Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
Crl. A(J) No. 13 of 2025
Nur Mohammad Khadim (aged 60 years), son of late Churat Ali
Khadim, village Khilpara, Jora Dighir Par, P.O. R. K. Pur, Udaipur,
District: Gomati Tripura.
…..Appellant
-V E R S U SState of Tripura, notice to be served through learned Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Tripura.
….. Respondent.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing and
Delivery of judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. T. D. Majumder, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. D. Kalai, Advocate.
Mr. R. Datta, P.P.
:
:
25.03.2026
NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
[Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J]
[1]
Heard Mr. T. D. Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. D. Kalai, learned counsel appearing for the appellant also heard Mr. R.
Datta, learned P.P. appearing for the respondent-State.
[2]
This is an appeal filed under Section-374 of Criminal
Procedure Code, 1973 against the judgment and order of conviction dated
20.12.2024 and sentence dated 20.12.2024 passed by the learned Sessions
Judge (Court No.1), Gomati Judicial district in connection with case
No.ST/37 of 2022 Type-I under Section-302 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 and
sentenced him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of
Rs.20,000/- for commission of offence under Section-302 of IPC and in
default to suffer rigorous imprisonment for one year.
[3]
The genesis of the case of the prosecution can be traced back to
the lodging of a written ejahar by P.W.1 Jahir Hossain Khadim alleging,
inter-alia that there was long land dispute between his father Titu Miah
Khadim (now deceased) and his uncle Nur Mohammad Khadim, the
appellant herein, and with a view to resolve the dispute his another uncle
Jethu Soharab Ali Khadim (P.W.1) arranged for a meeting in his house on
01.10.2021 at around 5 p.m. in the afternoon and the meeting was attended
by his father Titu Miah Khadim, accused Nur Mohammad Khadim, P.W.2
Soharab Ali Khadim and respectable persons of village and that at the
beginning of the meeting there was hot altercation between his father Titu
Miah Khadim and accused Nur Mohammad Khadim @ Nomad and that at
that time accused Nur Mohammad Khadim brought out a knife from his
waist and attacked his father by inflicting blows on his stomach and other
parts of the body causing severe bleeding injuries and that accused Titu
Miah Khadim was taken to hospital where he was declared dead by the
attending doctor. It is alleged by the informant that accused Nur Mohammad
Khadim brutally killed his father and that one of his uncle also got severely
injured by knife when he went for rescue of Titu Miah Khadim.
[4]
On the basis of such information, O/C, R. K. Pur P.S. registered
FIR No. 151 of 2021 dated 01.10.2021 under Sections 302/326 of IPC and
endorsed the case to SI Debabrata Biswas for investigation. The I/O on
completion of investigation submitted charge-sheet vide No.46 of 2022
dated 30.06.2022 against the appellant alleging commission of offence
punishable under Sections 302/324/201 of IPC.
[5]
After taking cognizance of offence punishable under Sections
302/324/201 of IPC, the case was committed and framed charge vide order
dated 29.08.2022 under Sections-302/201/324 of IPC against the accused
appellant and the contents of the charges were read over and explained to
him to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
[6]
In course of the trial, to prove the charge, the prosecution
examined as many as 14 (fourteen) witnesses. Upon closure of prosecution
evidence, the accused person was examined under Section-313(1)(b) of
Cr.P.C. to which he pleaded his innocence and expressed his willingness to
adduce defence evidence. Thereafter, accused was examined as DW.1. In
support of his defense, two witnesses namely Biswajit Islam @Rana Miah
and Kaji Sahin Ahammed were also examined as DW.2 and DW.3
[7]
Having heard both the parties and on perusal of the material
evidence on record, the learned Court below has observed as under:
“81. In view of the aforesaid discussion and analysis, it is held that the
prosecution has successfully proved the charge for commission of offence
punishable under Sec. 302 IPC by the accused Nur Mohammad Khadim and
so the accused Nur Mohammad Khadim is found guilty. Accordingly the
accused Nur Mohammad Khadim is convicted for commission of offence
punishable under Sec. 302 of IPC. However due to lack of evidence, the
accused Nur Mohammad Khadim is acquitted of the charges framed under
Sec. 201/324 of IPC. Consequently, the accused Nur Mohammad Khadim is
taken into custody. He will be heard today itself on sentence.
[3] Thus the convict Nur Mohammad Khadim is sentenced to Rigorous
Imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of Rs. 20,000/- (rupees twenty
thousand) for commission of offence punishable under Sec. 302 IPC and in
default of payment of fine, he shall suffer Rigorous Imprisonment for one
year.
[4]. In the event of deposit of fine, the same shall be paid to the legal heirs of
the deceased Titu Miah Khadim.
[5] The period of detention, if any, undergone by the convict during
investigation, inquiry and trial shall be set off from the substantive period of
sentence.
[6] The surety of the convict stands discharged. However, the bond submitted
as per provision under Sec. 437A, Cr.P.C. shall remain in force for a period of
six months from today.
[7] Copy of this judgment shall be delivered to the convict free of cost as per
provision of section 363 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
[8] A copy of this judgment be also forwarded to the District Magistrate,
Gomati, Tripura as per provision of section 365 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure.
[9] The convict is informed about his right to appeal before the Hon’ble High
Court of Tripura and right of legal aid.
[10] The seized alamats, except article no.4 of the charge-sheet, be destroyed
after expiry of the period of appeal. However, article no.4 of the charge-sheet
shall be disposed of in the event of making of any claim, after expiry of the
period of appeal.”
[8]
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the same, the present
appeal has been preferred by the appellant before this Court for ends of
justice.
[9]
Mr. Majumder, learned senior counsel appearing for the
appellant has submitted that the learned Court below has failed to exercise
jurisdiction when there has been existence of evidence of multiple FIRs for
the same incident involving cognizable offences. The legal principles and
judicial precedents has been given a goodbye while specific law in the
precedents has been shown to the learned Court on how such situation
should be handled, ignored by the Court below. The principle laid down in
TT Antony v. State of Kerala, reported in (2001) 6 SCC 181 which was
relied on and pressed for on specific point that there can be no second FIR
where the information concerns the same cognizable offences, reported to
P.S. vide GD Entry No.29 dated 01.10.2021.
[10]
The Officer-in-charge of the PS is duty bound to investigate not
only the cognizable offence disclosed to them, reported in the GD Entry
No.29 but also other connected offences found during the same transaction
or occurrence. Any further information or evidence, collected during the
investigation can be added to the existing investigation without registering a
fresh FIR or ignoring the earlier information of cognizable offence. This is
the cardinal principle of law that has been adhered to by the learned Court
below and punished the appellant most erroniously.
[11]
In the present case subsequent FIR is not a counter complaint
or presents a rival version of a set of facts, in reference to which an earlier
FIR already stand lodged. The learned Court should have inferred from the
conduct of the appellant qua the P.W. 1 ( son of the deceased), PW 2( Elder
Brother of deceased) and 8( Naxal Leader), deposed to before the learned
Court to show that he was absolutely straight-forward in his dealings while
PW-1, PW-2 and PW- 8 there was inconsistency relating to their evidence.
The prosecution case rests on the non-cross examination of PWs-4, 5 & 11
by the accused; therefore it is proved that death was homicidal in nature. But
the cardinal principle of law that prosecution must prove its case to the hilt.
In the case in hand, the learned Court did not follow the cardinal principle of
law as such findings of him is perverse and liable to be set aside.
[12]
The I/O of the case had prepared inquest report wherein in the
report it was specially spoken of three nos. of injuries, specifically stated 3
Nos. of injuries, particularly in the neck, left side of the chest, and right side
of the waist, while the post mortem report would show 6 nos. of injuries.
These vital contradiction on physical injuries found on the body of the
deceased soon after death does no match with the post mortem examination
report as exhibited. XII) For that the Ld. Sessions Court failed to appreciate
that failure on the part of the accused to cross-examine PWs-4, 5 & 11
cannot result automatically acceptance of evidence against the accused
without scrutiny of Exhibit-3 & 4.
[13]
The learned Court below reading to his findings on the basis of
arguments of the defense that exhibit P1 could not be treated as FIR, as
complaint was already taken note of in the GD entry of R.K Pur P.S GDE
No.29 dated 01.10.2021 reported at 06:00 PM disclosing cognizable
offence. The learned Court below has given stress on the testimony of PW14 who had once stated that contents of GD Entry No.29 did not reveal
cognizable offence without looking to the next sentence which runs as “I
have mentioned in my CD that by peruse of GDE No.29 dated 01.10.2021,
cognizable offence is revealed on the spot, after revealing of the commission
of cognizable offence I was asked to investigate by the O/C at the spot. The
time was 18.20 hrs. on 01.10.2021. Thereafter, I have started investigation
on the advice of the O/C.”
[14]
The learned Court below has completely taken a side by
accepting delay in examining material witnesses, after a long delay when
those witness available with police officer soon after incident without any
reasons, therefore, could not appreciate decision in State of U.P Vs
Satroghan @ Satroghan Singh in (2005) 4 SCC 117 in this regard. Delay has
not been caused by any justifiable reason or by deliberate to affect the
fairness of the trial. But in the case in hand the prosecution admitted the
presence of PW-2 before the I/O at 6:20 PM on the day of incident at place
of occurrence, Rana Miah DW-1 at 06:20 PM making his seizure list
witness at 19:05 hrs. but, I/O did not give any sort of explanation as to why
he has not examined Rana Miah, the first informer of the cognizable offence
despite his availability, no explanation has been coming on record from the
I/O as to why he did not examine PW-2 on 01.10.2021 despite presence
before the I/O at 06:20 PM. There was no explanation as to why PW-1 who
was available near the place of occurrence on 01.10.2021 at the time of
commission of crime was not examined by the I/O on that day itself.
[15]
The learned Court below has failed to give any weightage for
non-examination of inmates of PO such as mother of the victim, wife, adult
son & daughter of PW-2 by the I/O of case, which cast serious doubt of the
facts presented by the Prosecution. The injured eyewitness i.e. DW-3 was
withheld by the prosecution without any reasons but, the learned Court
below recorded these witness were gained over by the accused without any
supporting materials. So, recording of such unsubstantiated allegation
against the accused and favoring the prosecution has resulted serious
miscarriage of justice.
[16]
It has been further contended that the learned Court below has
failed to look into the reasons to withheld prosecution material eye witness,
named in the charge-sheet without any ostensible reasons including nonexamination of presiding member of the meeting by IO of the case has
serious cascading affect on the finding recorded. There was no appreciation
of evidence by the learned Court below when vital contradiction about
information received of the death of Titu Miah Khadim by the PW-1 from
PW-2 over the phone and later would deny passing of such information to
PW-1. There is no ascertainment of the fact as to how PW-1 got information
of death of his father.
[17]
Mr. Majumder, learned senior counsel has submitted that the
alleged place of occurrence is surrounded by dense population but strangely
enough the I/O of the case did not find any witnesses of the locality to
support prosecution case, rather prosecution has withheld the relative
witness being material eye witnesses who were withheld without any
ostensible reason. The learned Court below only to punish the appellant
banking up on PW-8 who happens to be not an eye witness of the
occurrence but closely associated with PW-2 who has come on being called.
[18]
No documentation of meeting was forth coming in evidence to
justify the presence of PW-8 who had no business in an alleged family
dispute of Mohamadan Community. The presence of PW-8 is highly
suspicious when the DW-1 deposed that he had seen PW-8 at Ramesh
Choumohani at 05:10 PM igniting his motor cycle, which is also visible
from the evidence of PW-1 who deposed the presence of others being heard
from PW-2 excluding PW-8 in the meeting. This vital aspect has been
intentionally ignored without any ostensible reasons by the learned Court
below causing serious threat to the delivery system causing and irreparable
prejudice to the accused. The appearance of the PW-8 in the scene and he
was introduced by PW-2 after seven days of the occurrence and he was not
even examined by the police soon after the incident when story is he was
available with police in presence of PW2.
[19]
Advancing the argument further, learned senior counsel argued
that the knowledge of PW-1, as reflected in Exbt.P1 FIR, from PW-2 was
without any basis because PW-2 in his cross-examination specifically stated
that he did not inform PW.1 about any incident and thus evidence of PW-1
could not be taken into consideration. Further it was argued that except PW2 none of the witnesses stated about the presence of PW-8 in the meeting
and submitted that the evidence of PW-8 could not be relied upon. It was
again pointed out that even though PW.3 in his evidence stated that on 0110-2021 PW-7 informed him that accused stabbed Titu Miah and killed him
but PW-7 in his evidence did not state that he informed PW-3 regarding
stabbing of Titu Miah by the accused.
[20]
Mr. Majumder, learned senior counsel in support of his
arguments, has placed reliance on some decisions of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in State of UP v. Satish, reported in (2005) 3 SCC 114, In
Balakrushna Swain v. State of Orissa, reported in (1971) 3 SCC 192, In
Ganesh Bhavan Patel and Another v. State of Maharashtra, reported in
(1978) 4 SCC 371, In Takhaji Hiraji v. Thakore Kubersing Chamansing
and Others, reported in (2001) 6 SCC 145 and in Surajit Sarkar v. State of
West Bengal, reported in (2013) 2 SCC 146.
[21]
Arguing the case for the prosecution, Mr. R. Datta, learned PP
appearing for the respondent-State has submitted that the prosecution
remained successful in proving the charge under Section-302 of IPC against
the accused person. Learned PP, during argument, had drawn the attention
of this Court to the evidence of the prosecution witnesses. It was submitted
that the star witnesses of the prosecution were PW-2, PW-4 and PW-8 and
such witnesses in their evidence very specifically brought out the
incriminating evidence against the accused.
[22]
It was pointed out that PW-2 and PW-8 were the eye witnesses
and that PW-2 and PW-8 saw the accused stabbing the deceased and that
PW-2 and PW-4 saw the accused cleaning a blood stained knife with a
gamcha, which was the sufficient evidence to bring home the guilt of the
accused. It was further submitted that the defence did not dispute that the
deceased died due to injuries caused by sharp weapon and it was pointed out
that the defence declined cross-examination of PW-5, PW-6, PW-11, PW-12
and PW-13 who were the medical officer and expert witnesses.
[23]
It was further submitted that the evidence of the prosecution
witnesses very specifically revealed the motive of the accused behind the
commission of offence charged. Learned PP also submitted that the accused
after commission of crime, fled away and concealed himself and after about
07 months the accused could be arrested from another place under Jatrapur
PS and the same, revealed the subsequent conduct of the accused. Learned
P.P. submits that the appellant killed his own brother in cold blood without
any genuine reason and so the convict may be sentenced appropriately.
[24]
The learned PP on the point of defence evidence submitted that,
the evidence of defence witnesses could not have any effect over the
evidence of prosecution witnesses because, as per evidence of the accused
as DW-1 he met PW-8 at Ramesh Chowmuhani while returning from the
house of PW-2 but, no such suggestion was put to PW-8 by the defence. It
was again submitted that DW-2 and DW-3 though were cited as witnesses in
the charge-sheet but they were not examined by the prosecution when they
were found gained over by the prosecution and so, the evidence of DW-2
and DW-3 could not be said to have any effect on the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses and prayed to affirm the judgment of the learned
Court below.
[25]
Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P. in support of his case has placed
reliance on certain judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court most importantly
on the point that if the weapon of offence is not recovered, it cannot be fatal
the case of the prosecution and the accused can be convicted. In Goutam
Joardar v. State of West Bengal and ors reported in (2022) 17 SC 549, In
Baban Shankar Daphal and Others v. State of Maharashtra, reported in
(2025) SCC Online 137, In Ghanshyam Mandal and Others v. State of Bihar
(now Jharkhand) reported in (2026) SCC Online SC 307 and In State
through the Inspector of Police v. Laly alias Manikandan and Another,
reported in (2022) SCC Online SC 1424 and in Harivadan Babubhai Patel v.
State of Gujarat, reported in (2013) 7 SCC 45.
[26]
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and
perusal of the observation made by the learned Court below, before deciding
the case, it would be apposite to discuss the evidence on record once again.
[27]
PW-1 is the informant as well as son of deceased Titu Miah
Khadim. According to his evidence, the appellant is the elder brother of his
father and they had a property dispute. On 01.10.2021 another uncle
Soharab Ali Khadim (PW.2) called a mediation meeting in his house at
around 5 p.m. to settle the dispute between his father and appellant. The
meeting turned hostile and there was a heated argument between his father
and accused who brandished a knife and assaulted his father in his stomach
and other parts of the body and his father suffered fatal injuries and was
rushed to the hospital by other villagers present in the meeting. His father
succumbed to his injuries in the hospital. He learnt the incident from his
uncle PW-2 and lodged the complaint to the O/C, R.K. Pur P/S narrating the
incident.
[28]
PW-2 Sohorab Ali Khadim is the brother of accused and the
deceased and also the uncle of PW-1. In his evidence has stated that the
deceased and the accused are his younger brothers and both of them had
some property dispute. On 01.10.2021 he called for a mediation meeting in
his house to settle the dispute between his brothers and in the meeting his
cousin brother Ahamed Ullah @ Madhab, cousin brother Setu Miah Sarkar,
cousin Kaji Sahin Ahmed (DW-3), Mohan Miah (PW-7), Nurul Islam
Khadim (PW-4) and Partha Karmakar (PW-8) were present. During meeting
accused started the discussion in high and aggressive tone and he was not
amiable for any resolution and when he was about to leave, the deceased
requested him to solve the dispute in presence of him (PW-2) and suddenly
accused brought out a meat cutting knife and lunged it in the stomach and
neck of Titu Miah. He quickly intervened to stop further blows. DW-3 also
received cut injuries while trying to intervene. Accused went to the
courtyard and cleaned the knife with a 'gamcha' and commented that why
the victim was still alive. In the mean time they collected a car and tried to
rush the victim to the hospital but he died before reaching the hospital. On
the same date police came and seized some blood stain from the floor of his
dwelling house and he signed the seizure list and also signed the inquest
report as witness.
[29]
PW.3 Amir Hossain in his evidence stated that accused and the
deceased were his maternal uncles and on 01.10.2021 his cousin brother
PW-7 informed him that accused has stabbed Titu Miah Khadim and killed
him and on hearing the incident he went to the hospital and saw the dead
body of Titu Miah Khadim and on the next day he signed the inquest report
as witness.
[30]
PW.4 Nurul Islam Khadim in his evidence stated that the
deceased and accused were his younger brothers and both of them had
property dispute and that about one year and two months back a mediation
meeting was called in the house of his elder brother PW-2 and to settle the
dispute between the brothers. He further stated that in the meeting there was
hot altercation between the accused and the deceased and that the accused
was not agreeing to any solution and he (PW-4) therefore, left the meeting
but within a minute heard uproar from that house and went back and saw
that the deceased was lying with bleeding injuries in the room while the
accused was cleaning a blood stained knife with a 'gamcha'. He also stated
that the deceased told him that he was stabbed by accused with a sharp
knife.
[31]
PW-7 Mohan Miah Chowdhury stated in his evidence that the
incident took place on 01.10.2021 at around 4.30 to 5 p.m. and on that day
on call he went to the house of PW-2 for preparation of some documents as
he worked as advocate’s Clerk and in that house he attended a meeting
where discussion between the brothers were going on in a room and he also
attended the meeting and suddenly he came out of the room to attend natural
call and heard hue and cry and returned to the meeting hall and saw that Titu
Miah Khadim was in bleeding and with the help of the bothers of Titu Miah
he took Titu Miah to Tepania Hospital where he was declared dead by the
doctor.
[32]
PW-8 Partha Karmakar stated in his evidence that the incident
took place on 01.10.2021 and that he had good relation with the Khadim
family and he was informed by PW-2 that there was a dispute between
accused and the deceased Titu Miah Khadim for property and on request he
attended a meeting fixed at 5 p.m. called by PW-2 in his house where the
relatives of Khadim family and other local persons were present and that he
sat in the back side of the meeting hall and in the meeting discussion started
with cordial relationship between the brothers but in the mean time a hot
discussion started between the accused and the deceased and they started to
push each other in presence of the relatives and that sitting in the back side
he was not of the view that a brother could attack another brother and in a
very short span of time the incident happened and the relatives were trying
to capture accused from attacking on his brother and it was noticed that Titu
Miah had fallen on the ground and Nurul Islam Khadim started to cry and
asked for bringing Titu Miah to hospital. He also stated that Titu was
attacked by accused and noticed that blood was oozing from Titu and that he
also went to the hospital and came to know from the doctor that Titu Miah
Khadim had been brought dead due to oozing of blood.
[33]
PW.13 Dr. Subhankar Nath, Dy. Director, SFSL, Tripura has
examined the exhibit-D (blood stain collected from the body of the
deceased) and his observation was that partial male genetic profile was
generated from Exhibit-D, and concluded that the blood belonged to human
male. He has also examined the exhibit-E (blood stain collected from the
alleged PO) and his observation was that partial male genetic profile was
generated from Exhibit-E, and concluded that the blood belonged to human
male. He prepared the report and on identification the report was marked as
Ext.P/10.
[34]
In view of overall discussions, it is undisputed position that
Titu Miah Khadim (deceased) died because of injuries sustained by sharp
cutting weapon. P.W-5 and P.W-6 the doctors, who conducted P.M.
examination over the dead body of Titu Miah Khadim found stab wound
(02x0.5x cavity deep) cm on chest 25 cm below the left shoulder top and
14.5 cm lateral to midline, incised wound (6.5x02x skin deep) cm on medial
aspect of left elbow, stab wound (2.6x01x3.5) cm on upper anterior chest at
the level of suprasternal notch and medially touching the midline, contusion
of underlying tissue and injury to neck vessels, incised wound (4.3x0.4x
skin deep) on right side of anterior abdomen and situated 11 cm above right
anterior superior iliac spine and 08 cm lateral to midline, about 500 ml of
liquid blood in left pleural cavity and contusion with one puncture wound
(0.5x0.2x0.2) cm in lateral aspect of lower lobe of left lung and in their
opinion, the cause of death was due to shock and hemorrhage due to
multiple homicidal injuries caused by the impact of hard and sharp force.
[35]
The defence also did not dispute the evidence of P.W.4, P.W.5
and P.W.11 in cross-examination. Though the prosecution argued that the
wearing apparels of the deceased were not seized and because of such non
seizure of the wearing apparels of the deceased, it would not be possible to
presume the kind of injuries sustained by the deceased but such argument
cannot be sustained because it is the case of defence that Titu Miah Khadim
was killed by some unknown miscreants.
[36]
The IO i.e., PW.14 admitted the receipt of telephonic
information, on 01-10-2021 at 06:00 pm, about stab injury at Khilpara
resulting death of Titu Miah Khadim. According to his evidence, such
information was entered in GDE bearing GDE No. 29, dated 01-10-2021
and to verify the information he along with others went to the spot and after
observation of the PO, it was found that there was commission of cognizable
offence and so as per direction of the OC PS, he took the self investigation.
[37]
From the cross-examination of PW.14 it is also evident that
from 1820 hours to 1905 hours he did the acts such as cordoning of PO,
sending of requisition to the SFSL team, seizure of blood stain from the PO.
Cross-examination of PW.14 also reveal that SFSL team with dog squad
reached the spot at 1900 hours and after arrival they started their work.
Again the cross-examination of PW.14 further reveals that he left the PO at
2330 hours and thereafter went to District Hospital, Tepania and reached
there at 2340 hours. As per the prescribed form of FIR i.e., Exbt.P11 the
First Information was received at PS at 2214 hours. Thus from the above, it
is unequivocally clear that on reaching the spot, PW.14 was busy in taking
the steps as reflected above and he did not examine any witness in the nature
of examination as is required under section-161 Cr.P.C.
[38]
Law is well settled that there cannot be more than one FIR in
respect of the same occurrence. However law also says that a cryptic
telephonic information cannot be treated as FIR. The Ld. Defece Counsel
relied upon the decision of “Lalita Kumari v Govt. of UP and others,
2014(2) SCC 1”, “T.T. Antony v State of kerala, 2001(6) SCC 181” and
there is no dispute in the law declared therein.
[39]
In State of UP v. Satish, reported in (2005) 3 SCC 114, the
Hon’ble Apex Court has held as under:
“As regards delayed examination of certain witnesses, this Court in several
decisions has held that unless the Investigating officer is categorcially asked
as to why there was delay in examination for the witnesses the defence cannot
gain any advantage therefrom. It cannot be laid down as a rule of universal
application that it there is any delay in examination of a particular witness the
prosecution version become suspect. It would depend upon several factors. If
the explanation offered for the delayed examination is plausible and
acceptable and the court accepts the same as plausible, there is no reason to
interfere with the conclusion [See Ranbir and Ors. v. State of Punjab, AIR
(1973) SC 1409, Bodhraj @ Rodha and Ors. v. State of Jammu and Kashmir,
[2002] 8 SCC 45 and Banti @ Guddu v. State of M.P., [2004] 1 SCC 414.]”.
[40]
In Balakrushna Swain v. State of Orissa, reported in (1971) 3
SCC 192, the Hon’ble Apex Court has observed as under:
“5. It has been contended before us that the evidence of P.W. 5 is also not
reliable, in that he is inimically disposed to the deceased and was an interested
witness inasmuch as he was the brother of Sundari whose side he was taking
to obtain for her the status of a wife. In fact according to the submission of the
learned Advocate the Appellant had not killed the deceased but the rafter had
fallen while they were all quarrelling in the house of the deceased injuring the
deceased and P.W. 5 as a result of which injury the deceased died. Thereafter
there was a conference between P.W. 1, P.W. 5 and others all night in that
house as to what should be done with the dead body and ultimately it was
decided to remove the dead body to the paddy field put it on a bamboo
platform which was to be built for this purpose and implicate the accused.
Accordingly P.W. 1 was sent to give a report. As we said earlier the High
Court did not rely on the evidence of P.W. 1 and P.W. 2 as in its view they
could not have witnessed the occurrence. It was also observed that P.W. 1 was
an interested witness being the sister's son of the deceased and also that he
could not have seen the actual murder and assault as on his own showing he
was proceeding to P.W. 2's house when the deceased who had gone to ease
himself was assaulted while he was on his way to join hint, P.W. 2's evidence
was not relied on although he is stated to have been assaulted by (the accused)
the Appellant, Pranakrushna Swain because there was no mark of injury on
his person nor was he medically examined P.W. 19, the Investigating Officer
admitted that although he had seen P.W. 2 in the Village from January 7 to
January 13, 1966 he found no marks of assault on him nor did P.W. 2 consent
for being sent to medical examination. As we have pointed out earlier P.W. 2
was also declared hostile and the prosecution allowed to cross-examine, him.
In these circumstances their evidence was rightly not relied upon to support
the prosecution case as to who and in what circumstances the occurrence took
place. The only other evidence is that of P.W. 5 who was not examined till the
15th January i.e. till after 10 or 11 days of the incident. There was no reason
why P.W. 19 could not have examined him because on his own showing P.W.
19 had met P.W. 5 while he was going to the Village when P.W. 5 was being
taken to the Hospital. No doubt P.W. 19 says that P.W. 5 was not in a
condition, for him, to record his statement but apart from his saying so he
does not tell us in what condition P.W. 5 was. P.W. 5 went to the Ersama
Primary Health center where Dr. Kanungo P.W. 22 who was then the Medical
Officer In-charge had examined him on receiving a requisition Ex. 11 from
the Police. According to the Doctor, P.W. 5 was under his treatment from 7-11966 to 12-1-1966. On examination he found four wounds:
1) One contused wound with, blood clot over the injury over the surrounding
tissues, extending to face. The margins were rough and regular.
The size of injury was 11/2" x 1/4". As the injury was bleeding I could not
measure its depth, but the injury had a depth. The injury was on the left side
head.
2) One contused wound with blood clot, with haematoma of mucous surface
on right side upper lip. The size of the injury was 1/4" x 1/4" The colour of
the injury was black.
3) One bruise with swelling 3" x 11/2" on the left fore-arm dorsal aspect-close
to elbow joint.
4) One bruise with swelling 2" x 1" on left side back over scapula.
In cross-examination the Doctor admitted that P.W. 5 was not treated as an
emergency patient and since there were only 2 beds for emergency cases he
did not admit him as Indoor patient and that P.W. 5 was making his own
arrangement for his stay and attending the Primary Health center daily for his
treatment. P.W. 5 however states that he was admitted as an indoor patient for
12 days which cannot be accepted in view of the Doctor's evidence. While
noting this divergence in the evidence of P.W. 19 and P.W. 5 the High Court
seems to accept an explanation given by the Public Prosecutor that because
P.W. 5 was being seen by the P.W. 19 everyday, P.W. 5 may have made
arrangements for his stay in the Hospital premises but this is no-one's case.
P.W. 19 says that P.W. 5 was coming everyday for treatment but there is no
evidence as to whether P.W. 5 was staying in the Hospital premises or
elsewhere, as such we find no justification in accepting the statement of P.W.
5 which in our view is a falsehood. In answer to a question by the Additional
Sessions Judge P.W. 22 says he found a laceration in injury No. 1 although he
did not mention the word laceration. He however admitted that in a contused
wound there is always a laceration but the margins are regular. In further
cross examination the Doctor said that since the margins of injury were
regular he mentioned it as a contused wound instead of a lacerated wound and
noted accordingly in his report Ex. 11/1. He further states that by a lathi no
incised wound can be caused. Incised wounds have always some depth. In
injury No. 1 also he found a depth but says that in contused wound also there
can be some depth. This evidence clearly shows that P.W. 5 was not certainly,
in a condition where his statement could not have been taken. The statement
by P.W. 5 that he was an indoor patient was an attempt to support P.W. 19's
explanation for not recording his statement earlier. That there was no valid
reason for P.W. 19 not to record his statement earlier when he met P.W. 5 on
the 7th itself is clear from his admissions that after he received the injuries he
did not lose his senses and in fact sat at the place where the incident took
place for two ghadis. The High Court itself has commented on the lapses in
investigation and the delay in examination of P.W. 5 who was a material
witness; none-the-less it merely says "even so the evidence of Chakradhar
P.W. 5 cannot be rejected on account of his delayed examination by the
investigating officer. In our opinion the delayed examination does not affect
the veracity of Chakradhar Swain". Why when a similar statement made by
P.W. 1 regarding the occurrence is not relied on, the statement of P.W. 5
should be relied particularly when such a long delay in his not being
examined earlier is not explained. The High Court said that the Doctor P.W.
22 had not mentioned that there was a bleeding injury on the right side forehead in certificate Ex. 11/1 although such an injury was mentioned in the
Police requisition Ex. 11 of 7-1-66. This comment we may observe is not
warranted because the Doctor was not cross-examined in respect of these
discrepancies. The mere fact that P.W. 19 had given a requisition to examine
P.W. 5 for an injury on the right side does not necessarily establish that the
injury was on the right side. A good deal of cross-examination was directed in
respect of the Report Ex. 11/2 given by him but nowhere was he asked as to
whether there was an injury on the left side and why he had omitted to
mention it. It is no one's case that there were two wounds one on the left side
and the other on the right side. What P.W. 5 says is that Laxmidhar gave him
four lathi blows as a result of which he had bleeding injury on the nostril and
on the left side of head and he fell down because of this assault. The Doctor
however said that this injury was on the right side. While there could have
been a mistake whether the injury was on the right side as spoken by the
Doctor or on the left side as spoken by the injured, there could be no mistake
as to whether there could be one wound or two wounds because the witness
does not speak about his having two wounds one on the left side and the other
on the right side. Further P.W. 5 says that the Doctor gave him a discharge
slip on the day he was discharged but later took it back after consultation with
the Thana Babu and thereafter he did not give him any discharge slip. P.W.
5's blood stained clothes were also seized on the 15th about 10 days after the
incident. The witness wants us to believe that for these 10 days he was
wearing these blood stained clothes without removing them.
6. In view of all these Incongruities we think there is justification in the
comment of the learned Advocate for the accused that the delayed
examination of P.W. 5 by P.W. 19 would give an opportunity to P.W. 5 to
concoct a different version than what actually took place.”
[41]
In Ganesh Bhavan Patel and Another v. State of
Maharashtra, reported in (1978) 4 SCC 371, the Hon’ble Apex Court
observed as follows:
“15. As noted by the Trial Court, one unusual feature which projects its
shadow on the evidence of P.Ws., Welji, Pramila and Kuvarbai and casts a
serious doubt about their being eyewitnesses of the occurrence, is the undue
delay on the part of the investigating officer in recording their statements.
Although these witnesses were or could be available for examination when
the investigating officer visited the scene of occurrence or soon thereafter,
their statements under Section 161 Cr. P.C. were recorded on the following
day. Welji (P.W. 3) was examined at 8 a.m., Pramila at 9.15 or 9.30 a.m., and
Kuvarbai at 1 p.m. delay of a few hours, simpliciler, in recording the
statements of eyewitnesses may not, by itself, amount to a serious infirmity in
the prosecution case. But it may assume such a character if there are
concomitant circumstances to suggest that the investigator was deliberately
marking time with a view to decide about the shape to be given to the case
and the eyewitnesses to be introduced. A catena of circumstances which lend
such significance to this delay, exists in the instant case.
18. In this connection, the second circumstance, which enhances the
potentiality of this delay as a factor undermining the prosecution case, is the
order of priority or sequence in which the investigating officer recorded the
statements of witnesses. Normally, in a case where the commission of the
crime is alleged to have been seen by witnesses who are easily available, a
prudent investigator would give to the examination of such witnesses
precedence, over the evidence of other witnesses Here, the natural order of
priorities seems to have been reversed. The investigating officer first recorded
the statement of Ravji, in all probability, between 12.45 and 3 a.m. On the
30th, of Constable Shinde, at 4 a.m., and thereafter of Walji, Kanjibhai (P.W.
7), Santukbai (P.W. 6), Pramila, and Kuvarbai, between 8 a.m. and 1 p.m.
19. The investigating officers made a futile attempt to explain away their
conduct in not promptly recording the statements of the alleged eyewitnesses.
Inspector Tipnis and Sub-Inspector Pathak stated that after the completion of
the panchnamas at the spot, they made efforts to contact the material
witnesses, including Pramila, Santukbai and Kuvarbai. Santukbai was actually
questioned by the investigating officers, but they did not then record her
statement, because she was in an anguished state of mind and was wailing.
20. With regard to Pramila and Kuvarbai, the investigators said that these girls
were then asleep, and therefore, they did not think it proper to disturb them.
Inspector Tipnis tried to give an additional reason for delaying the
examination of these witnesses till the following day. He stated that he did not
want the girls and the women-folk to be present in the Police Station at that
hour of the night. The Trial Judge rejected this explanation, and we think
rightly. Santukbai herself had knocked the bottom out of these 'explanations'.
She stated that she was questioned by the investigating officers during the
night and she had answered all their questions. Even if she was then in a state
of anguish, it is not understandable why the answers given by her to the
questions of the investigating officer, were not recorded. If she answered
those questions, which, even according to S.I. Pathak, she did, it could not be
said that she was not in a position to make a statement.
21. Ravji (P.W.1) further falsified the 'explanations' given by the investigating
officers. He stated that Pramila, Kuvarbai and Santukbai, all the three, were
actually called out and questioned during the night, by the investigating
officers.
22. If the untruth of any aspect of these 'explanations' remained in the
penumbral zone, hidden from judicial scrutiny, the same was fully exposed by
Constable Kakde (P.W. 18) of this very Police Station.
23. In cross-examination, Kakde let the cat out of the bag in as much as he
stated that about 2.30 a.m. he had seen P.Ws. Pramila, Kuvarbai, Santukbai,
Kanjibai and Ravji in the Police Station.
24. A third circumstance to be noted in the context, which enhances the
suspicion about Welji, Pramila and Kuvarbai having been introduced as 'eyewitnesses' at a late stage of the case, is, that their names as such witnesses
were not mentioned anywhere in the investigation record before the morning
of the 30th November. In this connection, it may be mentioned that Ravji and
Shinde reached the scene of crime soon after its commission. Ravji came a
few moments earlier than Constable Shinde. Damji was then alive and lay
injured at the spot. It was Constable Shinde who, accompanied by Ravji,
removed the injured in a taxi, first to the Police Station and from there to the
Sion Hospital.
25. At the trial. Shinde stated that on reaching the Police Station, he had
reported "the matter" to S.I. Patil, who was incharge of the Police Station.
Shinde did not say that he had mentioned the names of the assailants of Damji
or the witnesses to the Sub-Inspector on this occasion. Further, Shinde did not
vouch that Ravji had made any report about the incident to S.I. Patil.
26. S.I. Patil (P.W. 21), also, did not say that Shinde had told him that Damji
had been, according to his information, assaulted by the accused, Ganesh and
Dana. Nor did Patil say that Shinde had mentioned the names of the witnesses
of the occurrence. All that Patil stated on this point was that at about 7.30
a.m., Constable Shinde came to the Police Station and informed the witness
that one person who had been assauled by two others with knives, was lying
injured in a Taxi outside, and that he was accompanied by Ravji. In variance
with Shinde's version, however, S.I. Patil stated that he had questioned Ravji
on this occasion and the latter told him that Damji had been assaulted with
knives by Ganesh and Dana accused. Ravji directly contradicted S.I. Patil on
this point, and stated that on this occasion he was not at all questioned by S.I.
Patil; nor did the witness himself give any information about the incident to
the Sub-Inspector. Ravji had no motive to tell a lie on this point. He was a
"would-be" son-in-law of the deceased. He was in no way hostile to the
prosecution. on the contrary, he was playing the active role of a "complainant"
in this case. The Trial Court was, fully justified in accepting his testimony on
this point, in preference to the bare oral word of S.I. Patil, particularly, when
Ravji's version was, and Patil's was not, consistent with the surrounding
circumstances and probabilities of the case.
27. The most important of these circumstances is the conduct of S.I. Patil in
not recording that "first information" allegedly given by Shinde and Ravji on
that occasion. S. I. Patil admitted that he did not record the information given
to him by Shinde and Ravji about the occurrence on that occasion. The
information, which he then received, was about the commission of a
cognizable offence. It was, therefore, the duty of S.I. Patil (who was incharge
of the Police Station) to record it in accordance with the provisions of Section
154 Cr. P.C., but he did not do so. The explanation given by him was that it
was the practice of his Police Station not to record such information until a
message was received from the Hospital with regard to the condition of the
injured person. This explanation of Patil's failure to do what was his statutory
duty. was mere moonshine and was rightly repelled by the learned trial Judge.
28. It will bear repetition that the learned Judges of the High Court have
disbelieved Ravji and accepted S.I. Patil's bare word of mouth, both with
regard to the time of recording Ravji's statement and Ravji's having informed
Patil in the Police Station at 7.30 p.m. about the accused being the assailants
of the deceased, when Ravji and Shinde took the injured there in a taxi. As
noticed already, one of the reasons given by the High Court for rejecting
Ravji's testimony on this point, is that he was a mere labour boy having no
sense of time. With respect, this reason appears to us manifestly, unsound.
Labourers, masons and artisans who work on daily wages for fixed hours,
have an acute sense of time. There was nothing indefinite or unbelievable in
Ravji's version to the effect that his statement was recorded by the Police SubInspector between 12 midnight and 1 a.m., while his signature was obtained
on that statement probably at 3 a.m. No question was put to him to test his
'sense of time'. Nor was any attempt made in re-examination to elicit a
clarification, if one was needed, with a view to reconcile this version of the
witness with that of the prosecution case, as laid by S.I. Patil, about the time
of recording Ravji's statement, treated as the F.I.R.
29. Thus considered in the light of the surrounding circumstances, this
inordinate delay in registration of the 'F.I.R.' and further delay in recording
the statements of the material witnesses, casts a cloud of suspicion on the
credibility of the entire warp and woof of the prosecution story.”
[42]
Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P. in support of his case has placed
reliance on certain judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court most importantly
on the point that if the weapon of offence is not recovered, it cannot be fatal
the case of the prosecution and the accused can be convicted. In Goutam
Joardar v. State of West Bengal and ors reported in (2022) 17 SC 549, In
Baban Shankar Daphal and Others v. State of Maharashtra, reported in
(2025) SCC Online 137, In Ghanshyam Mandal and Others v. State of
Bihar (now Jharkhand) reported in (2026) SCC Online SC 307 and In
State through the Inspector of Police v. Laly alias Manikandan and
Another, reported in (2022) SCC Online SC 1424 and in Harivadan
Babubhai Patel v. State of Gujarat, reported in (2013) 7 SCC 45.
[43]
In Goutam Joardar v. State of West Bengal and Ors. reported
in (2022) 17 SC 549, the Hon’ble Apex Court has observed thus:
“20. The submissions on behalf of the accused that as the original informant
Mahendran has not been examined and that the other independent witnesses
have not been examined and that the recovery of the weapon has not been
proved and that there is a serious doubt about the timing and place of the
incident, the accused are to be acquitted cannot be accepted. Merely because
the original complainant is not examined cannot be a ground to discard the
deposition of PW-1. As observed hereinabove, PW1 is the eye witness to the
occurrence at both the places. Similarly, assuming that the recovery of the
weapon used is not established or proved also cannot be a ground to acquit the
accused when there is a direct evidence of the eye witness. Recovery of the
weapon used in the commission of the offence is not a sine qua non to convict
the accused. If there is direct evidence in the form of eye witness, even in the
absence of recovery of weapon, the accused can be convicted. Similarly, even
in the case of some contradictions with respect to timing of lodging the
FIR/complaint cannot be a ground to acquit the accused when the prosecution
case is based upon the deposition of eye witness.”
[44]
In Baban Shankar Daphal and Others v. State of
Maharashtra, reported in (2025) SCC Online 137, the Hon’ble Apex Court
has observed thus:
“27. One of the contentions of the learned counsel for the appellants is that the
eyewitnesses to the incident were all closely related to the deceased and for
prudence the prosecution ought to have examined some other independent
eyewitness as well who were present at the time of the unfortunate incident.
This was also the view taken by the Trial Court, but the High Court has
correctly rejected such an approach and held that merely because there were
some more independent witnesses also, who had reached the place of incident,
the evidence of the relatives cannot be disbelieved. The law nowhere states
that the evidence of the interested witness should be discarded altogether. The
law only warrants that their evidence should be scrutinized with care and
caution. It has been held by this Court in the catena of judgments that merely
if a witness is a relative, their testimony cannot be discarded on that ground
alone.”
31. Further, the High Court rightly rejected the Trial Court's conclusion that
the eyewitness accounts were unreliable. The Trial Court based its findings on
perceived inconsistencies between the testimony of the eyewitnesses and the
medical evidence. Specifically, the Trial Court found fault with the
eyewitness account of multiple stick blows to the victim's head, contending
that the post-mortem report did not show multiple head injuries. However, the
High Court, after analysing the evidence holistically, pointed out that minor
inconsistencies in eyewitness accounts do not render their testimony
unreliable, especially when they pertain to incidents involving sudden and
brutal violence.”
[45]
In Ghanshyam Mandal and Others v. State of Bihar (now
Jharkhand) reported in (2026) SCC Online SC 307, the Hon’ble Apex
Court has observed as under:
“7. It was urged on behalf of the appellants that in the absence of recovery of
any weapons of assault, the prosecution had failed to establish the guilt of the
appellants. It is true that the Investigating Officer failed to bring on record any
material indicating recovery of the weapons of assault that were described by
the eye-witnesses. However, this aspect cannot enable the appellants to seek
any benefit in the light of the fact that the version of the eye-witnesses as
regards the assault has been found to be reliable. It may be observed that
recovery of the weapons of assault is not the sine qua non for convicting an
accused as the entire evidence on record is required to be taken into
consideration. In this regard, we may refer to the decision in Rakesh and anr.
Vs. State of U.P. and anr.8. In paragraph 11, it has been observed as under:
“11. Now so far as the submission on behalf of the accused that as per the
ballistic report the bullet found does not match with the fire arm/gun
recovered and therefore the use of gun as alleged is doubtful and therefore
benefit of doubt must be given to the accused is concerned, the aforesaid
cannot be accepted. At the most, it can be said that the gun recovered by the
police from the accused may not have been used for killing and therefore
the 2021 INSC 321 recovery of the actual weapon used for killing can be
ignored and it is to be treated as if there is no recovery at all. For convicting
an accused recovery of the weapon used in commission of offence is not a
sine qua non. PW1 & PW2, as observed hereinabove, are reliable and
trustworthy eyewitnesses to the incident and they have specifically stated that
A1-Rakesh fired from the gun and the deceased sustained injury. The injury
by the gun has been established and proved from the medical evidence and the
deposition of Dr. Santosh Kumar, PW5. Injury no.1 is by gun shot. Therefore,
it is not possible to reject the credible ocular evidence of PW1 & PW2 – eye
witnesses who witnessed the shooting. It has no bearing on credibility of
deposition of PW1 & PW2 that A1 shot deceased with a gun, particularly as it
is corroborated by bullet in the body and also stands corroborated by the
testimony of PW2 & PW5. Therefore, merely because the ballistic report
shows that the bullet recovered does not match with the gun recovered, it is
not possible to reject the credible and reliable deposition of PW1 & PW2.”
8. We may also refer to a recent decision in Om Pal and Ors. Vs. State of
U.P. (now State of Uttarakhand)9. In paragraphs 49 and 50 thereof, it has
been observed as under:
“49. Another contention raised by the appellants was that the weapons used
during the incident were never recovered from the site. However, this Court
has many a times reiterated that non- recovery of the weapons cannot be
considered fatal to the case of the prosecution if there is consistent medical
and ocular evidence. This Court in the case State of Rajasthan vs. Arjun Singh
& Ors.16 held as under:
“18. As rightly pointed out by the learned Additional Advocate General
appearing for the State that mere nonrecovery of pistol or cartridge does not
detract the case of the prosecution where clinching and direct evidence is
acceptable. Likewise, absence of evidence regarding recovery of used pellets,
bloodstained clothes, etc. cannot be taken or construed as no such occurrence
had taken place. As a matter of fact, we have already pointed out that the
gunshot injuries tallied with medical evidence. It is also seen that Raghuraj
Singh and Himmat Raj Singh, who had died, received 8 and 7 gunshot
wounds respectively while Raj Singh (PW
2) also received 8 gunshots scattered in front of left 2025 INSC 1262 thigh.
All these injuries have been noted by the doctor (PW 1) in his reports, Exts. P1 to P-4.” (Emphasis supplied)
50. Also in Nankaunoo vs. State of Uttar Pradesh17, this Court held that
where in light of unimpeachable oral evidence is corroborated by the medical
evidence, non-recovery of murder weapon does not materially affect the case
of the prosecution. Any omission on the part of the investigating officer
cannot go against the prosecution’s case. Story of the prosecution is to be
examined dehors such omission by the investigating agency. Otherwise, it
would shake the confidence of the people not merely in the law enforcing
agency but also in the administration of justice.” From the aforesaid, it is clear
that the absence of recovery of the weapons of assault would not weaken the
case of the prosecution in the presence of other evidence on record that is
found reliable.”
[46]
In Harivadan Babubhai Patel v. State of Gujarat, reported in
(2013) 7 SCC 45, the Hob’ble Apex Court observed thus:
“20. In the case at hand, the factum of information related to the discovery of
the dead body and other articles and the said information was within the
special knowledge of the present appellant. Hence, the doctrine of
confirmation by subsequent events is attracted and, therefore, we have no
hesitation in holding that the recovery or discovery in the case at hand is a
relevant fact or material which can be relied upon and has been correctly
relied upon.
24. In State of H.P. v. Gian Chand it has been opined that “14.....Nonexamination of a material witness is again not a mathematical formula for
discarding the weight of the testimony available on record howsoever natural,
trustworthy and convincing it may be. The charge of withholding a material
witness from the court levelled against the prosecution should be examined in
the background of the facts and circumstances of each case so as to find
whether the witnesses are available for being examined in the court and were
yet withheld by the prosecution.”
The three Judge Bench further proceeded to observe that the
court is required first to assess the trustworthiness of the evidence available
on record and if the court finds the evidence adduced worthy of being relied
on, then the testimony has to be accepted and acted upon through there may
be other witnesses available who could also have been examined but were not
examined.
26. In Dahari v. State of U.P while discussing about the non-examination of
material witnesses, the Court expressed the view that when he was not the
only competent witness who would have been fully capable of explaining the
factual situation correctly and the prosecution case stood fully corroborated
by the medical evidence and the testimony of other reliable witnesses, no
adverse inference could be drawn against the prosecution. Be it noted, the
Court also took note of the fact that during the cross-examination of the
investigating officer, none of the accused persons had voiced their concerns or
raised any apprehension regarding the non-examination of the material
witness therein.
27. In the case at hand, it was A-1 who had announced that he was taking the
deceased to the house of Gulia. On a search being conducted, nothing has
been found from the house of Gulia. There has been no cross-examination of
the investigating officer about the non-examination of Gulia. On the contrary,
it was A-1 who had led to the discovery of the dead body and other articles.
Thus, when the other evidence on record are cogent, credible and meet the test
of circumstantial evidence laid down in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of
Maharashtra, State v. Saravanan, Sunil Kumar Sambhudayal Gupta v. State of
Maharashtra and further reiterated in Jagroop Singh v. State of Punjab, there
is no justification to come to hold that the prosecution has deliberately
withheld a witness that creates a concavity in the concept of fair trial.
28. Another facet is required to be addressed to. Though all the incriminating
circumstances which point to the guilt of the accused had been put to him, yet
he chose not to give any explanation under Section-313 Cr. P.C. except
choosing the mode of denial. It is well settled in law that when the attention of
the accused is drawn to the said circumstances that inculpated him in the
crime and he fails to offer appropriate explanation or gives a false answer, the
same can be counted as providing a missing link for building the chain of
circumstances. (See State of Maharashtra v. Suresh). In the case at hand,
though a number of circumstances were put to the accused, yet he has made a
bald denial and did not offer any explanation whatsoever. Thus, it is also a
circumstance that goes against him.”
[47]
Thus in view of the aforesaid case laws, the non-treating of
information noted in GDE No.29(Exbt.P.15) as FIR and treating of Exbt.P1
information by P.W.1 cannot be said to have suffered from any illegality
and so plea of defence that Exbt.P1 information would be hit by the
provision of S.162 Cr.P.C falls flat. Here in the instant case there is nothing
on record that more than one FIR was lodged in connection with the murder
of the deceased Titu Miah Khadim.
[48]
It is quite illogical to expect from a person like PW.1 to
chronologically disclose the information to police immediately on receipt of
information because a son on hearing the information about the killing of his
father might not be in a stable position to decide the course of action to be
adopted immediately and it is quite probable that in such a situation a son
like PW.1 was under immense mental shock and agony, as is revealed from
the answer of PW.1 in cross examination that “on that evening I did not
have any conversation with anyone at the home of Soharab Ali Khadim
since I was mentally devastated” and thus non disclosure of information
received by PW.1 to PW.14 immediately cannot be held to be so fatal to the
case of the prosecution.
[49]
Regarding the argument of the learned senior counsel that there
was delay in examination of witnesses by the IO and that the same provided
the scope for manipulation of evidence thereby prejudicing the accused, this
Court is of the view that delay in the examination of witnesses by the
investigating officer (IO) can raise questions about the fairness of the
investigation, but not every delay necessarily vitiates the entire investigation
unless there is no prejudice to the accused or the integrity of the
investigation is not compromised. The Hon’ble Apex Court ruled that delay
in the examination of witnesses does not automatically vitiate an
investigation unless the delay has caused prejudice to the accused and that it
is important to examine whether the delay was caused by valid reasons or
was deliberate to affect the fairness of the trial.
[50]
Now turning to the evidence, it appears that the informant P.W-
1 had no personal information and as per his evidence, he got the
information about the alleged incident from his uncle PW-2 and he stated
that in the mediation meeting called by PW-2 in his house to settle the
dispute between the accused and the deceased, accused assaulted his father
with knife in stomach and other parts of body. PW-2, whose presence on the
place of occurrence is not disputed by the defence, stated that on 01.10.2021
he called for a mediation meeting in his house to settle the property dispute
between his two younger brothers i.e.; accused and the deceased and that
accused started discussion on high and aggressive tone and was not amiable
for any solution and so when he was about to leave, the deceased requested
him to resolve the dispute in his(PW-2) presence and suddenly accused
brought out a meat cutting knife and lunged it in the stomach and neck of
the deceased. He further stated that he intervened to stop further blows and
his cousin Sahin Ahamed i.e., DW-2 also sustained cut injuries. He again
stated that the accused went to the courtyard and cleaned the knife with a
gamcha and commented that why the deceased was still alive.
[51]
Now let’s see whether the evidence of PW-2 gets corroboration
from any other witness. PW-2 in his evidence made it clear that in the
meeting his cousin brother Ahamed Ullah @ Madhab, cousin brother Setu
Miah Sarkar, cousin Kaji Sahin Ahamed (DW-2), Mohan Miah (PW-7),
Nurul Islam Khadim (PW-4), and Partha Karmakar (PW.8) were present. As
per evidence of PW.4, deceased and accused are his younger brothers and
they had property dispute and about one year back, in a mediation meeting
held in the house of PW.2 to settle the dispute between the accused and the
deceased, there was hot altercation between the deceased and the accused,
who was not agreeable to any solution, and so he left the meeting but within
a minute he heard uproar and so went back and found that the deceased was
lying with bleeding injuries in the room while the accused was cleaning a
blood stained knife with a gamcha.
[52]
The aforesaid evidence goes to show that the evidence of PW-2
gets corroborated by PW-4, PW-8 and to some extent by PW-3. The
aforesaid witnesses were thoroughly cross-examined by the defence and
now it is to be seen whether the defence could shake the evidence of
prosecution witnesses or could impeach the credibility of such witnesses. It
was pointed out that the evidence of P.W.2 and P.W.8 were not corroborated
by other prosecution witnesses such as P.W.3, P.W.4, P.W.7 and that there
were inconsistencies and contradictions in their evidence and thus according
to the defence, the evidence of prosecution witnesses could not be relied
upon. Now on this point the law is well-settled that inconsistencies in the
testimony of witnesses do not automatically render the evidence
inadmissible or unreliable.
[53]
It was argued by the defence that the prosecution withheld the
evidence of D.W.2 and D.W.3 to screen the evidence of innocence of
accused but such evidence cannot be accepted here because it is clearly
revealed that the evidence of DW-2 and DW-3 were afterthought and
subsequent creation and so their non-examination by the prosecution cannot
be said to have any impact on the case of the prosecution.
[54]
The defence further agitated during argument that SFSL team
and dog master were not examined either by the IO or by the prosecution.
From the evidence of prosecution witnesses it is not revealed that the action
of the dog squad revealed any relevant material supporting the case of the
prosecution. Again the defence did not dispute the evidence of expert
witness such as PW-11, PW-12 and PW-13. Thus non examination of SFSL
team or dog master is non-consequential.
[55]
Here in the case at hand, we have discussed the evidence on
record of the prosecution in detail. Now we are to conclude our decision on
the basis of material evidence on record as well as the observations made by
the learned Court below. In our ultimate analysis, it is crystal clear that there
is no reason as to why the continuity of the chain of circumstances and the
complaint made against the appellant to be disbelieved. The witnesses
supported the entire case of the prosecution with regard to the commission
of offence by the appellant herein and furthermore, we find that the
statement made by the witnesses needs no interference. Consequently, we
find no reason to interfere with the observations made by the learned Court
below and thus, the same is affirmed. However, the reliance as has been
placed on certain judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court by the learned
senior counsel appearing for the appellant has no relevance to the facts and
circumstances of the present case.
[56]
In the result, the appeal stands dismissed. As a sequel,
miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed. Send down
the LCRs forthwith.
S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA, J
A.Ghosh
signed by ANJAN GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2026.03.30 10:28:36 +05'30'
DR.T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review