Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Reserved On
: 29/04/2026
Pronounced On : 17/07/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 531 of 1986
With
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 1093 of 1987
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE L. S. PIRZADA
==========================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
✓
==========================================================
HOUSE OF DUBARY & ORS.
Versus
THE OFFICER LIQUIDATOR OF HANSPA KNIT (P) LTD., & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
ADVOCATE NOTICE NOT RECD BACK for the Appellant(s) No. 2
MR C B UPADHYAYA(3508) for the Appellant(s) No. 3,4
MR ND NANAVATI(507) for the Appellant(s) No. 1
MR ABHIJIT P JOSHI(1330) for the Defendant(s) No. 1
MR PRANAV G DESAI(290) for the Defendant(s) No. 6
MR SH SANJANWALA(729) for the Defendant(s) No. 7
MS PJ DAVAWALA(240) for the Defendant(s) No. 1
NOTICE NOT RECD BACK for the Defendant(s) No. 2,3
NOTICE SERVED for the Defendant(s) No. 4,5,8
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE L. S. PIRZADA
CAV JUDGMENT
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA)
Sr.
No.
Particulars
Paragraph
nos.
1)
Introduction
1 to 5
2)
Facts
a) Plaint
6 to 31
b) Written statement of
defendant nos. 1 to 4
32 to 43
c) Counter claim
44 to 52
d) Written statements of
defendant nos.5 and 6
53 to 54
e) Written submissions of
Appellant no.2
55 to 65
3)
Issues framed by the Trial
Court
and
summary
of
findings
4)
Oral Evidence
67 to 75
5)
Orders passed by the Trial
Court and orders in appeals
76 to 82
6)
Submissions
defendants
83 to 100
7)
Submissions
of
respondent-plaintiff
8)
Points for Determination
9)
Reasons
of
appellantsthe
101 to 144
Analysis
of
points
for
determination and findings
1)
Points for Determination
no. 1 to 4
146 to 168
2)
Point for Determination
169 to 172
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
No.5
10)
3)
Point for Determination
no.6
173 to 204
4)
Points for Determination
No.7 and 8
205 to 210
5)
Point for Determination
no.9
211 to 219
6)
Point for Determination
No.10
220 to 222
7)
Point for Determination
no.11
223 to 230
Conclusion
231 to 236
1) Introduction
1.Heard learned advocate Mr.C.B. Upadhyaya for
the
appellants
Mr.Abhijit
and
Joshi
learned
advocate
the
respective
for
respondent.
2.These matters are cross appeals and for the
sake of convenience, facts are recorded from
First Appeal No.531 of 1986.
3.First Appeal No.531 of 1986 is filed by the
defendant
nos.
to
being
aggrieved
by
Judgment and Order dated 31.01.1986 passed by
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Civil Judge (Senior Division) Kutchh at Bhuj
in Special Civil Suit No.120 of 1979 partly
allowing the suit in favour of the plaintiff
- respondent no.1 – M/s. Hanspa Knit (P) Ltd.
(Under
Liquidation)
Official
Liquidator
represented
for
decree
through
of
sum
of
Rs.49,81,336/- from the appellants- defendant
nos. 1 to 4 with running interest at the rate
of 12% per annum from the date of the suit
till realisation. Counter claim filed by the
appellants is rejected.
4.First
Appeal
plaintiff
No.1093
M/s.
of
Hanspa
Knit
is
filed
by
(P)
Ltd.
(in
liquidation) being aggrieved by Judgment and
Order dated 31.01.1986 passed by Civil Judge
(Senior Division) Kutchh at Bhuj in Special
Civil
Suit
allowing
No.120
of
freight
and
so
other
far
as
not
charges
and
dismissing the suit qua defendant nos. 5 and
6.
C/FA/531/1986
5.Since
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
both
arising
the
out
appeals
of
a
are
common
cross
appeals
Judgment,
First
Appeal No.531 of 1986 is treated as a lead
matter.
For
the
sake
of
convenience,
appellant nos. 1 to 4 are referred to as the
defendant nos. 1 to 4 and respondent no.1 is
referred
to
as
the
plaintiff
whereas
respondent nos. 7 and 8 are referred to as
defendant nos. 5 and 6. Respondent nos. 2 and
3 are ordered to be deleted vide order dated
24.07.1995 whereas respondent nos. 4 to 6 are
joined as defendant nos. 4,5 and 6 in the
counter claim filed by the appellants.
2)Facts
a) Plaint
6.The plaintiff was a private limited company
registered under the provisions of Companies
Act, 1956 (For short “the Companies Act”) and
was engaged in assembling and manufacturing
of radio, transistors, car radios, cassettes,
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
transistors
etc.
having
its
factory
at
Gandhidham, Kandla in Kandla Free Trade Zone
District Kutch, Gujarat designated under the
provisions
of
the
Customs
Act,
(For
short “the Customs Act”).
7.The plaintiff was holding license under the
provisions of the Customs Act to carry out
its business in Sector-1, Kandla Free Trade
Zone.
The
plaintiff
was
importing
semi
finished components technically known as SKDs
in Semi Knocked Down Form from abroad and
thereafter assembled the same for export and
the plaintiff was not entitled to make any
domestic sales in India.
8.The defendant nos. 2, 3 and 4 are brothers
who were carrying on the business of export
of various items in the name and style of
“House of Dubary” -defendant no.1. Defendant
nos.2,
and
are
also
the
partners
of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
defendant no.1 firm as averred in the plaint.
Defendant no.5 M/s. Airfreight (P) Ltd. is a
company registered under the Companies Act
and carrying out its business at Mumbai as
Clearing
and
Forwarding
Agent.
Defendant
no.6-New Bank of India is a Scheduled Bank
situated at Delhi and had issued Irrevocable
Letters
of
Credit
(LCs)
in
favour
of
the
plaintiff at the request and on account of
defendant no.1-firm.
9.The plaintiff filed Special Civil Suit No.
of
to
recover
a
sum
of
Rs.62,91,245.18 from the defendants jointly
and severally.
10.
It
is
averred
December, 1977,
in
the
plaint
that
in
6 Yugoslavian buyers were
brought by defendant no.2 at the factory of
the
plaintiff
export
of
for
electronic
negotiation
goods
to
regarding
Yugoslavia.
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Thereafter, pursuant to further negotiation
at Bombay, Delhi and Hongkong, defendant nos.
1 to 4 agreed to act as Export House and
placed orders in their own name for reason of
expediency subject to goods being exported to
Yugoslavia. On 04.10.1978, defendant nos. 1
to 4 placed an order with the plaintiff for
supply of goods amounting to US$ 781521.14
equivalent to Rs.62,91,245.10. Thereafter on
05.10.1978,
four
confirmed
Irrevocable
Letters
Credit
(LCs)
opened
by
defendant no.6 -New Bank of India, Delhi
in
of
were
favour of the plaintiff. As per the LCs, the
plaintiff
was
to
complete
the
shipment
by
10.10.1978 and negotiation by 30.10.1978 and
goods were to be shipped from Kandla Port.
Thereafter, LCs were amended by letter dated
09.10.1978
by
defendant
no.6
-New
Bank
of
India by correcting the last date of shipment
as 01.12.1978 and last date for negotiation
to
be
30.12.1978.
Thereafter,
New
Bank
of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
India - defendant no.6 further amended LCs by
letters
dated
14.10.1978,
20.10.1978
and
18.11.1978 by amending the shipment by air
from Bombay Airport to Theossaloniki (Greece)
Airport.
11.
The
Agent
plaintiff
namely
consignment
M/s.
of
through
Dawn
following
its
India
Forwarding
made
first
shipments
from
Kandla:
Inv. No. Date
HK/01
22/11/78
HK/02
22/11/78
Qnty
Model
(Sets)
12,900
SITTAR
sets
5000 sets PANASIA
HK/03
25/11/78
4995 sets
“
HK/04
25/11/78
1906 sets
“
HK/05
2/12/78
8000 sets SITAR
HK/06
3/12/78
10000 sets PANASIA
Total
12.
Aggregate
value
of
Amount U.S.A.R.4
$
Forms
98,040.00 Hans/Exp/
01/78-79
40,000.00 Hans/Exp/
02/78-79
39,960.00 Hans/Exp/
03/78-79
14,485.60 Hans/Exp/
04/78-79
60,800.00 Hans/Exp/
05/78-79
80,000.00 Hans/Exp/
06/78-79
3,33,285.60
the
aforesaid
consignment was US $333,285.60 equivalent to
Rs.26,80,327.55. The plaintiff received the
said amount from defendant no.6 for and on
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
behalf of defendant no.1.
13.
The plaintiff thereafter dispatched the
second
consignment
from
Kandla
Free
Trade
Zone to defendant no.5 - M/s. Airfreight (P)
Ltd. for export at Bombay through M/s. Vijay
Transport Co. for export by air.
14.
The
aggregate
value
of
consignment was US$ 2,60,863.00
second
equivalent
to Rs.20,99,947.01.
15.
The
plaintiff
dispatched
the
goods
in
part for third consignment to defendant no.5
M/s. Airfreight (P) Ltd. through M/s. Vijay
Transport Co. from Kandla Free Trade Zone to
Bombay.
16.
is
Aggregate value of the third consignment
US$
4,30,510.14
Rs.34,65,606.60.
equivalent
to
C/FA/531/1986
17.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
As the defendants did not pay the amount
of
second
and
third
consignment,
the
plaintiff filed the suit on 21.05.1979 for
recovery
of
Rs.62,91,245.18
together
with
interest at the rate of 15% from 17.12.1978
to
05.05.1979
and
running
interest
at
the
rate of 15% per annum till realisation.
18.
It
after
is
the
the
case
of
plaintiff
the
plaintiff
exported
the
that
first
consignment from Kandla by ship to Yugoslavia
through
M/s.
the
Dawn
Clearing
India,
and
Forwarding
defendant
nos.
Agent
to
persuaded the plaintiff to export the goods
by air through defendant no.5 as defendant
no.5 was giving 30 days credit for payment of
freight to defendant nos. 1 to 4 as the goods
were to be exported on FOB basis.
19.
The plaintiff agreed to the suggestion
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
to export the goods by air through defendant
no.5
-
M/s.
Airfreight
(P)
Ltd.
who
was
Clearing and Forwarding agent of defendant
nos. 1 to 4 from Bombay airport to Greece
airport.
Accordingly,
plaintiff
sent
the
second consignment after removing the goods
from Kandla Free Trade Zone under Form A.R.4
issued by Customs Department to M/s. Vijay
Transport Co. to Bombay to defendant no.5 so
as to export to Yugoslavia by air.
20.
It
is
the
case
of
the
plaintiff
that
though defendant no.5 was required to send
the goods
for and on behalf of the plaintiff
by air but it did not forward the Airway bill
to the plaintiff but the same was forwarded
to defendant no.1 which shows the collusion
between defendant nos. 1 to 4 and defendant
no. 5. It is also the case of the plaintiff
that in the Airway bill in the column of
shippers, name of defendant no.1 “House of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Dubary”
was
mentioned
by
defendant
no.5.
Because of such collusion between defendant
nos. 1 to 4 and defendant no. 5,
defendant
no.
from
made
the
payment
received
the
negotiating bank of Yugoslavia in the account
of defendant no.1 “House of Dubary”.
21.
It
that
is
the
also
the
case
of
the
plaintiff
goods
sent
by
the
plaintiff
was
entitled to exemption from duty only if the
exporter is having factory within Kandla Free
Trade Zone and it would amount to an offence
to mention the name of defendant no.1 under
the column of shippers name and address in
the airway bill.
22.
It is a normal trade practice in a case
where a manufacturer is exporting the goods
at
the
foreign
instance
buyer
of
would
an
give
Export
Letter
House,
of
the
Credit
from his banker in favour of the Export House
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
in India and the bankers of the Export House
would give Letter of Credit in favor of the
manufacturer and hence, the Airway Bill in a
case where the goods are exported by air and
Bill of Lading in case where the goods are
exported by the ship are the most important
documents of title. The Airway Bill or the
Bill
of
Lading,
therefore,
as
the
case
may
be,
is
required
by
the
manufacturer
exporting the goods to be produced through
the negotiating bank to the LC opening Bank
along with the bank draft and documents drawn
on
the
LC
negotiating
opening
bank.
bank
The
LC
through
opening
the
bank
on
receipt of Airway Bill, bank draft and the
documents
manufacturer
would
of
make
the
payment
value
of
to
the
the
goods
exported.
23.
However, it is the case of the plaintiff
that in facts of the case, the LC opening
C/FA/531/1986
bank
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
i.e.
defendant
no.6
as
well
as
the
plaintiff who had manufactured the goods for
export
and
defendant
through
whom
the
no.1
export
Export
was
made
House
were
required to follow the prescribed procedure.
Therefore, defendant no.6 received Letters of
Credit drawn in its favour by the bankers of
Yugoslavian buyers i.e. “Manufacturer Hanover
Trust”,
a
leading
American
Bank
of
International repute. Defendant no.6-New Bank
of India
had drawn LCs in favour of the
plaintiff and was expected to honour the LCs
and pay the amount thereof to the plaintiff
on production of bank draft and the documents
to
the
defendant
no.6
through
negotiating
bank i.e. State Bank of India at Kandla.
24.
It
is
the
case
of
the
plaintiff
that
though defendant no.6 being in full knowledge
of true facts and after having received the
original Airway Bill showing the name of the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
plaintiff in the column of shippers, should
not have paid the entire amount received from
the
bankers
of
defendant no.1.
Yugoslavian
buyers
to
The plaintiff has therefore,
alleged that defendant nos. 1 to 4 as well as
defendant no.6 New Bank of India are liable
to pay the amount covered by LCs drawn by
defendant
no.6
insofar
as
in
favour
of
the
the
value
of
plaintiff
the
second
consignment exported by defendant no.5 to the
Yugoslavian buyers through Air on 27.12.1978
amounting to US $ 2,60,863=00 equivalent to
Rs.20,99,947.01.
25.
It
is
the
case
of
the
plaintiff
that
defendant nos. 1 to 4 and defendant no.6 has
thus committed a fraud on the plaintiff by
appropriating the credit of the entire amount
received
buyers
in
from
the
the
bankers
account
of
of
Yugoslavian
defendant
no.1-
“House of Dubary”. The plaintiff therefore,
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
insisted from defendant nos.1 to 4 to agree
and assure that payment due to the plaintiff
would be made latest by March or April, 1979
but the defendant nos. 1 to 4 failed to keep
their assurance and did not pay the amount of
US$
2,60,863=00
equivalent
to
Rs.20,99,947.01.
26.
Regarding
the
third
consignment
forwarded by the plaintiff between December
30, 1978 to January 11, 1979 comprising of 6
parcels through M/s. Vijay Transport Co. to
defendant no.5 Air Freight Pvt. Ltd. as a
Clearing
and
Forwarding
Agent
of
the
plaintiff, same were exported after delay of
more than four to five months by defendant
nos. 1 to 4, and as such defendant nos. 1 to
5 are jointly and severally liable for the
amount of the third consignment.
27.
It
is
the
case
of
the
plaintiff
that
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
defendant
no.5
ought
original
airway
bill
to
to
have
the
sent
the
plaintiff
but
deliberately forwarded the same to defendant
nos.
to
and
hence
defendant
no.5
is
guilty of conversion and misappropriation of
the goods sent by the plaintiff for export
purpose to defendant no.5 at Mumbai.
28.
It
is
between
the
case
of
the
January
13,
plaintiff
to
May
3,
that
1979,
plaintiff as well as the custom authorities
of Kandla Free Trade Zone addressed several
communication
to
the
defendant
no.5.
M/s.
Airfreight
(P)
Ltd.
calling
upon
the
information
for
withholding
goods
by
defendant
no.5.
The
back
third
consignment
the
Mumbai.
However
no
the
plaintiff
response
to
also
called
Kandla
was
from
given
by
defendant nos. 1 to 5.
29.
The plaintiff by letter dated 27.04.1979
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
also
requested
Customs
the
Assistant
International
Area
Collector
Cargo
of
Complex,
Export department, Mumbai putting on record
that
defendant
no.5
inspite
of
repeated
requests failed to advise the plaintiff of
dispatch of the cargo under AR-6 to 11 and
AR-12
to
regarding
second
and
third
letter
dated
consignment respectively.
30.
The
plaintiff
by
another
14.04.1979 placed on record that defendant
no.5 was warned of the legal liability of its
action in keeping cargo and preparing false
documents
and
also
informed
the
customs
authority that the defendant no.5 is called
upon to return cargo under AR-12 to 20 along
with
relevant
24.04.1979,
documents.
the
By
plaintiff
letter
dated
informed
the
Assistant Collector of Custom ,Kandla Free
Trade Zone giving details of AR-4 Form from
AR-12 to 20 regarding the third consignment
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
that the goods have been sent to defendant
no.5 but the same were not exported till that
date and further steps are required to take
back the goods from the defendant no.5.
31.
The
Kandla
Assistant
Free
Trade
Collector
Zone
by
of
Customs
letter
dated
03.05.1979 also informed the defendant no.5
that goods are kept in an unauthorised manner
for a period of more than four months since
the goods were under customs export bonds and
threatened
the
defendant
no.5
for
action
under the provisions of the Customs Act and
called
upon
defendant
no.5
to
deliver
the
consignments back to the plaintiff since the
goods
were
not
exported
and
the
plaintiff
being the owner of the goods did not wish to
export the goods and intended to bring them
back to Kandla Free Trade Zone. The customs
authorities also warned defendant no.5 for
holding the bonded goods illegally. However,
C/FA/531/1986
in
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
spite
of
plaintiff
such
and
communication
the
customs
from
the
authorities,
defendant no.5 exported the goods by air to
Yugoslavian
buyers
but
did
not
send
the
airway bills to the plaintiff nor returned
the AR-4 Forms showing the proof of export to
the
plaintiff.
plaintiff
It
that
consideration
is
the
case
of
the
amount
of
the
sale
goods
of
the
third
of
consignment was received in the account of
defendant no.1.
b) Written statement of defendant nos. 1 to 4
32.
The
defendant
nos.
to
filed
the
written statement at Exh.29 raising various
preliminary objections as under:
1)
The
plaint
has
not
been
signed
and
verified by a duly authorised person.
2) The Trial Court did not have territorial
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
jurisdiction to try the suit or entertain it
or grant any relief thereunder.
3) No notice of demand was ever served by the
plaintiff upon the defendants, hence the suit
is premature.
4) That the plaint suppresses material facts
as well as relevant details and as such, is
mala
fide,
false
and
frivolous
to
the
knowledge of the plaintiff and is liable to
be dismissed outright with special costs and
exemplary cost as provided under section 35
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
5) The suit is bad for mis-joinder of parties
inasmuch as the plaintiff cannot claim any
amount
and
collectively,
for
that
jointly
matter
and
severally
alternatively
from
defendant nos. 1 to 4 representing one group
and
defendant
nos.
to
as
separate
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
entities.
6) On ex-facie reading of para no. 14(i) to
(v) of the plaint, total aggregate of the
figures does not tally with the claim made of
Rs.62,91,245.18.
7)
The
suit
amount
valued
for
purposes
has
not
of
been
Court
properly
fees
and
jurisdiction.
33.
Apart
from
preliminary
objections,
it
was contended by the defendant nos. 1 to 4
that there was no evidence of any privity of
contract
whereby the plaintiff was entitled
to receive the alleged amount from defendant
nos. 1 to 4.
34.
It was contended that the suit is liable
to be stayed under section 10 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 as separate suit for
declaration
negating
the
claim
of
the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
plaintiff
had
already
been
filed
by
the
defendants in the Courts at Delhi which was
pending for trial.
35.
It was contended that the plaintiff did
not come to the Court with clean hands and
there is no equity in his favour.
36.
It was contended that as per section 20
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, place
of
suing
shall
be
where
the
defendants
actually and voluntarily reside and carry on
the business and work for gain or where the
cause of action wholly or in part arose and
therefore, the Court at Kuchchh at Bhuj has
no
territorial
jurisdiction
as
negotiation
between the parties took place only at three
places i.e. Bombay, Delhi and Hongkong.
37.
It was also contended that plaintiff has
no locus standi to institute the suit on his
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
own volition or free will at Bhuj as the
plaintiff
has
failed
to
show
as
to
how
defendant nos. 5 and 6 could be impleaded as
party.
38.
an
It was also contended that though it is
admitted
Rs.26,80,327.50
position
that
pertaining
amount
to
of
first
consignment has already been received by the
plaintiff then how that amount can be again
claimed by the plaintiff.
39.
It was further contended on behalf of
defendant nos. 1 to 4 that the plaintiff is
not entitled to claim any amount as LCs have
expired on 30.12.1978. It was also contended
that
the
terms
and
conditions
of
LCs
was
contract between the parties and in absence
of any LCs, defendants are not liable to pay
any amount to the plaintiff.
C/FA/531/1986
40.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
It
was
also
contended
that
defendant
no.5 was only Clearing and Forwarding Agent
of defendant nos. 1 to 4 therefore, there was
no obligation or moral duty to handover the
airway bill to the plaintiff and plaintiff
has
no
locus
standi
to
ask
for
such
documents.
41.
It was also the case of the defendants
that plaintiff has committed gross violation
of terms and conditions of the back to back
LCs
and
realising
have
been
made,
that
have
default
dumped
the
and
lapses
unsalable
goods with defendant no.5 and on the contrary
defendants have incurred freight charges and
demurrage and filed counter claim claiming
that the defendants have suffered loss to the
tune of
US$ 13,60,644.17 equivalent to Rs.
1,08,85,152.00.
42.
It was contended that the defendants are
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
not liable for the claimed amount as total
value claimed by the plaintiff is CIF value
which
come
into
operation
without
costs,
insurance and freight. Since the plaintiff
has not paid freight/ chartered charges or
insurance charges nor there is any averment
in the plaint to that effect and therefore,
such
amount
cannot
be
claimed
by
the
plaintiff. It was further contended that the
defendants have held the plaintiff to export
the
goods
but
demurrage
etc.
required
to
be
the
paid
amount
by
adjusted
of
defendant
and
the
freight,
no.1
was
Managing
Director of the plaintiff Mr. Hasmukh Khatri,
has flown out of country due to indebtedness
as there were liabilities of the banks and
Gujarat
and
Financial
other
Corporation,
institutions
with
State
Bank
which
the
plaintiff was associated in the course of its
business.
C/FA/531/1986
43.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
It was therefore, claimed that when the
Letter of Credits have expired on 30.12.1978
there was no contract between the parties and
the goods were exported at the cost and risk
of the plaintiff by defendant no.5 directly
and defendant nos. 1 to 4 only helped the
plaintiff to clear the goods as the plaintiff
did
not
have
enough
finance
to
pay
the
freight and other charges. It was therefore,
contended
that
30.03.1979
stand
estoppel,
all
the
waived
matters
of
waiver,
by
prior
to
doctrine
of
forfeiture
and
acquiescence.
c) Counter claim
44.
suit
The defendant nos. 1 to 4 filed their
in
form
of
counter
claim
under
the
provisions of Order VIII Rule 6 (a) and (b)
read
with
section
of
Code
of
Civil
Procedure. In the counter claim, defendant
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
nos.
to
are
plaintiffs
and
Hasmukh
Brothers (HK) Hongkong, M/s. Hanspa Knit(P)
Ltd., Shree Hasmukh C Khatri, Shree P.U.Oza,
Shree
A.C.
Pota
and
State
Bank
of
India,
Kandla Free Trade Zone, Gandhidham-Kutch were
joined as defendant nos. 1 to 6 respectively.
45.
In para no.5 of the counter claim, it
was averred that various irrevocable Letters
of
Credit
opened
in
their
favour
by
a
Government Enterprise “SOLUN” Import-Export,
Gevgelija,
Yugoslavia
of
US$
2,284,465.00
equivalent to Rs.2,27,31,800/-. It is further
averred that Hasmukh Brothers (HK) assured
and agreed to assemble the items as per the
order in factories located in Hongkong and
accordingly,
irrevocable
Letters
of
Credit
dated 20.06.1978 and 21.06.1978 in favour of
the said firm were opened and in turn Letters
of Credit were opened by the defendant no.1
firm “House of Dubary” as stated in para no.9
C/FA/531/1986
of
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the
counter
claim.
However,
Hasmukh
Brothers (HK) failed to supply the goods but
assured to execute the orders under the said
Letters
of
Credit
through
sister
concern
plaintiff M/s. Hanspa Knit (P) Ltd. located
at Kandla.
46.
It
is
further
averred
that
upon
assurance given by the plaintiff M/s. Hanspa
Knit (P) Ltd., 7 Letters of Credit in favour
of Hasmukh Brothers (HK) were withdrawn and
three
Letters
of
Credits
were
opened
in
favour of Hasmukh Brothers (HK) and 4 Letters
of
Credit
were
opened
Hanspa Knit (P) Ltd.
in
favour
of
M/s.
stipulating the period
of supply upto 20.12.1978.
47.
Regarding the first consignment sent on
22.11.1978,
it
was
claimed
that
there
was
violation of the implied terms and conditions
agreed
upon
of
sending
the
consignment
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
through charter aircraft and therefore, there
was
a
loss
of
approximately).
made
for
Rs.51,013
(US$
6,376.66
A claim for refund was also
Rs.1,44,846.90
on
the
ground
of
failure to supply total quantity of goods.
48.
Regarding the second consignment as per
details given in para no.15 of the counter
claim,
M/s.
Hansa
Knit
(P)
Ltd.
sent
the
goods to clearing agent M/s. Air Freight (P)
Ltd. at Bombay on 27.12.1978 on its own which
was
exported
to
SOLUN
Import-Export
after
great persuasion in the month of May, 1979.
49.
in
The third consignment was also exported
May,1979
incurring
letters
after
other
dated
paying
airfreight
miscellaneous
22.05.1979,
expenses.
24.05.1979
and
By
and
19.06.1979 SOLUN Import-Export raised dispute
regarding the shortage in quantity and defect
in quality of the goods as stated in para 19
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
and 20 of the counter claim.
claim
of
US$
Rs.4,75,000/-
59,375.00
in
Therefore, a
equivalent
respect
of
to
second
consignment and US$ 56,250.00 equivalent to
Rs.4,50,000/- in respect of third consignment
for
making
various
correspondence
and
contacting SOLUN Import-Export personally and
other necessary miscellaneous expenses during
the course of transaction was raised. Claim
for
demurrage
of
US$
7,500(Rs.60,000)
and
payment made to clearing and forwarding agent
M/s Dawn India for US$ 7500 (Rs.60,000) and
US$
5,250
respectively
was
also
raised.
Interest claim at the rate of 18% per annum
on US$
21,754.60 i.e. US$ 93,915.03 (Rs.
7,51,326.64
Further
approximately)
claim
reputation
and
for
loss
future
was
raised.
of
goodwill,
business
due
to
negligence and misconduct of M/s. Hanspa Knit
(P) Ltd. and others was raised at the rate of
20%
on
US$
1,440,960
amounting
to
US$
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
288,192.0 (Rs.23,05,536 approx) further claim
of
demurrage
(Rs.35,27,680/total
claim
of
Rs.
approx.)
was
of
432,288.00
raised.
US$
Thus
13,60,644.17
(Rs.1,08,85,152) was made.
50.
It was also claimed that as the CCIE did
not grant license to “House of Dubary”, it
had
to
transfer
the
Letter
of
Credit
Yugoslavian
about
Rs.
Lacs
issued
by
buyers
in
the
name
of
sister
its
for
concern
Dubary Exports sustaining heavy loss of Rs.
22 Lacs.
51.
It was therefore, prayed that Suit no.
120 of 1979 should be dismissed and counter
claim
of
Rs.1,08,85,152
together
with
interest at the rate of 18% per annum should
be decreed. The declaratory suit filed before
Delhi High Court is placed on record at Exh.
442.
C/FA/531/1986
52.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
The
plaintiff
also
filed
the
written
statement to the counter claim denying the
facts stated therein and reiterated the facts
stated in the plaint and also denied that
M/s. Hasmukh Brothers (HK) has any connection
with the 2nd and 3rd consignment which were
admittedly
exported
for
which
payment
has
been received from the Yugoslavian buyers.
The
other
defendants
in
the
counter
claim
also filed their written statement denying
the claim made in the counter claim.
d) Written statements of defendant nos.5 and 6
53.
Defendant no.5 filed its reply at Exh.35
wherein similar contention has been raised as
raised by defendant nos. 1 to 4.
54.
Defendant
statement
at
no.6
Exh.38
also
filed
contending
its
written
that
draft
drawn by the plaintiff on defendant no.1 was
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
submitted through State Bank of India, Kandla
along with papers and the details of the same
are narrated in paragraph no.9 of the written
statement. It was contended that plaintiff is
not entitled to any relief and requested the
suit be dismissed with cost.
e)Written submissions of Appellant no.2
55.
Appellant no.2 – defendant no.2 Shakar
Darbari
has
filed
written
submission
vide
email dated 09.06.2026 through his power of
attorney
holder
submitted
in
Ms.Raj
the
Darbari.
written
It
was
statement
that
chronology of events narrated therein from
1979 onwards reveal a systematic pattern of
fraud, suppression and abuse of process that
has resulted in appellant no.2 - defendant
no.2 Shakar Darbari and others being deprived
of property.
56.
It was further contended that there is
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
no Official Liquidator who is appointed for
the
plaintiff
company
which
is
under
liquidation and therefore, notice issued by
the Registry was upon a non-existent entity
as the plaintiff company was ordered to be
wound up on 10.07.2000.
57.
Reliance was placed on the decision in
cases
of
(i)
S.P.
Chengalvaraya
Naidu
v.
Jagannath reported in (1994) 1 SCC 1, (ii)
A.V.
Papayya
Sastry
v.
Government
Of
A.P.
reported in (2007) 4 SCC 221 and (iii) Ram
Chandra
Singh
v.
Savitri
Devi
reported
in
(2003) 8 SCC 319. Relying upon the aforesaid
decisions, it was submitted that the alleged
fraud
is
including
not
curable
actual
by
subsequent
appointment
of
event
Official
Liquidator in 2000. It was also pointed out
that
the
plaintiff
company
had
become
a
defunct company in 1983 and therefore, such
company cannot sue as it is equivalent to
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
deceased natural person. In support of such
submission,
reliance
was
placed
on
the
following decisions:
(i) Purtabpore Co. Ltd. v. Cane Commissioner
of Bihar reported in (1969) 1 SCC 308.
(ii)
Cotton
United
Corporation
Industrial
Bank
of
India
Ltd.
Ltd.
v.
reported
in
(1983) 4 SCC 625.
(iii) Dale & Carrington Invt. (P) Ltd. v.
P.K. Prathapan reported in (2005) 1 SCC 212.
58.
It was further alleged that decree dated
31.01.1986 was passed ex-parte in favour of
the company that had ceased to exist in law
since 1983 and the Trial Court was misled
into
believing
that
a
living
company
was
prosecuting its claims. Reliance was placed
on the following decisions:
C/FA/531/1986
i)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Sushil Kumar Sabharwal v. Gurpreet Singh
reported in (2002) 5 SCC 377.
ii)
State
Bank
of
Travancore
v.
Kingston
Computers reported in (2011) 11 SCC 524.
iii) A.R. Antulay v. R.S. Nayak reported in
(1988) 2 SCC 602.
59.
It was alleged that advocates appearing
for the plaintiff were not authorised. It was
also pointed out that in 2019, a statement
was made before the Court that appellant no.2
- defendant no.2 Shakar Darbari had expired
which was a false statement and thereafter on
an
application
being
filed
on
20.12.2024,
vide order dated 09.07.2025, the abatement
order
was
recalled,
resulting
into
deprivation of right to access justice for
six years which constitute a grave violation
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
of Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
60.
Reference
was
also
made
to
the
background of the appellants-defendants and
the
respondent-plaintiff
vis-a-vis
national
character of the family of “House of Dubary”
and the plaintiff company and its Director.
61.
Thereafter reference is made to medical
emergency of Shakar Darbari aged 76 years who
was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer and had
undergone
major
surgical
procedure
lasting
for 10 hours and requires immediate access to
funds for continuous treatment. Reliance was
placed on
decision in case of Paschim Banga
Khet Mazdoor Samity v. State of West Bengal
reported in (1996) 4 SCC 37.
62.
Referring
following
to
summary
above
was
propositions:
made
submissions,
of
legal
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
“a) A decree obtained by a defunct,
non-existent company is void ab
initio and a nullity: Sushil Kumar
Sabharwal (supra).
(b) Notice issued to a non-existent
Official
Liquidator
confers
no
jurisdiction: A. V. Papayya Sastry
(supra).
(c) Fraud on the court vitiates all
proceedings:
S.P.
Chengalvaraya
Naidu (supra); A. V. Papayya Sastry
(supra); Ram Chandra Singh (supra).
(d) A company without a Board of
Directors
cannot
authorise
litigation:
Dale
&
Carrington
(supra); State Bank of Travancore
(supra); Patel Roadways (supra).
(e)
The
ROC's
failure
under
mandatory Section 560(3) is a breach
of statutory duty: Purtabpore Co.
Ltd.
(supra).
Winding
up
of
a
defunct company is futile: Cotton
Corporation (supra).
(f) Deprivation of property for 47
years
without
authority
of
law
violates Article 300A. Restitution
mandatory: Southeastern Coalfields
(supra).
(g) A 40-year pendency violates
Article
21:
Hussainara
Khatoon
(supra).
Denial
of
livelihood
violates right to life: Olga Tellis
(supra).
(h)
Abatement
without
a
death
certificate violates Order XXII Rule
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
4 CPC and Article 21.
(i) The Court must correct its own
errors ex debito justitiae: A.R.
Antulay (supra).
(j) Courts must refuse assistance to
economic offenders: Tapas D. Neogy
(supra). Right to emergency medical
care is fundamental: Paschim Banga
Khet Mazdoor Samity (supra).”
63.
the
It was therefore, prayed to set aside
Judgment
and
Decree
dated
31.01.1986
passed in Special Civil Suit No.120 of 1979
and further prayed for immediate release of
money deposited in Fixed Deposits with State
Bank of India with interest.
64.
It is also prayed to dismiss the Cross
appeal and initiate proceedings under section
340 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
for fraud practiced upon the Court and award
compensation of Rs. 50 crores with exemplary
cost
of
Rs.
crore
and
further
pass
strictures against the advocates who appeared
for
the
company
in
liquidation
without
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
sanction under section 446 of the Companies
Act, 1956.
65.
Considering
the
order
passed
by
this
Court dismissing
Civil application filed by
the
No.2
Appellant
averments
,
these
contending
submissions
similar
are
not
required to be dealt with as the appeal filed
by the defendant nos. 1 to 4 was heard at
length
and
is
hereby
decided
considering
submissions made by the learned advocates of
both the sides.
3)Issues framed by the Trial Court and summary
of findings
66.
The Trial Court framed following issues
at Exh. 218 and findings on the issues are
also recorded in para no.48 of the judgment
which are summarised as under:
Issue
ISSUES
FINDINGS
No.
1)
Whether the def. Nos. 1 In
the
C/FA/531/1986
2)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
to 4 prove that the negative
plaintiff Hanspa Knit
(P)
Ltd.,
has
been
committed the breach of
contract ?
If
so,
they
are
entitled to recover the
amount as claimed in
the counter claim ?
Whether the plaintiff Yes.
As
M/s. Hanspa Knit (P) order
Ltd., is entitled to
all or any reliefs on
basis
of
the
allegations as made in
the plaint?
2-(A)
Whether
this
court has jurisdiction
to entertain the suit
of the plaintiff Hanspa
(P) Ltd., against the
defts.?
(2-B) Whether it is
proved
that
the
deft.Nos. 5 & 6 of the
suit are not necessary
or proper parties and
that the suit is bad?
(2-C) Whether the deft.
Nos. 1 to 4 prove that
there was no privity of
contract
between
the
parties ?
(2-D) Whether the deft.
Nos. 1 to 4 prove that
the
contract
in
question is void on the
ground of the violation
law and regulation.
(2-E) Whether the deft.
per
In
the
affirmative
Defendant no.5
and
are
necessary
and
proper parties
as the nature
of the suit.
In
the
negative.
No
No
C/FA/531/1986
3)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Nos. 1 to 4 prove that
the
plaintiff
M/s.
Hanspa Knit (P) Ltd.,
is estopped in view of
the letter dated 16-379 from recovery of the
suit amount?
(2-F)
Whether
the
plaint
signed
and
verified by Shree A.C.
Pota
is
legal
and
valid?
If, not, what effects?
(2-G) Whether the suit
is maintainable in the
present form?
What order and decree
regarding to the suit
and counter claim?”
Yes.
In
the
affirmative
In
the
affirmative
As per order
4)Oral Evidence
67.
Both
the
sides
produced
evidence
and
examined
documentary
witnesses
who
were
cross examined during the trial.
68.
The
plaintiff
Chandubhai
Pota
at
has
examined
Exh.
276,
Anilbhai
the
then
Director who is also cross examined on behalf
of the defendants.
C/FA/531/1986
69.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
In
his
Chandubhai
examination-in-chief,
Pota
has
produced
the
Anilbhai
orders
placed by the defendant nos. 1 to 4 which
were exhibited as Exh. 278 to Exh.281. Letter
of confirmation of those orders is produced
at Exh.282. Letters of Credit are produced at
Exh.283 to 289 and 290 to 309. Invoices and
documents of the second consignment at Exh.
to
Exh.315.
Documents
of
third
consignment are at Exh. 316 to 317. Amount of
sale consideration received by the defendant
nos. 1 to 4 in their bank account which is
kept in Fixed Deposit in Sundry account and
bank statement thereof is produced at Exh.
318 which is received in two parts. First
with regard to goods of standard quality and
second part when dispute of standard quality
was given up by the buyers and entire amount
was
received.
Copies
of
AR-4
Forms
are
produced from Exh. 319 to 322. Fixed Deposit
Receipts of the amount received by defendant
C/FA/531/1986
no.1
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
are
produced
at
Exh.
323.
Copies
of
letter of the State Bank of India along with
documents returned to defendant no.6 being
Exh. 324 and 325. Telex messages are produced
from Exh. 326 to 333 regarding communication
for
confirmation.
Notice
issued
by
the
customs authorities to defendant nos. 1 to 5
on
08.10.1979
and
its
reply
is
given
by
defendant nos. 1 to 4 at Exh.334 to Exh. 336.
Order of penalty dated 02.01.1981 passed by
Special
Officer
of
the
Customs
Department
upon defendant nos. 1 to 4 at Exh. 337. Telex
Message of defendant nos. 1 to 4 accepting
the
mistake
and
agreement
for
payment
at
Exh.338. Copies of communication between the
plaintiff and defendant no.5 is produced at
Exh.
to
348.
Copy
of
communication
between customs officer and defendant no.5 at
Exh. 349. Telex message from the defendants
at
Exh.350.
by
the
Freight bill of spare part sent
plaintiff
to
Yugoslavian
buyer
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
regarding 2nd and 3rd consignment at Exh.352.
Details
of
letter
dated
26.10.1978
of
the
defendants having agreed to extend the period
for
delivery
plaintiff
on
of
goods
received
17.12.1978
at
by
Exh.353.
the
Telex
messages between the parties from 12.12.1978
to
30.04.1979
written
by
at
Exh.354
Customs
to
368.
authority
to
Letter
defendant
no.5 at Exh. 369.
70.
In
the
cross
examination
and
re-
examination, witness of the plaintiff denied
that
the
plaintiff
was
liable
to
pay
the
airfreight. It was also denied that due to
financial crisis, defendant nos. 1 to 4 paid
the airfreight.
71.
The witness of the plaintiff also placed
on record letter dated 10.03.1979 addressed
to defendant no.5 to return the goods which
is exhibited as Exh. 450. Various documents
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
containing the communication by the plaintiff
for
export
of
third
consignment
were
exhibited from Exh. 453 to Exh. 461.
72.
Witness
of
the
plaintiff
denied
the
contentions of the defendants whereby it was
proposed
that
counter
claim
placed
by
defendant nos. 1 to 4 was part of the letter
at Exh. 205.
73.
It
was
contended
on
behalf
of
the
plaintiff that though defendant nos. 1 to 4
have received the payment from Yugoslavian
buyers, same was not paid to the plaintiff,
inspite of the fact that it was known to the
defendants that the manufacturer who exported
the goods was the plaintiff and therefore, by
collusion, the defendants have deprived the
plaintiff of its legitimate dues, inspite of
having full knowledge of the true facts and
having received original airway bill showing
C/FA/531/1986
the
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
name
of
the
plaintiff
in
column
of
shippers and therefore, the defendants could
not have retained the entire amount received
from Yugoslavian buyers and as such, all the
defendants are jointly and severally liable
for the amount claimed by the plaintiff of
Rs.62,91,245.18.
74.
The defendants have examined one witness
defendant
no.4
Deepak
examination
in
chief,
Durbari.
he
In
his
reiterated
the
contentions in the written statement and has
placed the original partnership deed at Exh.
416,
letter
dated
19.06.1979
at
Exh.
417,
Letter received from Yugoslavian buyers at
Exh.418, Copies of certificate of export at
Exh. 420 to 425, Copies of airway bill of 1 st
consignment at Exh.426, copies of invoice of
2nd consignment at Exh. 427 to 428, Copies of
telegram and telex message of the transaction
entered into by Hasmukh Brothers (HK) from
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Exh. 429 to Exh. 435.
75.
In the cross examination made on behalf
of the plaintiff, defendant no.4 has accepted
the documents with counter claim which are
exhibited at Exh. 437 to 441.
5) Orders passed by the Trial Court and orders
in appeals
76.
The Trial Court after considering oral
and
documentary
evidence
led
by
both
the
sides partly allowed the suit in favour of
the Plaintiff as under:
“ORDER
The documents mark-202/6,
mark413/32, mark-413/33, mark-413/45 and
mark-466/ (1) are hereby permitted and
allowed to be exhibited.
The Special Civil Suit No 120 of 1979
is hereby partly allowed and decreed.
The plaintiff M/s Hanspa Knit (P)
Ltd.,
Kandla,
Gandhidham
Kachchh
is
entitled to recover the sum of Rs.
49,81,336-00
(Rupees
forty
nine
lac,
eighty one thousand three hundred thirty
six only.) from the defendant Nos. 1 to 4
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
with running interest at rate of twelve
per cent per annum from the date of the
suit till realization.
It is therefore ordered that the
defendant Nos. 1 to 4 shall pay the amount
of Rs. 49,81,33 with running interest at
rate of twelve percent per annum from the
date of the suit till date of the payment
to the plaintiff.
The rest of the claim and that suit
against the defendant Nos. 5 & 6 stand to
be dismissed.
It is hereby ordered that the
defendant Nos. 1 to 4 are restrained to
take money from standing sundry account in
New Bank of India Ltd., D-47 Defence
Colony., New Delhi and be directed to be
deposited the entire amount lying in such
sundary account of New Bank of India Ltd.,
New Delhi, in the court for payment and
satisfaction of the decree passed against
them in Special Civil Suit No. 120 of
1979.
It is further ordered that the
sixth defendant New Bank of India Ltd., D47,
Defence
Colony,
New
Delhi
is
prohibited to pay any money standing and
lying in sundry account to the defendant
Nos. 1 to 4 and be directed to be
deposited all money lying in such sundry
account, into court within three months
from the date of this order for the
payment
and
satisfied
decree
passed
against the defendant Nos.1 to 4.
bear
The defendant Nos. 1 to 4 shall
their own costs and costs of the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
plaintiff and that the defendant Nos 5 & 6
shall bear their own costs.
Decree will be draw accordingly in
favour of the plaintiff in Special Civil
Suit No. 120 of 1979.
The counter claim by way of the
cross suit which being filed by House of
Dubary and partners thereof is liable to
be dismissed and it is hereby dismissed.
The plaintiffs in the counter claim
by way of the cross-suit shall bear their
own costs and costs of the defendants.
Decree will be drawn accordingly.”
77.
Being
aggrieved
by
the
Judgment
and
Decree, First Appeal No.531 of 1986 is filed
by
the
original
defendant
challenging
the
Judgment
31.01.1986
passed
by
and
the
nos.
Decree
Trial
to
dated
Court
and
First Appeal 1093/1987 was filed by plaintiff
company under liquidation.
78.
The appeal was admitted by order dated
11.04.1986 [Coram : Hon’ble Mr. Justice M.B.
Shah and Hon’ble Mr. Justice R.A. Mehta (As
their Lordships Were Then)].
C/FA/531/1986
79.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Thereafter
by
order
dated
02.11.2006,
notice was issued to the Official Liquidator.
It
appears
taken
for
onwards
that
the
regular
and
the
matter
final
matter
was
thereafter
hearing
was
from
adjourned
from
time to time on one ground or the another,
either
time
was
being
sought
by
the
appellants-defendants or by the respondent.
80.
It
appears
that
Civil
Application
No.1094 of 1986 was filed for stay wherein
interim
order
was
passed
by
the
Division
Bench on 28.04.1986 calling upon the New Bank
of India, Delhi to transfer an amount of Rs.
37.5 Lacs to the State Bank of India, Main
Branch, Ahmedabad to be invested in the name
of the Additional Registrar, High Court of
Gujarat which was transferred on 17.06.1986.
Civil Application No.2256/1986 was filed by
the plaintiff with a prayer to permit the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
withdrawal of the amount of Rs. 37.5 Lacs
which was standing in the name of Additional
Registrar, High Court of Gujarat, pursuant to
the
order
alternative
dated
to
28.04.1986
invest
the
or
in
the
amount
of
Rs.37,67,420/- in any nationalised bank for a
period as may be specified by the Court. It
was also prayed to direct the New Bank of
India, to transfer Rs. 30 Lacs standing in
the Fixed Deposit account of the defendant
nos. 1 to 4 together with interest or in the
alternative to issue injunction against the
bank from operating and/or withdrawing any
amount from the Fixed Deposit account.
81.
This Court (Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice
I.C.
Bhatt
and
Hon’ble
Mr.
Justice
J.P.
Desai, As their Lordships were then) by order
dated
23.09.1988
directed
to
deposit
the
amount received by the Additional Registrar
with the Bank of Baroda, Navrangpura branch,
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Ahmedabad for a period of three months which
was renewed from time to time.
82.
It is reported that as per the latest
status
report
obtained
from
State
Bank
of
India, GHCC Branch, Sola, if fixed deposit is
encashed prematurely, the payment amount will
be
about
Rs.7,14,70,627/-
approximately
[(P)1,91,04,323/- + (I)5,23,66,304/-)
6)Submissions of appellants-defendants
83.
Learned advocate Mr. C.B. Upadhyaya on
behalf of the appellants- original defendant
nos. 1 to 4
submitted that the Trial Court
lacked territorial jurisdiction under section
20 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 and
that
the
most
fundamental
and
threshold
challenge to the impugned judgment is that
the
learned
Trial
Court
at
Bhuj
lacked
territorial jurisdiction to entertain and try
the
suit.
The
entire
proceedings
are
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
therefore, a nullity and the decree is void
ab initio.
It was submitted that Section 20
of the Code of Civil Procedure provides that
a suit may be instituted in a Court within
whose
local
limits
the
defendant
resides,
carries on business, or personally works for
gain;
or
any
of
the
defendants
resides,
carries on business, or personally works for
gain; or the cause of action, wholly or in
part, arises. It was submitted that in the
present
case,
neither
the
Appellants-
defendants who are at New Delhi nor the cause
of action which took place at Delhi/Bombay
had any connection with Bhuj as the Place of
Contract Formation was Delhi and not Kandla.
However,
the
Trial
court
held
that
the
contract was formed at Kandla, relying upon
the letter dated 18.11.1978 (Ex. 205) written
by the Plaintiff which is erroneous finding.
It was submitted that the Trial court gave
the
reason
that
on
04.10.1978,
the
orders
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
were placed by Defendants No. 1 to 4, which
constituted the 'proposal' within the meaning
of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, and that
the
letter
various
dated
18.11.1978
conditions
'acceptance'
by
stipulating
constituted
the
Plaintiff,
the
thereby
forming the contract at Kandla.
84.
It was submitted that this reasoning is
fundamentally
misconceived
because
as
per
Sections 2, 3 and 4 of the Indian Contract
Act,
1872,
a
proposal
is
accepted
either
expressly or impliedly by the acceptor. It
was submitted that in the present case, there
was no separate contract between the parties
with regards to the sale of goods and it is
an
admitted
position
in
the
plaint
itself
that the sale of goods was to take place on
the terms of the Letters of Credit which were
to be opened by Defendants No. 1 to 4 in
favour of the Plaintiff. The precondition for
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the execution of the confirmed order was the
opening of the Letters of Credit in favour of
the Plaintiff and the Letters of credit were
opened on 05.10.1978 in Delhi by New Bank of
India at the request of Defendants No. 1 to
4. It was submitted that when the plaintiff
accepted
the
Letters
of
Credit
as
the
beneficiary, the proposal of Defendants No. 1
to 4 was accepted. It was further submitted
that admittedly, the Letters of Credit were
opened in Delhi and therefore, the place of
contract was Delhi and not Kandla and the
Trial Court's conclusion that the place of
contract
was
Kandla
is
erroneous
and
misconceived.
85.
It was submitted that before the first
shipment was made on 27.11.1978, the Letters
of Credit (which were the only terms of the
contract between the parties) were amended
and
modified
on
09.10.1978,
14.10.1978,
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
20.10.1978, and 18.11.1978, all of which were
communicated to the Plaintiff with sufficient
knowledge.
Therefore,
18.11.1978
at
the
Exh.205
letter
written
dated
by
the
Plaintiff, which the Trial Court relied upon
as the ‘acceptance’, was written after the
contract had already been concluded through
the Letters of credit and therefore, reliance
on
this
letter
to
determine
the
place
of
contract is, therefore, legally untenable.
86.
Learned advocate Mr. Upadhyaya for the
appellants- defendant nos. 1 to 4 submitted
that place of performance of the contract was
Bombay and not Kandla and the finding of the
Trial Court that the place of delivery of
goods was Kandla, relying upon Sections 36
and 39 of the Sale of Goods Act, 1930 is
erroneous
as
the
Letters
of
credit
were
amended to permit shipment by air from Bombay
Airport to Greece Airport. It was submitted
C/FA/531/1986
that
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
this
condition
was
stipulated
in
the
Letters of Credit and was made aware to the
Plaintiff
and
performance
of
conditions
of
therefore,
the
the
the
contract,
Letters
of
place
of
per
the
Credit,
was
as
Bombay and not Kandla. Furthermore, it is an
admitted
position
in
the
plaint
that
Defendant no.5-M/s. Airfreight (P) Ltd. acted
in its capacity as the agent of the Plaintiff
and was holding the goods as an agent of the
Plaintiff
and
only
effected
be
the
delivery
when
of
goods
would
the
goods
were
airlifted from Bombay, and not at Kandla and
therefore,
the
place
of
performance
was
Bombay.
87.
It was further submitted that Sections
36 and 39 of the Sale of Goods Act can only
be pressed into service in the absence of any
express contract with regards to the delivery
of goods whereas in the present case, the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Plaintiff himself admitted that the delivery
of goods was to be handed over at Bombay. It
was therefore submitted that the benefit of
Sections 36 and 39 of the Sale of Goods Act
is not available to the Plaintiff. It was
submitted
that
however,
the
Trial
Court
ignored that the goods were transported to
Defendant no.5-M/s. Airfreight (P) Ltd. in
terms
of
the
conditions
of
the
Letter
of
Credit so as to export the goods from Bombay
which would be the final proof of delivery.
Therefore, the provisions of Sections 36 and
39 of the Sale of Goods Act cannot be pressed
into service to conclude that the goods were
delivered at Kandla.
88.
Learned advocate Mr. Upadhyaya for the
appellants-defendants
submitted
that
the
place of payment of consideration was Delhi
and
not
Kandla.
However,
the
Trial
Court
committed an error in holding that since the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
negotiating
bank
favour
the
of
was
to
make
Plaintiff
at
payment
Kandla,
in
the
performance of the contract had taken place
at Kandla.
89.
It was submitted that the privity of
contract between the negotiating bank and the
Plaintiff
is
entirely
different
from
the
privity of contract between the Plaintiff and
the
Defendants.
It
was
submitted
that
the
negotiating bank acts as an agent of the LC
Opening Bank
(New Bank of India, Delhi) and
the LC Opening Bank
liable
is the party primarily
to
the
beneficiary
Therefore,
the
place
of
under
payment
the
LCs.
under
the
contract was Delhi, where the LC Opening Bank
was located.
90.
Learned advocate Mr. Upadhyaya for the
appellants-defendants
submitted
that,
the
cause of action, in its entirety, arose in
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Delhi (contract formation and payment) and
Bombay
(performance).
Therefore,
the
Trial
Court at Bhuj had no jurisdiction whatsoever
to
entertain
the
suit
and
therefore,
the
entire proceedings are void and the decree is
a nullity.
91.
In support of his submission, reliance
was placed on the following decisions:
1)
Bhagwandas
Goverdhandas
Kedia
v.
Girdharilal parshottamdas & Co. reported in
AIR 1966 SC 543.
2)
A.b.C.
Laminart
Pvt.
Ltd.
v.
A.P.
Agencies reported in AIR 1989 SC 1239.
3)
Union of India v. Ladulal Jain reported
in AIR 1963 SC 1681.
4)
Patel Roadways ltd. v. Prasad Trading Co.
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
reported in AIR 1991 SC 1514.
92.
Learned advocate Mr. Upadhyaya for the
appellants-defendants
Trial
Court
erred
submitted
in
holding
that
the
that
the
contract was independent of the Letters of
Credit. It was submitted that the Letters of
Credit are individual contracts independent
of the terms and conditions of the underlying
contract
of
sale.
However,
in
the
present
case, the only terms and conditions of the
contract which have been placed into service
by
the
Plaintiff
were
the
terms
and
conditions of the Letters of Credit. No other
contract was executed between the parties. It
was
submitted
that
as
per
the
Letters
of
Credit, the goods were to be delivered from
Bombay
Airport
to
Greece
Airport
and
this
condition was stipulated in the Letters of
Credit and was made aware to the Plaintiff.
Therefore, the terms of the Letters of Credit
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
were the terms of the contract between the
parties, and the Trial Court's finding that
the contract was independent of the Letters
of Credit is erroneous. It was submitted tha
the
Letters
specific
of
Credit,
as
amended,
had
date
for
shipment
being
expiry
a
01.12.1978 and for negotiation of documents
being
30.12.1978.
The
Plaintiff
dispatched
the second consignment on 27.12.1978, after
the Letters of Credit had expired and the
third consignment was dispatched in JanuaryApril
1979,
Credit
had
months
after
expired.
It
the
Letters
of
was
therefore,
submitted that there was, no valid contract
under which the Plaintiff could claim payment
for the second and third consignments.
93.
Learned
advocate
for
the
appellants-
defendants submitted that the counter-claim
filed by the defendants was wrongly held to
be
barred
under
section
of
the
Indian
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Partnership Act, 1932 and the Trial Court had
wrongly
claim
dismissed
of
the
defendants'
Rs.1,08,85,152/-
counter-
solely
on
the
ground that M/s. “House of Dubary” was not a
registered partnership firm, invoking the bar
under Section 69(3) of the Indian Partnership
Act, 1932.
94.
It was further submitted that the bar
under
Section
does
not
apply
to
the
counter-claim as the counter-claim is not a
'suit' within the meaning of Section 69(1)
and (2) of the Indian Partnership Act because
it is a proceeding incidental to the main
suit. It was submitted that the appellantsdefendants were not instituting a separate
suit,
they
were
defending
the
Plaintiff's
claim and asserting their own rights arising
from
the
Plaintiff's
breach
in
the
same
submitted
that
the
proceedings.
It
was
counter-claim
is
covered
under
sub-section
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
(4) of Section 69 of the Indian Partnership
Act as an exception and Sub-section (4)(b)
provides that the section shall not apply to
any suit or claim of set off not exceeding
one hundred rupees in value. It was submitted
that though the amount exceeds Rs. 100, the
counter-claim is in the nature of a defensive
claim arising from the same transaction, and
the
spirit
of
the
exception
should
be
applied. Learned advocate Mr. Upadhyaya for
the appellants-defendants submitted that the
Trial Court's interpretation is inconsistent
as the Plaintiff sued the Appellant-firm as a
legal entity under Order XXX of the CPC and
the Trial Court passed a decree against the
firm and its partners, however, it is legally
untenable
to
recognize
the
firm
for
the
purpose of being sued but to de-recognize it
for the purpose of its own claim in the very
same suit. It was submitted that if the firm
can be a defendant, it can also be a claimant
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
in a counter-claim. It was further submitted
that,
the
right
to
defend
a
suit
is
a
fundamental right and to deny the appellantsdefendants
the
counter-claim,
right
which
to
prosecute
their
arises
from
very
the
same transaction and is intrinsically linked
to the Plaintiff's claim, amounts to denying
them an effective right to defend. It was
submitted that the bar under Section 69 of
the Partnership Act was not intended to be
used as a sword by the Plaintiff to unjustly
enrich itself. It was submitted that though
the
Trial
Court
relied
upon
the
case
of
Babulal Dhandhania v. Gautam and Co. reported
in AIR 1950 Cal. 391 and in case of Ajit
Kumar Maity v. Naranarainath Jana reported in
AIR 1955 Cal. 224 to hold that the counterclaim is barred, however, learned advocate
for the appellants-defendants submitted that
these cases do not apply to the facts of the
present case and that the counter-claim is
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
not a proceeding to enforce a right arising
from the contract in the same manner as a
suit but it is a defensive claim arising from
the
plaintiff's
Referring
to
own
the
breach
of
contract.
decision
in
case
of
Vishwanath Lohia v. Allahabad Bank (AIR 1979
All. 12) relied upon by the Trial Court to
hold that a counter-claim has the same effect
as
a
cross-suit,
Upadhyaya
for
learned
the
advocate
Mr.
appellants-defendants
submitted that even if the counter-claim is
treated
as
a
cross-suit,
it
is
still
maintainable because the cause of action for
the counter-claim is the plaintiff's breach
of
contract,
which
is
different
from
the
cause of action in the main suit and the
counter-claim is intrinsically linked to the
main suit and cannot be separated from it.
95.
In support of his submissions, reliance
was placed on the following decisions:
C/FA/531/1986
1)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Raptakos
Brett
&
Co.
ltd.
v.
Ganesh
Property reported in AIR 1998 SC 3085.
2)
Haldiram Bhujiawala v. Anand Kumar Deepak
Kumar reported in AIR 2000 SC 1287.
3)
Jagdish Chandra Gupta v. Kajaria Traders
(India) Ltd. reported in AIR 1964 SC 1882.
4)
M/s.
Shreeram
Finance
Corporation
v.
Yasin Khan reported in AIR 1989 SC 1769.
5)
Babulal
Dhandhania
v.
Gautam
and
Co.
reported in AIR 1950 Cal 391.
96.
Learned advocate Mr. Upadhyaya for the
appellants-defendants submitted that it was
the plaintiff and not the defendants, who was
in breach of contract. It was submitted that
the Trial Court erred in law in holding that
the
defendants
committed
breach
of
the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
contract by not getting the Letters of Credit
extended and by diverting the airway bills.
It was submitted that this finding of Trial
Court
is
perverse
and
evidence
on
record
committed
by
the
contrary
as
the
plaintiff,
to
the
breach
was
and
not
the
defendants, as the plaintiff dispatched the
second
and
third
consignments
after
the
Letters of Credit had expired, without any
valid
contractual
basis.
It
was
submitted
that the plaintiff also changed its clearing
and
forwarding
(its
own
Airfreight
without
agent)
(P)
the
plaintiff
agent
from
to
M/s.
Dawn
Defendant
India
no.5-M/s.
Ltd.(the
appellants'
defendants'
consent
and
the
ensure
that
the
also
failed
to
agent)
goods were exported in compliance with the
terms
of
therefore,
the
Letters
submitted
of
that
Credit.
the
It
was
appellants-
defendants were under no obligation to accept
or pay for goods shipped in violation of the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
fundamental terms of the contract hence, the
Trial Court's finding that the appellantsdefendants
were
creating
new
a
liable,
contract
tantamount
for
the
to
parties,
which is impermissible in law.
97.
Learned advocate Mr. Upadhyaya for the
appellants-defendants
submitted
that
the
Trial Court has erred in holding that the
defendants
committed
fraud
by
submitting
forged airway bills and exporting goods in
their
own
name
as
this
finding
is
not
supported by the evidence on record. It was
submitted
that
Section
of
the
Indian
Contract Act, 1872, defines ‘fraud’ as the
suggestion as to a fact of that which is not
true by one who does not believe it to be
true, the active concealment of a fact by one
having knowledge or belief of the fact, a
promise
made
performing
it,
without
any
any
other
intention
act
fitted
of
to
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
deceive or any such act or omission as the
law specially declares to be fraudulent. It
was further submitted that, the Trial Court
itself has held in Para 65-66 of the impugned
Judgment that the defendants were not in a
position
to
dominate
the
will
of
the
plaintiff and that the transaction cannot be
considered unconscionable. It was submitted
that the Trial Court further found that the
plaintiff had come forward on its own accord
to
send
the
goods
Transport
Co.
from
Kandla
delivered
the
same
to
Airfreight
(P)
Ltd.
inducement
from
the
through
to
M/s.
Bombay
Defendant
and
and
no.5-M/s.
there
defendants.
Vijay
was
no
Therefore,
the allegation of fraud is not proved. It was
submitted
that
the
appellants-defendants
acted in good faith to carry out the export
of goods as per the contract, however, the
dispute
unable
arose
to
pay
because
the
the
freight
air
plaintiff
charges
was
in
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
advance, which was a requirement under the
Letters
of
Credit
and
the
appellants-
defendants permitted defendant No. 5 to take
delivery of the airway bill on payment of
freight which was a commercial arrangement
and not fraud.
98.
Learned advocate Mr. Upadhyaya for the
appellants-defendants
decreed
amount
is
submitted
arbitrary
and
that
the
based
on
manifest errors as the Trial Court decreed a
sum of Rs.49,81,336/- with 12% interest which
is arbitrary and based on manifest errors of
calculation and law as the Trial Court failed
to
account
contract
for
the
fact
that
no
valid
existed
for
the
second
and
third
consignments, as the Letters of Credit had
expired.
It
was
submitted
that
the
Trial
Court also did not consider the costs borne
by
the
defendants
in
connection
with
the
export of goods or the losses suffered by the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
appellants-defendants due to the plaintiff's
breach of contract or the payments already
made by the defendants to the plaintiff for
the
first
consignment.
It
was
further
submitted that the decreed amount includes
amounts for the third consignment for which
there was no clear evidence of delivery or
acceptance
contract
in
and
accordance
therefore,
calculation is,
with
the
any
Trial
valid
Court's
arbitrary and unsupported by
evidence.
99.
Learned advocate Mr. Upadhyaya for the
appellants-defendants
submitted
that
the
Trial Court has incorrectly fastened joint
and several liability as the plaintiff's suit
alleged that the appellants - Defendant nos.
to
were
jointly
and
severally
liable
along with the clearing agent -Defendant 5
and the New Bank of India -Defendant 6. It
was submitted that the Trial Court could not
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
have exonerated defendant nos. 5 and 6 from
any
liability
in
its
findings.
It
was
submitted that there is a logical and legal
contradiction because when the agents through
whom
the
committed
alleged
fraud
are
liable,
not
or
breach
the
was
principal
cannot be held liable on the same cause of
action and therefore,
the findings of the
Trial Court are not tenable on this issue.
100.
Learned
advocate
Mr.
Upadhyaya
therefore, prayed to quash and set aside the
impugned Judgment and Decree dated 31.01.1986
and dismiss the Civil Suit No. 120 of 1979
filed by the original plaintiff- respondent
no.1
as
being
without
jurisdiction
and
without merits. It was also prayed to allow
the counter claim filed by the appellantsdefendants and pass a decree in their favour.
In the alternative, it was prayed to reduce
the
decreed
amount
to
the
extent
of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
legitimate
claims
and
set-offs
of
the
appellants-defendants.
7)Submissions of the respondent-plaintiff
101.
Learned advocate Mr. Abhijit Joshi for
plaintiff – respondent no.1 submitted
that
the question of jurisdiction has arisen on
the
basis
plaint,
of
the
written
averments
statement,
made
counter
in
the
claim,
rejoinders and the correspondence which took
place between the parties. It was submitted
that the place of suing in the suit arising
out of a contract is governed by Section 20
of Code of Civil Procedure, which states that
suits to be instituted where cause of action
arises wholly or partly, in other words, the
bundle of essential facts which are necessary
for
the
plaintiff
plaintiff
can
entirely
to
to
succeed
the
prove,
in
grounds
the
before
suit,
set-forth
the
refers
in
the
plaint as cause of action. It was submitted
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
that clause (c) of Section 20 of Code of
Civil Procedure makes it clear that a suit
may be instituted within the local limits of
whose jurisdiction the cause of action wholly
or
in
part
arises.
It
was
therefore,
submitted that the making of the contract,
itself is part of the cause of action and the
determination of the place where the contract
was made is part of cause of action.
It was
further
in
submitted
that
as
set
out
the
plaint, the contract was finally concluded on
accepting
the
orders
Kandla, Gandhidham,
by
the
plaintiff
at
Kuchchh and admittedly,
there was a contract between the parties that
the delivery of the goods would take place by
shipment from Kandla and therefore, in such
circumstances, the admitted position is that
the goods were to be lifted by shipment from
Kandla but subsequently, on the request of
the defendants, the goods were lifted by Air
from Bombay and even the plaintiff had agreed
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
to lift the goods by Air from Bombay on the
same terms and conditions of the contract. It
was therefore, submitted that the whole cause
of action arose at Kandla. It was submitted
that there is another aspect of the matter,
that the defendants, requested the plaintiff
to deliver the goods at Bombay by Air, hence,
it is clear that the defendants had requested
to lift the goods by Air from the Bombay.
102.
It
was
case,
terms
submitted
that
in
the
present
there is nothing to show that the
and
conditions
of
the
contract
were
altered for the payment of the goods as the
terms of the contract
were that the price of
the goods should have been paid by LC Opening
bank
to
State
Bank
of
India
at
Kandla,
therefore, the place of payment was certainly
at Kandla and not at Bombay. It was submitted
that
there were preliminary negotiations at
Bombay,
Delhi
and
Hongkong
and
then
the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Letters of Credit were opened and orders were
placed
by
the
defendants
and
these
orders
were accepted by the plaintiff at Kandla. It
was submitted that this would show that the
acceptance of the offer was made at Kandla.
It was submitted that this being so, it is
clear that the cause of action had arisen at
Kandla
and
therefore,
Court
at
Bhuj
would
also have jurisdiction to entertain the suit
filed by the plaintiff.
103.
Learned
advocate
Mr.
Joshi
for
the
respondent no. 1 submitted that the suit is
based upon the breach of the contract for
recovery of the price of the second and the
third consignments from the defendants Nos.1
to 4. It was submitted that the suit is based
on two counts, first,
and
second,
the
the breach of contract
damage
resulting
from
the
tort have been mentioned in the plaint. It
was submitted that admittedly, the goods of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
third consignment were sent from Kandla to
Bombay for the purpose of the export to the
defendant No.5, through M/s. Vijay Transport
Co. therefore, the Civil Judge (S.D.) at Bhuj
would have jurisdiction to try and decide the
suit on all counts, and hence issue No.2-A is
rightly decided in the affirmative.
104.
Learned
that
the
advocate
contract
Mr.
was
Joshi
entered
submitted
between
the
plaintiff and the defendants Nos.1 to 4 and
under
the
contract,
the
components
of
electronic goods which were being imported,
were to be exported after assembling to six
Yugoslavian buyers and the goods relating to
third
consignment
were
sent
through
M/s.
Vijay Transport Co. from Kandla to Bombay by
the plaintiff as the name of the consignor
and the name of defendant No.5 was mentioned
as consignee in the consignment note. It was
submitted that nowhere in goods consignment
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
note of M/s. Vijay Transport Co., the name of
the
defendant
No.1
was
mentioned
as
consignee. Thus, the defendant No.5 received
the goods from M/s. Vijay Transport Co. for
and on behalf of the plaintiff as the agent
of the plaintiff but the defendant Nos.1 to 5
acted in collusion with each other because
the defendant No.5 deliberately did not send
the Airway bill to the plaintiff but sent the
said Airway bill to the defendant No.1, and
thereby
defrauded
the
plaintiff.
It
was
further submitted that the defendant No.5,
ought not to have mentioned the “House of
Dubary”,
New
Delhi
in
the
"Shipper",
in
the
Airway
Column
bill
as
of
the
defendant No.5 was well aware that the goods
were forwarded by the plaintiff from Kandla
Free
Trade
Custom
Zone
duty,
which
as
the
were
exempted
plaintiff
was
from
having
license and the goods were lying within the
vicinity
of
the
Free
Trade
Zone
Kandla.
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Learned advocate Mr. Joshi further submitted
that the witness on behalf of the respondent
-original
plaintiff-
namely
Shree
Anilbhai
Chandubhai Pota who was examined at Ex.276,
has stated that the factory of the plaintiff
company
Free
was
Trade
situated
within
Zone
Kandla,
of
the
and
limits
of
all
the
benefits of the Free Trade Zone Kandla
were
availed and plaintiff was not liable to pay
customs duty for imports and exports of the
goods. It was submitted that Shree Anilbhai
Chandubhai Pota
had also stated that the
defendants Nos.2 to 4 had placed four orders
in name of the defendant No. 1 who opened the
said Letters of Credit
which
bears
the
produced at Ex.278 to
signature
of
the
defendant No.3. It was further deposed by the
said witness that the defendants Nos.1 to 4
also gave confirmation of those orders and
the letter of confirmation of the orders is
produced at Ex.282. It was submitted that the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
said
witness
has
also
stated
that
the
Yugoslavian buyers were supposed to open the
Letters of Credit in favour of the defendant
No.1, in the Bank of Defendant No.1 i.e. New
Bank of India, New Delhi -Defendant No.6. It
was further deposed that out of those seven
orders, relating to the Letters of Credit,
the
defendant
No.1
opened
four
letters
of
credit in favour of the plaintiff's bank –
i.e. State Bank of India, Kandla which are
produced at Exh.290 to Exh.309, along with
other papers. It was also deposed that the
goods
relating
consignments
defendant
to
were
No.5
and
the
second
supplied
the
and
third
through
the
defendant
No.5
was
supposed to send the Airway bills for the
second
and
third
consignments
to
the
plaintiff, however, the defendant No.5 did
not
send
those
Airway
bills
and
sent
to
defendants Nos.1 to 4. It is also stated in
the deposition that the defendants Nos.1 to 4
C/FA/531/1986
had
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
then
submitted
those
Airway
bills
directly to the defendant No.6 New Bank of
India, New Delhi and the Airway bills were
forged and goods were exported on the basis
of
the
fabricated
documents.
It
was
also
submitted that, the custom authorities had
issued notice to the defendants Nos.1 to 4
and
recorded
their
statements
which
are
produced at Exh.334 to Exh. 336. The witness
of
the
plaintiff
has
also
said
that
the
defendants Nos.1 to 4 were also prosecuted
for
the
breach
of
the
provisions
of
the
Customs Act and were held guilty for the same
and
the
Judgment
thereof
is
produced
at
Exh.337, thereafter the defendants Nos.1 to 4
had
preferred
the
appeal
before
Board
of
Revenue at New Delhi and the said appeal was
allowed and the order of punishment against
the defendants Nos.1 to 4 was set aside. It
was further submitted that the defendant No.5
was bound to export the goods relating to
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
third consignment within one month and if it
was not possible then the goods should have
been returned at Kandla. However, the goods
of third consignment were detained for about
five months and were not exported within the
stipulated
time
limits,
therefore,
various
letters were written to the defendant No.5
asking
to
return
the
goods
of
the
third
consignment at Kandla, but defendant No.5 did
not give any heed to the said letters which
are produced at Exh.339 to Exh.347. It was
submitted
that
the
plaintiff
company
also
wrote a letter to Assistant Customs Collector
at Bombay and at Kandla which is placed at
Exh.348, and therefore the Assistant Customs
Collector
at
Kandla
wrote
the
letter
at
Exh.349 to the defendant No.5 and informed
the defendant No.5 to return the goods at
Kandla.
The
therefore
witness
the
has
also
stated
that
defendant
No.5
sent
telex
message and thereby gave threat, that they
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
would
cancel
other
orders.
correspondence
took
place
Copies
between
of
the
plaintiff and the defendants Nos.1 to 5 are
produced at Exhs.450 to 460.
105.
Learned
advocate
for
the
plaintiff
-
respondent no. 1 submitted that the documents
produced at Exhs. 328, 335, 336, 339 to 349,
357 to 358, 369, 443, 451 to 456 and 459
clearly proves that the respondent-original
plaintiff
Freight
was
not
relating
liable
for
to
pay
second
the
and
Air
third
consignments but the defendant No.1, had to
make the payments thereof. It was submitted
that the Letters of Credit were amended on
F.O.B. basis and Air Freight was to be paid
by
“House
of
Dubary”
-
appellant
No.1
Company. In this regard, reliance was placed
on
the
4.12.1978
Telex
to
message
show
that
at
Exh.357
dated
the
defendant
No.1
agreed to pay airfreight on F.O.B. basis and
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
therefore, there was no question to pay the
airfreight
by
the
and
second
therefore,
the
respondent-plaintiff
third
submitted
consignments.
that
the
for
It
was
respondent-
plaintiff was not liable to pay airfreight
when goods were handed over to the defendant
No.5, for the purpose of the export as the
carriers.
106.
It was further submitted that the goods
relating
to
third
consignment
were
sent
through M/s. Vijay Transport Co., Gandhidham,
via
Truck bearing registration No. GTY 3883
from Kandla to Bombay on 9.12.1978 showing
plaintiff as "Consignor" in goods consignment
note and showing the name of M/s. Dawn India
as consignee and therefore, M/s. Dawn India
as the representative of the plaintiff handed
over
the
goods
to
the
defendant
No.5,
on
27.12.1978 for the purpose of exporting those
goods to Yugoslavian buyers. It was submitted
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
that the defendant No.5 was the carrier and
the plaintiff was the owner of the goods and
the
goods
were
handed
over
for
shipment,
subject to the payment of airfreight by the
defendant
No.1
and
the
goods
were
to
be
exported to Yugoslavia via Athens (Greece) on
behalf of the plaintiff.
107.
It
was
submitted
that
the
plaintiff
wrote the letter vide Exh.339 dated 13.1.1979
to
the
defendant
No.5
to
remit
all
the
documents to the plaintiff and also informed
the defendant No.5 that the defendant No.5
would
would
be
be
responsible
for
answerable
all
payments
to
the
and
customs
authorities. It was submitted that thereafter
the plaintiff wrote another letter at Exh.
342 dated 3.3.1979 to the defendant No.5 and
requested him to call upon the documents from
the defendant No.1 and requested to hand over
the same to the plaintiff so as to enable the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
plaintiff to
submitted
Customs
negotiate with the Bank. It was
that
both
Authorities
the
plaintiff
intimated
by
and
the
writing
several letters and by Telex messages to the
defendant No.5, and requested to return the
goods
at
Kandla,
however,
the
goods
were
lifted and exported to Yugoslavia by using
the
name
of
the
defendant
No.1,
as
the
consignor in the Airway bill at Exh. 317 of
the third consignment.
108.
It was therefore, submitted that in view
of the facts emerging from the record
and
documentary
the
evidence
produced
before
learned Trial Court, it is not in dispute
that the name of the defendant No.1, has been
shown in the airway bill at Exh.317 in the
column "shipper's name and address" as “House
of Dubary” New Delhi, India, and the cargo
was lifted from Bombay on 4.5.1979 whereas
the
Airway
bill
at
Exh.315
which
is
in-
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
respect of second consignment has shown in
the column "shipper's name and address" of M/
s. Hanspa Knit (P) Ltd., “House of Dubary”,
Kandla Free Trade Zone, Gandhidham Kachchh,
New
Delhi
India
and
the
second
cargo
was
lifted on 27.12.1978 and it is also not in
dispute that the Airway bill was delivered to
the defendant No.1, by the defendant No.5,
and it was not sent to the plaintiff.
109.
It was further submitted that the goods
relating
to
the
third
consignment
were
exported by the defendant No.5 from Bombay to
Yugoslavia
goods
were
via
Ethens
intended
(Greece)
to
be
and
those
exported
to
Yugoslavian buyers under the orders as placed
by the defendant No.1, being the agent of the
said foreign purchasers, accordingly, those
goods were delivered to the defendant No.5,
on 27.12.1978 by the plaintiff through its
own clearing and forwarding agent M/s. Dawn
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
India, but the defendant No.5 deliberately
and in collusion with the defendants Nos.1 to
4 did not do so. It was therefore, submitted
that
the
plaintiff
demanded
back
the
possession of the goods from the defendants
Nos.1 to 5 in terms of the letter at Exh.369,
however, subsequently on 4.5.1979, the said
goods
were
exported
and
delivered
to
Yugoslavian buyers.
110.
It was also submitted that the defendant
No.6 i.e. New Bank of India was also liable
to make the payments of the second and third
consignments under the Letters of Credit on
receipt of the actual amounts from the Bank
of
the
Yugoslavian
buyers,
however,
the
defendant No.6 failed to do so and supported
the defendant No.1, in releasing the payment
in personal account of the defendant No.1,
which is nothing but collusive fraud on the
part of the defendants. It was submitted that
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the
Yugoslavian
irrevocable
buyers
Letters
of
opened
Credit
seven
towards
the
payments of the goods as the photocopies of
such Letters of Credit are produced at Exh.
to
Exh.289,
however,
in
turn,
the
defendant No.6 - New Bank of India opened
four
Letters
of
Credit
in
favour
of
the
plaintiff in the State Bank of India, Branch
office
Kandla.
It
was
submitted
that
the
photocopies of such Letters of Credit along
with the documents produced at Exh. 290 to
Exh.309
clearly
shows
that
the
defendant
No.1, opened four Letters of Credit valued at
US$
18,67,488-75
equivalent
to
Rs.
1,49,47,909-00 in favour of the plaintiff for
supply of
Letters
the goods as mentioned in the said
of
Credit
namely,
Radio
Cassette,
Transistor Radio, Car Radio, Cassettes etc.
It was pointed out that the Letters of Credit
at
Exh.
290,
Exh.295,
Exh.300
and
Exh.305
were issued on 5.10.1978 and price was fixed
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
on C.I.F. basis for export from Kandla to
THESSALONIKI (Greece), but subsequently, the
date and the time was extended up to 14th
December,
and
30th
December,
1978,
respectively without altering the terms and
conditions of the Letters of Credit.
It was
submitted that the documents relating to this
amendment are produced at Exh.294, Exh.299,
Exh.302
and
amendment
Exh.307
which
and
was
after
the
said
carried
out
on
14.10.1978, further amendment was carried out
on 28.10.1978 with regard to mode of shipment
and amended mode of shipment was by Air from
Bombay
Airport
to
THESSALONIKI
(Greece)
Airport.
111.
Learned
advocate
Mr.
Joshi
for
the
respondent submitted the plaintiff has filed
the suit to recover the price of the second
and third consignments from the defendants
Nos.1 to 4 on the ground that the defendants
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Nos.1 to 4 were working as the agents of the
Yugoslavian buyers and worked as the export
house for the plaintiff and therefore, the
Yugoslavian
Credit
in
buyers
the
opened
name
and
the
in
Letters
favour
of
of
the
defendant No.1, which are on record at Exh.
283 to Exh.289 dated 20.6.1978 and 21.6.1978
and after that the defendant No.1 placed four
orders
with
the
plaintiff
at
Exh.
to
Exh.281 on 4.10.1978 and not only that, but
the defendant No.1, also opened four Letters
of Credit in favour of the plaintiff through
the defendants No.6 - New Bank of India Ltd.,
New Delhi which are also placed at Exh. 290,
Exh.292, Exh.295, Exh.298, Exh.300, Exh.301,
Exh.305
and
Exh.306.
It
was
further
reiterated that the defendant No.1 asked the
confirmation
of
those
orders
and
the
plaintiff in turn made the confirmation in
terms of the letter at Exh. 282, hence,
the
contract was concluded as per the Letter of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Credit which is produced at Exhs. 282. It was
submitted
that
stated
the
Letters
by
it
has
been
specifically
plaintiff
that
the
of
Credit
Yugoslavian
buyers
which
in
were
favour
of
original
opened
by
“House
of
Dubary” New Delhi, and defendant No.1 in turn
opened seven Letters of Credit in the name
and in favour of M/s. Hasmukh Brothers (HK),
Hongkong as per at Exh. 374 to Exh.380 on
4.9.1978 ,however, M/s. Hasmukh Brothers (HK)
Ltd.,
was
unable
to
perform
the
entire
contract work, hence as per mutual consent of
all the parties, it was decided to open three
Letters of Credit in the name and in favour
of M/s. Hasmukh Brothers (HK), Hongkong and
four Letters of Credit to be opened in the
name
and
in
favour
of
the
respondent/plaintiff – i.e. M/s. Hanspa Knit
(P) Ltd., therefore, the Letters of Credit at
Exh. 381, Exh.383 and Exh.386 were opened in
name and in favour of M/s. Hasmukh Brothers
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
(HK) on 5.10.1978 and four Letters of Credit
at Exh.290, Exh.295, Exh.300 and Exh.305 were
opened
in
the
name
and
in
favour
of
the
plaintiff.
112.
It was further submitted that it was not
possible to supply the entire goods of the
orders, within specified time and therefore,
the plaintiff requested to extend the time
limit up to 20.12.1978 for the shipment and
such time limit was extended by the letter at
Exh. 253 dated 26.10.1978, accordingly, the
plaintiff supplied the goods in three parts
on 22.11.1978, 25.11.1978 and on 12.12.1978
relating to the first consignment and that
the amount in Indian Rs.26,80,327.50 was paid
by the defendants Nos. 1 to 4 on the payments
received from
Letters
of
Yugoslavian buyers under the
Credit
as
however, the plaintiff
per
the
contract,
did not receive its
payment of second and third consignments and
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
therefore the present suit is filed.
113.
Learned
advocate
Mr.
Joshi
for
the
respondent no. 1 submitted that the claim has
been setup in Para No.10 of the plaint for an
amount
of
US$
64,80,50-00
for
the
second
consignment and has relied upon the invoices
which are at Exh. 310 to Exh.312 and the
Airway bill which is at Exh. 315. It was
submitted
that
it
is
an
admitted
position
that the defendant No.1, has already received
the payment of goods from Yugoslavian buyers
and agreed to pay such amounts of the second
consignment to the plaintiff in March, 1979
or latest by first week of April, 1979 in
terms of letter at Exh. 205, but the payments
were avoided even after the assurances were
given
respect
by
of
the
the
defendants
third
Nos.1
to
4.
In
consignment,
it
was
submitted that the defendant No.1 sent the
goods to Yugoslavian buyers as per the Airway
C/FA/531/1986
bill
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
at
Exh.317
dated
4.5.1979
the
goods,
the
sending
and
while
defendants
deliberately and willfully omitted to mention
the name of the plaintiff in shipper's column
of the Airway bill and mentioned the name of
defendant No.1 in the shipment sent by the
defendant No.1, therefore, the plaintiff has
set up the claim of the total amount of US$
1,79,157-82, by giving the details in Para
No.13
of
the
plaint
in
respect
of
third
consignment and has relied upon the documents
produced at Exh. 317 and Exh.325 i.e. the
Invoice,
Packing
Certificates,
List,
Certificate
of
Inspection
Origin
and
AirWay Bill. It was submitted that though the
defendant
entire
No.1
amount
had
of
already
third
received
the
consignment
from
Yugoslavian buyers during the pendency of the
suit,
but
no
payment
was
made
to
the
plaintiff and thereby committed the breach of
the contract.
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
114.
Learned advocate Mr. Joshi in reply to
the
contention of the defendants that the
plaintiff failed to supply the goods within
the
specified
extending
the
time
limit
and
even
after
time
limits
and
therefore,
there was a breach of the contract on the
part of the plaintiff and the defendants are
not liable for any loss to the plaintiff or
not liable to pay any money/dues as claimed
in the suit, referred to deposition of Mr.
Deepak Darbari on behalf of the defendants
Nos.1
to
4,
at
Exh.
admitted
that
Mr.
wherein
he
has
Deepak
Darbari
was
the
partner in year the 1978 but retired from the
partnership as a partner, and it was admitted
that the partnership firm is being registered
for the purpose of the Income Tax and not
registered under the Partnership Act. It was
alleged that the plaintiff failed to supply
the
goods
relating
to
second
and
third
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
consignments within stipulated time limit and
defendants have not renewed the Letters of
Credit either in favour of the plaintiff or
in favour of M/s. Hashmukh Brothers (HK) to
submit
that
Deepak
Darbari
has
falsely
contended the appellants/original defendants
has not intimated the respondent/plaintiff to
send
the
goods
of
second
and
third
consignments and not made any fresh contract
thereof and did not give any consent even
after sending the goods of second and third
consignment and that the defendant No.1 has
paid the freight, insurance premium and borne
the expenses of handling the goods for the
second and third consignments and also paid
the demurrage of the goods. It was therefore,
submitted
that
except
deposition
of
the
defendant no.2 there is no other documentary
evidence on record to prove such allegations.
115.
Learned
advocate
Mr.
Joshi
further
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
submitted that the contentions which are put
forth
by
the
appellants/defendants
are
required to be examined in relation to and in
respect
of
the
evidence
available
on
the
record and as a matter of fact, there is
voluminous
evidence
which
proves
that
the
second and third consignments were exported
to Yugoslavian buyers under the contract and
not
exported
at
the
personal
risk
of
the
plaintiff.
116.
It was submitted that the defense put
forth by the appellants/defendants is totally
against the documentary evidence and it is
with a view to avoid the liability thereof,
and
the
entire
correspondence
which
took
place between the parties clearly shows that
the
goods
were
sent
under
F.O.B.
to
the
defendant No.5 for the purpose of export to
Yugoslavian buyers and the Yugoslavian buyers
accepted those goods under the contract and
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
under the Letters of Credit, the amount was
paid to the defendant No.1. It was submitted
that it is also clear from the correspondence
that the defendant No.1, entered in to an
agreement with the defendant No.5, for the
arrangement of the charter on basis of F.O.B.
contract as intimated and it is also clear
from
the
evidence
that
the
plaintiff
repeatedly
asking
the
defendant
No.5
was
to
export the goods of third consignment, but
defendant
because
No.1
delayed
Yugoslavian
to
export
buyers
wanted
the
same
to
re-
validate their license and due to that reason
there was delay in exporting the goods.
117.
It
clear
was
submitted
from
the
Yugoslavian
defendant
it
is
correspondence
buyers
No.1,
that
to
further
that
the
had
intimated
to
the
pay
the
of
the
price
second consignment and the defendant No.1,
promised the Yugoslavian buyers to pay such
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
amount
to
accordingly
the
the
plaintiff
defendant
immediately,
No.1,
gave
the
assurance to the plaintiff that they would
make the payment of the second consignment at
end of March or first week of April 1979. It
was pointed out from the evidence that under
the
terms
of
the
contract,
the
defendant
No.1, has to make the payment of the goods to
the
plaintiff
on
receiving
the
same
from
Yugoslavian buyers though Bank to Bank, but
the defendant No.1 did not make the payment
of
the
second
consignment
even
after
receiving the payment from Yugoslavian buyers
and
kept
in
its
own
account
of
the
partnership firm, hence it was submitted that
the entire correspondence as well as the oral
evidence on the record leave no doubt that
the plaintiff was ready and willing to act as
per the terms of the contract and accordingly
acted upon it also. It was submitted that
oral evidences of the witness Deepak Darbari
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
is
self-contradictory
against
the
correspondence which took place between the
parties
to
the
contract,
therefore,
the
defendants Nos.1 to 4 only with a view to
avoid their liabilities got up such defense,
evidence and arguments which is nothing but
an afterthought.
118.
It
was
therefore
submitted
that
the
learned Trial Court has rightly come to the
conclusion
that
the
defendants
Nos.1
to
committed default in making payments, and it
is also quite clear that the defendant No.1,
was not having any grievance about the delay
in performance of the contract when it was
agreed with the consultant of the Yugoslavian
buyers
to
contract
extend
and
voluntarily.
defendants
the
that
It
was
agreed
to
time
limits
of
the
extension
was
made
submitted
that
the
delivery
of
take
the
goods of the second and third consignments
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
even after the expiration of the time limit
and not complained at any time for the delay
in
the
correspondence
and
accepted
the
delivery even after expiry of time limit.
119.
in
It was therefore submitted that
keeping
view
it
the
impossible
to
documentary
evidences,
accept
version
the
of
is
Mr.
Deepak Darbary that there is no such breach
of
the
contract
by
the
defendants
and
defendants are not liable to make any payment
to the plaintiff.
120.
It
was
plaintiff
further
has
submitted
properly
and
that,
the
sufficiently
explained about the outstanding amount which
is payable by the defendants to the plaintiff
under writing which is on record at Exh. 205
and that cogent evidence at Exh.205 is duly
supported by other documentary evidence and
the oral evidence, hence there was no reason
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
for the learned Trial Court to discard such
cogent
and
reliable
evidence
against
the
absurd, vague and baseless oral statement of
Mr. Deepak Darbari.
121.
It
was
submitted
that
the
documentary
evidence produced by the plaintiff clearly
establishes
that
the
defendants
committed
breach of the contract and committed default
and they were trying to avoid the legitimate
dues
of
though
have
the
plaintiff
admittedly
received
consignments
Therefore,
rightly
defendants
the
the
from
the
under
entire
to
money
Yugoslavian
the
Nos.1
contract
appellants/defendants
learned
given
the
of
the
buyers.
Trial
Court
has
findings
that
the
committed
the
has
breach of the contract and the plaintiff is
entitled to recover the payment of second and
third consignments from the defendants Nos. 1
to 4.
C/FA/531/1986
122.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Learned
advocate
Mr.
Joshi
submitted
that the defendant No.1 firm namely “House of
Dubary” and the partners thereof have filed
the counter claim by way of a cross-suit for
recovery
of
the
sum
plaintiff, however
as
damages
from
the
from the oral evidence of
Mr. Deepak Durbari, it is evident that firm
namely, “House of Dubary” is only registered
for the purpose of Income Tax Act and not
registered under the provisions of the Indian
Partnership Act. It was submitted that the
plaintiff has taken the plea that the crosssuit
is
barred
by
the
Section
of
the
Indian Partnership Act for the want of the
registration of the partnership firm namely,
“House of Dubary”.
123.
It was submitted that the provision of
Section 69 of the Indian Partnership Act is
mandatory
which
provides
that
the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
unregistered firm shall not be entitled to
institute any suit or in form of the Counter
Claim or the cross suit to enforce the right
arising from the contract. It was therefore
submitted that the effect of the Section 69
is that the suit by the unregistered firm is
bad in law and not tenable at its inception
as
Section 69 does not confer any right and
debars the unregistered firm from filing the
suit.
124.
It was submitted that once the Court is
satisfied that the firm is not registered,
the Court must treat the suit or cross-suit
as if it has not been filed and Court should
proceed to dismiss it and in the present case
the firm namely, “House of Dubary” is not
registered under the provisions of the Indian
Partnership Act then the counter claim by way
of the cross suit is not maintainable. It was
therefore submitted that the learned Trial
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Court has rightly rejected the Counter Claim
of the defendants.
125.
Learned
advocate
Mr.
Joshi
for
the
respondent no. 1 submitted that the liability
for the freight, insurance etc. relating to
the second and third consignments is of the
defendant No.1 firm because the firm took the
delivery of the goods at Bombay through their
agent defendant No.5, however, the defendants
have failed to prove that they are not liable
to
pay
freight,
insurance
etc.
as
the
defendant No.5 -M/s. Air Freight (P) Ltd. has
not come forward to support the case of the
defendant No.1 firm “House of Dubary” and has
remained absent and there is only the bare
words
of
demurrage
Mr.
was
Deepak
paid
by
Darbary
that
the
defendant
no.1
firm
without any corroborative evidence on record.
It was submitted that the plaintiff has taken
the
plea
from
the
beginning
in
the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
correspondence that the defendant No.1 firm
“House of Dubary” was not empowered to keep
the
goods
in
private
godown
provisions
of
Customs
Act
against
which
is
the
also
evident from the record as the defendants had
withheld the goods on their own against the
instructions of the plaintiff and it is clear
from the correspondence that the defendant
No.1 firm “House of Dubary” wrote the letter
dated 5.12.1978 addressing to the plaintiff
wherein
it
plaintiff
was
clearly
would
not
mentioned
be
liable
that
the
for
the
demurrage, and this admission on the part of
the defendants is sufficient to exonerate the
plaintiff
from
the
responsibility
of
the
demurrage and therefore, learned Trial Court
has correctly held that the defendants are
not entitled to set off for the amount of
demurrage from the plaintiff's claim.
126.
Learned
advocate
Mr.
Joshi
for
the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
respondent
no.
submitted
that
in
all
respect the appellants (original defendants)
have failed to prove that the plaintiff has
committed
breach
contrary,
it
established
defendant
of
the
is
contract,
clearly
by
the
No.1
firm
its
the
proved
and
that
the
partners
have
plaintiff
and
on
committed the breach of the contract and have
not paid the dues to the plaintiff namely,
M/s. Hanspa Knit (P) Ltd., and withheld the
legitimate
payment
of
the
plaintiff
even
after receiving the payment from Yugoslavian
buyers without any substantial reasons.
127.
Learned
advocate
Mr.
Joshi
for
the
respondent no. 1 in light of the facts of the
present
allow
case
the
(original
submitted
total
claim
plaintiff)
that
the
Court
of
the
respondent
an
amount
for
may
of
Rs.62,91,245.18 from all the defendants Nos.1
to
of
the
Original
Special
Civil
Suit
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
No.120/1979
with
running
interest
12%
per
annum from the date of filing of the Suit
till the date of the payment and prayed for
allowing the First Appeal No.1093/1987 and
dismissing the First Appeal No.531/1986.
128.
Learned
plaintiff
advocate
raised
Mr.
Joshi
preliminary
for
the
objection
regarding the maintainability of appeal.
It
was submitted that the appeal filed by the
appellants (original defendant nos. 1 to 4)
is not maintainable as per Section 69 of the
Partnership
Act,
provisions
of
more
particularly,
Section
69(2)
of
the
the
Partnership Act, 1932 which is as under: "Section 69(2) - No suit to enforce
a right arising from a contract
shall be institute in any Court by
or on behalf of a firm against any
third party, unless the firm is
registered and the persons suing are
or have been shown in the Register
of Firms as partners in the firm."
129.
It
was
submitted
that
in
the
present
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
case it is categorically admitted by Deepak
Dubari in his deposition (Exh-415) and also
admitted in his cross examination that the
partnership firm namely, “House of Dubary”
defendant
No.1
is
not
a
registered
partnership firm. It was submitted that the
learned Trial Court has rightly come to the
conclusion in
Para No.110 of the Judgment.
It was therefore submitted that in view of
aforesaid
factual
matrix
as
well
as
provisions of law, the present Appeal filed
by
the
appellants
dismissed
on
herein
this
ground
deserves
alone
to
be
without
entering into merits of the matter.
130.
In
support
of
was placed on the
Apex Court in
his
submission
reliance
judgments of the
Hon'ble
case of
Loonkaran Sethiya and
Ors. Versus Ivan E. John and Ors., reported
in MANU/SC/0048/19 76
and in case of Jagdish
Chander Gupta Versus Kajaria Traders (India)
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Ltd., reported in MANU/SC/0047/1964.
131.
Learned advocate for respondent no. 1-
plaintiff
submitted
that
appellants-defendants
on
have
one
hand,
contended
the
that,
Trial Court is not having jurisdiction, and
on the other hand the appellants-defendants
had filed their counter claim before the same
Court. It was therefore submitted that once
the defendants have filed their counter claim
before the Bhuj Court, then the defendants
are
estopped
from
raising
the
contentions
about the jurisdiction of the Bhuj Court. It
was further submitted that the appellantsdefendants herein cannot blow hot and cold
both
together
as
once
they
submitted
themselves to the jurisdiction of the Bhuj
Court by way of filing the counter claim, it
is
crystal
accepted
clear
the
that
the
jurisdiction
defendants
of
the
have
Court
at
Bhuj-Kutchh and therefore, defendant nos. 1
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
to 4 are not legally entitled to raise the
contentions
about
the
jurisdiction
of
the
Trial Court to try and decide the suit.
132.
It was submitted that if the appellants-
defendants
were
of
the
firm
opinion
and
belief that the Court at Bhuj is having no
jurisdiction in any case and only the Court
at
Bombay
that
is
case,
having
they
jurisdiction,
ought
to
have
then
in
filed
an
independent suit before the Civil Court at
Bombay instead of filing counter claim before
the Bhuj Court. It was therefore submitted
that when the defendants themselves submitted
and
accepted
the
jurisdiction
of
the
Bhuj
Court by way of filing counter claim, which
is nothing but a substantial suit in nature,
the contentions of the appellants-defendants
on the ground of jurisdiction is baseless and
not tenable in eye of law. Learned advocate
for the respondent no. 1 places reliance on
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the provision of Section 19 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 which reads as under: "Section 19 - Suits for compensation for
wrongs to person or movables
When a suit is for compensation for
wrong done to the person or to movable
property, if the wrong was done within
the local limits of the jurisdiction of
one Court and the defendant resides, or
carries on business, or personally works
for gain, within the local limits of the
jurisdiction of another Court, the suit
may be instituted at the option of the
plaintiff in either of the said Courts."
133.
It
was
submitted
that
the
aforesaid
provision itself provides an option to the
plaintiff to institute the suit in either of
the Courts. It was further submitted that the
making of a contract is part of cause of
action, and performance of a contract is also
a part of cause of action, hence a suit in
respect of the breach can always be filed at
the place where the contract was made or it
should
have
performed
or
where
its
performance is completed. Not only that, even
part of cause of action arises where money is
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
expressly
or
impliedly
contract.
In
support
submission,
reliance
payable
under
of
aforesaid
the
was
placed
the
on
the
judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court, in the
matter of A.B.C. Laminart Pvt. Ltd. and Ors.
Versus
A.P.
Agencies,
MANU/SC/0001/1989.
Trial
Court
No.2-A
in
has
Therefore
rightly
affirmative
Salem,
the
learned
decided
the
on
point
of
applicability
of
the
issue
jurisdiction.
134.
With
provisions
regard
of
to
Sale
the
of
Goods
Act,
learned
advocate for the plaintiff submitted that it
is an admitted position that, the goods of
second and third Consignments were delivered
through M/s. Vijay Transport Co. at Bombay to
the defendant No.5, who was the clearing and
forwarding agent of the appellants herein. It
was submitted that at the instance of the
appellants-defendants the goods of second and
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
third
consignments
were
sent
to
defendant
No.5 for the purpose of export to Yugoslavian
buyers, which prima facie is deemed to be a
delivery
support
of
of
the
this
goods
to
submission,
the
buyer.
Section
In
of
Sale of Goods Act, 1930 was referred to which
reads as under: "39(1)
Delivery
to
carrier
or
wharfinger- Where, in pursuance of a
contract of sale, the seller is
authorised or required to send the
goods to the buyer, delivery of the
goods to a carrier, whether named by
the buyer or not, for the purpose of
transmission
to
the
buyer,
or
delivery
of
the
goods
to
a
wharfinger for safe custody, is
prima facie deemed to be a delivery
of the goods to the buyer."
135.
It was submitted, that the learned Trial
Court has rightly come to the conclusion that
goods of second and third consignments are
transmitted and delivered to the defendant
No.5 who has received the goods as the agent
of the appellants herein and therefore the
appellants-defendants are liable to make the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
payment of the second and third consignments
to the respondents (original plaintiff).
136.
With
regard
to
the
appellants-defendants
second
and
third
contention
that
the
consignments
delivered
in
time
by
the
therefore
the
goods
were
of
the
Goods
of
were
never
plaintiff
and
not
exported
at
Yugoslavia in time and the appellants herein
has
not
received
any
payment
towards
the
second and third consignments, the question
of
any
payment
to
the
plaintiff
for
the
second and third consignments does not arise
at all, learned advocate Mr. Joshi for the
Respondent
No.1
submitted
that
the
said
contention
is
totally
misleading
and
misguiding
and
completely
against
the
evidence available on record as well as the
written
statement
filed
by
the
Defendant
No.6-New Bank of India which is the Bank of
the appellants herein. It was submitted that
C/FA/531/1986
the
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Exh.318
Account
which
of
the
is
a
photocopy
of
Bank
appellants-defendants
with
their Bank i.e. Defendant No.6 clearly shows
the receipt of money from M/s. SOLUN during
the
pendency
Statement
of
of
the
suit,
Account
of
moreover,
the
the
appellants-
defendants with their Banker i.e. Defendant
No.6,
are
produced
at
Exh.386
to
Exh.393
which it is important piece of evidence about
the
payments
defendants
received
from
by
the
the
appellants-
Yugoslavian
buyers.
Learned advocate for the plaintiff referred
to and relied upon the Written Statement of
the
defendant
No.6
at
Exh.38
and
more
particularly, in Para No.11, the Defendant
No.6 wherein it was categorically admitted
and stated on oath as under: "The answering Defendant is not
aware of the circumstances under
which the first Defendant came in
possession of the Airway Bill which
he handed over to the answering
Defendant along with his Drafts
drawn on his foreign buyers, for
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
purpose of collection of their Draft
amounts by the answering Defendant.
The Defendant No.1 had submitted his
drafts for US $ 1,09,960/-, US $
1,02,820/ and US $ 1,00,000/- drawn
in his foreign buyers along with
necessary documents including the
Airway Bill No. 098-2561-9996 in
which the name of House of Dubary
appeared as one of the shippers.
Answering Defendant forwarded the
same on 27/12/78 to the Bank of
foreign
buyer
for
payment.
The
answering Defendant got payment of
these Drafts on or about 14/2/1979,
30/1/1979 and 30/1/1979 respectively
in the account of Defendant No.1 and
gave credit of the same to Defendant
No.1 in their account. Defendant
No.1 has utilized the credits so
given by the answering Defendant by
making various withdrawals therefrom
with the result that there now
stands a debit balance in their said
account
with
the
answering
Defendant."
137.
It was submitted that from the perusal
of the admission of the defendant No.6, it is
clear
that
whole
defense
appellants-defendants
the
put-forth
about
by
the
non-receipt
of
payment
of
the
second
and
third
consignments
from
the
foreign
buyers
is
totally false, frivolous and vexatious, hence
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the learned Trial Court has rightly come to
the conclusion that the appellants-defendants
have failed to make the payment of second and
third Consignments to the respondents and the
appellants-defendants
are
correctly
held
liable for the payment of second and third
consignments.
138.
Learned
advocate
for
the
respondent-
plaintiff submitted that the contention of
the appellants-defendants that there is no
privity of contract with the respondent is
not
valid
assuming
without
admitting
that
there is no existence of privity of contract
between
the
appellants-defendants
and
respondent-plaintiff, then in that case how
and on what basis the defendants have filed
their counter claim in the said Special Civil
Suit
No.120/1979
and
demanded
from the plaintiff.
the
damages
C/FA/531/1986
139.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
It
was
submitted
contentions
raised
that
by
in
fact,
the
the
appellants-
defendants itself is self-contradictory and
not tenable in eye of law. It was submitted
that there is enough evidence on record which
clearly
existence
proves
that
between
the
the
contract
parties
was
and
in
the
defendants committed breach of the contract
and had not paid the amount of the second and
third
consignment,
from
the
though
Yugoslavian
it
was
received
buyers,
and
it
was
credited in the accounts of the Appellantsdefendants by their Bank i.e. New Bank of
India (defendant- No.6) and the plaintiff has
sufficiently
proved
the
said
aspect
by
producing the statement of accounts of the
appellants herein, before the Trial Court,
which contains the entries of the receipt of
the
amount
of
the
consignment.
second
and
third
C/FA/531/1986
140.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Learned advocate Mr. Joshi with regard
to
the
contention
of
the
appellants-
defendants that the learned trial Judge has
wrongly come to the conclusion and committed
a
grave
error
by
imposing
liability
of
Freight, Insurance etc. on the appellantsdefendants
submitted
that,
fact,
the
liability
of
Freight,
Insurance
etc.
is
not
all
imposed
upon
the
contrary
on
at
appellants-defendants,
on
as
the
a
matter
of
bare perusal of the observations made by the
learned trial Judge in Para Nos.137, 139 of
the Judgment, it proves that the total amount
of Rs.7,22,446-00 towards Freight, Insurance
etc. is disallowed by the learned trial Judge
and
the
total
claim
further
trial
said
amount
of
submitted
Judge
has
is
deducted
from
the
Rs.62,91,245-00.
It
was
that
learned
since
disallowed
the
the
amount
of
Rs.7,22,446-00, therefore in the Cross Appeal
No.1093/1987,
the
appellant
of
the
said
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Appeal has raised one of the grounds in Para
No.4, as under: "(4):
That
the
learned
Judge
seriously
erred
in
deducting
Rs.1,91,646/ and Rs.5,30,800/- by
way of freight charges from the
price of the goods defendants Nos.1
to 4 were held liable and to which
amount the plaintiffs were held
entitled to realize from the said
defendants. It is submitted that the
said finding of the learned Judge
with
regard
to
freight
charged
payable for the second and third
consignment is not supported by any
evidence on record."
141.
It was therefore submitted that it is
misconception of the part of the appellantsdefendants that the learned trial Judge has
wrongly
fastened
the
liability
of
the
Freight, Insurance etc. on the appellantsdefendants
as,
out
of
Rs.62,91,245.18
for
the
second
and
third
learned
trial
Judge
only
of
Rs.49,81,336
and
of
Rs.13,09,909
is
consignment,
allowed
remaining
the
the
claim
amount
the
total
claim
of
disallowed by the learned trial Judge, which
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
includes
the
amount
of
Rs.7,22,446
of
Freight, Insurance etc.
142.
Insofar as First Appeal No.1093/1987, it
was submitted that since the learned trial
Judge
has
partly
allowed
the
suit
and
therefore the appellants have preferred the
cross Appeal with a prayer to allow the total
claim
of
the
appellants
for
an
amount
of
Rs.62,91,245.18 and also prayed to allow the
Special Civil Suit no.120/1979 against all
the
defendant
severally
nos.1
to
jointly
and
with the running interest @12% per
annum from the date of filling of the Suit
till the date of the payment/realization of
the dues of the appellants. Hence in view of
legal submission made, facts narrated and the
relevant and important documentary evidence
relied upon, it was submitted to allow the
First
Appeal
No.1093/1987
First Appeal No.531/1986.
and
dismiss
the
C/FA/531/1986
143.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Learned
advocate
Mr.
Joshi
for
the
Plaintiff submitted that the defendant No.6
deposited an amount of Rs.37,67,420/- with
the
Trial
knowledge
Court,
of
Bhuj,
the
which
as
plaintiff
per
was
the
later
transferred to the Registry of this Court in
compliance of Para
No.145 of the impugned
Judgment
Trial
of
the
Court
and
the
directions were given which are as under:
“....... I find that the amount of
Rs.37,67,420-00 is at present and still
lying in the sundry account in the New
Bank of India Ltd., Defense Colony New
Delhi, and that amount being received
towards the value of the goods of the
third consignment and that amount is
liable
to
be
realized
towards
the
satisfaction of the decree in favour of
the
Plaintiff
in
Special
Sult
No.120/1979 and it is therefore on the
ground of justice and equity required to
be directed the Defendant No.6 as to be
deposited such lying amount in sundry
account in this Court for the payment
and satisfaction of the decree...”
144.
It was further submitted that in view of
the above, the amount which is lying with the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Registry of this Court may please be directed
to pay the said amount with accrued interest
to the Office of the Respondent No.1 i.e.
Official Liquidator, so that the respondent
No.1-Official Liquidator can settle the dues
of the workers as well as of the secured and
unsecured
Liquidation
creditors
as
per
of
the
the
Company
provisions
of
in
the
Companies Act, 1956 accordingly dismiss the
First Appeal No.531/1986.
8)Points for Determination
145.
Considering the submissions of both the
sides and oral and documentary evidence on
record, following points for determination:
1) Whether the Trial Court has committed
an error in assumption of jurisdiction to
entertain the suit under section 20 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908?
2)
Whether
the
place
of
formation is Delhi or Kandla?
contract
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
3) Whether the place of performance of
contract was at Bombay or Kandla?
4) Whether the place of payment was Delhi
or Kandla?
5) Whether the appellants defendants were
in breach of contract or not?
6) Whether the Trial Court erred in law
in holding that contract was independent
of Letters of credit?
7)
Whether
the
decreed
amount
is
arbitrary and based on manifest error or
not?
8)
Whether the Trial Court was just and
correct
in
decreeing
the
suit
for
Rs.49,81,336/- and disallowing the claim
of the plaintiff for Rs.13,09,909/-?
9) Whether the Trial Court committed an
error in holding that counter claim was
barred under section 69 of the Indian
Partnership Act, 1932?
10) Whether the Trial Court was justified
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
in
fastening
the
joint
and
several
liability upon the defendant nos. 1 to 4
only while exonerating defendant nos. 5
and 6?
11)
Whether the decree passed by the
Trial Court for Rs.49,81,336/- is just
and proper?
9)Reasons
Analysis of points for determination and
findings
146.
Having heard the learned advocates and
having
perused
Order
and
the
oral
impugned
and
Judgment
documentary
and
evidence
available on record, it would be necessary to
summaries
the
chronology
relevant
evidence
placed
of
on
events
record
by
and
the
parties:
Sr
Date / Period
Event
Exhibit
No
1.
December 1977
The defendant no. 2 came to the
-
factory of the plaintiff at Kandla
with Six Yugoslavian buyers so as
to
negotiate
for
export
electronic goods to Yugoslavia.
of
C/FA/531/1986
2.
1977 – 1978
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Further
negotiations
were
between
the
parties
at
places
and
it
agreed
was
made
-
different
that
defendant no. 1 firm would act as
an
export
house
by
placing
the
orders in its name for export of
the goods to Yugoslavia.
3.
20.06.1978
Seven
Irrevocable
Letters
of
Credit were issued by Yugoslavian
283 to
Buyers in favour of the defendant
no. 1 firm.
4.
04.09.1978
The
defendant
seven
no.
firm
irrevocable
issued
Letters
of
374 to
Credit in favour of sister concern
of the plaintiff Hasmukh Brothers.
5.
04.10.1978
Defendant Nos. 1 to 4 placed an
order
for
supply
of
goods
worth
278 to
US$ 7,81,522.14 equivalent to Rs.
6.
05.10.1978
62,91,245.10
Four Letters of Credit were opened
290, 295,
by
300, 305
the
defendant
Bank
of
the
Plaintiff
terms
of
the
Contract
shipment
by
20.10.1978
goods
09.10.1978
favour
negotiation
7.
no.
were
wherein
regarding
01.10.1978
of
was
documents
mentioned
to
be
in
and
shipped
and
by
the
from
Kandla Port.
The defendant no. 6 Bank amended
Letters of Credit by extending the
shipment
last
date
date
documents
01.12.1978
and
of
negotiation
of
was
extended
to
30.12.1978.
to
-
C/FA/531/1986
8.
14.10.1978
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
As
per
the
negotiations
the
parties,
it
was
between
agreed
-
that
the shipment would be sent by Air
from Bombay Airport for export of
the goods to Yugoslavia
and
accordingly the Letters of Credit
9.
26.10.1978
were amended.
Letter of the defendant no. 1 firm
to extend the period of Letters to
Credit to complete the delivery of
10.
18.11.1978
the goods.
Letter
of
the
Plaintiff
for
acceptance of the order placed by
the
defendant
no.
firm
on
04.10.1978
11.
October –
The
plaintiff
November 1978
consignment
of
shipped
the
first
goods
through
-
its
clearing agent M/s. Dawn India for
value
of
US$
3,33,285.60
to
Rs.
26,80,327.50.
payment
for
equivalent
The
12.
04.12.1978
the
first
consignment
was
received
plaintiff
and
there
is
dispute
regarding
no
the
by
legal
first
consignment.
Telex message of Hasmukh brothers
to pay airfreight by defendant no.
1 firm and for the amendment of
13.
07.12.1978
the Letter of Credit on FOB basis.
Airfreight
Private
Limited
was
appointed
as
forwarding
agent
a
clearing
instead
of
and
Dawn
India for the remaining Letter of
14.
07.12.1978
Credits by the defendant no. 6.
The defendant no. 1 firm by telex
message informed the defendant no.
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
5 to hold the goods until further
advice
till
the
Yugoslavian
15.
15.12.1978
license
buyer
of
the
was
not
revalidated.
Telex message of the defendant no.
1 accepting the liability to pay
16.
18.12.1978
demurrages.
Telex from
firm
to
the
defendant
plaintiff
no.
cancelling
of
order of models of Indian Star and
17.
19.12.1978
Ganges.
Export invoices were issued by the
310 to
18.
27.12.1978
defendant no. 1 firm.
Plaintiff dispatched the goods for
315 to
second consignment from Kandla to
317 & 325
defendant no. 5 Airfreight Private
Limited.
The
Airway
bills
were
also issued by the defendant no. 5
in
19.
16.03.1979
name
of
the
plaintiff
and
defendant no. 1 firm.
Letter of the defendant no.1 firm
informing
the
plaintiff
that
the
goods will be exported subject to
validation
20.
06.04.1979
of
the
Yugoslavian buyers.
Letter
of
defendant
no.
informing
the
Hasmukh
brothers
that
goods
would
be
shipped
licenses
are
the
after
21.
22.
26.04.1979
30.04.1979
of
license
the
revalidated.
Letter
to
defendant
no.
requesting
arrange
Letter
of
to
Credit in favour of the plaintiff.
Letter of the defendant no. 1 to
Hasmukh
brothers
informing
that
the goods would be lifted between
23.
30.04.1979
10th and 15th May, 1979
Plaintiff had written a letter to
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the
Asst.
Collector
of
Customs,
Bombay for detention of the goods
24.
01.05.1979
by the defendant no. 5.
Letter
from
defendant
25.
02.05.1979
seeking clarification.
Letter addressed to defendant no.
no.
1 by the plaintiff for providing
26.
03.05.1979
the clarification.
Letter written by Asst. Collector
of
27.
04.05.1979
Customs,
Bombay
to
defendant
no. 5 Airfreight Private Limited.
The defendant No. 5 exported the
316 & 317
goods which were
retained
months
28.
21.05.1979
for
at
approximately
the
request
of
the
defendant no. 1 firm.
Special Civil Suit No. 120 of 1979
was filed before the Civil Judge
(S.D.),
29.
24.05.1979
Bhuj
by
the
plaintiff
claiming Rs. 62,91,245.18.
Defendant no. 1 firm filed
the
counter-claim
for
Rs.
damages
and
1,08,85,152/-
for
reimbursement of expenses from the
30.
12.06.1979
plaintiff.
Special
Investigation
Intelligence
Customs
Branch
issued
and
of
Bombay
show-cause
notice
under section 108 of the Customs
Act, 1962 upon the defendant no.1
31.
19.06.1979
firm.
Yugoslavian
buyers
defendant
no.
requesting
the
informed
by
the
letter
confirmation
regarding deduction of 2% for the
32.
26.06.1979
defective goods.
Appointment
of
commissioner
to
take inventory of the account of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
defendant no.1 from the books of
33.
26.06.1979
defendant no.6.
Defendant
no.1
to
restrained
realizing
from
were
any
consideration of third consignment
received
34.
35.
from
22.08.1979
buyers to the defendant no.1 firm.
Criminal Complaint was filed by
02.01.1981
Collector
Customs
unauthorised
31.01.1986
of
Customs
against defendants nos. 1 to 5
Order-in-Original was passed
the
37.
Yugoslavian
buyers.
Payment intimation from Yugoslavia
Assistant
36.
the
authorities
export
defendant no.1 firm.
The
trial
court
of
by
against
goods
decreed
by
the
Special Civil Suit No. 120 of 1979
decreeing
in
favour
of
the
plaintiff Rs. 49,81,336/- with 12%
interest
and
dismissed
the
counter-claim.
147.
From
there
is
regarding
the
above
chronology
of
events,
no
dispute
between
the
parties
the
first
consignment
as
the
plaintiff exported the goods through its own
clearing and forwarding agent M/s. Dawn India
for value of US$ 3,33,285.60 equivalent to
Rs.26,80,327.50.
The
plaintiff
has
duly
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
received the payment of the said amount from
New Bank of India- defendant no.6.
148.
Therefore,
the
dispute
between
the
parties pertains only with regard to 2nd and
3rd consignment. As per the amended terms of
Letters of Credit, last date for shipment was
01.12.1978.
The
goods
Kandla
from
plaintiff
on
dispatched
27.12.1978
the
which
was
after 26 days from the expiry of Letters of
Credit.
Goods
were
sent
to
defendant
no.5
M/s. Airfreight (P) Ltd. through transporter
M/s.
Vijay
Transport
Co.
from
Kandla
to
was
dispatched
Bombay for export by Air.
149.
from
The
third
Kandla
to
consignment
Bombay
through
M/s.
Vijay
Transport Co. on 27.12.1978 for export from
Bombay
to
Yugoslavia
by
defendant
no.5.
Defendant no.5 retained the goods for about 5
months and ultimately exported the same to
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Yugoslavia
in
May,
1979.
No
payment
was
received by the plaintiff for export of the
second and third consignment and thereafter
the
suit
for
recovery
was
filed
by
the
plaintiff and counter claim for damages was
filed by the defendants.
150.
In view of above facts, with regard to
Points
for
Determination
no.
to
for
objections raised by the appellants-defendant
for assumption of jurisdiction by the Trial
Court
to
entertain
the
suit
filed
by
the
plaintiff is required to be considered. In
order to consider such objection, it would be
germane to refer to the relevant provisions
of relevant Acts:
CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
SECTION 16 : Suits to be instituted
where subject-matter situate.
Subject to the pecuniary or
other limitations prescribed by any
law, suits(a)
for
the
recovery
of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
immovable
property
with
without rent or profits,
or
(b)
for
the
partition
immovable property,
of
(c) for foreclosure, sale or
redemption in the case of a
mortgage
of
or
charge
upon
immovable property,
(d) for the determination of any
other right to or interest in
immovable property,
(e) for compensation for wrong
to immovable property,
(f) for the recovery of movable
property
actually
under
distraint or attachment, shall
be
instituted
in
the
Court
within the local limits of whose
jurisdiction the property is
situate:
Provided that a suit to obtain
relief
respecting,
or
compensation
for
wrong
to,
immovable property held by or on
behalf of the defendant may,
where the relief sought can be
entirely obtained through his
personal
obedience,
be
instituted either in the Court
within the local limits of whose
jurisdiction the property is
situate, or in the Court within
the
local
limits
of
whose
jurisdiction
the
defendant
actually
and
voluntarily
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
resides, or carries on business,
or personally works for gain.
Explanation.-In this section
"property"
means
property
situate in [India.]
SECTION 19 : Suits for compensation
for wrongs to person or movables.
Where a suit is for compensation
for wrong done to the person or
to movable property, if the
wrong was done within the local
limits of the jurisdiction of
one Court and the defendant
resides, or carries on business,
or personally works for gain,
within the local limits of the
jurisdiction of another Court,
the suit may be instituted at
the option of the plaintiff in
either of the said Courts.
SECTION 20 : Other suits
instituted where defendants
or cause of action arises.
to be
reside
Subject
to
the
limitations
aforesaid, every suit shall be
instituted in a Court within the
local
limits
of
whose
jurisdiction(a) the defendant, or each
of
the
defendants
where
there are more than one, at
the time of the commencement
of the suit, actually and
voluntarily
resides,
or
carries
on
business,
or
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
personally works
or
for gain;
(b) any of the defendants,
where there are more than
one, at the time of the
commencement of the suit,
actually
and
voluntarily
resides,
or
carries
on
business,
or
personally
works for gain, provided
that in such case either the
leave of the Court is given,
or the defendants who do not
reside,
or
carry
on
business, or personally work
for
gain,
as
aforesaid,
acquiesce
in
such
institution; or
(c) the cause of action,
wholly or in part, arises.
[Explanation].-A corporation shall
be deemed to carry on business at
its
sole
or
principal
office
in [India] or, in respect of any
cause of action arising at any place
where it has also a subordinate
office, at such place.
SALE OF GOODS ACT, 1930
SECTION 36 : Rules as to delivery
(1) Whether it is for the
buyer to take possession of
the goods or for the seller
to send them to the buyer is
a question depending in each
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
case
on
the
contract,
express or implied, between
the parties. Apart from any
such contract, goods sold
are to be delivered at the
place at which they are at
the time of the sale, and
goods agreed to be sold are
to be delivered at the place
at which they are at the
time of the agreement to
sell, or, if not then in
existence, at the place at
which they are manufactured
or produced.
(2) Where under the contract
of sale the seller is bound
to send the goods to the
buyer, but no time for
sending them is fixed, the
seller is bound to send them
within a reasonable time.
(3) Where the goods at the
time of sale are in the
possession
of
a
third
person, there is no delivery
by seller to buyer unless
and until such third person
acknowledges to the buyer
that he holds the goods on
his behalf: Provided that
nothing
in
this
section
shall affect the operation
of the issue or transfer of
any document of title to
goods.
(4) Demand or tender of
delivery may be treated as
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
ineffectual unless made at a
reasonable hour. What is a
reasonable
hour
is
a
question of fact.
(5) Unless otherwise agreed,
the
expenses
of
and
incidental to putting the
goods into a deliverable
state shall be borne by the
seller.
SECTION 39 : Delivery to carrier or
wharfinger
(1) Where, in pursuance of a
contract of sale the seller is
authorised or required to send
the goods to the buyer, delivery
of the goods to a carrier,
whether named by the buyer or
not,
for
the
purpose
of
transmission to the buyer, or
delivery of the goods to a
wharfinger for safe custody, is
prima facie deemed to be a
delivery of the goods to the
buyer.
(2) Unless otherwise authorised
by the buyer, the seller shall
make such contract with the
carrier or wharfinger on behalf
of
the
buyer
as
may
be
reasonable having regard to the
nature of the goods and the
other
circumstances
of
the
case(s). If the seller omits so
to do, and the goods are lost or
damaged in course of transit or
whilst in the custody of the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
wharfinger,
the
buyer
may
decline to treat the delivery to
the carrier or wharfinger as a
delivery to himself, or may hold
the
seller
responsible
in
damages.
(3) Unless otherwise agreed,
where goods are sent by the
seller to the buyer by a route
involving
sea
transit,
in
circumstances in which it is
usual to insure, the seller
shall give such notice to the
buyer as may enable him to
insure them during their sea
transit, and if the seller fails
so to do, the goods shall be
deemed to be at his risk during
such sea transit.
CONTRACT ACT, 1872
SECTION 2 : Interpretation clause.
In this Act the following
words and expressions are
used
in
the
following
senses, unless a contrary
intention appears from the
context :(a)
When
one
person
signifies
to
another
his willingness to do
or
to
abstain
from
doing anything, with a
view to obtaining the
assent of that other to
such act or abstinence,
he is said to make a
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
proposal:
(b) When the person to
whom the proposal is
made
signifies
his
assent
thereto,
the
proposal is said to be
accepted. A proposal,
when accepted, becomes
a promise:
(c) The person making
the proposal is called
the "promisor", and the
person
accepting
the
proposal is called the
"promisee":
(d) When, at the desire
of the promisor, the
promisee or any other
person
has
done
or
abstained from doing,
or
does
or
abstains
from doing, or promises
to do or to abstain
from doing, something,
such act or abstinence
or promise is called a
consideration for the
promise:
(e) Every promise and
every set of promises,
forming
the
consideration for each
other, is an agreement:
(f) Promises which form
the
consideration
or
part
of
the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
consideration for each
other
are
called
reciprocal promises:
(g) An agreement not
enforceable by law is
said to be void:
(h)
An
agreement
enforceable by law is a
contract:
(i) An agreement which
is enforceable by law
at the option of one or
more
of
the
parties
thereto, but not at the
option of the other or
others, is a voidable
contract:
(j) A contract which
ceases
to
be
enforceable
by
law
becomes void when it
ceases
to
be
enforceable.
SECTION 3 :Communication, acceptance
and revocation of proposals.
The communication of proposals,
the acceptance of proposals, and
the revocation of proposals and
acceptances, respectively, are
deemed to be made by any act or
omission of the party proposing,
accepting or revoking, by which
he intends to communicate such
proposal,
acceptance
or
revocation, or which has the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
effect of communicating it.
SECTION
complete.
:
Communication
when
The communication of a proposal
is complete when it comes to the
knowledge of the person to whom
it is made.
The
communication
of
acceptance is complete,-
an
as against the proposer, when it
is
put
in
a
course
of
transmission to him, so as to be
out
of
the
power
of
the
acceptor;
as
against
the
acceptor, when it comes to the
knowledge of the proposer.
The
communication
of
revocation is complete,-
a
as against the person who makes
it, when it is put into a course
of transmission to the person to
whom it is made, so as to be out
of the power of the person who
makes it;
as against the person to whom it
is made, when it comes to his
knowledge.”
151.
The contention raised on behalf of the
appellants-defendants that
for assumption of
jurisdiction by the Trial Court to entertain
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the suit only Letters of Credit issued by the
defendant no.6 New Bank of India stipulating
the
terms
of
considered,
contract
is
are
concerned,
required
on
to
be
perusal
of
section 19 read with clause (c) of section 20
of the Code of Civil Procedure, it is not in
dispute that goods have been dispatched by
the plaintiff from Kandla. Moreover, so far
as transaction of first consignment out of
four Letters of Credit issued by defendant
no.6
Bank,
transaction
has
taken
place
at
Kandla for which the payment is also received
at Kandla by the plaintiff and there is no
dispute
with
regard
to
the
transaction
of
first consignment which is one of the part of
the goods agreed to be sold by the plaintiff
to defendant nos. 1 to 4 for which, four
Letters of Credit were opened stipulating the
terms and conditions of the contract.
152.
On perusal of the terms and conditions
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
stipulated
in
record
Exh.
at
Letters
of
to
Credit
placed
including
on
the
letters of amendment of the Letters of Credit
issued by defendant no.6 in favour of the
plaintiff’s bank State Bank of India, Kandla
are considered, it is discernible that terms
of Letters of Credit are only for the purpose
of payment to be negotiated so as to complete
the transaction of sale of goods between the
parties. The cause of action wholly or in
part can said to have been arisen out of
bundle of essential facts necessary for the
plaintiff to prove if traversed in order to
support
the
right
to
the
judgment
of
the
Court. It refers entirely to the grounds set
forth in the plaint as the cause of action.
Clause (c) of section 20 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, clearly stipulates that suit may
be
instituted
where
the
cause
of
action,
wholly or in part arises. In the facts of the
case, part of the cause of action can be said
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
to have arisen at Kandla when defendant no.2
had
brought
along
with
him
Yugoslavian
buyers to the factory of the plaintiff in
December, 1977 at Kandla. Thereafter, further
negotiation had taken place at various places
i.e. Bombay, Delhi and Hongkong between the
parties. Orders were placed firstly before
M/s. Hasmukh Brothers (HK)
and 7 Letters of
Credit were opened. However, as M/s. Hasmukh
Brothers (HK) could not fulfill the contract,
it was agreed between the parties to enter
into contract for supply of the goods by the
plaintiff
who
is
sister
concern
of
M/s.
Hasmukh Brothers (HK) and three Letters of
Credit
were
confirmed
in
favour
of
M/s.
on
05.10.1978
and
of
Credit
were
the
plaintiff
vide
Hasmukh
Brothers
(HK)
remaining
four
Letters
confirmed
in
favour
of
Exhs. 290, 295, 300 and 305 and on opening of
such four Letters of Credit in favour of the
plaintiff
through
State
Bank
of
India,
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Kandla, four orders were placed by defendant
no.1 with the plaintiff vide letters dated
04.10.1978
Exh.
to
Exh.
taking
confirmation from the plaintiff. It is also
not
in
dispute
that
after
placing
four
orders, defendant no.2 had come to Kandla and
discussed regarding shipment and on basis of
such discussion, the plaintiff vide letter
dated 18-19.11.1978 confirmed four orders. It
is, therefore, a clear part performance of
the
contract
at
Kandla
as
contract
was
finally concluded on accepting the orders by
the
plaintiff
at
Kandla,
Gandhidham-Kutch.
Therefore, reliance placed by the defendants
only on Letters of Credit for contending that
other
ignored
circumstances
and
only
and
terms
facts
and
are
to
be
conditions
of
Letters of Credit and place of issuance of
Letters
of
Credit
is
required
to
be
considered to determine the jurisdiction of
the Court, is contrary to the facts proved by
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the plaintiff regarding part performance of
the contract at Kandla.
153.
It
is
pertinent
to
note
that
merely
opening Letters of Credit is not sufficient
but thereafter action taken by the plaintiff
by
letter
dated
18.11.1978
confirming
the
orders placed by the defendants, accepting
the offer at Kandla, would be sufficient to
confer jurisdiction upon the Civil Court at
Kutch-Bhuj
jurisdiction,
within
part
whose
territorial
performance
of
the
contract had taken place.
154.
The Trial Court was therefore, justified
in holding that only Letters of Credit alone
are
not
required
to
be
considered
but
in
substance who placed orders and accepted the
orders as the orders were in form of the
offer and that offer was accepted on part of
the plaintiff is material.
C/FA/531/1986
155.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
The Trial Court was also justified in
considering the transaction while observing
that negotiations were to be made for just
arrangement
for
fixing
the
terms
and
conditions of the contract and in connection
of such discussions or negotiations, Letters
of
Credit
were
required
to
be
opened
in
favour of the first defendant.
156.
It is also required to be consider the
entire chain of events which had taken place
between
the
parties
for
sale
of
goods
manufactured in Free Trade Zone at Kandla.
The contention of the defendants that merely
manufacturing of goods at Kandla and dispatch
by the plaintiff for export to Bombay cannot
be
considered
as
part
performance
of
the
contract, is not tenable because performance
of contract is part of the cause of action.
It is also not in dispute that payment has
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
been received for the first consignment by
the
plaintiff
at
Kandla
which
is
integral
part of the entire contract and as per the
averments made in the plaint and documents
placed along with the plaint as well as oral
and documentary evidence led by the parties,
it cannot be said that only the terms and
conditions stipulated in Letters of Credit
would
determine
the
jurisdiction
of
the
Court.
157.
The suit in respect of realisation and
recovery of the price can always be filed at
the place where the contract should have been
performed
or
where
its
performance
is
completed. If the contract is to be performed
at the place where it is made then the suit
on the contract is required to be filed at
the said place however, in a contract of sale
of goods, the place where the goods have to
be
delivered,
is
also
the
place
of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
performance and the Court of that place would
have jurisdiction to entertain the suit in
respect
of
the
dispute
of
the
contractual
rights of the plaintiff.
158.
In the facts of the case, from perusal
of the Letters of Credit at Exh. 290 to 309,
it appears that it was initial contract that
the goods were shipped from Kandla to Greece
accompanied
by
all
necessary
mentioned
therein.
documents
However,
as
parties
subsequently agreed to permit the shipment by
Air
from
arrangement
Bombay
to
was
made
Yugoslavia
for
the
and
such
purpose
of
expedient delivery to the buyer.
159.
From
the
correspondence
between
the
parties, it is evident that place of shipment
is
from
Kutch
and
the
performance
of
the
contract was to be made at Kandla, Kutch.
Therefore, it is not in dispute that cause of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
action or part of cause of action had taken
place at Kandla which is material for the
plaintiff to prove to succeed. The plaintiff
has
therefore,
rightly
been
held
to
have
proved that originally contract between the
parties was to ship the goods from Kandla
which was agreed to be changed for shipment
of goods by Air from Bombay. Therefore, it
cannot
be
said
that
since
delivery
of
goods
has
Kandla,
the
Court
at
jurisdiction.
In
been
Bhuj
fact,
the
place
shifted
would
the
of
from
not
have
goods
were
dispatched from Kandla to Bombay for export.
Merely because goods are to be airlifted from
Bombay
would
not
be
a
fact
against
the
plaintiff to hold that goods were delivered
at Bombay and therefore, there was no cause
of action which had taken place at Kandla. We
are therefore of the opinion that the Trial
Court
was
justified
in
cause
of
action
arisen
had
holding
at
that
whole
Kandla
and
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
merely
because
defendant
no.5
goods
at
were
Bombay,
delivered
to
it
be
cannot
considered that goods have not been delivered
from Kandla.
160.
and
The Trial Court has rightly referred to
relied
upon
the
provisions
of
section
39(1) of the Sale of Goods Act, 1930 to turn
down the contention of the defendants that
the
goods
delivered
by
the
plaintiff
was
received at Bombay for the purpose of export
and therefore, cause of action had arisen at
Bombay only. The undisputed facts are that
goods
were
handed
over
to
the
transporter
M/s. Vijay Transport Co. to carry them at
Bombay as per the amended clause of Letters
of Credit. Therefore, as per the provisions
of section 39(1) of the Sale of Goods Act,
when the goods are delivered to the carrier
for the purpose of transmission to the buyer
then prima facie delivery of goods would be
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
deemed to have been made to the buyer at
Kandla.
161.
Reliance
placed
on
behalf
of
the
plaintiff on the decision in case of Harshad
Chiman Lal Modi v. DLF Universal Ltd. and
another reported in (2005) 7 Supreme Court
Cases 791, therefore, would not be applicable
in facts of the case. However, it would be
fruitful to refer to the observations made by
Hon’ble
Apex
Court
on
applicability
of
sections 16, 19 and 20 of the Code of Civil
Procedure to determine the jurisdiction which
would be helpful to determine the issue on
hand as under:
“14. Having heard learned counsel
for
the
parties
and
having
considered the relevant provisions
of the Code as also the decisions
cited before us, in our opinion, the
order passed by the trial court and
confirmed by the High Court deserves
no interference. As stated above, it
is an admitted fact that the suit
relates to the recovery of immovable
property, a plot admeasuring 264 sq.
mtrs. in the Residential Colony Page 158 of 236
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
DLF Qutub Enclave Complex, Gurgaon.
It is not in dispute by and between
the parties that the property is
situate in Haryana. It is no doubt
true that the defendants are having
their head office at Delhi. It is
also true that the agreement was
entered into between the parties at
Delhi. It also cannot be denied that
the payment was to be made at Delhi
and some installments were also paid
at Delhi. The pertinent and material
question, however, is in which court
a suit for specific performance of
agreement
relating
to
immovable
property would lie15. Now, Ss. 15 to 20 of the Code
contain detailed provisions relating
to jurisdiction of courts. They
regulate forum for institution of
suits. They deal with the matters of
domestic concern and provide for the
multitude of suits which can be
brought in different courts. Section
15 requires the suitor to institute
a suit in the court of the lowest
grade competent to try it. Section
enacts
that
the
suits
for
recovery of immovable property, or
for partition of immovable property,
or
for
foreclosure,
sale
or
redemption of mortgage property, or
for determination of any other right
or interest in immovable property,
or for compensation for wrong to
immovable
property
shall
be
instituted in the court within the
local limits of whose jurisdiction
the property is situate. Proviso to
Sec. 16 declares that where the
relief
sought
can
be
obtained
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
through the personal obedience of
the defendant, the suit can be
instituted
either
in
the
court
within
whose
jurisdiction
the
property is situate or in the court
where the defendant actually or
voluntarily resides, or carries on
business, or personally works for
gain. Section 17 supplements Sec. 16
and is virtually another proviso to
that section. It deals with those
cases where immovable property is
situate within the jurisdiction of
different courts. Section 18 applies
where local limits of jurisdiction
of different courts is uncertain.
Section 19 is a special provision
and
applies
to
suits
for
compensation for wrongs to a person
or to movable property. Section 20
is a residuary section and covers
all those cases not dealt with or
covered by Ss. 15 to 19.
16. Section 16 thus recognizes a
well
established
principle
that
actions against res or property
should be brought in the forum where
such res is situate. A court within
whose territorial jurisdiction the
property is not situate has no power
to deal with and decide the rights
or interests in such property. In
other
words,
a
court
has
no
jurisdiction over a dispute in which
it
cannot
give
an
effective
Judgement Proviso to Sec. 16, no
doubt, states that though the court
cannot,
in
case
of
immovable
property
situate
beyond
jurisdiction, grant a relief in rem
still it can entertain a suit where
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
relief
sought
can
be
obtained
through the personal obedience of
the defendant. The proviso is based
on well known maxim "equity acts in
personam,
recognized
by
Chancery
Courts in England. Equity Courts had
jurisdiction to entertain certain
suits
respecting
immovable
properties situated abroad through
personal obedience of the defendant.
The principle on which the maxim was
based was that courts could grant
relief in suits respecting immovable
property situate abroad by enforcing
their
judgments
by
process
in
personam,
i.e.
by
arrest
of
defendant or by attachment of his
property.”
162.
Another
aspect
jurisdiction
of
for
the
deciding
Court
for
the
part
performance is where the money is expressly
or impliedly payable under the contract. In
the
facts
of
the
case,
admittedly
price
consideration was payable at Kandla as per
the stipulation in Letters of Credit stating
that State Bank of India, Kandla to receive
the
payment
and
in
fact,
for
first
consignment the payment has been received at
Kandla.
Section 36 of the Sale of Goods Act
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
clearly lays down that in absence of contract
to
the
contrary,
goods
sold
are
to
be
delivered at the place at which they are at
the time of sale read with section 32 of the
said
Act
which
lays
down
that
unless
otherwise agreed, delivery of the goods and
payment
of
the
price
are
concurrent
conditions. Therefore, in the facts of the
case when the terms of the contract is and
was that price of the goods should have been
paid to the plaintiff’s bank at Kandla and as
such, place of payment was at Kandla and not
at
Bombay,
therefore,
even
on
this
count,
considering the place of payment would confer
jurisdiction to the Court to entertain the
suit.
163.
In view of the facts emerging from the
record, the part cause of action has arisen
at
Kandla
being
place
of
performance
and
place of payment, because the plaintiff has
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
accepted the contract at Kandla, performed
the contract by dispatching the goods from
Kandla
and
receiving
the
payment
at
State
Bank of India, Kandla. Therefore, reliance
placed by the plaintiff on decision in case
of
Bhagwandas
Goverdhandas
Kedia
v.
Girdharilal Parshottamdas & Co. (supra) would
not be applicable in facts of the case as the
plaintiff has proved part performance of the
contract that the place of contract place of
performance
and
place
of
payment
was
at
Kandla.
164.
Reliance placed on decision in case of
A.B.C. Laminart Pvt. Ltd. v. A.P. Agencies
(supra)
facts
would also not be applicable in the
of
the
case
because
in
view
of
provision of clause (c) of section 20 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, suit can be filed
where part of cause of action arises.
C/FA/531/1986
165.
in
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Similarly,
case
of
reliance placed on decision
Union
of
India
v.
Ladulal
Jain(supra) wherein it is held that the place
of performance of a contract is determined by
the terms of contract and not by the place
where goods are handed over to carrier, would
also not be applicable in facts of the case
because terms of contract clearly stipulate
the goods to be shipped from Kandla which
were later on changed to shipment from Kandla
to
airlifting
change
the
from
Bombay
nature
of
which
would
contract
not
more
particularly, when the goods were sent to the
clearing
and
forwarding
agent
-
defendant
no.5 who was appointed by the defendant no.1
for the purpose of export of goods as per the
terms of negotiation carried out between the
parties.
166.
Reliance placed on the decision in case
of Patel Roadways ltd. v. Prasad Trading Co.
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
(supra) would also not be applicable to the
facts of the case as it cannot be said that
contract
stipulated
a
delivery
then
place
jurisdiction
that
and
not
specific
the
place
of
determines
the
place
of
initial
handing over to a carrier. In the facts of
the case, the place of shipment was changed
from
Kandla
to
Bombay
and
that
would
not
divest the jurisdiction of the Court at BhujKutch when as part performance, the payment
is also received by the State Bank of India
at Kandla.
167.
The Trial court has also considered the
transaction as bundle of essential facts to
conclude that there was part performance of
the
contract
at
Kandla
and
therefore,
it
cannot be said that the cause of action had
not arisen at Kandla. The Trial Court was
therefore,
justified
entirety
facts
of
in
and
considering
circumstances
the
while
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
dismissing the contention of the defendants
that
only
terms
and
conditions
of
the
contract were the terms and conditions of the
Letters of Credit and therefore, the Trial
Court would not have any jurisdiction. Such a
contention raised on behalf of the plaintiff
is
nothing
but
an
effort
to
consider
the
entire issue in a truncated manner by only
referring to the Letters of Credit ignoring
the
vital
fact
that
goods
have
been
dispatched from Kandla through carrier of the
plaintiff
to
the
clearing
and
forwarding
agent at Bombay for export by Air. Therefore,
it cannot be said that the goods were not
dispatched
from
Kandla
taking
into
consideration the provisions of section 39(1)
of the Sale of Goods Act which is relied upon
by the Trial Court only to show that there
was a part performance of the contract at
Kandla.
C/FA/531/1986
168.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
The
contention
of
the
defendants
that
when the goods were dispatched for second and
third
consignment,
Letters
of
Credit
had
expired is also not tenable in view of the
fact that the plaintiff had participated in
execution of the export of second consignment
and
third
consignment
dispatched
by
the
plaintiff and further the contention of the
defendants
cannot
be
accepted
only
Letters
of
Credit
that
considering
had
expired,
ignoring transactions which had taken place
and not denied by the defendants regarding
export of goods dispatched by the plaintiff
from
Kandla
to
Bombay
and
as
such,
the
technical plea of the defendants that because
Letters of Credit had expired and there was
no
contract
and
jurisdiction,
is
therefore,
not
Court
tenable
has
as
contention of the defendants is dehors
facts and is liable to be rejected.
no
such
the
C/FA/531/1986
169.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
With regard to Point for Determination
No.5 that defendants nos. 1 to 4 and not the
plaintiff were in breach of contract,
the
Trial Court on the basis of the oral and
documentary evidence led by the parties has
categorically arrived at the conclusion that
the defendants have committed breach of the
contract
by
retaining
the
goods
with
the
defendant no.5 who was appointed by defendant
no.1
as
clearing
and
forwarding
agent,
coupled with the fact that even after export
of the goods, airway bill was prepared by
defendant
no.5
in
name
of
defendant
no.1
instead of plaintiff so as to negotiate the
Letters of Credit with the LC opening bank
by defendant no.1 to get the payment directly
from Yugoslavian buyers.
170.
The Trial Court has analysed the facts
and has come to the following conclusion in
the impugned order as under:
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
“60).....
The
main
point
for
consideration
in
this
case
is
whether of the omission of the name
of the plaintiff to write first and
then mentioned the name of the first
deft., in Air-way bill was a part of
cause of action which was resulted
the damage and on that ground,
entitled the plaintiff to bring the
suit in the present court for the
tortious act. It is now clear from
the above of completed action and is
wide enough to take in the result as
the
basis
for
the
purpose
of
restitution.
According
to
the
plaintiff, if the fifth deft. was
not made the forged document i.e.
Air way bill showing in shipper
column of the name of the first
deft., as the consigner then the
first deft., was entitled to be
converted the money of the goods in
their own account of the New Bank of
India but the sixth deft., New Bank
of India was bound to remit the said
money to the plaintiff's bank i.e.
State Bank of India Kandla in terms
of the letters of credit and that
the plaintiff had to receive at
least value of the goods in time but
the change was permitted the first
deft., to be converted the said
money for their own use otherwise
not restrained by the order of the
injunction of the court. The learned
advocate
for
the
defts.,
has
submitted that the light in which
the matter shall be considered is
different. It is contended that the
sequence of writing the name in Air
way bill was not given the right to
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the first deft., but the first
deft., was exporter of the goods to
Yugoslavian Buyer in terms of the
contract and was entitled to recover
the money from the buyer through
Bank to Bank and received the money
accordingly and nothing more. It is
therefore contended that there was
no consequential effect resulted to
damage
or injury to the plaintiff.
On the other hand, it is submitted
on the part of the plaintiff that
the term "cause of action" is much
wider and for the present purpose,
it shall be understood to mean the
bundle of facts constituting the
cause of effect in resulting the
damage for the tortious act. I am
inclined to take the view that the
fact of the deprivation of the
property would be one of the bundle
of the facts which is necessary to
be proved in order to entitled the
plaintiff to file the suit against
the defts., Apart from this in
determining whether the court has
jurisdiction, or not, the court
shall always consider the matter on
the pleadings as they stand. I have
therefore carefully considered the
plaint and the written statement.
Admittedly
the
goods
of
third
consignment were sent from Kandla to
Bombay for the purpose of the export
to
the
fifth
deft.,
in
Vijay
Transport and that the said goods
were
entrusted
along
with
the
necessary documents to the deft.,
No.5 which were lifted after five
months and during the course of such
delay, the goods were kept in godown
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
so that the plaintiff wrote the
several letters addressing to the
fifth deft., that the goods were
required under the provisions of the
custom Act to be lifted within one
month otherwise to be returned back
to the plaintiff even if the goods
were
not
returned
back
to
the
plaintiff and were exported after
five
months
by
Air
way
bill
mentioning the name of the first
deft. as the shipper which was
resulted to be moved the custom
authorities
and
the
suit.
I
therefore
quite
agree
with
the
submission of the plaintiff that the
plaintiff deprived to be received
the goods back and resulted in the
consequent to damage. Therefore this
court has jurisdiction to try the
suit on all counts, In view of this
findings and
in result thereof I
decide
issue
No.2
in
the
affirmative.
(61).....In the present case, the
plaintiff has set up the case in the
plaint that the contract was entered
between the plaintiff and the deft.
Nos. 1 to 4 and under such contract,
the electronic goods which being
imported were to be exported to six
Yugoslavian buyers so that the deft.
Nos. 1 to 4 had placed the orders
for the same. The said goods were
exported to Yugoslavian buyers as
per rules and regulations of the
customs
in
Free
Trade
Zone
of
Kandla. It was understood during the
negotiations that the Yugoslavian
buyers would in their turn obtain
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the requisite import license for
importing such goods in Yugoslavia
and would open necessary letters of
credit in favour of the first deft.,
House of Dubary and then the deft.,
Nos. 1 to 4 would in their turn open
the letters of credit in favour of
the plaintiff It was also understood
during the negotiations that the
plaintiff would deliver the goods
against of subsisting and valid
letters of credit and under rules
and regulations of Free Trade Zone
Kandla.
Therefore,
the
plaintiff
would export the goods under their
own clearance of customs in AR-4
form. It was further understood in
the negotiations that the goods
would be transported under requisite
transfer permits and AR-4 forms
under the provisions of the Customs
Act by road to the clearing and
forwarding agent at Bombay and that
the goods would be exported by the
clearing and forwarding agent from
Bombay
to
Yugoslavia
via
Athen
(Greece) in name of the plaintiff.
It has further set up in the plaint
that under such terms and conditions
of the contract and understanding
between the parties, the Yugoslavian
buyers had opened the letters of
credit
in
favour
of
the
first
defendant House of Dubary and then
the deft., Nos. 1 to 4 in their turn
opened the letter of credit in
favour of the plaintiff through
their Bankers i.e., the deft., No.6
New Bank of India Limited, New Delhi
Therefore the deft. No.6 is the
opening Bank. It has further set up
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the facts in the plaint that the New
Bank of India, New Delhi has been
opened the four letters of credit on
5-10-78 in favour of the plaintiff
as described more particularly in
paragraph
No.6
of
the
plaint.
According
to
those
letters
of
credit, the goods were to be shifted
not later than 10-10-78 and bills
would be negotiated on or before 3010-78. It has further stated in the
plaint that the date of shipment and
negotiation of the documents were
extended up to 1-12-78 and 30-12-78
respectively.
This
extension
was
conveyed by the deft., No.6 New Bank
of India, New Delhi vide letter
dated 9-10-78. The deft. No.6 had
thus amended the letters of credit
by the letters dated 14-10-78, 2010-78
and
18-11-78.
Under
this
circumstance, it was belief on the
part of the plaintiff that the
Yugoslavian buyer had got to be
extended their own letters of credit
in favour of the first deft. It has
also set up in the plaint that the
plaintiffs have their own clearing
and forwarding agent namely M/s.
Dwan India.
(61)......In the present case, the
plaintiff has set up the case in the
plaint that the contract was entered
between
the
plaintiff
and
the
deft.Nos.1 to 4 and under such
contract, the electronic goods which
being imported were to be exported
to six sex Yugoslavian buyers so
that the deft., Nos. 1 to 4 had
placed the orders for the same. The
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
said
goods
were
exported
to
Yugoslavian buyers as per rules and
regulations of the customs in Free
Trade
Zone
of
Kandla.
It
was
understood during the negotiations
that the Yugoslavian buyers would in
their turn obtain the requisite
import license for importing such
goods in Yugoslavia and would open
necessary
letters
of
credit
in
favour of the first defendant House
of Dubary and then the deft. Nos. 1
to 4 would in their turn open the
letters of credit in favour of the
plaintiff. It was also understood
during the negotiations that the
plaintiff would deliver the goods
against of subsisting and valid
letters of credit and under rules
and regulations of Free Trade Zone
Kandla.
Therefore,
the
plaintiff
would export the goods under their
own clearance of customs in AR-4
form. It was further understood in
the negotiations that the goods
would be transported under requisite
transfer permits and AR-4 forms
under the provisions of the customs
Act By road to the clearing and
forwarding agent at Bombay and that
the goods Would be exported by the
clearing and forwarding agent from
Bombay to Yugoslavia Via, ATHENS
(Greece) in name of the plaintiff.
It has further that the goods had
duly exported through the said M/s.
Dawn
India
the
26,90,327-50
shipments from Kandla dated 22-1178,22-11-78, 25-11-78, 25-11-78 and
2-12-78 which being aggregated value
of Indian rupees to paise. The
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
plaintiff has already received the
said amount in respect of the first
consignment through sixth deft. New
Bank of India, New Delhi for and on
behalf of the first deft. These
goods were expected to be exported
by ship however, by letter dated 1410-78, the letters of credit were
amended and permitted shipment by
Air
from
Bombay
Airport
to
THEOSSALONIKI (Greece) Air port and
Air way bill was to be made to the
order of " "Makosped" SKOPJE Notify
Solun (DVGELAJA) Yugoslavia. Further
by letter dated 27-11-78, the sixth
deft., had amended the letter dated
14-10-78 so as to read "shipment by
Air from Bombay Airport to Athens
Airport
(Greece)
permitted
one
original and two copies of the air
way bill made out to the order of
Makosped
Skopje
Notify
Solun
(DGELALJA) Yugoslavia marked freight
prepaid
would
require.
It
has
further set up the facts that the
deft. Nos. 2 to 4 had persuaded and
prevailed upon the plaintiff for
further shipment by Air to be made
through the fifth deft., as the
clearing and Forwarding Agents which
would provide the 30 days facility
for the payment of freight even
though the representatives of the
plaintiff were hesitating to accept
the change of the clearing and
forwarding agents as suggested by
the deft. Nos. 2 to 4 but at last,
the
plaintiff
relied
upon
the
bonafide of the deft. Nos. 1 to 4
and agreed with suggestion to export
the goods by Air through the fifth
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
deft. It has stated in the plaint
that
the
plaintiff
was
unaware
whether the deft. Nos. 1 to 5 were
closely
associated.
It
is
now
alleged that the goods relating to
third consignment were sent through
M/s. Vijay Transport from Kandla to
Bombay by the plaintiff as the
consignment consigner of mentioning
in consignment note and mentioned as
the consignee of the fifth deft.,
and thereby the goods were sent to
the fifth deft. It is alleged that
no where in goods consignment note
of
Vijay
Transport
Company
was
mentioned the name of the first
defendant
as
consignee.
It
is
therefore alleged that the fifth
defendant had received the goods
from Vijay Transport Company for and
on behalf of the plaintiff and as
the Agent of the plaintiff. It has
now set up in the plaint that the
receipt of the goods covered by the
goods consignment notes of Vijay
Transport Company so that the fifth
defendant did not entitle to receive
or to hold or to deal or to dispose
of the goods under the instructions
of or at the instance of the first
deft. It is therefore alleged that
the
fifth
defendant
had
to
be
exported
the
goods
by
Air
to
Yugoslavian Buyer and that the fifth
deft., did so for and on behalf of
the plaintiff. It is now alleged in
the plaint that the deft. Nos. 1 to
5 were acted in collusion with each
other and disabled the plaintiff
from drawing the documents on the
opening
Bank
because
the
fifth
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
defendant was not sending the Air
way bill to the plaintiff but parted
with, the said Air way bill to the
first
deft.,
and
defrauded
the
plain- tiff which was resulted not
to be realized the payments by
drawing
the
documents
on
the
negotiation
Bank,
i.e.
the
deft.No.6. on this background of the
facts, it is alleged the fraud by
collusion between the deft., Nos. 1
to 5. It has further set up the
facts in the plaint that the goods
relating to the third consignment
notes were exported by Air on 27-1278 by the fifth deft., to M/s.Solun
Export
company,
(DVGELAJA,
Yugoslavia even not sent the Airway
Bills but parted with the deft.,
Nos. 1 to 4 and in the said Air way
bills, mentioned in the column of
shippers name and address as House
of Dubary instead of M/s. Hanspa
Knit (P) Ltd., House of Dubary
Kandla Free Trade Zone, Gandhidham
Kachchh, New Delhi India,. It is
therefore alleged that the fifth
deft., could not have mentioned in
the column of "shipper" the House of
Dubary, New Delhi "At the most, in
view of the letters of credit the
fifth deft., could have mentioned
after the name of the plaintiff
House of Dubary and not to be
described House of Dubary as the
shipper at all. It has further set
up the case in the plaint that the
fifth deft., knew that the goods
were forwarded by the plaintiff from
Kandla Free Trade Zone which were
exempted from Custom duty only if
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the exporter of the goods would be
within Free Trade Zone, Kandla.”
171.
From
the
above
findings
of
facts
on
analysis of evidence done by the Trial Court,
we do not find any infirmity in the same and
therefore, no interference is called for in
the findings arrived at by the Trial Court
that the defendants had committed breach of
contract. The contention raised on behalf of
the appellants-defendants that the plaintiff
dispatched the second and third consignment
after Letters of Credit had expired without
any
contractual
changed
the
basis
clearing
and
and
the
plaintiff
forwarding
agent
from M/s Dawn India to defendant no.5 without
the
consent
plaintiff
of
failed
the
to
defendant
ensure
that
no.1
and
the
goods
were exported in compliance to the terms of
Letters
of
Credit,
are
contrary
to
the
subsequent events which had taken place from
December, 1978 to May, 1979 as enumerated in
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
detail by the Trial Court on the basis of
evidence led before it.
172.
We are therefore, of the opinion that
the
Trial
Court
committed
any
cannot
error
be
in
said
to
have
holding
that
the
defendant nos. 1 to 4 have committed breach
of contract which was subsisting even after
expiry of Letters of Credit. It appears that
the defendants in order to be discharged from
the
liability
of
payment
have
raised
such
flimsy contention with regard to the expiry
of Letters of Credit or change of agent in
spite
of
the
admitted
fact
that
defendant
no.5 was the clearing and forwarding agent
appointed by the plaintiff.
173.
the
Point for Determination no.6 refers to
issue
as
to
whether
independent
of
Letters
of
contract
Credit
or
was
not.
Contention raised on behalf of the defendants
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
that the Trial court has erred in holding
that
the
contract
was
independent
of
the
Letters of Credit is also without any basis
as
the
Trial
Court
has
arrived
at
a
conclusion regarding issue no.2(D) and 2(E)
to
the
effect
that
so
far
as
first
consignment is concerned, there is no dispute
between the parties.
174.
The
second
and
third
consignment
originated from the purchase orders as well
as followed by Letters of Credit determining
the terms of contract. Merely because Letters
of Credit have expired would not result in
termination
parties
of
have
originally
the
contract
carried
agreed
oral evidence of
out
upon.
On
when
the
both
the
transactions
perusal
of
the
Mr.Anilbhai Chandubhai Pota
at Exh. 276, it is deposed that the defendant
no.1 firm had issued four purchase orders on
04.10.1978 (Exh. 278 to Exh.281) which was
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
confirmed by the plaintiff by letter dated
28.11.1978
(Exh.282)
and
upon
confirmation
defendant no.1 firm opened seven Letters of
Credit
by
the
Yugoslavian
buyers
“SOLUN”
Import-Export, Gevgelija, from the Bank of
Rajasthan, Delhi (Exh.283 to Exh.289) in name
of defendant no.1 which were transferred to
New Bank of India-defendant no.6. Defendant
no.1 in turn opened the Letters of Credit
through its LC Opening Bank – New Bank of
India
-defendant
no.6
in
favour
of
the
plaintiff (Exh.290 to Exh.309).
175.
On perusal of these documents which are
exhibited before the Trial Court as per the
deposition of the witness of the plaintiff,
heavy reliance is placed on behalf of the
advocate of the defendants that the terms and
conditions
would
mentioned
govern
regarding
the
the
in
terms
shipment
Letters
of
of
of
the
goods
Credit
contract
by
the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
plaintiffs. On perusal of each of the Letters
of Credit at Exh.290 to Exh.309 only relevant
condition is regarding the date of Letters of
Credit
stated
as
10.10.1978
which
was
subsequently extended by mutual consent of
both the sides. Another condition which is
referred to and heavily relied upon by the
defendants is with regard to shipment by air
from
Bombay
Airport
to
Greece
Airport
was
permitted by amending the original Letter of
Credit
as
(Exh.303)
per
so
letter
far
as
dated
Letter
14.10.1978
of
Credit
No.13/1978 and 14/1978 was concerned which
are
relevant
consignment.
for
It
second
appears
that
and
rest
third
of
the
Letters of Credit were not amended. So far as
first consignment is concerned, shipment was
made from Kandla port by extending the date
of shipment upto 01.12.1978 for submission of
the
documents
upto
30.12.1978.
It
is
true
that after 30.12.1978, Letters of Credit were
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
not enforceable.
176.
From the facts emerging from the record,
shipment of first consignment was made by the
plaintiff on 22.11.1978 and thereafter as per
the
mutual
second
agreement
and
third
between
the
consignment
parties,
were
sent
through M/s. Vijay Transport Co. to defendant
no.5
so
as
to
export
the
same
by
Air
by
preparing the bills by the plaintiff, in turn
defendant no.1 also prepared the bills which
are placed on record at Exh.310 to Exh.315
regarding second consignment and Exh.316 and
Exh.317 for the third consignment.
177.
On perusal of the Airway bill prepared
by defendant no.5 which is in the name of
defendant
appears
no.1
that
and
not
admittedly
the
the
plaintiff
it
goods
were
manufactured by the plaintiff and sent for
export from Kandla Free Trade Zone, invoice
C/FA/531/1986
no.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
HK/0778-79
packing
list
of
for
8.12.1978
10966
Radio
along
with
Transistors
Model “North Star” 220 packages along with
inspection
and
quality
certificates
issued
the
plaintiff
which
by
are
were
placed
before defendant no.6 by defendant no.1 for
the Letters of Credit which were issued by
defendant
no.6
New
Bank
of
India.
Even
certificate of origin was also provided by
Administrative Officer Kandla Free Trade Zone
for export of goods on 08.01.1979 in respect
of second and third consignment which were
admittedly sent by the plaintiff for export.
178.
From the facts emerged from the record,
it also appears that in spite of the goods
having been received by defendant no.5 M/s.
Air Freight (P) Ltd. same were not exported
as defendant no.1 firm did not complete the
required procedure being Export House of the
plaintiff who was supposed to carry out the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
export of the consignment.
179.
It appears that thereafter only in the
month of May, 1979, defendant no.1 was able
to see that the goods which are lying with
the
defendant
no.5
were
exported.
In
the
backdrop of the above facts, claim of the
defendants for incurring various expenditures
as
stated
considered
in
by
counter
the
Trial
claim
were
not
Court
except
the
freight charges which were borne by defendant
no.1
for
export
of
the
second
and
third
consignment.
180.
by
Regarding the issue of payment received
defendant
no.1
firm
from
Yugoslavian
buyers for second and third consignments is
concerned, the witness of the plaintiff has
deposed
that
defendant
no.5
has
forwarded
freight bills to defendant no.1 instead of
the plaintiff and before the plaintiff can
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
submit the bills before the bank, defendant
no.1 had already encashed Letters of Credit
opened by the Yugoslavian buyers.
181.
At this stage, it is pertinent to note
that during the pendency of the suit, interim
order was passed to keep the money received
by the defendant no.6 bank in Sundry account
and accordingly amount of Rs.33,82,509.08 on
06.09.1979 and amount of Rs.3,84,911.47 on
07.06.1986
were
kept
in
sundry
account
by
defendant no.6 and copy of the statement of
Sundry
account
Trial
Court
is
while
placed
at
disposing
Exh.318.
The
the
has
suit
directed to transfer this amount which during
the
pendency
of
the
appeal
has
been
now
invested by the Registry in the Fixed Deposit
with State Bank of India.
182.
On perusal of the deposition of witness
no.1 of the plaintiff – Anilbhai Chandubhai
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Pota, it is deposed in the examination-inchief that payment of third consignment was
received by defendant no.1 in two parts as
Yugoslavian buyers made the first payment as
per
the
standard
quality
of
the
goods
received and dispute of quality was raised
regarding some part of the goods and withheld
the payment, subsequently such dispute was
given up and entire payment was made by the
foreign buyer. He has also referred to Form
A.R.4 which is placed on record at Exh.319 to
Exh.321. It was also pointed out that the
carbon copy was sent to the plaintiff, and
the original were kept by defendant no.5 M/s.
Airfreight (P) Ltd. He has also identified
Fixed
Deposit
Receipt
(FDR)
for
2 nd
consignment taken out by defendant nos. 1 to
4 at Exh. 323.
183.
By referring to letter dated 06.10.1988
at Exh.324, it was stated that State Bank of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
India has returned the unpaid bill received
by it from defendant no.6 New Bank of India
along with original certificate issued by the
Customs
along
department
with
the
sent
by
goods.
the
Witness
plaintiff
of
the
plaintiff also referred to telex messages at
Exh.326 to Exh.333 in which it is disclosed
that
the
goods
would
be
shifted
after
licenses are re-validated by the buyer. Telex
messages are from 06.04.1979 to 03.05.1979
for not exporting the goods by defendant nos.
1 to 5. Thereafter notice dated 08.10.1979
was issued by the plaintiff and notices were
also issued by the Customs Officer and reply
was given by defendant nos. 1 to 4 and order
of
the
Special
02.01.1981
Officer
against
of
defendant
Customs
dated
nos.
to
which was challenged by defendant nos. 1 to 4
before the Board of Revenue who set aside the
adjudication
order.
These
documents
are
placed on record from Exh.334 to 337. The
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
plaintiff has also made efforts for return of
the goods through Customs Officer. Documents
thereof are placed on record from Exh.339 to
Exh. 349 and thereafter in the month of May,
1979, it was decided by the plaintiff to file
the suit. Even spare parts were sent to the
Yugoslavian buyers by the plaintiff and bill
for Airfreight was placed at Exh.352.
184.
Reference
was
also
made
to
telex
messages between the parties from Exh.353 to
Exh. 368. Thus, the witness of the plaintiff
proved that the goods sent by the plaintiff
was exported but no payment was made.
185.
No cross examination of the witness of
the plaintiff was made on behalf of defendant
nos. 1 to 4 as advocate was not present.
However, cross examination was made on behalf
of
defendant
regarding
the
no.6
-
extension
New
Bank
of
India
of
the
Letters
of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Credit wherein it is deposed by the witness
that defendant nos. 1 to 4 did not pay the
amount of the goods and further denied that
no amount is sent by the Yugoslavian buyers
for the goods manufactured by the plaintiff
which were exported by defendant no.5 for 2nd
and 3rd consignment. Regarding counter claim
of the defendant nos. 1 to 4, witness also
deposed in examination in chief to the effect
that
the
plaintiff
had
informed
defendant
no.5 to return the goods which is placed on
record at Exh.451 and letter dated 10.03.1979
which is at Exh No. 452 and letters dated
30.04.1979,
Exh.455,
09.05.1979
letter
written
at
Exh.
to
to
Air
India
to
export the goods through air cargo is also
placed at Exh.456 and reply given by the Air
India is placed at Exh.457. Even the customs
officer has written letter to the plaintiff
for
return
Kandla
Free
of
goods
Trade
as
Zone
it
was
without
sent
from
payment
of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
duty. Said letters are placed from Exh.458 to
460.
186.
Considering
such
documents,
it
was
deposed that the details given in para no. 20
of the counter claim are not true and correct
and defendant nos. 1 to 4 have concocted the
story of damages to raise exaggerated counter
claim.
187.
In the cross examination, carried out on
behalf of defendant nos. 1 to 4, witness has
reiterated the facts which were deposed in
examination in chief and deposed that goods
sent by the plaintiff was of good quality and
same
was
to
be
exported
at
the
cost
and
liability of the plaintiff. However, it was
admitted
by
the
witness
that
airfreight,
demurrages and handling charges were not paid
by the plaintiff company and the goods of
second and third consignment were sent from
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Kandla after the expiry of Letters of Credit.
However, it was denied that defendant no.1
firm did not inform the plaintiff company to
send
the
goods
of
second
and
third
consignment. It is also denied that defendant
no.1 firm was not liable to export the goods
of 2nd and 3rd consignment and the plaintiff
company was liable to receive the amount as
agreed between Hasmukh Khatri and defendant
no.1 firm. It was also denied by the witness
that the plaintiff company was not liable to
pay demurrage amount to defendant no.1 firm
for 3rd consignment.
188.
The witness has also denied that there
was any negligence on part of the plaintiff
as well as it was also denied that goods of
2nd
and
defendant
3rd
consignment
no.1
firm
was
on
sent
the
through
basis
of
collection and after expiry of the Letters of
credit, no facilities can be obtained from
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the bank and there was no correspondence made
by
the
plaintiff
company
with
Yugoslavian
buyers. Thus, the witness has not accepted
any
suggestion
made
on
behalf
of
the
defendants regarding the counter claim and
reiterated what is stated in examination in
chief.
189.
Witness no.1 of defendant no.6- Devraj
Indraprasad Anand deposed in examination in
chief that defendant “House of Dubary” opened
the account in New Bank of India, Defense
colony branch, in the year 1978 and at that
time
only
two
partners
Deepak
Darbari
and
Ravi Darbari were declared. Letters of Credit
were
issued
on
05.10.1978
wherein
date
of
shipping was fixed as 01.12.1978 and date of
submission
of
document
was
fixed
as
20.12.1978. It was also deposed that for 2nd
consignment,
the
defendant
consignment
documents
like
firm
submitted
airway
bills
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
invoices, packing list etc. on 27.12.1978 and
in airway bill, one of the name of shipper
was
shown
as
“House
of
Dubary”
and
such
documents were sent to Yugoslavian bank and
out of three bills of exchange, payment of
two
bills
of
exchange
were
received
on
30.01.1979 and the date of payment of third
bill
was
fixed
on
14.02.1979
and
after
receipt of the amount by the bank, the same
was credited in the account of the defendant
firm. It was deposed that the documents were
in the name of defendant firm and therefore,
the
plaintiff
was
not
entitled
to
receive
such amount, and the amount was permitted to
be withdrawn by the defendant no.1 firm, and
the
defendant
firm
adjusted
the
amount
against the outstanding dues of the bank. It
was also deposed that 3rd consignment was sent
through airway bill dated 04.05.1979 and the
documents
were
deposited
with
the
bank
on
09.05.1979 and in the airway bill only name
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
of “House of Dubary” was stated as shipper.
190.
It also emerges from record that payment
for 3rd
consignment was also received from
Yugoslavian buyers by the defendant no.6 Bank
and in view of stay order granted, payment of
3rd consignment of about Rs. 37 Lacs were not
paid
to
the
defendant
firm
but
the
said
amount was kept in sundry account. It was
deposed that payment of 3rd consignment could
not be made by the bank as the airway bill,
inspection and Letters of Credit had expired
and
there
was
no
agreement
between
the
plaintiff and defendant firm with the bank
for making payment directly to the plaintiff.
191.
In the cross examination of the said
witness of defendant no.6, it was admitted on
the basis of documents at Exh.283 to Exh.289,
which pertains to Letters of Credit opened by
the Yugoslavian buyers in Bank of Rajasthan,
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Janpath Branch at New Delhi in the name of
“House of Dubary” and Letters of Credit of
Rajasthan
papers
bank,
and
as
an
Letters
agent
of
collected
Credit
the
through
defendant firm to the New Bank of India and
on the basis of such documents, New Bank of
India issued Letters of Credit in favour of
defendant firm.
192.
It
was
also
admitted
that
for
3rd
consignment, airway bill was not sent to the
State Bank of India, but invoices and packing
list
etc.
India.
It
was
was
sent
to
also
the
State
admitted
Bank
that
of
the
documents stated in Exh.325 were received by
defendant no.6 bank. When document at Exh.318
was shown to the witness of defendant no.6,
it was admitted that it was copy of sundry
account and no interest is paid in sundry
account and such amount is kept for non-use
purpose by the bank.
C/FA/531/1986
193.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Regarding
admitted
Court
that
Commissioner,
papers
of
it
the
was
Court
Commissioner were signed by him and the Court
Commissioner had inspected the accounts of
the bank and the report is placed at Exh.400.
Witness also agreed that as per Exh.388, 2nd
consignment
amount
of
three
bills
was
deposited which was credited on 31.01.1979,
01.02.1979 and 27.02.1979 and amount of FDR
from Commissioner’s report was pertaining to
the 2nd consignment.
194.
It
was
also
admitted
that
name
of
defendant no.1 firm was mentioned as shipper
of the plaintiff and accordingly, the amount
received from Yugoslavian buyer was deposited
in the account of the defendant no.1 firm.
195.
Witness no.1 of defendant nos. 1 to 4
Deepak Darbari at Exh.415 has submitted his
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
examination in chief wherein it is deposed
that after expiry of Letters of Credit, the
plaintiff sent the goods for 2nd consignment
without
consent
of
the
defendants
and
therefore, such goods were not exported. It
was
also
deposed
that
amount
of
freight,
demurrages and handling charges were paid by
defendant no.1 firm though same was to be
paid by the plaintiff. It is also deposed
that such amount paid by the defendant nos. 1
firm is stated in counter claim. It is also
deposed that for 2nd consignment, the amount
was received from Yugoslavian buyers however,
as Letters of Credit had expired, same was
deposited in the account of defendant no.1.
196.
With regard to 3rd consignment, it was
deposed that the plaintiff informed defendant
no.1 firm when the goods reached from Kandla
to
Mumbai
and
it
was
informed
by
the
plaintiff that such goods were to be exported
C/FA/531/1986
on
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
their
own
and
after
Hasmukh
Khatri
requested for negotiation with regard to 3rd
consignment, defendant no.1 paid the amount
of airfreight etc. as there was no financial
facility
with
the
plaintiff.
deposed
that
defendant
It
no.1
was
also
firm
paid
clearing, handling service demurrage amount
for 3rd consignment which was to be paid by
the plaintiff and the said amount is stated
in
the
counter
claim.
It
was
therefore,
deposed that as the plaintiff was required to
pay the charges of freight, demurrage etc.,
amount received from Yugoslavian buyers was
adjusted against such charges to be received
from the plaintiff by deducting the amount to
be payable to the plaintiff and as defendant
no.1 firm could not earn profit of about Rs.
20 Lacs
had the plaintiff sent the goods
within the period of Letters of Credit, the
said amount was included in the counter claim
filed by the defendant nos. 1 to 4.
C/FA/531/1986
197.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Various documents were placed on record
regarding the payment made by defendant no.1
firm from Exh.420 to Exh.425. In the cross
examination, it was admitted by the witness
of defendant nos.1 to 4 that defendant no.1
firm is not registered under the Partnership
Act
and
only
counter
claim
was
filed
on
behalf of the firm and its partner. It was
also
admitted
that
defendant
no.1
firm
is
keeping the account books at Delhi office and
is also paying the income tax. It is also
admitted by the witness of defendants in the
cross examination that at the time of export
of 3rd
consignment, free shipping bill was
obtained and A.R.4 Form was not submitted. It
was also admitted that defendant no.1 firm
had exported the goods for 3rd consignment at
the cost of the plaintiff by obtaining the
free shipping bill in the name of defendant
no.1 firm.
C/FA/531/1986
198.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
However, it was denied that A.R.4 Form
was not utilised as Yugoslavian buyers were
not able to pay the amount of 3rd consignment
as Letters of Credit had expired.
199.
It
was
also
admitted
that
Exh.310
to
Exh.314 are photocopies of invoices of 2nd
consignment which were sent to Yugoslavia and
Exh.315 is airway bill of the 2nd consignment.
It was also admitted that the amount of 3rd
consignment was received in part. It was also
deposed
that
amount
of
freight,
handling
services of 2nd and 3rd consignment was to be
borne by the plaintiff.
200.
It was admitted by the witness that no
amount
was
deducted
by
Yugoslavian
buyers
with regard to 2nd consignment and there is no
outstanding payment to be made by Yugoslavian
buyers
regarding
any
goods
which
exported for 2nd and 3rd consignment.
were
C/FA/531/1986
201.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Thus, the witness of defendant nos. 1 to
4 admitted that goods of 2nd consignment and
3rd
consignment
no.1
firm
were
and
exported
payment
was
by
defendant
received
from
Yugoslavian buyers which was not paid to the
plaintiff as defendant no.1 was required to
recover
the
amount
of
freight
and
other
charges from the plaintiff.
202.
From the above analysis of the oral and
documentary evidence on record, it cannot be
said that the Trial Court has erred in law in
holding
that
contract
was
independent
of
Letters of Credit.
203.
by
So far as the first consignment exported
the
parties,
transaction
and
relation
thereto was over as per the terms of the
Letters of Credit. However, so far as 2nd and
3rd consignment which are admittedly exported,
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Letters
of
inspite
such
fact
being
known
to
Letters
of
Credit
had
expired,
that
Credit
had
already
expired
and
everyone
2nd
consignment was also exported and payment was
received
from
the
Yugoslavian
buyers
and
third consignment was detained by defendant
no.5 Clearing and Forwarding Agent for about
four
months
and
ultimately,
the
said
consignment was also exported and defendant
no.1 firm received the payment by encashing
the Letters of Credit on the basis of airway
bill in its name without utilising the A.R.4
Form which were sent by the plaintiff firm
along with the goods.
204.
Thus, the defendant no.1 firm exported
the goods
of 2nd and 3rd consignment without
considering the Letters of Credit which were
issued in favour of the plaintiff. Hence , it
cannot be said that the Trial Court has erred
in holding that contract was independent of
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Letters of Credit.
205.
Points
for
Determination
No.7
and
raise a very important issue as to whether
the decretal amount is arbitrary and based on
manifest error or not and whether the trial
Court was just and correct in decreeing the
suit for Rs.49,81,336/- and disallowing the
claim of the plaintiff for Rs.13,09,909/-.
After considering the evidence on record, the
Trial Court has rightly concluded that the
plaintiff was entitled to the amount of 2nd
and 3rd consignment as observed in para no.
137 of the impugned judgment and order as
under:
“(137).... I have carefully examined
the plaint and the recital of the
cross
suit
along
with
the
documentary
evidence
and
gone
through particularly the relevant
invoice at Exhts. 310,312 and 314
along with air way bill at Ex.315
and found that three cargo were sent
in
the
second
consignment
and
thereby supplied the goods viz.,
2000 pieces of venus model, 10996
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
pieces of the model North Stars and
10,000 pieces of the model panasia
at rate per piece in US dollar 8.50,
43,6985,
8,00
respectively.
The
C.I.F. price value was in total US
Dollars
93,466-00,
87,397-00
and
80,000 respectively. It
was the
understanding that the firm House of
Darbary should have been arranged
for the insurance and therefore be
deducted one percent of such price
value C.I.F. For the deduction of
such one percent it was necessary to
be deducted in US Dollar 934.66,
873.97 and 800 respectively from C.
I.F. value of these items. After
deduction, it will be found that in
US Dollars the balance amount will
be 92,531.34, 86,523-03 and 79,20000 respectively.
If we will be converted the balance
value of the dollars into Indian
rupees then it will be Rs.7,71,09450 paise, R.7,21,025-00 paise and
Rs. 6,60,000-00 paise respectively
of the value on basis C & F. I find
that the total value on basis C & F
of the goods relating to the second
consignment
will
be
of
Rs.
21,52,119-50 paise. In the present
case it is now no longer in dispute
that the items as to be shown on
page No.11 in paragraph No.110 of
the plaint are not entirely second
consignment but on the contrary, it
is admitted position that the item
"shella" and the item "Binoculars"
are not relating to the contract
with the plaintiff but are related
with the contract M/s. Hashmukh
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Brothers
and
the
said
Hashmukh
Brothers
had
supplied
the
item
Shella and the item Binoculars even
wrongly
and
by
mistaken
to
be
mentioned in the plaint. According
to the parties, the goods as to be
shown above were sent in the second
consignment out of the total items
as mentioned in the plaint and the
remaining goods relating to item
"khashmir" and the item "victory"
and the item "venus" pieces
were sent in the third consignment
along with othe goods. On basis of
this fact, I have found that the
firm House of Dubary had received
the total amount of Rs. 34,49,578-07
paise including the item of "shella"
and the item of Binoculars of the
second consignment from Yugoslavian
buyers which being credited in the
account of the firm in New Bank of
India Ltd., New Delhi as per Ex.388
showing the same in red ink circle.
This shows that this total amount of
Rs. 34,49,578-07 paise was including
the value of the goods "shella" and
Binocular which being supplied by
Hashmukh Brothers and therefore it
will be required to be deducted from
the total amount of Rs. 12,92,87-96
paise out of such total balance.
After deducting such amount, we will
get
the
total
amount
of
Rs.
21,56,570-71 paise which will be the
amount of the second consignment as
received by the firm House of Dubary
as per vide Ex. 388 from the
Yugoslavian buyers. I have already
stated above that the firm House of
Dubary paid the chatter freight for
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the second consignment of the amount
Rs. 1,91,646-00 If we will deduct
this amount of freight, of the
total amount of Rs. 21,56,570.71
paise then will be got the amount of
Rs. 19,64,924-71 paise. It shows
that the amount of Rs. 19,64,924-71
is less than the total value on
basis C & F of Rs.21,52,119-50
paise. This being so, it is now
clear that the firm House of Dubary
had at all not received any amount
towards the freight and insurance
from Yugoslavian buyers. If it was
the contract on
basis of F.O.B.
then the firm House of Dubary was
certainly received the amount which
being spent after the freight and
insurance for the second consignment
from
Yugoslavian
buyers
when
Yugoslavian buyers did not pay such
freight and insurance to the firm
House of Dubary which would go to
show
that
the
goods
of
second
consignment were supplied by the
plaintiff
under
the
original
contract on basis C.I.F. It is
therefore clear that the plaintiff
had to be paid the insurance and
charter freight of the second and
third consignment and it was the
provisional accommodation and was
given the facility to the plaintiff
by the firm House of Dubary with
bonafide to be exported the goods
even after expiration of the time
limit of the contract on basis of
C.I.F
and
not
F.O.B.
without
altering the essence and foundation
or nature of the contract on basis
of C.I.F. I therefore disagree with
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the
submission
of
the
learned
advocate
Shree
Bheda
for
the
plaintiff that the firm House of
Dubary
and
partners
there
were
liable to pay the insurance freight
and handling charges of the goods
The defence story is found most
probable and convincing and it is
fully supported by the oral and
documentary evidence on record.
206.
With
regard
to
the
amount
for
2nd
consignment, Trial Court has rightly observed
that amount of Rs.26,00,863/- mentioned in
para no. 10 of the plaint is not correct and
correct amount would be Rs.19,60,473.50 as
per the Letters of Credit on the basis of CIF
without deducting 1% value of insurance as
per the correspondence as under:
“138).....I have found from the
evidence that the plaintiff is only
entitled
to
get
the
amount
of
5.19,60.473-50 paise for the goods
relating to the second consignment
from the deft., Nos. 1 to 4 only and
not the amount of Rs. 26,0,863-00 as
claimed and mentioned in the plaint.
The claim of the plaintiff is no
correct
towards
the
second
consignment. I have found that the
facts as to be furnished on pageNo.11 in paragraph No.10 of the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
plaint are not correct and it is
contrary
even
on
basis
of
the
accounts which have been produced by
the plaintiff itself under mark
202/6 (on page No.5 to 7). I have
carefully examined the statement of
the accounts mark 202/6 and found
that the plaintiff has shown the
value on basis C & F eventhough
mentioned in the plaint the value on
basis C.I.F. without deducting the
one percent value of the insurance
as per the correspondence. I have
further found that the invoice H.K.
No.8
and
the
invoice
H.K.No.9
relating to the item "Shella" and
the
item
"Binoculars"
are
not
entered into books of account of the
plaintiff even if mentioned in the
plaint covering such two items as to
be supplied by the plaintiff, where
there was no orders and contract for
the same with the plaintiff but the
orders were under the con tract with
M/s. Hashmukh Brothers.”
207.
Regarding
3rd
consignment,
the
Trial
Court has held that the plaintiff is entitled
to
the
amount
of
Rs.30,20,912.75
after
deducting freight of Rs.5,30,806/- as under:
“139).....As
regards
to
third
consignment is concerned, it is
clear that the goods were sent to
Yugoslavian buyers on 4-5-79 vide
air-way bill ex, 317. The invoice at
Ex. 316 speaks that in the third
consignment, the goods were sent
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
viz. A Car Radio cassettes Model
venus 3000 pieces at rate per piece
in US Dollars 51-41, (2) Transistor
Radio Model panasia 6000 pieces at
rate per piece in US dollars 10-00
(3) Transistor Radio Model Tele
star, 5000 pieces at rate per piece
in
US
dollars
17,76
(4)
radio
cassettes Model Kashmir, 2499 pieces
at rate per piece in US Dollars
42,49 (5) Radio cassettes Model
victory. 2500 pieces at rate per
pieces in US dollars 40-32. Now
these items are tally with the facts
as mentioned on page-11 and on page
20 in paragraphs Nos. 10 and 13 of
the plaint and it is found that the
goods as mentioned above were sent
in the third consignment as per the
invoice vide Ex. 316 by the Air-way
bill vide Ex. 317 to Yugoslavian
buyers. But the plaintiff has shown
the price value of such goods in the
plaint on basis of C.I.F. without
deducting one percent of the charges
insurance as per the correspondence.
I have found from the accounts mark202(6)
that
the
plaintiff
has
entered the price value of such
goods into its own books of account
on basis C&F after deducting the one
percent charges of the insurance. It
is therefore clear that the price
value
of
the
goods
as
to
be
mentioned is not on based. C & F but
on basis C.I.F. which is not as per
terms
of
the
contract.
I
have
therefore
taken
total
value
on
basis, C & F from the accounts mark
202 (6) (on- pages 8 to 13) in US
dollars
42,6475-53
equivalent
in
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Indian Rs. 35,51,712-75 paise. It is
now necessary to be deducted the
amount
of
the
freight
of
Rs.
5,30,800 so that we will get the
figure of Rs. 30,20,912-75 paise of
the
value
on
basis
F.O.B.
The
plaintiff
has
claimed
of
Rs.
34,65,606-60 which is incorrect but
will be entitled to get only the
amount of Rs. 30,20,912-75 paise
towards the goods relating to third
consignment on basis F.O.B. and not
more.”
208.
The Trial Court has also rejected the
claim of the defendants regarding Rs.60,000/towards
demurrages,
Rs.
Lacs
towards
defects in goods on coming to the conclusion
that
no
deduction
was
made
by
Yugoslavian
buyers from the payment of 3rd
consignment
which is proved by the plaintiff from the
evidence on record and the defendants have
therefore, failed to prove that the plaintiff
has committed breach of contract but it has
also been established that defendant nos. 1
to 4 have not paid the money to the plaintiff
and withheld the money even after receiving
from Yugoslavian buyers.
C/FA/531/1986
209.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Thus,
the
Trial
Court
has
passed
the
decree for Rs.49,81,336/- (for 2nd consignment
Rs.19,60,473.50
and
3rd
for
consignment
Rs.30,20,912.75).
210.
In
view
of
aforesaid
findings
of
the
Trial Court which is borne out from the oral
and documentary evidence on record, it cannot
be said that decretal amount is arbitrary and
based on manifest error. There is no error in
arriving at decretal amount of Rs.49,81,336/awarded by the Trial Court.
211.
Point for Determination no.9 pertains to
counter
claim
raised
by
defendant
no.1
by
filing the written statement under Order VIII
Rule 6(A) of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 raising a claim of Rs.1,08,85,152/-.
212.
Learned advocate Mr. Joshi appearing for
C/FA/531/1986
the
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
plaintiff
raised
preliminary
objection
regarding the maintainability of the appeal
filed by the defendant nos. 1 to 4 contending
that First Appeal with counter claim itself
would
not
be
contained
maintainable
under
section
in
view
of
of
the
bar
Indian
Partnership Act, 1932.
213.
Learned
Trial
Judge
while
answering
issue no.2(G) at para no. 119 and 122 of the
impugned
judgment
and
order
has
discussed
this issue and answered that counter claim is
not
maintainable
defendant
registered
no.1
on
the
premise
that
the
firm
was
not
provisions
of
the
partnership
under
the
Partnership Act, 1932. Section 69 and section
69A of the Partnership Act reads thus:
“69. EFFECT OF NON-REGISTRATION. (1) No suit to enforce a right
arising from a contract or conferred
by this Act shall be instituted in
any Court by or on a behalf of any
persons suing as a partner in a firm
against the firm or any person
alleged to be or to have been a
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
partner in the firm unless the firm
is registered and the person suing
is or has been shown in the Register
of Firms as a partner in the firm :
Provided that the requirement of
registration of firm under this subsection shall not apply to the suits
or proceedings instituted by the
heirs or legal representatives of
the deceased partner of a firm for
accounts of the firm or to realise
the property of the firm.
(2) No suit to enforce a right
arising from a contract shall I be
instituted in any court by or on
behalf of a firm against any third
party unless the firm is registered
and the persons suing are or have
been shown in the Register of Firms
as partners in the firm.
(2A) No suit to enforce any right
for the dissolution of a firm or for
accounts of a dissolved firm or any
right or power to
realise the
property of a dissolved firm shall
be instituted in any Court by or on
behalf of any person suing as a
partner in a firm against the firm
or any person alleged to be or have
been a partner in the firm, unless
the firm is registered and the
person suing is or has been shown in
the Register of Firms as a partner
in the firm :
Provided that the requirement of
registration of firm under this subsection shall not apply to the suits
or proceedings instituted by the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
heirs or legal representatives of
the deceased partner of a firm for
accounts of a dissolved firm or to
realise the property of a dissolved
firm.
(3) The provisions of sub-sections
(1), (2) and (2A) shall apply also
to a claim of setoff or other
proceedings
to
enforce
a
right
arising from a contract but shall
not affect
(a) the firms constituted for a
duration upto six months or with a
capital upto two thousand rupees;
or;
(b)
the
powers
of
an
official
assigned, receiver or Court under
the Presidency Towns Insolvency Act,
1909, or the Provincial Insolvency
Act, 1920, to realise the property
of an insolvent partner.
(4) This section shall not apply (a) to firms or partners in firm
which have no place of business in
the territories to which this Act
extends, or whose places of business
in the said territories are situated
in areas to which, by notification
under section 56 this Chapter does
not apply, or OF GUJARAT
(b) to any suit or claim of set-off
not exceeding one hundred rupees in
value
which,
in
the
presidency
towns, is not of a kind specified in
section 19 of the Presidency Small
Cause Courts Act, 1882, or outside
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the Presidency towns, is not of a
kind
specified
in
the
Second
Schedule to the Provincial Small
Cause Courts Act, 1887, or to any
proceeding in execution or other
proceeding incidental to or arising
from any such suit or claim.
Comment:
"...Thus,
the
persons
suing, namely, the current partners
as on the date of the suit were not
shown as partners in the Register of
Firms. The result is that the suit
was not maintainable in view of the
provisions of sub-sec. (2) of S. 69
of the said Partnership Act..." M/s.
Shreeram
Finance
Corporation,
Appellants v. Yasin Khan AIR 1989
SUPREME COURT 1769
Section69A PENALTY FOR CONTRAVENTION
OF SECTION 60, 61, 62, OR 63.
If any statement, intimation or
notice under sections 60, 61, 62 or
63 in respect of any registered firm
is
not
sent
or
given
to
the
Registrar,
within
the
period
specified
in
that
section,
the
Registrar may, after giving notice
to the partners of the firm and
after
giving
them
a
reasonable
opportunity of being heard, refuse
to make the suitable amendments in
the records relating to the firm,
until the partners of the firm pay
such penalty, not exceeding ten
rupees per day, as the Registrar may
determine in respect of the period
between the date of expiry of the
period specified in sections 60, 61,
62 or as the case may be, 63 and the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
date of making the amendments in the
entries relating to the firm.”
214.
A plain reading of the above provision
would
indicate
that
no
suit
to
enforce
a
right arising from a contract or conferred by
the Act shall be instituted in any Court by
or on a behalf of any persons suing as a
partner in a firm against the firm or any
person
alleged
partner
in
to
be
or
to
the
firm
unless
of
the
have
been
a
the
firm
is
registered.
215.
Section
Partnership
Act
mandates as to how registration of a firm may
be
effect
and
the
non-consequence
of
registration is traceable to section 69. The
said provision is mandatory in character, and
its effect is to render a suit in respect of
a right under the Contract which he entered
into
a
partner
of
a
unregistered
firm
as
being void. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
case of Loonkaran Sethia etc. versus Mr. Ivan
E. John and Others reported in AIR 1977 SC
336 has held that Section 69 is mandatory in
character and its effect is to render a suit
filed by the plaintiff in respect of a right
vested in him or acquire by him under the
contract which he entered into as a partner
in a unregistered firm, whether existing or
dissolved as void. It has been further held
in para 21 as under:“21. A bare glance at the section is
enough to show that it mandatory in
character and its effect is to
render a suit by a plaintiff in
respect of a right vested in him or
acquired by him under a contract
which he entered into as a partner
of an unregistered firm whether
existing or dissolved, void. In
other
words,
a
partner
of
a
erstwhile unregistered part- nership
firm cannot bring a suit to enforce
a right arising out of a contract
falling within the ambit of section
69 of the Partnership Act. In the
instant case, Seth Suganchand had to
admit in unmistakable terms that the
firm
'Sethiya
&
Co.'
was
not
registered
under
the
Indian
Partnership Act. It cannot also be
denied that the suit out of which
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
the appeals have arisen was for
enforcement of the agreement entered
into by the plaintiff as partner of
Sethiya
&
Co.
which
was
an
unregistered firm. That being so,
the suit is undoubtedly a suit for
the benefit and interest of the firm
and consequently a suit on behalf of
the firm. It is also to be borne in
mind that it was never pleaded by
the plain- tiff, not even-in the
replication, that he was suing to
recover
the
outstandings
of
a
dissolved firm. Thus the suit was
clearly
hit
by
section
the
Partnership
Act
and
was
not
maintainable."
216.
While examining as to embargo contained
under sub-section 3 of Section 69, wherein
the expression "other proceedings" is found.
The Apex Court in the case of M/s. Umesh Goel
versus
Himachal
Pradesh
Cooperative
Group
Housing Society Ltd. reported in AIR 2016 SC
3116, has held :
"8. Having heard learned counsel for
the appellant as well the respondent
and having bestowed our serious
consideration
to
the
respective
submissions, the various decisions
relied
upon
and
the
provisions
contained in the Partnership Act,
the Interest Act, Civil Procedure
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Code and Arbitration Act, we are of
the view that the submissions of Mr.
Dhruv Mehta, learned Senior Counsel
for the appellant merit acceptance.
xxx
10. Though, some of the decisions
which were cited before us dealt
with
Section
69(3)
of
the
Partnership Act, in the instance we
wish to analyze the said sub-section
along with the other components of
the said Section 69. When we read
sub-section
(3)
of
Section
carefully, we find that as rightly
contended
by
Mr.
Dhruv
Mehta,
learned
Senior
Counsel
for
the
appellant, the provisions of subsections (1) and (2) have been
impliedly
incorporated
in
subsection (3). When the opening set of
expression in sub-section (3) states
that the provisions of sub- sections
(1) and (2) shall apply, there is no
difficulty in accepting the said
submission of learned Senior Counsel
for the appellant that the entirety
of the said two sub-sections should
be held to be bodily lifted and
incorporated in sub-section (3). It
is difficult to state that any one
part of sub-sections (1) and (2)
alone
should
be
held
to
be
incorporated for the purpose of subsection
(3).
Therefore,
we
are
convinced that when we read subsection (3) it is imperative that
all the ingredients contained in
sub-sections (1) and (2) should be
read
into
sub-section
(3)
and
thereafter
apply
the
said
sub-
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
section when such application is
called for in any matter.
xxx
12.
The
question
for
our
consideration is by virtue of subsection (3) whether the expression
"other
proceedings"
contained
therein
will
include
Arbitral
proceedings and can be equated to a
suit filed in a Court and thereby
the
ban
imposed
against
an
unregistered firm can operate in the
matter of arbitral proceedings. If
subsections
(1)
and
(2)
are
virtually
lifted
whole
hog
and
incorporated in sub-section (3), it
must be stated that it is not the
mere ban that is imposed in subsections (1) and (2) that alone is
contemplated for the application of
sub-section (3). In other words,
when the whole of the ingredients
contained in sub-sections (1) and
(2) are wholly incorporated in subsection (3), the resultant position
would be that the ban can operate in
respect of an unregistered firm even
relating to a set off or other
proceedings only when such claim of
set off or other proceedings are
intrinsically
connected
with
the
suit that is pending in a Court. To
put it differently, in order to
invoke sub-section (3) of Section 69
and for the ban to operate either
the firm should be an unregistered
one or the person who wants to sue
should
be
a
partner
of
an
unregistered firm, that its / his
endeavour should be to file a suit
in a Court, in which event even if
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
it pertains to a claim of set off or
in respect of 'other proceedings'
connected with any right arising
from a contract or conferred by the
Partnership Act which is sought to
be enforced through a Court by way
of a suit then and then alone the
said sub-section can operate to its
full extent.
13. As far as the construction of
the said sub-section (3) of Section
69 is concerned, we are able to
discern the above legal position
without any scope of ambiguity. To
be
more
precise,
the
condition
precedent for the operation of ban
under sub-section (3) is that the
launching of a suit in a Court of
law should be present and it should
be by an unregistered firm or by a
person claiming to be partner of an
unregistered firm either to a claim
for set off in the said suit or any
other
proceedings
intrinsically
connected with the said suit.
14. In the event of the above
ingredients
set
out
under
subsections (1), (2) and (3) being
fulfilled then and then alone the
ban
prescribed
against
an
unregistered
firm
under
Section
69(1), (2) and (3) would operate and
not otherwise.”
217.
The
Hon'ble
Apex
Court
concluded
that
the expression "other proceedings" occurring
in section 69(3) of the Act does not having
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
application
section,
to
the
the
ban
imposed
proceedings
under
said
initiated
for
arbitral proceedings as well as arbitration
award.
218.
Thus, the counter claim filed by first
defendant for payment of Rs. 1,08,85,152/- by
the
plaintiffs
in
favour
of
the
defendant
itself was not maintainable and consequently
the
appeal
preferred
by
first
defendant
insofar as rejection of the counter claim by
the trial court which is the subject matter
of the appeal No. 531 of 1986 would not be
maintainable. However, insofar as the
appeal
filed challenging the judgment and decree of
the
suit
being
decreed
for
a
sum
of
Rs.
49,81,336/- against defendant Nos. 1 to 4,
the correctness and legality of the same can
be
assailed
by
defendant
Nos.
to
4,
inasmuch the decree being joint and several,
the appeal filed under section 96 of CPC by
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
defendant nos. 1 to 4 would be maintainable.
219.
Thus,
we
are
of
the
opinion
that
the
trial Court was justified in rejecting the
counter claim filed by defendant nos. 1 to 4.
However,
merely
by
rejecting
the
counter
claim we cannot be oblivious to the facts of
the
case
that
expenses
incurred
by
the
defendant no.1 firm for export of 2 nd and 3rd
consignment which were liable to be borne by
the
plaintiff
defendant
no.1
cannot
be
denied
firm.
We
have
to
the
therefore,
considered this aspect while deciding point
no.11.
220.
Point
for
Determination
No.10
pertains
to exonerating defendant nos. 5 and 6 from
joint and several liability from making the
payment of the decretal amount by the Trial
Court is justified or not as raised in First
Appeal No.1093/1987 filed by the plaintiff.
C/FA/531/1986
221.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
The contention raised on behalf of the
plaintiff that defendant no.6 was also party
to
the
breach
of
contract
committed
by
defendant nos. 1 to 4 was dealt with by the
Trial Court in para no. 94 as under:
“94)......
The
question
for
consideration in this case is whether
the six deft., New Bank of India is
liable for the fraud as to be committed
by the deft., Nos. 1 to 5 regarding to
their consignment whereby is the six
deft., committed negligence in tort.
The learned advocate Shree Bheda for
the plaintiff submits that the New Bank
of India was liable to make the
payments of the second and third
consignments
under
the
letters
of
credit on receipt the actual amounts
from the Bank of the Yugoslavian buyers
even if failed to do so and permitted
the first deft., to be converted the
said moneys in personal account of the
first deft., which being amounted of
the conversion on basis of the fraud
and collusion of the defts., Now on the
facts and circumstances of the case
before us., the Yugoslavian buyers
opened the irrevocable seven letters of
the credit towards the payments of the
orders of the goods in favour of the
first deft. The Zerox copies of such
letters of credit are produced by the
deft., which are exhibited vide Exhts.,
283 to 289. After that, in turn, the
New Bank of India opened the four
letters of credit in favour of the
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
plaintiff in the State Bank of India,
Branch office Kandla. Zerox copies of
such letters of credit along with the
documents are produced by the defts.,
which are exhibited vide exhts. 290 to
309. This shows that Bank of India was
opening bank and the State India was
advising Bank. It appears from the
letters of credit vide Exhts., 290 to
309 that the first deft., opened four
letters of credit valued at U.S.
Dollars
1,867,488-75
equivalent
to
Indian rupee 1,49,47,909-00 in favour
of the plaintiff for supplying the
goods as mentioned in the said letters
of the credit namely Radio cassette
Transistor Radio, Car Radio, Cassettes
etc., and proportionate payment as to
be made to beneficiary for any part of
shipments made. For such payments are
required
the
following
documents.
Commercial invoice, one origin and five
copies (2) packing list, one origin and
five copies (3) certificate of origin
one original and two copies from Indian
Chamber of Commerce (4) Inspection
quality certificate, one original and
two copies as issued by House of Dubary
New Delhi (5) Insurance Policy in U.S.
Dollars for 40 percent above the C. I.
F. value of the shipment one original
and three copies in assignable form
endorsed in Bank. Insurance to cover
all risks from seller's warehouse to
party's warehouse (6) original and two
copies of the bill of lading marked
freight prepaid, made out to the order
of
Makosped
skopje.
Notify
solun,
Gavgelija,
Yugoslavia
(7)
All
the
documents will be marked name of
shipper A/c House of Dubary, New Delhi,
India (8) we (New Bank of India Ltd.)
will
remit
the
proceeds
to
the
negotiating Bank of the OD/DC buying
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
rate prevailing on the day of
documents are negotiated under
above letter of credit therein
received by us.”
222.
the
the
are
In view of the aforesaid finding of the
Trial Court,
We do not find any infirmity in
findings of the Trial Court as the same is
based on oral and documentary evidence. So
far
as
Ltd.
defendant
is
no.5
concerned,
M/s.
Airfreight
(P)
was
appointed
by
it
defendant no.1 as a Clearing and Forwarding
Agent
and
was
acting
as
an
agent
of
the
plaintiff as well as defendant no.1 firm for
the export of goods and there is no oral and
documentary evidence to show that defendant
no.5 is liable for not exporting the goods
inspite of the instructions either from the
plaintiff
or
defendant
no.1
firm.
In
such
circumstances, the Trial Court has rightly
come to the conclusion that the suit stands
dismissed qua defendant nos. 5 and 6. In our
opinion,
the
Trial
Court
has
rightly
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
concluded that the rest of the suit and the
claim
stands
dismissed
against
defendant
nos.5 and 6.
223.
to
Point
for
Determination
no.11
pertains
whether the decree passed by the Trial
Court for Rs.49,81,336/- is just and proper.
224.
At this stage, it is pertinent to note
that on appreciation of oral and documentary
evidence on record, the Trial Court has not
granting set off of the expenses borne by the
defendant no.1 firm for export of the goods
of 2nd and 3rd consignment through defendant
no.5. However, from the findings which emerge
from
the
facts
on
the
basis
of
oral
and
documentary evidence, amount of expenditures
incurred by defendant no.1 firm are required
to be considered to be set off against the
amount of decree passed by the Trial Court in
favour of the plaintiff. The amount paid by
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
defendant no.1 firm for export of second and
third
consignment
is
discernible
from
the
counter claim of defendant nos. 1 to 4 which
is
supported
by
the
oral
evidence
of
the
defendant no.2 as analysed herein above.
225.
Therefore, for the purpose of rendering
substantial justice to see that the amount
spent by defendant no.1 firm for export of
goods
of
second
and
third
consignment
on
behalf of the plaintiff is required to be
reimbursed to defendant no.1 firm and
that extent the decretal amount
to
is required
to be modified.
226.
The plaintiff in the cross examination
of the defendant no.2 could not extract any
contradictory
facts
for
the
payment
of
airfreight, demurrage etc. for export of the
2nd and 3rd consignment made by the defendant
no.1 firm. Even the witness of the plaintiff
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
in his deposition has admitted that amount of
freight, demurrage, handling charges etc. for
export of 2nd and 3rd consignment were paid by
defendant no.1 firm.
227.
In
view
of
analysis
of
oral
and
documentary evidence made herein above and
considering
the
submissions
of
both
the
learned advocates, we have to consider as to
whether the decree passed by the Trial Court
for Rs.49,81,336/- is just and proper or not.
As we have noted while considering the point
no.9 for determination while upholding the
findings of the Trial Court that the counter
claim
of
defendant
no.1
firm
is
not
maintainable, however, we are of the opinion
that the expenses incurred by it for export
of
the
2nd
defendant
and
no.1
3rd
firm
consignment
are
reimbursed.
required
by
to
the
be
C/FA/531/1986
228.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
On perusal of the documents placed along
with the counter claim and considering the
deposition of the defendant no.2, it appears
that
defendant
no.1
firm
has
incurred
the
following expenditures:
Rs.4,75,000/(US$ 59,375.00)
Towards
airfreight
charges in respect of 2nd
consignment
(First
Charter)
Rs.4,50,000/(US$ 56,250.00)
Airfreight
charges
in
respect of 3rd consignment
(Second Charter)
Rs.1,53,990.08
(US$ 19,248.76)
For
goods
returned
Yugoslavian buyers
Rs.1,77,128/(US$ 22141.00)
As
per
letter
dated
19.06.1979 of Yugoslavian
buyers for not supplying
spare parts
Rs. 60,000/(US$ 7500.00)
For demurrage charges
Rs.50,000/-
For
clearing
forwarding charges
Rs.13,66,118/-
Total
229.
by
and
The above expenses are considered to be
paid by defendant no.1 on the basis of the
documents
placed
on
record.
Though
the
counter claim is rejected by the Trial Court,
the documents placed along with the counter
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
claim are considered by the Trial Court in
the impugned judgment and order in para no.
137 reproduced here-in-above. The Trial Court
has
also
60,000/-
considered
paid
by
the
the
amount
defendant
of
Rs.
no.1
firm
towards demurrage charges in para no.140 of
the judgment and order and has rejected the
claim of Rs. 10 Lacs on the ground that the
plaintiff has supplied the goods which were
not upto the mark of standard in para no. 141
of the judgment and also referred to Exh. 318
that
by
the
letter
by
Yugoslavian
buyers
remitted the amount of Rs.3,84,711/- which
was withheld for the defective goods. Even
reference
where
was
value
made
of
to
letter
defective
at
goods
Exh.
have
been
shown in US$ 65,595 and towards the value of
defective goods Yugoslavian buyers had paid
amount of Rs.3,84,711/- and has come to the
conclusion that the entire amount had been
paid
and
the
Yugoslavian
buyers
had
not
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
deducted
any
money
towards
the
defective
goods. Accordingly, the Trial Court has held
that the claim for defective goods does not
survive.
230.
Regarding
the
deficit
goods,
it
was
observed by the Trial Court in para no. 141
of the judgment that as per the Letter at
Exh. 418, goods worth US$ 8291 equivalent to
Rs.65,000/-
were
sent
under
the
insurance
with full value on the basis of C.I.F. and
therefore, the defendants would be entitled
to take legal course for recovery of damages
against the insurance company. However, such
findings of Trial Court cannot be accepted as
ultimately the plaintiff was responsible for
the payment of deficit goods. In that view of
the matter, we hold that the aforesaid amount
is required to be reimbursed to the defendant
no.1 firm by the plaintiff.
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Conclusion
231.
In view of foregoing analysis, we are of
the opinion that amount of Rs. 13,66,118/- is
required
to
be
further
reduced
from
the
decretal amount of Rs.49,81,336/- awarded by
the Trial Court.
232.
Therefore,
modified
to
the
the
decree
extent
is
of
accordingly
Rs.36,15,218/-
(Rs.49,81,336-Rs.13,66,118).
233.
We,
therefore,
hold
that
the
decretal
amount as per the decree passed by the Trial
Court is modified at Rs.36,15,218/- together
with proportionate interest accrued therefrom
as per the order passed by the Trial Court.
234.
As per the status report of FDR-25 as
issued
by
30.06.2026,
State
Bank
principal
1,91,04,023/-
and
of
value
accrued
India
of
FDR
dated
is
Rs.
interest
is
C/FA/531/1986
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Rs.5,23,66,304/- and therefore, total
on said FDR is
amount
Rs.7,14,70,627/- with running
interest which may accrue till the date of
premature encashment.
235.
of
As the decree is modified to the extent
Rs.36,15,218/-,
the
plaintiff
will
be
entitled to the said decretal amount along
with accrued interest thereon from the amount
deposited
in
Fixed
deposit
with
the
State
Bank of India, High Court Complex Branch. The
balance
amount,
deposited
by
Rs.1,52,202/-
out
of
defendant
the
total
no.6
amount
bank
i.e.
[Rs.37,67,420-Rs.36,15,218]
together with proportionate interest accrued
thereon to be bifurcated from the amount to
be realised on premature encashment of Fixed
Deposit till the date of realisation shall
be
paid
to
defendant
nos.
firm
and
remaining amount to be paid to the plaintiff.
Ordered accordingly.
C/FA/531/1986
236.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 17/07/2026
Appeals
aforesaid
stand
terms.
disposed
Decree
of
stands
in
the
modified
accordingly. No order as to cost.
(BHARGAV D. KARIA, J)
(L. S. PIRZADA, J)
RAGHUNATH R NAIR
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review