The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. 02.2011 to 29.05.2011 in respect of No.97040664 Hav(GD) Dilip Kumar Tripura of „E‟ Coy, 2 nd Bn TSR (Now „D‟ Coy) has been treated as “SPENT OF DUTY” under Rule- FR-54(B) since the Disciplinary Proceeding drawn up against him was finalized by awarding Minor Punishment.” [8] The petitioner, on 25.02.2019, filed an appeal before the respondent No.2 for review and revocation of punishment imposed upon him by the respondent No.4. But, the respondent No.2 upheld the punishment imposed by the respondent No.4 vide order No.3440- 42/F.47(17)/DAP/TSR/RSV/11 dated 13th May, 2019 with a view that the charges in criminal case as well as in the departmental proceedings are different. For the purpose of reference, the relevant portion of the order of the Dy. IG of Police (AP), Tripura, Agartala i.e. Respondent No.2 is quoted below: “……5. The charges in criminal case as well as in the Departmental proceedings are different. Moreover, the 30 days time limit for appeal has been long over. In view of the above, the undersigned does not find merit in the contention of the appellant that in view of the judgment in criminal case his punishment should be reviewed. Undersigned finds no justifiable grounds that warrants relook into the punishment order of the then Commandant, 2nd Bn TSR.
6. The appeal petition is disposed off accordingly.” [9] Thereafter, on 22.05.2019, the petitioner submitted an application before the respondent No.3 i.e. the Director General of Police, Government of Tripura, Agartala for revocation of punishment order imposed by the respondent No.4 and the petitioner has stated that he has been acquitted from the charges under Section 379 of IPC but, the said prayer of the petitioner was rejected by order dated 25.06.2019. The relevant portion of the order dated 25.06.2019 passed by the I/C Director General of Police, Tripura, Agartala is quoted below for the purpose of reference: “…..4. The undersigned does not find merit in the appeal petition of the applicant to review the punishment order as he was acquitted of the charge leveled by the Court of SDJM, Bishalgarh. The charges in both the instances are different. The undersigned agrees with the order of the Appellate Authority (DIG, AP) as there is no justifiable ground to relook into the punishment order. The appeal petition is disposed off accordingly.” [10] Aggrieved thereby, the instant writ petition has been filed by the petitioner seeking following reliefs: (i) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them to show cause as to why a writ of certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued. (ii) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them to s…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No. 182 of 2022
No 97040664, Hav (GD)
Dilip Kumar Tripura
E Coy, 2nd Bn TSR, State Rifles
R.K. Nagar, P.O. Kash Noagaon
District- West Tripura
Now posted at
Boys Hostel, Tripura Medical College
AGMC & GBP Hospital Complex,
Agartala, P.O. Agartala, Dist- West Tripura.
--- Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Commissioner
Cum Secretary to the Government of Tripura,
Home Department, New Capital Complex,
P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, District- West Tripura.
2. The Deputy Inspector General of Police (AP)
Government of Tripura, Agartala, West Tripura.
3. The Inspector General of Police ( TSR & OPS)
Government of Tripura, Agartala, West Tripura.
4. The Commandant, 2nd Bn TSR,
R.K. Nagar, West Tripura.
5. The Deputy Commandant, 2nd Bn TSR,
R.K. Nagar, West Tripura.
---Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing and
delivery of judgment
and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. A. Acharjee, Advocate.
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. GA
21.11.2023
Yes
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & order (Oral)
This writ petition has been filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India for issuance of writ of certiorari and/or
thereof, for quashing
in the nature
or setting aside the punishment order No.DP/07/
2011/DKT/TSR/-II/Estt/11/11597/11606 dated 27.09.2011 and the order vide
No.3440-42/F.47(17)/DAP/TSR/RSV/11 dated 13.05.2019.
[2]
Brief facts, leading to this case is that on 15.09.1997, petitioner
joined service as TSR personnel as Hav(GD) E Coy, 2nd Bn. R. K Nagar,
West
Tripura. While the petitioner discharging his duty as night guard
Commander in the ONGC Office main gate, on 08/09.02.2011 in the
midnight, 5/6 civilians entered into the complex without taking prior
permission
from
the
superior
authority.
Thereafter
on
24.02.2011,
respondent no.4 i.e. the Commandant, 2nd Bn TSR, R.K. Nagar, West
Tripura issued a memorandum to start an enquiry against the petitioner.
Subsequently, one departmental proceeding was drawn and on the basis of
that, on 30.08.2011, respondent no.4 issued a provisional punishment
order vide No. DP/07/2011/DKT/TSR-II/Estt/11/7849 dated 30.08.2011
and punished the petitioner by withholding three annual increments of pay
of the petitioner with cumulative effect. Petitioner was directed to submit
his representation or to appear personally before the enquiry officer.
Thereafter, the petitioner submitted his representation on 16.09.2011 and
stated everything as defence statement. It was submitted by the petitioner
that during departmental proceeding no documents relating to the DP were
supplied to the petitioner inspite of his representation and the petitioner
had been kept in confinement in the barrack and the competent assistant
was not provided to him. It is pertinent to mention that on 27.09.2011,
respondent no. 4 issued a punishment order vide No.DP/07/2011/DKT/
TSR/II/Estt/11/11597-11606 was passed stating that in exercise of power
conferred by Rule 12(1) of Tripura State Rifles Act, 1983 and Rule 11(iv) of
CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 two annual increments of pay with cumulative
effect of the petitioner be withheld.
[3]
The Commandant, 2nd TSR (ONGC) Battalion, R.K. Nagar,
Tripura West vide memorandum dated 24th February, 2011, framed the
following Article of Charge against the petitioner, Dilip Kumar Tripura:
“ARTICLE-I
No 97040664 Hav (GD) Dilip Kumar Tripura of E/TSR2 was performing the duty of night Guard Commander on
08/09-02-2011 night at ONGC office gate allowed 5/6
civilians in the midnight to enter inside ONGC Base Complex
un-authorisedly without obtaining any permission of his
superior by threatening the duty sentry, which is gross
misconduct and prejudicial to the good order and discipline
of the Rifles.”
[4]
The petitioner submitted a representation on 16.09.2011 in
his defence stating that during departmental proceeding, no documents
related to the DP were supplied to him inspite of his representation. He
further stated that though he was asked to engage defence assistance, but
he had been kept in confinement in the barrack and inspite of his request,
he had not been allowed to go out to engage a defence assistant. It was
also submitted that he had been instructed to engage a defense assistant
from the battalion but no such competent person came forward to assist
him or such competent person was not available in the barrack.
[5]
On 27th September, 2011, the punishment order vide No.
DP/07/2011/DKT/TSR-II/Estt/11/11597-11606
was
passed
by
the
respondent No.4 against the petitioner, which reads as under:
“NOW THEREFORE, I Shri Khatra Joy Reang, IPS,
Commandant, 2nd Bn TSR being the appointing authority in
exercise of the power conferred by Rule- 12(1) of the
Tripura State Rifles Act 1983, and Rule 11(iv) of CCS (CCA)
Rules 1965, do hereby awarded punishment of „Withholding
of 02(two) Annual Increments of Pay with cumulative
effect‟ to No.97040664 Hav (GD) Dilip Kumar Tripura of „E‟
Coy, 2nd Bn TSR. DP No.07/2011 is hereby disposed off.”
[6]
A criminal complaint was also lodged by the departmental
authority, 2nd Bn. TSR against the petitioner bearing Amtali Police Station
Case No. 16 of 2011 under Section 379 of the Indian Penal Code.
Subsequently, petitioner faced trial before the then Sub-Divisional Judicial
Magistrate, West Tripura, Bishalgarh on the said charges in PRC 49 of
2011. Learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, West Tripura, Bishalgarh,
while examining the witnesses, opined vide his judgment dated 01.06.2016
that from the evidence of PW.1 (Md. Habib Miah) and PW.4 (S.I. Obaidul
Haque, the I.O), it was quite evident that it was Biswajit Deb (PW.3) who
had performed duty at the relevant time on the alleged date of occurrence.
Examining all the witnesses and materials on record, leaned SDJM has
acquitted the petitioner of the charge leveled against him. For the purpose
of reference, the relevant portion of the judgment passed by the then
SDJM, Bishalgarh, West Tripura on 01.06.2016 is quoted hereinbelow:
“ORDER
In the result, the accused persons namely Dilip
Kumar Tripura and Raju Das are hereby acquitted of the
charge levelled against them u/s. 379 of IPC and they
are set at liberty.
The surety of the accused persons stands
discharged from the liability of the bail bond.
The seized article, if any, shall be disposed of
as per law after expiration of period of appeal, if no
appeal is preferred.
The Judgment is pronounced in the open Court.
The case is thus disposed of on contest on
acquittal…..”
[7]
On 28th October, 2016, Commandant, 2nd Bn, Tripura State
Rifles, Office of the Commandant, 2nd Bn Tripura State Rifles, R.K. Nagar,
West
Tripura
vide
order
No.
10689-94/F.107/TSR-II/Suspension/12
finalized the departmental proceeding, the relevant portion of which is
extracted herein-below:
“…..4. NOW THEREFORE, the period of Suspension from
23.02.2011 to 29.05.2011 in respect of No.97040664
Hav(GD) Dilip Kumar Tripura of „E‟ Coy, 2 nd Bn TSR (Now
„D‟ Coy) has been treated as “SPENT OF DUTY” under
Rule- FR-54(B) since the Disciplinary Proceeding drawn
up against him was finalized by awarding Minor
Punishment.”
[8]
The petitioner, on 25.02.2019, filed an appeal before the
respondent No.2 for review and revocation of punishment imposed upon
him by the respondent No.4. But, the respondent No.2 upheld the
punishment
imposed
by
the
respondent
No.4
vide
order
No.3440-
42/F.47(17)/DAP/TSR/RSV/11 dated 13th May, 2019 with a view that the
charges in criminal case as well as in the departmental proceedings are
different. For the purpose of reference, the relevant portion of the order of
the Dy. IG of Police (AP), Tripura, Agartala i.e. Respondent No.2 is quoted
below:
“……5.
The charges in criminal case as well as in the
Departmental proceedings are different. Moreover, the
30 days time limit for appeal has been long over. In view
of the above, the undersigned does not find merit in the
contention of the appellant that in view of the judgment
in criminal case his punishment should be reviewed.
Undersigned finds no justifiable grounds that warrants
relook into the punishment order of the then
Commandant, 2nd Bn TSR.
6. The appeal petition is disposed off accordingly.”
[9]
Thereafter, on 22.05.2019, the petitioner submitted an
application before the respondent No.3 i.e. the Director General of Police,
Government of Tripura, Agartala for revocation of punishment order
imposed by the respondent No.4 and the petitioner has stated that he has
been acquitted from the charges under Section 379 of IPC but, the said
prayer of the petitioner was rejected by order dated 25.06.2019. The
relevant portion of the order dated 25.06.2019 passed by the I/C Director
General of Police, Tripura, Agartala is quoted below for the purpose of
reference:
“…..4. The undersigned does not find merit in the appeal
petition of the applicant to review the punishment order
as he was acquitted of the charge leveled by the Court of
SDJM, Bishalgarh. The charges in both the instances are
different. The undersigned agrees with the order of the
Appellate Authority (DIG, AP) as there is no justifiable
ground to relook into the punishment order. The appeal
petition is disposed off accordingly.”
[10]
Aggrieved thereby, the instant writ petition has been filed by
the petitioner seeking following reliefs:
(i) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one
of them to show cause as to why a writ of certiorari
and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued.
(ii) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each
one of them to show cause as to why a writ of certiorari
and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued, for
directing the respondents to provide 02(two) Annual
Increments of pay of the petitioner with cumulative
effect and to provide the financial benefit thereto and for
quashing or setting aside the punishment order No.
DP/07/2011/DKT/TSR/-II/Estt/11/11597/11606 dated
27.09.2011
and
the
order
vide
No.344042/F.47(17)/DAP/TSR/RSV/11 dated 13.05.2019.
[11]
Heard Mr. A. Acharjee, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. representing the
respondent-State. Perused the material evidence on record.
[12]
Mr. A. Acharjee, learned counsel representing the petitioner
submits that though the petitioner was acquitted of the charge leveled
against him by the learned SDJM, the respondents have illegally withheld
two annual increments of pay of the petitioner with cumulative effect and
therefore, he prays that the punishment order passed by the respondent(s)
be declared illegal, arbitrary, unreasonable, unconstitutional. Learned
counsel, therefore, urges before this Court for directing the respondents to
provide
02(two)
Annual
Increments
of
pay
of
the
petitioner
with
cumulative effect setting aside the punishment order imposed upon the
petitioner in the departmental proceedings.
[13]
Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the State-
respondents on the other hand contends that it is not a fact that charge in
the criminal case and in the instant departmental proceeding was identical
and same. As such, he submits that the instant writ petition has no merit
and same is liable to be dismissed.
[14]
In the punishment order dated 27th September 2011, it has
been observed that the petitioner repeatedly allowed some people to enter
inside the gate and to move outside whereas, 1st sentry Rfn(GD), namely,
Biswajit Dey was deployed in the duty. From the above mentioned
punishment order, it is also revealed that at the night of incident, there
were other personnel alongwith the petitioner, but, strangely, they kept
silent and did not complain their superior authority immediately that the
petitioner who was not on duty at that time of occurrence was allowing
some civilians to enter inside the gate in committing theft with one Cycle
Cart and leaving the barrack thereafter. This Court is surprised to observe
that the respondents authority held an inquiry only against the petitioner,
sought for explanation and imposed punishment on the petitioner only and
they did not take any action against the other personnel performing sentry
duty, who might be directly or indirectly involved in the incident of theft.
The respondent authorities could have called for explanation from the
security in-charge of the barrack regarding theft in the complex at that
night but, they did not do so. For the purpose of reference, the relevant
portion from the punishment order dated 27 th September, 2011 is quoted
below:
“WHEREAS Guard Commander Hav(GD) Dilip Kumar
Tripura said, he would perform sentry duty himself from
1900 hrs to 2300 hrs, 1st Sentry Rfn(GD) Biswajit Dey
from 2300 to 0130 hrs, 2nd Sentry Rfn(GD) Bintesh
Kumar Singh from 0130 hrs to 0400 hrs and Rfn(GD)
Binod Das from 0400 hrs to 0700 hrs 3 rd sentry would
perform sentry duty but Guard Commander Hav(GD) Dilip
Kumar Tripura did not mention the time in the Guard
Register. Accordingly, they started sentry duty in the
night. At 2300 hrs 1st Sentry Rfn(GD) Biswajit Dey took
up sentry duty of ONGC Base Complex Main Gate from
Guard Commander Hav(GD) Dilip Kumar Tripura. Guard
Commander returned to his Guard Room but again came
out repeatedly. He was also found talking with someone
over mobile phone to come quickly.
WHEREAS After about half-an-hour he again called
them up and went out of the gate. At about 0115/0120
hrs, when 02(two) civilian came near the gate Hav(GD)
Dilip Kumar Tripura allowed them to come inside the gate
1st sentry Rfn (GD) Riswajit Dey raised objection but
Hav(GD) Dilip Kumar Tripura did not care and allowed
the civilian to inside alongwith him. After 10/15 minutes,
he also allowed 3/4 persons inside with one Cycle Cart.
At about 0145 hrs, they brought Cycle Cart loaded with
some materials duly covered and left ONGC Base Complex
through Main Gate. Hav (GD) Dilip Kumar Tripura also
went outside ensuring the leaving of Cycle Cart. It was
also revealed that as per direction of Hav (GD) Dilip
Kumar Tripura, 1st Sentry Biswajit Dey continued duty
upto 0220 hrs. Hav (GD) Dilip Kumar Tripura also given
false OK report to Nb/Sub(GD) Habib Miah on 09-022011 at 0715 hrs that no incidents took place on 8/9-022011 night at ONGC Base Complex to save himself from
illegal activities.”
[15]
It is evident from the record that in the departmental inquiry
and in the criminal case before the then learned Sub-Divisional Judicial
Magistrate, West Tripura, Bishalgarh against the petitioner, Nb/Sub (GD)
Habib Miah and Rfn (GD) Biswajit Dey were the common witnesses. While
examining the witnesses, learned SDJM, West Tripura, Bishalgarh in his
judgment dated 01.06.2016 mentioned that from the evidence of PW.1,
Md. Habib Miah, and PW.4, S.I. Obaidul Haque, the I.O., it was quite
evident that it was Biswajit Deb (PW.3) who had performed duty at the
relevant time on the alleged date of occurrence. The said observation of
the then learned SDJM, West Tripura, Bishalgarh is quoted hereunder for
the purpose of reference:
“…..PW.1
examination
Md. Habib
stated that
Miah also in his crosson the alleged date of
occurrence from 11pm to 1:30 Biswajit Deb (PW.3) was
in duty.
From the evidence of PW.1 and PW.4 it is quite
evident that it was Biswajit Deb (PW.3) who had
performed duty at the relevant time on the alleged date
of occurrence.
[16]
Having appreciated the facts and circumstances of the case
and the submissions made by the learned counsel appearing for the
parties, this Court is of the view that the proper departmental inquiry was
not conducted by the respondent authorities and no proper action was
taken against all those personnel who were directly or indirectly involved in
the alleged offence. It was not only the petitioner who might have allowed
the persons inside but, at the same time, the personnel who were present
at the place of occurrence at that night also kept quiet allowing 5 to 6
civilians to enter inside 3/4 times and to commit theft of the property of
the respondent department from the barrack. The personnel present there
who did not inform the matter to the higher officials and colleagues
immediately, might be responsible for the incident of theft and the same
could have been inquired into. The security in-charge of the barrack was
supposed to guard his barrack round the clock and he could not escape
from the responsibility bestowed upon him by his superior authority. In the
case in hand, the respondent- authorities imposed punishment only upon
the petitioner excepting all other personnel who might be responsible for
the alleged incident. A discrete departmental inquiry is required against all
those personnel who might be directly or indirectly involved in the matter.
Accordingly,
the
matter
needs
re-examination
in
its
entirety
and
appropriate action needs to be taken against all the responsible personnel
directly or indirectly involved in the matter allowing the civilians to enter
into the barrack.
[17]
In view of the above discussion, this Court feels that the
matter needs to be remanded back to the respondent authorities for
conducting the discrete enquiry into the matter keeping in view the
observations made above by this Court and a final decision be taken in
accordance with law. Thus, the impugned orders herein passed by the
respondent authorities need to be set aside and accordingly, the same is
set aside. It is further observed that the petitioner shall cooperate with the
respondent authorities during the course of the enquiry.
[18]
In terms of the above directions, the present case in hand is
remanded back to the respondent authorities and accordingly, the present
writ petition stands disposed of. Miscellaneous application(s) pending, if
any, shall also stand closed.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
GHOSH
Sabyasachi G.
GHOSH
Date: 2023.12.02 19:21:26 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review