The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
6. If the question of law termed as a substantial ques-tion stands already decided by a larger Bench of the High Court concerned or by the Privy Council or by the Federal Court or by the Supreme Court, its merely wrong application on the facts of the case would not be termed to be a substantial question of law. Where a point of law has not been pleaded or is found to be arising between the parties in the absence of any factual format, a litigant should not be allowed to raise that question as a substantial question of law in second appeal. The mere appreciation of the facts, the documentary evidence or the meaning of entries and the contents of the document cannot be held to be raising a substantial question of law. But where it is found that the first appellate court has assumed jurisdiction which did not vest in it, the same can be adjudicated in the second appeal, treating it as a substantial question of law. Where the first appellate court is shown to have exercised its discretion in a judicial manner, it cannot be termed to be an error either of law or of procedure requiring interference in second appeal. This Court in Reserve Bank of India v. Ramkrishna Govind Morey [AIR 1976 SC 830]held that whether the trial court should not have exercised its jurisdiction differently is not a question of law justifying interference. [11] In case of Laxmidevamma v. Ranganath : (2015) 4 SCC…
16. Based on oral and documentary evidence, both the courts below have recorded concurrent findings of fact that the plaintiffs have established their right in A schedule property. In the light of the concurrent findings of fact, no substantial questions of law arose in the High Court and there was no substantial ground for reappreciation of evidence. While so, the High Court proceeded to observe that the first plaintiff has earmarked the A schedule property for road and that she could not have fullfledged right and on that premise proceeded to hold that declaration to the plaintiffs’ right cannot be granted. In exercise of jurisdiction under Section 100 CPC, concurrent findings of fact cannot be upset by the High Court unless the findings so recorded are shown to be perverse. In our considered view, the High Court did not keep in view that the concurrent findings recorded by the courts below, are based on oral and documentary evidence and the judgment of the High Court cannot be sustained. [12] Recently, the Apex Court in case of Adiveppa & Others Vs. Bhimappa & Others : (2017) 9 SCC 586 has held as under: "17. Here is a case where two Courts below, on appreciating the entire evidence, have come to a conclusion that the Plaintiffs failed to prove their case in relation to both the suit -8properties. The concurrent findings of facts recorded by the two Courts, which do not involve …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE
HIGH COURT
OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 19th OF JANUARY, 2024
SECOND APPEAL No. 581 of 2020
BETWEEN:1.
OMPRAKASH S/O MANSHARAM SOLANKI, AGED ABOUT 45
YEARS, OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURIST BADGAON TEH
GOGAWA KHARGONE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
RAJU S/O MANSHARAM SOLANKI, AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURE BADGAON, TAH. GOGAWA,
DISRT KHARGONE (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
PAPPU S/O MANSHARAM SOLANKI, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURE BADGAON, TAH. GOGAWA,
DISRT KHARGONE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI JITENDRA BHARAT MEHTA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
APPELLANT)
AND
1.
ANANDRAM S/O NATTHU SUTAR, AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURIST BADGAON TEH GOGAWA
KHARGONE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
SHANTABAI W/O NATTHU SUTAR, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: HOUSEHOLD BADGAON, TAH. GOGAWA, DISRT
KHARGONE (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
TEHSILDAR TEHSILDAR TEHSIL GOGAWA, DIST KHARGONE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
STATE OF M.P. THROUGH COLLECTOR KHARGONE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
-2(BY MS. SEEMA PANDEY, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT
[R-1].
This appeal coming on for judgment this day, the court passed the
following:
JUDGMENT
The appellants/defendant Nos. 1 to 3 filed this Second Appeal
against the following judgments and decrees:
[i]
Judgment and decree dated 28.04.2018 passed by 3rd Civil
Judge Class-I, Khargone in Civil Suit No.49-A/17 whereby the suit
filed by the plaintiffs Anandram and Shantabai for declaration and
permanent injunction has been decreed.
[ii]
Judgment and decree dated 22.11.2019 passed by is 2nd
Additional District Judge, Khargone in Civil Appeal No. 21/2018
whereby the Appeal filed by the defendant No.1 to 3 has been
dismissed.
Facts of the case in short are as under:
[2]
The plaintiff No.1 is a carpenter and plaintiff No.2 his
married sister. The defendant Nos. 1 to 3 belongs to Kachhi
Community and the neibours of the plaintiffs. The land bearing survey
No.65 area 0.036 hectare situated in the village Badgaon had been
recorded in the name of plaintiffs’ father as owner. After the death of
Natthu, the name of the plaintiffs were mutated in the revenue record.
The plaintiffs sold his old house and started living at village Badgaon
in rented house. He had covered the suit land by way of fencing.
Thereafter, in the year 2000, he went to Bhopal to search a job. He
returned to the village in the year 2013 and found that the defendant
Nos.1 to 3 had unathorizedly encroached over the suit land by erecting
temporary shed. Upon request, when they did not vacate the land that
-3-
gave casue of action to file the Civil Suit for possession. The plaintiffs
applied for demarcation before the Tehsildar on 25.05.2015, the
Tehsildar reached to the spot for demarcation but the defendant Nos. 1
to 3 created the dispute, therefore, the demarcation could not be carried
out and application under Section 250 of M.P.L.R.C. has been
dismissed, therefore, the plaintiffs filed Civil Suit on the basis of cause
of action accrued in their favour, first time in the year 2013, second
time in the year 2014 and third time in the year 2016.
[3]
The defendant Nos. 1 to 3 filed the written statement by
submitting that the Civil Suit is barred by limitation. They came up
with the plea that father of the plaintiffs had sold the suit land to their
grandfather/Shiva of Rs. 40/- by way of oral sale and the Natthu
handed over the possession to Shiva and since then the Shiva is in
possession. The learned Civil Court framed the six issues for
adjudication which are reproduced below:
Øa
1-
okni z' u
fu"d "kZ
D; k okn hx . k x zke cM+
x ka
o i 0g0u a
0 34- Rkgl hy x kxs ka
o k esa i ze kf. kr
fLFkr [ ky k Hkw
fe [ kl j k u Ecj 63 j d ck 0-036 gs0] ft l d s
iw
o Zesa v ke j kLr k] i f’ p e esa d UgS
; k p ekj d k [ krs ] mRr j
esa d UgS
; k d h Hkw
fe i j
t ku s d k j kLr k r Fkk n f{k. k esa
l hr kj ke fi r k x sa
n ky ky
/kkeM+
s d k [ ky k gS
] d s , d eso
LoRokf/kd kj h gS
\
2-
D; k okn hx . k okn x L
zr Hkw
fe d k i fzr okn h Øeka
d 1 y x k; r
i ze kf. kr
3 l sfj Dr v kf/ki R; i kzIr d j u sd sv f/kd kj h gS\
3-
D; k i zLr q
r okn v of/k c kg~
; gS\
4-
D; k okn hx . k u s i L
zr rq okn d k mfp r
i ze kf. kr u gha
ew
Y; ka
d u d j ml
i ze kf. kr
i j Ik; kZ
Ir U; k; ' kq
Yd v n k fd ; k gS
\
5-
D; k i zLr q
r okn esav l a
; kts u d k n k"sk gS
\
i ze kf. kr u gha
6-
Lgk; r k , oaO; ; \
Okkn
l O; ;
v kK Ir
-4fd ; k x ; kA
[4]
The plaintiff Anandram examined himself as PW-1,
Shantibai PW-2 and exhibited 26 documents including the Khasra
Panchshala to show the mutation of their father and after his death
plaintiffs name. Shiva examined as DW-2, he was specifically asked
the question whether he was having any document in respect of the
purchased of the suit land. He denied that since the sale consideration
below of Rs.100/-, therefore, no deed was executed.
[5]
After appreciating the evidence, the learned Civil Court
decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiffs. So far as issue of limitation
is concerned, the learned Civil Court found that the Civil Suit is in
limitation as the plaintiff was out of the village for long time and when
he came in the year 2013, he started proceedings for taking possession
back. Vide judgment dated 28.04.2018, the learned Civil Court has
held that the plaintiffs are exclusive owner of the suit land directed
defendant Nos. 1 to 3 to vacate the possession within two months.
[6]
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment, Civil Appeal
No.21/2018 was filed before the Appellate Court which was dismissed
vide judgment and decree dated 22.11.2019. Hence, present Second
Appeal before this Court.
[7]
Shri Mehta learned counsel for the appellant submits that
before both the Courts below, the plaintiffs have failed to file any
document to establish their title of suit land. The revenue entries does
not confer any title, the learned Trial Court has committed grave error
of law while entertaining the time barred suit. Admittedly, the plaintiffs
are not in possession since 1985, as stated before the Tehsildar in
Ex.D/3, therefore Appeal is liable admitted on the substantial question
-5-
of law as suggested in the memo of Appeal. The appellants/defendant
Nos. 1 to 3 have proposed following substantial question of law;
‘’A. Whether under the facts and circumstances of the case the
decree of lower court could be sustained as it ignored the settled
principle of law that the plaintiff in a suit for declaration and
possession has to prove his case by filing the documents of title and in
absence thereof suit cannot be decreed and he cannot get any benefit
of defendant’s weakness ?
B.
Whether under the facts and circumstances of the case the
decree of lower Court could be sustained as it erred in law in not suit
is hopelessly time barred ignoring the admission of plaintiff (PW.1
Anandram) that he is not possession since 1985 and his statements
(ExD/3) given before Tehsildar ?
C.
Whether under the facts and circumstances of the case the
decree of lower court could be sustained as erred in law in brushing
aside the admission of plaintiff and his witnesses about possession of
defendants and their predecessors and has not considered admission
made in application Ex.D/2 in its proper perspective ?
D.
Whether under the facts and circumstances of the case the
decree of lower court could be sustained as it erred in law in not
properly appreciating the evidence lead by the parties and has simply
confirmed the findings of learned trial court without discussing the
issue of limitation in detail in the impugned judgment and decree ?
F.
Whether under the facts and circumstances of the case the
decree of learned lower court could be sustained as in ignoring the
settled law that revenue entries do not confer title ?
G.
Whether under the facts and circumstances of the case the
decree of learned lower court could be sustained as its findings of
learned lower court are perverse being contrary to law and evidence
on record ?’’
[8]
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the
plaintiffs have not filed any document in respect of title except the
revenue entries i.e. Khasra Panchshala. The defendant No.1 to 3 are
estopped to challenge the title of the plaintiffs because they came up
with the plea that they purchased the land from the father of the
plaintiffs by way of oral sale deed. Once they are admitting the title of
the plaintiff’s father/ Natthu and there is no dispute that the plaintiffs
are son and daughter of Natthu, therefore, their title is established.
Even otherwise there is no reason to doubt the revenue entries of the
year 1968-69 which has presumption value under M.P.L.R.C. The
defendants No.1 to 3 have not filed any counter claim to seek
-6-
declaration of the title, therefore, they have failed to prove their title by
way of registered sale deed, hence, they are not entitled to continue of
the possession of the land.
[9]
So far issue of limitation is concerned, both the Courts
below have concurrently held that the suit filed within limitation.
Plaintiff No.1 stated that due to financial crises they sold his house and
shifted village Badgaon, where he gave birth to a daughter and
thereafter his mother expired in the year 1995. For search of job he
went to Bhopal in the year 2000. In the year 2013 and found that the
defendant No.1 to 3 have encroached the suit land. The defendant No.1
to 3 sought one year time to vacate the suit land which he have and
thereafter filed an application for demarcation which was objected by
the defendant Nos.1 to 3, hence, he had to file suit. Had the defendant
purchased the land, they would have applied for mutation their name in
the revenue record, thus they came up with false plea that they
purchased the suit land from Natthu i.e. father of plaintiffs. Hence, in
such a case, a decree of possession has rightly been granted.
[10]
In case of Kondiba Dagadu Kadam v. Savitribai Sopan
Gujar : (1999) 3 SCC 722, has held as under:
5. It is not within the domain of the High Court to investigate
the grounds on which the findings were arrived at, by the last
court of fact, being the first appellate court. It is true that the
lower appellate court should not ordinarily reject witnesses
accepted by the trial court in respect of credibility but even
where it has rejected the witnesses accepted by the trial court,
the same is no ground for interference in second appeal when it
is found that the appellate court has given satisfactory reasons
for doing so. In a case where from a given set of circumstances
two inferences are possible, one drawn by the lower appellate
court is binding on the High Court in second appeal. Adopting
any other approach is not permissible. The High Court cannot
substitute its opinion for the opinion of the first appellate court
unless it is found that the conclusions drawn by the lower
appellate court were erroneous being contrary to the mandatory
provisions of law applicable or its settled position on the basis
of pronouncements made by the Apex Court, or was based upon
-7inadmissible evidence or arrived at without evidence.
6. If the question of law termed as a substantial ques-tion
stands already decided by a larger Bench of the High Court
concerned or by the Privy Council or by the Federal Court or by
the Supreme Court, its merely wrong application on the facts of
the case would not be termed to be a substantial question of
law. Where a point of law has not been pleaded or is found to be
arising between the parties in the absence of any factual format,
a litigant should not be allowed to raise that question as a
substantial question of law in second appeal. The mere
appreciation of the facts, the documentary evidence or the
meaning of entries and the contents of the document cannot be
held to be raising a substantial question of law. But where it is
found that the first appellate court has assumed jurisdiction
which did not vest in it, the same can be adjudicated in the
second appeal, treating it as a substantial question of law.
Where the first appellate court is shown to have exercised its
discretion in a judicial manner, it cannot be termed to be an
error either of law or of procedure requiring interference in
second appeal. This Court in Reserve Bank of India v.
Ramkrishna Govind Morey [AIR 1976 SC 830]held that
whether the trial court should not have exercised its jurisdiction
differently is not a question of law justifying interference.
[11] In case of Laxmidevamma v. Ranganath : (2015) 4 SCC
264, again the Apex court has held as under:
16. Based on oral and documentary evidence, both the courts
below have recorded concurrent findings of fact that the plaintiffs have established their right in A schedule property. In the
light of the concurrent findings of fact, no substantial questions
of law arose in the High Court and there was no substantial
ground for reappreciation of evidence. While so, the High Court
proceeded to observe that the first plaintiff has earmarked the A
schedule property for road and that she could not have fullfledged right and on that premise proceeded to hold that
declaration to the plaintiffs’ right cannot be granted. In exercise
of jurisdiction under Section 100 CPC, concurrent findings of
fact cannot be upset by the High Court unless the findings so
recorded are shown to be perverse. In our considered view, the
High Court did not keep in view that the concurrent findings
recorded by the courts below, are based on oral and
documentary evidence and the judgment of the High Court
cannot be sustained.
[12]
Recently, the Apex Court in case of Adiveppa & Others Vs.
Bhimappa & Others : (2017) 9 SCC 586 has held as under:
"17. Here is a case where two Courts below, on appreciating
the entire evidence, have come to a conclusion that the
Plaintiffs failed to prove their case in relation to both the suit
-8properties. The concurrent findings of facts recorded by the two
Courts, which do not involve any question of law much less
substantial question of law, are binding on this Court.
18. It is more so when these findings are neither against the
pleadings nor against the evidence and nor contrary to any
provision of law. They are also not perverse to the extent that no
such findings could ever be recorded by any judicial person. In
other words, unless the findings of facts, though concurrent, are
found to be extremely perverse so as to affect the judicial
conscious of a judge, they would be binding on the Appellate
Court."
[13] No substantial of questions of law are involved in this
Second Appeal, same is dismissed by affirming the judgment and
decrees of both the Courts below.
Decree be prepared accordingly.
Certified copy as per rules.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Praveen
Date: 2024.01.23 15:23:41
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review