Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Reserved on 14.09.2026
Pronounced on 18.09.2026
Uploaded on: 18.09.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced: Full
Mac App No. 134/2019
c/w
Mac App No. 133/2019
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.
Through: Mr. Amrit Sarin, Adv.
Q
vs
.…. Respondent(s)
Ghulam Nabi Naik and others
Haneefa Begum and others
Through: Mr. T. R. Wani, Adv.
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Through the medium of this judgment, afore-titled two appeals arising out of
a common award passed by Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ramban(for
short the Tribunal) in two claim petitions arising out of same motor vehicular
accident are proposed to be disposed of.
2.
It appears that two separate claims petitions arising out of same road traffic
accident came to be filed by the dependants of deceased Fayaz Ahmed Naik
and deceased Jhangir Alam. While claim petition No. 45 was filed by mother
and sister of deceased Jhangir Alam, the claim petition No. 46 was filed by
the parents of deceased Fayaz Ahmed Naik.
3.
As per the case of the claimants, on 28.06.2014, both the deceased, while
travelling on a motorcycle bearing registration No. JK02AH 0139 from
Ramban towards Dharamkund, on reaching near Sharoor, at a place near
Kanga, their motorcycle was hit by a speeding Tipper bearing registration No.
JK14B 7164, which was coming from opposite direction. As a result of this
accident, both the deceased suffered fatal injuries leading to their death. FIR
No. 8/2014 for offences under sections 279 and 304-A RPC was registered
with Police Station, Dharamkund and after investigation of the case, charge
sheet was filed against driver of the offending Tipper.
4.
In the claim petitions, the claimants impleaded the appellant-insurer and
driver as well as the owner of the offending vehicle as the respondents. While
dependents of deceased Jhangir Alam claimed compensation to the tune of
₹30.10 lacs by pleading that the deceased had qualified in engineering
examination and he had taken examination in Polytechnic College, Ramban in
the second year. It was further pleaded that the deceased was aged 21 years at
the time of his death and he was earning ₹10,000/- per month from
agriculture.
5.
The dependents of deceased Fayaz Ahmed Naik, claimed a total
compensation of ₹30.30 lacs. According to them, the deceased was aged 22
years at the time of his death. It was claimed that the deceased had completed
his two years electronic course from Industrial Training Institute(ITI) College,
Ramban and he had also completed diploma in Computer Science. His
income from agriculture was projected as ₹30,000/- per month.
6.
The owner and driver of the offending vehicle did not contest the claim
petitions and they were set ex parte, whereas appellant-insurer filed its reply
to the claim petitions. In the reply, the insurer(appellant herein) while
admitting the currency of policy of insurance of the offending vehicle with it,
Mac App Nos. 133/2019 & 134/2019
at the time of the accident, it was pleaded that the driver of the offending
vehicle was not holding a valid and effective driving license and that the
offending vehicle was being plied against the conditions of insurance policy,
without fitness certificate and road permit. On the basis of the pleadings of the
parties, the learned trial court framed the following issues:
i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
7.
Whether deceased Jhangir Alam and Fayaz Ahmed Naik died
as a result of injuries received in a Road Traffic Accident on
28.06.2014 near Sharoor Kanga fall within the jurisdiction of
Police Station Dharam Kund, involving vehicle No. JK14B
7164 being driven in a rash and negligent manner by its driver,
respondent No. 3? (OPP)
Whether the petitioners are entitled to receive compensation in
terms of M. V. Act, and if so, to what extent and from whom?
(OPP)
Whether the offending vehicle was being driven at the time of
accident in contravention of terms and conditions of the
insurance policy and the driver is not having a valid license,
thus respondent insurance company is not liable to pay
compensation? (OPR-1)
Relief?
The learned Tribunal on the basis of the evidence led by the parties, while
deciding Issue No. 1, held that the said issue is proved and that the deceased
had died due to road traffic accident caused on account of rash and negligent
driving of the offending Tipper by its driver. While deciding Issue No. 3, the
learned Tribunal concluded that after scrutiny and verification of the
documents of the offending Tipper, no violation of the terms of the policy of
insurance has been detected. Thus, Issue No. 3 has been decided against the
appellant- insurance company.
8.
The learned Tribunal, while assessing compensation, in the claim petition No.
45 which has arisen out of death of Jhangir Alam. Age of the deceased was
taken in the range of 21 to 25 years, his notional income has been taken as
₹10,000/- per month. After applying the multiplier of 16, „loss of dependency‟
to the claimants, was worked out as ₹13,44,200/-. After adding compensation
Mac App Nos. 133/2019 & 134/2019
on account of “loss of estate” to the tune of ₹15,000/- and the funeral
expenses to the tune of ₹15,000/-, the total compensation was assessed as
₹13,74,200/-.
9.
In the claim petition No. 46, which has arisen out of death of deceased Fayaz
Ahmed Naik, his age was taken in the range of 21 to 25. So far as his income
is concerned, the learned Tribunal, after relying upon the certificates issued
by the Director Technical Education, Jammu and Kashmir, observed that the
deceased had passed the prescribed test in the trade of electrician and he had
pursued this course from August 2011 to July 2013, as such, he was a
qualified electrician. His monthly income was taken as ₹12,000/-. After
applying the multiplier of 16, the “loss of dependency” was assessed as
₹16,12,800/- to which the compensation of ₹15,000/- on account of “loss of
estate” and another sum of ₹15,000/- under the head of “funeral expenses”
was added, thereby making the total compensation as ₹16,42,800/-.
10.
The appellant has challenged the impugned award primarily on the ground
that both the deceased were non earning persons and there was no cogent and
convincing evidence on record with regard to their income before the learned
Tribunal. Therefore, their income should have been taken on the basis of
minimum wages prescribed by the Government. It has been contended that it
was not open to the learned Tribunal to assess compensation of the claimants
by taking the income of the deceased at the rate of ₹10,000/- and ₹12,000/per month. Thus, according to the appellant, the compensation assessed in
terms of the impugned award is highly exaggerated.
11.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and I have also perused the
record, including the record of the learned Tribunal.
Mac App Nos. 133/2019 & 134/2019
12.
So far as claim petition No. 45 is concerned, which arises out of death of
Jhangir Alam, as per the claim petition, the deceased had just qualified the
examination of engineering. He had taken admission in Government
Polytechnic College, Ramban in second year and was a student. His income
from agriculture has been projected as ₹10,000/- per month. Claimants have
not placed on record any document to show that the deceased was student of
Polytechnic College and was undergoing the course in Electronics.
13.
Mother of the deceased, in her statement, has projected a different story by
stating that the deceased was teaching the children at his home and he was
also helping in agriculture activities. In her cross examination, she admitted
that she had not produced any document on record with regard to the income
of the deceased.
14.
In view of the aforesaid nature of the evidence on record, it was not open to
the learned Tribunal to take the income of the deceased as ₹10,000/- per
month. The deceased was a young man, aged 21 years at the time of his death,
as such, was capable of earning income. In the absence of any cogent
evidence with regard to his income, the Tribunal at best, could have been
taken his income on the basis of minimum wages of an unskilled labourer. As
per the notification issued by the Government of the Jammu and Kashmir, the
minimum wages for an unskilled labourer with effect from 01.01.2013 at the
relevant time was Rs. 150/- per day. Thus, on that basis, his monthly income
should have been taken as ₹4500/-. After adding 40% of ₹4500/- on account
of „future prospects‟ in terms of ratio laid down by the Supreme Court in
National Insurance Company Limited vs Pranay Sethi and others, (2012)
6 SCC 421, the total monthly income of the deceased works out to ₹6300/-.
Mac App Nos. 133/2019 & 134/2019
After deduction of 50% on account of „personal and living expenses‟, the
monthly „loss of dependency‟ to the claimants would work out to ₹3150/-.
Since the age of the deceased was in the group of 21 to 25, as such, multiplier
of 18 is to be applied. Therefore, „loss of dependency‟ to the claimants would
work out to ₹6,80,400/-. Besides this, the claimants are also entitled to
₹15,000/- on account of „loss of estate‟ and another sum of ₹15,000/- on
account of „funeral expenses‟. The claimants are also entitled to „loss of filial
consortium‟ at the rate of ₹40,000/- each in terms of ratio laid down by the
Apex Court in Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v Nanu Ram alias
Chuhru Ram and others, (2018) 18 SCC 130, making the total
compensation of ₹7,90,400/-.
15.
That takes us to the claim petition No. 46, which arises out of death of
deceased Fayaz Ahmed Naik. As per the claim petition, the deceased had
completed two years electrician course from Government ITI Ramban and he
had also completed one year diploma in Computer Science. It has been
pleaded in the claim petition that the deceased was earning ₹13,000/- per
month from agriculture activities. Age of the deceased has been mentioned as
22 years.
16.
Father of the deceased in his statement recorded before the Tribunal has
deposed that his son had undergone training of electrician from ITI Ramban
and he was also trained in computers. He further stated that the deceased was
working as electrician besides undertaking agriculture activities. He stated
that his monthly income was ₹35,000/-. In his cross examination, he stated
that he does not have any document with regard to the income of the
deceased. However, he reiterated that his son was doing the job of electrician.
Mac App Nos. 133/2019 & 134/2019
17.
The claimants also placed on record certificate issued by the Directorate of
Technical Education, Jammu and Kashmir which certifies that the deceased
had undergone course in the trade of electrician. The claimants have further
placed on record copy of certificate to show that the deceased had undergone
six months certificate course in computers.
18.
From the aforesaid material on record, it can safely be stated that the deceased
was a trained electrician and as such, had the potential of earning income as a
skilled worker. Even in the absence of any documentary material with regard
to the income of the deceased, it can safely be stated that the deceased was a
skilled person and on the basis of the minimum wages of skilled workers, he
would have earned ₹225/- per day, which comes to ₹6750/- per month.
19.
The learned Tribunal, without any material in support of his findings that the
deceased was earning ₹12,000/- has proceeded to take the said figure as the
monthly income of the deceased. The figure of the monthly income of the
deceased as projected by the Tribunal in these circumstances cannot be relied
upon being devoid of any supporting material. The monthly income of the
deceased is therefore, taken as ₹6750/-.
20.
After adding 40% as „future prospects‟, the monthly income of the deceased
would come to ₹9450/-. After deducting 50% on account of „living and
personal expenses‟, the „loss of dependency‟ per month would work out to
₹4725/-. After applying multiplier of 18, the „loss of dependency‟ of the
claimants would work out to ₹10,20,600/-. Besides this, a sum of ₹15,000/- as
„funeral expenses‟ and another sum of ₹15,000/- as „loss of estate‟ is to be
added. Further, the claimants, who happen to be the parents of the deceased,
are also entitled ₹40,000/- each on account of „filial consortium‟. Finally, the
Mac App Nos. 133/2019 & 134/2019
claimants in claim petition No. 46 are held entitled to compensation of
₹11,30,600/-.
21.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the details of compensation awarded by
the learned Tribunal and the compensation assessed by this Court are
tabulated as under:
S. No.
Head
Amount assessed by the
Tribunal in rupees
Deceased (Jhangir Alam) Claim Petition No. 45
Income of the ₹10,000/- per month
deceased
Add
Future ₹14,000/2.
prospects @40%
Dependency i.e. ₹7000/3.
personal
and
living expenses
@ 50%
Multiplier
4.
applied
Compensation on 7000x12x16=13,44,200/5.
account of loss of
dependency
Funeral expenses 15000/6.
Loss of estate
15,000/7.
Loss of filial Nil
8.
consortium
Interest
7.5%
9.
Total
₹13,74,200/Deceased (Fayaz Ahmed Naik) Claim Petition No. 46
Income of the ₹12,000/- per month
deceased
Add
Future ₹16,800/2.
prospects
@40%
Dependency i.e. ₹8400/3.
personal
and
living expenses
@50%
Multiplier
4.
applied
Compensation
8400x12x16=16,12,800/5.
on account of
loss
of
dependency
Funeral
15000/6.
expenses
Mac App Nos. 133/2019 & 134/2019
Amount assessed by
this Court in rupees
₹4500/- per month
₹6300/₹3150/-
3150x12x18=
₹6,80,400/15,000/15,000/40,000 each
claimants
7.5%
to
the
₹7,90,400/-
₹6750/- per month
₹9,450/₹4725/-
4725x12x18=
₹10,20,600/-
15,000/-
Loss of estate
15,000/-
15,000/-
Loss of filial
consortium
Interest
Nil
7.5%
40,000 each
claimants
7.5%
Total
16,42,800/-
11,30,600/-
7.
8.
to
the
9.
22.
In light of the position noted above, the appeals are allowed and the impugned
award is modified as indicated above and the interest awarded by the learned
Tribunal as also the other terms are conditions of the impugned award shall
remain unaltered. The amount of compensation as assessed by this Court
indicated above, shall be disbursed to the claimants as per their entitlement in
terms of the award after their proper identification. The excess amount, if any
deposited by the appellant-insurance company, shall be released in favour of
the appellant.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
Jammu
18.09.2026
Rakesh PS
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
Mac App Nos. 133/2019 & 134/2019
Rakesh Kumar
2026.09.18 14:15
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Jammu
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review