The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
6. Already this Court passed passed an order of Interim Injunction in Original Application No.1204 of 2025 in C.S.No.311 of 2025 dated 26.12.2025 and same was challenged by way of Original Side Appeals before the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in O.S.A.Nos.10 to 13, 15 and 16 of 2026 and the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court by Judgment dated 22.01.2026 observed that impleading petitions filed by 10/13 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis some of the applicants, which were pending on the date of pendency of the appeal have to be impleaded, therefore, considering the above said facts and taking note of the fact that the applicants are also to be heard, in order to avoid multiplicity of the proceedings and to get valid and binding decree, it is appropriate to allow these applications and by allowing these applications, no prejudice would be caused to the other side. Therefore these applications are liable to be allowed. Accordingly, the applications are allowed (i) Applicants in Application Nos.6433 to 6456 of 2025 are ordered to be impleaded as Defendants 4 to 56 in C.S.No.311 of 2025 and Respondents 4 to 56 in O.A.Nos.1204, 1205 and 1220 of 2025 and A.Nos.6396 to 6398 and 6432 of 2025 and O.A.No.118 of 2026; (ii) Applicants in Application Nos.6459 to 6478 of 2025 are ordered to be impleaded as Defendants 57 to 93 in C.S.No.311 of 2025 and Applicants in Application Nos. 6459 to…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 12-02-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P. DHANABAL
A.Nos.6433 to 6456, 6459 to 6465 to 6478 of 2025 &
A Nos.19, 20, 221, 223 to 252 and 299 of 2026 in
C.S.No.311 of 2025
1. P.Karunanidhi
2. M.Deva Irrakkam
Applicants in A.No.6433 of 2025
1. S.Arul Mayer
2. C.Samuel Asariya Stephen
Applicants in A.No.6434 of 2025
1. S.P.A.Jebadurai
2. P.Jefferson Samuelraj
Applicants in A.No.6435 of 2025
1. S.Gnanasteen
2. S.Peter Thanasingh
3. P.Jeyakumar
Applicants in A.No.6436 of 2025
1. P.Janiel Solomon Maniraj
2. Anthireya Anandaraj
Applicants in A.No.6437 of 2025
1. S.Alexander Albert
2. S.Saint Ravi Rajan
Applicants in A.No.6438 of 2025
1. P.Thanasingh
2. E.Dinesh Edison
Applicants in A.No.6439 of 2025
1. S.Maniraj
2. L.Christopher
Applicants in A.No.6440 of 2025
1. S.T.Chellapandian
Applicants in A.No.6441 of 2025
1/13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2. S.Gnanaraj Daniel
3. A.Prabakaran
4. J.Navin Joshua
1. L.Thanasingh
2. B.Thanasekaran
3. A.Stephen Jebaraj
Applicants in A.No.6442 of 2025
1. D.Dharma Nesa Selvin
2. S.Kingsly Paulraj
Applicants in A.No.6443 of 2025
1. P.Kirubairaj
2. J.Abinaya
Applicants in A.No.6444 of 2025
1. V.Stephen
2. Sudha Udayakumar
Applicants in A.No.6445 of 2025
1. A.Johnsingh
2. D.Moses Anthony
3. I.Thanaraj
Applicants in A.No.6446 of 2025
1. Y.Koilraj
2. A.Ponpandi
Applicants in A.No.6447 of 2025
1. R.Lavey Ashok Sunderraj
2. Rajasingh Solomon
Applicants in A.No.6448 of 2025
1. P.Franklin Asaf Jebaraj
Applicants in A.No.6449 of 2025
1. D.Gnana Sundar
2. D.Inbaraj
3. M.Stephen
Applicants in A.No.6450 of 2025
1. A.Archibal Johnson
2. Jebin James Kirubaz B.
Applicants in A.No.6451 of 2025
1. G.James
2/13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2. S.Jacob Raja
3. N.Raja Durai
Applicants in A.No.6452 of 2025
1. A.Abel Vijay
2. K.Thangaraj
Applicants in A.No.6453 of 2025
1. J.Dhinakaran
2. L.Gnanam
Applicants in A.No.6454 of 2025
1. T.Augustin
2. S.K.Samuel Raj
Applicants in A.No.6455 of 2025
1. D.Mohan Arumainayagam
Applicant in A.No.6456 of 2025
1.S.Savan
Applicant in A.No.6459 of 2025
1. S.D.Prabhakar
Applicant in A.No.6460 of 2025
1. P.Daniel Jebasingh
Applicant in A.No.6461 of 2025
1. Kurusmuthu
Applicant in A.No.6462 of 2025
1. P.Dhas
Applicant in A.No.6463 of 2025
1. V.Beulah Rathinam
2. S.Jeberson Arun
3. P.Jebamani
Applicants in A.No.6464 of 2025
1.S.Pavul Sitha Selvin
2. S.Koilraj John
Applicants in A.No.6465 of 2025
1.D.Ebenezer Mangalaraj
Applicant in A.No.6466 of 2025
1. A.Christopher
2. F.Uthangan Franklin
3. V.Sekar
Applicants in A.No.6467 of 2025
1.Rev.P.J.Groves Barnabas
Applicant in A.No.6468 of 2025
1. M.Mallsornapandian
2. M.Thanga Bharath Alex
3/13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
3. P.Suganthi
Applicants in A.No.6469 of 2025
1. J.Rajkumar
2. J.Jackresan
Applicants in A.No.6470 of 2025
1. T.Jeyakumar
2. C.Nelson Durai Raj
Applicants in A.No.6471 of 2025
1. P.Alayamani
2. N.Jeyakumar Santhosh
Applicants in A.No.6472 of 2025
1. G.Jeyapaul
2. D.Rajmohan
Applicants in A.No.6473 of 2025
1. M.Yesuvadian
2. J.Edwin Christopher
Applicants in A.No.6474 of 2025
1. A.Subash
2. D.Sathiyakumar
3. C.Justin Gnanadurai
Applicants in A.No.6475 of 2025
1. S.Bercy Sundar
2. T.Robins Stephen Prakash
3. A.S.Appadurai
Applicants in A.No.6476 of 2025
1. K.Aaron
2. S.Jeyasingh
Applicants in A.No.6477 of 2025
1. J.Jebachandran
Applicant in A.No.6478 of 2025
1.A.Ponraj
Applicant in A.No.19 of 2026
1. K.R.Amalraj Kumar
Applicant in A.No.20 of 2026
1. S.Elizabeth
Applicant in A.No.221 of 2026
1. J.Jayajothi Koilraj
Applicant in A.No.223 of 2026
1. Grace Jebaraj
Applicant in A.No.224 of 2026
1. J.Blesson
Applicant in A.No.225 of 2026
4/13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
1. Thanam Saral Kanagamani Jeyeraj
Applicant in A.No.226 of 2026
1. H.Evans Devanesam
Applicant in A.No.227 of 2026
1. V.Vijin Thiruthuvaraj
Applicant in A.No.228 of 2026
1. E.Chitranand Jesudas
Applicant in A.No.229 of 2026
1. J.Jayakar
Applicant in A.No.230 of 2026
1. A.Issac
Applicant in A.No.231 of 2026
1. D.Jebathangam
Applicant in A.No.232 of 2026
1. Anand Anburaj
Applicant in A.No.233 of 2026
1.Sheeba Balasingh
Applicant in A.No.234 of 2026
1. Annie Pushpa
Applicant in A.No.235 of 2026
1.S.Ponraj
Applicant in A.No.236 of 2026
1.Anburaj Solomon
Applicant in A.No.237 of 2026
1. A.Dharmam Moses
Applicant in A.No.238 of 2026
1. T.Suresh Arul
Applicant in A.No.239 of 2026
1. J.Balasundar Manoj Kumar
Applicant in A.No.240 of 2026
1. K.Dhanasingh
Applicant in A.No.241 of 2026
1. D.Jeyabal Abraham
Applicant in A.No.242 of 2026
1. P.Jeya Rathish
Applicant in A.No.243 of 2026
1. J.Justus Rathish
Applicant in A.No.244 of 2026
1. M.Jolly
Applicant in A.No.245 of 2026
5/13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
1. D.Samuel
Applicant in A.No.246 of 2026
1. J.Moses Rajakumar
Applicant in A.No.247 of 2026
1. P.Jeyachandran
Applicant in A.No.248 of 2026
1. Jeyarani
Applicant in A.No.249 of 2026
1. Solomon Raj
Applicant in A.No.250 of 2026
1. M.Samuvel Selvin
Applicant in A.No.251 of 2026
1. Barnabas Devasuthan. H
Applicant in A.No.252 of 2026
1. M.Koilraj
2. D.Devaraj Chelliah
Applicants in A.No.299 of 2026
Vs
1. Jeyaratchakar C
Diocese Council Member
Mannarayanthattu Pastorate
CSI Thoothukudi – Nazareth Diocese
No.15G, Toovipuram 1st Street,
Thoothukudi
2. Rev.Jebakumar Jolly Jeremiah
Bishop Robert Caldwelll Church Council &
Pastorate Chairman, Cladwell Colony,
CSI Thoothukudi – Nazareth Diocese
No.34A, Mission Kovil Street,
Madathuvilai, Arumagneri, Thoothukudi Dist.
3. Church of South India
rep. By its General Secretary,
CSI Synod Secretariat, CSI Centre,
6/13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
No.5, Whites Road, Royapettah,
Chennai – 600 014
4. Moderator Commissary / Bishop In-charge,
The CSI Thoothukudi – Bazareth Diocese,
100 Beach Road,
Caldwell School Campus
Thookudi – 628 001
5. The Administrator,
The CSI Thoothukudi Nazareth Diocese,
100 Beach Road, Caldwell School Campus,
Thoothukudi – 628 001
Respondents
A.Nos.
6433 to 6456, 6459 to
6465 to 6478 of 2025 &
A. Nos.19, 20, 221, 223
to 252 and 299 of 2026
Prayer in all the Applications except A.No.6466 of 2025 :
Applications filed under Order XIV Rule 8 of Original Side Rules r/w Order 1
Rule 10(2) CPC r/w Section 152 CPC to implead as defendants in C.S.No.311 of 2025
consequently as respondents in all Applications in C.S.No.311 of 2025.
Prayer A.No.6466 of 2025 :
Application filed under Order XIV Rule 8 of Original Side Rules r/w Order 1 Rule
10(2) CPC to implead as defendant in the C.S.No.311 of 2025.
For Applicant(s) in
Mr.V.Raghavachari,
A.Nos.6464 to 6478 of
Senior Counsel for
2025 & A.Nos.6448 to
M/s Kingsly Solomon
6455 of 2025; 6433 and
6434 of 2025 &
A.No.299 of 2026:
For Applicants in
A.Nos.6459 of 2025 to
6463 of 2025 ; 19 and
20 of 2026; A.Nos.221,
223 to 252 of 2026
Mr.Vinet Subramani
7/13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
For Applicants in
A.Nos.6439 to 6042 of
Ms.J.Johnsy Greeta
For Applicants in
A.Nos.6435 to 3438 of
Mr.S.Thankasivan for
Ms.M.Akila
For Applicant in
A.No.6456 of 2025
Mr.Thankasivam for
Mr.Jebaselvan Newman
For Applicant in
A.No.6466 of 2025
Mr.D.Ebenezer Mangalaraj
For Applicants in
A.Nos.6443 to 6466 of
Ms.N.Vijayamalathi
COMMON
ORDER
These Applications have been filed by the applicants to implead them as
defendants in the Main Suit in C.S.No.311 of 2025. Since all the applicants have filed
separate applications to implead them as parties in the main suits, all the applications
are taken up together and a common order is passed.
2. According to the applicants, they are the members of various Church CSI
Thoothukudi Nazareth Diocese of South India. The respondents 1 and 2, being the
plaintiffs have filed a suit in C.S.No.311 of 2025 to declare the elections conducted by
the 3rd defendant herein at various levels on various dates on 09.11.2025, 15.11.2025,
8/13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
and 22.11.2025 in respect of CSI TND as null and void; permanent injunction
restraining the 3rd defendant from conducting the election of CSI Thoothukudi
Nazareth Diocese scheduled to be held on 13.12.2025, 30.12.2025 and 31.12.2025
and on any subsequent dates in accordance with 3 rd defendant’s fresh election
mandate dated 31.10.2025; mandatory injunction to recover dues, to continue election
process and prohibit the defaulters and permanent injunction restraining the 3 rd
respondent from allowing defaulters from 2018 to 2024 to participate in the election of
office bearers of CSI TND; The applicants have held various posts in various church
and therefore, they are also proper and necessary parties to the suits and without their
presence, the suits cannot be disposed of, therefore all the applicants have to be
impleaded as necessary parties to the suits.
3. The respondents filed counter denying the averments made in the affidavits
and stated that the same are false. The applicants have made various averments in
respect of erstwhile office bearers, therefore, they ought to have filed separate suits,
but without filing separate suits, now, the applicants have filed these applications only
to delay the proceedings. The elected candidates are not necessarily required to be
impleaded and every elected candidates are party to the proceedings for adjudicating
the issue raised and there is sufficient representation for the Church. Though the
Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in W.A.Nos.3069-3072 of 2025 ordered for status
quo, the 5th respondent not maintained the status quo and proceeded to conduct
9/13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
elections contrary to the orders of the Status quo. These applicants are neither proper
nor necessary parties to the proceedings, therefore, only to delay the proceedings,
these applications have been filed, therefore, the applications are liable to be
dismissed.
4.Heard the learned counsel on either side and perused the documents placed
on record.
5. These applications have been filed by the applicants, who are members of
the various church and erst while office bearers of the church - CSI ThoothukudiNazareth Diocese and the respondents / plaintiffs filed the suits challenging the
election process. According to the applicants, they are also proper and necessary
parties because the applicants have also held various posts on various occasions in
various places, therefore, they are also proper and necessary parties to the suit.
thereby the applicants are also proper and necessary parties to the suits.
6. Already this Court passed passed an order of Interim Injunction in Original
Application No.1204 of 2025 in C.S.No.311 of 2025 dated 26.12.2025 and same was
challenged by way of Original Side Appeals before the Hon’ble Division Bench of this
Court in O.S.A.Nos.10 to 13, 15 and 16 of 2026 and the Hon’ble Division Bench of
this Court by Judgment dated 22.01.2026 observed that impleading petitions filed by
10/13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
some of the applicants, which were pending on the date of pendency of the appeal
have to be impleaded, therefore, considering the above said facts and taking note of
the fact that the applicants are also to be heard, in order to avoid multiplicity of the
proceedings and to get valid and binding decree, it is appropriate to allow these
applications and by allowing these applications, no prejudice would be caused to the
other side. Therefore these applications are liable to be allowed.
Accordingly, the applications are allowed
(i) Applicants in Application Nos.6433 to 6456 of 2025
are ordered to be
impleaded as Defendants 4 to 56 in C.S.No.311 of 2025 and Respondents 4 to 56 in
O.A.Nos.1204, 1205 and 1220 of 2025 and A.Nos.6396 to 6398 and 6432 of 2025 and
O.A.No.118 of 2026;
(ii) Applicants in Application Nos.6459 to 6478 of 2025 are ordered to be
impleaded as Defendants 57 to 93 in C.S.No.311 of 2025 and Applicants in
Application Nos. 6459 to 6465 and 6467 to 6478 of 2025 are ordered to be impleaded
as Respondents 57 to 92 in O.A.Nos.1204, 1205 and 1220 of 2025 and A.Nos.6396
to 6398 and 6432 of 2025 and O.A.No.118 of 2026;
(iii) Applicants in Application Nos.19, 20, 221, 223 to 252 and 299 of 2026 are
ordered to be impleaded as Defendants 94 to 128 in C.S.No.311 of 2025 and
11/13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Respondents 93 to 127 in O.A.Nos.1204, 1205 and 1220 of 2025 and A.Nos. 6396 to
6398 and 6432 of 2025 and O.A.No.118 of 2026;
Registry is directed to carry out necessary amendment and post the matter on
18.02.2026.
12.02.2026
ssd
12/13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
P. DHANABAL, J.,
ssd
A.Nos.6433 to 6456, 6459 to 6465 to 6478 of 2025 &
A Nos.19, 20, 221, 223 to 252 and 299 of 2026 in
C.S.No.311 of 2025
12.02.2026
13/13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review