Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:49186-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 3793 OF 2022
Nobel Carrying Corporation, Omerga Through G.p.a. Holder Ansari
Mohammad Nadim Mohd. Yunus And Anr
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
Mr. S. N. Patne, Advocate for applicants
Mr. A. R. Kale, APP for respondent-State
CORAM : R. M. JOSHI, J.
DATE
: 12th OCTOBER, 2026
PER COURT :1.
This application is filed under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure seeks quashment of the First Information Report
bearing No. 187 of 2022 registered with Palam Police Station, Dist.
Parbhani, for the offences punishable under Sections 3, 7, 8, 9, 10 of the
Essential Commodities Act, 1955, under Sections 7, 13 of the Public
Distribution System (Control) Order, 2015 and under Sections 407, 34 of
the Indian Penal Code.
2.
In-charge Nayab Tahsildar (supply), Tahsildar office, Palam,
lodged report stating that on 11.08.2022 at about 11 AM, when he was
in his office, Tahsildar authorized him to register the crime against Nobel
Carrying Corporation, Omerga. It was alleged that the District Collector,
Parbani, has alleged contract of transportation of Food Corporation of
India (For short “FCI”) grains, and as there is no entry in respect of FCI
23-Cri Appln-3793-2022.odt
1 of 7
vehicle in the office of government warehouse at Palam, Tahsildar
directed Nobel Carrying Corporation to make entry in the office of
Tahsildar office, Palam, in respect of the vehicles, and thereafter to
transport the vehicle in the government warehouse for unloading. It is
further claimed that as per the letter dated 10.08.2022, the food grain
lifting agent has loaded the grains in vehicle number mentioned therein.
After inquiry it was found that the vehicles have not reached to the
government warehouse at Pethshivni, Tq. Palam. In view of the said
facts,
complaint
came
to
be
lodged
with
regard
to
the
misappropriation/black marketing of government food grains. On the
basis of this information, offence under the provisions of Essential
Commodities Act as well as Public Distribution System (Control) Order,
2015, so also offences under Indian Penal Code came to be invoked
against applicants.
3.
Learned counsel for applicants submit that the offence under
the Essential Commodities Act could not have been made applicable to
the present applicants in absence of Nobel Carrying Corporation and its
partners being joined as a party accused to this proceeding. It is his
submission
that
in
order
to
attract
the
provisions
of
Essential
Commodities Act, in view of Section 10 thereof, applicants ought to have
been directors, partners, officers, or persons in charge of the business of
the said company. It is his submission that admittedly applicant No. 1 is
not partner of the company, but is said to be a constituted attorney. In
23-Cri Appln-3793-2022.odt
2 of 7
so far as applicant No. 2 is concerned, he argues that applicant is a
driver of the truck and hence, they cannot be considered to be in charge
of the business of the said company. According to him, unless the
present person responsible for the affairs of the company is made
accused, so also the company is made as an accused, criminal
proceedings cannot be maintained against applicants with regard to the
offence punishable under Section 407 of Indian Penal Code is concerned,
it is his contention that there is absolutely no evidence to indicate that
any food grain were entrusted to the applicants and they committed
breach of trust and in any case no offence is attributed by the company
against them.
4.
Learned APP opposed grant of any relief to the applicant by
contending that offence is serious in nature and there is misappropriation
of government food grain to substantial amount. It is his submission by
relying upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of
State of Panjab Vs. Kasturi Lal and others AIR 2004 SC 4087 that
the prosecution against the persons in charge of the company, even they
joined company as an accused, is permissible. He also drew attention of
the court to the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of State
(Government of NCT of Delhi) Vs. D.A. M. Prabhu and another
(2009) 3 SCC 264.
5.
There is no dispute about the fact that the main offence
23-Cri Appln-3793-2022.odt
3 of 7
sought to be attracted against the applicant is punishable under the
Essential Commodities Act and the Public Distribution System (Control)
Order, 2015. There is allegation with regard to the non-compliance of
order passed by the authorities under the Act by Nobel Carrying
Corporation, Omerga. It would therefore be relevant at this stage to
make reference to the provisions of Section 10, which reads thus:
“(1) if the person contravening an order made under
Section 3 is a company, every person who, at the time
the contravention was committed was in charge of, and
was responsible to, the company, shall be deemed to
be guilty of the contravention and shall be liable to be
proceeded against punished accordingly:
Provided that nothing contained in this sub-section
shall render any such person liable to any punishment if
he proves that the contravention took place without his
knowledge or that he exercised all due diligence to
prevent such contravention.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section
(1), where an offence under this Act has been
committed by a company and it is proved that the
offence has been committed with the consent or
connivance of, or is attributable to any neglect on the
part of, any director, manager, secretary or other officer
of the company, such director, manager, secretary or
other officer shall also be deemed to be guilty of that
offence and shall be liable to be proceeded against and
punished accordingly.
Explanation - For the purpose of this section, (a) “company” means any body corporate, and includes
a firm or other association of individuals; and
(b) “director” in relation to a firm means a partner in
the firm.
6.
Perusal of this section clearly indicates that a person,
23-Cri Appln-3793-2022.odt
4 of 7
contravenes the order made under Section 3, and such person is a
company, every person who at the time of contravention was in charge
or responsible to the company shall be deemed to be guilty of the
contravention. It is thus clear that in order to make some guilt or
responsible for the commission of crime, such person should be in charge
or responsible to the company.
7.
In the backdrop of this provision, Hon'ble Supreme Court in
case of State of Panjab Vs. Kasturi Lal and others (supra) has held
that having regard to the nature of the said provision, the person in
charge of the company or an officer of the company may be separately
prosecuted, even if company itself is not prosecuted. In order to apply
the said judgment, in the instant case, there must be evidence to
indicate that present applicants were in charge of the company, i.e.,
Nobel Carrying Corporation.
8.
Learned APP made an attempt to convince this court that the
applicant No. 1 is constituted attorney and therefore he is responsible for
the affairs of the company. It would be relevant to take note of the said
power of attorney, which reads thus:
lokZf/kdkji+=
fygqu ?ka.kkj %& vUlkjh eks-ufne eks ;quql
o; % 27 o”kZ] /kank % O;kikj
jk- dkykckoj IykWV ijHk.kh rk- ft- ijHk.kh
fygqu ns.kkj %& eksfg;ksfÌu vcqy Qst lqyrku
o; % 49 o”kZ] /kank % O;kikj
jk- mejxkk rk- mejxk ft- mLekukckn
23-Cri Appln-3793-2022.odt
5 of 7
dkj.ks lokZf/kdkji= dj.;kr ;srs dh] eh fygqu ns.kkj eksfg;ksfÌu vcqy Qst
lqyrku vlqu eyk ukscy dkWfjax dkWiksZjs’ku ;k daiuhps loZ dkedktkckcr lokZf/kdkj
i= izkIr vkgs- lcc daiuhyk ijHk.kh ftYg;kps b- Lk- 2017&2020 ps vUu/kkU;
iqjoBk okgrqd dj.;kckcrps da=kV feGkysys vkgsgs dh] eh fygqu ns.kkj eksfg;ksfÌu vcqy Qst lqyrku o; % 49 o”kZ] /kank %
O;kikj jk- mejxk rk- mejxk ft- mLekukckn ekb;k dkgh [kktxh dkj.kkeqGs lacaf/kr
da=Vkckcr dk;kZy;kr i=O;ogkj ns.ks@fLodkj.ks] chy cuo.ks o lknj dj.ks] okgrqd
izrhfu/khph fu;qDrh dj.ks] b- dkek lanHkkZr lokZf/kdkj rlsp vko’;d vl.kk&;k dkgh
dkeklkBh fu.kZ; ?ks.ks ckcr lokZf/kdkj /kkjd Eg.kqu ek>s eq[kR;kj vke Eg.kqu fygwu ?
ks.kkj vUlkjh eks-ufne eks ;quql o; 27 o”kZ /aknk jk- dkykckoj IykWV ijHk.kh rk- ftijHk.kh vkEgh ;kauk nsr vkgsdfjrk lnjhy lokZf/kdkji= eh ekb;k jkth[kq’khus dks.kkP;kgh nckokyk cGh u
iMrk fygqu ?ks.kkj ;kaP;k gDdkr [kkyhy lk{khnkjkle{k d#u fnys rs lR; o cjkscj
vkgsThe above power of attorney, which does not indicate that
the business of Noble Carrying Corporation being entrusted to applicant
No. 1. Applicant No. 1 was permitted to do certain things which are
mentioned in the power of attorney and on behalf of the partners of the
company. By no stretch of imagination it could be said that applicant No.
1 is the partner or in charge of the company as contemplated by Section
10 thereof. As far as applicant No. 2 is concerned, by no stretch of
imagination it could be said that this applicant is in charge of the said
company. This court, therefore, finds substance in the contention of the
learned counsel for the applicant that in so far as offences under the
Essential Commodities Act and Public Distribution System (Control)
Order, 2015, are not made out against them and proceedings against
them without company and/or partners thereof, being accused cannot
sustain.
23-Cri Appln-3793-2022.odt
6 of 7
9.
Coming to the offence punishable under Section 407 of
Indian Penal Code, there is absolutely no material on record to show that
any food grain was entrusted to these applicants in order to accept the
existence of offence of commission of breach of trust against them. In
any case such offence would be attracted in case there is breach of trust
committed by the company and not of any other person. No case to that
effect is sought to be made out by prosecution. Thus, the entire
proceeding against applicants cannot be allowed to be continued.
10.
This court is surprised to notice that during the course of the
investigation on behalf of the prosecution, it was sought to be argued
without justification that there was no need of the partners of the said
company to be joined as accused persons. Needless to say that it was
open for the prosecution to claim in case evidence is found against the
partners of the company, they can be arraigned as accused at any stage
of proceeding but for the reason best known to the prosecution, it is not
so claimed. This court, therefore, finds no hesitation to hold First
Information Report and the entire proceedings on the basis of said First
Information Report against the present applicants to be not sustainable.
11.
Hence, application stands allowed in terms of prayer clause
“C, C-1, and C-2”.
B. S. Joshi
23-Cri Appln-3793-2022.odt
(R. M. JOSHI, J.)
7 of 7
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review