Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE MARY JOSEPH
FRIDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF MAY 2023 / 29TH VAISAKHA, 1945
MACA NO. 443 OF 2013
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 14.08.2012 IN OP(MV) 843/2009 OF MOTOR
ACCIDENTS CLAIMS TRIBUNAL,KOLLAM
APPELLANT/1ST RESPONDENT:
P.BEEMA
6/56 A,MANDALAKSHIKONAM,
NEAR SALVATION ARMY CHURCH,
KULASEKHARAM.P.O,KANYAKUMARI,TAMIL NADU.
BY ADV SRI.PIRAPPANCODE V.S.SUDHIR
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONER & RESPONDENTS 2 & 3:
ADDL.R4
TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD,
REPRESENTED BY P.R.ANITHA,
SECRETARY,TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD,
NANTHANCODE,THIRUVANANTHAPURAM - 695121
ABU MUHAMMED,
S/O.MUHAMMEDALI,KALLUVETTANKUZHIVILA,
NEAR KULASEKHARAMANGALAM MISSION HOSPITAL,
TIRUVATTAN VILLAGE,KALKULAM,KANYAKUMARI-629161
THE ICICI LAMBARD GENERAL INSURANCE CO,
REPRESENTED BY ITS BRANCH MANAGER, 3RD FLOOR,
KANNANKERI ESTATE,MARINE DRIVE,KOCHI.- 682030.
ADDL. RESPONDENT NO. 4 IMPLEADED
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED,
DIVISIONAL OFFICE NO.1, CWC BUILDING, PALAYAM,
LMS COMPOUND, TRIVANDRUM, KERALA - 695 033.
ADDITIONAL RESPONDENT NO.4 IS IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DATED
14/03/2013 IN I.A. 695/13 IN MACA 443/2013.
R1 BY ADV.SMT.A.SREEKALA, SC, TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD
R2 BY ADV.SRI.BRIJESH MOHAN
R3 BY ADV.SRI.R.AJITH KUMAR VARMA
ADDITIIONAL R4 BY ADVS.SRI.P.JACOB MATHEW
SRI.MATHEWS JACOB SR.
SRI.G.SANTHOSH KUMAR (P).
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
03.11.2022, THE COURT ON 19.05.2023 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
M.A.C.A. No. 443 of 2013
-:2:-
MARY JOSEPH, J.
-----------------------M.A.C.A. No. 443 of 2013
-----------------------Dated this the 19th day of May, 2023
JUDGMENT
Appeal on hand is filed by the 1 st
respondent in
O.P.
(MV) No.843/2009 on the files of Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal, Kollam (for short, ‘the Tribunal’)
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties to
this appeal will hereinafter be referred to as the petitioner
and respondents 1 to 3 in accordance with their status in
the Original Petition.
3.
As revealed from the pleadings in the Original
Petition,
petitioner was the owner of a tusker named
Gopalakrishnan. At about 5.30 a.m. on 24.03.2009 while
the
elephant
was
taken
by
its
mahouts
through
Alappuzha-Kollam National Highway a Truck bearing
Registration No.TN-74-V-2449 hit him at Sakthikulangara
due to rash and neglect driving by its driver and thereby
M.A.C.A. No. 443 of 2013
-:3:-
sustained
injuries.
Treatment
was
given
to
it
immediately, but it died at 1.30 p.m. on 26.03.2009.
Alleging negligence on the part of the driver of the Truck
arrayed as the 2nd respondent and claiming a sum of
Rs.70,00,000/- as compensation,
was filed.
the Original Petition
The owner, the driver and the insurer of the
Truck were arrayed in the Original Petition as respondents
1 to 3.
4.
Summons was served on all the respondents,
but respondents 1 and 2, due to their failure to appear
before the court responding to the summons served on
them were declared ex-parte. 3rd respondent had filed
written statement admitting insurance coverage for the
Truck as on date of the motor accident but contending
that the original petition is bad for non-joinder of
necessary parties, that the elephant being insured with
United India Insurance Company Limited, compensation
can be realised from them, that the petitioner is not the
owner of the elephant and against the provisions of law
M.A.C.A. No. 443 of 2013
-:4:-
existing, the elephant was taken on foot through the road,
that the elephant was not properly fed at the relevant
time, that the elephant became weak on account of poor
feeding, that additional premium having not been paid by
the insured of the offending vehicle for having unlimited
coverage, that the elephant falls in the category of third
party property and the coverage for that is limited under
the policy stands issued to Rs.7,50,000/-, that by causing
2nd respondent to drive the Truck without a valid driving
licence, conditions in the policy was violated by the
insured
and
therefore,
the
insurer
is
liable
to
be
exonerated from liability to indemnify the insured.
5.
Evidence adduced by the petitioner consists of
oral evidence tendered by PWs 1 and 2 and documentary
evidence consists of Exts.A1 to A9.
Evidence of the
respondents consists of the oral evidence of RW1 and
Ext.B1.
6.
As per the pleadings in the Original Petition, the
elephant owned by Travancore Dewaswom Board died due
M.A.C.A. No. 443 of 2013
-:5:-
to the motor accident.
A Truck bearing Registration No.
TN-74-V-2449 knocked it at Sakthikulangara while being
taken by its mahouts by foot for a festival through
Alappuzha-Kollam National Highway. Due to the injuries
sustained,
it
died
during
the
course
of
treatment.
Elephant had sustained fractures to both rear limbs as
well as backbone. The injuries were grave in nature and
therefore, the elephant died while undergoing treatment.
7.
The Truck which knocked down the elephant
was established from Exts.A1 to A4 and A6 as driven by
the 2nd respondent in a rash and negligent manner.
8.
The 3rd respondent had raised a contention on
the basis of the elephant health card marked in evidence
as Ext.A8 that the temperament history of the elephant
was very poor and that has also contributed to the motor
accident.
9.
The postmortem examination of the elephant
was held and the report obtained was marked in evidence
as Ext.A5. Antemortem injuries reported in Ext.A5 include
M.A.C.A. No. 443 of 2013
-:6:-
fracture of pubis, vertebrae and ribs.
organs,
lumbosacral
damaged considerably.
regions
and
Kidney, visceral
spinal
cord
were
Cause of death was reported in
Ext.A5 as renal failure.
PW1 and PW2 were also
categorically stated that the death of the elephant was
due to the injuries sustained in the motor accident.
Therefore, this Court has to maintain the finding of the
Tribunal that the elephant died on account of the injuries
sustained by it in the motor accident itself.
10.
The Tribunal awarded Rs.36,02,000/- as the
compensation to the owner of the elephant on account of
the death of the elephant. The owner of the elephant has
not come up challenging the quantum of compensation
stands awarded. The owner of the Truck alone challenged
the quantum stands awarded as compensation
for the
reason
adduce
mainly
that
the
petitioner
failed
to
evidence to establish the market value of the elephant as
Rs.35 lakhs.
According to the learned counsel, the
Tribunal has arrived at the market value of the elephant
M.A.C.A. No. 443 of 2013
-:7:-
from Ext.B1 wherein the elephant stands insured for Rs.35
lakhs.
11.
True that the petitioner failed to adduce any
evidence to establish the market value of the elephant as
on date of the accident.
But the market value of the
elephant was shown in Ext.B1 policy as Rs.35 lakhs. The
elephant was insured with the insurer to cover the risk of
an elephant while showing its value as Rs.35 lakhs.
Therefore, the Tribunal cannot be found fault with in
considering the market value of the elephant as Rs.35 lakhs
and in awarding the same as compensation for the loss
caused to its owner on account of its death. Apart from
Rs.35 lakhs, the Tribunal has also awarded Rs.1,01,031/as compensation towards treatment expenses, stands
established by the medical bills.
The challenge raised
against the quantum of compensation is repelled for the
reason.
12. According to the petitioner, she was not the
registered owner of the Truck as on date of the motor
M.A.C.A. No. 443 of 2013
-:8:-
accident. According to her, the vehicle was sold by her to
one
Mr.Maheen
on
19.03.2009
and
the
change
of
ownership has also been incorporated in the Certificate of
Registration of the vehicle.
The Certificate of Insurance
was also issued in favour of the transferee of the vehicle.
According to her, such being the scenario, liability ought
not to have been fastened by the Tribunal on her.
According to her 2nd respondent was not the driver
employed by her as on date of the motor accident and
therefore, the Tribunal has gone wrong in fixing liability
upon her to pay the compensation arrived at, in favour of
the petitioner.
13.
Despite raising contentions as above, the 1st
respondent failed to produce the certificate of registration
of the offending vehicle as well as the certificate of
insurance issued for it, wherein change of name of the
transferee has been incorporated.
It is found that the
extract taken from the Website VAHAN – National Register
e-Services vahan.nic.in/nr services, is produced in the
M.A.C.A. No. 443 of 2013
-:9:-
appeal on hand with a view to establish that application
has been filed for transfer of woenrship of the vehicle in
favour of Mr.Maheen and the required fees for change of
permit and ownership in latter’s name were paid.
It is
found that a petition seeking to receive those in evidence
additionally is not filed.
Moreover, the extract produced
now will not help the 1 st respondent to establish that
registered ownership and permit of the offending vehicle
had already been transferred in the name of Mr.Maheen.
Therefore, the contention of the 1st respondent that the
Tribunal has wrongly fixed liability upon her to pay the
balance compensation is devoid of any basis. It appears
that the 1st respondent herself is the registered owner of
the vehicle at the relevant time and only the registered
owner
can
be
fastened
with
the
liability
to
pay
compensation.
14.
According to her, the offending Truck has
insurance coverage under the policy stands issued and the
liability is unlimited.
According to her the Tribunal
M.A.C.A. No. 443 of 2013
-:10:-
misconstrued the terms of Ext.B1 and thereby made the
3rd respondent liable to pay Rs.7,50,000/- towards the
compensation arrived at. According to her under Ext.B1,
the liability of the insured, towards third parties being
limited, the petitioner is not entitled to get the entire
compensation as arrived at and awarded by the Tribunal.
15.
It is further contended that the elephant was
insured by the petitioner with United India Insurance
Company Limited and therefore, compensation could have
been obtained from it.
But, the petitioner failed to
implead the insurer of the elephant in the Original
Petition.
According to her, the attempt of the petitioner
was to claim compensation from the insurer of the
elephant later and thus to be benefited twice.
He thus
canvassed for dismissal of the Original Petition for
non-joinder of necessary parties viz. the insurer of the
elephant as well as the transferee of the vehicle.
16. During the pendency of the appeal on hand, the
insurer of the elephant was also impleaded as additional
M.A.C.A. No. 443 of 2013
-:11:-
4th respondent. There is no merit in the contentions raised
by the learned counsel for the respondent that the
petitioner has to seek compensation from the insurer, in
view of coverage of liability under the policy issued by
additional 4th respondent.
The offending vehicle stands
insured with the 3rd respondent. Therefore, the petitioner
can opt to seek compensation from 3 rd respondent or
additional
4th
respondent
now
got
impleaded,
since
premium has been collected by both insurers to cover the
risk of the elephant under the cover, own damages as well
as third party property damages. Petitioner can opt one
or both. Premium having been collected by the respective
insurers, they cannot seek for exemption from liability.
The contention raised by the 1st respondent is repelled for
the above reason.
17. It is found from Ext.B1 policy that premium has
been collected to cover property damages, but the liability
to indemnify the insured stands limited to Rs.7,50,000/-.
Accordingly the 3rd respondent was fastened by the
M.A.C.A. No. 443 of 2013
-:12:-
Tribunal with liability to pay Rs.7,50,000/-.
The total
compensation stands awarded by the Tribunal being
Rs.36,01,031/- rounded off to Rs.36,02,000/-, the
1 st
and 2nd respondents were directed to pay the balance
amount.
This Court finds no reason to interfere with the
impugned award. MACA fails for the reasons and is dismissed.
Sd/-
MJL
MARY JOSEPH,
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review