.S.No. 59 of 2007 had been filed by the plaintiffs
Padmasini Sathi and her two children Ram P.Sathi and Harini Sathi against
Dr.S.P.Rajan, who is the elder brother of the late husband Semur P.Sathi of
the first plaintiff and against S.P.Srinivasan, another brother and
S.Sivaprakasam and S.Dinesh Kumar, who are both sons of S.P.Srinivasan
and Gunavathi, the wife of S.P.Srinivasan and also against Shyamala
Vijayanand, Sachithan and Kashvi, who are minors and children of Syamala
Vijayanand, who are the legal heirs of another son of S.P.Srinivasan,
Vijayanand who died pending the suit, seeking partition and separate
possession of the properties described as A, B and C schedule to the plaint
by dividing the said properties into three equal shares and to allot one such
share to the plaintiffs and also to divide the cash, jewellery and other articles
as described in the D schedule to the plaint again into three equal share and
allot one such share to the plaintiffs and to direct the defendants to pay
mense profits of Rs.4,50,000/- for three years prior to the filing of the suit
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
and future mesne profits at the rate of Rs.1,50,000/- per annum or any other
sum till date of delivery of possession to the plaintiffs and for consequential
reliefs of injunction and rendering of accounts relating to the administration
of the properties and for costs of the suit.
3. Even before proceeding further with the averments in the plaint, it
would only be appropriate to set out the relationship among the parties.
4. The first defendant S.P.Rajan, the second defendant S.P.Srinivasan
and Semur P.Sathi, the late husband of the first plaintiff, were the three sons
of S.Perumal Gounder and Pavayammal.
It is the case that earlier the
properties were actually owned by Ramasamy Gounder, the father of
S.Perumal Gounder. It had been contended that Ramasamy Gounder had
inherited the properties at Periyasemur Village in Erode Taluk and District.
The properties as described in 'A' schedule to the plaint are primarily
agricultural properties but with close proximity to Erode Town. There are 14
items of property measuring totally 26.96 acres.
There are also two
residential house and buildings in the said property. It had been contended
by the plaintiffs that these lands are fertile lands, yielding substantial income
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
to the family. They are included in the Lower Bhavani Project Irrigation
scheme. They also have great potential to develop housing and commercial
sites.
5. It had been stated that from and out of the income derived from 'A'
schedule properties, Perumal Gounder had purchased several properties
described in 'B' schedule to the plaint. There are three items mentioned in 'B'
schedule to the plaint. The first item is a residential plot measuring 2963
sq.ft., of land at Surampatti Village in Erode Taluk. The second item is land
and building in Old S.No. 129/B, New Survey No.19/2 at Brahmana Peria
Agraharam Village, Erode Taluk and District. The third item of property is
agricultural land measuring about 60 cents in R.S.No. 60/4 and measuring
50 cents out of a larger area of 0.38 Hectares in R.S.No. 60/5 at Brahmana
Peria Agraharam Village, Erode Taluk and Dsitrict.
6. It had also been contended that quite apart from using the income
to purchase the properties, Perumal Gounder had also started several
business establishments described in 'C' schedule to the plaint.
In 'C'
schedule to the plaint, there are three items, namely, M/s. S.B.S. Hi-Tech Tex
Mills at Door No.3, Chinnasemur, Ellapalayam Road, Erode and M/s. S.B.S.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Leather Industry, again in the same address and M/s. S.Leather Tanning
Industry also in the same address.
7. It has been pointed out by the learned Senior Counsel for the
second to eighth respondents that item Nos.1 and 2 in 'C' schedule property
had been established by the second defendant and by the sixth, seventh and
eighth defendants respectively. It had been further contended that item No.3
is a trading concern run by the third defendant. It is also to be pointed out
that these business establishments are situated at item No.14 in 'A' schedule
property.
8. It is also contended that Perumal Gounder left behind liquid cash
and cash balance in bank and also jewellery which have been described in
'D' schedule to the plaint. It had also been contended that in 'A' schedule
property, there are two houses which had been constructed by Perumal
Gounder.
These are the properties for which partition and separate
possession had been sought by the plaintiffs in the suit.
9. It is the case of the plaintiffs that the late husband of the first
plaintiff, S.P.Semur P.Sathi, died in an accident in USA on 07.01.1997. He
was at that time survived by the first plaintiff and by the second and third
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
plaintiffs. It had been contended that soon thereafter, two Wills were said to
have been executed by late Perumal Gounder on 02.05.1997.
10. It is the case of the plaintiffs that the said wills had not been
executed when Perumal Gounder was in sound state of mind.
It was
contended that he had been deeply affected by the death of his son and it was
therefore improbable that the Will should have been written in the terms in
which they had been written disinheriting the family of his deceased son. It
is the further case of the plaintiffs that the Wills should not be rejected by the
Court, on the ground that the Wills had been procured particularly by the
second defendant in the suit. It should also be noted that Perumal Gounder
had also purchased item No.1 in 'B' schedule properties by sale deed dated
18.06.1977. He had executed a lease deed dated 16.05.1997 in favour of his
three grand sons, 27 acres of cultivatable lands for 10 years on annual rent.
He had also orally sold, Item No. 3 of 'B' schedule property to one Sundar
@ Sundararaj on 09.08.2000 but no document is available on that particular
transaction.
11. The immediate cause to filing the suit was the forwarding of a
partition deed signed by the first and second defendants and forwarded to
the plaintiffs herein dated 05.01.2004 as a proposed partition deed. The
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
plaintiffs did not agree to the terms thereof, since towards their share, a sum
of Rs.1,00,000/- alone had been allotted. They had therefore not signed the
deed. They also came to know that subsequent to the death of Perumal
Gounder, on 09.08.2006, the second item of 'B' schedule property was
settled in favour of Gunavathi, the fifth defendant in the suit / husband of
S.P.Srinivasan, the second defendant. Contending that they were denied of
their lawful share, the suit had been filed seeking partition and separate
possession as stated above.
12. The first defendant did not participate in the judicial proceedings.
He did not file any written statement.
13. The second defendant S.P.Srinivasan, the elder brother of the late
husband of the first plaintiff filed written statement. It is to be noted that
among the three sons of Perumal Gounder, the first son and the third son had
both gone over to the United States of America for education and for further
employment. It was only the second defendant/second son, who stayed back
at Erode and could be considered to be in effective possession of all the suit
schedule properties.
14.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
In his written statement, the second defendant denied and
disputed the contention that Perumal Gounder died intestate. He pointed
out that Perumal Gounder had executed two separate Wills both on
02.05.1997. By the first Will, he had bequeathed his undivided 1/4 th share in
'A' schedule property in favour of the grand sons of the second defendant.
Under the second Will also dated 02.05.1997, he bequeathed the 'B' schedule
property to the second defendant. It was also contended that both the Wills
were registered documents. The second defendant further contended that the
'A' schedule properties were the self acquired properties of Ramasamy
Gounder, the father of Perumal Gounder. It was stated that he had purchased
the same under various sale deeds ranging from 1903 to 1934 and had
purchased them out of his own hard earned money.
It was further
contended, there was no joint family nucleus prior to him.
15. It had been further contended that Ramasamy Gounder had
executed a registered Will on 13.01.1965 bequeathing his properties in
favour of his son Perumal Gounder and his three grand sons, namely, the late
husband of the plaintiffs and also the first and second defendants.
Ramasamy Gounder died in the year 1969. It had been therefore stated that
on his death, his son Perumal Gounder and his three grand sons inherited 'A'
schedule in equal undivided share of 1/4 th each. It had been further stated
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
that the 1/4th share in 'A' schedule property which had fallen to the share of
the late husband of the first plaintiff was always in his exclusive possession.
He enjoyed the same letting out to tenants. It was also contended that the
Wills of Perumal Gounder executed on 02.05.1997 were both acted upon by
the legatees under the Will.
16. It was further contended that the 'B' schedule properties were the
self acquired and separate properties of Perumal Gounder.
He had
purchased the second item of 'B' schedule property under a registered sale
deed dated 12.04.1956 much prior to the Will executed by Ramasamy
Gounder on 13.01.1965. It was further contended that the first item of 'B'
schedule property was purchased by Perumal Gounder by sale deed dated
18.06.1977 for valuable consideration. He had also similarly purchased the
third item of 'B' schedule property in his name. It was contended that for
this purchase, the mother of the late husband of the first plaintiff
Pavayammal had also contributed by selling her properties.
17. It was contended that Perumal Gounder was a Village Munsif and
was also running a ration shop and quite well versed with purchase and sale
of properties and there was a continuous flow of income enabling him to
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
purchase the properties by his own efforts in his name.
18. It was also contended that the second defendant had sold the first
item of 'B' schedule property to one Kasi Viswanathan under a registered
sale deed dated 09.03.2007 for valuable consideration and the purchaser had
also taken possession of the property. It was also stated that by a registered
settlement deed dated 09.08.2006, the second item of 'B' schedule property
had been settled in favour of the fifth defendant Gunavathi, his wife. It had
been stated that Perumal Gounder himself had sold the third item of 'B'
schedule property by oral sale to one Sundar @ Sundararaj and had received
the entire consideration, but the sale deed was not executed or registered.
19. With respect to the other items, namely, 'C' schedule properties, it
had been contended that the factories and the trading concern in 'C' schedule
had been started by the second defendant and by his sons and grand sons and
they were in exclusive possession of the same. It had been contended that
they had obtained loans to commence leather business and therefore, the said
businesses are not available for partition and they are not liable to render
accounts relating to the said businesses. With respect to the 'D' schedule
property, it had been contended that special description had not been given
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
and fanciful figures had been given by the plaintiffs and the properties are
not available for partition.
20. Stating as above, the second defendant contended that the suit
should be dismissed.
21. With respect to the partition deed which had been forwarded to
the plaintiffs, it had been stated that it had been forwarded in good faith and
more particularly the plaintiffs had no intention to come back to settle in
this country and therefore, to consolidate the properties of their father, the
said partition deed had been prepared and signed by the first and second
defendants and forwarded to the plaintiffs. The second defendant also denied
that there were talks for settlement or settlement.
22. A Reply statement had been filed by the plaintiffs once again
reiterating their contentions as stated in the plaint.
They disputed the
statement made that Perumal Gounder was in a sound state of mind when he
executed the Wills. They put the two Wills to strict proof. They also denied
that Ramasamy Gounder had executed a Will.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
It was stated that the
contention that Perumal Gounder had left behind cash of just Rs.18,07,524/was not correct and it was stated that substantial amount of cash and jewels
had been screened away from being available for partition. They disputed
the encumbrances made over the three items of 'B' schedule property and
stated that the said properties are also available for partition. In effect, they
reiterated that they were entitled 1/3rd in the suit schedule properties.
23. On the basis of the pleadings, the learned Trial Judge had framed
the following issues:-
“1.
Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for
1/3rd share in 'A' 'B' 'C' and 'D' schedule
properties?;
2.
Whether the two Wills executed by
Perumal Gounder on 02.05.1997 are true and
valid documents?;
3.
Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for
the relief against the defendants to submit
accounts?;
4.
Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for
past and future mense profits?;
5.
Whether the cause of action for filing
the suit is true?; and
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
6.
To what other reliefs the parties are
entitled to?”
24. During trial, the power of attorney agent of the plaintiffs was
examined as PW-1 and another witness was examined as PW-2.
The
plaintiffs marked Exs. A-1 to A-3. The second defendant was examined as
DW-1 and the defendants also examined five other witnesses as DW-2 to
DW-6. The defendants marked Exs. B-1 to B-84.
25. On the basis of the evidence and the documents produced, the
learned Trial Judge was of the opinion that the Will dated 13.01.1965
indicated that the properties were the self acquired properties of Ramasamy
Gounder and that under the said Will, he had bequeathed 1/4 th undivided
share in 'A' schedule properties to his son Perumal Gounder and had
bequeathed an equal 1/4th undivided share each to his three grandsons.
26. The learned Trial Judge was of the opinion that the two Wills
which had been marked as Ex. B-26 and B-27 said to have been executed by
Perumal Gounder had not been proved in manner known to law. This would
indicate that the 'B' schedule properties were available for partition and
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
separate possession and had therefore granted 1/3 rd undivided share in the 'B'
'C' and 'D' schedule properties and an undivided 1/4 th share in 'A' schedule
property. Challenging the limiting of the share to the extent of 1/4 th share in
'A' schedule property, the plaintiffs have filed A.S.No. 27 of 2019 and
challenging the rejection of the Wills, the second to eighth defendants have
filed A.S.No. 358 of 2014.
27. Since both Appeals arise out of the same Judgment and Decree, a
common Judgment is rendered.
28. Heard arguments advanced by Mr.T.P.Manoharan, learned Senior
counsel for Mr.M.Guruprasad, learned counsel for the appellants in A.S.No.
358 of 2014 and advanced by Mr.G.Masilamani, learned Senior Counsel for
the appellants and Mr. V.P.Senkuttuvel, learned Senior Counsel for the
appellants in A.S.No. 27 of 2019.
29. It is the contention of Mr.T.P.Manoharan, learned Senior Counsel
that the Wills dated 02.05.1997 under Exs. B-26 and B-27 had been tested
during the course of trial and that the attesting witness had also been
examined during the course of trial. The learned Senior Counsel contended
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
that the appellants had examined DW-3 Subramaniam, who was one of the
attesting witness and DW-4 Velliayangiri to speak about the execution of the
said Wills.
30. With respect to 'A' schedule property, the learned Senior Counsel
pointed out that the said properties were the self acquired properties of
Ramasamy Gounder and he had executed a Will dated 13.01.1965 which had
been marked as Ex.B-14. Under the said Will, Ramasamy Gounder had
bequeathed the shares to his son Perumal Gounder and to his three grand
sons the first and second defendants and the late husband of the first
plaintiff.
It was contended that no dispute had been raised over the
execution of the said Will. On the death of Ramasamy Gounder in the year
1969, the Will came into effect. The 'A' schedule was divisible into four
equal shares with one share being allotted to Perumal Gounder and one share
each to the three sons. The learned Senior Counsel contended that Perumal
Gounder had executed a Will on 02.05.1997 bequeathing his 1/4 th share to
his grandsons / sons of the second defendant.
The learned counsel
contended that this Will also had been proved in manner known to law. The
plaintiffs will therefore be entitled only to an undivided 1/4 th share in the 'A'
schedule property in accordance with the original bequeath under the Will
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
dated 13.01.1965 of Ramasamy Gounder in their capacity as legal heirs of
Semur P.Sathi.
31. With respect to the 'B' schedule properties, the learned Senior
Counsel pointed out that these properties had been dealt with by Perumal
Gounder under the Will dated 02.05.1997 marked Ex.B-27 which was also a
registered document. Under this Will, the 'B' schedule properties were
bequeathed to the second defendant. The learned Senior Counsel then took
the Court through the two Wills. He contended that S.Perumal Gounder had
given reasons why property was bequeathed to the second defendant alone.
He had very categorically stated that other two sons, namely, the first
defendant and the late husband of the first plaintiff were settled in the United
States of America and earning money. He had also stated that it was only the
second defendant, who was residing in Erode and looking after him. The
learned Senior Counsel contended that the Wills have been proved in manner
known to law.
He argued that the Trial Court had come to a wrong
conclusion in rejecting the two Wills.
The learned Senior Counsel
contended that the Wills having been proved in manner known to law should
have been taken into consideration and the plaintiffs should not have been
granted any share in 'B' schedule properties and the plaintiffs should be
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
entitled only to an undivided 1/4th share in 'A' schedule properties.
32. With respect to the 'C' schedule properties, the learned Senior
Counsel contended that the first and second items were manufacturing units
started by the second defendant and by his family members with loans
obtained and being run on a day-to-day basis by them. He contended that
there no input had been provided by the plaintiffs towards the running of the
said businesses. With respect to the third item of 'C' schedule property, it
was contended that it was a trading concern and it was being run only by the
family members of the second defendant.
The learned Senior Counsel
contended that the plaintiffs were not entitled for any share in the 'C'
schedule properties.
33. Similarly with respect to 'D' schedule properties, it had been
contended that a very vague description had been given and the plaintiffs are
not entitled to any share since the property had not been properly described
in the schedule to the plaint.
34. The learned Senior Counsel therefore contended that the decree
granting partition and separate possession of 'B' 'C' and 'D' schedule property
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
should be set aside by this Court and claimed that an undivided 1/4 th share
could be granted to the plaintiffs in the 'A' schedule property.
35. Mr.G.Masilamani, learned Senior Counsel for the appellants in
A.S.No. 27 of 2019 very seriously disputed the said contentions.
The
learned Senior Counsel contended that 'A' schedule properties were specific
properties and though they were termed as agricultural properties, they
abetted Erode town. It was contended that the properties are extremely
valuable and the plaintiffs had been denied even the right to be in possession
of the said properties. The learned Senior Counsel pointed out that the first
and second defendants had forwarded a proposed partition deed dated
05.01.2004 signed by them to the plaintiffs calling upon the first plaintiff to
appended her signature. This document was marked as Ex. A-1. The
learned Senior Counsel stated that in the said document, the plaintiffs had
been allotted a paltry sum of Rs.1,00,000/- alone towards their share. He
then pointed out that 'A' schedule properties were substantial in area nearly
about 26 acres and expressed dismay on the paltry amount allotted to the
plaintiffs.
36.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
The learned Senior Counsel further widened the scope of
arguments by stating that the properties at the hands of Ramasamy Gounder
were ancestral properties. The learned Senior Counsel further pointed out
that Ramasamy Gounder had executed a registered Will under Ex.B-14
bequeathing the properties in favour of his son Perumal Gounder and his
three grandsons.
He also contended that once such a Will had been
executed, the properties became the self acquired properties in the hands of
each one of the four legatees.
37. The learned Senior Counsel then questioned the Wills marked
under Ex. P-26 and P-27. He pointed out that the late husband of the first
plaintiff died in a road accident in United States of America on 07.01.1977
leaving behind the first plaintiff, a young widow and two minor children.
The learned Senior Counsel argued that in those circumstances, it was highly
improbable that Perumal Gounder would have execute the two Wills
immediately thereafter, within less than four months, on 02.05.1997
disinheriting the plaintiffs from his share in the 'A' schedule properties and
also from the 'B' schedule properties. The learned Senior Counsel argued
that this Court should visualise the agony which Perumal Gounder would
have suffered on the death of his son in an accident in the United States of
America and wondered as to how a widow and her two minor children
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
would have been disinherited from any share in the 'B' schedule and from his
share in the 'A' schedule properties.
38. The learned Senior Counsel contended that the entire 'A' schedule
properties had been in exclusive possession of the second defendant and of
his family members. They had been enjoying the income which had been
received from the 'A' schedule properties. He contended that from that
income, the businesses described in the 'C' schedule properties had been
storted. The learned Senior Counsel contended that the profits earned under
the said businesses must also be shared and accounts should be rendered by
the second to eighth defendants.
39. The learned Senior Counsel further contended that it is also
improbable to hold that the mother, Pavayammal did not have any jewels at
all. The family were in financially very good circumstances and there could
a lady in the house would certainly be having jewels. The learned Senior
Counsel contended that the 'D' schedule properties were very
much
available for partition. He pointed out that the trial Court had granted
partition and separate possession of 'B' 'C' and 'D' schedule properties and
had correctly rejected the Wills said to have been executed by Perumal
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Gounder. The learned Senior Counsel stated that the plaintiffs should be put
in possession immediately and in this connection urged that the Court should
also pass a Judgment on admission under Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code of
Civil Procedure particularly taking note of the admission on the part of the
respondents in A.S.No. 27 of 2019 that the appellants therein were entitled to
a share in the 'A' schedule properties.
40. Mr.V.P.Senkuttuvel, learned Senior Counsel supplemented the
arguments and urged that the Court should set aside the Wills marked as
Ex.P-26 and Ex.P-27 and should decree the suit as prayed.
41.
We have carefully considered the arguments advanced and
perused the materials available on record.
42.
Both the Appeals arise from O.S.No. 59 of 2007 a suit for
partition and separate possession on the file of the II Additional District
Court at Erode.
43. The points which arise for consideration are:
1) Whether the two Wills marked as Ex.P-26 and P-27 have been
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
proved in manner known to law? And, if so, what is the effect and if not,
what is the effect?; and
2) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to a share in 'C' and 'D' schedule
properties?
44. The Geneology Table of the parties reflecting their relationships is
as follows:-
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
45. There were four items described in the schedule to the suit as 'A'
'B' 'C' and 'D'.
46. 'A' schedule properties are agricultural lands measuring about 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
acres. 'B' schedule properties and three items of land and buildings, 'C'
schedule properties were three business enterprises and 'D' schedule
properties were liquid cash, gold and jewellery.
47.
It is contended that the properties were anscestral properties
purchased by S.Ramasamy Gounder. He had executed a registered Will on
13.01.1965. That Will is not in dispute. Under the said registered Will
marked as Ex.B-14, he bequeathed an equal undivided 1/4 th share in the 'A'
schedule properties to his son Perumal Gounder and to his three grandsons,
the first and second defendants and the late husband of the first plaintiff.
There is no dispute about this bequeath. This would indicate that during the
lifetime of Perumal Gounder, he and his three sons were each entitled to an
undivided 1/4th share in the 'A' schedule property. It is also to be noted that
the first defendant S.P.Rajan and the late husband of the first plaintiff, late
Semur P.Sathi went over to United States of America for further education
and settled there. The second defendant S.P.Srinivasan continued to reside
in Erode with his father Perumal Gounder.
48. The third son, Semur P.Sathi unfortunately died in a road accident
on 07.01.1997. Immediately thereafter on 02.05.1997 within about four
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
months Perumal Gounder is said to have executed a registered Will, marked
as Ex.B-26 bequeathing his undivided 1/4 th share in the 'A' schedule
properties to his grandsons through the second defendant. This document
has been strongly attacked by the learned Senior Counsel on behalf of the
plaintiffs/appellants in A.S.No. 27 of 2019. It had been contended that it
was improbable that Perumal Gounder would have disinherited the young
widow of his son and the two grand children from his share in the 'A'
schedule properties.
49. It is to be noted that Perumal Gounder during his lifetime had
purchased item No.1 of 'B' schedule property on 18.06.1977 which sale deed
had been marked as Ex.B-22 and had earlier purchased item No. 2 of 'B'
schedule property by a sale deed dated 12.04.1956 which document was
marked as Ex.B-21.
50. It is to be noted that on the same day on 02.05.1997 when
Ex.B-26 Will had been executed and Perumal Gounder also executed
another Will which had been marked as Ex.B-27 and which had also been
registered, bequeathing the 'B' schedule properties to his second son /the
second defendant/ S.P.Srinivasan. This Will also had been questioned and
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
attacked by the learned Senior Counsel for the plaintiffs/appellants in
A.S.No. 27 of 2019 by again pointing out the improbability of disinheriting
the young widow and her two minor children of his third son.
51.
The learned Senior Counsel argued that one of the attesting
witness was said to have been a driver and therefore he would be only a
compliant witness to the Wills. The other witness was an employee of the
document writer. The learned Senior Counsel contended that the evidence of
the said two witness very clearly revealed that they had been tutored and
therefore urged that this Court should reject the evidence and should hold
that the two Wills had not been executed when Perumal Gounder was in a
sound state of mind and should also declare that the said Wills had been
executed at the instance of the second defendant.
52.
Placing strong reliance on the covenants in the Will,
Mr.T.P.Manoharan, learned Senior Counsel argued that sufficient reasons
had been given regarding the manner in which the properties had been
bequeathed and why his undivided /14 th share in the 'A' schedule properties
had not been bequeathed to the late husband of the first plaintiff. The
testator had very clearly stated that it was only the second defendant, who
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
was taking care of him and that his other two sons had shifted to America. It
was also noted that the second defendant had grandsons who were all
looking after him. Since they were permanently in India and in Erode, he
was desirous to settling the properties in their favour for their future.
Similarly in the other Will marked as Ex.P-27 and also executed on the same
date on 02.05.1997, which had been executed with respect to the 'B'
schedule properties Perumal Gounder had also given the very same reasons.
The two Wills had been attested by DW-3 and DW-4. The learned Senior
Counsel therefore contended that the Wills cannot be rejected merely
because the late husband of the first plaintiff had been disinherited.
53. We had examined the evidence tendered by DW-3 and DW-4.
54. Section 63(c) of the Indian Succession Act 1925 is as follows:-
“63. Execution of unprivileged Wills.—
Every testator, not being a soldier employed in an
expedition or engaged in actual warfare, or an
airman so employed or engaged, or a mariner at
sea, shall execute his Will according to the
following rules:—
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
(a) ..................
(b) ..........
(c)The Will shall be attested by two or more
witnesses, each of whom has seen the testator sign
or affix his mark to the Will or has seen some other
person sign the Will, in the presence and by the
direction of the testator, or has received from the
testator a personal acknowledgement of his
signature or mark, or the signature of such other
person; and each of the witnesses shall sign the Will
in the presence of the testator, but it shall not be
necessary that more than one witness be present at
the same time, and no particular form of attestation
shall be necessary. ”
55.
Section 68 of Indian Evidence Act / Section 69 of BNSS 2023
is as follows:-
“68. Proof of execution of document
required by law to be attested.
If a document is required by law to be
attested, it shall not be used as evidence until one
attesting witness at least has been called for the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
purpose of proving its execution, if there be an
attesting witness alive, and subject to the process
of the Court and capable of giving evidence :
[Provided that it shall not be necessary to call an
attesting witness in proof of the execution of any
document, not being a Will, which has been
registered in accordance with the provisions of the
Indian Registration Act, 1908 (XVI of 1908),
unless its execution by the person by whom it
purports to have been executed is specifically
denied.] [Inserted by Act 31 of 1926, Section 2.] ”
56. It is requisite that any Will should be attested by two persons and
they should have seen the testator signing the Will and they should also sign
the Will in the presence of the testator and under his authority. Out of the
two attesting witnesses, it is sufficient if one was present at the time when
the testator signed. Further to prove the Will, out of the two attesting
witnesses, atleast one attesting witness must be examined.
57.
The attesting witness in the instant case, deposed about the
execution of the Will and stated that the testator signed the Will in his
presence. It should be noted that both Ex. B-26 and B-27 are registered
documents. The registration might give a presumption regarding genuinity,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
but still a Will must be proved in manner known to law.
58. In this case, DW-3 and DW-4 the two attesting witnesses have
both examined and also cross examined. It is not required that the attesting
witness should have any special designation. It should also be understood
that in a Will, individuals would be called upon to sign as attesting witnesses
with confidence that they would later depose in Court when called upon to
tender evidence in a Court of law regarding the circumstances surrounding
the execution of the Will.
59. In the instant case, the two attesting witness are a driver and an
employee of the document writer. The driver was called upon to tender
evidence as DW-3. The other attesting witness had also deposed as DW-4.
They had both spoken about the execution of the Will. It is also to be noted
that even if there are minor contradictions, unless they go to the root,
touching upon the mental capacity of the testator, the evidence cannot be
rejected. The witnesses spoke about the testator voluntarily signing the Will.
Additionally, in the instant case, the Wills had also been presented before the
Sub Registrar Office. A presumption arises that the Sub Registrar also
discharged his official duty by asking the testator about his knowledge of the
contents of the Wills. The fact is that the Wills had been executed within
four months from the date of death of the late husband of the first plaintiff. It
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
however emanated during the arguments that the plaintiffs had not brought
back the dead body of the late husband of the first plaintiff back to India.
This is a relevant fact for Perumal Gounder to believe hold that there would
not be any possibility of them ever coming back to this Country and
therefore bequeathing the properties to his son in India.
60. We also note that DW-3 and DW-4 had both spoken extensively
about the mental capacity of the testator to the Will. They also spoke about
his voluntariness in executing the Will. This voluntariness had not been
taken into consideration by the Trial Court. They also spoke about the
manner in which the Wills had been signed and executed by the testator and
also about their individual attestations. These are relevant factors which
should be considered while examining the proof of a Will.
61. The observations of the learned Trial Judge that it is not known
whether the signatures had been obtained in the office of the Sub Registrar
or outside the office are irrelevant. The fact that the testator signed alone is
a relevant fact. The fact that the signature of the testator was witnessed by
the attesting witness alone is a relevant fact. It could be argued that the
testator was in an agitated state of mind owing to death of a son in an
accident but that is not reflected in the Wills. He had given necessary and
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
adequate reasons as to why he was bequeathing the properties as he so
desired. He had mentioned the reasons in the Will. We find that there are no
suspicious circumstances surrounding the execution of the Will. The finding
of the Trial Court necessarily have to be set aside and is interfered with by
us.
62. We uphold the validity of the execution of the Wills and affirm
that Perumal Gounder had executed the Wills in a sound state of mind. We
hold that the plaintiffs would be entitled to 1/4 th share in 'A' schedule
property.
63. With respect to 'B' schedule properties, though it is contended that
Perumal Gounder did not have the sources to purchase the properties, the
documents stand in his name. Item No.2 of 'B' schedule property had been
purchased on 12.04.1956 much prior to the death of his father Ramasamy
Gounder. This fact is very relevant. If it had been purchased from and out
of the ancestral nucleus, then Ramasamy Gounder would also have inherited
a share over the said property but had consciously not included that property
in his Will under Ex.B-14 dated 13.01.1965.
64. It is also to be noted that Perumal Gounder had purchased the first
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
item of 'B' schedule property under Ex.B-22 dated 18.06.1977. It is on
evidence that he was a Village Munsif and was also running a ration shop.
The property had been purchased for a sum of Rs.7,000/-. The fact that he
was running a ration shop was disputed but the fact that he was a Village
Munisf is admitted by the appellants in A.S.No. 27 of 2019. We would
therefore uphold Ex. B-26 and B-27 Wills executed by Perumal Gounder.
This would indicate that the plaintiffs are not entitled to any share in the 'B'
schedule properties.
65. With respect to 'C' schedule items, it is evident that they had been
commenced and are run only by the family members of the second
defendant. They had also obtained loan for the commencement of the said
businesses. There is no document produced to show that the plaintiffs had
contributed any share towards the purchase of any machinery or any other
item of the said industries. It is also to be noted that Perumal Gounder had
also not contributed for the commencement or running of the said
businesses. We therefore hold that the 'C' schedule properties are businesses
of the second to eighth defendants. However, the said businesses are now
situated in item No.14 of 'A' schedule property. Since we have held that the
plaintiffs are entitled to as undivided 1/4 th share in the 'A' schedule properties
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
at the time of passing of the final decree, the equity of the shares must be
worked out.
66. With respect to 'D' schedule property, it is on evidence that a sum
of Rs.18,07,524/- is available and admitted to be available in the bank
account of Perumal gounder.
67.
Mr.G.Masilamani, learned Senior Counsel argued that the
plaintiffs are entitled to an undivided 1/3rd share in the said amount. He
further argued that even with knowledge that the plaintiffs are entitled to an
undivided 1/3rd share in the said amount, the defendants in the suit have not
come forward to voluntarily hand over the said amount to the plaintiffs and
had denied the plaintiffs a share in that particular amount right from the
death of Perumal Gounder. He therefore very strongly insisted that interest
should be granted on the said amount payable by the defendants to the
plaintiffs. We agree with the said contention.
68. We hold that in the sum of Rs.18,07,524/-, the plaintiffs are
entitled to 1/3rd share and are further entitled to interest at the rate of 12%
p.a., from the date of institution of the suit till date of payment.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
69. Accordingly, the Judgment and Decree of the Trial Court is
modified as follows:-
(i) 'A' schedule property: The plaintiffs are entitled to an undivided
1/4th share;
(ii) 'B' and 'C' schedule property: the plaintiffs are not entitled to any
share;
(iii) 'D' schedule property: the plaintiffs are entitled to 1/3 rd share out
of a sum of Rs.18,07,524/- together with interest at 12% p.a., from the date
of the plaint till date of payment.
70. Both the Appeals are disposed of accordingly.
71. We direct the Registry to prepare the decree in the aforesaid terms
within a period of 8 weeks from this date. No order as to costs.
(C.V.K.,J.)
(K.R.S.,J.)
07-04-2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Index:Yes / No
Speaking / Non-Speaking order
vsg
To
II Additional District Court, Erode
C.V.KARTHIKEYAN, J.
And
K.RAJASEKAR, J.
vsg
A.S.No. 27 of 2019
And
A.S.No. 358 of 2014
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
07.04.2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review