The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
26. 02.2008 to 26.03.2008 & iv) Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh w.e.f.
31. 12.2008 to 21.01.2009. ‘M/6 & M/7’ are the certificates for attending refresher courses prior to placement in Sr. scale. Hence, these 2(two) certificates cannot be considered for placement in the Selection grade/ Reader as the requirement under ‘para 2.4.1’ is refresher course after placement in the Sr. scale. ‘M/8 & M/9’ certificates issued by North-Eastern Hill University, Shillong and Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh in the years 2008 & 2009 are admittedly after placement of the petitioner in the Sr. scale. Hence, the requirement of ‘para 2.4.1 (iv)’ of the UGC guidelines 2000 is satisfied by the petitioner. [18] This Court is of the view that the petitioner is lacking only in fulfilling the criteria in ‘para 2.4.1 (ii)’ of having Ph.D degree or equivalent published work. [19] However, whether the original writ petitioner was a Ph.D degree holder or published equivalent work is not found from the records of the case. ‘Annexures- M/7, M/8 & M/9’ of the additional affidavit dated 24.07.2025 filed by the LR of the writ petitioner establishes that after placement of the original writ petitioner in the Sr. scale w.e.f. 25.01.2005 to 14.02.2005, the writ petitioner undergone 2(two) refresher courses in the years 2008 & 2009 from the NorthEastern Hill University, Shillong and Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh. There is no dispute about the other qualifications, the only requirem…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OINAM Digitally
signed by
THOIB OINAM
THOIBA MEITEI IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
Date:
AT IMPHAL
A
2025.11.11
11:05:32
MEITEI +05'30'
W.P. (C) No. 678 of 2018
Okram Indrani Devi
- Versus State of Manipur
Item no. 8
… Petitioner
… Respondent
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
06.11.2025
[1]
ORDER
Heard Mr. S. Rupachandra, learned sr. counsel assisted by Md.
Shahidur Rahman, learned counsel on behalf of the petitioner and Mr. Y. Ashang,
learned GA assisted by Mrs. R.K. Emily, learned Dy. GA on behalf of the State
respondent.
[2]
The original writ petitioner was initially appointed as Lecturer in
Physical Education, Health Education & Sports vide order dated 29.11.2025
issued by the Principal, D.M. College of Science, Imphal. Thereafter, the
petitioner was promoted to the post of Assistant Professor/ Lecturer (Sr. Scale)
vide order dated 04.08.2008 along with other persons and the Sr. Scale for the
petitioner w.e.f. 14.02.2005. Thereafter, the petitioner submitted a joint
representation dated 08.11.2016 to the 1) Commissioner/ Secretary, Higher &
Technical Education, Govt. of Manipur, Imphal, 2) Director, Higher & Technical
Education, Govt. of Manipur, Imphal, 3) Commissioner/ Secretary (Finance),
Govt. of Manipur, Imphal & 4) Accountant General (A&E), Manipur, Imphal for
fixation/ modification for dates of sr. scale as well as selection grade scale.
Thereafter, the petitioner also submitted an application dated 08.05.2018 to the
Director, University and Higher Education, Govt. of Manipur, Imphal for
placement to sr. scale and selection grade which is going to be retired on
31.07.2018. Then the petitioner approached this Court by way of writ petition
being W.P. (C) No. 467 of 2018 inter-alia praying for consideration of pending
writ petition and vide order dated 20.06.2018, the W.P. (C) No. 467 of 2018 was
disposed of by directing the authorities to consider the case of the petitioner for
promotion to the higher grade of selection grade as per law.
[3]
In compliance of the order dated 20.06.2018 in W.P. (C) No. 467
of 2018, the Commissioner (Higher & Tech. Edn.), Govt. of Manipur issued an
impugned order dated 17.07.2018 thereby, rejecting the petitioner for promotion
to the selection grade as he has not submitted relevant documents showing
satisfying the requirements for placement in the selection grade. Being aggrieved
by the said impugned order, the petitioner filed the present writ petition being
W.P. (C) No. 678 of 2018.
[4]
Since, the petitioner expired during the pendency of the writ
petition, Smt. Okram Indrani Devi, wife of the petitioner has been brought on
record as LR of the deceased original petitioner.
[5]
Vide letter dated 23.02.2010, the Principal of the D.M. College of
Science, Imphal forwarded the Appraisal report and application to the Director
(Univ. & Hr. Edn.), Govt. of Manipur, for consideration.
[6]
Mr. S. Rupachandra, learned sr. counsel for the petitioner draws
the attention of this Court to the additional affidavit dated 24.07.2025 filed by
LR of the petitioner bringing all record and certain documents. It is submitted
that after promotion to the sr. scale w.e.f. 14.02.2005, the petitioner attended 2
(two) refresher courses in the year 2008 & 2009. In the certificate issued by the
North-Eastern Hill University, Shillong certified that the writ petitioner attended
the refresher course from 26.02.2008 to 26.03.2008 and obtained grade- ‘B’ and
in the certificate issued by Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh indicating the
petitioner attended refresher course from 31.12.2008 to 21.01.2009 and
obtained grade- ‘A’. It is stated that the petitioner had attended 2(two) refresher
courses after the placement in the sr. scale and as such he is eligible for
consideration/ promotion to the next scale of Reader/ Selection grade.
[7]
Mr. S. Rupachandra, learned sr. counsel for the petitioner refers
to the UGC Regulations, 2000 issued in March, 2000 regarding Minimum
Qualifications for Appointment and Career Advancement of Teachers in
Universities and Colleges and the relevant portions is reproduced herein below:
“2.3.0 Lecturer (Selection Grade)
Lecturers in the Senior Scale who do not have a Ph.D.
degree or equivalent published work, and who do not meet the
scholarship and research standards, but fulfil the other criteria
given above for the post of Reader, and have a good record in
teaching and, preferably, have contributed in various ways such
as to the corporate life of the institution, examination work, or
through extension activities, will be placed in the Selection Grade,
subject to the recommendations of the Selection Committee which
is the same as for promotion to the post of Reader. They will be
designated as Lecturers in the Selection Grade. They could offer
themselves for fresh assessment after obtaining Ph.D. and/or
fulfilling other requirements for promotion as Reader and, if found
suitable, could be given the designation of Reader.
2.4.0 READER (PROMOTION)
2.4.1 A Lecturer in the Senior Scale will be eligible for promotion
to the post of Reader if she/he has:
(i).
Completed 5 years of service in the Senior Scale;
(ii).
Obtained a Ph.D. degree or has equivalent published
work;
(iii).
Made some mark in the areas of scholarship and
research as evidenced e.g. by self-assessment,
reports
of
referees,
quality
of
publications,
contribution to educational innovation, design of new
courses and curricula and extension activities.
(iv).
After placement in the Senior Scale participated in two
refresher courses/summer institutes of approved
duration, or engaged in other appropriate continuing
education programmes of comparable quality as may
be specified or approved by the University Grants
Commission, and
(v).
Possesses consistently good performance appraisal
reports.
2.4.2 Promotion to the Post of Reader will be through a process
of selection by a Selection committee to be set up under the
Statutes/Ordinances of the concerned University or other similar
Committees set up by the appointing authorities.”
[8]
It is submitted that the requirement of Ph.D. degree is not a
requirement for promotion to the Selection grade and if the Lecturer of Sr. scale
is published equivalent work.
[9]
Mr. S. Rupachandra, learned sr. counsel for the petitioner submits
that in terms of the ‘para 2.3.0’ & ‘para 2.4.0’, the petitioner who has attended
2(two) refresher courses after placement in sr. scale and having the required
length of service and having published equivalent work is eligible for promotion
to the selection grade/reader.
[10]
In the circumstances, the impugned order dated 17.07.2018
issued by the Commissioner (Higher & Tech. Edn.), Govt. of Manipur has been
issued without considering the UGC guidelines of 2000.
[11]
On the other hand, Mr. Y. Ashang, learned GA submits that
referring to ‘para 2.4.0’ of the UGC guidelines 2000, 5(five) requirements as sr.
scale reader to be eligible for Reader / Selection grade and the same is reflected
above. It is further submits that at the time of appraisal, the petitioner has failed
to submit 2(two) refresher courses and also Ph.D. degree or equivalent published
work/publication. In the circumstances, the impugned order issued to the
petitioner has not satisfied all the 5(five) requirements.
[12]
This Court has perused the materials on record including the UGC
guidelines 2000. The position is not disputed for the 5(five) requirements under
the ‘para 2.4.0 of the UGC guidelines 2000. There are 5(five) requirements for
promotion of the Sr. scale Lecturer to the post of Reader/ Selection grade.
Admittedly, the petitioner has completed the 5(five) years service in the Sr. scale
on the date of the impugned order dated 17.07.2018.
[13]
Mr. S. Rupachandra, learned sr. counsel for the petitioner submits
that as per ‘para 2.4.1’ of the UGC guidelines 2000, the petitioner seems to be
lacking only the requirement of ‘para 2.4.1 (ii)’ obtained Ph.D degree or
equivalent publication and LR of the petitioner may be permitted to submit
necessary documents.
[14]
Mr. Y. Ashang, learned GA submits that the writ petitioner has not
submitted the requisite documents so the LR of the writ petitioner may submit
all the relevant documents.
[15]
This Court has perused the materials on record and gone through
the UGC guidelines 2000 with respect to the promotion and academic carrier
precaution of the Lecturer, Reader and Professor.
[16]
‘Para 2.4.1’ of the UGC guidelines 2000 prescribes 5(five)
requirements for the Sr. Lecturer in Sr. scale for promotion in Reader/ Selection
grade and the same is reflected above.
[17]
On perusal of the documents filed along with the writ petition,
there is only 1(one) certificate for refresher course. In the writ petition, no
document for attending refresher course for placement in the Sr. scale was
produced and no document regarding equivalent publication or equivalent work.
Later on, the LR of the writ petitioner filed additional affidavit dated 24.07.2025
thereby, documents ‘M/6, M/7, M/8 & M/9’ which are the certificates of attending
refresher courses in i) Mangalore University w.e.f 3.02.2003 to 26.02.2003, ii)
Lakshmibai National Institute of Physical Education, Gwalior (M.P.) w.e.f.
25.01.2005 to 14.02.2005, iii) North-Eastern Hill University, Shillong w.e.f.
26.02.2008 to 26.03.2008 & iv) Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh w.e.f.
31.12.2008 to 21.01.2009. ‘M/6 & M/7’ are the certificates for attending refresher
courses prior to placement in Sr. scale. Hence, these 2(two) certificates cannot
be considered for placement in the Selection grade/ Reader as the requirement
under ‘para 2.4.1’ is refresher course after placement in the Sr. scale. ‘M/8 &
M/9’ certificates issued by North-Eastern Hill University, Shillong and Aligarh
Muslim University, Aligarh in the years 2008 & 2009 are admittedly after
placement of the petitioner in the Sr. scale. Hence, the requirement of ‘para 2.4.1
(iv)’ of the UGC guidelines 2000 is satisfied by the petitioner.
[18]
This Court is of the view that the petitioner is lacking only in
fulfilling the criteria in ‘para 2.4.1 (ii)’ of having Ph.D degree or equivalent
published work.
[19]
However, whether the original writ petitioner was a Ph.D degree
holder or published equivalent work is not found from the records of the case.
‘Annexures- M/7, M/8 & M/9’ of the additional affidavit dated 24.07.2025 filed by
the LR of the writ petitioner establishes that after placement of the original writ
petitioner in the Sr. scale w.e.f. 25.01.2005 to 14.02.2005, the writ petitioner
undergone 2(two) refresher courses in the years 2008 & 2009 from the NorthEastern Hill University, Shillong and Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh. There is
no dispute about the other qualifications, the only requirement to be satisfied by
the writ petitioner is whether he is Ph.D degree holder or published equivalent
work in terms of the ‘para 2.4.1 (ii)’ of the UGC guidelines 2000. In the
circumstances, the impugned order dated 17.07.2018 issued by the
Commissioner (Higher & Tech. Edn.), Govt. of Manipur rejecting the
representation of the original writ petitioner for promotion to the Selection grade/
Reader is set aside giving liberty to the LR of the writ petitioner to place all
materials as required in terms of ‘para 2.4.1 (ii)’ of the UGC guidelines 2000 to
examine whether the original writ petitioner was a Ph.D degree holder or has
equivalent published work.
[20]
In the circumstances, the LR of the writ petitioner may submit
relevant documents with respect to Ph.D. degree or equivalent published work
or any other documents to the Director, Higher & Technical Education, Govt. of
Manipur within a period of 1(one) month and the representation of the writ
petitioner shall be considered within a period of 2(two) months from the date of
receipt of the necessary documents from the LR of the petitioner.
[21]
This Court is of the view that the only requirement to be examined
is a Ph.D degree holder or equivalent published work in terms of ‘para 2.4.1(ii)’
of the UGC guidelines 2000.
[22]
In the circumstances, the W.P. (C) No. 678 of 2018 is allowed
with the aforesaid directions. No cost.
JUDGE
Thoiba
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review