The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. In view of the foregoing discussion, in the considered opinion of this Court, it is not proved that claimants have falsely implicated the offending vehicle only for seeking compensation in the case. Therefore, in the considered opinion of this Court, Tribunal has rightly 12:15:37 PM allowed the claim petition and fastened the liability to pay compensation on the insurance company.
12. The appeal being devoid of merit is hereby dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT
OF MADHYA
PRADESH
AT INDOR E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE HIRDESH
ON THE 29 th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. APPEAL No. 5381 of 2023
BETWEEN:ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED THROUGH 07 RACE
COURSE ROAD, 4TH FLOOR BUILDING INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(SHRI AKSHANSH MEHRA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT) .
AND
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
1.
SMT KALA BAI AUOLIYAWAT W/O LATE DINESH
AUOLIYAWAT, AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
NOTHING HOME NO. 245 VILLAGE CHAPLANA TEHSIL
MANASA DISTRICT NEEMUCH PRESENT R/O MANPASAND
COLONY P.S. AERODRUM DISTRICT INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
MUSKAN D/O LATE DINESH AUOLIYAWAT THROUGH LRS
KALA BAI AUOLIYAWAT W/O LATE DINESH AUOLIYAWAT,
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS, OCCUPATION: NOTHING HOME NO.
245, CHAPLANA, TEH. MANASA, DIST. NEEMUCH PRESENT
MANPASAND COLONY, P.S. AERODRUM INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
3.
PAYAL D/O LATE DINESH AUOLIYAWAT THROUGH LRS
SMT. KLA BAI AUOLIYAWAT W/O LATE DINESH
AUOLIYAWAT, AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
NOTHING HOME NO. 245, CHAPLANA, TEH. MANASA, DIST.
NEEMUCH PRESENT MANPASAND COLONY, P.S. AERODRUM
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
NEETU D/O LATE DINESH AUOLIYAWAT THROUGH LRS
KLA BAI W/O LATE DINESH AUOLIYAWAT, AGED ABOUT 33
YEARS, OCCUPATION: NOTHING HOME NO. 245, VILLAGE
CHAPLANA, TEH. MANASA, DIST. NEEMUCH PRESENT
MANPASAND COLONY, P.S. AERODRUM INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
5.
KUNWARI BAI W/O BHERULAL AUOLIYAWAT, AGED ABOUT
52 YEARS, OCCUPATION: STUDENT HOME NO. 245 VILLAGE
CHAPLANA TEHSIL MANASA DISTRICT NEEMUCH PRESENT
R/O MANPASAND COLONY P.S. AERODRUM DISTRICT
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
6.
BHERULAL S/O LAKSHMAN AUOLIYAWAT, AGED ABOUT 57
YEARS, OCCUPATION: NOTHING HOME NO. 245, VILLAGE
CHAPLANA, TEH. MANASA, DIST. NEEMUCH PRESENT
MANPASAND COLONY, P.S. AERODRUM INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
7.
SUMIT URF SANDEEP S/O LATE DINESH AUOLIYAWAT
THROUGH LRS KLA BAI AUOLIYAWAT W/O LATE DINESH
AUOLIYAWAT, AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
NOTHING HOME NO. 245 VILLAGE CHAPLANA TEHSIL
MANASA DISTRICT NEEMUCH PRESENT R/O MANPASAND
COLONY P.S. AERODRUM DISTRICT INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
8.
BABU S/O MR. JORJE 32B, AASHIYANA DHARA NAKA MAHU,
SHRIRAM NAGAR COLONY, MAHU, INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
9.
ANITA BABU JORJE 32-B AASHIYANA DHARA NAKA MAHU,
SHRIRAM NAGAR COLONY, MAHU INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI GOVIND MEENA & SHRI JM POONEGAR, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR
THE RESPONDENTS NO.1, 2, 4, 5, 6 & 7.
SHRI KAUSHAL SISODIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENTS
NO.8 & 9.
This appeal coming on for orders this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
This appeal by the Insurance Company under section 173(1) of
the Motor Vehicles Act is arising out of the award dated 08.08.2023
passed by IInd MACT, Indore in Claim Case No.1608/2019 seeking
exoneration from the liability to pay compensation/reduction in the
compensation amount as awarded by the Tribunal.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that on 22.04.2019 when deceased
Dinesh was going to Lekar Chinar park with his friend Sourabh Jain
on a motor cycle bearing registration no.MP-09-VP-0648 and when
they reached Eicher bridge Mhow- Neemuch Road, the offending
vehicle bearing registration no.MP09-CN-2719 which was driven
rashly and negligently came and hit the motorcycle due to which
Dinesh sustained grievous injuries and succumbed to death.
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
3.
Before the Tribunal respondents filed their written statement
and denied all the averments made in the claim petition. On the
basis of the pleadings Tribunal framed issues and after taking
evidence of the parties allowed the claim petition and awarded a sum
of Rs.41,74,632/- as compensation in favour of the claims and
against the appellant/insurance company.
4.
Being aggrieved by the impugned award, appellant/Insurance
Company has filed this appeal by submitting that Tribunal has
grossly erred in not considering that the offending vehicle has been
falsely implicated in the accident. The Tribunal has grossly erred in
not considering the testimony of driver of the offending vehicle in
which he has clearly stated that on 31.01.2019 he has gone along
with his vehicle from Indore to Betma church and when he was
returning his vehicle got broke down due to which he had to carry
his car to show room and he had not caused any accident on the said
date. He further stated that he had also made a complaint to the
police authorities regarding false implication of his vehicle. The
delay in filing the FIR regarding the accident has also not been
properly explained by the claimants, hence prayed for setting aside
the impugned award exonerating the insurance company from the
liability to pay the compensation awarded by the Tribunal.
5.
On the other hand, respondents/claimants have submitted that
Tribunal has rightly passed the award which does not call for any
interference by this court in appeal and prays for dismissal of the
appeal.
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
6.
Learned counsel for the appellant/Insurance Company has
submitted that the offending vehicle has been falsely implicated in
the accident only for the purpose of compensation. The delay in
lodging the FIR has also not been properly explained by the
claimants. The Tribunal has committed an error in not believing the
evidence of the driver of the offending vehicle. Considering the
document Ex.P/3, FIR in which it was mentioned that after enquiring
the Marg intimation dated 11.02.2019 the FIR was lodged. The
accident occurred on 30.01.2019 and FIR was lodged on 06.02.2019.
It is true that according to Ex.P/3 FIR was lodged on 06.02.2019 but
perusal of the record it was found that police after enquiring the
Marg intimation the FIR was lodged.
7.
It is settled law that delay in filing the FIR is not fatal either in
criminal case or in claim case provided that sufficient and cogent
reason for delay in filing the FIR is given. The Apex Court in the
case of Ravi vs. Badrinarayan and others – AIR 2011 SC 1226 in
para 20 & 21 has held as under:
[20] It is well-settled that delay in lodging FIR cannot be a
ground to doubt the claimant's case. Knowing the Indian
conditions as they are, we cannot expect a common man to first
rush to the Police Station immediately after an accident. Human
nature and family responsibilities occupy the mind of kith and
kin to such an extent that they give more importance to get the
victim treated rather than to rush to the Police Station. Under
such circumstances, they are not expected to act mechanically
with promptitude in lodging the FIR with the Police. Delay in
lodging the FIR thus, cannot be the ground to deny justice to the
victim. In cases of delay, the courts are required to examine the
evidence with a closer scrutiny and in doing so; the contents of
the FIR should also be scrutinized more carefully. If court finds
that there is no indication of fabrication or it has not been
concocted or engineered to implicate innocent persons then,
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
even if there is a delay in lodging the FIR, the claim case cannot
be dismissed merely on that ground.
[21] The purpose of lodging the FIR in such type of cases is
primarily to intimate the police to initiate investigation of
criminal offences. Lodging of FIR certainly proves factum of
accident so that the victim is able to lodge a case for
compensation but delay in doing so cannot be the main ground
for rejecting the claim petition. In other words, although lodging
of FIR is vital in deciding motor accident claim cases, delay in
lodging the same should not be treated as fatal for such
proceedings, if claimant has been able to demonstrate
satisfactory and cogent reasons for it. There could be variety of
reasons in genuine cases for delayed lodgment of FIR. Unless
kith and kin of the victim are able to regain a certain level of
tranquility of mind and are composed to lodge it, even if, there
is delay, the same deserves to be condoned. In such
circumstances, the authenticity of the FIR assumes much more
significance than delay in lodging thereof supported by cogent
reasons.
8.
In the present case perusal of the criminal case it is found that
accident occurred on 30.01.2019 and deceased died on the same date
and post-mortem was conducted on 31.01.2019.
On perusal of
Ex.P/3 it is found that an information was sent to the police station
that dead body of Dinesh who died in a road accident came for postmortem, so according to the criminal record information regarding
accident and death of Dinesh was given to the police from the
hospital and police enquired the matter and thereafter police
registered the case. After registration of the case police investigated
the matter and after due investigation police found the driver of the
offending vehicle caused the accident and after investigation charge
sheet has been filed before the competent Magistrate for trial.
Therefore, the delay in filing the FIR was sufficiently explained, hence
the argument canvassed by the learned counsel for the insurance
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
company that the delay in registration of the FIR has not been
explained has no substance.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellant has further submitted that
driver of the offending vehicle came before the Tribunal and stated that
he had not committed any accident and Tribunal had committed error
in not believing his evidence. Considering the evidence of the driver
of the offending vehicle it was found that he stated in evidence that he
made a complaint before the higher authorities of the police
department that his vehicle was falsely implicated in the accident but
he has unable to produce any document which show that he filed a
complaint before the higher authorities of the police department. He
further admitted that he faced a criminal trial under section 304A of the
IPC before the competent Magistrate and he also admitted that he was
unable to produce any postal receipt by which he had sent the
complaint to the higher authorities of the police department.
So
considering the evidence of the driver of the offending vehicle, in the
considered opinion of this Court, Tribunal has rightly disbelieved the
evidence of the driver of the offending vehicle.
10.
Considering the evidence of AW/4 Pappulal it was found that he
was eye witness and he was intact in his cross examination, therefore,
there is no reason to disbelieve him and criminal document also
supports his evidence and evidence of the driver of the offending
vehicle is not reliable.
11.
In view of the foregoing discussion, in the considered opinion of
this Court, it is not proved that claimants have falsely implicated the
offending vehicle only for seeking compensation in the case.
Therefore, in the considered opinion of this Court, Tribunal has rightly
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
allowed the claim petition and fastened the liability to pay
compensation on the insurance company.
12.
The appeal being devoid of merit is hereby dismissed.
(HIRDESH)
JUDGE
hk/
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review