Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
SHARMA
SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.07.27 15:32:50 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.1124 of 2022
Nongthombam Sanaton, aged about 50 years, S/o N.
Ibopishak
Meitei,
resident
of
Nongmeibung
Ayangpalli, Porompat, P.O. & P.S. Porompat and
District Imphal East, Manipur – 795005.
...Petitioner
-Versus-
1. The State of Manipur, through the Principal
Secretary/Commissioner/Secretary,
(Revenue
Department), Govt. of Manipur, Imphal West
District, Manipur -795001.
2. The Under Secretary (Revenue), Govt. of
Manipur, Secretariat Building, Babupara, P.O. &
P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur795001.
3. T. Nandakumar Singh, UDC, LA/Sub-Registrar,
office address – SDO Office Moirang, P.O.
Moirang,
P.S.
Moirang,
Bishnupur
District,
Manipur – 795133.
...Respondents
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
Page |2
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
::
Mr. BP Sahu, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Anjan Prasad Sahu, Adv.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. A. Romenkumar, Sr. Adv.
Mr. H. Debendra, Dy. AG
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
27.06.2023
Date of Judgment & Order ::
24.07.2023
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner to
quash the impugned order dated 26.12.2022 and to direct the
respondents to allow the petitioner to continue to work at
LA/SDC(HQ)/SDC office, Lamsang.
2.
The case of the petitioner is that the petitioner was
initially appointed as Process Server in the Revenue
Department on 10.6.1996. While he was serving as look after
SDC/Sub-Registrar (Zilladar) at the office of the SDO,
Porompat, the petitioner was transferred to the office of LA/SubRegistrar, Thoubal vide order dated 7.1.2021. Subsequently,
five transfer orders were issued in respect of the petitioner and
vide impugned order dated 26.12.2022, the petitioner was
transferred and posted at SDO office, Moirang as LA/Sub-
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
Page |3
Registrar/SDC(HQ) merely two months after he was last
transferred. Challenging the impugned order, the petitioner has
filed the present writ petition.
3.
The respondents 1 and 2 filed affidavit-in-
opposition stating that the impugned transfer order was issued
mainly on the criteria of having thorough knowledge and
experience of National Generic Document Registration System
(NGDRS), which was made mandatory in the valley districts of
Manipur vide notification dated 4.11.2022 of the Revenue
Department. There is no malafide on the part of the State
authority in issuing the impugned transfer order and it was
issued for effective implementation of NGDRS as the private
respondent is more experienced in respect of the same and on
the other hand, the petitioner is less experienced in order to
start the operation of NGDRS in Lamsang Sub-Division, which
has a large territorial jurisdiction. It is stated that the impugned
transfer order was issued with the approval of the Hon’ble Chief
Minister of Manipur with an objective for implementation of
NGDRS in larger public interest. The department has never
violated any rules or transfer policy.
dismissal of the writ petition.
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
Hence, prayed for
Page |4
4.
Assailing the impugned transfer order, the learned
counsel for the petitioner submitted that barely two and half
months from his previous transfer order dated 4.10.2022, the
impugned transfer order dated 26.12.2022 came to be passed,
which is in gross violation of all extant norms, rules and
regulations, more particularly, it is in clear violation of the
transfer policy of the State issued under notification dated
12.5.2022.
5.
Mr. Anjan Prasad Sahu, the learned counsel
further submitted that the official respondents claimed that the
transfer order had taken place due to the position in Lamsang
requiring an expert in NGDRS which the petitioner has not
equipped to handle. However, no documents have been
submitted that the third respondent who was chosen to take
over the charge from the petitioner in Lamsang is an expert in
NGDRS.
6.
According to Mr. Anjan Prasad Sahu, the learned
counsel for the petitioner, Lansang consists of only two
Assembly Constituencies, whereas Moirang consists of three
Assembly Constituencies.
The question of transferring the
petitioner from an area with smaller territorial jurisdiction
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
Page |5
(Lamsang) to an area with a larger territorial jurisdiction
(Moirang) vitiates the whole plea of the petitioner being a nonexpert in the NGDRS.
7.
Drawing this Court’s attention to the notification
dated 12.5.2022, the learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the normal tenure of posting of an officer in a
post will be minimum of one year and six months and maximum
of three years in a place of posting and no transfer may be
effected unless the concerned employee has completed one
year and six months in a post, unless there are compelling
reasons to do so.
8.
Adding further, the learned counsel for the
petitioner submitted that the only reason the petitioner had been
patiently going to the last four places of posting every single
time without any complaints is because of the petitioner’s firm
belief on the sanctity of administrative exigency and incidence
of service that every Government employee has to abide by.
But the impugned order has been the last nail on the coffin, as
the petitioner has barely had time to acclimatize in the position,
he was charged with in Lamsang. In fact, the impugned transfer
order has been passed in order to favour the third respondent
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
Page |6
and not in public interest. The fact also remains that the third
respondent has been in the same office for the past 20 years
previously as LDC upto 2021. Even the third respondent’s
previous antecedent of having been accused of selling an
agricultural land without the owner’s consent is a concealed fact
and is now facing the case. In support, the learned counsel for
the petitioner placed reliance upon the following decisions:
(i)
B.Varadha Rao v. State of Karnataka and
others, (1986) 4 SCC 131.
(ii)
Prasanna Kumar Nath v. State of Assam
and others, 2005 (3) GauLR 269.
(iii) Thounaojam Jamini Devi v. State of
Manipur and others, 2019 (3) GLT (MN)
78.
9.
Per contra, Mr. H. Debendra, the learned Deputy
Advocate General for the respondents 1 and 2 submitted that
the reason/justification for transfer of Government employees
are not similar and the transfer and posting of the third
respondent at the office of the SDO, Lamsang was done in
exigency of service for effective implementation of NGDRS and
there is no malafide in the impugned transfer.
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
Page |7
10.
The learned Deputy Advocate General further
submitted that the transfer was proceeded after due
consideration and by executing the power of relaxation issued
in Government transfer notification dated 12.5.2022 because of
exigency of service for effective implementation of NGDRS.
The third respondent is having thorough knowledge and
experience of NGDRS and because of his expertise, NGDRS
was effectively implemented in Moirang Sub Division of
Bishnupur District.
11.
Mr. A. Romenkumar, the learned senior counsel
for the third respondent submitted that in order to meet the
urgent requirements, the third respondent has been posted in
the place of the petitioner in public interest, more particularly, in
order to carry out and implement the decision of the State
Government for registration through the NGDRS.
Only the
official who is trained and expert in the subject is required to be
posted in the office of the SDO/Lamsang in the rank of LA/SubRegistrar/SDC(HQ), SDC office, Lamsang.
12.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that
the impugned transfer order was not issued under the pressure
of the third respondent and the same was issued in an
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
Page |8
administrative exigency and in public interest to implement the
scheme, which cannot be questioned by the petitioner. Thus, a
prayer has been made to dismiss the writ petition. In support,
the learned senior counsel for the third respondent placed
reliance upon the following decisions:
(i)
Chief
Commercial
Manager,
South
Central Railway, Secunderabad and
others v. G.Ratnam and others, (2007) 8
SCC 212.
(ii)
Dr. Nagorao Shivaji Chavan v. Dr. Sunil
Purushottam Bhamre and others, AIR
2019 SC 189.
(iii)
Bobby Laishram v. State of Manipur and
others, 2022 (1) MnLJ 249.
(iv)
Thanglemsang Khongsai v. Union of
India and others, 2022 (2) MnLJ 384.
13.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
14.
The petitioner assails the impugned transfer order
mainly on the ground that two months after his earlier transfer,
the impugned order has been passed, which is in clear violation
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
Page |9
of the rule made by the Government of Manipur. It is also the
plea of the petitioner that the transfer had taken place not once
but five times already and on the face of it, the impugned
transfer order is clearly illegal and void abi-initio.
15.
Coming to the merits of the impugned transfer, the
petitioner contends that there is no document to support the
third respondent’s expertise in NGDRS and in fact, he is facing
legal action based on the complaint lodged by one Ningthoujam
Laphoijao Singh that the third respondent conspired to commit
wrong deeds by selling the property of the complainant being
gift deed No.70, Tairenpokpi area of .62 acres.
16.
On the other hand, the plea of the respondents 1
and 2 is that there is no malafide on the part of the State
authority in issuing the impugned transfer and it was issued for
effective implementation of NGDRS as the third respondent is
more experienced in respect of the same and on the other hand,
the petitioner is less experienced in order to start the operation
of NGDRS in Lamsang Sub-Division, which has a large
territorial jurisdiction.
17.
First of all, the petitioner being a Government
employee ought to understand the fact that transfer is an
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
P a g e | 10
incidence of service and no employee has any right to be posted
at a particular place. According to the official respondents, the
criteria of having thorough knowledge and experience of
NGDRS is mandatory in the valley districts of Manipur and the
petitioner is less experienced than the third respondent to start
the operation of NGDRS in Lamsang Sub Division. When that
being the ground for transferring the petitioner from the office of
the SDO, Lamsang to the office of the SDO, Moirang, the plea
of the petitioner that Lamsang consists only two Assembly
Constituencies whereas the Moirang is a larger territorial
jurisdiction consisting three Assembly Constituencies cannot be
ground to invalidate the impugned transfer order. On the face
of it, the impugned transfer is made in public interest.
18.
Though the petitioner contends that as per the
Policy for Transfer and Posting of Government Employees of
the State of Manipur, the normal tenure of posting of an
employee in a post will be minimum one year and six months
and maximum of three years in a place of posting and no
transfer may be effected unless the concerned employee has
completed one year and six months in a post, the said Transfer
Policy dated 12.5.2022 stipulates relaxation clause, which
reads thus:
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
P a g e | 11
“V. Power to relax: Notwithstanding anything
contained in the policy, the State Government,
with the prior approval of the Chief Minister,
Manipur shall be competent to transfer an
employee to any place in relaxation of any or
all of the above provisions after recording
reasons justifying such relaxation.
No transfer and posting which is contrary to
this Policy shall be made be any Department
without the approval of the Chief Minister,
Manipur.”
19.
In the case on hand, the official respondents
submitted that the impugned transfer order was issued with the
prior approval of the Hon’ble Chief Minister with the object of
implementation of NGDRS in larger public interest. Nothing has
been produced by the petitioner to show that the impugned
transfer is made without the approval of the Hon’ble Chief
Minister.
20.
In the decision relied upon by the learned counsel
for the petitioner in the case of B.Varadha Rao (supra), the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that if the power is exercised mala
fide, then obviously the order of transfer is liable to be struck
down. In the case on hand, nothing has been produced by the
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
P a g e | 12
petitioner to show that the impugned transfer order was issued
in exercise of malafide power.
21.
The next decision relied upon by the learned
counsel for the petitioner is in the case of Prasanna Kumar
Natha (supra). The said case deals with the transfer order
issued as per the desire of a particular MLA and having found
that the order impugned therein is not based on any bonafide
exercise of power involving any public interest but the same was
issued as per the desire of the particular MLA, the Gauhati High
Court set aside the order of transfer. As stated supra, in the
present case, the transfer was made in public interest qua for
implementation of NGDRS in Lamsang Sub-Division.
22.
The next decision relied upon by the learned
counsel for the petitioner is in the case of Thounaojam Jamini
Devi (supra). The ultimate decision of this Court in the said
case is that the petitioner therein does not accrue any legal right
to question the transfer order and the transfer order dated
8.3.2019 was issued in public interest.
In the facts and
circumstances of the case, the decision in Thounaojam Jamini
(supra) is not applicable to the case of the petitioner.
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
P a g e | 13
23.
In G.Ratnam (supra) relied upon by the learned
senior counsel for the third respondent, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held as under:
"20. It is well settled that the Central Government or
the State Government can give administrative
instructions to its servants how to act in certain
circumstances; but that will not make such
instructions statutory rules which are justiciable in
certain circumstances. In order that such executive
instructions have the force of statutory rules, it must
be shown that they have been issued either under
the authority conferred on the Central Government
or the State Government by some statute or under
some provision of the Constitution providing
therefor. Therefore, even if there has been any
breach of such executive instructions that does not
confer any right on any member of the public to ask
for a writ against the Government by a petition under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India."
24.
In Dr. Nagorao Shivaji Chavan (supra), the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
"12. Notwithstanding the provisions contained in
Section 3 which uses the expression that “ordinarily
the tenure is three years”, in our opinion in
exceptional circumstances in a given case, or in the
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
P a g e | 14
case of administrative exigencies, transfer is
permissible, and no absolute bar on transfer is
created by virtue of the provisions contained in
Section 3 read with Section 4. In the facts and
circumstances of the case and also considering the
past record of Respondent 1 of not joining the place
where he was transferred for five years, no
interference with the order of transfer is called for."
25.
In Bobby Laishram (supra), this Court held:
"34. It is well settled that matters of transfers are
best left to the discretion of the competent
authority and should not be tinkered with, in the
absence of a demonstrable violation of statutory
rules, or an instance of mala fide on the part of
the competent authority. In the case on hand,
the respondent authorities have satisfactorily
explained the reason for issuing the transfer and
posting order to the petitioner."
26.
In Thanglemsang Khongsai (supra), this Court
held:
“[14] Admittedly, the order of transfer does not
adversely affect the status or emoluments or
seniority of the petitioner. The petitioner has no
vested right to get a posting at a place of his
choice.
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
It is for the respondent authorities to
P a g e | 15
determine at which place and for how long the
services of a particular employee are required.
The transfer order has been passed considering
the administrative exigency and not arbitrarily or
for extraneous consideration or for victimization
of the petitioner.”
27.
The Government servant holding a transferable
post has no vested right to remain posted at one place or other,
and he/she is liable to be transferred from one place to another.
Even if a transfer order is passed in violation of the executive
instructions or orders, the Courts ordinarily should not interfere
with the said order. It is for the authorities to determine at which
place and for how long the services of a particular employee are
required.
28.
In the case on hand, the reason for transferring the
petitioner to Moirang has been clearly spelt out by the official
respondents. Further, the transfer of the third respondent to
Lamsang Sub Division is mainly for effective implementation of
NGDRS scheme. The matters of transfers are best left to the
discretion of the competent authority and should not be tinkered
with in the absence of a demonstrable violation of statutory rules
or an instance of malafide on the part of the competent
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
P a g e | 16
authority. Merely because the petitioner was transferred five
times before the impugned transfer, it cannot be contended that
the impugned transfer order was issued in malafide exercise of
power. Therefore, this Court finds no infirmity in the impugned
transfer order. Accordingly, the writ petition fails.
29.
In the result, the writ petition is dismissed. There
will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 1124 of 2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review