Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/nutan-devi-nutan-kumari-sinha-vs-md-hasnain-alam-20261012/ · Printed 20 Nov 2026
Civil

Nutan Devi @ Nutan Kumari Sinha vs Md. Hasnain Alam

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Patna High Court
Date
12 October 2026
Case No.
C.R. 1/2024
Result
Dismissed
Bench
Ramesh Chand Malviya
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

21. Accordingly, the present Civil Revision No. 01 of 2024 stands dismissed.

22. There shall be no order as to costs. (Ramesh Chand Malviya, J) Mayank/U

Filed under

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Order VII Rule 11, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 115, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 80, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Rejection of plaint (Order VII Rule 11 CPC)

The sections, explained

The law this judgment cites

Opens the section on Law Maker (lawmaker.in), our sister site for law students.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CIVIL REVISION No. 1 of 2024 CNR No. BRHC011243372023 1. ====================================================== Nutan Devi @ Nutan Kumari Sinha W/o Late Rajesh Kumar Rai, R/o Village- Imadpur, P.O.- Chakhamid, P.S.- Bakhari, District- Begusarai. 2. Nirupa Rai, W/o Umesh Prasad Rai, R/o Village- Imadpur, P.O.Chakhamid, P.S.- Bakhari, District- Begusarai. 3. Umesh Prasad Rai, S/o Late Saryug Rai, R/o Village- Imadpur, P.O.Chakhamid, P.S.- Bakhari, District- Begusarai. ... ... Petitioner/s 1. 2. Versus Md. Hasnain Alam S/o Abdul Kuddus, R/o Village- Chakhamid, P.O.Chakhamid, P.S.- Bakhari, District- Begusarai. Ranjeet Kumar Mishra, S/o Shri Diwakar Mishra, R/o Village- Jailakh Abhiman, P.O.- Sakarpura, P.S.- Bakhari, District- Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== Appearance : For the Petitioner/s For the Respondent/s : : Mr. Onkar Nath, Advocate Mr. Mukund Kumar, Advocate ====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAMESH CHAND MALVIYA CAV ORDER 12-10-2026 Heard learned counsel for the petitioners as well as learned counsel for the opposite parties. 2. This Civil Revision application has been filed under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure,1908 (hereinafter referred to as ‘CPC’) against the order dated 15.09.2022 passed by the learned Munsif, Bakhri, Begusarai (hereinafter referred to as ‘Trial Court’) in Title Suit No.11 of 2016 whereby and where under the petition dated 17.02.2020 filed on behalf of defendant/petitioner for rejection of plaint Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 2/17 under Order VII Rule11of the CPC was rejected. 3. Briefly stated, the facts giving rise to the present Civil Revision are that the plaintiff files Title Suit No. 11 of 2016 to seeks declaration of title and recovery of possession and permanent injunction of Schedule-I land. The plaintiff acquired the suit land through the registered sale deed dated 19.03.2012 executed by the Ranjeet Kumar Mishra, grandson of Pandit Suresh Mishra in whose favour Raja Rajeshwar Prasad Singh executed a registered Ladawinama dated 01.06.1956. Further, the plaintiff got possession, mutated his name (Jamabandi No. 430) and pays rent to the State. Later, on the midnight of 07.05.2012 the defendants allegedly put up a hut over 5 dhur, and the plaintiff lodged Sanha No. 45 of 2012 before the SDO, Bakhri. The plaintiff then filed B.L.D.R. Case No. 108 of 2012 before the DCLR, Bakhri, the DCLR ruled in his favour on 30.08.2013. The defendants appealed B.L.D.R. order (Appeal No. 387 of 2013) and on 18.01.2016 the Divisional Commissioner, Munger set aside the CO Gadhpura’s order dated 24.04.2013 (Misc. Case No. 02 of 2013-14) and directed the aggrieved party to file a declaratory suit in the civil court. Further the plaintiff claims that he was forcibly dispossessed on 10.04.2016 and then filed the suit. Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 3/17 4. The defendant/petitioner entered appearance and filed a written statement disputing the maintainability of the suit as well as the plaintiff’s title and possession over the suit property. Simultaneously, the petitioner filed a petition dated 17.02.2020 under Order VII Rule 11(a) & (d) of the CPC praying for rejection of the plaint, inter alia, contending that the suit is barred by limitation, estoppel, waiver and acquiescence, Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, and Sections 11 and 80 of the CPC. The State of Bihar is a necessary party but has not made a party. Further it is also stated that the suit land is undervalued and beyond the court's pecuniary jurisdiction (value alleged to be more than Rs. 1,70,000/-) and proper court fee has also not been paid. The plaintiff opposed all the contention and stated that the application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC was dilatory, filed only to avoid the further proceedings of the Court. 5. Upon hearing the parties and considering the facts and circumstances of the case, the learned Trial Court, by the impugned order dated 15.09.2022, rejected the petition dated 17.02.2020 filed under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC and held that the issues raised by the defendant was filed to delay the suit. Aggrieved by the impugned order the petitioner has Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 4/17 preferred this Civil Revision application before this Court, assailing the legality, propriety and correctness of the said order on the ground that the learned Trial Court has failed to properly appreciate the mandatory provisions of law and has exercised jurisdiction with material irregularity. 6. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the impugned order suffers from patent jurisdictional error inasmuch as the learned Trial Court has failed to exercise jurisdiction vested in it by law. He further submitted that the learned Trial Court has committed a manifest error of law in rejecting the petitioner’s application dated 17.02.2020 without appreciating the fact that the relief sought is not maintainable as the plaintiff has no cause of action. It was contended that, on a plain reading of the plaint itself, the suit is not maintainable in law and is liable to be rejected at the threshold. 6.i. He further submitted that the impugned order does not considered the grounds actually urged under the application of Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC. The grounds were the absence of cause of action, the arbitrary valuation of the suit, the failure to implead the State and the long-standing parcha holder and the statutory bar. A mere finding that the application is dilatory does not meet the case, and the failure to decide the questions raised Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 5/17 is itself a failure to exercise jurisdiction. Further, it is also argued that the plaint does not disclose a real cause of action and is barred by limitation on its own showing. The suit is barred by Section 18 of the Bihar Privileged Persons Homestead Tenancy Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Act’). Section 18 provides that the orders passed under the Act is final. No civil court may vary or set aside such an order except on the ground of fraud or want of jurisdiction. The plaint pleads no fraud and no want of jurisdiction. It does not allege that the parcha grants were fraudulent or void. 6.ii. He further submitted that the plaintiff did not implead Kavita Devi, the parcha holder in possession of the adjoining and allegedly identical land. He did not implead the State of Bihar, whose revenue authorities issued the parchas and also did not impleaded Nutan Devi, who holds a separate parcha for a separate area. The plaint suffers from the nonjoinder and mis-joinder of the necessary parties. Lastly, learned counsel submitted that all the objections raised by the petitioner were apparent from the averments contained in the plaint itself and attracted the provisions of Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC. Accordingly, the learned Trial Court ought to have rejected the plaint instead of postponing the consideration of such legal bars Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 6/17 to the stage of trial. The impugned order suffers from patent illegality, and material irregularity warranting interference in exercise of the revisional jurisdiction of this Court and deserves to be rejected at the very outset. 7. Per contra, learned counsel for the plaintiff/opposite parties has substantiated the impugned order and submitted that the application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC is wholly misconceived and not maintainable in the facts of the case and the learned Trial Court has rightly rejected the petition filed under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC. It was contended that while considering an application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC, the Court is required to confine itself to the averments made in the plaint and the documents relied upon by the plaintiff and cannot take into consideration the defence set up by the defendant in the written statement or the materials produced by him. It was submitted that a meaningful reading of the plaint clearly discloses a cause of action for institution of the suit, wherein the plaintiff has specifically pleaded his title and possession over the suit property. 7.i. It was further submitted that the objections raised by the petitioner with regard to bar on civil suit “to vary or set aside” an order under the Act is not applicable in the instant case Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 7/17 as the plaintiff does not seek to vary or set aside any order or parcha. The plaint does not mention any parcha. It asks for a declaration of title and recovery of possession based on registered Ladawinama dated 01.06.1956 grant and on registered sale deed dated 19.03.2012. A civil court's jurisdiction under Section 9 of the CPC is not ousted unless the bar is express or clearly implied, and the ouster must be strictly construed. The revenue authorities themselves recognised that title cannot be decided in revenue proceedings. The Divisional Commissioner, Munger directed the aggrieved party to file a declaratory suit in the civil court. It cannot be said that the civil court has no jurisdiction. 7.ii. He further submitted that the plaintiff is dominus litis and sues only those who dispossessed him. The plaintiff seeks no relief against the State and challenges no order of the State. The State is therefore neither a necessary nor a proper party. Section 80 of the CPC applies only to suits against the Government or a public officer, and no such suit is filed. The learned Trial Court’s reasoning that no government party was impleaded so, notice under Section 80 of the CPC was not required is correct. Kavita Devi is also not a necessary party. 7.iii. Learned counsel for the opposite party lastly Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 8/17 submitted that the impugned order does not suffer from any jurisdictional error, illegality or material irregularity warranting interference in exercise of the revisional jurisdiction of this Court and, accordingly, the present civil revision application deserves to be dismissed and the same would not ipso facto warrant the rejection of the plaint. 8. Having considered the rival submissions advanced on behalf of both the parties and perused the materials available on record, including the impugned order and the order sheets of the learned Trial Court, the point that arises for determination in the present revision is “whether the learned Trial Court erred in law in rejecting the application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC seeking rejection of the plaint?” 9. Before adverting to the rival contentions on merits, it would be apposite to notice the scope of interference in exercise of revisional jurisdiction under Section 115 of the CPC. This Court does not sit as a Court of appeal over the order of the subordinate Court; interference is warranted only where the learned Trial Court has exercised a jurisdiction not vested in it by law, or has failed to exercise jurisdiction so vested, or has acted in the exercise of its jurisdiction illegally or with material irregularity. Thus, unless the finding recorded by the learned Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 9/17 Trial Court is shown to suffer from a patent error of law or jurisdictional infirmity, this Court would be slow to substitute its own view merely because another view is possible. 10. The contours of revisional jurisdiction under Section 115 of the CPC has been authoritatively delineated by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Shiv Shakti Coop. Housing Society v. Swaraj Developers and Ors., reported in (2003) 6 SCC 659, wherein, it has been held that “the revisional power is supervisory in nature and cannot be equated with appellate jurisdiction; interference is permissible only where the subordinate Court has acted without jurisdiction or with material irregularity in the exercise of such jurisdiction”. Similarly, in Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Dilbahar Singh, reported in (2014) 9 SCC 78, the Hon’ble Apex Court reiterated that re-appreciation of facts or substitution of a possible view is impermissible in revision unless the impugned order suffers from patent illegality or perversity. 11. At this stage, it is apposite to reproduce the principles governing rejection of a plaint under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC which have been explained in the case of Dahiben v. Arvindbhai Kalyanji Bhanusali (Gajra) and Ors., reported in (2020) 7 SCC 366 wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 10/17 has settled the principles and made the following observations: “12.6. At this stage, the pleas taken by the defendant in the written statement and application for rejection of the plaint on the merits, would be irrelevant, and cannot be adverted to, or taken into consideration. “12.7. The test for exercising the power under Order VII Rule 11 is that if the averments made in the plaint are taken entirety, in conjunction with the documents relied upon, would the same result in a decree being passed”. “23.2. The remedy under Order 7 Rule 11 is an independent and special remedy, wherein the court is empowered to summarily dismiss a suit at the threshold, without proceeding to record evidence, and conducting a trial, on the basis of the evidence adduced, if it is satisfied that the action should be terminated on any of the grounds contained in this provision. 23.5. The power conferred on the court to terminate a civil action is, however, a drastic one, and the conditions enumerated in Order 7 Rule 11 are required to be strictly adhered to. 23.9. In exercise of power under this provision, the court would determine if the assertions made in the plaint are contrary to statutory law, or judicial dicta, for deciding whether a case for rejecting the plaint at the threshold is made out. 23.10. At this stage, the pleas taken by the defendant in the written statement and application for rejection of the plaint on the merits, would be irrelevant, and cannot be Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 11/17 adverted to, or taken into consideration. [Sopan Sukhdeo Sable v. Charity Commr., (2004) 3 SCC 137] 23.12. In Hardesh Ores (P) Ltd. v. Hede & Co. [Hardesh Ores (P) Ltd. v. Hede & Co., (2007) 5 SCC 614] the Court further held that it is not permissible to cull out a sentence or a passage, and to read it in isolation. It is the substance, and not merely the form, which has to be looked into. The plaint has to be construed as it stands, without addition or subtraction of words. If the allegations in the plaint prima facie show a cause of action, the court cannot embark upon an enquiry whether the allegations are true in fact. D. Ramachandran v. R.V. Janakiraman [D. Ramachandran v. R.V. Janakiraman, (1999) 3 SCC 267; See also Vijay Pratap Singh v. Dukh Haran Nath Singh, AIR 1962 SC 941]. 23.13. If on a meaningful reading of the plaint, it is found that the suit is manifestly. vexatious and without any merit, and does not disclose a right to sue, the court would be justified in exercising the power under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC. 23.15. The provision of Order 7 Rule 11 is mandatory in nature. It states that the plaint “shall” be rejected if any of the grounds specified in clauses (a) to (e) are made out. If the court finds that the plaint does not disclose a cause of action, or that the suit is barred by any law, the court has no option, but to reject the plaint.” 12. Upon overall consideration of the pleadings of the Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 12/17 parties and the grounds urged in the application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC, this Court finds that the issue raised by the petitioner is regarding and the suit is also suffered from nonjoinder of necessary parties, barred by limitation and also barred under Section 18 of the Act. 13. Moreover, Order I Rule 9 of the CPC provides that that no suit shall be defeated by reason of misjoinder or nonjoinder of parties. Non-joinder is not a ground for rejection under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC. The remedy, if any, is impleadment under Order I Rule 10. While a suit can eventually be dismissed at the trial stage if a vital necessary party is missing and the Court cannot pass an effective decree, it cannot be summarily thrown out at the initial stage of the proceeding under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC. Moreover, non-joinder of a necessary party does not lead to the initial rejection of a plaint under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC instead, it can lead to the ultimate dismissal of the suit after trial if the plaintiff fails to fix the defect upon the direction of the Court. The Hon’ble Madhya Pradesh High Court in the case of Babulal & Others Vs. Smt Omwati & Others (2014), in C.R.No.30 of 2014 held that: “Non-joinder of necessary parties is not one of the grounds recognized by Order 7 Rule 11 which can occasion rejection of Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 13/17 plaint at the outset. Non-joinder of necessary party can at best lead to the plaintiff being afforded opportunity to implead the necessary party. Non-joinder of parties thus cannot lead to immediate rejection of the plaint. The other ground of non-payment of sufficient Court fees cannot also lead to instant rejection of the suit as the provision of order 7 Rule 11, itself provides for opportunity to the plaintiff to cure the default, failing which the plaint suffers rejection”. 14. it is well settled law that while dealing with an application Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC, the only document which have to be look into is the plaint. The parchas, the ceiling case and the written statement are the defendant’s material, which can not be considered at this stage. Where the plea depends on disputed facts or mixed questions of law and fact, the matter must go to trial. Order VII Rule 11 cannot be used to decide such pleas on the defendant’s version. Further, the plaint pleads a registered Ladawinama of 1956, a registered sale deed of 19.03.2012, proceedings, the mutation, rent Divisional receipts, the Commissioner’s B.L.D.R. order of 18.01.2016 directing a civil suit, and forcible dispossession on 10.04.2016. These facts if taken as true, disclose a cause of action. Moreover, the plaintiff seeks no relief against the State and not challenges the order of the State, so the State is not a Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 14/17 necessary party and the compliance of Section 80 of the CPC does not required in the present case. 15. Further, under Order VII Rule 11(b) of the CPC, a plaint can be rejected for undervaluation only if the plaintiff, “being required by the court to correct the valuation within a time to be fixed by the court”, fails to do so. No such requirement was ever made. Real valuation is a disputed question of fact, which the court can decide as a preliminary issue after evidence. It is not a ground for rejecting the plaint at the threshold. Moreover, relief based on possession falls under Article 65 of the Limitation Act,1963 (twelve years), and the declaration of title is only ancillary to it. The suit was filed about a month after the pleaded dispossession on 10.04.2016. Even on the petitioner’s Article 58 theory, the time spent in the B.L.D.R. proceedings (2012 to 18.01.2016) is excludable under Section 14 of the Limitation Act,1963, since the revenue forum itself directed to file a civil suit. Whether the plaintiff acted bona fide is a question of fact and a triable question which can be decided on the evaluation of evidences adduced by the parties at the stage of trial. 16. Further, the objections raised by the petitioner with regard to bar on civil suit “to vary or set aside” an order Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 15/17 under the Act is not applicable in the instant case as the plaintiff does not seek to vary or set aside any order or parcha. The plaint does not mention any parcha. It asks for a declaration of title and recovery of possession based on registered Ladawinama dated 01.06.1956 grant and on registered sale deed dated 19.03.2012. The revenue authorities themselves recognised that title cannot be decided in revenue proceedings and the Divisional Commissioner, Munger directed the aggrieved party to file a declaratory suit in the civil court. It cannot be said that the civil court has no jurisdiction to try the instant suit. 17. Moreover, the defence sought to be raised by the petitioner cannot be used to displace such averments at this preliminary stage. Accordingly, in the considered view of this Court the said contention falls outside the limited scope of inquiry under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC and has rightly not been accepted as a ground for rejection at this stage and does not warrant rejection of the plaint. 18. In view of the aforesaid discussions, this Court is of the considered opinion that the learned Trial Court rightly held that the plaint, on its face, discloses a triable cause of action and no statutory bar is apparent from the averments made Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 16/17 therein, the application filed under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC was rightly rejected by the learned Trial Court and the learned Trial Court has not committed any jurisdictional error, illegality, or material irregularity in rejecting the application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC. 19. In view of the settled legal position that rejection of plaint under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC is a drastic power to be exercised sparingly and only when the plaint, on the face of it, is barred by any law, this Court finds that the learned Trial Court has rightly refused to reject the plaint. The impugned order does not suffer from any jurisdictional error or material irregularity warranting interference in revisional jurisdiction. Accordingly, this Court is not inclined to interfere with the order under challenge, and the present civil revision application is liable to be dismissed. 20. As settled above that in revisional jurisdiction, interference is warranted only when the learned Trial Court has exercised the jurisdiction not vested in it, failed to exercise jurisdiction so vested, or acted with material irregularity. The impugned order, though concise, reflects consideration of the relevant aspects and does not suffer from jurisdictional error or perversity so as to warrant interference under Section 115 of the Patna High Court C.R. No. 1 of 2024(14) dt.12-10-2026 17/17 CPC. Since the plaint, on its face, discloses triable issues requiring adjudication after full-fledged trial and evaluation of evidences, this Court is of the considered view that no such ground is made out to invoke the revisional power of this Court. 21. Accordingly, the present Civil Revision No. 01 of 2024 stands dismissed. 22. There shall be no order as to costs. (Ramesh Chand Malviya, J) Mayank/U

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Patna HC judgments →

Civil Litigation advocates near the Patna High Court

Dealing with a similar matter? Send a free enquiry to advocates who handle it. Fees are agreed with the advocate directly.

All Civil Litigation advocates in India