The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused material on record, I am of the considered opinion that the appeal of the Insurance Company, which is devoid of any merit, deserves to be dismissed. The only plea taken by Mr. Amrit Sarin, leaned counsel for the Insurance Company, to assail the award is that, though, the respondent-claimant has proved the income of the deceased by placing on record and proving the Income Tax Return for the relevant year, yet he failed to demonstrate the source of income earned by the deceased. The plea taken is without substance and cannot be accepted.
12. Neither this court hearing appeal nor the tribunal could have gone into the source of income of the deceased, which was duly recorded in the ITR filed by her with the Income Tax authorities. That apart, there is ample evidence on record to show that she was a partner in a business firm by the name of M/s Chander Parkash Prem Kumar and had been earning income from the aforesaid business. There is no evidence in rebuttal led by the Insurance Company to doubt the correctness of the income or Income Tax Return submitted by respondent-claimant. We, however, find substance in the submission of Mr. Mehta, learned counsel appearing for the respondent-claimant, that the Tribunal has failed to take into consideration the actual income of the deceased at the time of accident. The Tribunal has also not applied the relevant multiplier to workout fair and just compensation, which in the instant case is 9. Amount granted on account of consortium is also required to be modified in terms of the National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi and others.
13. For all these reasons, I hold the respondent-claimant entitled to following amount of compensation:- i) Taking the annual income of the deceased as Rs.2,71,747/-, making an addition of 10% in terms of National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi and others, (2017) 16 SCC 680, annual loss of comes to (2,71,747 + 27,175)=Rs.2,98,922. Deducting 50% towards her personal expenses (deceased has left behind only one dependent), the total annual loss of income would be Rs.1,49,461.00. Applying the multiplier of 9, as per Sarla Verma and others v. Delhi Transport Corp. and anr (2009) 6 SCC 121, the total loss of income comes to (1,49,461 x 9) Rs.13,45,149/-. Under conventional heads, the claimant shall be entitled to i) Funeral expenses ii) Loss of consortium : : Total : 15,000/Rs.40,000/Rs.14,00,149/- The aforesaid amount minus the amount already received shall become payable to the respondent No.1-claimant with interest @ 7.5% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition till its realization. The Insurance Company shall satisfy the modified award and deposit the balance amount before the Registry of this Court. The Registry shall release the amount in terms of the modified award in favour of the claimant after verification and identification. The award passed by the tribunal is modified to the aforesaid extent and the appeal of the respondent-claimant shall stand dispose…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
MA No.500/2009
c/w
MA No.516/2009
Reserved on: 30.01.2026
Pronounced on: 13.02.2026
Uploaded on: 13.02.2026
MA No.500/2009
The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
Divisional Office No.1, Town Hall Building, Jammu
Through its Sr. Divisional Manager, Dr. R.K.Dupper, Age 48 years
....Appellant(s)
Through:- Mr. Amrit Sarin, Advocate
Versus
1.
Prem Gupta S/o Late Chander Parkash Gupta
R/o 51 C/C Gandhi Nagar, Jammu
2.
Madan Lal S/o Sardari Lal Gupta
R/o H.No.391, Gandhi Nagar, Jammu
3.
Kulvinder Singh S/o Santokh Singh
R/o Sarore Adda, Samba
Sukhvinder Singh @ Buntoo S/o Dhian Singh
Caste Labana Sikh r/o Sunjwan, Vijaypur,
Tehsil and District Samba
4.
...Respondent(s)
5.
The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.
B.O. College Road, Kathua Through I/C
Branch Manager (Insurer of Bus No.JK08-7129).
….Proforma respondent(s)
Through:- Mr. Raghu Mehta, Advocate for R-1
MA No.516/2009
MA Nos.500/2009 & 516/2009
Prem Gupta S/o Late Chander Parkash Gupta
R/o 51 C/C Gandhi Nagar, Jammu
....Appellant(s)
Through:- Mr. Raghu Mehta, Advocate
Versus
The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
B.O. Canal Road, Jammu through its I/C Branch Manager
(Insurer of Bus No.JK02X-1731)
2.
Madan Lal S/o Sardari Lal Gupta
R/o H.No.391, Gandhi Nagar, Jammu
(Owner of the Bus No.JK02X-1731)
3.
Kulvinder Singh S/o Santokh Singh
R/o Sarore Adda, Samba District samba
(Owner of Bus No.JK02X-1731)
4.
Sukhvinder Singh @ Buntoo S/o Dhian Singh
Caste Labana Sikh r/o Sunjwan, Vijaypur,
Tehsil and District Samba (Driver of the Bus NO.JK02X-1731)
5.
The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.
B.O. College Road, Kathua Through its I/C
Branch Manager (Insurer of Bus No.JK08-7129)
6.
Ravinder Singh S/o Sh. Jagdev Singh R/o Village Billawar,
Tehsil Billawar District Kathua
(Owner of the Bus No.JK02-7129)
Nardev Singh S/o Sh. Isher Singh R/o village Tilla,
Tehsil Billawar District Kathua
(Driver of the Bus No.JK08-71209
...Respondent(s)
7.
Through:- Mr. Amrit Sarin, Advocate for R-1
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
MA No.500/2009
MA Nos.500/2009 & 516/2009
1.
This is an appeal against the award dated 13th August, 2009
passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Jammu [“the
Tribunal”] in file No.707/Claim titled Prem Gupta v. Oriental
Insurance Company Limited and others, whereby the Tribunal
has awarded a compensation of Rs.2,22,024/- minus the interim
compensation, if any received by respondent No.1, along with
interest @ 7.5% per annum and the appellant-Insurance
Company along with respondent No.5-New India Assurance
Company have been directed to satisfy the award. The Oriental
Insurance Company alone has chosen to file appeal whereas
respondent No.5-New India Assurance Company has accepted
the award.
MA No.516/2009
2.
The is an appeal by the claimant-Prem Gupta seeking
enhancement of compensation awarded by the Tribunal, in terms
of the impugned award dated 13.08.2009 passed in file
No.707/Claim titled Prem Gupta v. Oriental Insurance Limited
and others.
3.
Having regard to the fact that both these appeals arise out of an
award dated 13th August, 2009, passed in claim petition titled
Prem Gupta v. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. and others, as
such, are taken up for consideration and disposal together.
MA Nos.500/2009 & 516/2009
Factual Matrix
4.
On 01.11.2007, at about 9 am the deceased Neelam Gupta, the
wife of respondent No.1 (Claimant) along with few others was
travelling in a Maruti Car bearing Registration No.JK02M-0615
from Jammu to Dharmshalla. The deceased along with others
met with an accident near Berero Khad near Barian Camp
Supwal Tehsil and District Samba, when it was crushed between
two offending busses bearing Registration Nos.JK02X-1731 and
JK028-7129, which were coming from opposite direction in high
speed driven by their drivers in rash and negligent manner. The
wife of respondent No.1-claimant died on spot.
5.
With a view to claiming compensation under the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 [“the Act”], respondent No.1 filed a claim petition
before the Tribunal seeking a total compensation of Rs.37 lakh
along with interest @ 12%. The claim petition was inter alia
contested by the appellant-Insurance Company. On the basis of
the pleadings of the parties, following issues were framed in all
the claim petitions arising out of the accident, including the claim
petition under consideration:
“1.
Whether an accident occurred on 1.-11-2007 at Barero
Khad near Baria Camp Supwal Tehsil and District Samba
by involvement of two vehicles No.JK08 7129 and
No.JK02X 1731 being driven in the hands of respective
drivers in which deceased namely Anil Sharma, Neelam
Gupta, N.D.Gupta and Sushil Gupta received fatal injuries?
OPP
MA Nos.500/2009 & 516/2009
6.
2.
If issue No.1 is proved in affirmative, whether petitioners in
each case are entitled to the compensation; if so to what
amount and from whom? OPP
3.
Whether drivers of both vehicles at the time of accident
was not holding valid and effective driving license and
drove the vehicles in contravention of terms and conditions
of policy of insurance, RC, route permit and fitness? OPR 1
and 5
4.
Whether accident has occurred by the contributory
negligence by the drivers of both vehicles, if so how and
what is its effect? OPR 1 & 5
5.
Whether claim petition are bad for misjoinder of parties, if
so how? OPR 5
6.
Whether on the date of accident vehicle No.JK02X 1731
had been transferred by the erstwhile owner, if so how and
what it its effect? OPR 1
7.
Relief. O.P. Parties.”
With a view to discharge the burden of proof, the respondentcomplainant examined himself and Pw-J.S.Kudian, an employee
of the Income Tax Department. On the basis of the evidence that
was led by the parties including respondent No.1 herein, issue
No.1, 3, 4, 5 and 6 have been decided in favour of the claimants
and against the Insurance Companies.
7.
So far as issue No.2 is concerned, which pertains to the
entitlement of the respondent-claimant to compensation, the
Tribunal having considered the statements of claimant-Prem
Gupta and PW-J.S.Kudian, came to the conclusion that the
respondent-claimant had failed to prove the actual income of the
deceased-Neelam Gupta at the time of accident and, accordingly,
fixed Rs.4,000/- per month as notional income of the deceased
MA Nos.500/2009 & 516/2009
and computed the compensation payable to the respondent. The
respondent was held entitled to Rs.2,22,024/- along with interest
@ 7.5% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition
till liquidation.
8.
Insofar as the appeal of the Insurance Company is concerned, I
do not find any substantial ground urged to find fault with the
impugned award passed by the Tribunal.
9.
It is submitted by Mr. Amrit Sarin, learned counsel appearing for
the Insurance-Company, that the Tribunal did not appreciate that
the respondent-claimant had miserably failed to indicate and
demonstrate the source of income, which was reflected in the
income tax return of the deceased for the assessment year 20072008. He, however, did not dispute the amount of compensation
granted on other aspects.
10. Per contra, Mr. Raghu Mehta, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent-claimant, who has also filed a separate appeal, seeks
enhancement of compensation on the ground that respondent
No.1-claimant has sufficiently proved that the annual income of
the deceased in the assessment year 2007-08 was Rs.2,71,747/-,
which was recorded in the Income Tax Return filed by the
deceased and proved before the Tribunal by examining PWJ.S.Kudian, an employee of the Income Tax Department. It is
also the case of the respondent-claimant that while computing
MA Nos.500/2009 & 516/2009
compensation payable to him, the Tribunal did not apply the
correct multiplier, which, in the instant case, was 9 keeping in
view the age of the deceased as 57 years. The enhancement of
compensation is also sought on the ground that having regard to
the age of the deceased, there ought to have been increase in the
income of the deceased on account of future prospects, which in
the instant case would 10% of the annual income.
11. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused material
on record, I am of the considered opinion that the appeal of the
Insurance Company, which is devoid of any merit, deserves to be
dismissed. The only plea taken by Mr. Amrit Sarin, leaned
counsel for the Insurance Company, to assail the award is that,
though, the respondent-claimant has proved the income of the
deceased by placing on record and proving the Income Tax
Return for the relevant year, yet he failed to demonstrate the
source of income earned by the deceased. The plea taken is
without substance and cannot be accepted.
12. Neither this court hearing appeal nor the tribunal could have
gone into the source of income of the deceased, which was duly
recorded in the ITR filed by her with the Income Tax authorities.
That apart, there is ample evidence on record to show that she
was a partner in a business firm by the name of M/s Chander
Parkash Prem Kumar and had been earning income from the
MA Nos.500/2009 & 516/2009
aforesaid business. There is no evidence in rebuttal led by the
Insurance Company to doubt the correctness of the income or
Income Tax Return submitted by respondent-claimant. We,
however, find substance in the submission of Mr. Mehta, learned
counsel appearing for the respondent-claimant, that the Tribunal
has failed to take into consideration the actual income of the
deceased at the time of accident. The Tribunal has also not
applied the relevant multiplier to workout fair and just
compensation, which in the instant case is 9. Amount granted on
account of consortium is also required to be modified in terms of
the National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi and
others.
13. For all these reasons, I hold the respondent-claimant entitled to
following amount of compensation:-
i)
Taking
the
annual
income
of
the
deceased
as
Rs.2,71,747/-, making an addition of 10% in terms of
National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi and
others, (2017) 16 SCC 680, annual loss of comes to
(2,71,747
+
27,175)=Rs.2,98,922.
Deducting
50%
towards her personal expenses (deceased has left behind
only one dependent), the total annual loss of income would
be Rs.1,49,461.00. Applying the multiplier of 9, as per
Sarla Verma and others v. Delhi Transport Corp. and
anr (2009) 6 SCC 121, the total loss of income comes to
(1,49,461 x 9) Rs.13,45,149/-.
Under conventional heads, the claimant shall be entitled to
MA Nos.500/2009 & 516/2009
i)
Funeral expenses
ii)
Loss of consortium :
:
Total :
15,000/Rs.40,000/Rs.14,00,149/-
The aforesaid amount minus the amount already received
shall become payable to the respondent No.1-claimant with
interest @ 7.5% per annum from the date of filing of the claim
petition till its realization. The Insurance Company shall satisfy
the modified award and deposit the balance amount before the
Registry of this Court. The Registry shall release the amount in
terms of the modified award in favour of the claimant after
verification and identification.
The award passed by the tribunal is modified to the
aforesaid extent and the appeal of the respondent-claimant shall
stand disposed of. The appeal of Insurance Company is,
however, dismissed.
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge
JAMMU
13.02.2026
Vinod, Secy
Vinod Kumar
2026.02.18 15:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Whether the order is speaking : Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review